Source: AUBURN UNIVERSITY submitted to
DEVELOPMENT OF INTENSIVE INDOOR REARING STRATEGIES FOR LARGEMOUTH BASS DURING CRITICAL EARLY LIFE HISTORY STAGES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1031196
Grant No.
2023-67016-40777
Cumulative Award Amt.
$650,000.00
Proposal No.
2022-08034
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2023
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2027
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1231]- Animal Health and Production and Animal Products: Improved Nutritional Performance, Growth, and Lactation of Animals
Recipient Organization
AUBURN UNIVERSITY
108 M. WHITE SMITH HALL
AUBURN,AL 36849
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Largemouth bass (LMB) is a high-value freshwater aquaculture species with a rapidly expanding food fish market in North America. However, current rearing practices depend on uncontrollable pond-based technologies plagued by high mortality, especially during the early life stages (i.e., egg to early fingerlings). As such, complete indoor intensive culture of LMB would improve production yields by circumventing the high rates of mortality associated with these initial pond stages. Indoor growing technologies that embrace conditions for optimal growth and survival would also enable year-round sustainable production of LMB fingerlings to supply the rapidly expanding food fish industry. Our long-term goal is to develop intensive indoor-rearing strategies for LMB during critical early life stages. To accomplish this goal, we will use basic and applied research to better understand the morphological, physiological, and molecular underpinnings associated with the development of LMB. Objectives are to: i) identify yolk-sac fry stocking density and prey density that maximizes hatchery production; ii) determine the influence of photoperiod, light intensity, and tank color on growth and development; iii) elucidate ontogenetic development of digestive system morphology and function; iv) optimize first-feeding to fingerling dietary regimens using live feed and artificial diets; v) train students in aquaculture; and vi) disseminate results to industry, government, and educational institutions. The overall success criterion will be to further intensify the production of healthy fry/fingerlings to enhance production, sustainability, and national food security. Results can be applied to other species of national scope, resulting in expansions in sector-wide production and economic growth.
Animal Health Component
20%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
80%
Applied
20%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3050810101030%
3050810102020%
3073799105010%
3050810105010%
3050810104020%
3073799102010%
Goals / Objectives
Our long-term goal is to develop intensive indoor rearing strategies for a commercially importantfood fish (largemouth bass) during the critical early life stages.To accomplish this goal, we will employ an integrative morphological, physiological, and molecular approach, where specific objectives are to:oIdentifyyolk-sac fry stocking density, prey density, or stocking density × prey density interaction that increases productionefficiency.oDetermine the influence of photoperiod, light intensity, and tank color on growth and development.oElucidate the ontogenetic development of digestive system morphology and function.oOptimize first-feeding to fingerling dietary regimens using live feed and artificial diets.Adopting these integrated techniques will constitute new avenues of aquatic research. These novel approaches will advance hatchery conditions to improveaquaculture production and genetic enhancement programs.
Project Methods
This largemouth bass project is organized into complementary tasks in chronological order.Exp. 1- Effects of initial yolk-sac fry stocking density and prey density (Artemiaspp.) on industry-relevant offspring performance traits.Experimental design-Three Northern bass embryo cohortswill be transported to Auburn University, where they will be reared at ~21oC. At peak hatch, yolk-sac fry from each replicate cohort will be placed into 75 L aquaria equipped with recirculation technologyand acclimated to 27oC. Yolk-sac fry from each cohort will be stocked inaquaria at densities of 25, 50, 75, and 100yolk-sac fry/L. Starting at 3 days post-hatch (DPH), fry from each stocking density will be factorially fed Premium GradeAArtemiaat 2, 4, and 8Artemia/mL. These stocking and prey densities were selected as they span the density ranges investigated for bass and other fish species. In addition, artificial diet will be added to each aquarium starting at 120degree-days until 28 DPH.Mortalities, excess feed, and fecal matter will be removed daily. Rearing of offspring will take place under a 12-hour light/12-hour dark photoperiod at ~250 lux. Water quality variables will be monitored daily to ensure they remain within acceptable ranges.Data collection-Growth and morphology: At peak hatch (time 0), ten individuals will be randomly sampled from each aquarium. After that, fish (n = 10) from each aquarium will be sampled at various developmental landmarks during early ontogeny. Digital images will be taken of each fish, wheretotal length, notochord length, yolk-sac area, eye diameter, jaw length, myotome height, and body area will be obtained for each individual. Yolk utilization efficiency will be calculated as the increase in length from hatch to the first-feeding stage divided by the corresponding decrease in yolk area. For each fish,gut fullnesswill be calculated as the percentage of food particles relative to the total gut area.The weight(wet/dry) of fingerlings (n = 50 per aquarium) will be determined at the end of the experiment.Classification of deformities: Fish (n = 10) from each aquarium will be sampled at 2, 4, 8, 12, and 28 DPH, visually inspected under a microscope, and classified into the following deformity groups.Targeted gene expression: We will follow the expression of targeted genes previously reported to be associated with stress tolerance, growth, anddevelopmentand functionally important muscle tissue.Exp. 2- Effects of light regimen and tank color on industry-relevant offspring performance traitsExperimental design- Embryos will be transported to Auburn University, where they will be incubated at ~21oC, while fry and fingerling rearing temperatures will be adjusted to27oC.Tanks will be stocked (yolk-sac fry/L)andfed live feed and artificial diet according to Exp. 1.Fluorescent white light will be provided to all rearing tanks.Part A- At peak hatch, yolk-sac fry will be transferred to a recirculation system equipped with 30 × 50 L circular tanks. Here, the effect of light intensity [250 lux (currently used at commercial bass farms) and 500 lux; both measured at the water surface] and tank color(black, blue, red, green, clear) willbe tested using a 2 × 5 factorial design with three replicate tanks per treatment. Photoperiod will be 12-hour light/12-hour dark, and layers of shade cloth will be used to manipulate light intensity.Part B- In a separate study, the effect of photoperiod will be tested using the best light intensity and tank color from above. Here, the hatchery-reared fish will be reared under three different photoperiods: 12-hour light/12-hour dark, 16-hour light/8-hour dark, and 24-hour light/0-hour dark. Conditions will be replicated across three tanks per treatment. All other conditions will mimic optimal conditions observed in Exp. 1.Data collection-Growth and morphology,gut fullness,weight,deformities, andtargeted gene expressionwill be quantified (for Part A-B)Exp. 3- Development of early weaning strategies for LMB during early ontogenyExperimental design- Yolk-sac fry will be stocked into tanks and reared in a recirculation system using our top fry stocking density prey density combination, light regimen, and tank color evaluated in Exp. 1-2. Fish will be administered eight different dietary treatments, each with three replicate tanks. Treatments 1-4 will be fed freshwater rotifersat 10 rotifers/mL from2 to 5DPH. Those fry will also receive liveArtemia(density based on Exp. 1) from 2 to 5 DPH (Treatment 1), 2 to 10 DPH (Treatment 2), 2 to 15 DPH (Treatment 3), and 2 to 20 DPH (Treatment 4). Meanwhile, Treatments 5-8 will only receive liveArtemia(density based on Exp. 1) from 2 to 5 DPH (Treatment 5), 2 to 10 DPH (Treatment 6), 2 to 15 DPH (Treatment 7), and 2 to 20 DPH (Treatment 8). All fish (Treatments 1-8) will be gradually transitioned onto an artificial diet for 60 hours before eliminating all live feed; after that receiving only an artificial diet to 28 DPH. The control group (Treatment 9) will only receive an artificial diet.Data collection-Growth and morphology,weight,deformities,targeted gene expression, andlarval gut fullnesswill be quantified.Exp. 4- Using hatchery-based nutritional programming to improve industry-relevant offspring performance traitsExperimental design- Yolk-sac fry (represented by ~8-10 families) will be stocked into 280 L tanks and reared in a recirculating system using our top treatments evaluated in Exp. 1-3. There will be nine dietary treatments, with×3 replicate tanks,where fish will be fed either(1)+Control= non-enriched live feed, followed by a fishmeal-based diet until the end of the trial, (2)-Control= non-enriched live feed, followed by 45% soybean meal (SBM)-based diet until the end of the trial, (3)-Control= non-enriched live feed, followed by 65% SBM-based diet until the end of the trial; (4)Non-programmed= non-enriched live feed, followed by fishmeal-based diet for six weeks, and then 45% SBM diet,(5)Non-programmed= non-enriched live feed, followed by fishmeal-based diet for six weeks, and then 65% SBM diet,(6)21-daynutritional programming= live feed enriched with SBM for 21 days, followed by fishmeal-based diet for six weeks, and then 45% SBM diet,(7)21-daynutritional programming= live feed enriched with SBM for 21 days, followed by fishmeal-based diet for six weeks, and then 65% SBM diet,(8)Exp. 3-based nutritional programming= live feed enriched with SBM using our top treatment combination from Exp. 3 (both live feed types and feeding duration), followed by a fishmeal-based diet for six weeks, and then a 45% SBM diet, and(9)Exp. 3-based nutritional programming= live feed enriched with SBM using our top treatment combination from Exp. 3, followed by a fishmeal-based diet for six weeks, and then a 65% SBM diet.The SBM feeding period will be considered a "SBM challenge" and will last until the fish reach a 12 cm stocking size. Live feed will be enriched by adding sieved, finely-ground SBM into live feed water for a minimum of three hours before fish feeding. "Non-enriched" live feeds will be fed spirulina before fry feeding. Both fishmeal- and SBM-based diets will be produced according to formulations previously reported for LMB with some modifications to account for the high inclusion of SBM. Fish will be fed to apparent satiation during the live feed stages and up until the SBM challenge phase. During SBM challenge, all fish will be fed restrictively (% biomass). All groups will be weighed biweekly to adjust the feeding rates according to fish growth.Data collection- Industry-relevant offspring performance traits will be quantified at 2, 8, 12, and 28 DPH following Exp. 1-3. After that, fish will be sampled at 78 (before the start of SBM challenge), 122, and 150 DPH. Offspring performance traitsincludegrowth and morphology, weight, deformities,gut fullness,gene expression,enzymatic activity,fatty acids, proximate composition, andhistology.

Progress 09/01/23 to 08/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Stakeholders directly affected by this research include hatchery managers, owners, and their hired personnel. Other parties involved includeresearch and Extension faculty members, graduate students, undergraduate students, and research staff of Auburn University, who wereresponsible for conducting each of the proposed experiments. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Training activities - Graduate students directly involved in this USDA-NIFA project (1 MS and 1 PhD) and other student helpers (3 MS and 1 PhD) in theAquatic Reproductive Physiology and Hatchery Science Lab at Auburn University(PI: Butts) learned fundamental concepts in aquatic reproductive biology/physiology, hatchery science, larval fish nutrition, gene expression, experimental design, and data analyses. Specifically, they gain hands-on training (one-on-one work with a mentor) in fish husbandry; broodstock management; and culturing of rotifers (Brachionus plicatilisandBrachionusrotundiformis),Artemia sp.andmicroalgae (Isochrysissp., Tahitian strain (TISO) andPavlova lutheri). They were also responsible for building, operating, and maintaining flow-through and recirculation systems and monitoring lab equipment and water quality (dissolved oxygen, pH, temperature, salinity, saturation, NH3, NH4, NO2,Cl2). Students also played an integral role in conducting and designing experiments; supervising undergraduate students; ordering laboratory supplies; and maintaining up-to-date standard operating procedures and material safety data sheets. Professional development -Graduate students (1 MS and 1 PhD) are now conducting individual studies for their thesis projects [chair: Butts (PD); committee members: Bruce, Roy (co-PDs)]. This includes studies on aquatic hatchery science, molecular physiology, and nutrition. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?A. Cletzer wrote an article about our largemouth bass research for the Auburn University website (section:Research and Innovation Stories) titledAuburn hatchery scientists take on a project to help U.S. largemouth bass producers(6 Dec 2023;https://agriculture.auburn.edu/research/hatchery-scientists-take-on-project-to-help-u-s-largemouth-bass-producers/?utm_source=web&utm_medium=auburn-stories-research). Three scientific papers are currently In Preparation from this work, which will be disseminated to the scientific community and stakeholders. Bernal, M.A., Aguilar, G.L., Sakmar, J., Politis, S.N., Oglesby, S.L., Nicholls, A., Kelly, A.M., Roy, L.A., Butts, I.A.E. Transcriptome analyses reveal differences in the response to warming in Florida and Northern largemouth bass (Micropterus spp.) during early life stages.To be submitted in Fall 2024 Parajuli, N.S.,Sakmar, J.,Nicholls, A.,Martin, K.A.,Liyange, S., Wood, K.R.,Swanepoel, A.,Kelly. A., Roy, L., Bruce, T.J.,Butts, I.A.E. Predator and prey density impacts largemouth bass performance during early life history when cultured in an indoor recirculation aquaculture system.To be submitted in Fall 2024? Swanepoel, A.,Sakmar, J.,Nicholls, A.,Parajuli, N.S., Goodman, D., Martin, K.A.,Liyange, S., Wood, K.R.,Kelly. A., Roy, L., Bruce, T.J.,Butts, I.A.E. Impact of tank color and light intensity on early larval development in largemouth bass.To be submitted in Fall 2024 What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During Fall 2024 and Spring 2025, we will look at the impact of photoperiod on the growth and development of LMB and developearly weaning strategies during early ontogeny. For the photoperiod study, the hatchery-reared fish will be reared under three different photoperiods: 12-hour light/12-hour dark, 16-hour light/8-hour dark, and 24-hour light/0-hour dark. Conditions will be replicated across three tanks per treatment. All other conditions will mimic optimal conditions observed in our completed studies. Data collection - Growth and morphology, gut fullness, weight, deformities, and targeted gene expression will be quantified. For the weaning study, we willdetermine the necessity of rotifers and theearliest time to wean fry onartificial diets. For methods, yolk-sac fry will be stocked into tanks and reared in an RAS using our top fry stocking density prey density combination, light regimen, and tank color. Fish will be factorially administered eight different dietary treatments, each with three replicate tanks. Treatments 1-4 will be fed freshwater rotifers,Brachionus calyciflorus(fed microalgae and ORI-One from Skretting) at 10 rotifers/mL from2 to 5DPH. Those fry will also receive liveArtemiafrom 2 to 5 DPH (Treatment 1), 2 to 10 DPH (Treatment 2), 2 to 15 DPH (Treatment 3), and 2 to 20 DPH (Treatment 4). Meanwhile, Treatments 5-8 will only receive liveArtemiafrom 2 to 5 DPH (Treatment 5), 2 to 10 DPH (Treatment 6), 2 to 15 DPH (Treatment 7), and 2 to 20 DPH (Treatment 8). All fish (Treatments 1-8) will be gradually transitioned onto an artificial diet for 60 hours before eliminating all live feed; after that receiving only an artificial diet to 28 DPH. The control group (Treatment 9) will only receive an artificial diet. Growth and morphology, weight, deformities, targeted gene expression, and larval gut fullness will be quantified.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Our team started collecting data in January 2024. Since then, we have made great progress, completing fish data collection for two experiments. Our progress is outlined below: Exp. 1- Effects of initial yolk-sac fry stocking density and prey density (Artemiaspp.) on industry-relevant offspring performance traits.Objective- Determine initial yolk-sac fry stocking density, prey density, and stocking density x prey density interactionthat increases the efficiency of largemouth bass (LMB) hatchery production. Experimental design- Northern LMB embryo cohorts were collected from Red Hills Fishery and transported to SFAAS, where they were reared at ~21oC. At peak hatch, yolk-sac fry from each replicate cohort was placed into blue tanks equipped with recirculation aquaculture system (RAS) technologyand slowly acclimated to 25-26oC. The RAS had30 blueaquaria,3 × 794 L circular blue tanks, 2 × 190 L sump tanks, UV sterilizer, mechanical filter, fluidized bed biological filter, and temperature control (heat pump). Yolk-sac fry from each replicate cohort was stocked in RAStanks at densities of 25, 50, and 100yolk-sac fry/L.Starting at 3 days post-hatch (DPH), fry from each stocking density were factorially fed Premium GradeAArtemiaat 2, 4, and 8Artemia/mL every 2 h from 07:00 to 23:00. In total there were 27 experimental tanks (3 stocking densities× 3 prey densities × 3 replicateembryo cohorts). In addition, an artificial diet was added to each tank starting at ~120degree-days until 26 DPH.Mortalities, excess feed, and fecal matter were removed daily. Rearing of offspring took place under a 12-hour light/12-hour dark photoperiod at ~250-400 lux. Handling and sampling were done under low-intensity light conditions. Water quality variables were monitored daily to ensure they remained within acceptable ranges.Data collection-Growth and morphology: At peak hatch (time 0), 10-12 individuals were randomly sampled from each tank. After that, fish (n = 10-12) from each tank were sampled at various developmental landmarks during early ontogeny (7, 14, 21, 26 DPH). Fish were anesthetized or euthanized using buffered M2-222 before handling. Digital images were taken of each fish using a Zeiss SteREO Discovery V12®microscope equipped with a Zeiss Axiocam 305 camera, with measurements extracted using Zeiss imaging software. Total length, notochord length, yolk-sac area, eye diameter, jaw length, myotome height, and body area were obtained for each individual. For each fish,gut fullnesswill be calculated as the percentage of food particles relative to the total gut area.Classification of deformities: Fish (n = 10) from each aquarium were sampled and visually inspected under a Zeiss SteREO Discovery V12®microscope and classified into the following deformity groups: pericardial (edema), head (deformed head shape), eye (no eye/abnormal eye), yolk (abnormal lobe shape), tail (bent, curled, or missing), and spine (bent curvature). The rate of deformities (%) will soon be calculated.Targeted gene expression: To further understand phenotypic sensitivity to predator (fish) and prey density, we will follow the expression of targeted genes previously reported to be associated with stress tolerance, growth, anddevelopment.Relative gene expression between the stocking density groups will then be assessed using theDDCt method. Our preliminary data shows promising results, with increased survival (up to 80%) and growth at the lower larval stocking densities and higher prey densities. Exp. 2- Effects of light regimen and tank color on industry-relevant offspring performance traits.Objective-Determine the light regimen and tank color that increases the hatchery production efficiency.Experimental design- Tank color and reflectance influence light dispersion and subsequent prey detection within a tank. Thus, these factors are relevant for enhancing the production of LMB. Embryos (represented by ~8-10 families) were transported to SFAAS, where they were incubated at ~21oC, while larvae and fingerling rearing temperatures were adjusted to27oC.Tanks were stocked (50 yolk-sac larvae/L)andfed live feed and an artificial diet.Fluorescent white light (full spectrum approximating natural sunlight at 5000 K) was provided to all rearing tanks. At peak hatch, yolk-sac larvae were transferred to a RAS system equipped with 30 × 15 L circular tanks. Here, the effect of light intensity (400 and 800 lux; both measured at the water surface) and tank color(black, blue, red, green, white) weretested using a 2 × 5 factorial design with three replicate tanks per treatment. Photoperiod was 12-hour light/12-hour dark.Data collection-Growth and morphology,gut fullness,weight,deformities, andtargeted gene expressionare now being quantified.Preliminary results- No significant differences were observed between different tank colors or light intensities for final weight and biomass. Black tanks produced a significantly higher survival of 77.45% compared to white, red, and green tanks which were 63.25, 67.33 and 66.23% respectively, and no difference to blue tanks which showed a survival of 71.9%. Black tanks showed a significantly lower cannibalism percentage of 0.06% compared to red and white tanks which had a cannibalism percentage of 0.14 and 0.21% respectively and no difference to blue and green tanks at 0.12 and 0.15% respectively. In terms of different light intensity lux levels, no differences were observed for survival or cannibalism.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2024 Citation: Butts, I.A.E.. 2024. Aquatic Reproductive Physiology and Hatchery Science Lab. 8th Fish and Shellfish Larviculture Symposium. Ostend, Belgium (Poster presentation)
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2024 Citation: Butts, I.A.E., Parajuli, N., Swanepoel, A., Roy, L., Kelly, A., Bruce, T., Davis, D.A., Kwasek, K.A., Nicholls, A., Sakmar, J. 2024. Development of intensive indoor rearing strategies for largemouth bass during critical early life history stages. NIFA-USDA Annual Growth and Lactation Program Project Director Meeting. Calgary, Canada (Poster presentation)