Source: SOUTH DAKOTA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
CONTROL STRATEGIES FOR EMERGING VARIANTS OF TURKEY REOVIRUS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1030919
Grant No.
2023-68008-40546
Cumulative Award Amt.
$300,000.00
Proposal No.
2022-10034
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2025
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1701]- Critical Agricultural Research and Extension: CARE
Recipient Organization
SOUTH DAKOTA STATE UNIVERSITY
PO BOX 2275A
BROOKINGS,SD 57007
Performing Department
Veterinary and Biomdical Sciences
Non Technical Summary
Turkey reoviruses (TRVs) continue to cause disease in turkeys with varied pathogenicity and tissue tropism. The incidence of hepatitis and mortality in turkey poults and lameness in older turkeys is continuously increasing even with the use of autogenous vaccines in breeder turkeys. The change from causing mild enteric disease to economically important arthritis and hepatitis highlights the need for improving diagnostic and control measures through research and extension.This study proposes to translate whole genome sequence data into easy-to-understand genotyping classification with proper nomenclature of sequences. The genotypic classification is important to understand substantial heterogeneity in the spatial distribution and spread of different strains, potential turnover in dominant strain across time, and selection of vaccine strains. Non-invasive environmental sampling will help in early detection of TRV infection in the farm as well as be helpful in tracking the source of infection.Extension activities will help enhance knowledge level of disease diagnosticians, field veterinarians, veterinary diagnostic laboratory staff and turkey producers about the sequence-based analysis, proper naming, and genotyping of TRVs. Implementation of non-invasive sampling and decontamination strategies will help in disease diagnosis, surveillance, and management and control. The information generated from this study will be delivered to field veterinarians, scientific community, and poultry producers. Positive outcomes from this study will help in improving diagnostics and control measures for TRV-associated diseases.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
50%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
31132301101100%
Knowledge Area
311 - Animal Diseases;

Subject Of Investigation
3230 - Turkey, live animal;

Field Of Science
1101 - Virology;
Goals / Objectives
The goal of this study is to develop proper nomenclature and genotyping classification of turkey reoviruses (TRVs), to standardize non-invasive sampling method for early detection of TRV infection in farms, and to evaluate decontamination strategies. This information will be translated for implementation by the turkey industry for enhanced TRV control.Objectives:Objective 1: Develop nomenclature and a genotypic classification method for turkey reovirusesObjective 2: Validate real-time RT-PCR (RT-qPCR) for environment samplesObjective 3: Develop a non-invasive sampling method to detect turkey reovirusesObjective 4: Conduct whole genome sequencing and genotyping of selected biosurveillance samplesObjective 5: Evaluate various decontamination technologies.The results will be disseminated through close interaction with stakeholders (turkey producers and veterinarians). We will develop and distribute fact sheets to promote awareness of the new effective technologies for controlling TRV infections. Stakeholders will be invited to a demonstration of the technology. The proper use and implementation of decontamination strategies will help limit TRV infection. Based on our experience with these technologies, we believe that one or more of these technologies will be very effective against TRV. The results of the study will be communicated to the scientific community via scientific presentations and publications. We plan to educate stakeholders in understanding genotyping criteria and sequence-based analysis such as percent identities of new emerging variant sequence with old sequences. Online training modules will be developed for production systems, veterinarians, and diagnostic laboratories.
Project Methods
Objective 1. Develop nomenclature and a genotypic classification method for turkey reovirusesA standard classification system to refer to different strains of a virus is essential for management of RNA viruses in animal agriculture, particularly because producers and practitioners request virus sequencing to inform management decisions (i.e., how closely related is a farm's virus to the vaccine strain or a neighbor's strain). We will first construct phylogenetic trees for each segment, apply clustering algorithms to define and label different clades for each segment, and then tabulate each unique genotype that occurs in the dataset (i.e., a given virus's genotype is its combination of subtypes across segments). The spatial and temporal distribution of different genotypes will be evaluated across the dataset, and in combination with phylodynamic models, the approximate dates and frequency of re-assortment events will be quantified.In brief, all TRV isolates with full genome sequences published in the Genbank will be retrieved and combined with the sequences generated by our team previously and throughout this proposed project. Molecular-clock phylodynamic models implemented in the BEAST v1.10.4 software package will be used to reconstruct TRV's evolutionary history. Once genetic subtypes have been defined from phylogenies, the evolutionary characteristics for each monophyletic clade will be compared in terms of inferred date of emergence and viral population dynamics over time using a Bayesian Skygrid plot. In addition, the geographic and temporal distribution of different genotypes (the combination of subtypes across segments) will be summarized.Objective 2: Validate real-time RT-PCR (RT-qPCR) for environment samplesWe will validate Universal Avian Reovirus (U-ARV) real-time RT-PCR test for environment samples including swabs from different surfaces, meconium, and drinker swab samples. The U-ARV test has been validated for tendon, feces, egg yolk, and cell culture, but will now be validated for drinkers and environment samples using the following methods.Environmental samples: Serial ten-fold dilution of each virus will be spiked into the environment swab, drinker swab, and meconium samples which previously tested negative for common viruses tested at Animal Disease Research and Diagnostic Laboratory (ADRDL), South Dakota State University and University of Minnesota Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory (MVDL). Following the U-ARV test SOP, samples will be processed for RNA extraction and real-time RT-PCR. The test will be done in triplicate. The end dilution testing positive and one dilution above it will be tested for virus isolation to compare test sensitivity.Diagnostic Sensitivity and Specificity: Archived samples at the VDL and samples from biosurveillance study will be used to evaluate diagnostic sensitivity and specificity. We will run 30 positive and 30 negative samples of each type. Representative positive and negative samples will be tested by virus isolation which is a gold standard method.Objective 3: Develop a non-invasive sampling method to detect turkey reoviruses To assess performance of the cleaning/disinfection protocols, swab samples from throughout the facility will be collected and analyzed for TRV infection before turkey poults are placed in the facility. During placement of poults, samples of meconium (the first stool) will also be analyzed. After placement, drinkers will be swabbed and litter samples collected for testing. Based on our discussion with industry veterinarians, some farms have regular problems with TARV-associated lameness. We will select four farms with consistent reovirus problems and compare them with clean farms (n=2) from two different states or different geographical area such as from Minnesota and Virginia. We will collect environment samples before placement of birds and fecal samples soon after placement of birds. Five fecal pools (one pool of 5-10 fecal samples) and drinker swabs as per routine collection for avian influenza virus testing in a farm will be collected at 3, 5 and 8 weeks of age for TRV PCR. At 5 and 8 weeks of age, five birds will be collected and euthanized for gross and microscopic examination and for TRV PCR. Tenosynovitis by microscopic examination of tendons will confirm TARV infection in case there is no clinical lameness at the time of sampling.Objective 4. Conduct whole genome sequencing and genotyping of selected biosurveillance samplesWe will sequence whole genomes of representative samples from flocks infected with TARV and THRV based on clinical findings and MVDL test reports. Some TERV strains from flocks negative for TARV and THRV will be selected for whole genome sequencing (WGS). The WGS of TRV positive from environment samples before placement, meconium and samples testing positive after placement will be performed to compare sequences. The WGS and sequence analysis will be performed using standard protocol optimized at MVDL.Objective 5: Evaluate various decontamination technologiesWe plan to conduct a comprehensive study to determine the efficacy of four recently developed commercial technologies for inactivation of TRV under farm conditions. Since viruses behave differently on different fomites, we plan to study TRV inactivation on seven different fomites.Experimental Plan: Discs/coupons of various fomites will be placed in 24-well microtiter plates and contaminated with a known amount of TRV. Following exposure to a given technology for appropriate time, the surviving virus from the discs will be eluted in an eluent solution (3% beef extract in 0.05M glycine). Appropriate controls will be included in all experiments in which the virus will not be exposed to the disinfecting technology. Serial 10-fold dilutions of eluates from both control and treated discs will be prepared in MEM. All dilutions will be inoculated in monolayers of QT-35 cells contained in 96-well microtiter plates using 3 wells/dilution. The plates will be incubated at 37C until viral cytopathic effects (CPE) appear (usually 72-96 h). Viral titers will be calculated using the Karber (1931) method. Differences in titers of control and treated coupons will indicate the amount of virus killed.EXTENSION:To integrate the extension component with research, the learning objectives are as follows: 1) Work with researchers to disseminate research results in a language understandable by the lay audience and in a timely manner; 2) Utilize research results and collaborate with researchers and producers to develop assessment tools to help producers understand the risk of vertical and horizontal introduction of reovirus; 3) Increase understanding of proper nomenclature and sequence-based genotyping of emerging variants; 4) Assess biosecurity on farms relative to the spread of reovirus on affected farms and provide educational materials to enhance biosecurity and diagnoses; 5) Increase producer knowledge on identifying hepatitis and lameness issues through proper use of appropriate diagnostic assays to assist in diagnosing reovirus vs other conditions and associated physical characteristics, as well as gait assessment in case of TARV infection; 6) Train post-docs in conducting extension work.

Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Conduct in-person and zoom meetings with veterinarians specialized in the turkey industry to discuss our project and to explain the significance of non-invasive sampling as a novel method for early detection of turkey reoviruses. This personalized approach allows for in-depth discussions and addressing specific concerns. Conduct in-person workshops for veterinarians to train them on proper collection and preservation techniques of non-invasive samples from commercial turkey farms. Additionally, it included the guidelines for the proper shipment of samples to our lab. This interactive approach ensures proper sample collection, handling, preservation, and shipment for accurate testing. North Central Avian Disease Conference (NCADC) presentation: we presented our research effectively at the NCADC. This presentation helped to reach a broad audience of industry professionals. The audience was a collection of poultry veterinarians, turkey-producing companies, professors, and experts in turkey production and diseases. Interestingly, it also included several discussions with veterinarians and producers interested in recruiting their farms for our project. In-person training was conducted for virology section at the Animal Disease Research and Diagnostic Laboratory (ADRDL) to train them for sample processing (tendons, tissues, and non-invasive samples) for virus isolation and real-time RT-PCR. Changes/Problems:Due to continuous outbreaks of highly pathogenic avian influenza viruses, we are not able to visit different farms for samples collection and on farm training. We are using online tools to educate producers and field veterinarians. We are also scheduling in-person meetings with field veterinarians to train them for sample collection and to provide them with sampling kits. We are also sending sampling kits through courier services. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We conducted a series of online and in-person workshops specifically designed for veterinarians working in turkey production. We trained veterinarians to collect environmental samples from turkey farms. This training emphasized the benefit of early detection, in implementing proactive measurements before clinical signs appear in the flock and mitigate the devastating impact of the infection. They were able to understand the importance of collecting non-invasive samples during the pre-placement period (after cleaning and disinfection but before poults arrival). This step is very helpful for veterinarians to evaluate the effectiveness of cleaning and disinfection programs as well as to decide on repeating cleaning and disinfection if needed to ensure complete eradication of TRV before restocking. Additionally, importance of testing environmental samples from commercial turkey hatcheries was highlighted as a method to ensure that the one-day-old poults that will be received by the commercial turkey farms are free from TRV. This method will help the producers to receive TRV-free poults that will reduce the incidence of infection and significant economic losses. The Participants gained valuable knowledge on collecting representative samples from various sites in the farm environments. Veterinarians were educated with the required skills to label and store samples for precise identification, as well as preserve and ship the samples properly to the lab. Two post-doctoral associates at the UMN and one post-doctoral associate at the SDSU were mentored for professional development. One graduate student is also being involved at the SDSU to learn about turkey reoviruses. All (post-docs and student) were able to understand diseases caused by different variants of turkey reoviruses. They were able to understand turkey production system and challenges associated with control and prevention of disease cause by turkey reoviruses. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We have actively disseminated the exciting findings of our research to a wide range of stakeholders in the turkey industry. We conducted online and in-person meetings specifically for poultry veterinarians to discuss and implementing our findings. Results were presented at the North Central Avian Disease Conference (NCADC). We will also present our findings at the American Association of Avian Pathologists (AAAP) annual conference to be held in July 2024, reaching to a broad international scientific community. All our findings and results will be published in scientific journals to ensure wide accessibility. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Goal One: Develop nomenclature and a genotypic classification method for turkey reoviruses We will continue to work on defining nomenclature and genotyping classification. New sequences from environmental samples will be included. Training materials will be developed for workshops mainly for field veterinarians, graduate students, molecular diagnosticians at veterinary diagnostic laboratories and researchers for better understanding of genotyping classification and interpretation of whole genome sequence analysis. Goal 2: Validate real-time RT-PCR (RT-qPCR) for environment samples Continue to evaluate diagnostic sensitivity of this assay mainly for environmental samples as well as for detection of emerging variants of TRVs. Goal 3: Develop a non-invasive sampling method to detect turkey reoviruses We will continue to screen more farms with a known history of TRV infection and clean farms with no TRV infection reported in the past. Goal 4: Conduct whole genome sequencing and genotyping of selected biosurveillance samples Biosurveillance samples for virus isolation and real-time RT-PCR. The selected positive samples will be processed for whole genome sequencing. Goal 5: Evaluate various decontamination technologies Experiments are in progress to test the other two strains for evaluation of inactivation of turkey reovirus strains by a commercial device using ultraviolet light and ozone h. All six TRV isolates will be tested with H2O2-producing technology and misting with AquaPure AquaLyte. The focus will be on specific aim B (extension) to prepare educational materials related to all goals.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal One: Develop nomenclature and a genotypic classification method for turkey reoviruses (25% Accomplished) The South Dakota State University and University of Minnesota teams are working on defining nomenclature and genotyping classification. We are working on (n = 257) TRV whole genome sequences grouped into seven geographic regions: Canada; Dakotas (ND, SD); Midwest (KS, MO, AR); Upper Midwest (IA, WI); Minnesota (MN); North Central (MI, IN, OH, KY); and East (PA, VA, NC, SC). This grouping was based on turkey density, state adjacency, and sequence availability. Bayesian phylodynamic analyses were performed using the final sequence alignment of all ten TRV segments as input to estimate the evolutionary dynamics and spreading patterns of the virus. This extensive data analysis will make a base for proposing nomenclature and genotyping classification. Goal 2: Validate real-time RT-PCR (RT-qPCR) for environment samples (80% Accomplished) Our research team has successfully validated a universal real-time RT-PCR assay for detecting avian reoviruses from environment samples. This assay demonstrated high sensitivity and specificity in the detection of TRV in the environment (non-invasive) samples. Importantly, the results confirmed the absence of any inhibitory substances within these samples that could interfere with the samples processing, nucleic acid extraction and real-time RT-PCR. This high sensitivity of the assay is extremely important for detection of TRV even if virus is present in low concentration. Goal 3: Develop a non-invasive sampling method to detect turkey reoviruses (80% Accomplished) We developed a cost-effective in-house sampling kit for early detection of turkey reovirus. These kits are sterile cotton gauze pre-soaked in brain heart infusion broth with antibiotics and antifungals (to prevent contamination) and were shipped to the recruited farms at 4°C. Farm staff used the kits to collect environmental samples weekly, starting before poults arrival (pre-placement) until they were marketed. Samples were typically collected from surfaces like walls, drinkers, fans, and litter. After collection, the samples were shipped back to our lab at 4°C and stored at -80°C until processing. This method allowed us to detect turkey reovirus RNA in the farm environment before any clinical signs of infection appeared in the turkeys. We also succeeded in the isolation of live turkey reoviruses from the farm environment from foot covers, fans, and walls which was the report of virus isolation from the environment. Furthermore, the application of a noninvasive sampling strategy at the preplacement time helped in the assessment of the cleaning and disinfection programs used in the farms. Interestingly, in the preplacement sampling, we detected the turkey reovirus RNA and infectious virus in noninvasive samples collected from the walls, indicating that cleaning and disinfection efforts were insufficient to eradicate the virus. This early detection allows for corrective actions to be taken before the turkeys arrive, minimizing the risk of infection. Hence, there is no doubt that this approach will be very helpful in evaluating cleaning and disinfecting strategies at turkey farms. This effective cleaning and disinfecting will be helpful in reducing TRV infection in new flocks. Goal 4: Conduct whole genome sequencing and genotyping of selected biosurveillance samples (20% Accomplished) As mentioned in goal 3, we have isolated TRV from environmental samples. We are planning to do whole genome sequencing. Goal 5: Evaluate various decontamination technologies (30% Accomplished) The evaluation of inactivation of four turkey reovirus strains (TERV, TARV-1, TARV-O'Neil, TBRV) by a commercial device using ultraviolet light and ozone has been completed. Experiments are in progress to test the other two strains. A commercial device called the "PathO3Gen Solutions UVZone Shoe Sanitizing Station (SSS)" was obtained from Pathogen Solutions (St. Petersburg, FL). This machine produces ozone (6.0 ppm) at a wavelength of 185 nm and UV-C (2000 lW/cm2 ) at a wavelength of 254 nm. The machine has four UV (386 mm) and two ozone (357 mm) lamps and is certified by a Nationally Recognized Test Laboratory for safe use. The machine sterilization cycle, which lasts a total of 8 sec, begins automatically when someone stands on the glass shield of the machine. All experiments were conducted at room temperature (25º C) with 50% relative humidity. Six different fomites were tested, namely aluminum (AL), rubber boot (RB), cardboard (CB), denim fabric (FB), polypropylene (PP), and stainless steel (SS). The surviving viruses were eluted from all fomites using 100 µl of elution buffer (3% beef extract in 0.05 M glycine) per fomite. Serial 10-fold dilutions of all eluates were prepared in maintenance medium for virus titration. The experiment was repeated once, and the amount of average virus reduction was calculated by subtracting virus titer in "treated" fomites from those in "control" fomites In general, the SSS shoe sterilization machine was able to kill more viruses on porous fomites than on non-porous ones. No significant difference was observed in the inactivation rate among the four different reovirus strains. Hence, disinfection strategy using SSS shoe sterilization machine should be effective irrespective of reovirus type.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2024 Citation: M., Selim, Jangra, S, Luqman, M., Temeeyasen, G., Ohnstad., M, Long., C, Sharafeldin, T., Mor, S. Validation of non-invasive sampling as a diagnostic tool for early detection and screening of avian reovirus in turkey flocks. The 75th North Central Avian Disease Conference (NCADC) was held in Minnesota on the 16th and 17th of April.