Source: TEXAS STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
SEED: EXPLORING NOVEL FISH CULTURES FOR SMALL AND MIDSCALE AQUAPONICS SYSTEMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1030640
Grant No.
2023-67023-40297
Cumulative Award Amt.
$268,217.00
Proposal No.
2022-10395
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2025
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1601]- Agriculture Economics and Rural Communities: Small and Medium-Sized Farms
Recipient Organization
TEXAS STATE UNIVERSITY
601 UNIVERSITY DRIVE
SAN MARCOS,TX 78666
Performing Department
Biology
Non Technical Summary
Aquaponic practices in small and mid-scale systems have often low revenue because fish production is suboptimal compared to plant production. Therefore, there is a need to find new commercial fish culture models that integrate with established plant cultures in aquaponic systems and maximize the profitability of mid and small-scale aquaponic systems. Our exploratory seed project aims to identify novel fish models that can lead to new lines of production in aquaponics. Thus, we will characterize the reproductive output and optimized welfare parameters of green swordtail and of fathead minnow cultures in a small-scale and mid-scale basil aquaponic set-up. We additionally propose extension activities to advance the connection between academia and local farmers (e.g., design of a new aquaponic courses directed to increase the aquaponics taskforce). This proposal is included in the Program Area Agriculture Economics and Rural Communities and directly fits the Program Area Priority of Small and Medium-Sized Farms. Our long-term aim is to develop and adopt new fish culture models that assist farmers in the establishment of aquaponics strategies and technologies that will enhance economic sustainability and competitiveness in the farm market. This will be achieved by addressing the need of 1) create opportunities for new markets in aquaponics systems 2) promote novel fish culture as a source of revenue in aquaponics systems 3) develop effective strategies to aid in the development of research, education and extension/outreach programs that meet the needs of underserved small and medium-sized farmers and ranchers.
Animal Health Component
40%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
40%
Developmental
40%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3073716102040%
3013715108140%
3052235101020%
Goals / Objectives
ObjectivesOur long-term goal is to develop the culture of two novel aquaponics fish species and determine the optimal input of macronutrient derived from plant fertilizer that maximizes these fish welfare. The overarching hypothesis of this proposal is that K and Fe can affect hormonal output during fish sexual reproduction reducing reproductive yield and fish welfare. Our experiments will answer the following experimental aims: (1) Characterization of reproductive output of green swordtail (Xiphophorus helleri). in a small-scale and mid-scale basil aquaponic set-up; and (2) Characterization of reproductive output of fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) in a mid-scale and large-scale basil aquaponic set-up. We also have an educational and extension third aim that will focus in the design a new aquaponic course and stablish connections with the local farmer community.
Project Methods
AIM #1. Characterization of reproductive output of green swordtail (Xiphophorus helleri) in a small-scale and mid-scale basil aquaponic set-up. Small-scale experiments: We will co-cultivate basil with green swordtail for 3 months. The experiments will be conducted in spring in four aquaponic units located in the green house of TXST. The green house has partial control of temperature and a retractable semi-translucent ceiling cover to prevent direct sunlight. Each aquaponic unit contains a 500L fish tank, a biofilter tank, a mixing tank, a plant tank with a floating bed of 160x122x40 cm (63x48x15 inch) with a surface area of 1.9 m2 (20.7 ft2) hosting 24 plants/ bed, a submersible sump pump of capacity 1 HP and ball valves to regulate the water flow (Fig.1). The water pumps will be continuously recirculating water. Coconut coir will be used as the medium in the plant bed to anchor plants. We will culture and harvest basil 3 times during the experiment. Green swordtails will be stocked at a density of 50 individuals per tank (15 males, 35 females) and fed daily with swordtail pellets (Hikari micro pellets) supplemented with black fly larvae (3% w/w). We produce our own black fly larvae in our TXST greenhouse. Adult fish will be hosted in a 1 m3 basket with mesh walls located inside the tank, thus when juveniles are born can escape the basket and avoid predation from parents. Swordtail pregnancy last 1 month and the embryonal sac have embryos at different stages of development. Thus, one single female can have dozens of fish in 3 months.Due to the fast growth of basil, we will plant and harvest two generations of plants during the experiment. Preliminary experiments showed a nutritional deficit in our basil crops in the aquaponic system. Thus, once a week, two units will have plants leaves sprayed with fertilizer containing knowns amounts of Fe, K and two units will be sprayed with water.We will monitor daily for water quality and environmental conditions including temperature and humidity, water temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen [DO], water ammonia, nitrites, nitrates, and alkalinity. We will take weekly water samples (from the different sections of the aquaponics system), adult fish samples, juvenile fish samples and basil leave samples. Moreover, we will quantify reproductive output in fish, and yield basil production weekly. To quantify the flow of nutrients in water fish and plants we will measure chlorophyll of the basil leaves, nitrogen (N), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium, (Mg), phosphorus (P) and sulfur (S) and seven trace elements (chlorine (Cl), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), boron (B), zinc (Zn), copper (Cu) and molybdenum (Mo) of the fish food, leaves, water, and waste by variety of sensors; as well as X-ray fluorescent (XRF) analyzer technique developed at Dr. Asiabanpour lab or using chromatography lab services in TXST. Additionally, fish and water samples will be extracted and analyzed for steroid metabolomics profile to asses reproductive and stress status. For that fish will be homogenized with ethanol 70%, centrifuged, and supernatant evaporated and reconstituted with phosphate buffer. Water and tissue extracts will be extracted by solid phase extraction methods using a C18 Seppac [33]. Extracts will be stored in methanol until analysis by the LC-MS in the Metabolomics and Small Molecules center at NC State University [9]. This technique allows to measure up to 15 different steroids in 80 samples per run. The steroids to be measured are estradiol-17β, testosterone, 11-ketotestosterone, 17α,20ß-dihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one, androstenedione, cortisol, pregnenolone, progesterone and other related progestogens. The PI used these methods in the past and feels confident with this technique. We will analyze statistical differences between treatments for different variables with ANOVA using GraphPad Prism 9.0 software (San Diego, CA, USA). The PI and co-PI will coordinate with the master's student on the development and sampling of this experiment at TXST.Mid-scale experiments. These experiments will be repeated in the mid-scale aquaponics set up in SFCC. The mid-scale system at SFCC has a 500ft2 dome greenhouse also operates a year-round aquaponics system on campus with goldfish and koi.The TXST master student will displace for 3 summer months to Santa Fe and will perform these experiments supervised by R.. Shultz. During this time the master's student will learn several techniques in aquaponics under the supervision of R. Shultz and will also be exposed to the different extension programs that SFCC has developed with the local communities.AIM #2. Characterization of reproductive output of minnows in a mid-scale and large-scale basil aquaponic set-up. We will perform, in the second year fall in TXST and summer at SFCC, the same experiments detailed in aim 1, but replacing the swordfish by fathead minnows. The main difference will be that minnows will be stocked at 20 females: 20 males per tank. Also, instead of baskets we will introduce floating spawning mats. Eggs from floating mats will be collected and hatched embryos will be cultured in 500L fish tanks in Dr. Huertas fish laboratory.AIM 3#. Development of a virtual aquaponics course with a practical laboratory and build of farmers connections. The Pi and coPI will design a 3 credit aquaponic course that can be taught virtually during the spring semester. This course can be added as an elective class to the biology, agriculture and engineering programs or offered as a formative course for anyone interested. The course will be composed of several modules, each one of them taught by a different PI. The TXST master sand SFCC student will design and perform outreach activities directed to local farmers (e.g., farm visits, in which we will facilitate information of aquaponics courses and record information to build a database of local farmers) both in Texas and New Mexico.

Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:We reach out to the Aquaponics community during the Aquaculture America 2024 meeting (San Antonio, Texas)and the Aquaponics 2023 meeting (Santa Fe, New Mexico). During that time, we exchanged information about the technical improvement of aquaponics systems and the production needs of farmers. We also interacted with the aquaponic farming community in Santa Fe, New Mexico, and attended their monthly meetings during the summer experiments.The mid-scale basil production was distributed between the local communities for free. Changes/Problems:We found a high incidence of bacterial infections and cannibalism in swordtail fish. This interferedwith the optimal production of fish.To solve this problem, we designed and established prophylactic treatments with peroxide and designed new fish hiding that will be tested shortly. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?1 Master's students and four undergrads(2 from biology and two from engineering)were trained during this period. The master and two undergraduate students attended the National Aquaponics meeting. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We maintain continuous communication with the Aquaponic community in Santa Fe and with the rest of the aquaponic farmers through the Aquaponics Association. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We aim to design and build, in collaboration with the engineering department, hiding sites for short-tailed fry to avoid cannibalism. We aim to develop the minnows culture described in aim two and elaborate on the financial analysis of every culture.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Fish production in aquaponics is typically limited to common aquaculture species such as tilapia, catfish, and salmon. However, these species yield low outputs in small and mid-sized farms. Consequently, the fish component in aquaponics is primarily utilized as a source of nitrogenous compounds derived from fish waste. Our goal is to introduce new species of smaller fish (including ornamental, research, and recreational species) that can enhance the financial returns of these farms. AIM 1: Characterization of Reproductive Output of Green Swordtail (Xiphophorus helleri) in Small-Scale and Mid-Scale Basil Aquaponic Setups We conducted our experiments at Texas State University (fall 2023 and sprin 2024) and at a small to mid-sized farm at Santa Fe Community College from June to August 2024. Texas State University (Small Laboratory System) We have built four new aquaponics setups, each consisting of a 400-liter fish tank equipped with outlets adapted for small species, a sump pump, a biofilter, and a plant bed with 24 plants. These setups are located in the Biology Greenhouse at Texas State University. In our experiments, we developed co-cultures of basil and swordtail fish. We established optimal light conditions for basil production and analyzed the nutrient cycles in the plants and water, as well as the nitrogen contributions from the fish. We found that the nitrogen input from swordtails was insufficient to sustain our plant culture, necessitating the addition of fertilizer for adequate basil growth. Additionally, we encountered health issues that prevented the swordtails from reproducing. In response, we began developing peroxide treatments for the swordtails in the aquaponic systems. Our research indicated that two treatments per month of 200 ppm of hydrogen peroxide were adequate to prevent illness in the fish without significantly impacting basil growth. Santa Fe Community College (Small Farm) At this location, we co-cultured tilapia (26 kg/m²) and swordtails (0.1 kg/L) with 108 basil plants in two systems (one control and one treatment) over a 21-day period. The treatment involved a single exposure to 200 ppm of peroxide on day two of basil cultivation. Over the course of the experiment, we measured fish cortisol excretion, as well as water concentrations of NO2, NO3, and NH4. At the end of the experiment, we assessed plant and root growth and took samples for compositional analysis (N, P, K, Ca, Mg, S, Fe, Mn, B, Cu, Zn, Mo, Na, Al). This experiment was replicated three times over a three-month period. During this time, the fish biomass was sufficient to produce basil without the need for additional fertilizers. Although swordtails did not show any illness, their spawn was quickly cannibalized, indicating a need for better-designed hiding places for these species. Our preliminary data suggested that peroxide treatments rapidly affected the aquaponic systems, resulting in an increase in water ammonia from the fish within a few days after treatment, returning to baseline levels after 14 days. Cortisol levels in the water rose immediately after dosing but remained within typical aquaculture values. Only micronutrient levels, such as boron, manganese, and copper, were negatively impacted by the peroxide treatment. At the time of harvest, we recorded plant data including height, weight, root length, and leaf width. We also processed and analyzed root and leaf samples from each system for microbiome and chemical composition. Our preliminary data indicated that H2O2 treatments might affect plant production by causing stunted growth (a 5% reduction) while having a negligible impact on cortisol levels in the fish, indicating that the treatment did not induce significant stress.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: The Dynamics of Ammonia Excretion of Green Swordtails (Xiphophorus hellerii) in an Aquaponics Environment. William Ortiz, Alex Tran, Mar Huertas. Graduate Student Symposium. Texas State University. San Marcos, TX