Source: UNIV OF HAWAII submitted to NRP
MHEALTH TO IMPROVE DIET QUALITY AMONG ADOLESCENTS IN EFNEP IN HAWAII
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029971
Grant No.
2023-67012-39409
Cumulative Award Amt.
$225,000.00
Proposal No.
2022-09708
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Apr 1, 2023
Project End Date
Mar 31, 2026
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1344]- Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Disease
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF HAWAII
3190 MAILE WAY
HONOLULU,HI 96822
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
In collaboration with Drs. Corby Martin and John Apolzan, the Project Director (PD), Dr. Chloe Lozano, led the development and conducted preliminary evaluation of the PortionSize Ed mobile app at the Pennington Biomedical Research Center (PBRC), in Louisiana. PortionSize Ed is a dietary assessment and nutrition education app that provides real-time feedback to the user on adherence to personalized dietary recommendations. In collaboration with key stakeholders at the University of Hawaii (UH), Hawaii Extension, PBRC, and industry, the goals of this two year integrated extension and research Postdoctoral Fellowshipare to tailor PortionSize Ed for youth in the Hawaii Expanded Food and Nutrition Education Program (EFNEP), develop a modified EFNEP curriculum that facilitates the use of PortionSize Ed, and to test the feasibility, acceptability, and preliminary efficacy of integrating PortionSize Ed with EFNEP for improving diet quality among youth in Hawaii. Dr. Rachel Novotny at UH is the Primary Mentor, and Dr. Martin at PBRC is a Collaborating Mentor. The AFRI Farm Priority Area of this Postdoctoral Fellowship is food safety, nutrition, and health and it addresses food and nutrition translation. This research will build on the PD's experience in developing mHealth apps and delivering randomized controlled trials. The project supports one of EFNEP's key priority areas, which is to "strengthen science-based learning methods and enhance teaching techniques with appropriate new technologies, social media, and social-ecological approaches". Through the activities of this project, the PD will meet the requirements to be an independent researcher at UH.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
0%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
70360993020100%
Goals / Objectives
This Postdoctoral Award will provide training and experience for the Project Director (PD), Dr. Chloe Lozano, to be an independent researcher at the University of Hawaii (UH) with research focused on mobile health (mHealth) and the prevention of childhood obesity. The PD is a dietitian with a Master's in Health Promotion and completeda Postdoctoral Research Fellowship at the Pennington Biomedical Research Center (PBRC) in the T-32 Training in Obesity Research program. During the PD's masters and doctoral training, she gained experience using a mobile food record to assess food waste of youth in a cross-sectional study in Hawaii, and for dietary intake of adults in a randomized controlled trial (RCT) in Hawaii. As part of her Postdoctoral Fellowship at PBRC, in collaboration with Drs. Corby Martin and John Apolzan, the PD led the development and conducted preliminary evaluation of the PortionSize Ed mobile app in Louisiana. PortionSize Ed, is a dietary assessment and nutrition education app that provides real-time feedback to the user on adherence to tailored US Department of Agriculture's (USDA) MyPlate food group recommendations. The development of PortionSize Ed was informed by the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB).With support from key stakeholders, the objectives of this two year Integrated Extension and Research project are for the PD to 1) gain experience in developing an mHealth tool for improving diet quality among youth in the Hawaii Expanded Food and NutritionEducation Program (EFNEP), 2) Obtain skills in developing an EFNEP curriculum that includes mHealth, 3) Learn key policies and procedures of EFNEP evaluation, and 4) demonstrate competence in developing and managing an RCT pilot study aimed at testing the acceptability, feasibility and preliminary efficacy of coupling PortionSize Ed with EFNEP to improve diet quality among youth in Hawaii. This project supports one of EFNEP's key priority areas, which is to "strengthen science-based learning methods and enhance teaching techniques with appropriate new technologies, social media, and social-ecological approaches". This project builds on the PD's research experience. However, the PD's previous research primarily focused on adults, and she has not developed and delivered a RCT aimed at improving dietary behaviors among youth. Therefore, under the primary mentorship of Dr. Rachel Novotny, who is renowned for community-based childhood obesity research in the Pacific region, co-mentorship by Dr. Martin, a leading expert in mHealth research, and through activities proposed in this project, the PD will meet the requirements to be faculty at UH with research focused on mHealth and prevention of childhood obesity.
Project Methods
The current study is a 6-week cluster randomized design, with two study arms, 1) usual EFNEP for youth, (EFNEP), and 2) EFNEP integrated with the PortionSize Ed app (ENFEP-PSEd). The study will be delivered in one school on Kauai. The Extension Nutrition Educator on Kauai will deliver the EFNEP program to youth, which is the HI-FLY curriculum. Having a paraprofessional from the local community deliver EFNEP is a key part of the program. This study design will help ensure study results are transferable to the local community in Hawaii. Inclusion criteria include males or females, Grades 9 to 12 students attending the target school on Kauai, Hawaii, and there are no additional exclusion criteria. Parental consent and youth's assent will be required for study participation. The aim is to recruit at least 20 out of ~30 students from each classroom. However, this study can accommodate participation by the entire class. The two classrooms will be randomized to either EFNEP or EFNEP-PSEd. Participants will receive a $100 stipend at study completion. Study approval will be obtained through the Institutional Review Board at UH and will be registered with ClinicalTrials.gov.Since EFNEP is usually performed during regular class time, all children in the participating classrooms will receive the standard EFNEP program, and only participants enrolled in the study will undergo additional assessment measures. EFNEP usual care is the HI-FLY curriculum which includes 6 lessons of 1-2 hours each, over 6-weeks. Lesson topics include 1) food storage, safety, and sanitation practices, 2) enjoying more fruits and vegetables, 3) preparing and eating more meals at home, 4) choosing right-sized portions, 5) moving more every day and limiting screen time, and 6) re-thinking your drinks. For the EFNEP-PSEd group, participants will receive EFNEP usual care and be provided with a study smartphone for the 6-week study. Between each EFNEP session, participants will be asked to log their food intake in PortionSize Ed for ≥ one day, outside of school hours. PortionSize Ed data will be used during EFNEP to support goal setting. Participants will be directed to access the educational videos in PortionSize Ed, outside of school hours, to achieve learning outcomes.For all study participants, at baseline, trained study staff will administer a demographics questionnaire, the EFNEP Nutrition Education Survey, and collect weight and height measurements. The Nutrition Education Survey evaluates healthy eating behaviors, physical activity and reduced sedentary behavior, food safety behaviors, and beverages. If requested by the school, height and weight will be measured for all students in the classroom. Study staff will provide participants with a study smartphone and PortionSize Ed training. All participants will complete a one-day mobile food record, on a weekend day, using PortionSize Ed on the study smartphone provided. The Portion Summary tab and Videos tab in PortionSize Ed will be disabled and not visible to the participant when capturing their mobile food record, to reduce reactivity, and to capture usual dietary intake. The Portion Summary and Videos tabs will be re-activated during the intervention period to assist with healthy behavior change. Food images from the mobile food records will be analyzed using RFPM, to ensure minimal error in energy estimates, and each food item will be matched to FPEDs. HEI-2015 total scores an HEI-2015 component scores will be calculated from the FPED data. On completion of the study, baseline measures will be repeated. In addition, trained study staff will administer the Computer Systems Usability Questionnaire (CSUQ)and a User Satisfaction Survey (USS). The CSUQ has 19 questions, answered using a 7-point Likert scale, to rate overall satisfaction, usefulness, information quality and interface quality. The USS has nine quantitative questions, answered with a 6-point Likert scale, and rates satisfaction, ease of use, and adequacy of training. The USS also contains an open-ended question where participants can provide any additional comments. For the EFNEP-PSEd group, throughout the study, data will be collected on participants' usage of the PortionSize Ed app (e.g., number of meals logged, number of times the app was used).Continuous variables will be reported as mean ± SD or SEM, and categorical variables will be reported as counts and percentages. To assess feasibility, we will collect data on participation in the two study arms (EFNEP-PSEd and EFNEP), including the number of students who consent to participate and attrition rates over the 6-week study. To assess acceptability, we will summarize quantitative data and qualitative responses from the USS, and scores from the CSUQ. Any positive or negative experience from study participation will also be evaluated using qualitative responses from the USS, and by evaluating reasons for study dropout. Tracking food group intake is in line with DGA recommendations; therefore, we do not anticipate this intervention will negatively affect eating behaviors. We will also assess PortionSize Ed usage data. To assess preliminary efficacy, we will use intention-to-treat-analyses, where all individuals will be analyzed in a randomization group, regardless of compliance. A linear mixed model will be fit for each outcome. This model uses all available data to estimate the treatment effects over time using maximum likelihood estimation under a missing-at-random assumption. The model will include an indicator variable for intervention group (EFNEP vs. EFNEP-PSEd). The F test will be used to assess the intervention effect, defined as the contrast of change in EFNEP minus change in EFNEP-PSEd. Outcome variables include HEI-2015 score, HEI-2015 component scores, and healthy eating behavior score from the Nutrition Education Survey. Comparisons will be made between Week 6 vs. baseline for HEI-2015 scores, HEI-2015 component scores, and healthy eating behavior scores. Transformations will be made for non-normally distributed data. Diet data will be represented as group mean daily values. Per protocol analyses, for changes in diet quality will also be conducted only among those completing the intervention (i.e., had a Week 6 assessment). Statistical significance will be defined as p<0.05.Primary outcome measures: Feasibility: 1) at least 65% of students in each classroom enroll in the study, 2) No more than 15% study attrition. Acceptability: 1) USS scores and qualitative responses, 2) CSUQ scores, 3) PortionSize Ed usage data across the 6-week intervention, 4) reason for study drop out. Efficacy: 1) change in total HEI-2015 total score, HEI-2015 component scores, and healthy eating behavior scores between baseline and Week 6, 2) difference between change in total HEI-2015 total scores, HEI-2015 component scores, and healthy eating behavior scores between baseline and Week 6 for EFNEP vs. EFNEP-PSEd.

Progress 04/01/23 to 03/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Target audience(s): Children and adolescents Community and school-basededucators Efforts: Conference presentations Nutrition education videos for extension and outreach Workshops Experiential learning opportunities Development of novel dietary assessment methods Laboratory instruction Conference presentations Changes/Problems:The major changes include working with SNAP-Ed instead of EFNEP and early adolescents instead of adolescents. Working with SNAP-Ed instead of EFNEP: Rationale for change: The PD works closely with the Hawaii EFNEP and SNAP-Ed Director, Dr. Jeannie Butel. Dr. Butel advised the PD that it would be better to work with SNAP-Ed to deliver the pilot study in Kauai because there is no EFNEP in Kauai. Both EFNEP and SNAP-Ed deliver the Hawaii Food and Lifeskills for Youth (HI-FLY) curriculum, which will be used during this pilot study. Therefore, changing from working with EFNEP to SNAP-Ed does not affect the study design. Working with early adolescents instead of adolescents: Rationale for change:The School Principal in Kauai advised the PDthat it would be better to work with Grades 6-8 students and not those in Grades 9-12. This is because the Grades 9-12 students will be busy focusing on their exams and will have less time to dedicate to this pilot study. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This NIFA Postdoc has provided the PD with ample training and professional development. To assist with tailoring the PortionSize Ed food database for youth in Hawaii, the PD was trained on the development and application of the Pacific Tracker (PacTrac). Dr. Novotny developed the PacTrac dietary assessment program for evaluation of dietary data for the Pacific Islands. The PD also attended weekly CHL(Children's Healthy Living)Research Group meetings with Dr. Novotny to assist with training on delivering a childhood obesity prevention program in Hawaii. To create culturally appropriate nutritional educational videos for Hawaii SNAP-Ed youth, the PD worked closely with the Hawaii SNAP-Ed Program Director, SNAP-Ed Program Coordinator, and SNAP-Ed Nutrition Educator. The PD was also trained in the delivery of SNAP-Ed classes to children in Hawaii and shadowed the delivery of SNAP-Ed in a classroom. With support from Dr. Butel, the PD was trained in SNAP-Ed policies and procedures, including program implementation, and evaluation guidelines. The PD has also met monthly with her collaborating mentor, Dr. Corby Martin for training in developing mHealth technologies and delivering RCTs. The PD also audited a coding class at the University of Hawaii in SAS and R coding, to ensure she could score diet quality (HEI-2020) at the completion of the study. The PD also developed professionally by hiring and managing a Research Assistant. The Research Assistant was hired at the beginning of this study and continues to provide important research assistance. Overall, the PD has become more competent as an independent researcher in Hawaii. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The study will begin in August 2024; therefore, the primary results are not yet available to disseminate to the community. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next reporting period we will finalize the study recruitment, deliver the RCT pilot, conduct data collection, analyze study data, publish the study results in a peer-reviewed journal, and use the pilot data to apply for another research grant.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? In the last 12 months the PD led the development of the PortionSize Ed app for SNAP-Ed Hawaii. We had originally planned to work with EFNEP; however, with guidance from the Hawaii EFNEP and SNAP-Ed Program Director, we changed to working with SNAP-Ed. To create the PortionSize Ed app multiple steps were needed including, development of a nutrient database, development of nutrition education videos, visual design of the PortionSize Ed app, and creating a PortionSize Ed app tutorial. Each of these components were tailored for children in Hawaii. In addition, we developed a web-based platform for receiving and analyzing all PortionSize Ed data, and conducted continuous in-lab testing of the app. Further details are provided on these steps below: Development of a nutrient database for PortionSize Ed: A dataset of 1,858 commonly consumed foods in Hawaii was compiled from dietary studies conducted at the University of Hawaii (UH) at Manoa and the UH Cancer Center. Using this dataset, the PD identified 97 foods not found in FNDDS (version 17-18). These 97 foods were 1) matched to the closest match in FNDDS if they were single item foods, and 2) using recipes, broken down into ingredients and matched to FNDDS ingredients codes (version 17-18). These 97 foods were then added into the PortionSize Ed app, in addition to 6,556 foods from FNDDS (version 17-18) that are consumed by children (e.g. excluded alcohol and baby foods). Therefore, each food in PortionSize Ed is linked to a FNDDS code and diet quality (HEI-2020 scores) can be calculated from the data output. Development of nutrition education videos: Seven nutrition education videos were developed with the assistance of the Distance Education team at the University of Hawaii at Manoa. These videos include 1) Meet MyPlate, 2) MyPlate: Protein, 3) MyPlate: Vegetables, 4) MyPlate: Fruits, 5) MyPlate: Grains, 6) MyPlate: Dairy, 7) Understanding Nutrition Labels. Each video is less than 3 minutes in duration and featured foods commonly consumed in Hawaii (e.g. taro, papaya, hapa rice). Each video also contains subtitles. The videos are embedded into the PortionSize Ed app, under the "Videos" tab, are available through YouTube, and are also featured on the University of HawaiiNutrition Center website. Visual design of the PortionSize Ed app: The PortionSize Ed app was designed to be appropriate for children. Therefore, the Portion Summary screen provides tailored feedback on intake of Fruits, Vegetables, Dairy, Grains, and Protein, Saturated Fat and Added Sugar, but does not provide feedback on intake of alcohol or energy (kcal).Alcohol should not be consumed by children, and it is recommended that children focus on meeting food group requirements. Creating a PortionSize Ed app tutorial: A PortionSize Ed app tutorial was created and embedded into the app. This tutorial is also available through YouTube.The tutorial was designed so that users could re-train how to use the PortionSize Ed app when needed. Obtain skills in developing an EFNEP curriculum that includes mHealth: Given we changed to working with the SNAP-Ed program, the PD developed skills in developing SNAP-Ed curriculum that includes mHealth. The standard SNAP-Ed curriculum will be provided to all study participants. For the experimental group, who receives the PortionSize Ed app, they will also be provided with a Portion Summary Worksheet and a SMART Goals Worksheet. After participants have recorded their intake using the PortionSize Ed app, they will transfer the information from the Portion Summary screen into the hard copy Portion Summary Worksheet. This information will then be used to set SMART goals. For example, if a participant only consumes one instead of the recommended two cup eq. of Fruits for the day, they could use the SMART goals worksheet to problem solve how to consume two cup eq. of Fruits by the next SNAP-Ed lesson in one week. Learn key policies and procedures of EFNEP evaluation: Instead of EFNEP, the PD learned about key policies and procedures for SNAP-Ed evaluation. Given the PD target group is children, she was trained on delivering and evaluating SNAP-Ed for children in Hawaii. This training was provided by the SNAP-Ed Program Director, SNAP-Ed Program Coordinator, and SNAP-Ed Nutrition Educator in Hawaii. Training was provided online and in person. The PD also observed a final SNAP-Ed session, including completion of the SNAP-Ed Nutrition Education Survey by participants. Demonstrate competence in developing and managing an RCT pilot study aimed at testing the acceptability, feasibility and preliminary efficacy of coupling PortionSize Ed with EFNEP to improve diet quality among youth in Hawaii: The PD has demonstrated competence in these areas by developing the pilot study protocol, study questionnaires, study flyer, consent and assent forms, registering the study on ClincalTrials.gov, receiving IRB approval, building the PortionSize Ed app, managing the study budget, hiring, supervision and training of a Research Assistant, delivering recruitment sessions at the target school, and establishing partnerships with key community stakeholders. The PortionSize Ed pilot study will begin at the end of August; therefore, the PD will report on her competence on delivering the RCT in the next progress report.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2023 Citation: https://www.usp.ac.fj/the-institute-of-applied-sciences/11th-oceania-foods-2023/
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Lozano CP, Canty EN, Saha S, Broyles ST, Beyl RA, Apolzan JW, Martin CK. Validity of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Application to Identify Foods and Estimate Energy Intake Among Adults: A Pilot Study. Curr Dev Nutr. 2023 Sep 29;7(11):102009. doi: 10.1016/j.cdnut.2023.102009. PMID: 38026571; PMCID: PMC10656219.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2024 Citation: Validity of the PortionSize app compared to MyFitnessPal for estimating intake: A randomized crossover laboratory-based evaluation (in print in AJCN).
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Accepted Year Published: 2024 Citation: A Food and Nutrient Database for Dietary Studies (FNDDS) Tailored to Hawaii May Reduce Dietary Assessment Error