Source: UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA submitted to NRP
SP: ACCELERATING THE DELIVERY OF CONVENTIONALLY DEVELOPED HLB TOLERANT CITRUS SCIONS AND ROOTSTOCKS AS PATHOGEN-FREE BUDLINES FOR REPLICATED MULTI-SITE TESTING
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029413
Grant No.
2022-70029-38584
Cumulative Award Amt.
$535,957.00
Proposal No.
2022-06721
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 15, 2022
Project End Date
Sep 14, 2025
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[ECDRE]- Emergency Citrus Disease Research and Extension Program
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
G022 MCCARTY HALL
GAINESVILLE,FL 32611
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The project is focused on accelerating the delivery of conventionally developed HLB tolerant citrus scions and rootstocks as pathogen-free budlines for replicated multi-site testing by adopting an alternating temperature treatment. This simple technology will reduce the current clean-up time by 1.5-2 years and significantly increase the number of selections that can be processed. The project will utilize extensive collections of novel HLB tolerant/resistant citrus germplasm generated by the UF-CREC breeding team, including many that have the potential to create new niche/specialty marketing opportunities for national citrus growers. For example, new cold-hardy selections would be available for north Florida and other states like Georgia. Future plantings will be less susceptible to tree decline and crop losses, creating a more stable and expanded citrus industry. Using pathogen-free HLB tolerant scion/rootstock combinations reduces fruit production costs, including pesticide and fertilizer applications, which would positively impact human health and the environment. Commercial use of the high-quality and unique HLB-tolerant scions and rootstocks will provide Florida growers with more sustainable and profitable alternatives to replace the hundreds of acres currently going out of production due to HLB. Growers, processors, packers, and marketers will all benefit, and the project will also accelerate the delivery of new unusual and lucrative niche-market varieties. In short, developing a reliable rapid protocol for generating pathogen-free material with no rejuvenation is necessary for the timely delivery of these new scions and rootstocks to our ravaged Florida citrus industry.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
20209991080100%
Knowledge Area
202 - Plant Genetic Resources;

Subject Of Investigation
0999 - Citrus, general/other;

Field Of Science
1080 - Genetics;
Goals / Objectives
Florida field-tested Huanglongbing (HLB) resistant/tolerant scions and rootstocks by using an alternating temperature treatment. The project is an elevated risk/high reward that would enable HLB tolerant/resistant germplasms from different citrus genetic backgrounds, which have been developed by conventional breeding (not genetically modified or CRISPR manipulated genomes), to serve as resources for breeding programs and for dissecting the genetic basis of resistance to HLB. The results of this project would expedite large multi-site field testing in Florida necessary to determine the actual value of HLB resistant/tolerant scions and rootstocks.The four objectives planned to accomplish the goals of the project are:Identify and Propagate elite conventionally bred field-tested HLB tolerant citrusApply alternating temperature treatments to induce healthy growth from diseased plantsConfirm HLB and CTV-free cultivars after alternating temperature treatmentsPropagate pathogen-free cultivars to be validated by the Florida PTP battery of tests
Project Methods
?The four objectives are strongly interrelated. The project team members will assemble an outstanding group of scientists with expertise in different technology areas. PD will identify the most promising scions and rootstock to be cleaned up based on his 30+ years of citrus breeding (Objective 1). qPCR and ELISA will be used to confirm the infection of propagated materials before treatment (Co-PIs - Objective 1). Pre-treatment and post-treatment qPCR and ELISA to verify that the reproduced materials are pathogen-free (Co-PIs - Objective 2, 3, and 4).The citrus breeding program at the UF/CREC conducts several fruit/juice displays every year and invites different stakeholders to evaluate the new citrus cultivars in all the mentioned categories. New selections identified with potential for specialty crop niche markets, the fresh market industry, or the processing industry are identified by input provided by participating citrus growers and stakeholders, but unfortunately, there is no pathogen-free budwood for the immediate release of these cultivars. Besides, many of these new selections have been standing well in the field under intense HLB pressure. Since HLB became a problem, the CREC Citrus Improvement Program began a new 'gauntlet' screening program to quickly identify new rootstock hybrids with the best potential to mitigate or eliminate HLB from any grafted scions (Grosser et al. 2020). So far, more than 15,000 hybrid seedlings encompassing tremendous genetic diversity have been screened, and promising selections are now being identified. These selections require immediate large-scale testing to help save all types of citriculture in Florida, and pathogen-free material is needed to make this happen. Thus, developing a reliable rapid protocol for generating pathogen-free material with no rejuvenation is necessary for the timely delivery of these new scions and rootstocks to all phases of our citrus industry.The selection of the scion cultivars that will be included in this project for the generation of pathogen-free budlines will depend on the stakeholder's evaluations to meet their demand or that fill potential new specialty niches. All the outcomes from this project expedite the potential benefits of new varieties to the citrus industry at both the local and the national levels. Since most of the target citrus germplasm in this project are not commercially available yet, collaboration with different stakeholders (DPI, Florida PTP, FFSP, FNGLA and growers) will facilitate introducing these new cultivars to the citrus industry. Work will occur on all the project objectives each year.Objective 1: Identify and Propagate elite conventionally bred field-tested HLB tolerant citrus.Budwoods from new varieties but not commercially available yet will be collected from the source tree and propagated by grafting onto selected rootstocks that push vigorous scion growth. This will include any promising scions (sweet orange, mandarin, grapefruit, pummelo, tangerine, and unique acid-fruit types) and rootstocks. The selected cultivars for cleanup will be chosen based on their fruit quality evaluation, specialty crop potential, and consumer acceptance as well as grower interest and the most important HLB performance in the field. Grafted plants will grow in the greenhouse for three months to reach at least 30" before moving to the alternating temperatures chamber.HLB diagnosis of mature leaves for Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas) titer and activity will be performed by using the quantitative polymerase chain reaction (q-PCR) according to Li et al. (2006)on the propagated plants before treatment.CTV diagnostics is dependent on double antibody sandwiched enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (DAS-ELISA) and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). ELISA is easy to perform and suitable for large scale processing of samples. However, RT-PCR which is more laborious is more sensitive. ELISA is used to semi-quantify the amount of CTV in a sample by running a serial dilution analysis. DAS-ELISA protocol (Garnsey and Cambra 1991) is established and routinely run in EL Mohtar lab. ELISA positive post-treatment plants will be discarded whereas ELISA negative plants will be subject to RT-PCR using CTV coat protein primers (Hilf et al. 2005) to confirm the ELISA negative tests. Template RNA for RT-PCR will be extracted from the midribs of treated plants using a Trizol reagent (Ambion) or RNeasy® Plant Mini kit (Qiagen). Proper positive and negative controls will be included in all assays.Objective 2: Apply alternating temperature treatments to induce healthy growth from diseased plants.Exposing actively growing infected citrus plants (HLB and CTV) to the alternating temperature regimes does not cure the tree but prevents the establishment of the pathogens in the newly growing tissue. The temperature regimes will oscillate between 4 hours at 45°C and 4 hours at 25°C for three months. The oscillation between the temperatures will minimally affect plant growth but degrades viral ssRNA and the continuous heat shock will prevent bacteria from establishing in the new tissue. To the best of our knowledge, there is no non-destructive effective rapid protocol to clean up infected citrus plants from HLB. The established meristem-tip culture protocol generally takes about 2 years. Thus, the proposed new technique will offer an alternative method to produce propagative pathogen-free materials and still maintain the genetic integrity of the original plant in significantly less time.Objective 3: Confirm HLB and CTV-free cultivars after alternating temperature treatments.On a monthly basis, the plants inside the chamber will be screened for HLB using qPCR and CTV using ELISA test as described in objective 1. This will allow us to monitor the titer reduction of HLB and CTV in the new growth to make sure that the collected budwoods for the next objective are HLB and CTV-free.Our preliminary data showed that CLas and CTV could be eliminated from citrus materials after alternate temperature regime treatment (45°C for 4 hours and 25°C for 4 hours) for 3-4 months.Objective 4: Propagate pathogen-free cultivars to be validated by the Florida PTP battery of testsPlants confirmed to be pathogen-free from the previous objective will be used as a source for budwoods for micrografting onto the most promising rootstocks. After establishing the grafted plants, another round of qPCR and ELISA will be performed to make sure that they are still pathogen-free. At this stage, plants confirmed pathogen-free will be provided to the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Bureau of Citrus Budwood Registration for validation by their standard battery of PCR-based tests for all the important pathogens, the same testing that is performed on selections coming from meristem-tip culture. It should be noted that this procedure does not work for the elimination of viroids, but most new selections in the breeding program have not been in the field long enough to acquire any viroids; thus, this should not be a problem, but demonstrates the importance of thorough validation by DPI. Any selections validated to be pathogen free could be made available for commercial use in Florida, and also made available to the USDA Citrus Germplasm Repository in Riverside, California, for certification and distribution to other States. New pathogen-free scions and rootstocks developed by this project must be available to the industry as quickly as possible to maintain a sustainable, profitable US citrus industry.

Progress 09/15/23 to 09/14/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience reached during this reporting period was the Florida Department of Plant Industry Citrus Regulatory Officers involved with the Parent Tree Program. We established a cooperation to have them validate our putative pathogen-free lines using the standard PCR testing they use for the Parent Tree Program to certify pathogen-free budlines. Changes/Problems:In our old growth chamber that became too old to continue maintaining the alternate temperature treatment setup., we used alternate temperatures oscillating between high (45oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for hrs). This condition allowed the development of HLB and CTV-free growth from infected plants. However, when we used the same setting in the new growth chamber, it induced some severe phenotype (burning) in the new growth after two months. This prompted us to optimize the program conditions for the new growth chambers. After several trials, the settings were adjusted to maintain 42°C for 4 hrs, followed by 25°C for 4 hrs, with relative humidity and light intensity set as gradients. The first batch of plants entered the growth chamber on June 26, 2023. Most plants are thriving under these conditions and produced new flushes. Samples were collected from the new growth and confirmed HLB and CTV negative by qPCR and ELISA, respectively. Budwoods were collected and grafted onto pathogen-free rootstocks in a certified disease-free greenhouse in preparation for sending the plant materials to the DPI facility to be tested for other pathogens. We repeated the treatment cycle on another patch of plants.Thus, the unanticipated problem of growth chamber parameters was finally solved. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The technical staff participating in the project learned about fundemental citrus scion and rootstock improvement, and basic plant pathology relating to disease resistance and pathogen removal. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Meeting Abstract: We presented our preliminary data at the ASHS 2023 meeting in Orlando, Florida, from July 31 - August 4, 2023. Title "Accelerating the release of new citrus varieties through alternate temperature treatment". Also, we presented our data at FY24 Citrus Disease Subcommittee (CDS) and NIFA's ECDRE (Emergency Citrus Disease Research Extension) Program Joint Meeting from November 2 - 3, 2023 What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will continue to treat more germplasm in the extended third year of the project with no additional request cost to finish our pre-selected 33 lines and add more whenever possible. New additions to the program are focused on new high quality processing orange selections showing enhanced HLB tolerance.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Objective 1.We observed significant genetic variation in the nucellar seedlings derived from processing sweet orange somaclones with excellent fruit quality, which allowed us to identify lines with potential tolerance to HLB. Objective 2.We have optimized and confirmed the different parameters of light, humidity, and temperatures to run the alternate temperature program in the new growth chambers without causing any deleterious phenotype (burning) to the new growth as well as confirming that the new growth on plants in the chamber is both HLB and CTV free. Objective 3.We confirmed that alternate temperature regimen treatment of 42oC for 4 hrs followed by and optimal temperature of 25oC for 4 hrs would produce HLB and CTV-free growth from field-infected materials that could be further used as sources to increase sources of HLB resistant plant materials. Objective 4. Pathogen-free budlines of 14 selections were certified by the DPI to be free from all pathogens tested for and will be propagated for large-scale field testing in Florida.

Publications


    Progress 09/15/22 to 09/14/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target audience involves components of the Citrus Industry that are promoting field trials of new scion/rootstock combinations as needed to defeat HLB. These include: The Florida Department of Citrus, The Florida Citrus Commission, The New Varieties Development and Management Corporation and the Citrus Research and Development Foundation. Various progressive citrus growers, processors and nurserymen are also included in the target audience. Changes/Problems:We encountered burning and dieback on the first batch of plants put into the new chambers. We also were using a controlled release fertilizer (CRF)product for nutrition. However we determined that under the high temperatures, that the CRF released the nutrients too quickly, resulting in fertilizer burn and dieback on the plants. This has now been corrected. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Presentation at annual ASHS meeting in Orlando - provided update on progress. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We expect to validate the pathogen-free status of the first batch of new varieties via PCR analyses. All resulting pathogen-free selections will be propagated onto rootstocks for replicated field trials. We are negotiation with Florida DPI to have this technology considered for use in the Parent Tree Program (PTP).

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Objective 1: Identify & Propagate elite conventionally bred field-tested HLB-tolerant citrus A- Major activities completed / experiments conducted: Our field visits enabled the identification of 33 new lines that could potentially be tolerant/resistant to HLB. B- Data collected: Field samples were collected from selected trees showing HLB tolerant/resistant to propagate on selected rootstocks in the greenhouse to prepare for thermotherapy and confirm HLB and CTV infection by qPCR and ELISA, respectively. C- Results summary and Discussion: Tissue collected from the field was not ideal, which resulted in some failed grafts and forced us to recollect tissue and propagate more plants to enable thermotherapy on more than one plant from the same tree. qPCR confirmed all 33 samples are positive HLB. However, only one of the collected samples was positive for CTV by ELISA. The difference between HLB and CTV infection is intriguing. It could be attributed to the difference in the mode of transmission by the insect vector of the two phloem-limited pathogens. For example, HLB is transmitted in a circulative propagative manner, which enables the Clas bacteria to exist in the ACP insect for the life of the vector. On the contrary, CTV is transmitted by the aphid species in a semipersistent manner, which means the vector needs around 12 hours to be able to transmit the CTV virus and would be transmitted to healthy plants for 24-28 hrs only. Thus, insecticidal sprays used to control the ACP in the field could be playing a major role in preventing the spread of CTV by its aphid's insect vector. One could not rule other factors playing a role in the difference in the result such as the quality of the tissue collected and the nature of the two pathogens one being a DNA (Clas) and one an RNA (CTV). We would run again the ELISA assay on budwood collected from the field and propagated in the greenhouse to reconfirm the CTV infection results. D- Key outcomes or other accomplishments realized: Within the nucellar seedlings derived from sweet orange somaclones, there is a high genetic variation which enabled us to identify lines with potential tolerance to HLB. Objective 2: Apply alternate temperature treatments to induce healthy growth from diseased plants. A- Major activities completed / experiments conducted: As expected, the old growth chamber operating within our facilities failed to maintain the setup of alternate temperature treatment due to age. Thus, as suggested in the grant, we pre-ordered two new growth chambers to ensure the work outcome. The growth chambers were installed at the Citrus Research and Education Center (CREC) 6 months after ordering on Feb 23. B- Data collected: The major focus of the data collection was the quality of the new growth in the new chambers under the alternate temperature regiment and the relative humidity and light gradients. C- Results summary and Discussion: Alternate temperatures oscillating between high (45oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for hrs) enabled the development of HLB and CTV of free growth from infected plants. Our first run was to confirm that the alternate temperature treatment program of high temperature (45oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for 4 hrs) used in the old chamber would not affect the growth of seedlings when applied in the new growth chambers. Unfortunately, the conditions mentioned above in the new growth chamber induced some severe phenotype (burning) in the new growth after two months. This forced us to work on optimizing the program conditions for the new growth chambers. The program was optimized for (42oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for 4 hrs), whereas the relative humidity and light intensity are gradients. The first plant patch entered the growth chamber on June 26, 2023. Most of the plants are growing normally at the condition settings and started new flushes. Samples will be collected from the new growth for HLB and CTV testing. Once the qPCR and ELISA results confirm no presence of HLB and CTV, respectively, in the emerging hardened growth, budwood will be collected and grafted onto pathogen-free rootstocks in a certified disease-free greenhouse in preparation for large scale field testing. 4) Key outcomes or other accomplishments realized: We have optimized the different parameters of light, humidity, and temperatures to run the alternate temperature program in the new growth chambers without causing any deleterious phenotype (burning) to the new growth. Objective 3: Confirm HLB and CTV-free cultivars after alternating temperature treatment A- Major activities completed / experiments conducted:Still waiting for first group of plants to complete the thermotherapy treatment. B- Data collected: Our first run was to confirm that the alternate temperature treatment program of high temperature (45oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for 4 hrs) used in the old chamber would not affect growth of seedlings when applied in the new growth chambers. C- Results summary and Discussion: Alternate temperatures oscillating between high (45oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for hrs) enabled the development of HLB and CTV of free growth from infected plants. In the new growth chamber, the conditions mentioned above induced some severe burning phenotype in the new growth after two months. This forced us to work on optimizing the program conditions for the new growth chambers. The program was optimized for (42oC for 4 hrs) and optimal temperatures (25oC for 4 hrs) whereas the relative humidity and light intensity are gradients. The first plant patch entered the growth chamber on June 26, 2023. Most of the plants are growing normally at this setting and started new flushes. Samples will be collected from the new growth for HLB and CTV. Once the qPCR and ELISA results induct no presence of HLB and CTV, budwood will be collected and grafted onto pathogen-free rootstocks in a certified disease-free greenhouse for the next step. 4) Key outcomes or other accomplishments realized: We have optimized the different parameters of light, humidity, and temperatures to run the alternate temperature program in the new growth chambers without causing any deleterious phenotype (burning) to the new growth. Objective 3: Confirm HLB and CTV-free cultivars after alternating temperature treatment. A- Major activities completed / experiments conducted: The new growth from the seedlings introduced into the growth chambers is starting to emerge, which will enable us in the near future to run qPCR and ELISA bioassays to confirm the success of the alternate temperature program in the new growth chamber. B- Data collected: In the project's second year, qPCR and ELISA data will be run in the alternate temperature treatment growth, enabling the generation of trees traditionally bred and free of HLB and CTV for large-scale field testing in Florida. C- Results summary and Discussion: The qPCR and ELISA negative data will be generated. D- Key outcomes or other accomplishments realized: The qPCR and ELISA assay in the 2nd year of the project will confirm HLB tolerant/resistant plants are free of HLB and CTV, which will enable us to establish large-scale field experiments to demonstrate that HLB tolerance is stable and propagative.

    Publications