Progress 09/01/23 to 08/31/24
Outputs Target Audience:The primary target audiences reached for the current project period were cattle feedlot management, industry professionals (consultants and producers), and university and government researchers (including students). Interactions with these audiences were through research collaborations, consulting, and conference presentations. Changes/Problems:
Nothing Reported
What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project has provided numerous training and professional development opportunities, for both the students and staff involved. It has supported three full-time employees and enabled their training in numerous techniques ranging from phage isolation and characterization to metagenomic sequencing and analysis. Additionally, it has supported a part-time employee/student and served as the foundation for their thesis work. Five other students were also involved in the animal trial, which required conducting some novel procedures and presented unique educational opportunities. All key personnel were also able to attend the ASM Microbe 2023 conference and the 2023 Evergreen Phage conference, which provided substantial professional development opportunties. Additionally, key personnel and collaborators participated in preparing two new peer-reviewed publications this project period. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Project results have been disseminated in the following manner: Two publications in leading industry journals (PHAGE and ACS Agricultural Science & Technology) Oral presentation at Microbiota Days 2023 Depositing sequencing data in a public database (GenBank) Discussions with academic and industrial experts What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?While we have met the success metric for Objectives 2, 3, 4, and 5, several challenges remain to be overcome this next project period. For Objective 1, our success metric was to isolate and characterize at least 6 genetically distinct lytics phages against S. bovis. Currently, most of our S. bovis phages fall into 3 genetically distinct groups, while we have three individual phages that each appear unique. However, two of these phages have proven difficult to sequence despite multiple attempts. Thus, for the next project period, we will focus on characterizing these three phages, and potentially isolating additional phages to expand our current library. We will also continue to improve phage production methods, particularly for several phages that do not reproduce well in liquid broth. These phages do produce high titers when grown in double layer agar, but this technique is not very scalable. We intend to test several different methods to enhance production, including the use of semi-solid or viscous media and microcarrier beads that can serve as substrate for bacterial attachment.
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
This project period marked significant progress toward characterizing and improving bacteriophages targeting Streptococcus bovis/Streptococcus equinus complex (SBSEC) bacteria. Below is a detailed summary of achievements across the project objectives for the current project period: Objective 1: Isolate additional S. bovis complex phages and characterize life cycles. Substantial work was completed to expand and characterize our SBSEC phage library. We isolated over 25 phages, though some were unstable or duplicates of previously identified strains, resulting in a focused characterization of 17 unique phages. These phages were categorized into types A, B, C, and others based on phenotypic traits, including host range, optimal amplification conditions, and bacterial growth inhibition in vitro. Host range analysis showed that despite high phage specificity, our SBSEC phages could lyse bacterial isolates from geographically diverse sources. These results suggest broader potential applications, with host range further expandable using established methods like Appleman's protocol. Genomic sequencing of 13 phages revealed a high degree of genetic similarity within certain groups (>99% identity for types B and C), with genome sizes ranging from 33.8 to 40.5 Kbp and GC content from 37.1% to 39.4%. These values closely align with the GC content of SBSEC genomes (~37%). Ongoing work is focused on elucidating the links between small genomic differences and observed phenotypic traits, providing insights into phage-host interactions and informing future applications. Objective 2: Expand phage host ranges and efficacy through in vitro evolution. We built on previous successes in expanding host range through Appleman's protocol by conducting in vitro evolution experiments to increase phage virulence. Six SBSEC phages underwent 30 rounds of serial passaging with bacterial cultures, with growth clearance and plaque-forming ability assessed every 10 rounds. Among these, one phage (PY1) showed dramatic improvement in bacterial suppression. While two phages (Mushu, PY7) showed minimal or no improvement, and two (PY20, PY3) lost viability, these results provide valuable data on the variability of phage adaptability. The study highlights the potential for enhancing phage efficacy through targeted training, with implications for developing more robust phage formulations. Objective 3: Assess and improve phage thermal stability. Thermal adaptation experiments were conducted to address the limited heat tolerance of two lytic phages, CSJC and Mushu, which previously lost viability after 10 minutes at 65°C. By applying heat-exposure protocols combined with sodium pyrophosphate (SPP) and ethyl-methanesulfonate (EMS), we successfully increased their thermal resistance. The improved phages demonstrated significantly greater stability under heat stress compared to their parental counterparts, representing a key step toward developing phages suitable for varied environmental and processing conditions. Objective 4: Scale up and optimize production of Streptococcus and Fusobacterium phages. We optimized protocols to achieve higher phage titers for SBSEC bacteriophages, focusing on adjusting multiplicity of infection (MOI) and initial cell concentrations in liquid cultures. These efforts resulted in 2-3 fold higher titers for most phages, enabling more efficient production. Three phages, however, remained challenging to amplify outside of plaque assays. For Fusobacterium varium phages, previously reported high titers were maintained, though further increases were not observed. These results demonstrate progress in scaling up phage production and improving yields for future applications.
Publications
- Type:
Peer Reviewed Journal Articles
Status:
Accepted
Year Published:
2024
Citation:
Schwarz, Cory, Jacques Mathieu, Jenny Laverde Gomez, Marina Tikhonova, T. G. Nagaraja, and Pedro JJ Alvarez. "Detection of Tylosin Resistance in Fusobacterium necrophorum subspecies necrophorum." ACS Agricultural Science & Technology (2024).
- Type:
Peer Reviewed Journal Articles
Status:
Accepted
Year Published:
2024
Citation:
Schwarz, Cory, Jacques Mathieu, Jenny Laverde Gomez, Megan R. Miller, Marina Tikhonova, Clark Hamor, and Pedro JJ Alvarez. "Isolation and Characterization of Six Novel Fusobacterium necrophorum Phages." PHAGE (2024).
|
Progress 09/01/22 to 08/31/23
Outputs Target Audience:The primary target audiences reached for the current project periodwerecattle feedlot management, industry professionals (consultants andproducers), and university and government researchers (including students). Interactions with these audiences were through research collaborations, consulting, and conference presentations. Changes/Problems:
Nothing Reported
What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project has provided numerous training and professional development opportunities, for both the students and staff involved. It has supported three full-time employees and enabled their training in numerous techniques ranging from phage isolation and characterization to metagenomic sequencing and analysis. Additionally, it has supported a part-time employee/student and served as the foundation for their thesis work. Five other students were also involved in the animal trial, which required conducting some novel procedures and presented unique educational opportunities. All key personnel were also able to attend the ASM Microbe 2023 conference and the 2023 Evergreen Phage conference, which provided substantial professional development opportunties. Additionally, key personnel and collaborators participated in preparing a publication onsome of our initial findings. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Project results have been disseminated in the following manner: Publication in a leading industry journal (Journal of Animal Science) Invited symposium at ASAS 2023 Invited oral presentation at Microbiota Days 2023 Poster presentation at ASM Microbe 2023 Poster presentation at Evergreen 2023 Depositing sequencing data in a public database (GenBank) Discussions with academic and industrial experts What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?For the next reporting period, our primary focus will be on optimizing and modifying various adaptive laboratory evolution (ALE) methods to help advance our efforts at improving phage killing efficiencies, expanding phage host ranges, and increasing thermal stability. There is relatively little research regarding the use of ALE for phages and it is clear that much more work is remaining in this area. A particular area we intend to focus on is a quantitative analysis of the rationale behind certain methods, such as the Appleman's protocol. Though there are many potential parameters to optimize for this and similar assays, little work has been done in that regard. Improving our understanding of individual phage mutation rates andgrowth kinetics under various conditions will help ensure we are able to capture desirable mutations as they might arise. Additionally, we will assess how different combinations of phages and bacterial strains impact the results of select ALE methods. For example, in Appleman's protocol, is it better to use phages with high similarity to promote more frequent recombination, or more genetically diverse phages that have the potential for producing a broader range of potential outcomes or novel functionalities?How does the number of phages used in each cocktail impact the results? Is it beneficial to use mixed species cultures containing both susceptible and non-susceptible hosts? Our experience to date suggests that improving ALE method efficiency will be critical for commercializing off-the-shelf phage products and we believe focusing our efforts on this is key to advancing this project as well as the broader field of phage-based microbiome engineering.
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
Substantial progress towards accomplishing the overall project goals was made this project period, with several objectives having been completed. Major accomplishments included the isolation and characterization of nine new phages that are able to infect S. bovis complex species (objective 1: 80% complete), the successful scaling up of four F. varium phages and six S. bovis phages to greater than 1010phages/mL (objective 4: 50% complete), and completion of a small-scale animal trial to evaluate phage efficacy and safety in vivo(objective 5: 100% complete). Other accomplishments include successfully expanding the host range of our S. bovis phage collection (objective 2: 25% complete), and assessing the thermal stability of numerous F. varium and S. bovisphages (objective 3: 33% complete). Specific details are discussed below. Objective 1: Isolate additionalS. bovisphages and characterize life cycles. Our goal for this objective was to isolate 6 new S. bovis complex phages, and we were able to isolate 9 from independent samples, bringing our total to 15 S. bovis complex phages. We have completed genome sequencing for 6 of these and are currently in the process of sequencing the remaining genomes. Of the 6 genome-sequenced phages, one is temperate while the remaining 5 are lytic. Objective 2:Expand phage host ranges and efficacy through in vitro evolution. In general, our F. varium phages have relatively broad host ranges (infect multiple strains) but a limited ability to inhibit host growth (regrowth after ~7 h). In contrast, our S. bovis complex phages have strong inhibitory activity (up to 30 h without bacterial growth), but a fairly narrow host range. Thus, we conducted adaptive laboratory evolution with the intent of increasing F. varium phage killing efficiencies and broadening S. bovis phage host ranges. Specifically, 6 F. varium phages were subjected to a phage training protocol (TRAIN30) in conjunction with various hosts. After 30 cycles,we foundthat 4 phages had increased inhibitory activity (6 -32% reduction in area under the curve (AUC) relative tothe parent phage (p<0.05)). One phage performed worse than its parentphage by 13%(p<0.05). One phage improved after the training, but not in a statistically significant manner (4% less bacterial growth). We also attempted to accelerate mutagenesis using the mutagen ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS). After 5 rounds (CAVE5 protocol), we observed one phage with a 6% increase in inhibitory activity (p<0.05), while the others showed non statistically signficant changes in activity. We did not observe any changes in phage yields in liquid culture amplifications of any of the F. variumphages after either the TRAIN30 or CAVE5 method. However, average yields range from 1 - 6 x1010 PFU/mL of lysate, which exceeds our production objectives. A modified Appleman's protocol was used to facilitate S. bovis complex host range expansion. A total of 30 cycles was performed using a combination ofthree phage-sensitive S. bovis strains,four phage-resistant strains, and five phages. After 10 rounds, plate reader assays and spot tests indicated one resistant strain was being inhibited, and by 30 rounds all four resistant strains were clearly being lysed by the pooled phage cocktail. However, further investigation of several phage isolates was impaired by their apparent instability as their activity was lost over very short periods of time (days), despite numerous attempts. We are currently developing new protocols to address such instability issues during adaptation. Objective 3: Assess and improve phage thermal stability. The thermal stability of allS. boviscomplex and F. variumphages was evaluated at 65C at various time intervals up to 60 minutes. Four out of six F. variumphages presented a titer loss of only 2-log after60 mins at 65C. One phage dropped by 5-log after 60 minutes and only one phagedroppedbelow the limit of detection after 30 mins at 65C. Considering theirhigh innate thermal stability, thermal adaptation ofF. variumphages was not pursued. In contrast, thermal adaptation of two S. boviscomplex phages was attempted since they were found to be very temperature sensitive. A 5-log decrease in titer was observed after only 5 mins at 65C with titers droppingto undetectable levels after 10 mins. We used two methods to try to increase thermal stability: In theSPP-55method, phages were exposed to 50 mM sodium pyrophosphate (SPP) at 55C for 30 mins, and subsequentlyamplified in their corresponding host. This method had previously been successful in our laboratory to increase phage thermal stability. However, after 6 rounds, there was no detectable improvement in stability at 65C for either phage. In the EMS-55method, phages were exposed to the mutagen EMS prior to amplification. Subsequent exposure to 55C for 30 minutes and amplification of survivors was performed to selectfor mutants with increased thermal stability. However, similarly, after 9 rounds, neither phageshowed increased thermal stability at 65C. Currently we are exploring new methods for thermal adaptation, including encapsulation, which has been found to be very effective for certain phages. Objective 4: Scale up and optimize production ofStreptococcusandFusobacteriumphages. To date, we have achieved production yields of 1010 PFU/mL for all phages tested up to the 1 L scale. Additional efforts to scale to 10 L will be performed with fully adapted phages. No challenges are foreseen. Objective 5: Assess safety and efficacy of phage cocktails. A small-scale animal study was performed using ten cannulated calves at a USDA facility. One calf was removed from the study prior to phage treatment due to illness. Three calves were provided PBS only as a control. The other six were split into low dose (108phages) and high dose (1010 phages) treatment groups. TwoF. varium phage cocktails containing two lytic phages eachwere provided twice daily (rotated).The ruminal contents were sampled prior to study initiation and then at various intervals over two weeks using an adaptive sampling regimen. Data from this study is still being analyzed, though no safety issues were observed or identified during necroscopy.
Publications
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2023
Citation:
Schwarz, C., Mathieu, J., Gomez, J. L., Miller, M. R., Tikhonova, M., Nagaraja, T. G., & Alvarez, P. J. (2023). Unexpected finding of Fusobacterium varium as the dominant Fusobacterium species in cattle rumen: potential implications for liver abscess etiology and interventions. Journal of Animal Science, 101, skad130.
|