Source: GREENTECHNOLOGIES, L.L.C. submitted to NRP
NEW REACTIVE MINERAL LAYER COATING TECHNOLOGY FOR THE PRODUCTION OF BIOBASED ENHANCED EFFICIENCY FERTILIZERS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1028738
Grant No.
2022-33610-37531
Cumulative Award Amt.
$649,875.00
Proposal No.
2022-04362
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2022
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2024
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[8.4]- Air, Water and Soils
Recipient Organization
GREENTECHNOLOGIES, L.L.C.
3926 NW 34TH DR
GAINESVILLE,FL 326051475
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Biobased fertilizers are an under-utilized plant nutrient resource. Recycled biobased fertilizers help conserve natural resources through protecting water quality, improving soil health, and promoting superior nutrient management practices. However, they remain underutilized in practice due to low nutrient content, nutrient imbalance, safety concerns related to storage, and physical characteristics that limit compatibility with established application methods.GreenTechnolgoies (hereinafter "GT") has identified a new, untapped market opportunity leveraging its patented coating technology paired with underutilized biosolids to address current limitations associated with the use of recycled biobased fertilizers. This coating can be applied to biosolids, animal waste, organic granular fertilizers, and even some inorganic granular fertilizers to create a sustainable and affordable line of enhanced-efficiency fertilizers.During Phase I, GT demonstrated the feasibility of a patented new technology for applying a mineral coating onto biosolids pellets to address these inherent barriers. Coated biosolids with higher nitrogen content, better nutrient balance and variable composition were produced and characterized. Furthermore, GT demonstrated that the coating prevents heating and smoldering when the coated product is stored in bulk.This Phase builds on the success achieved during Phase I. Phase II R&D and commercialization activities will result in a unique line of enhanced efficiency fertilizer products. The technology has potential to greatly expand use of biosolids and manure-based fertilizers by fulfilling agricultural producers' needs in a cost-effective and environmentally sound manner.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
0%
Applied
50%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
10252102000100%
Knowledge Area
102 - Soil, Plant, Water, Nutrient Relationships;

Subject Of Investigation
5210 - Fertilizers;

Field Of Science
2000 - Chemistry;
Goals / Objectives
Having demonstrated the feasibility of the technology in Phase I, GT will continue its research on, and development of, the coating method to manufacture enhanced efficiency biosolids and manure-based fertilizer products for commercialization in agriculture-related markets. Phase II Technical Objectives are identified specifically to overcome key technical challenges that must be addressed to move the product to commercialization. Objectives include, 1. Develop commercial pilot manufacturing. Phase II will carry out the research needed to adapt the batch processes demonstrated in Phase I to a Pilot scale continuous production process of five targeted coated biosolids fertilizer products. 2. Demonstrate safety and quantify the physical characteristics of the new fertilizer compositions. Phase II will quantify and document self-heating characteristics of the coated fertilizer products and compare results to uncoated bio-based organic fertilizers. Phase II will also measure and document the physical characteristics of the coated fertilizers, including hardness, bulk density, and product uniformity. 3. Conduct field studies of the new coated organic fertilizers. Field studies will target entry markets of turfgrass and citrus to demonstrate the efficacy of the new product line. 4. Adapt the patented coating process to other biobased sources, in particular, manure-based fertilizers.
Project Methods
Develop Commercial Pilot Manufacturing. The targeted Phase II coated biosolid products are GreenEdge® RLC products, 8-3-0, 8-3-1, 10-3-0, 10-2-1, and 12-2-0.For Phase II,GT will develop a continuous process described below, targeting pilot scale capacities of 4000 to 7000 kgs per day.GT has arranged to lease a coating drum equipped with a sprayer boom from FEECO International. GreenTechnologies will evaluate whether a drum dryer or fluid bed hot air dryer provides better product outcome. Packaging, storage and transport for the Phase II pilot manufacturing will be integrated with GT's ongoing operations. Optimization of many parameters is required to adapt the batch coating process to a continuous coating process, among them interplay of drum rotation rates, precursor addition rates, nozzle spray rates and spray pressures, angle of application relative to the drum angle, and residence time in coater. These process parameters will need to be determined for each of the target formulations and for different size ranges of the organic fertilizer precursor.Chemical composition and physical attributes will be monitored and used to feedback into process development. Chemical and physical characterization will also be used to monitor uniformity and quality control during pilot manufacturing. For chemical analysis, GT will use licensed commercial labs.For methods development, higher resolution microscopic inspection will be performed to more closely monitor the consistency of the coating process. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) will be used to determine a coating's thickness and uniformity. Electron microscopy also allows detailed chemical mapping of the coating using energy dispersive X-ray emission spectroscopy (EDX).SafetyStudiesPhase II will include a study of different storage practices in two different parts of the country to further demonstrate the effect of the GreenEdge® RLC coating in preventing self-heating. The study will compare at least two different thicknesses of the calcium sulfate based coating. Coated fertilizer will be stored at GT's facility in one-ton bulk bags (52"x35"x35") and monitored for periods of six months during the Florida winter and Florida summer. The temperature of the bulk bags at a 12" and 40" depth over this six-month time period will be measured, while simultaneously recording ambient conditions and making observations on evidence of smoldering and level of characteristic odors. A parallel control study will be conducted using GreenTechnologies' uncoated biosolid product, GreenEdge 6-3-0. In addition, a second "open air" storage test will be monitored by Synagro personnel at Synagro's facility in Pennsylvania. For the open-air study, at least two temperature probes will be monitored at different depths in the outdoor pile. Weather/climate data will also be monitored, including daily high temperatures, relative humidity, wind speed and rainfall. Once again, controls with uncoated biosolids pellets will be performed in parallel. The results will be compared to the Phase I study to reveal any variations in high-volume storage.Fertilizer physical characteristics Among the fertilizer specifications to be measured are hardness, bulk density, typical sizing and size variation.Studies will be conducted to measure the crushing force of the different coated formulations, using a particle crush test press. In addition, the PI will measure fertilizer density (lbs/ft3 or kg/m3) for each of the compositions produced during pilot production. Particle size variations will also be measured utilizing the size guide number (SGN) with uniformity index (UI = (d95/d10) x 100) for each product.Turfgrass Field Study:ResearchersNorth Carolina State University willconduct a turfgrass field study to testGreenEdge RLC products, 8-3-0, 8-3-1, 10-3-0, 10-2-1, and 12-2-0. Tests will be conducted on two turfgrass varieties, tall fescue, a cool season grass, and bermudagrass, a warm season grass. Fertilizer products will be applied at two rates, 0.5 lb N per 1000 sq.ft and 1.0 lb N per 1000 sq.ft, with a frequency of three to four applications per year. Studies will be replicated three times, so each product will be tested in six plots for a total of 24 turfgrass plots. The plots will be monitored bi-weekly for 24 months by Dr. Grady Miller. Controls will include the uncoated biosolids based product, GreenEdge 6-3-0 and a standard soluble (not enhanced efficiency) N-P-K fertilizer.Standard Visual Quality Rating and NDVI (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index) will be recorded to evaluate the turfgrass response to the coated fertilizer treatments and nutrient analysis will be performed on harvested tissue. Additionally, the nutrient content (N-P-K and selected micronutrients) of the turfgrass tissue will be measured. Dr. Miller will provide quarterly reports to GT on the progress of the study as well as a final report.Turfgrass field studies:Early AdoptersGT will partner with Haile Plantation Golf and Country Club and Quail Creek Country Club to test new products. GT will work with course managers to layout field plots of three to five the targeted GreenEdge® RLC formulations. Typically, three 4 ft x 6 ft field plots will be established for each product and monitored over a twelve-month period. Standard Visual Quality Ratings will be recorded bi-weekly for each field plot.Story Groves Services, Inc.has agreed to collaborate and monitor the response of GreenEdge® RLC 10-3-1 on their citrus trees. In conjunction with Story Groves, GT will evaluate the trees treated with GreenEdge® RLC formulations toinclude visual inspection by GT representatives along with qualitative assessments provided by Story Groves. Growth rates will be monitored for young trees. Observations of yield will be recorded on mature trees. Importantly, observations will be made related to citrus greening in comparison to other treatments.Adapt Coating to other biobased sources.An additional technical objective of Phase II is to adapt the coating technology to different sources of organic fertilizers, beginning with dried swine sludge.GT will target three size regimes, SGN 90, SGN 200, and SGN 280-300. Initial studies will utilize the experimental system fabricated in Phase I, which employs a hydraulic sprayer coupled to Rotary Blender equipped with sparging nozzles. Typically, the blender will be charged with the dried sludge pellets and solid precursors of the coating while other precursors are applied with the sparging equipment. This research coating system operates in a batch processing mode with up to 1000 kg capacity. This scale is adequate for methods development and for studies to analyze the coatings.The three coating processes adopted for biosolids products will be explored, all based on our calcium sulfate coating matrix. All three of the proposed coating processes use ammonium sulfate and calcium nitrate as precursors to produce calcium sulfate and ammonium nitrate.The precursor ammonium sulfate is obtained as a solid and blended with the biosolid.The water-soluble calcium nitrate is spray-applied, wetting the biosolid. The gradually dissolving ammonium sulfate induces the cross reaction leading to the lower solubility calcium sulfate, which coats the pellets driving the process. Modifications involve the addition of K2Mg2(SO4)3 as a potassium sourceand incorporation of micronutrients.Target compositions will better balance nitrogen and phosphorous levels. Proposed initial NPK targets will be 10-10-0 and 10-10-2.The composition of coated products will be monitored by chemical analysis. Product uniformity and the characteristics of the coated products will include both the bulk chemical analyses and the microscopic comparisons, including electron microscopy and microscopic elemental analysis.

Progress 09/01/22 to 08/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Our target audience is our current customer base. These include golf courses, lawn and landscape, agricultural producers, fertilizer companies, and distributors. Long-time customers are familiar with GreenEdge fertilizers and have strongrelationships with representatives in the company. These relationships allowed us to test out product success and hear real customer feedback from those who have used other GreenEdge products in the past. So far, there has been no negative feedback regarding the new coating. Customers reported no significant change in product efficacy, which was to be expected as the RLC technology allows us to offer more cost effective variations of similar formulations without changing endresults. Changes/Problems:Initial testing was completed to test the self-heating characteristics of the coated products in Phase I. In Phase II, we proposed to expand this testing in partnership with a major biosolids processor in Philadelphia. In Year 1, this study was postponed due to supply issues in Jacksonville. In Year 2, the proposed study was discontinued by the biosolids processor due to the excessive cost of hauling the materials which was not supported in the budget. The biosolids processor also communicated satisfaction with the results from Phase I testing and decided a larger Phase II study was not necessary to prove the efficacy of the coating on reducing self-heating. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Under the guidance of the project PI, Dr. Varshovi, the production crew members were actively involved in modifying the existing equipment to incorporate the mineral layer coating into the current production process. This hands-on experience not only enhanced their technical skills but also their understanding of innovative production techniques. Employees received comprehensive training on best practices for operating and maintaining the modified equipment, ensuring optimal performance and safety. This training included identifying and addressing common issues that may arise during the production process, thereby increasing their problem-solving capabilities and technical proficiency. Moreover, employees were educated on the chemical reactions between the reactive mineral layer coating and the fertilizer base. This knowledge is crucial for understanding the underlying principles of the new production method and ensuring the quality and effectiveness of the final product. Overall, the project has significantly contributed to the professional growth of the production crew, equipping them with advanced skills and knowledge relevant to the fertilizer industry. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?After receiving confirmation of our award, GreenTechnologies ran a press release across all major news platforms. This press release was targeted towards the fertilizer industry and agricultural producers. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. Develop commercial pilot manufacturing. GreenTechnologies has successfully achieved commercial pilot scale manufacturing with an accumulated $424,000 in pilot product sales and over 15,000 bagssold over the two year grant period. Our initial goals were to target five different formulations, however, we found the most demand for the GreenEdge 7-7-7 RLC and GreenEdge 8-2-1 RLC products. Resources were diverted to producing these two product lines while the other three were available upon request. 2. Demonstrate safety and quantify the physical characteristics of the new fertilizer compositions.Initial testing was completed to test the self-heating characteristics of the coated products in Phase I. In Phase II, we proposed to expand this testing in partnership with a major biosolids processor in Philadelphia. In Year 1, this study was postponed due to supply issues in Jacksonville. In Year 2, the proposed study was discontinued by the biosolids processor due to the excessive cost of hauling the materials which was not supported in the budget. The biosolids processor also communicated satisfaction with the results from Phase I testing and decided a larger Phase II study was not necessary to prove the efficacy of the coating on reducing self-heating. The parallel safety study that was completed on-site at the GreenTechnologies facility included a one ton bag of coated product compared to a one ton bag of uncoated product. A thermometer was periodically inserted to take the temperature of the two bulk product to ensure a safe temperature throughout the testing period. In addition to the self-heating control properties, other physical properties were analyzed including hardness, bulk density, typical sizing, and size variation. Throughout the pilot production, different size variations were analyzed and separatedby screening materials into two categories,SGN 90 and SGN 190, which are sold and marketed as two separate product lines.Our studyalso showed that the bulk density of thebiosolids increased from 38 cubic feet per lbto 45 cubic feet per lb when the coating was applied confirming our initial hypothesis that the reactive mineral layer coating would increase bulk density of the product. Overall, all testing of the physical properties of the pilot products were in-line with our initial analyses and expectations. 3. Conduct field studies of the new coated organic fertilizers.Newly developed RLC products were sent to Dr. Grady Miller at North Carolina State University for field testing as stated in the project narrative. At the end of each study, we received two reports, one for each year. The results of the field studies were consistent year-over-year and proved the effectiveness of the slow-release technology on the trial turfgrass. 4. Adapt the patented coating process to other biobased sources, in particular, manure-based fertilizers.Limited testing of the reactive mineral layer coatinghas been done on samples of swine manure received from North Carolina. Preliminary results show the coating can be successfully applied with similar results to the organic biosolids base.GreenTechnologies will further this research through a new USDA Phase I SBIR grant recieved and started in 2024 which focuses on using animal waste digestate from anaerobic digestion operations to produce biobased, enhanced efficiency fertilizers. The coating will be used as a part of this R&D todevelopand test new products usingthisorganic base.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/22 to 08/31/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Our target audience is our customer base. These include golf courses, lawn and landscape, agricultural producers, fertilizer companies, and distributors. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?After receiving confirmation of our award, GreenTechnologies ran a press release across all major news platforms. This press release was targeted towards the fertilizer industry and agricultural producers. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Our goals were to create a pilot scale manufacturing project for the commercialization of the new GreenEdge Reactive Layer Coating. We believe we have accomplished these goals thus far and will continue to work towards further commercialization of the technology. Goal 1Pilot Scale Manufacturing - During the project period so far, we have produced two of the five target fertilizer formulations. For product #1, we have produced and sold 42 tons. For product #2, we have produced and sold 25tons. These are small batch orders that have proven the effectiveness of the technology. By the end ofthe second year of the project, we intend to produce and sell all five formulations in pilot scale quantities. Goal 2Safety and Physical Characteristics - We have conducted limited material analysis so far with our materials science consultant. Our results have been successful in showing the patented coating reduces the self-heating properties of the biosolids materials as outlined in the application. We have even conducted limited studies with a large biosolids management company.However, the finalized results will not be concluded until the end of the project period. Goal 3Field Studies - We completed our first round of field studies with NC State. The results were positive and showed the effectiveness of our new GreenEdge RLC products on plant growth and health. A second round of studies will be conducted in Year 2 as well to confirm the results. Goal 4Adapt to Manure Sources - We have conducted small-batch lab testing using the RLC technology on manure samples. However, since the priority of this year was in creating biosolids based formulations, we have not dedicated as much time and resources to this goal in the first year. It will be a higher priority in Year 2.

    Publications