Source: RUTGERS, THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY (NEWARK) submitted to NRP
MONITORING METHODS AND FARMING PRACTICES TO MITIGATE SOIL GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION GEARED FOR SMALL SCALE FARM OPERATIONS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1028431
Grant No.
2022-67012-37270
Cumulative Award Amt.
$224,950.00
Proposal No.
2021-08350
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Mar 15, 2022
Project End Date
Mar 14, 2025
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[A1601]- Agriculture Economics and Rural Communities: Small and Medium-Sized Farms
Recipient Organization
RUTGERS, THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY (NEWARK)
123 WASHINGTON ST STE 510
NEWARK,NJ 071023026
Performing Department
Earth & Environmental Science
Non Technical Summary
Changing climate resulting in localized extreme weather is currently harming crop production in the U.S and is predicted to cause some reduction of crop yield (up to 60 %) for most of the U.S. by the years 2070-2100. Soil cultivation is a key contributor to the total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in the U.S (6%). Currently, there are limited means to mitigate soil GHG emissions that are geared to the needs of smaller farm operations (68% of overall farms), where currently available GHG monitors are not cost-effective for small-scale farming.A novel approach will aim to bridge this knowledge gap in GHG management by introducing a combined approach of:a. direct GHG measurement that is cost-effective using open-source soil-GHG readerb. rapid and cost-effective indirect estimate of soil GHG release potential with simulated thermal model (STM) analysisc. comprehensive farmers outreach program that is geared to the needs of small farms operations covering best management recommendation and cost-effective GHG monitoring approaches, with a robust online self-training and peers support component.In order to develop these means to mitigate soil GHG emission, the postdoctoral fellow will train in conducting related research and extension outreach, as well as create the seed of future research needed for reducing GHG emission from small farm operations. Research activities for this two-year postdoctoral fellowship project will include:a. model soil GHG emission trialb. Field soil emission trial.c. evaluating the use of STM analysis to predict GHG emission of soils and to identify low emission fertilizersd. development of an open-source soil GHG-reader geared to the needs of small farm operations.These will be used to determine the GHG emission impact of different soil cultivation practices such as tillage, cover crop, nutrition management, and soil inoculation. Finding from the analytical analysis of soil GHG emission will be compared to observations derived from two novel approaches: STM analysis and soil-GHG reader to determine their performance as a tool to estimate GHG emission.Outreach activities following the research component of the fellowship will develop and conduct a small farm training program on how to apply best management practices to reduce soil GHG emission and how to evaluate farm soil GHG emission using the soil-GHG reader and STM approaches. Amentorship program integrated into this proposal will support the postdoctoral fellow professional development through research advisory in the field of GHG research, soil fertility, and conducting agricultural outreach programs.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
0%
Applied
100%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1025210200025%
1320110302025%
1020199107050%
Goals / Objectives
I. Project goalScopeThe fellow's goal is to become an agriculture extension and soil health researcher dedicated to providing research and training services to small-scale farm operations in the northeast Atlantic region on mitigating the harmful impacts of climate change.This project's research goal is to support mitigation of greenhouse gases emission (GHG) from agricultural soils cultivated by small and medium farms by developing a synergic approach utilizing:direct GHG measurement that is cost-effective, using the designed open-source soil-GHG reader.rapid indirect estimate of soil GHG release potential with simulated thermal model (STM) analysis.comprehensive training program geared to the needs of small farm operations covering best management practices (BMP) recommendation and open-source GHG monitoring.II. Project Objectives (O1-3):Compare the effect of soil nutrient management and cultivation practices on GHG emissions.Evaluate the use of open-source GHG reader and STM approaches to improve the cost-effectiveness of GHG monitoring.Disseminate findings for best management practice recommendations for reducing GHG emissions from soil farmingto achieve these career and research objectives, the fellow's two-year program will:a. build work relations with stakeholders. a.1. Scheduled farm visits to collect qualitative data by surveying 60 farmers and ten service providers.a.2. Attend two regional/national soil science meetings annually.a.3. Write two technical papers yearly geared to the non-scientific community.a.4. Develop an online platform dedicated to soil greenhouse gas mitigation.b. Executing independent research. b.1. Design and conduct the proposed fellowship research planb.2. Submit research grants to appropriate programs that secure continuous funding, building on fellowship research and outreach work.c. Gain research skills in soil greenhouse gas (GHG) research. Execute mentorship and project plans addressing the research tasks addressing the research objectives (O1-3)Task 1 Measure total GHG flux released from model soil under standard cultivation practices in controlled pot and field site crop trials. Task 2 Soil thermal stability measures GHG release rate from the ground under different cultivation practices as a function of soil moisture, temperature, and aeration conditions using simulated soil thermal analysis model reactor.Task 3 Validate the use of open-source soil-GHG reader methodTask 4 Develop a farmer training program for implementing BMP and monitoring methods for reducing soil GHG emissions.d. Teaching skills. The fellow will develop training materials and conduct outreach training programs for farmers.
Project Methods
Analytical methods (Tasks 1-3): a. STA- PTA-EGA will be used to determine the potential of GHG emission in soil samples and the kinetics of thermal GHG release from soils. The instrument (STA 449 F3 Jupiter; Netzsch) components are a simulated thermal analysis (STA), pulse thermal analysis (PTA), and evolved gas analysis (EGA). This system is equipped with a furnace atmosphere control to model inert (N2g), pure air, or mixed gas environment over a soil sampled place inside the STA. Inside the STA, thermogravimetric (T.G.) mass change and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) are recorded. A pulse thermal analysis (PTA) attachment is used to measure NH3, CH3, and CO2 release from the soil with I.R. absorption calibration.b. Gas Chromatography Analysis of soil CH4 and total VOC content in gas samples will be done with a gas chromatographer (G.C.; Agilent, 6890)c. Chemiluminescence CO, CO2, NO, N2O39 readers (Thermo Fisher 49i, 48i, 42i, 410i)d.Soil characterization Standard soil lab methods, X-ray diffraction (XRD), Inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES), Scanning electron microscopy coupled with energy Dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM/EDX).Task 1.a: Pot trial model to evaluate the impact of soil nutrients, till, and inoculation on GHG emission A model soil experiment will compare GHG emission flux rates for isolated components of soil management treatments: till (T.L.), no-till (NTL); nutrition management; conventional (CONV), organic (ORG), livestock manure (MNR), plants compost (CMP); inoculation (INC) / no inoculation (NO-INC). For each soil treatment, a crop rotation cycle of corn, soybean, rye, and fallow will be applied over a 12-month period. For crop nutrition, an equivalent nutrient amount for N-P-K, liming, and micronutrients will meet growing recommendations for corn, rye, and soy using readily available fertilizers. A complete blank (No nutrients; No inoculations), as well as a baseline GHG estimator (Free air samples), will be used as the experimental control. In addition to insight on the effect of farming practices on Soil GHG emission, results will also provide method validation to the soil-GHG reader (Task 3).One day prior to the pot GHG sampling, a soil GHG flux static chamber(PVC frame with 6-mil nylon film) will be placed over the pots and sealed with band clamps. Overhead air samples (60 mL) will be then taken through a designated seal membrane with a collection syringe, stored in vials, and transferred for GHG analysis (G.C., Chemiluminescence). Following this, a 10 mL (~25 g) undisturbed soil sample will be taken from each pot with a portable 10 mm core-sampler for STM thermal analysis using STA-PTA-EGA and standard soil composition analysis (Task 2).Task 1.b: Field trial at Rodale FST The 6.1 ha farming system trial (FST) at Rodale Institute is the longest-running side-by-side comparison of organic and conventional agricultural systems in North America (1981-current). This trial includes a Conventional (CONV) chemical-based system, an Organic Legume (LGM), a low-input system that relies on leguminous green manures for fertility, and an organic Manure (MNR) system that includes forage crops and composted dairy manure as sources of fertility. Each design is split between tilled and no-till treatments. All treatment placements are randomized in blocks. Soil GHG sampling to compare these treatments will be collected from the four sub-plots in each of the six treatments that apply soy/ corn/ rye rotation at the time (n sub-plots = 4, N plots = 24). Sampling of soil GHG will take place monthly over 12 months in a similar manner to task 1.a, using 24 units of 5-gallon static chamber collectors placed at the field site. Three pilot soil-GHG readers will be placed at the site for field-scale evaluation as outlined in task 3.Task 2: Soil simulated thermal model (STM)Soil samples collected from Task 1 will be analyzed with STM using STA-PTA-EGA, comparing the overall potential GHG emission from substrates in the soil to the actual GHG emission measurements from soil-GHG reader and gas analyses. Soil STM analysis will determine the concentration of GHG substrates; overall thermal stability of volatile components (TG+DSC); emission energy (J g-1) of GHG substrates. The STM analysis will use STA sample holders (Netzsch) designated for soil samples.Task 3: an open-source approach for soil GHG readingSoil GHG reader will use Raspberry Pi microcontroller (raspberry Pi 3 B+) with MyCodo software. Soil-GHG readers will be evaluated by acquiring a short-term reading at pot trial (Task 1.a) and continuous reading at FST field site for a 30-d sampling period during July, October 2022, and March 2023 (Task 1.b). These will be compared to analytical GHG analyses for quality assurance. For continuous field placement, the microcontroller will start an air pump to fill the sample chamber and activate sensors once daily. Protocol for GHG measurements will be established and validated. The optimized soil GHG reading sequence will include sensors warm-up time (2-10 min), sequences of NDIR readings (CO2 CH4 total VOC and relative humidity), and chamber flushing. The concentration of GHG can be derived from: [reading (ppm)] x [pressure in the chamber (mbar)] x [atmospheric pressure (mbar)] -1. The microcontroller also records soil temperature, soil moisture, and ambient air temperature (Atlas scientific). A battery pack is used for powering the reader.?Task 4: farmer training programs 1. Open source GHG reader A farmer-oriented training program based on the principles of adult learning for farmers will disseminate the use of the soil-GHG reader method. Based on a previously executed training program developed by the fellow (Farm-IT), such open-source automation can be taught with a 6-12 h training program2. Best management practice (BMP) for GHG reduction Training will involve farm tours at study sites and/ or at selected field sites of participants in the soil GHG management program. Outcomes will include technical papers, videos, peer networks.

Progress 03/15/22 to 03/14/25

Outputs
Target Audience:Target audiences: This study was carried out in collaboration with cattle pasture farms, organic farms and small farmsin NJ,The target audience is small to medium farms that are interested in adopting farming systems with lower greenhouse gas emission and require better monitoring tools for offsetting increasing operation costs with added value from labeling their product as a environmentally friendly through local trading gtoups or gaining caron credits income. The research was conducted with the Rodale Institute in Kutztown, Pennsylvania, two farms in NJ, and the NOFA-NJ Foundation. The research product developed: soil carbon monitoring, is now being adopted to a large-scale pilot trial for monitoring poultry farmsoil in Delaware, and five farm sites in NJ that raise pasture cattle. The technology and training materials are being evaluated with extension and farmers in the Northeast Atlantic region, for follow-up studies in pilot scale and commercializing the open source soil carbon monitoring technology Efforts Finding and technology were discussed with research peers attending panels at the American Society of Agronomy annual meeting, where this study was presented. A workshop pilot meeting was presented at the NOFA NJ annual meeting in NJ. A training program for small farm is currently underway using the materials developed. Changes/Problems:The project encounteredseveral technical difficulties, primarily related to the simulated thermal analyses (STM) method. The primary instrument intended for this part of the study, the Simulated Thermal Analyser with Evolved Gas Analyser that uses Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR), was offline at Rutgers Universityand unavailable. Two alternative instruments at the University of Pennsylvania and Northwestern were also evaluated for the use of different evolved gas detectors (Licor CO2and CG-FTIR, respectively). The results from these two alternative methods demonstrated potential; however, insufficient instrument time availability resulted in insufficient data to conclude this proposed aspect of the project. The preliminary data were compiled into an instrument research grant that intends to allocate the resources needed to complete this experiment. Such efforts include several ong term soil pasture experiments with samples collected over 5-42 years. Additional obstacle to the project encountered was the underperformance of the greenhouse gases GC analyser that did not provide accurate and reproducible reading of soil gas samples. In order to improve the quality of field measurement, the research team received $140,000 in USDA funding to perform additional field measurements using LiCOR CO2/CH4and N2O gas analyser. This instrument is currently being utilized on the climate smart grant, a follow-upexpansion of this project. The project was terminated following the shift of the project effort away from the initial hosting lab STM STA-FTIR instrument and the lead mentor's decision to withdraw from it at the end of the two-year period. The research plan is being implemented through industry, expansion of research lab collaboration, and foundation collaboration in NJ and Delaware. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This program provided professional training through ongoing mentorship, including work on farm pilot sites alongside researchers and extension specialists. Additional professional development was gained throughinstrument workshops provided by Netsch company, and by attending the national ASA-CSA-CSSA meeting in 2023. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Result have been disseminated through farmers workshop held together with NOFA-NJ and are currently being integrated in five farm operation in NJ through a follow up study together with North Jersey RC&D as part of a subaward for climate smart and commodities grant What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? This project accomplished the goals of developing an open source soil greenhouse gas measurement system and implementing it throughthree follow-up NIFA and other USDA researchprograms with $329,000 of additional current funding and $650,000 of pending funding. The initial proposal called for the evaluation of greenhouse gas sensors based on nondispersive infrared (NDIR) sensor technology that offer smaller equipment size with lower cost. The two sensors evaluated were K30 for carbon dioxide (CO2) and K96 for methane (CH4) manufactured by Sensair company (Stockholm, Sweden). While in theory and lab trial, the K96 performed relatively well, in field conditions the overlap in infrared (IR) wavenumber absorption between CH3and soil water vapor (H2O) masked CH3fluxes. A modification of the soil gas sampling method with a water selective tube desiccationimproved the reading of CO2but did not reach the goal of <1% water content needed for soil CH4flux reading. The model automated soil gas flux reader was tested in field conditions at conventional, organic, till, and no till cropping systems and performed well, providing reliable continuous CO2flux reading at under $500 instrument cost. During the project operation period, working relations were established with NJ farmers, local extension personnel, andlocal companiesthat resulted in 20 acresof follow-up studies,where the new technology is being evaluated for monitoring pasture farming systems for CO2GHG emission. In addition, a new research group composed of Rutgers University faculty is now expanding the capacity of the soil GHG reader into a soil carbon reader with the addition of soil carbonate and soil induced resistivity reading to providecarbon credits verification for farming systems and improve soil fertility. This work is underway with a 1300 acre trial planned for the 2025-2026 year.

Publications


    Progress 03/15/23 to 03/14/24

    Outputs
    Target Audience:1. New Jersey Farmers: Five New Jersey cattle farms agreed to participate in a field pilot trial as part of a Climate Smart grant effort. 2. New Jersey extension personnel and research scientists. 3. Gas Sensors Product developers Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?1. Thermal analysis training: Soil samples were analyzed using simulated thermal analysis (STA) using three evolvedgas analysis (EGA) approaches using CO2reader (LiCOR), gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy (GC/MS),and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. Working with the Material Science Service lab at Northwestern University provided training in using the GS/MS instrument and software (Agilent MSD data analysis) andthe FTIR software package (Brucker OPUS). Additional training was gained by attending STA workshop(Netzch)in Akron, Ohio. 2.GC-MS gas analysis training: Working with the Meadowland Environmental Research Institute laboratory, the fellowship provided soil gas flux sampling and sample analysis training. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Research results were presented at the Soil Science of America annual meeting: Rabinovich, A. (2023, November). Open Source Greenhouse Gas Monitoring and Soil Thermal Analysis Approach to Predict Soil Emission from Small Farm Operations. InASA, CSSA, SSSA International Annual Meeting. ASA-CSSA-SSSA. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Following the mentorship plan research tasks, the following research and outreach activities will be taken to complete the workforce development fellowship. Task 1Measure total GHG flux released from model soil under standard cultivation practices in a controlled pot and field site crop trials. A revised open-source GHG reader will be used to collect emission data from the model soil experiment. Task 2Soil thermal stability measures GHG release rate from the ground under different cultivation practices as a function of soil moisture, temperature, and aeration conditions using a simulated soil thermal analysis model reactor. Continue analysis of soil samples using various STA-EGA methods. Task 3Validate the use of the open-source soil-GHG reader method. Begin a pilot trial with five NJ cattle farms to validate the soil-GHG reader method on a farm scale. Task 4Develop a farmer training program for implementing BMP and monitoring methods for reducing soil GHG emissions. Work with collaborators at the RC&D of Northern NJ and NJ extension services tocompile the current research and training materials into an outreach materials format.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Build work relations with stakeholders. A collaborative effort was established with the Rodale Institute in Pennsylvania and RC&D of Northern NJ to investigate open-source approaches for greenhouse gas monitoring. These will provide training and consulting services to local stakeholders using the methods developed. Execute independent research 1. Open source soil GHG reader: The 3D-printed prototype evaluated a revised soil GHG reader model. This research-oriented model is portable and can carry multiple sensors for field research. 2. Compare the thermal stability of soils from different farming systems: In collaboration with geochemistry research labs at the University of Pennsylvania and Northwestern University, two thermal analysis approaches were evaluated to see the effect of farming systems on soil organic matter thermal stability. Teaching skills: Five undergraduate students participated in the model soil research trial over a five-week period in collaboration with the Rutgers IDEA program for entrepreneurship development. Task 1Measure total GHG flux released from model soil under standard cultivation practices in controlled pot and field site crop trials. Task 2Soil thermal stability measures GHG release rate from the ground under different cultivation practices as a function of soil moisture, temperature, and aeration conditions using simulated soil thermal analysis model reactor. Task 3Validate the use of open-source soil-GHG reader method Task 4Develop a farmer training program for implementing BMP and monitoring methods for reducing soil GHG emissions.

    Publications


      Progress 03/15/22 to 03/14/23

      Outputs
      Target Audience:Target Audiences: NJ agricultural extension, Northeast Organic Farm Association of NJ, Rodale institute,Northeast Regional Committee on Soil Testing, NRCS of Northern NJ, Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Over the next reporting period, the conclusion of research tasks 1-4 is expected. To meet these goals, an action plan for soil greenhouse gas sampling at the Rodale field site was devised with Dr. Reza Afshar, chief scientistat Rodale institute, with sampling to begin in winter 2023. Sampling will include soil, gas sampling and soil gas flux readings. Additional experimental work will take place at Rutgers University research farm with the continuing of the model soil trial.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? Task 1Measure total GHG flux released from model soil under standard cultivation practices in controlled pot and field site crop trials. The sampling protocol was established with collaborating research lab- Meadowlands Research Institute of NJ. Sampling is expected to begin in tandem with the soil GHG reader measurements in winter 2023 Task 2Soil thermal stability measures GHG release rate from the ground under different cultivation practices as a function of soil moisture, temperature, and aeration conditions using a simulated soil thermal analysis model reactor. Analyses of sample collected from the greenhouse model soil and Rodale farming systems trialis expected to begin in the winter of 2023 in collaboration with theAlain F. Plante BioGeochemistry lab at the University of Pennsylvania. The analytical method will use a simulated thermal analysis coupled with LICOR LI-840 infrared evolved gas analyzer to measure CO2emission. Additional analyses will use simulated thermal analyses with Fourier Transform Infra-Red (FTIR) and mass spectroscopy (MS) evolved gas analyzers. Task 3Validate the use of open-source soil-GHG reader method A soil greenhouse gas reader prototype was built in collaboration with the Mary Whelan AtmosphericChemistry lab at Rutgers and Sensair AB company in Stockholm Sweden.the method is currently in experimental trials to determine the performance of a prototype multi-gas NDIR gas analyzer (K96 Sensair). Additional sensors are in line to be evaluated as well, and integrated into the open source gas reader platform. Task 4Develop a farmer training program for implementing BMP and monitoring methods for reducing soil GHG emissions. A training program for GHG monitoring is currently being developed in collaboration with NOFA NJ, NJAES, and advisory panel farmers. An expansion of the training program for cattle farming is funded and under development in collaboration with NRCS of Northern NJ.

      Publications