Source: New York University submitted to NRP
THE DEGRADATION OF PESTICIDES: MOVING TOWARDS MECHANISTIC UNDERSTANDING OF PHOTODEGRADATION FOR PREDICTIVE MODELING
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1027816
Grant No.
2022-67020-37182
Cumulative Award Amt.
$300,000.00
Proposal No.
2021-09137
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 1, 2022
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2025
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[A1411]- Foundational Program: Agricultural Water Science
Recipient Organization
New York University
665 Broadway, Suite 801
New York,NY 10012
Performing Department
CIVIL & URBAN ENG
Non Technical Summary
Pesticides are a unique class of chemicals because their use necessitates their release directly into the environment. As a consequence, there are relatively strict requirements for the evaluation of their movement and degradation in environmental systems. However, some of the testing guidelines used to evaluate these processes have become outdated as our knowledge has improved. One example is the currently used EPA guidelines to test the ability for sunlight-driven reaction to degrade pesticides in aquatic ecosystems. In particular, several potential sunlight-driven degradation pathways have been overlooked that are hypothesized to be important for pesticides. This research will use model systems to evaluate individual degradation pathways to determine (1) their relative importance in the environmental fate of pesticides, (2) the efficacy of results from simplified model systems to predict the degradation observed in complex environmental systems, and (3) how testing guidelines can be updated to obtain more accurate data that can be used to predict sunlight-driven degradation in diverse environments and under changing conditions.
Animal Health Component
10%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
90%
Applied
10%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
13303992000100%
Goals / Objectives
The overall goal of the proposed research is to develop and validate new experimental procedures that reflect current knowledge of how sunlight-driven processes degrade current use pesticides. This will be accomplished by investigating the photodegradation mechanisms thought to be the most important for aquatic photodegradation. Model systems will be used to determine quantum yields of direct photodegradation reactions and bimolecular reaction rates of indirect photodegradation reactions. These values will then be compared to observed photodegradation rates in waters containing complex natural organic matter and other dissolved species. If observed and predicted photodegradation rates match, this indicates that the current understanding of aquatic photodegradation is sufficient to predict environmental degradation based on test results from model systems. These experiments will serve as a basis for re-evaluating the recommended testing guidelines for pesticide registration to achieve more reliable estimates of environmental fate of currently used pesticides.The specific objectives are:Develop a better procedure to quantify and report the molar absorptivity of pesticidesQuantify the quantum yield of direct photodegradation using several different light sources to determine wavelength dependenceCompare two model systems used to determine bimolecular reaction rates constants with singlet oxygenCompare two model systems used to determine bimolecular reaction rates constants with hydroxyl radicalCompare reaction rates using 3 model sensitizers against the reaction rates with two sources of natural organic matter (a standard isolate and an agricultural soil leachate)Compare the predicted values of overall photodegradation (direct + indirect) with observed reaction rates for natural watersInvestigate if the photodegradation rates vary in a predictable manner due to the chemical structure
Project Methods
These research efforts will use laboratory experiments to create data. The analytical methods predominantly used will be UV-vis spectroscopy and liquid chromatography could with a UV-vis and fluorescence detector, which are commonly used for this type of experiment. More novel experimental system will be used to isolate individual reaction pathways. The kinetics data obtained will be evaluated using standard techniques and competition kinetics to determine reaction rate constants. Efforts to disseminate the gained knowledge will be in the form of peer-reviewed publications, an oral scientific presentation, and documented standard operating procedures. The success of these efforts can be evaluated by number of citations/views, audience members, and downloads of the SOPs from a publically available domain, respectively.

Progress 06/01/24 to 05/31/25

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience include environmental engineering researchers and practitioners that focus on the fate and transport of chemical contaminants (such as pesticides) in the environment. Additionally, government agencies (e.g., EPA, USDA) that set regulations regarding the application, testing, and safety of pesticides. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Since submission of the last annual REEport progress report, there have been numerous opportunities for professional development for the graduate student (Luana de Brito Anton) working on the project. Luanaparticipated in the Gordon Research Conference (GRC) focused on Environmental Sciences (Water) in June 2024, and the American Chemical Society's (ACS) Lasting Encounters between Aspiring and Distinguished Scientists (LEADS) Conference in November 2024. She gave oral presentations on her research funded by this grantat the ACS conference in March 2025 andthe New York Water Environmental Association Annual Meeting in February 2025 (USDA was acknowledged during both of those talks). Luana was chosen to participate in NYU's "PhD Live" program in April 2025, where she was chosed through a competative process to present her research to a broad audience at the university. Luana is defending her PhD dissertation at the end of April 2025, will graduate in May 2025, and will begina prestigious postdoctoral researcher position at Stockholm University, starting in Fall 2025. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Since submission of the last annual REEport progress report, results have been disseminated through oral presentations at national (ACS National Conference Spring 2025) and local technical (NYWEA 96th Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition) conferences and other academic and professional events (e.g., university-sponsored research expo). We submitted our second paper describing the results of this work tothe peer-reviewed journal Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period we planto complete data analysis and writing oftwo additional manuscripts, one related to Objective 2 and one related to Objectives 6 and 7. We aim to submit those papers to peer-reviewed journals before the end of the project period (December 2025). Once those papers are submitted, we will have completed all Objectives proposed for the funded grant.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? In previous years we completed Objectives 1 and 2. Since submission of the last annual REEport progress report, we have finished a full set of experiments evaluating indirect photolysis of 28 pesticides in 7 model experimental systems (two model systems used to determine bimolecular reaction rates constants with singlet oxygen, two with hydroxyl radical, and three with triplet state dissolved organic matter), fulfilling Objectives 3, 4, and 5. We have conducted photolysis experiments with pesticides in environmentally relevant solutions (i.e., with two sources of natural organic matter: a standard isolate and an agricultural soil leachate), and have compared predicted values of overall photodegradation (direct + indirect) with observed reaction rates for natural waters, thereby fulfilling goal of Objective 6. We previously published one manuscript describing research conducted as part of this grant (Obj 1), we recently submitted a manucript to Environmental Science: Processes and Impacts describing work related to Objectives 3, 4, and 5; that manuscript is under review. We arein the process of writing two additional manuscripts, one related to Objective 2 and one related to Objectives 6 and 7. We aim to complete and and submit these final two papers before the end of the project period (December 2025).

Publications

  • Type: Other Journal Articles Status: Under Review Year Published: 2025 Citation: de Brito Anton, L., Silverman, A., Apell, J. Comparing Photodegradation Model Systems: Measuring Bimolecular Rate Constants between Singlet Oxygen, Hydroxyl Radical, and Organic Contaminants. Submitted to Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts March 2025)


Progress 06/01/23 to 05/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience include environmental engineering researchers and practitioners that focus on the fate and transport of chemical contaminants (such as pesticides)in the environment. Additionally, government agencies (e.g., EPA, USDA)that set regulations regarding the application, testing,and safety of pesticides. Changes/Problems:Some of the pesticides evaluated had very slow to no photodegradation with exposure to photochemically produced reactive species such as singlet oxygen and triplet excited states. To better evaluate the indirect photodegradation of this subset of compounds, we shifted some of the experimental procedures, including repeating experiments at lower pesticide concentrations to increase sensitivity. These revised experimental procedures do not change the scope of work, and will be used in further experiments to ensure the accuracy of new results. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?ThePhD student supported by this project, Luana de Brito Anton, has presented their work at several significant events, including a university-sponsored research expo, the New York Water Environment Association (NYWEA) 96th Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, the NYWEA 2024 University Night, and the American Chemical Society (ACS) National Conference Spring 2024. An abstract for a poster presentation has also been accepted at the Environmental Sciences Water Gordon Research Conference (GRC), which is occurring in June 2024. Luana was accepted to and participate in the Tandon Faculty First Look program at NYU, which is a two day program that introduces PhD students to the academic job market and faculty careers. Additionally, Luana has been selected to participate in the American Chemical Society's Lasting Encounters between Aspiring and Distinguished Scientists (LEADS) Conference in November 2024. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The current results have been disseminated through oral presentations at national (ACS National Conference Spring 2024) and local technical (NYWEA 96th Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition) conferences and other academic and professional events (e.g., university-sponsored research expo, NYWEA 2024 University Night). Our work on characterizing actinometers to determine precise quantum yields has been published in the peer-reviewed journal Environmental Science: Processes & Impact: de Brito Anton, L., Silverman, A., Apell, J. Determining Wavelength-Dependent Quantum Yields of Photodegradation: Importance of Experimental Setup and Reference Values for Actinometers. Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts 2024. Advance Article. https://doi.org/10.1039/D4EM00084F What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the upcoming year, we will conclude the photolysis experiments with model sensitizers and perform experiments with two sources of natural organic matter (a standard isolate and an agricultural soil leachate). We will compare the observed reaction rate constants with the data predicted from the model systems to validate these model systems, addressing objectives 6 and 7. We are planning to prepare a minimum of two peer-reviewed journal articles describing the research funded by this grant.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? In the past year, we have made progress on objectives 3, 4, and 5. We have completed experiments with two model photosensitizer systems to determine bimolecular reaction rate constants with hydroxyl radicals. The experiments to determine bimolecular reaction rate constants with singlet oxygen are approximately 90% complete, as are the experiments using three model sensitizers to determine bimolecular reaction rate constants with triplet excited states. Additional experiments and literature review are being conducted to understand transformation mechanisms of a small subset of compounds that do not display expected first order decay kinetics.? Additionally, we have completed experiments evaluating the wavelength-dependent quantum yields of the target pesticides. Results from this work, along with recommendations for determining direct photolysis quantum yields and half-lives of pesticides in environmental and engineered systems, is being written now and will be submitted for publication within the next few months.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2024 Citation: de Brito Anton, L., Silverman, A., Apell, J. Determining Wavelength-Dependent Quantum Yields of Photodegradation: Importance of Experimental Setup and Reference Values for Actinometers. Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts 2024. Advance Article. https://doi.org/10.1039/D4EM00084F


Progress 06/01/22 to 05/31/23

Outputs
Target Audience: Given that the model systems developed in this work prove reliable, these protocols will be documented as Standard Operating Procedures and will be made publically available. These SOPs will be disseminated to scientific researchers and USDA and EPA scientists working in pesticide fate and transport,in an effort to update the recommended testing guidelines currently used by companies for the pesticide registration process. Changes/Problems:Becuase the quantum yields of the actinometers that were planned to be used were either not reported at all of the necessary wavelengths or the reported quantum yields could not be replicated, substantial work was undertaken to fully and accurately charatcterize these chemicals. The accurate characterization of these actinometers will be the basis for the determination of quantum yields for all of the selected pesticides. Consequently, this work was crucial for the overall success of the project even though it was not orginally anticpated to be needed. This work will also be very valuable for the photochemistry community. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The graduate student supported by this project has had the opportunity to present at a university-sponsored workshop. An abstract for a poster presentation has also been accepted to a national conference (AEESP 2023) and will be presented in June 2023. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The current results will be dissemenated through a national conference in June 2023 and submitted for publication in June 2023. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the upcoming year, the direct photolysis experiments will be concluded and the remaining objectives to characterize the indirect photodegradation of the selected pesticides (objective 3-5) will be started and largely completed. Objectives 6 and 7 will be worked on at the same time.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? In the past year, we have addressed objectives 1 and 2. The pocedure developed to quantify and report molar absorptivity has proven to be robust. We hafve also characterized more light sources than originally planned. During the first phase of this work - quantifying direct photodegradation rates - we found that the reported quantum yields for reference compounds were inaccurate. These reference compounds, known as actinometers, are used to quantify the incident irradiance in laboratory systems. Without accurate measurements of their quantum yields, all subsequent determinations of direct photolysis quantum yields for pesticides would be inaccurate. A substantial amount of work was conducted to characertize multiple photoreactor setups and 11 light sources. These results will be submitted for publication in the upcoming months and will be the foundation for characterizing the walelength-dependent quantum yields of all of the test pesticides. The determination of wavelength-dependent quantum yields of pesticides is approximately 80% complete.

Publications