Source: GLOBAL NEIGHBOR, INC. submitted to NRP
IMPROVE WEED MANAGEMENT – STOP THE WEEDS WHEN SEEDS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1027558
Grant No.
2021-39539-35921
Cumulative Award Amt.
$650,000.00
Proposal No.
2021-07246
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 15, 2021
Project End Date
Sep 14, 2023
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[8.13]- Plant Production and Protection-Engineering
Recipient Organization
GLOBAL NEIGHBOR, INC.
80 COMPARK RD
DAYTON,OH 454594802
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Global Neighbor (GNI) was awarded a Phase 1 to develop a design that makes weed seeds collected by a combine at harvest non-viable, saving the farmer money and reducing environmental impact. The work plan was to start with the technique developed under a DoD SBIR that made tumble weed seeds non-viable, alter that recipe, and engineer a solution to go on a combine. Our successful completion of Phase 1 showed our solution will make greater than 95% of common weed seeds non-viable.The growing number of herbicide resistant weeds and the shrinking chemical weed control options are alarming farmers, seed companies, herbicide manufacturers and government regulators across the globe. This growing problem has critical implications for agriculture, the environment and USDA's goal to encourage regenerative farming practices.For our Phase 2 proposal, we would construct and field the prototype designed in Phase 1, debug that design and make adjustments, and then design and field the weed seed destroyer (WDSD) product that we start selling at the conclusion of Phase 2. With professional investors poised to make an investment in GNI after being de-risked by the USDA Phase 2 award, we will swiftly introduce the WDSD helping farmers to realize improved profitability and decreasing the threat of new herbicide resistance evolving. GNI's Phase 2 proposal transforms our earlier scientific discovery of making tumble weeds seeds non-viable into a product that we have validated has large commercial potential, with the added environmental benefit of reduced herbicide usage to grow America's row crops.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
30%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
13301992020100%
Knowledge Area
133 - Pollution Prevention and Mitigation;

Subject Of Investigation
0199 - Soil and land, general;

Field Of Science
2020 - Engineering;
Goals / Objectives
The technical objective of this Phase II proposal is to fabricate the fieldable design and progressively test and enhance the field prototype (FP1); starting with fabrication, verification in free-standing operating mode, then verification when mounted to and powered by the combine engine, and finally, verification of the system's impact on field weed pressures.Major technical questions to be answered in Phase II include:How to insure the WDSD system operates in the field without stalling or clogging, and is capable of treating a wide range of crops under varying harvest conditionsWill the WDSD system achieve field efficacy similar to lab efficacy rates?Will the WDSD demonstrate measurable improvement in weed pressures within only a few harvest seasons?How to insure the WDSD allows the combine to operate normallyHow to adapt the WDSD design to a universal design that can be mounted on other combine models, beyond the CR940The basis of this work plan is to answer these questions, and is organized into the following engineering and testing tasks:Task 1: Fabricate field prototype 1 (FP1)Task 2: Test and debug FP1 in free standing modeTask 3: Design mounting interface to New Holland CR940Task 4: Mount FP1 to the CR940Task 5: Test and debug FP1 mounted to CR940Task 6: Design user interface to operate FP1Task 7: Test and optimize FP1Task 8: Test FP1 on CR940 in test field one (TF1)Task 9: Measure weed pressure and efficacy data in TF1Task 10: Create universal design (FP2) and installation kits for John Deere S seriesTask 11: Test FP1 on CR940 in an additional test field (TF2)Task 12: Beta Sites: Measure weed pressure and efficacy data in TF2The Phase II effort will result in a field-tested prototype that answers the technical questions needed for our successful commercial launch. During Phase II, GNI will keep investors updated via our quarterly newsletter, and will raise additional funds to support commercialization. With the technical success and the market interest generated during Phase I and continued technical and commercial success in Phase II; our pathway to commercial sales and success is a high certainty.
Project Methods
Design work and off-combine prototype testing will be conducted at GNI facilities, where our prior SBIR work on DE was conducted. GNI will use its CAD system and other computer equipment, instrumentation, and other electrical test equipment. Field testing and debugging, as well as field efficacy and weed pressure impact assessments will be performed at committed farm trial sites (see referenced letters of support), first in Ohio, followed by Tennessee, Minnesota, and Iowa, and continuing on an ongoing basis beyond product introduction. Our Phase II effort supports 2 farm trial sites with the CR940 in Ohio, whereas additional farm trial sites will be initiated as part of our Phase III commercialization effort.Task 1. Fabricate field prototype (FP1)GNI will fabricate the design from Phase I, assemble and make any adjustments required for consistent operation, to achieve greater than 95% efficacy with hand fed chaff and weed seeds.Task 2. Test and debug FP1 free standingGNI will test FP1 operationally using the hydraulic accessory port from a Bobcat skid steer loader that we have access to, with a hydraulic accessory port similar to that of the CR940. During this activity, the team will (a) measure the power output of the DE sources, (b) the performance of subsystems such as fans and controls, and (c) measure the auger's peak rpm and rpm consistency, when power is supplied from the hydraulic generator.Task 3. Design mounting interface to New Holland CR940For this task, the updated design produced in Task 2 will be used to create a representative foam model.The field spreader on the CR940 combine will be removed, and the foam model will be attached to the combine, and the final mechanical attachment elements will be designed and fabricated for both the generator and the auger.Task 4. Mount FP1 to the CR940The team will mount the entire FP1 system resulting from Tasks 1-3. FP1's auger and electronics will be driven from the combine's hydraulic source that was previously used to drive the field spreader. The combine will be operated and driven around the farm to test that the FP1 design is securely attached and operational.We will mount the WDSD (FP1) to a CR940 owned and operated by Kevin Davidson.Task 5. Test and debug FP1 mounted to CR940 Satisfactory operational performance will be achieved when the WDSD unit runs without stalling, clogging or exhibiting faults, and the combine's normal operating speed is maintained while the WDSD runs.Task 6. Design user interface to operate FP1As described in Task 4, the FP1 will be powered by the combine's hydraulic accessory lines. Enabling the hydraulic power to the FP1 will be accomplished through a standard hydraulic accessory switch mounted within the combine's cabin.Task 7. Test and Optimize FP1With the in cab displays and controls installed, operational performance will again be validated (largely a repeat of Task 5), and controls and display functions will be tested and evaluated.Task 8. Test FP1 on CR940 in test field one (TF1)In Kevin Davidson's conventionally farmed property (using herbicide treatments for weed control), in a field (TF1) with a soybean crop rotation, we will operate the WDSD (FP1). In control and test plots, Mr. Davidson will operate the combine on the control plot without the WDSD system activated, and in the test plot with the WDSD system activated.The test field (TF1) will consist of both a contiguous 25-acre plot, and a contiguous 110-acre plot, as shown in Figure 11. In 15 acres of the 25-acre plot, the farmer will intersperse the test and control plots in approximately 1.25-acre strips based on 3 header widths (approximately 100ft x 500ft), alternating between test and control plots, processing 6 test and 6 control strips in total. The remaining 10 acres of the 25-acre plot will be a contiguous control plot. The 110-acre plot will consist of a 100-acre test plot and a 10-acre control plot, located contiguously.Task 9. Measure weed pressures and efficacy data in TF1In TF1, we will verify the WDSD's (FP1's) operational performance, field efficacy, and impact on weed seed bank and weed density. By showing that there is a reduction in the weed seedbank and germinating weed seeds, and that there is no impact on the combine's operation, we can clearly demonstrate to customers that our WDSD system is viable for fighting herbicide-resistant weeds.For operational performance: The WDSD unit must run without stalling, clogging or exhibiting faults and the combine's normal operating speed must be maintained while using the WDSD.For field efficacy testing: GNI staff will collect chaff out the back of the WDSD system (FP1), with the WDSD's DE system ON in the test field, and with the DE system OFF in the control field. This process is described below:Collect 55 dry gallons of chaff generated from both the control and test plots, from the cleanout on the WDSDRemove the seeds from the treated chaff collected in the test plot, and the non-treated chaff collected in the control field.Measure chaff moisture contentSend both treated and untreated seeds to an independent university (CSU or OSU) for germination studies, as was described in Section E.Germination studies will follow the standard procedures developed in conjunction with CSUFor weed pressure impact measurements: In the 25-acre and 110-acre plots described in Task 8, soil samples will be taken from both test and control plots at consistent times (preliminarily planned for April of 2022 and 2023, and pre and post each harvest) and sent to Oregon State University's seed lab for weed seedbank level analysis. Also, GNI staff will conduct weed density measurements in both the test and control fields at specific times (preliminarily planned for prior to first chemical herbicide application of the year, and pre and post each harvest).Task 10. Create universal design (FP2) and installation kits for John Deere S seriesTo simplify the first steps of the planned Phase II work, the team verified the basic design works in the field using a design tailored to the New Holland CR940, which was readily accessible. The team will then evolve that system into a universal WDSD that uses installation kits to match up with the specific design of various combine models.Task 11. Test FP1 on CR940 in an additional test field (TF2)The FP1 design for the CR940 will be updated based on knowledge gained from operating the FP1 in Tasks 8 and 9, after one harvest. Once the design is updated, in the following harvest season, we will repeat Task 8 on a second field (Test Field 2 - TF2) managed by Kevin Davidson.Task 12. Post-harvest weed pressures and efficacy data In Test Field 2 (TF2), we will verify the WDSD's (FP1's) operational performance, field efficacy, and impact on weed seed bank and weed density. With the updated FP1, in TF2, we repeat the data gathering and analysis described in Task 9. Our goal is to demonstrate a reduction in the weed seedbank and germinating weeds, and that there is no impact on the combine's operation.

Progress 09/15/21 to 06/21/23

Outputs
Target Audience:Our target market (end customers) are the small grain and legume farmers in developed nations who own an estimated 640,000 operating combines worldwide, with 120,000 combines in the US. These farmers experience HR as well as escape weeds. Early adopters of the WDSD will come from organic farmers who experience high weed pressures, and farmers in the Midsouth (TN, KY, LA, AR, MS) and Midwest (OH, IN, IL, KS, MI, IA, MO, MN, WI, NE, ND, SD) with extreme HR weed problems. During the Phase 2 we have actively engaged with CNHi, who are one of the primary OEMs in combine production as well as ag equipment in general. They have expressed an interest in implementing a factory solution for combine offering. Additionally, we are working with anOEM for impact mills, which is the competing technology, to incorporate our DE into their solution in an effort to reduce their O&M expense. We continue to receive interest from the market with many periodicals writing stories. The following is a list of the most recent Ag media articles. January 2023: Real Ag interview, + included in daily newsletterhttps://www.farm-equipment.com/articles/21082-farm-equipments-best-of-the-web-feb-3-2023#1 November 22, 2022 An Ohio Company is Fighting Weeds With UV Light - TechOhio https://weare.techohio.ohio.gov/2022/11/22/an-ohio-company-is-fighting-weeds-with-uv-light/ June 1st, 2022 Is new kit the answer to future weed control? https://www.croptecshow.com/awm22/is-new-kit-the-answer-to-fu-ture-weed-control/ July 27, 2022 Equipment (Not Herbicide) Makers to Best Support No-Till Weed Management (no-tillfarmer.com) https://www.no-tillfarmer.com/articles/11738-equipment-not-herbicide-makers-to-best-support-no-till-weed-management November 2022 Acres U.S.A. magazine (acresusa.com) featured GNI's WSD in their November equipment issue Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?LSU, CSU and soon TAMU are posting results of their own independent research. These universities, as wellUIdaho and Western Australia University are also engaged and looking toward publications. TAMU has a dedicated graduate student, under their own budget, testing the WDSD and capturing data for eventual publication. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Through the work to date, the team has answered to positive results all the major goals of the technical development of phase 2. We had a bit of good fortune in that with the interest generated from the many articles published, we gained access to a test stand that is not available generally and costly to construct. This enabled the team to take measurements in house with more efficiency than taking field measurements. How to insure the WDSD system operates in the field without stalling or clogging, and is capable of treating a wide range of crops under varying harvest conditions The team constructed a test unit, attached to a John Deere S680 combine, and adjusted the design to accommodate the flow in a soybean field in TN. Additionally, we tested the flow on the combine test stand with the data shown in this graph ? Will the WDSD system achieve field efficacy similar to lab efficacy rates? We have confirmed through testing at LSU, CSU and TAMU that we have the efficacy in various chaff for a variety of weed seed types. Final designs will be tested at the combine stand for final fielded efficacy Will the WDSD demonstrate measurable improvement in weed pressures within only a few harvest seasons? Several research universities have reported that with efficacies as low as 75%, significant benefits for weed control are achieved How to insure the WDSD allows the combine to operate normally This is a strong advantage of our product. Since we use less than 20Hp, the operator does not even notice that the machine is engaged. How to adapt the WDSD design to a universal design that can be mounted on other combine models, beyond the CR940 Each weed seed destroyer has common components yet is field configured. This is quite common among other aftermarket products and several dealers have expressed interest in working with us to do field installations.

Publications


    Progress 09/15/21 to 09/14/22

    Outputs
    Target Audience:We have biweekly meetings with Case NewHolland as well as continual contact with a large agri-chemical and seed company. We have engaged with LSU and Cornell Universities as well as continued our relationship with Central State University. The following list is the media contacts that we had where our intended audience is the farm operators themselves: Press: March 24th, 2022: https://www.farmprogress.com/weeds/lsu-agcenter-shines-light-resistant-weeds March 11th, 2022: https://lsuagcenter.com/profiles/jmorgan/articles/page1647022740024 Feb 7th, 2022 https://www.agweb.com/news/crops/soybeans/agriculture-invention-harnesses-led-light-inside-combine-kill-weed-seed Late summer, 2021: https://www.farmshow.com/a_article.php?aid=37381 March 25th, 2021 https://www.farmprogress.com/weeds/weed-seed-destroyer-could-help-address-pigweed-issues?fbclid=IwAR2iuI5TiXnYvoSJlsIxcYQ1BjLES1GBEsZsbL4XfgpJj0qJfADyJCO4t-A Recognitions: June 21st, 2021: Ohio creativity challenge runner-up award, given to Ohio companies with the most innovative, problem-solving ideas: https://weare.techohio.ohio.gov/2021/06/21/the-judges-have-spoken-meet-our-startup-creativity-challenge-runners-up/ April 14th, 2021: Won Top Producer Summit Top Pick award--Selected by farmers as most promising new technology: https://www.agweb.com/news/business/technology/agtech-spotlight-global-neighbor Podcast: Feb 1st, 2022: https://engineeringyourfarm.buzzsprout.com/1444834/9888509-directed-energy-a-new-strategy-for-weed-control Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Mostly through the media, the team has communicated to the target market of farm producers. These include articles, podcasts and applying for and winning design awards: Press: March 24th, 2022: https://www.farmprogress.com/weeds/lsu-agcenter-shines-light-resistant-weeds March 11th, 2022: https://lsuagcenter.com/profiles/jmorgan/articles/page1647022740024 Feb 7th, 2022 https://www.agweb.com/news/crops/soybeans/agriculture-invention-harnesses-led-light-inside-combine-kill-weed-seed Late summer, 2021: https://www.farmshow.com/a_article.php?aid=37381 March 25th, 2021 https://www.farmprogress.com/weeds/weed-seed-destroyer-could-help-address-pigweed-issues?fbclid=IwAR2iuI5TiXnYvoSJlsIxcYQ1BjLES1GBEsZsbL4XfgpJj0qJfADyJCO4t-A Recognitions: June 21st, 2021: Ohio creativity challenge runner-up award, given to Ohio companies with the most innovative, problem-solving ideas: https://weare.techohio.ohio.gov/2021/06/21/the-judges-have-spoken-meet-our-startup-creativity-challenge-runners-up/ April 14th, 2021: Won Top Producer Summit Top Pick award--Selected by farmers as most promising new technology: https://www.agweb.com/news/business/technology/agtech-spotlight-global-neighbor Podcast: Feb 1st, 2022: https://engineeringyourfarm.buzzsprout.com/1444834/9888509-directed-energy-a-new-strategy-for-weed-control What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Task 7: Test and optimize FP1; The team will complete this task on a John Deere S680 combine in TN Task 8: Test FP1 on CR940 in test field one (TF1): The team will shift our focus from the CR940 and instead add an additional JD combines, a S660 Task 9: Measure weed pressure and efficacy data in TF1: The team will use soil sampling as well as aerial drone imagary to measure effectivity Task 10: Create universal design (FP2) and installation kits for John Deere S series Task 11: Test on JD S660/S670 Task 12: Beta Sites: Measure weed pressure and efficacy data in TF2

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Task 1: Fabricate field prototype 1 (FP1): prototype has been fabricated Task 2: Test and debug FP1 in free standing mode: team completed many "free standing" tests Task 3: Design mounting interface to New Holland CR940: This design has been completed. Though the team decided to focs on the John Deere solution as a priority since we have 3 customers all with S Series John Deere combines Task 4: Mount FP1 to the CR940: The team completed the mounting on the John Deere in TN. The weed seed destroyer (WDSD) mounted up properly and held in place under initial field testing conditions. Task 5: Test and debug FP1 mounted to CR940: The team did some debugging of the WDSD on the JD combine. This is not completed yet with initial tests showing some areas to be improved Task 6: Design user interface to operate FP1: this is complete Task 7: Test and optimize FP1: These tasks are scheduled for the second half of the project Task 8: Test FP1 on CR940 in test field one (TF1): This task is scheduled to later 2022 and will be performed on a JD combine

    Publications