Source: KANSAS STATE UNIV submitted to NRP
ADVANCING ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY KNOWLEDGE AND SKILLS OF THE FANH SCIENCES WORK-FORCE IN HOSPITALITY AND RETAIL INDUSTRIES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1027084
Grant No.
2021-70003-35430
Cumulative Award Amt.
$300,000.00
Proposal No.
2021-05419
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2021
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2025
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[ER]- Higher Ed Challenge
Recipient Organization
KANSAS STATE UNIV
(N/A)
MANHATTAN,KS 66506
Performing Department
Hospitality Management
Non Technical Summary
Hospitality and retail industries, which are consumer-facing sectors of the agricultural supply chain, have a profound negative impact on the environment. The amounts of energy and water used and the waste produced in these industries are significant. To address these challenges, hospitality and retail management (HRM) baccalaureate programs must prepare their graduates to advocate sustainable business practices. However, preliminary studies indicate a lack of sustainability emphasis in HRM programs and increase in desire for sustainability education among HRM educators and students. To enhance the quality of sustainability instruction for baccalaureate HRM programs, this project aims to develop and disseminate sustainability education modules. Deliverables are indexed, easy-to-use instructional support materials including 360-degree virtual videos and interactive case studies, which yield differential outcomes to demonstrate the impact of business decisions on environmental sustainability. Specifically, we aim to (a) expand environmental sustainability knowledge of HRM educators; (b) augment HRM educators' capabilities for improving students' exposure to sustainable management of energy, water, and waste; (c) advance faculty preparedness and teaching competency; and (d) indirectly, advance HRM undergraduate students' sustainability knowledge and self-efficacy to implement sustainable practices in hospitality and retail industries. Key outcomes include (a) increased sustainability knowledge of HRM faculty and students; (b) increased frequency and duration of sustainability education in HRM programs; and (c) improved self-reported preparedness of HRM educators. The project will extend beyond the funding period through continuation of the resource website.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
50%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
4030499107033%
6050430107033%
1110210310034%
Goals / Objectives
Goal: To enhancecurrent educators' environmental sustainability knowledge and ability to incorporate such complex and timely issues into hospitality and retail management programs across the U.S. By targeting HRM educators, we plan to reach future HRM professionals and ultimately benefit the hospitality and retail industries.Specific objectives:1. Enhance HRM educators' foundational knowledge on environmental sustainability by creating education modules with a systems perspective on energy, water, and waste management in the consumer-facing operations of HRM businesses;2. Strengthen HRM educators' capabilities for improving students' exposure to and competency for sustainable management of energy, water, and waste by developing educational support materials that can be easily incorporated into multiple functional topics and/or industry segment-related courses.3. Advance faculty preparedness and teaching competency through effective, current, and interactive instructional tools (i.e., 360-degree virtual tours, interactive choice-based simulation activities with differential choice outcomes, and teaching modules) to teach principles of energy, water, and waste management utilizing a systems approach.
Project Methods
Phase I. Development of Sustainability Education Modules and Supporting Materials Identification of Sustainability Education Priorities and Preferences: To identify specific concerns and preferred formats of instructional supporting materials, upon receiving the grant, the project team will conduct a series of HRM educator interviews (n=30) and a national survey of HRM educators. HRM educators in a variety of programs will be recruited through the PD and Co-PDs' professional associations for online interviews and a national survey. Data from the interviews and the survey will be used to refine content and formats of sustainability education materials to be developed. A variety of instructional support material formats will be developed, including 360-degree virtual videos, case studies,interactive simulations with different sustainability outcomes based upon student decisions,and other activities as deemed appropriate from educator interviews. Development of Sustainability Education Modules: Based on specific concerns about sustainability education, identified from interviews and the survey, educational modules will be developed including lesson plans, detailed resources, suggested presentation outlines, suggested assessment questions and answers, and discussion guidelines. Existing general sustainability education topics and hospitality and retail industry-specific concerns will be used as a basis for educational module development. Industry supporters (e.g., hotels, restaurants and industry-specific associations) have been committed to supporting this project, and more supporters will be sought for current and relevant content development upon receiving the grant. Producing 360-Degree Virtual Video Tours: Recording 360-degree virtual videos/tours will allow educators to show students a complete and immersive view of sustainable business practices. Based upon the notion that "seeing is believing", we expect these immersive experiences to be more effective, enabling students to fully see how sustainable practices are being implemented in the "real world". The PD and Co-PDs will work collaboratively recording the videos using this innovative technology. Creating Differential Outcome Simulation/Gaming Activities: To engage students more effectively, simulation activities will be created that provide differential outcomes, based upon inputs from the students. These differential outcomes will show the "what if" based upon their own decisions and choices. This will enhance engagement across the classroom and provide opportunities for students to see how choices and business decisions can affect sustainability in the big picture. Other Education Support Materials: Based on inputs from the HRM educator survey, additional education support materials will be developed. Efforts will be made to include a variety of topics to cover as many functional areas, specific segments within the hospitality and retail industries, and sustainability issues (i.e., energy, water, and waste management) as possible. Once developed, modules and all instructional supporting materials will be reviewed by HRM educators who have agreed to utilize sustainability education materials in their institutions. Sustainability education modules and supporting materials will be indexed with specific sustainability topics, functional topic areas (e.g., strategic management, financial management and cost controls, operations management, facilities management, and marketing), and industry segment (e.g., foodservice, lodging, and retail). Pilot Implementation at KSU and UofSC: Prior to finalizing the sustainability education materials, pilot implementation will be conducted using courses taught by the PD, Co-PDs, and other faculty members at KSU and UofSC. Pre- and post-tests will be developed for both course instructors and students to measure (a) sustainability knowledge, (b) attitudes toward sustainability challenges in hospitality and/or retail industry, and (c) attitudes including self-efficacy toward teaching sustainability (instructors) or implementing sustainable practices in students' future careers (students), before and after using education materials. Additionally, faculty and students will provide suggestions to improve the sustainability education materials and assessment instruments. Results will be used to revise the materials prior to implementing at other institutions.Phase II. Adoption and Evaluation of Sustainability Education Modules and Supporting Materials Development of Sustainability Education Resource Website: Once the sustainability education content is developed, a website developer from KSU will be hired to create the resource website. This website will be housed on the KSU server, and the PD and Co-PDs will maintain editing privileges. PD Kwon is capable of developing and maintaining websites using HTML language, and therefore, she will (a) update the contents as needed after the grant period ends and (b) monitor website activities and provide educators with access to password-protected, "instructor only" sections of the website. Recruitment of HRM Educators and Adoption of Sustainability Education Modules and Supporting Materials: As shown in the support letters, numerous teaching faculty members across the U.S. already support and are committed to adopting the proposed sustainability education materials. All resource materials will be indexed in three ways: Functional topic areas, industry segments, and sustainability education topic areas. These indices will make it easy for HRM faculty members to find and utilize specific materials that suit their classes. PD and Co-PDs will keep track of HRM faculty who adopt the sustainability education materials in their courses and inform them of evaluation procedures. Faculty Orientation and Evaluation of Sustainability Education Modules and Materials: Prior to adopting and evaluating baseline sustainability knowledge and attitudes, the project directors will offer online orientation for HRM educators to properly inform about the resource website and ways to evaluate the effectiveness of the education modules and materials. Formative evaluation will be done throughout the development of modules and materials by reviewing learning objectives, content, and engagement opportunities. For summative evaluation, a pre- and post-survey and short interviews with educators will be conducted before and after using education materials to measure: (a) sustainability knowledge, (b) attitudes toward sustainability challenges in the hospitality and/or retail industry, and (c) attitudes including self-efficacy toward teaching sustainability (instructors) or implementing sustainable practices in students' future careers (students). Online surveys of instructors and students will be created using the Qualtrics survey system to assess their knowledge and attitudes regarding environmental sustainability. Differences in knowledge and attitudes before and after sustainability education will be analyzed using paired sample t-tests and MANCOVA.Phase III. Dissemination and Ensuring Sustainability All sustainability education materials will be stored on a website, and the information for using education modules and supporting materials will be announced to HRM educators through professional networks, presentations, and publications.

Progress 09/01/23 to 08/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:During Fall semester 2023, select educatorsat University of South Carolina and University of Tennessee incorporated some of the educational tools developed (i.e., case studies and 360-degree videos) and feedback from these educators and students in the classes were gathered. During Spring semester 2024, additional feedback was gathered via focus group interviews (12 educators). Participants were asked to review a packet ofeducational resources (i.e., lesson plans, case studies, and 360-degree videos) and subsequently interviewed in two focus groups. They were ased to evaluate the overall and specific usefulness of the developed resources as well as to make specific recommendations for refinement. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Refinement of the educational resources began during summer months 2024 and will continue during the no-cost extention period. After refinement, final versions of the resources will be packaged and disseminated via an easy to access website.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Feedback from HRM educators reviewand use ofthe educational support materials indicated theseresourcesenhancedtheirknowledge about environmental sustainability,acknowledged the valueof the materials as resources to be used in their courses, and appreciation for how the materials will helpdeliver complex informationand prepare their students for changes happening in the hospitality and retail industries.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/22 to 08/31/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target audience during thisreview period was hospitality and retail management (HRM) educators currently teaching sustainability in their courses. In-depth interview methodology was employed to understand their motivations for bringing environmental sustainability into the classroom and the challenges experienced. Gathering and analyzingtheeducators' response revealsimportantstages in a HRM educator's sustainability journey.The primary goal of this project isto enhance HRM educators' environmental sustainability knowledge and assist their ability to bring this content into thecourses they teach. Understanding driversand challenges will guide educational resource development and dissemination plans. Pilot testing of preliminary educational resources was initiatedin September 2023 and is still in progress. Adescription of the audience and efforts to reach them will be reported next review period. Changes/Problems:Development of the educational tools (i.e., 360-degree videos, case studies, and lesson plans) took more time than planned and has put the team behind schedule. We expected to have the pilot testing completed by the end of this review period but were unable to meet that deadline. Upon reflection, we did not factor in the time it tookto convince companies to agree to havetheir business operations and sustainability practices video-recorded for educational purposes. Plus, creating assessment instruments without social desirability bias has also been challenging. Initial instruments developed need to be reworked before the full pilot testing process. Once the educational resources and assessment tools are refined and ready for testing, there will be several months prep time for recruited pilot testers to incorporate the material into their course for thesemester.These delays have impacted the originaltimeline. Project directors are considering a No Cost Extension for one year to give enough time to complete all activities. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Key activities during the next reporting period includeinitialpilot testing ofeducational tools, focus group interviews, refinement of educational resources, pilot testing of educational resources, and begin dissemination of educational resources. Pilot test several of the educational tools developed (i.e., 360-degree videos and cases) and assessment instruments early in the review period. This preliminary round of testing will reveal initial adjustments required before a full pilot testing of all educational resources developed by the team. 8-10 hospitality and retail management (HRM) educators familiar with environmental sustainability will be recruited to participate in focus group interviews. These educators will receive a packet of the educational resources developed to meet project goals, asked to complete a critical review of the materials prior to participating in a focus group interview. The goal of this activity is to collect formative feedback for final revisions of the materials. Project directors will incorporate feedback to revise materials. Several HRM educators will be recruited to participate in a full pilot testing of educational materials. Disseminate outcomes at conferences via presentations and/or workshops. Begin development of website to disseminate the project products.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? While hospitality and retail industries have significant impact on the environment due to water and energy usage and waste generation, there arevariable levels ofsustainability education provided in hospitality and retail management (HRM) programs in the United States. Educator preparation typically does not include sustainability, and this may lead to educator reluctance to incorporate these topics into the classroom.There are limited educational materials and support for educators seeking to include environmental sustainability topics in the classroom.Our preliminary findings revealed increased sustainability education in these programs and this project aims to providesustainabilty education resources easy to incorporate in a range of hospitality and retail management courses. Accomplishments during this review period will be outlined as they relate to project goals. Objective 1: enhancing educators' foundational knowledge on environmental sustainability. Activities next review period will focus on building educators' environmental sustainability. Objective 2: strengthening educators' capabilities for improving students' exposure to and competency for sustainable management of energy, water, and waste. Conducted interviews with educators to assess current barriers andstatus of sustainability education in their programs. These educator participants varied in the level of environmental sustainability topic integration into their courses. Analysis in progress. We are looking for similarities and differences inresponses tohelp guide development of educational resources that are easy to plug into existing courses, alleviating educator prep time that may discourage bring environmental sustainability concepts into the classroom. Lesson plans were developed duringthis review period and will be refined and finalized during the next review period. These plans will assist educators' incorporation of environmental sustainability into their courses. Objective 3: advancing faculty preparedness and teaching competency through effective and interactive instructional tools. Based on educator data collected and extensive review of literature, a series of instructional tools were developed during this review period. Tools included 360-degree virtual company tours that highlight key sustainability initiatives of that business, and case studies of fictionalhospitality and retail companies highlighting various environmental sustainability concerns for students to research and develop recommended solutions. During this period, preliminary development of baseline knowledge assessment survey for educators to gauge their student's current environmental sustainability knowledge. When completed, the instrumentcan also be used as a pre-test and post-test to evaluate the effectiveness of the educational resources employed by the educators. Development and refinement of assessment tools will continue into the next review period. Fall semester 2023 several instructional tools were pilot tested, but most of the testing occured after September 31, 2023, so will be reported next review.

    Publications


      Progress 09/01/21 to 08/31/22

      Outputs
      Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period research team will continue to develop instructional tools and educational resource online database in preparation for pilot testing and evaluation of materials.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? Hospitality and retail industries, which are consumer-facing sectors of the agricultural supply chain, have a profound negative impact on the environment. The amounts of energy and water used and the waste produced in these industries are significant. Recognizing the important role of hospitlity and retail management (HRM) educators must play to preparetheir graduates to advocate for sustainable business practices, this project will assist by developming easy to use educational resources. In thisfirst yearimportant foundational activities were completed to supportfinal project deliverables which will include sustainability education modules withtraining for HRM educators and indexed, easy-to-use instructional support materials including 360-degree virtual videos and interactive case studies withdifferential outcomes to demonstrate the impact of business decisions on environmental sustainability. During the past year HRM educators wereinterviewed HRM to determine priority areas for supportive resources. Interview findings are being used to guide development of educational materials. Objective 1: Enhance HRM educators' foundational knowledge on environmental sustainability by creating education modules with a systems perspective on energy, water, and waste management in the consumer-facing operations of HRM businesses. Major activities completed to meet this objective included qualitative HRM educator interviews to determine priorityenvironmental sustainability knowledge areas for subsequent module development. Additionally, data revealed level of sustainability content in current curriculums, challenges in teaching sustainability in HRM programs and preferredresources needed for assisting inclusion of sustainability education initiativesinto the future. Work supporting thisobjectivewill continue in next review period. Data collected to support this objective was qualitative in nature. Interviews were recorded andverbative transcriptions were createdfor analysis. Summary statistics and discussion of results: four representative HRM university programs were identified and program faculty contacted requesting participation. A total of 17 HRM educators agreed to the interveiw. Results indicated these faculty are concerned about awide varietyof sustainability challenges and are highly interested in receiving resources to support their current sustainabilty education efforts or assist the introduction of these concepts into their courses. Key outcomes or other accomplishments realized:An intriguing finding emerged from the data analysis. Educatorsinterviewed exhibited varying levels of sustainabiity knowledge and commitmment. Those with advanced knowledge and higher commitment shared a personal story revealing the origin or reason for increased knowledge/commitment. The interviewees with less knowledge and commitment were less likely to share their sustainability journey. Reseearch team intends to explore further as there may be important steps necessary to stimulate greater commitment to ensure adoption of final project products. Objective 2: Strengthen HRM educators' capabilities for improving students' exposure to and competency for sustainable management of energy, water, and waste by developing educational support materials that can be easily incorporated into multiple functional topics and/or industry segment-related courses. No activities completed for this objective during this review period. Objective 3: Advance faculty preparedness and teaching competency through effective, current, and interactive instructional tools (i.e., 360-degree virtual tours, interactive choice-based simulation activities with differential choice outcomes, and teaching modules) to teach principles of energy, water, and waste management utilizing a systems approach. Activities under this objective included initial development of instructional tools. Six 360-degree virtual tour videos were recorded and three differential outcome case studies were drafted.

      Publications