Source: TEXAS TECH UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
TRAINING EXPERTS TO INVESTIGATE, MANAGE & COMMUNICATE COMPLEXITIES OF FOREST RESOURCE USE UNDER NOVEL PATTERNS OF WILDFIRE IN THE WESTERN US
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1026506
Grant No.
2021-38420-34938
Cumulative Award Amt.
$241,000.00
Proposal No.
2021-03632
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 15, 2021
Project End Date
Jun 14, 2026
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[KK]- National Needs Graduate Fellowships Program
Recipient Organization
TEXAS TECH UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
LUBBOCK,TX 79409
Performing Department
Natural Resources Management
Non Technical Summary
The nation stands in dire need of multidisciplinary experts in wildfire and forestresources management combined with communications. As underscored by the recentwildfire season in Colorado and widespread impacts of severe fire and smoke along the PacificCoast this past year, the national approach to fire hazard and managing forest resources under changing patterns of fire activity is in dire need of revision. This undertaking will not be feasible without publicsupport garnered through effective communication of nuanced fire science, forest resourcemanagement, and policy. More than a century of aggressive fire suppression has led to fuelaccumulationin some forests, especially dry conifer forests of the southwestern United States, creating fires that are burning more severely than our forest management and land development strategies are equipped to handle. Other, moisture-laden forests, such as high elevation forests of the Rockies, have historically burned at very high severity, but did so only infrequently (i.e., every few hundred years) until recently, as a warming climate has increased (and will continue to increase) the occurrence of the hot and dry conditions that are conducive to severe wildfires in these landscapes (Westerling et al., 2011). Yet still other forest ecosystems of the United States fall somewhere along the middle of this spectrum, with current fire patterns driven by both past land managementas well as climate change, to varying degrees. This nuance is widely understood by experts in fire science and forest management, yet debate and confusion pervade the public arena as land management and climate change as drivers are politicized, sensationalized, and misunderstood. Public perceptions, along with internal agency practices and policies, play a role in influencing fire management strategies. Experts who develop this nuanced understanding often do so through graduate studies, but effective dissemination to other key stakeholders and the general public remains a challenge. Graduate studies typically require such in-depth immersion in a narrow field that graduate students have limited opportunities to develop truly multidisciplinary expertise, such as in fields of forest resource management and communications.Four National Needs Fellows (2 MS, 2 PhD) will become experts in wildland fire, forest resource managment, and science communication through a program at Texas Tech University. An expanded curriculum of cross-disciplinary coursework, service learning, and a unique capstone project will take Fellows' experiences beyond the rigor of traditional graduate studies to help them develop the expertise needed to both understand and communicate complex issues in forest resource management under novel patterns of fire and science communication. The goal of these fellowships will be to prepare the Fellowsto be effective leaders in research and management positions that have tremendous potential for positive impact through communication with stakeholders and the public.
Animal Health Component
40%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
40%
Developmental
40%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1230612206060%
9036099206040%
Goals / Objectives
We propose a suite of fellowships with the overall goal of training experts in a holistic knowledge base of two criticalareas: forest resource management given novel patterns of wildfire, and science communicationgiven the New Media Age. Two MS and two PhD Fellows will achieve objectives oftransdisciplinary coursework, workshops, Peer-to-Peer research, and a capstone project todisseminate findings widely. The Fellows' education will go above and beyond the rigor oftraditional graduate degrees because of the transdisciplinary focus, capstone project, andevidence-based learning strategies.
Project Methods
Academic advising of the proposed National Needs Fellows will include the following additional components:? Participation in regular (typically weekly) lab meetings with all Landscape Ecology andFire research laboratory personnel? Weekly one-on-one advisement with graduate advisor. In addition to supervising researchefforts and capstone project implementation, advisors will also give career guidance andregularly remind Fellows of college and university resources for health and wellness.? Monthly team meetings to plan next steps for collaboration with the National NeedsFellows and PIs of this proposal? Workshop and Service Learning with Forest Service (see Cordova letter of support? Service Learning (see Britton Gregg letter of support)? Participation in other one-time, opportunistic events to receive outside mentoring as theyarise, such as leadership development workshops or science communication seminarsEach Fellow will enter a graduate degree program in either Natural ResourcesManagementor Agricultural Education and Communications. To maintain flexibility and encourage Fellow initiative, after beingoffered a Fellowship, Fellows will have the opportunity to decide whether to pursue a degreethrough the Department of Natural Resources Management or through the Department ofAgricultural Education and Communications. Regardless of which of these degree programs theyenter, Fellows will be expected to attain core competencies in fire ecology, forest resourcemanagement, research design, leadership skills, oral communication, technical writing, andsocial media influence. The attainment of these core competencies will be fostered throughevidence-based experiential learning and specialized coursework, including coursework designedspecifically for the Fellows. In addition to coursework for their respective degree programrequirements, other graduate-level coursework all Fellows will be required to take includes:? Forest Resource Management Seminar? Natural Resource Professionalism? Fire Ecology and Management (a technical writing course)? Prescribed Burning (a Service Learning course)? Ecology of Renewable Natural Resources? Special Topics Fire Science Communication (designed especially for Fellows)? Risk and Crisis Communications in Agriculture and Natural Resources? Public Opinion in Agriculture and Natural Resources? Methods of Technological ChangeCombining these required courses with 12 additional credits of cross-department directedelectives, PhD Fellows will fill a total of at least 24 credits from the other department- NaturalResources Management Fellows will take 24 credits in Agricultural Education andCommunications, and vice versa.Evidence-based experiential learning opportunities will include Service Learning (Astin et al.2000) and structured Peer-to-Peer Learning (Ravanipour et al 2015). For Service Learning,Fellows will enroll in at least one relevant Service Learning-designated course (PrescribedBurning- recently developed into a Service Learning-designated course by PI Gill) and MS Fellows willparticipate in one Alternative Service Break (Jones et al., 2012) with the Forest Service (seeCordova letter of support). Service learning is known to increase sense of purpose, selfconfidence, civic engagement, and academic performance while also encouraging increasedunderstanding of social issues (Celio et al. 2011, Jones et al. 2012). Strong resources forimplementing Service Learning activities are available through the home institution (see Greggletter of support). Peer-to-Peer learning will occur among Fellows during the time periods thatfellowships overlap through a monthly forum. Peer-to-Peer learning is based on the premise thatmutual educational benefits arise as one student teaches another, and is strongly supported byempirical research (Roscoe & Chi, 2007, and references therein; Ravanipour et al., 2015). Toimplement Peer-to-Peer learning through the proposed monthly forums, we will facilitatediscussion among the Fellows to synthesize themes across their respective research topics andencourage the delegation of collaborative tasks to contribute to each other's written manuscriptsand capstone projects. This will create a consistent space for teaching and learning between eachFellow and the others.Furthermore, Fellows will have other beneficial opportunities to develop leadershipskills. By integrating with the aforementioned undergraduate Bridge Adventure undergraduateprogram for diversity and inclusivity (which is co-directed by the PIs of this proposal), Fellowswill have the opportunity to serve in a leadership role during a one-week field research campaignwith a team of 3-5 undergraduates. This field research may coincide with Fellowtheses/dissertations, or may be related to entirely separate projects. This opportunity, combinedwith the experience of leading an extended multi-week data collection campaign for their ownresearch, will allow the Fellows to gain substantial leadership experience. Fellows will also begiven the opportunity to communicate their findings to media outlets; for example, in the lastthree years, the PIs have been interviewed for articles, radio broadcasts, and video interviews forlocal and regional media (Lubbock Avalanche Journal, KCBD Local News, Wyoming PublicMedia, Texas Techsan Magazine, Southern Farm Network, Agriculture.com, Farm Progress, andSuccessful Farming) as well as national outlets (PBS, Discover Magazine) and outdoor-focusedmedia (Backwoods.com). Journalists who contact the PIs regarding fire science, forest resources,or agricultural education and communication will be directed to also interview the Fellows.

Progress 06/15/23 to 06/14/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience is the graduate students who are the fellows in this program to become leaders in the fields of fire ecology, forest resource management, and science communication. We reached this audience through mentoring and by offering classes specifically for the fellows, and by connectingthem with other resources. The four fellows include one Hispanic student, one south Asian student, and two White students. Two are male and two are female. Changes/Problems:We intended to have two PhD fellows in the program, but we were unable to recruit a sufficiently qualifed PhD stduent for the second position. However, we were able to attract an outstanding MS student, and this individual filled the fourth and final fellowship. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?See the description of the networking opportunities offerred through the Ecological Silviculture class described in the previous section. One fellow has been participating in a workinggroup (the Greater Ruidoso Area wildland urban interface working group) through quarterly meetings to address concerns about wildfire hazard in their community. One fellow helped USFS personnel to conduct an experimental prescribed fire in RIo Grande National Forest. Another Fellow has been workingalongside US Fish and Wildlife Service to collect data for monitoring Mexican Gray Wolf and supporting recovery efforts. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Sofar, results are preliminary and ave only been disseminated through small group conversations. Inthe coming years, formal reports and other deliverables will be prepared. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We anticipate that one or two other MS students will graduate and complete meaningful capstone projects. We will continue to mentor each fellow closely, and connect them with additional stakeholders and opportunities. In the coming year, each Fellow will present findigns from their research at a national conference related to their specific interests within fire ecology and management, forest resources, and communications.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The first of our MS students graduated and completed his fellowship. For his capstone project, he developed a side project (separate from his thesis) and presented his findings in a research competition at the Western Region of the American Association of Agricultural Education. He won first place in two separate award categories for this poster presentation. He has now been offerred a position in natural resource public affairs with the BLM. The other three fellows have all continued to make progress toward their degrees and complete their thesis/dissertation research.This includes new relationships between the Fellows and partners at Rio Grande National Forest, The US Fish and WIldlife Service, and the state government of New Mexico.

Publications

  • Type: Theses/Dissertations Status: Other Year Published: 2024 Citation: Dayton Wood. Between Flames and Facebook: A Content Analysis of Government Operated Facebook Pages Used During the 2022 New Mexico Wildfire Season. Texas Tech University Master's Thesis, 2024.


Progress 06/15/22 to 06/14/23

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience is prospective graduate students who are interested in developing expertise to become leaders in the fields of fire ecology, forest resource management, and science communication. We reached this audience by advertising the program widely through natural resource management and biology job boards as well as professional societies (Society of American Foresters, Association for Fire Ecology, Ecological Society of America, International Assoication for Landscape Ecology, others). More specifically, we also made an effort to attract students of underrepresented/minoritized groups within these associations. After admitting students to the fellowship program, the four fellows became the target audience. Changes/Problems:The largest change from what we planned is that we admitted a masters' student for the final fellowship position instead of a second PhD student like we had planned. This masters' student also started nine months after the other fellows, due to the time it took to recruit a suitable student. We had a limited applicant pool, especially for the PhD positions, and especially becaus enumerous applications had to be discarded from qualified individuals who were ineligible due to their non US citizen status (despite our advertising that clearly stated the eligibility requirements). Despite having a small pool of applicants, we thoroughly interviewed qualified candidates and spoke with their references, and this resulted in us enrolling four fantastic and highly qualified individuals to the fellowship program. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The fellows have taken opportunities to undertake additional, interest-specific professional development. For example, two of the students have been engaging regularly with a stakeholder group in a neghiboring state who meet quarterly to discuss the challenges of managing forested land in the Wildland Urban Interface. One student participated in the highly selectiveFreemuth Congress which had a central focus that year on wildland fire. Another student traveled to Europe to receive training from the world's leaders in quantitiative wood anatomy, which is a method he will employ for his dissertation research. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next reporting period, the first two students will be nearing graduation and we will be preparing to capture final evaluation data upon their completion, while we also continue to support the other two fellows.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We were unsuccessful at enrolling a second PhD student in the fellowship progra, but we have admitted an additionalmaster's student instead, so the goal of training and supporting four graduate students is underway. They have engaged in curricula from Natural Resources Management andAgricultural Communications, as well as hybrid courses that we have designed especially for them. We have offerred professional development training to the group. The masters students are beginning to formulate their capstone project ideas. Peer to peer research is underway, as they have all assisted each other with data collection and analysis.

Publications


    Progress 06/15/21 to 06/14/22

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target audience is prospective graduate students who are interested in developing expertise to become leaders in the fields of fire ecology, forest resoruce management, and science communication. We reached this audience by advertising the program widely through natural resource management and biology job boards as well as professional societies (Society of American Foresters, Association for Fire Ecology, Ecological Society ofAmerica, International Assoication for Landscape Ecology, others). More specifically, we also made an effort to attract students of underrepresented/minoritized groups within these assoications. Changes/Problems:It was challenging to find a large pool of applicants. Compared to pre-COVID times, our applicant pool was somewhat small. However, we've been able to find four excellent candidates nonetheless, and two of them have already accepted the offer to participate. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The fourfellows will begin their graduate degrees in Fall 2022and will start enrollign in corusework designed for the program. They will also form the fellowship community and begin meeting and collaborating together.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? One MS and one PhD student have accepted admission intot he program, beginning in Fall 2022. One other prospective graduate student at each leve (MS and PhD) have been extended an offer to be admitted to the program, but have not yet confirmed their participation. Alternates exist in the scenario that these first offers are declined. Both of the students who have accepted the offers are underrepresented minority students. At thisstage, the program has not begun; only recruiting has taken place.

    Publications