Source: IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to
MODULATING THE MAIZE MICROBIOME TO OPTIMIZE NITROGEN USE EFFICIENCY
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1026337
Grant No.
2021-67019-34833
Cumulative Award Amt.
$740,000.00
Proposal No.
2020-07217
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2021
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2025
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[A1402]- Agricultural Microbiomes in Plant Systems and Natural Resources
Recipient Organization
IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY
2229 Lincoln Way
AMES,IA 50011
Performing Department
Plant Pathology and Microbiolo
Non Technical Summary
Improving nitrogen use efficiency is essential for sustainable agricultural production, with the ultimate goal of reducing nitrogen fertilizer inputs while maintaining crop productivity and decreasing environmental damage. In this project, we will identify how high-nitrogen use efficiency corn influences plant-microbe interactions and the ability of microbes to deliver nitrogen to corn. We hypothesize high-nitrogen use efficiency corn fosters different microbial assemblages that will prime microbes to release nitrogen from soil organic matter for plant use while minimizing nitrogen losses. Moreover, we anticipate that some high-nitrogen use efficiency corn genotypes will be better able to directly acquire nitrogen from soil through their interactions with specific microbes.The specific objectives of our research are to (1) assess how high-nitrogen use efficiency corn influences rhizosphere (root-associated) and endophytic (within root) microbiome assembly, (2) quantify how high-nitrogen use efficiency corn influences rhizosphere nitrogen-transformations, and (3) assess how maize root properties are influenced by genotype and nitrogen-fertilization. This research will capitalize on diverse corn landrace accessions that have been genetically integrated into a temperate in-bred line and exhibits high-nitrogen use efficiency. We will also capitalize on a soil obtained from a long-term field experiment site that has gradients in soil organic matter and microbial community composition. These resources will allow us to interrogate potential interactions between genotype and fertilizer levels on plant-microbe interactions using a combination of biochemical analyses, soil laboratory incubations, microbial community profiling, and plant characterizations.This project directly addresses the priorities of the Agricultural Microbiomes Program by identifying plant genetic and microbial characteristics that affect corn nitrogen use efficiency in agricultural soils. The insights gained from our project will improve our understanding of microbiomes that can help optimize plant nutrient use efficiency and potentially reduce chemical inputs.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2031510106025%
1020110107025%
2031510107050%
Goals / Objectives
Improving nitrogen use efficiency is essential for sustainable agricultural production. Nitrogen use efficiency is low because it is an inherently complex systems property governed by multiple interacting genetic and environmental factors. The pathway for plant nitrogen uptake is initiated in the rhizosphere where interactions between roots, microbes, and soil create a complex interplay influencing the timing, amount, and chemical form of nitrogen that is available to the plant. The inability of maize to efficiently use nitrogen is also linked to past plant breeding strategies that have selected genotypes that flourish with large synthetic nitrogen fertilizer inputs, which is reflected by a reduction in the extent to which roots exploit soil nitrogen resources. In soils rich in organic matter, like those in the Midwest Corn Belt, much of the biologically available nitrogen is tied up in the organic matter.To achieve high yields with low fertilizer inputs requires identifying germplasm that stimulates microbial metabolic activities to liberate the nitrogen sequestered in the soil organic matter, and more efficiently deliver nitrogen to maize. This project will exploit a diverse set of high-nitrogen use efficiency germplasm derived from exotic maize landrace accessions integrated into a temperate inbred line and a long-term nitrogen fertilizer rate experiment that has created gradients in soil properties and microbial communities. Our goal is to determine whether high-nitrogen use efficiency genotypes select for a rhizosphere microbial community whose metabolic activities are better at liberating the nitrogen sequestered in the soil organic matter and more efficiently deliver nitrogen to maize. We will also assess whether high-nitrogen use efficiency genotypes are better able to directly acquire nitrogen from soil through their interactions with microbes.The specific objectives of our project are to 1) assess how high-nitrogen use efficiency maize germplasm influences rhizosphere and endophytic microbiome assembly, 2)quantify how high-nitrogen use efficiency maize germplasm influences rhizosphere nitrogen-transformations, and 3)assess how maize root properties are influenced by genotype and nitrogen-fertilization.By coupling descriptions of the root microbiome, N-transformations, and root properties with metabolite profiling of root exudates/secretions we will develop models to determining whether rhizosphere priming may shape the microbiome.
Project Methods
We will capitalize on two unique resources available for this project. We will exploit diverse maize landrace accessions generated from the USDA Germplasm Enhancement of Maize project, which has been genetically integrated into a temperate inbred line and exhibits high-nitrogen use efficiency in Midwest Corn belt soils. This germplasm will serve as a basis for comparative studies on root microbiome structure and metabolic activities. The project will further capitalize on soil obtained from a long-term field experiment site that has gradients in soil organic matter and microbial community composition. This resource will be used to specifically access whether high-nitrogen use efficiency maize genotypes prime soil organic matter mineralization by rhizosphere microorganisms while limiting nitrogen loses by minimizing nitrification. We will use rhizotrons in the laboratory because they provide greater experimental control to reduce the potentially confounding influences of soil heterogeneity present in the long-term fertilizer gradient site used in the study. Moreover, rhizotrons are amendable to use of the rhizon samples for continuous monitoring of ammonia and nitrate pool sizes, they provide access for more rigorous root architecture analyses, and provide more reliable measurements of gross ammonia and nitrate production rates that can be difficult to obtain in field studies. Our approach will be to integrate microbial community profiling using next generation DNA sequencing techniques with measures of ammonia and nitrate production and rhizosphere metabolome characterizations with descriptions of plant root architecture and nitrogen uptake.We anticipate identifying microbial community patterns that reflect interactions between genotype and nitrogen -fertilization level. These data sets will be mined to identify specific microbes that can potentially be exploited to enhance nitrogen use efficiency. We will assess how nitrogen-fertilization and high-nitrogen use efficiency genotypes influence gross rates of ammonia and nitrate production using isotopic pool dilution techniques. Lower nitrification to ammonia production ratios in the rhizosphere of high-nitrogen use efficiency maize will be evidence that high-nitrogen use efficiency genotypes conserve nitrogen by minimizing potential nitrogen losses due to large nitrate pools. Moreover, we will evaluate the interaction between fertilization rate and plant genotype on root architecture and root exudation/secretion chemical composition (metabolome). We predict that the chemical composition of root exudates will be strongly influenced by both plant genotype and nitrogen fertilizer rate. Moreover, we also anticipate that high-nitrogen use efficiency genotypes express root architectures that enable roots to explore more soil volume and the extent of root proliferation will be dependent on the rate of nitrogen-fertilizer application. Collectively, the data will provide evidence for or against the notion that high yields observed with high-nitrogen use efficiency maize genotypes is a consequence of stimulating maize metabolic activities to simulate root-associated microbial communities to liberate the nitrogen sequestered in the soil organic matter and to more efficiently deliver nitrogen to maize.

Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Agricultural researchers through poster presentations at scientific conferences. The target audience also includes co-investigators, scientists, and studentsworking on the project, as well as colleagues engaged in microbiome research. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Hands-on instruction and technical training are taking place in the Halverson and Castellano laboratories. Collectively, these labs have two undergraduate students, two graduate students, one post-doctoral researcher, and one high-school science teacher (participating in a Research Experience for Teachers-[RET] program) participating in laboratory components of the research. Two graduate students participated in professional, scientific meetings to share results and learn more about their discipline, technical advancements, and career opportunities while also providing networking opportunities. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Our work has been disseminated through classroom instruction in Castellano's Agroecology course serving both undergraduate and graduate students, as well as Halverson's Laboratory in Microbial Physiology, Genetics and Diversity for undergraduate students, where students learn techniques for characterizing rhizosphere microbial communities. Portions of the results have been presented as posters at international conferences and to peers in the graduate programs/seminar series at ISU that are open to the general public.One graduate student gave a public seminar open to ISU faculty and students on his research as a requirement for defending his master's thesis, which will be submitted/completed in the near future. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?For Aim 1, we plan to complete the construction of libraries to characterize the bacterial, archaeal, and fungal communities of the bulk soil, rhizosphere, and hyperspheres of high- and non-high NUE germplasm grown in soil with different (low, medium, high) N-fertilization histories. We will also complete the quantitative PCR measurements of total bacterial, archaeal, and fungal community sizes. We will also complete the isolation of DNA from plant tissue for microbiome characterizations of the endophytic community. Once amplicon sequencing is completed, we will begin bioinformatic analyses. For Aim 2, we will complete the inorganic N measurement of bulk soil, rhizosphere, and hyphosphere compartments of samples collected from the microbiome analyses described in Aim 1. We will also perform isotopic N mass spectrometry measurements to determine how much N is acquired by AMF. For Aim 3, we will continue to perform root architectural analyses of high and non-high NUE genotypes, assess the effects of Massilia to stimulate root development in low N conditions and complete the isolation of root exudates for metabolomic analyses. If the 15N analyses indicate differences in AMF-mediated N acquisition under low fertilization, we will explore developing tools to ascertain differences in plant transporters for incorporating N from AMF.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Aim 1: Assess how high-nitrogen Use Efficiency (NUE) germplasm influences rhizosphere and endophytic microbiome assembly. In this reporting period, we implemented our redesigned rhizotrons (mesocosms) to better enable higher throughput for comparing differences between high- and non-high NUE mazie genotypes on i)rhizosphere, ii) endosphere, and iii) hyphosphere bacterial, archaeal and fungal communities. Plants were grown in soils of contrasting low, middle, and high nitrogen fertilization to the V5/V6developmental stage with sufficient replication (n=8) for robust co-occurrence (network) analyses. Collected all the samples and extracted high quality DNA from bulk soils, rhizosphere, and endosphere samples and are in the process of isolating DNA from root tissue. We have processed all the bulk soil, rhizosphere, and hyphosphere samples for inorganic N pool sizes and for measuring the extent of Arbuscular Mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) contributing to NUE by the high-NUE genotypes. Samples are being processed for generating libraries for near full-length sequencing of the small subunit rRNA genes. Aim 2: Quantify how high-NUE maize germplasm influences rhizosphere N-transformations. In this reporting period, we completed collecting rhizosphere soil solution samples through various maize developmental stages (up to V5/V6) and conducted experiments to measure the gross rates of ammonia/nitrate production and consumption, potential nitrification rates, and inorganic N pool sizes at the V5/V6 developmental stage. Samples have been processed, and most of the data has been analyzed. The data supports the prediction that some high-NUE genotypes stimulate ammonia production (N-supply) in the rhizosphere and that some linesenhance nitrogen retention in the rhizosphere by inhibiting nitrification compared to non-high NUE germplasm. Additional statistical analyses are in progress. Aim 3: Assess how maize root properties are influenced by genotype and N-fertilization. In this reporting period, we have expanded on our initial observations that high-NUE genotypes vary in root architectural properties, differing in how they influence microbes around roots. We show that the root architecture of high-NUE genotypes generates roots that are more branched and with finer roots, in particular more lateral roots, compared to non-high NUE genotypes. Determined that some maize root-associated Massilia species isolates produce more biofilm when exposed to root exudates and are better at stimulating lateral root formation. This indicates that recruitment of Massilia on roots under low N fertilizer conditions could enhance nitrogen use efficiency by stimulating root development to better capture nitrogen. Stimulation of root development by Massilia could contribute to the observation of increased biomass in low N soils when plants are inoculated with a 31-member (29 species) synthetic community that includes twoMassilia isolates.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/22 to 06/30/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Agricultural researchers- posters were presented at two conferences, International Phytobiomes Conference 2022 (13-15 September 2022, Denver, CO, USA) and the 2022 ASA-CSSSA-SSSA International Annual Meeting (November 6-9, Baltimore, MD, USA). Undergraduate and graduate students at ISU through formal classroom and laboratory instruction. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Hands-on instruction and technical training are taking place in the Halverson and Castellano laboratories. Collectively, these labs have two undergraduate students, two graduate students, and one post-doctoral researcher participating in laboratory components of the research. One graduate student and one post-doctoral researcher participated in professional, scientific meetings to share results and to learn more about their discipline, technical advancements, and career opportunities while also providing networking opportunities. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Our work has been disseminated through classroom instruction in Castellano's Agroecology course serving both undergraduate and graduate students, and Halverson's Laboratory in Microbial Physiology, Genetics and Diversity for undergraduate students, where students learn techniques for characterizing rhizosphere microbial communities. Part of the results has been presented as posters at international conferences and to peers in the graduate programs/seminar series at ISU that are open to the general public. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period, we plan to continue analyzing samples for Aim 1 that were collected from bulk soil and rhizosphere of high- and low- NUE maize germplasm grown in soil with differing N-fertilization histories. Analyses include 15N isotope pool dilution measurement, an isotope ration mass spectrometer, and inorganic N pool sizes by colorimetric assays. DNA will be extracted from soil and rhizosphere samples for measuring the abundance of taxa involved in key N-cycling processes. For Aim 2, we will propagate plants in a modified rhizotron system to collect bulk soil, rhizosphere, hyphosphere, and endosphere microbial communities of high- and low-NUE maize germplasm grown in soil with differing N-fertilization histories. DNA will be obtained from these samples and processed for quantitative PCR and/or amplicon profiling of bacterial and fungal communities. We anticipate DNA will be submitted for amplicon sequencing by the end of this reporting period. For Aim 3, we will begin the propagation of plants for the collection of root exudates for metabolomic analyses once we finalize the development of an experimental system that is appropriate for the goal.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Aim 1. Assess how high-NUE maize germplasm influences rhizosphere and endophytic microbiome assembly. We have completed the design, test, build, and evaluationphase of the rhizotron system to complete the objectives of this Aim. This refined rhizotron(mesocosm) system will permit a more robust assessment of the potential contribution of Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi (AMF) in nitrogen acquisition by the high-NUE maize germplasm, utilize less variable nitrogen fertilizer soil, and provide compartments to evaluate root-free soil and the hyposphere. Presently, we are propagating plants to examine rhizosphere and endophytic microbiome assembly. Aim 2. Quantify how high-NUE maize germplasm influences rhizosphere N-transformations. In this reporting period, a graduate student has collected all the plant and soil samples necessary for the completion of this Aim. Significantly,he has developed the expertise to prepare samples labeled with 15N for mass spectral analysis for determining rates of nitrate and ammonia production in bulk compared to rhizosphere soil. Moreover, he obtained samples for inorganic N-pool size determinations and has conducted experiments to assess potential nitrification and ammonification. Aim 3. Assess how maize root properties are influenced by genotype and N-fertilization We are taking a hiatus on the continuation of additional root architectural analyses until we complete the analysis of samples obtained for Aim 2and have completed obtaining microbiome samples for Aim 1. We have also designed and tested a system for collecting root exudates and anticipate making new versions based on our earlier outcomes. The genome sequencesof 4 Masillia species (Oxalobacteraceae) have been obtained using both long-read Nanopore and short-read Illumina sequencing platforms. Assembly and polishing of the genomes are nearly complete, as well as initial bioinformatic analysis. These strains show different abilities to attach to plant roots and form biofilms and likely represent at least two and possibly three species. Reports by others suggest that these bacteria contribute to maize nitrogen use efficiency by promoting root development.

    Publications


      Progress 07/01/21 to 06/30/22

      Outputs
      Target Audience:The target audience reached by our efforts during this reporting period include co-investigators, scientists, and students working on the project as well as colleagues engaged in microbiome research. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Hands-on instruction and training is taking place in the Halverson and Castellano laboratories where collectively one undergraduate researcher and two graduate students are participating in laboratory components of the research. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period, we plan to initiate experiments to begin collecting the bulk soil, rhizosphere, and endosphere samples necessary for generating profiles of the microbial community and how N-fertilization levels and maize genotype influence microbial communities. We also plan to initiate experiments to measure rates of nitrification and ammonia production in the rhizosphere and endosphere, as well as to finalize development of the microfluidic-based quantitative PCR platform to measure ammonia mono-oxygenase gene abundance. Lastly, we will begin developing protocols for isolating maize root exudates for metabolomic analyses.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We successfully generated the high NUE germplasm required for this project in October2021, which was required to begin the proposed studies. We obtained sufficient amount of seed for all germplasm that will be needed for the duration of the project. Aim 1. Assess how high-NUE maize germplasm influences rhizosphere and endophytic microbiome assembly We successfully recruited a post-doctoral fellow to work on this aim. Aim 2. Quantify how high-NUE maize germplasm influences rhizosphere N-transformations In this reporting period, a graduate student initiated studies to assess the proposed methodologies for quantifying rhizosphere N-transformations. This work has led to several key changes in the experimental plan to accommodate the robust root development of the high NUE maize germplasm, as well as a strategy for measuring the non-radioactive nitrogen isotope for these experiments. Moreover, we have validated new molecular tools (PCR primers) specific for different groups (clades) of bacteria for measuring the abundance of genes involved in nitrification that are amendable to microfluidic, high-throughput analyses. Aim 3. Assess how maize root properties are influenced by genotype and N-fertilization We did a preliminary screen of root architectural features of the high-NUE maize germplasm and observed substantive differences in genotypes that exhibit greater grain yields than the parental lines under low and under low and high nitrogen fertilization levels. This suggests that differences in yield performance cannot be simply attributed to differences in one or more root architectural features. These results were obtained when plants were grown under in soil from the low and moderate N fertilization levels of the long-term nitrogen-fertilization study site: studies are planned for examining root architectural features under high N fertilization. Lastly, we isolated several Oxalobacteriaceae from maize roots that we are currently characterizing (genomic and phenotypic): these organisms were recently shown to contribute to maize nitrogen use efficiency.

      Publications