Source: UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN - PLATTEVILLE submitted to NRP
CHOREOGRAPHING CHANGE IN AGROECOLOGY: A NLGCA - TRIBAL COLLEGE NETWORK
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025970
Grant No.
2021-70001-34522
Cumulative Award Amt.
$29,827.00
Proposal No.
2020-11302
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2021
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2024
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[NLGCA]- Capacity Building Grants for Non Land Grant Colleges of Agriculture
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN - PLATTEVILLE
1 UNIVERSITY PLAZA
PLATTEVILLE,WI 53818
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Through ongoing, iterative discussions between Universityof WI-Platteville and the American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC), we have discovered many areas of complementary and synergistic research and education relating to the topics of soil and water quality. This has given rise to a desire to identify the larger scope of potential collaboration among these institutions and create a collaborative network across sites to facilitate research, education, and outreach activities. While we feel that there are significant research networks within the land grant universities and state and federal governments this capacity is underutilized in non-land grant colleges and the Tribal Colleges and Universities. Here we propose to enhance our capacity for research, education, and outreach by developing a mutually beneficial network of scientists and educators to leverage existing resources, share perspectives, and build capacity to support sustainable intensification of natural resources.Through this planning grant we intend to recruit additional interested scientists and educators from institutions within AIHEC and NLGCA in order to engage in inter-institutional strategic planning which will (1) identify water quality and soil health challenges common across the network; (2) inventory relevant resources and facilities; (3) formulate potential collaborative research, education, and outreach activities; and (4) generate and implement a NLGCA Large-Scale Comprehensive Initiative grant proposal focused on water quality and soil health.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
30%
Applied
30%
Developmental
40%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1020199107050%
1110210106050%
Goals / Objectives
The over-arching challenge facing agricultural production is one of demand for increased production framed within long-term resilience and sustainability of water and soil resources. Understanding the effects of environmental policy, subsequent best management practices, on yield, and economic returns, at the farm scale and across regions is fundamental in ensuring our long-term sustainable future. We feel that establishment and operation of a collaborative research and educational network between NLGCA and Tribal Colleges and Universities will allow for the investigation of economic and environmental consequences of sustainable intensification across agro-ecoregions within the United States. The short-term objectives of this planning proposal are to:Identify water quality and soil health challenges common across the network.Inventory relevant resources and facilities.Formulate potential collaborative research, education, and outreach activities.Generate and implement a NLGCA Large-Scale Comprehensive Initiative grant proposal focused on water quality and soil health.
Project Methods
Briefly, our first step in this process will be to recruit and formalize a working group of interested institutions from the AIHEC. Recruitment activities will focus on identification of individuals with interest in addressing challenges or problems related to soil health and water quality. Identification of tribal personnel and network sites will be led by John Phillips, Director of First Americans Land Grant Consortium (FALCON). We envision that proposed activities will utilize virtual meetings, face-to-face meetings, and both virtual and in-person field days where we:Define the local site challenges/situation, inputs, activities, and outputs. Our first planned virtual meeting will review the objectives of the planning proposal and have each participant define/describe their ecoregion, current challenges/situation, inputs, activities, and outputs relating to soil and water quality and agriculture production. This overview should include a description of stakeholder involvement in problem identification (e.g. current literature review, survey of local stakeholders, educators, and researchers, etc.). Identify commonalities across network and develop network outcomes and activities. This second meeting will combine a site visit with a face-to-face planning meeting. Here we intend to facilitate a discussion where we provide a forum for all interested parties to share ideas, concepts, and work relating to soil health and water quality in their ecoregions. Through the facilitated discussion, the group will utilize the forum setting and organize and work toward a consensus on the proposed network outcomes and activities, including research and educational methods. We are intending on following standard meeting practice.Conduct network inputs needs assessment based on outcomes and activities determined in prior meetings. During our second proposed virtual meeting we intend to utilize the results from our facilitated group discussion that developed consensus network outcomes and activities to determine the local site and network capacity limitations for cross-site activities. The assessment will include human resources, research infrastructure, funding streams and budgets.Development of network indicators & milestones. An important part of the planning process is the identification and development of network milestones and indicators. During the planning process we will develop metrics that can measure or evaluate inputs, outputs, and outcomes and track progress toward intended outcomes via milestones.

Progress 07/01/21 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems:Our proposal included participants from multiple time zones which has made meetings and group writing difficult, but not impossible. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During the early phase of this project the principal investigators (Dennis L Busch, John Phillips, Zach Lenning, Donita L. Cartmill, and Andrew D. Cartmill) identified and recruited additional participants from Aaniiih Nakoda College (ANC), Univ. of WI-Platteville (UWP), and American Indian Higher Education Consortium (AIHEC) to work assist with (1) the identification of common water quality and soil health challenges, (2) development of an inventory of relevant resources and facilities, (3) formulation of potential collaborative research, education, and outreach activities, and (4) generation and submission of a NLGCA Large-Scale Comprehensive Initiative grant focused on water quality and soil health. Our discussions were primarily conducted remotely utilizing cloud-based video conferencing due to our distant locations and localized covid restrictions. However, personnel from the UWP visited ANC in August of 2023 and representatives of Aaniiih Nakoda College traveled to the Univ. of WI-Platteville in May of 2024. Moreover, we meet for additional face-to-face discussions at the First Americans Land Grant Conference (FALCON) conference which was held in Denver in November of 2023. During our cross-site visits and video conferences we discovered multiple shared research interest and common soil health and water quality challenges. For example, both ANC and UWP had identified opportunities to increase the productivity and sustainability of pasture swords by implementing improved grazing management strategies (eg. managed intensive grazing) and interseeding pastures and rangeland with native grasses and/or forbs. While our grazing livestock are quite different (buffalo at ANC and Holsteins at UWP) many of our management and evaluation techniques could be similar across sites. In addition to the issue of pasture and rangeland sustainability, both institutions have active monitoring programs designed to determine how local land use influences the quality of surface and groundwater resources. Within the Fort Belknap Indian Reservation prior gold mining operations have resulted in cyanide contamination of water resources which are currently being monitored using chemical and biological methods. Similarly, chemical and biological monitoring of water resources are utilized to evaluate the impact farming systems have on water quality at UWP. A primary output of our planning activities was the development and distribution of a survey of institutions within AIHEC. The 50-question survey was designed to gauge respondent's level of interest in participating in a soil health / water quality research and education network. Survey results indicated a substantial level of interest in topics such as: developing a consortium with universities/colleges with similar interest in water and soils; development of for-credit lab and/or fieldwork curriculum; partnerships with organizations that can provide support; curriculum support for faculty; and professional development, training, and workshops for faculty. In addition to the survey, we developed a substantial list of institutional resources that could be utilized to support a NLGCA - TCU research and education network. For example, ANC currently operates a NSF-funded Buffalo Center and Water Center, a Community Garden with greenhouse, and USDA Extension program. Moreover, ANC offers several courses (e.g. Ecological Field Methods) and internship opportunities which could support network objectives. UWP agroecosystem research program lead by Dennis L. Busch has established a significant water quality (surface-water, groundwater, vadose zone), soil health, and greenhouse gas emissions monitoring program at their university farm and also offers classes (e.g. Applied Agricultural Hydrology) and internships that could be leveraged within the research network. While our discussion highlighted significant resources that could be leveraged to support a joint NLGCA - TCU research and education network, the authors believed that such a network would also benefit from the inclusion of an international research partner, and collaborators with expertise in data management and project evaluation. Therefore, we invited USDA ARS, Université de Montréal, and Massey University to participate in the grant proposal. The USDA ARS National Laboratory for Agriculture and the Environment hosts the STEWARDS Database which serves data for the ARS Conservation Effects Assessment Project and they will provide support for database development activities. A third-party, expert social scientist from the Université de Montréal (Boris H. J.M Brummans) has been recruited to assist with development and evaluation of specific learning outcomes. In addition, as a key staff/project researcher (Andrew/Donita) recently joined the School of Agriculture and Environment at Massey University, and Massey University (MU) in Aotearoa New Zealand (NZ) was recruited as an international partner to allow for broader student social, cultural, and scientific learning experiences. Based on the results of our AIHEC survey, review of available resources, and research interest among the principal investigators, it was determined that our project would focus on soil health and water quality aspects related to our livestock grazing programs. As each of our locations had the capability to implement grazing activities, it could serve as a common focus for data collection, development of sustainability metrics, and educational activities. As a team we developed a list of data sets and specific parameters that would be collected across sites according to specific sample and data collection methods. The common research focus will facilitate cross-site data collection, comparisons, aggregation, and analysis by students, scientists, and educators participating in the project. Students will assist with in-field sample collection, data analysis, and data interpretation at their local site as well as field trips to other network sites. Students will also be encouraged to work on cross-site teams to facilitate a deeper understanding of production systems and ecoregions associated with each of the research locations and to provide more immersive cross-cultural experiences. The proposed research projects have significant support from the stakeholders on local, regional, and national scales. For example, the proposed UW-P research supports the U.S. Dairy Net Zero Initiative (NZI)/Dairy Soil Water Regeneration project: a national initiative developed to provide data via on-farm research focused on quantifying the impacts of dairy farm management on soil health, water quality, and greenhouse gas emissions. In addition, the research supports the USDA Long-Term Agroecosystems Research and Global Farm Platform research networks. Fort Belknap Indian Community (FBIC) through its advisory board developed Agricultural Resource Management Plan and Programmatic Environmental Assessment in 2018. One of the recommendations provided by the 2018 plan is to implement improved grazing techniques to reduce the negative impacts on soil and water quality. Led by Massey University, Whenua Haumanu is a partnership between Massey University and the Ministry for Primary Industries through the Sustainable Food and Fiber Future fund. It is the most comprehensive program on the effect of conventional and regenerative pastoral practices. Whenua Haumanu explores conventional and regenerative farming practices across both standard and diverse pastures at two of Massey University's working farms. An important focus of the proposed project is the incorporation of multiple perspectives on agroecological practices and understandings. Participants will assist in integrating cultural attitudes, understandings, and perspectives related to soil and water resources and food production, helping to ensure that the research outcomes generated from the projects are locally relevant and actionable.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/22 to 06/30/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:During this reporting period faculty and staff from Univ. of WI-Platteville travelled to Harlem, Montana and visited co-investigators, faculty, staff, students, Extension personnel at Aaniiih Nakoda College to discuss available resources, local needs, and to gauge interest in future collaboration. The discussion was extended to additional Tribal Colleges and Universities during the FALCON (First American Land-Grant Consortion) conference held in Denver, Colorado. Later in the year, UW-Platteville hosted staff and students from Aaniiih Nakoda College. During their visit we toured UW-Platteville Pioneer Farm research facilities, visited local farmers, meet with UW-Platteville students, and discussed options for future collaborations. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The cross-site visits supported professional development for participants from both Univ. of WI-Platteville and Aaniiih Nakoda College. During these visits we discussed and compared local challenges facing agricultural production within each region. Moreover, we had the opportunity to frame these discussions within the differing cultural contexts and socio economic goals. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?This work has been disseminated to stakeholders within both communities through in-person and virtual meetings. In addition, hardcopies of our survey data and the NLGCA Large-Scale proposal were available to stakeholders. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We plan to finalize and submit a Large-Scale NLGCA grant proposal.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? During our cross-site virtual and in-person meetings, we have identified water quality and soil health challenges across the network, identified resources available for use in future projects, formulated research, education, and outreach activities, and drafted a NLGCA Large-Scale project proposal.

    Publications


      Progress 07/01/21 to 06/30/22

      Outputs
      Target Audience:We have succesfully reached out to various colleges and universities within the American Indian Higher Education Consortium to gauge interest in future research, education and outreach opportunities.This was achieved through online surveys and doodle polls. We haveinterest from over 25 universities/colleges within the American Indian Higher Education Consortium alone in areas of water and soil health,spanning the broad areas of research, education and outreach. Changes/Problems:COVID restrictions and concerns have made site visits and face to face meetings challenging. We are hoping to hold face to face meetings in 2022. We have increased the number of virtual meetings to compensate while COVID restrictions are in place. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We plan to conduct site visits as COVID restrictions allow and start writng and organizing materials for submission of a larger grant as proposed. Regular virtual meetings will continue as proposed. Some of the tribal colleges are not keen on site visits due to COVID concerns at this time. Visits will take place as allowed.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We have held numerousvirtual meetings to work towards the project goals listed above. An online survey has been conducted to gauge interest from the tribal colleges. Preliminary results include 25 colleges/universities with interest in collaboration opportunities. This data is being'mined' and discussed. Our next virtual meeting is plannedfor later in September/early October2022.

      Publications