Source: NANOSEPEX INC. submitted to NRP
CARBON NANOTUBE ENHANCED MEMBRANE DISTILLATION WITH AIR SPARGING FOR ECONOMIC SEPARATION OF BIOFUELS FROM FERMENTATION PRODUCTS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025806
Grant No.
2021-33530-34469
Cumulative Award Amt.
$100,000.00
Proposal No.
2021-01137
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2021
Project End Date
Jan 31, 2023
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[8.8]- Biofuels and Biobased Products
Recipient Organization
NANOSEPEX INC.
54 HUNTLEY WAY
BRIDGEWATER,NJ 088075565
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
In this project, we will address one of the world's major challenges - the economic development of biofuels to reduce fossil energy use. The biofuel development efforts are driven by issues such as global warming, energy efficiency, sustainability, and as sources of industrial chemicals. The United States is the world's largest producer of ethanol, having produced nearly 16.9 billion gallons in 2019 alone. Microbial fermentation is the most common approach to produce biofuels, especially ethanol from biomass using specific fermenters. For biofuel generation, the separation of products and downstream purification play critical roles in its final purity and economic viability. Problems such as the high energy consumption via traditional processes need to be overcome to achieve economic production of biofuels. In this project, we will develop a novel approach to the production of biofuels (and chemicals) by separating ethanol from fermentation products using carbon nanotube enhanced membrane distillation (CNEM-MD). We will investigate modification of membranes with carbon nanotubes to facilitate ethanol vapor transport. The modified membranes will be used to fabricate membrane modules and for development of MD system for ethanol recovery. While conventional distillation is typically carried out at higher temperatures (80-90°C), separation by CNEM-MD is driven by a vapor pressure difference across a membrane and thus can be carried out at lower temperature below the boiling point (40-75°C) and shows high rejection of dissolved and non-volatile species. The footprint of CNEM-MD systems is significantly smaller than the thermal distillation units. The CNEM-MD can also be integrated with other existing technologies for dehydration of biofuels. This will significantly lower the production cost of biofuels to a level that is competitive with petroleum based products.
Animal Health Component
40%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
0%
Applied
40%
Developmental
60%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
40274102020100%
Knowledge Area
402 - Engineering Systems and Equipment;

Subject Of Investigation
7410 - General technology;

Field Of Science
2020 - Engineering;
Goals / Objectives
The major goal of this project is to develop carbon nanotube (CNT) enhanced membrane distillation (MD) for the recovery of ethanol in biofuel industry. The novel membrane referred to as carbon nanotube enhanced membrane (CNEM) will be developed by immobilizing functionalized CNTs into membrane pores to selectively transport ethanol vapor. The CNEM along with a modified MD process that incorporates air sparging (or CNEM-MD) will be developed for the economic recovery of biofuels. CNEM-MD can be carried out at relatively low temperatures between 40 to 75°C as compared to 80 to 90°C for thermal distillation. CNEM-MD will lead to the lowering of capital expenditure, operating cost, and it will facilitate the recovery of ethanol from low concentration waste streams. Its low temperature operation will allow the utilization of industrial waste heat and solar energy, and prevent the formation of harmful byproducts during biofuel processing.The specific objectives of this project are:CNEM developmentEthanol recovery via CNEM-MDSystem configuration and design for maximizing recoveryIntegration with existing biofuel separation systems such as thermal distillation and pervaporation.
Project Methods
The methods to be used in the different tasks are described below,In Task 1, the CNTs will be functionalized and characterized by various techniques such as electron microscopy and spectroscopy. The CNTs then will be used to fabricate membranes which will be characterized based on their surface properties, porosity and hydrophobicity. The affinity between the synthesized membrane and the alcohol will be evaluated to prescreen candidate membranes for ethanol recovery.In Task 2, experiments on ethanol recovery will be carried out on developed CNEM-MD system operating at different conditions of feed temperatures, flow rates and feed ethanol concentrations. Performance of the CNEM-MD system for ethanol recovery will be evaluated based on measured process parameters including ethanol flux, mass transfer coefficients, ethanol selectivity and product recovery. Selectivity of the membrane will be calculated for the different f-CNTs. Mass and energy balance will be carried out and process flow sheet including product and energy recovery will be developed.In Task 3, a simulation tool will be developed to optimize configuration of multiple CNEM-MD modules to maximize ethanol recovery. This tool will allow us to predict the process for different bio refineries, for examples how many stages are optimum and how to best recover the latent heat of vaporization as we condense the vapors.In Task 4, we will study the integration of our CNEM-MD system with existing separation techniques that are used in refining bioethanol. We are particularly interested in pervaporation (PV) system using simulated biofuel streams. The output from the CNEM-MD system will be fed into the PV system. Once operational conditions for the CNEM-MD system and for the PV system are separately optimized, process conditions that are optimum for the integrated MD-PV system will be identified experimentally. Mass and energy balance will be carried out and process flow sheet including product and energy recovery will be developed.Besides the above tasks, we will carry out a techno economic analysis of our process as applied to biofuel refining.

Progress 07/01/21 to 01/31/23

Outputs
Target Audience:Our target audience are bio refineries and the engineering firms that work with the refineries. Based on our customer discovery, there are two major opportunities. The first is based on splitting a slurry stream, filtering and processing part of the liquid stream via CNEM-MD before sending it back to thermal distillation. The second is recovering ethanol fromCO2 scrubbers where there is typically 2% ethanol and this can be concentrated and sent back to distillation column. Either way, we expected to save in terms of operational cost and CAPEX. However, we realize that there may be many other opportunities in the biofuel refining. For example, a related opportunity may be the purification of refined products using our approach, and the dewatering distillates may lead to significant energy savings. Solvent recovery in waste streams and in solvent recycling may be some other important applications of our technology. We initiated discussions with several engineering firms who design bioethanol manufacturing plants in the USA. One of our strategies to reach the customers is to partner with engineering firms and ethanol refineries and conduct pilot tests at their facility to provide proof of concept. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? We initiated discussions with two engineering companies who designed most of the bioethanol manufacturing plants in the USA and rest of world. Simultaneously, we have been in discussions with two of the largest ethanol producers to act as a host site for a pilot demonstration. Currently we are working collaboratively with Lawrence Berkley Laboratory and US Navy to use our CNEM-MD approach torecover a bio aviation fuel product isoprenol. Another commercial potential of CNEM-MD technology is in solvent recycling. We have been in advanced talks with amajor waste processing company to run pilot testing for recovery of isopropyl alcohol and ethylene glycol in its plant. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? R&D activities carried out during the reporting period and significant results achieved under the specific objectives are described below: CNEM Development: (1) Several porous membranes were evaluated by liquid entry pressure (LEP), water contact angel and flux measurements. (2) Different CNT (carbon nanotube) coating formulations comprising of solvent and polymeric binder was made on trial-and-error basis and the stability of the dispersion were studied using dynamic light scattering (DLS) technique to evaluate the fabrication time line. (3) PTFE membrane and CNT coated PTFE membrane were characterized with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and thermogravimetry (TGA). (4) The effect of membrane pore size on ethanol recovery performance was studied experimentally on a bench scale CNEM-MD system. (5) The influence of forms of CNT functionalization was studied experimentally. (6) The effect of the number of CNT layers on top of base membrane was studied by water/solvent contact angle measurements, TGA analysis, SEM imaging and by SGMD experiments. Ethanol recovery via CNEM-MD: (1) Spiral wound CNEM modules were fabricated using a fully functional spiral wound module fabrication facility at NanoSepex. (2) A lab-pilot CNEM-MD system was developed and built at Nanosepex facility. (3) A series of experiments were conducted on the lab pilot system to verify the effectiveness of the CNEM-MD process for ethanol recovery from its aqueous solution. Effects of process parameters including feed inlet temperature, feed flow rate, sweep air flow rate were studied. (4) Experimental studies were carried out using the lab-pilot CNEM-MD system to recover ethanol from CO2 scrubber waste samples provided by a biofuel manufacturer. System configuration and design for maximizing recovery: We have developed a simulation tool that allows us to predict CNEM-MD process outcomes under different operation conditions (feed concentration, temperature, flow rate, etc.). This was used to carry out some simulations. Integration with existing biofuel separation systems such as thermal distillation and pervaporation: We studied the feasibility of integrating CNEM-MD with pervaporation. The results showed high separation factor that can generate pure (99%) ethanol at low flux. A dense membrane is needed to synthesize the CNEM membranes and the process would be difficult to scale up in our laboratory. Since the flux of pervaporation system was low, it would require large membrane modules. The technique does not appear viable for commercial scale manufacturing by NanoSepex at this time as it would also need additional investments. Also. it does not appear to be attractive at this point according to customer discovery. A concentrated ethanol stream generated by CNEM-MD can be integrated with thermal distillation. This we believe is the best way to enter the biofuel refining market to gain acceptance. Other applications of CNEM-MD: We also performed experimental studies that demonstrated the feasibility of CNEM-MD for application in recovery of ethylene glycol from antifreeze coolant waste and enrichment of other types of biofuel (isoprenol, butanol) from its low concentration aqeous solutions. Development of a pilot scale system: Development of a pilot scale 2 ~ 5 gpm CNEM-MD system has been initiated.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Mitun Chandra Bhoumick, Cheng Li, Sagar Roy, Eric Sundstrom, Benjamin G. Harvey, and Somenath Mitra, ÿ¿ÿ¢ÿ¿ÿ¿ÿ¿ÿ¿Enhanced Recovery of Aviation Biofuel Precursor Isoprenol Using Nanocarbon-Immobilized Membrane-Based Membrane Distillationÿ¿ÿ¢ÿ¿ÿ¿ÿ¿ÿ, Energy Fuels 37, 2875ÿ¿ÿ¢ÿ¿ÿ¿ÿ¿ÿ¿2885 (2023).


Progress 07/01/21 to 06/30/22

Outputs
Target Audience:Our target audience are bio refineries and the engineering firms that work with the refineries. Based on our customer discovery, there are two major opportunities. The first is based on splitting a slurry stream, filtering and processing part of the liquid stream via CNEM-MD before sending it back to thermal distillation. The second is recovering ethanol from CO2 scrubbers where there is typically 2% ethanol and this can be concentrated and sent back to distillation column. Either way, we expected to save in terms of operational cost and CAPEX. However, we realize that there may be many other opportunities in the biofuel refining. For example, a related opportunity may be the purification of refined products using our approach, and the dewatering distillates may lead to significant energy savings. Solvent recovery in waste streams and in solvent recycling may be some other important applications of our technology. We initiated discussions with several engineering firms who design bioethanol manufacturing plants in the USA. One of our strategies to reach the customers is to partner with engineering firms and ethanol refineries and conduct pilot tests at their facility to provide proof of concept. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? We initiated discussions with two engineering companies who designed most of the bioethanol manufacturing plants in the USA and rest of world. Simultaneously, we have been in discussions with two of the largest ethanol producers to act as a host site for a pilot demonstration. Currently we are working collaboratively with Lawrence Berkley Laboratory and US Navy to use our CNEM-MD approach to recover a bio aviation fuel product isoprenol. Another commercial potential of CNEM-MD technology is in solvent recycling. We have been in advanced talks with a major waste processing company to run pilot testing for recovery of isopropyl alcohol and ethylene glycol in its plant. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? R&D activities carried out during the reporting period and significant results achieved under the specific objectives are described below: CNEM Development: (1) Several porous membranes were evaluated by liquid entry pressure (LEP), water contact angle and flux measurements. (2) Different CNT (carbon nanotube) coating formulations comprising of solvent and polymeric binder was made on trial-and-error basis and the stability of the dispersion were studied using dynamic light scattering (DLS) technique to evaluate the fabrication time line. (3) PTFE membrane and CNT coated PTFE membrane were characterized with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and thermogravimetry (TGA). (4) The effect of membrane pore size on ethanol recovery performance was studied experimentally on a bench scale CNEM-MD system. (5) The influence of forms of CNT functionalization was studied experimentally. Ethanol recovery via CNEM-MD: (1) Spiral wound CNEM modules were fabricated using a fully functional spiral wound module fabrication facility at NanoSepex. (2) A lab-pilot CNEM-MD system was developed and built at Nanosepex facility. (3) A series of experiments were conducted on the lab pilot system to verify the effectiveness of the CNEM-MD process for ethanol recovery from its aqueous solution. Effects of process parameters including feed inlet temperature, feed flow rate, sweep air flow rate were studied. (4) Experimental studies were carried out using the lab-pilot CNEM-MD system to recover ethanol from CO2 scrubber waste samples provided by a biofuel manufacturer. System configuration and design for maximizing recovery: We have developed a simulation tool that allows us to predict CNEM-MD process outcomes under different operation conditions (feed concentration, temperature, flow rate, etc.). Integration with existing biofuel separation systems such as thermal distillation and pervaporation: We studied the feasibility of integrating CNEM-MD with pervaporation. The results showed high separation factor that can generate pure (99%) ethanol at low flux. A dense membrane is needed to synthesize the CNEM membranes and the process would be difficult to scale up in our laboratory. Since the flux of pervaporation system was low, it would require large membrane modules. The technique does not appear viable for commercial scale manufacturing by NanoSepex at this time as it would also need additional investments. Also. it does not appear to be attractive at this point according to customer discovery. A concentrated ethanol stream generated by CNEM-MD can be integrated with thermal distillation. This we believe is the best way to enter the biofuel refining market to gain acceptance.

Publications