Source: PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to
AGRICULTURAL SCIENCE IN ELEMENTARY EDUCATION - LEARNING IN GARDENS AT SCHOOL (AG SEED-LINGS)
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
NEW
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025688
Grant No.
2021-67037-34297
Project No.
PENW-2020-08618
Proposal No.
2020-08618
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
A7501
Project Start Date
Mar 1, 2021
Project End Date
Feb 28, 2025
Grant Year
2021
Project Director
Hill, K.
Recipient Organization
PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
408 Old Main
UNIVERSITY PARK,PA 16802-1505
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
This program provides the necessary framework for elementary school teachers to help their students understand the content and practices of pollinator research, in the areas of food, agriculture, and natural resources. Reforms in K-12 STEM teaching recommend using the practices of scientists to teach concepts in science. However, teachers often lack the ability to generate science learning opportunities that do not involve simply leading students through linear, stepwise exercises, which contrasts with the actual dynamic, interactive work of scientists. We will use the USDA Strategic Goal of "Food Security", particularly the crucial role of ecosystems services of pollinators on food production, to provide this framework. We will recruit elementary teachers from rural and urban communities that work with underserved populations to co-develop and test science curriculum at the K-1, 2-3, and 4-5 grade bands. This curriculum will involve hands-on activities in school gardens and yards and be integrated with other subject areas important in elementary teaching. We will develop and offer a hybrid (in person/remote) professional development program for 16 elementary teachers, engaging them in activities using the practices of pollinator research accessible to young learners. Teachers will be subsequently supported as they engage students in these practices-based, integrated projects, refining the curriculum as needed. Finally, additional modules will be created to offer a fully online version of the professional development program. The tested and validated elementary curriculum from this project will be disseminated broadly to multiple communities through conferences for agricultural professionals and educators and posted through our online learning portal.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
90330101130100%
Goals / Objectives
This program provides the necessary framework for elementary school teachers to help their students understand the content and practices of pollinator research, in the areas of food, agriculture, and natural resources. Reforms in K-12 STEM teaching recommend using the practices of scientists to teach concepts in science. However, teachers often lack the ability to generate science learning opportunities that do not involve simply leading students through linear, stepwise exercises, which contrasts with the actual dynamic, interactive work of scientists. We will use the USDA Strategic Goal of "Food Security", particularly the crucial role of ecosystems services of pollinators on food production, to provide this framework. We will recruit elementary teachers from rural and urban communities that work with underserved populations to co-develop and test science curriculum at the K-1, 2-3, and 4-5 grade bands. This curriculum will involve hands-on activities in school gardens and yards and be integrated with other subject areas important in elementary teaching. We will develop and offer a hybrid (in person/remote) professional development program for 16 elementary teachers, engaging them in activities using the practices of pollinator research accessible to young learners. Teachers will be subsequently supported as they engage students in these practices-based, integrated projects, refining the curriculum as needed. Finally, additional modules will be created to offer a fully online version of the professional development program. The tested and validated elementary curriculum from this project will be disseminated broadly to multiple communities through conferences for agricultural professionals and educators and posted through our online learning portal.The following goals will guide the design, implementation and evaluation of the AG SEED-LINGS program: (1) increase elementary teachers' and students' understanding of science practices (e.g., analyzing and interpreting data) related to pollinator research; (2) prepare elementary teachers to engage their students in classroom projects that parallel the PDs' pollinator research as it applies to issues of food production; (3) increase elementary teachers' and students' understanding of agricultural science concepts (e.g., life cycles, adaptations) underlying plant-pollinator research; and (4) increase elementary teachers' awareness of available resources available for engaging students in practices related to pollinator research.
Project Methods
The AG SEED-LINGS program will initially engage with a small cohort of teachers to develop integrated K-5 curricula and then transitions to offer a hybrid model of PD (partially in-person and partially online) followed by fully online PD programming. These workshops and online modules will be designed to address content and approaches employed by a research group and to prepare teachers to engage their students in age-appropriate classroom research projects. Initially, we will partner with STEM researchers (faculty and graduate students) with a cohort of up to 5 elementary (K-5) teachers from rural and urban schools serving underrepresented and underserved students. Using the researcher-practitioner partnership approach (Penuel et al., 2015), CSATS faculty and pollinator researchers in collaboration with the elementary teachers will co-develop curricula to engage students in integrated activities associated with plant-pollinator studies. In the following year, we will use a hybrid approach to offer a series of online modules focused on the pollinator-related curriculum and in-person workshops to engage up to 16 elementary teachers in targeted science practices. Finally, we will complete the development of the online resources to provide remote PD programming to support an additional 30 elementary teachers in learning and implementing the integrated curriculum. Teachers will be able to progress through the modules at their own pace with access to the AG SEED-LINGS team to ask questions and acquire feedback. All teachers participating in the PD programming will be able to receive continuing education hours required by the Pennsylvania Department of Education.Five elementary teachers will be recruited from the collaborating school districts to co-construct the AG SEED-LINGS curriculum that will engage young students in pollinator research in three distinct settings: (1) outdoors in the school garden and/or landscape, (2) in the classroom/lab, and (3) on the computer, using age-appropriate computational tools. With teachers from all grade bands, work will be conducted to ensure alignment with standards and vertical alignment in line with learning progressions set forth in NGSS. With support from the project team, these teachers will test and refine the curriculum in their classrooms with students.A hybrid PD program will be developed and implemented with up to 16 elementary teachers, with preference given to teachers from schools with high percentage of low socio-economic status students and to multiple teachers from the same school district. Teachers will complete a series of online modules and conduct readings about pollinator research prior to attending a 3-day in-person workshop at Penn State University Park campus. A dedicated website will be created for the AG SEED-LINGS program. With content provided by the project team, an instructional designer will develop and organize the online modules. In addition, a model developer will make improvements to the NetLogo Honey Bee Colony Collapse model (Huang, 2015). During the 3-day workshop, teachers will hear from PDs and graduate students from CPR about their research followed by conducting activities in the field, in the classroom, and on the computer that include similar science practices. Video footage of the 3-day workshop activities will be captured, edited, and used in the creation of additional online modules. Finally, a fully online PD program will be developed and offered to 30 teachers who were not able to participate in the hybrid program. With additional curricular-focused content and video footage, a complete series of online modules will be hosted on the AG SEED-LINGS website and made available for teachers to complete at each of the three grade-band levels (K-1, 2-3, and 4-5). These modules will be structured such that teachers engage with the content and practices on their own (as a student) followed by modules that support them to incorporate the curriculum into their classrooms with students (as the teacher). Additionally, we will develop a discussion board on the AG SEED-LINGS website to enable teachers to share findings from classroom implementation of the curriculum and solicit advice from the project team and each other on challenges they may be facing. This portal also provides another mechanism for research faculty and graduate students to share their research updates and provide support for classroom implementation. This website will be managed by project staff and will extend beyond funded life of the grant, serving as a data resource for monitoring the lasting influence of the AG SEED-LINGS program on K-5 teachers.

Progress 03/01/22 to 02/28/23

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience you describe should include only those that your efforts reached during the current reporting period; this may mean that the audiences you list are only a subset of all those you included on your projects initiation. Target audiences include individuals, groups, market segments, or communities that will be served by the project. Where appropriate, you should also identify population groups such as racial and ethnic minorities and those who are socially, economically, or educationally disadvantaged. Efforts include acts or processes that deliver science-based knowledge to people through formal or informal education programs. Examples include: formal classroom instruction, laboratory instruction, or practicum experiences; development of curriculum or innovative teaching methodologies; internships; workshops; experiential learning opportunities; extension and outreach. The target audience for the pilot implementation of the AG SEED-LINGS curriculum was elementary teachers from a school district near Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and a school district near State College, Pennsylvania. School District Number of teachers Black or African American (%) Hispanic (%) Multi-race (%) White (%) Economically disadvantaged (%) Aston Elementary School 3 3.76 4.8 3.76 84.76 23.8 Coeburn Elementary School 4 5.73 3.44 4.87 80.52 27.8 Parkside Elementary School 3 18.05 4.33 6.14 67.87 35.74 Pennell Elementary School 3 1.48 2.96 0.74 91.85 15.8 Penns Valley Elementary and Intermediate School 2 0 0.47 0.47 98.83 37.09 Changes/Problems:I am requesting a no-cost budget realignment to support the success of the project: Faculty in the Penn State College of Education will be fulfilling the work of developing and building the online modules. Remove purchase services and add monies to salaries to enable Penn State faculty to build the online modules and continue to improve the pollinator model. Stephanie Klixbull and Kit Martin are trained in the Articulate 360 platform to build the online modules. Kit Martin will continue to improve the pollinator model in NetLogo. The cost for housing teachers on campus during the workshop has nearly doubled. In addition, we have received many applications from teachers who are interested in attending the AG SEED-LINGS summer workshop, however, many of these teachers are not located within a commutable distance to Penn State University Park campus. I plan to adjust the budget to cover the increased costs of housing for participants coming from a distance. Also, increase the participant costs to cover the expenditures for 12 teachers to travel to State College, PA. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In summer 2022, professional development and training was provided to four elementary teachers regarding plant-pollinator research. Elementary teachers in Penn-Delco and Penns Valley school districts were provided with an introduction to the AG SEED-LINGS curriculum for grades K through 5. These teachers will be piloting the curriculum in their classrooms in the spring 2023. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period, we plan to: Pilot the AG SEED-LINGS elementary curriculum at Penn-Delco schools. Make improvements to the AG SEED-LINGS elementary curriculum based upon feedback from the pilot at Penn-Delco schools. Develop online modules that will support the 2023 summer workshop. Develop and implement the hybrid summer teacher workshop with teachers in grades K-5. Develop additional modules for the virtual workshop in summer 2024.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal 1: Increase elementary teachers' and students' understanding of science practices (e.g., analyzing and interpreting data) related to pollinator research. Four teachers who are co-leading the curriculum development were identified and engaged in two days of activities related to pollinator research. The first day occurred in May of 2022 while the second day occurred in July of 2022. Teachers visited the pollinator garden at the Arboretum and engaged in pollinator observations and a habitat assessment on the first day. For the second day, the teachers were paired with graduate students from the Center for Pollinator Research to engage in field activities related to the graduate students' research. In the summer of 2022, we also developed a NetLogo model and associated teacher and student guides designed for 5th and 6th grade students to understand how pollinator gardens can support pollinators. The pollinator model and guides were used in two 6th grade science classes as a pilot. Students engaged in the practice of using models to understand relationships between plants and pollinators. In addition, the students used the graphical output of the model to make claims about the relationship between flower color and particular pollinators. Goal 2: Prepare elementary teachers to engage their students in classroom projects that parallel the PDs' pollinator research as it applies to issues of food production. In July of 2022, teachers spent an additional two days with the AG SEED-LINGS team to develop classroom research project plans. These plans were designed to engage students in science practices from the two days of research experiences. Outline of Workshop Activities: Day 1: Review of program goals Pennsylvania's new science standards Review of Field Day Activities Share Available Resources Outdoor Education Activities Grade-Level Curriculum Development Work Day 2: Grade-Level Curriculum Development Work Goal 3: Increase elementary teachers' and students' understanding of agricultural science concepts (e.g., life cycles, adaptations) underlying plant-pollinator research. Teachers visited the Arboretum to learn about plant-pollinator relationships. The teachers also participated in a research field day with graduate students from the Center for Pollinator Research. The concepts underlying plant-pollinator research were then supported by Pollinator researchers during the curriculum development sessions that occurred in July of 2022. Using the NetLogo model and associated teacher and student guides designed for 5th and 6th grade, students increased their understanding of how pollinator gardens can support pollinators. We observed 6th grade students in two science classes use the model. The teacher introduced the lesson by having students write in science journals, "How are pollinators connected to what we have learned in class so far this year?" Example student responses: Growth/reproduction of cells Classification of animals Reproduction In small groups students collaborated on "what they know about pollinators?" Example student responses: Seed dispensing Collecting pollen Pollinators and plants have a working relationship and benefit each other. Honey is "bee barf" The teacher then introduced the student guide for the whole group discussion and gave students an overview of basic pollination education to be able to navigate using the model. The teacher presented about living communities of pollinators and threats to pollinators. The teacher led the whole group in setting up a garden in the model with particular flower colors and particular pollinators. The students observed the model run for a set period of time and then recorded their observations in their science journals. Student responses: "Bees only went for yellow." "Bees went for magenta as well but mostly yellow. You can tell by the chart." Teacher had students collaborate and decide on one variable to change in scenario 1. The teacher discussed "preferencing of flower color" with pollinators. Students as a class decided to run scenario 1 again but plotting all colors except yellow and magenta to observe if pollinator (bees) would change their preference. Students observed that when scenario 1 was run again, the bees did not pollinate and thus there were no new flowers. Goal 4: Increase elementary teachers' awareness of available resources for engaging students in practices related to pollinator research. During the two days of curriculum development in the Summer of 2022, the teachers were shown a collection of available resources for engaging students in practices related to pollinator research. These resources came from the Penn State Center for Pollinator Research, the Penn State Center for Science and the Schools, Shaver's Creek, and other identified USDA projects. In the summer of 2022, we also developed a NetLogo model and associated teacher and student guides designed for 5th and 6th grade students to understand how pollinator gardens can support pollinators. During the classroom observation, we identified areas of improvement for the model and the curriculum guides. Both the model and guides were updated to make these improvements. In the fall of 2022, we developed pollinator-plant curriculum for grades K through 5. As part of the curriculum development, classroom resources were identified and obtained to create multiple curriculum kits for each grade level such that the agricultural science integrated with appropriate levels of math and language arts.

Publications


    Progress 03/01/21 to 02/28/22

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Seven teachers were identified toco-leading the curriculum development for grades K-6. Two of the three school districts have student populations that are approximately 50% economically disadvantaged. These teachers were not able to engage in professional development sessions during the academic year due to school district restrictions from the COVID-19 pandemic. Changes/Problems:The curriculum develop and implementation plans have been delayed due to COVID-19 pandemic. Schools have not been able to release teachers to attend professional development resulting from teacher fatigue and substitute teacher shortages. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We willhold professional development sessions with the teachers in May and June 2022. Teachers will visitthe pollinator garden at the Arboretum and engagin pollinator observations and a habitat assessment. The teachers will be paired with graduate students from the Center for Pollinator Research to engage in field activities related to the graduate students' research.Curriculum development sessions will be held in July and August 2022.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Seven teachers were identified toco-leading the curriculum development for grades K-6. Two of the three school districts have student populations that are approximately 50% economically disadvantaged. These teachers were not able to engage in professional development sessions during the academic year due to school district restrictions from the COVID-19 pandemic.

    Publications