Source: NORTHERN ARIZONA UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
CULTURALLY RESPONSIVE FORESTRY CURRICULUM DEVELOPMENT FOR NATIVE-SERVING SCHOOLS UNDER CHANGING CLIMATE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025681
Grant No.
2021-67037-34300
Cumulative Award Amt.
$300,000.00
Proposal No.
2020-08776
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Mar 1, 2021
Project End Date
Feb 28, 2026
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[A7501]- Professional Development for Agricultural Literacy
Recipient Organization
NORTHERN ARIZONA UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
FLAGSTAFF,AZ 86011
Performing Department
School of Forestry
Non Technical Summary
: The proposed program will provide immersive professional development opportunities for K-12 teachers in Native-serving schools to develop culturally responsive curriculum units in the food, agricultural, natural resources, and human (FANH) sciences. We will be utilizing the proven best practices of professional development programs for teachers and structure of the Institute for Native-serving Educators (INE), which is a partnership between Northern Arizona University and Native-serving K-12 teachers in the southwestern United States. The model developed here is self-sustaining as it builds upon a successful national educational model already in place in Navajo-serving schools and will be institutionally maintained beyond the life of this grant. We will offer four year-long seminars for the topics chosen by K-12 teachers. Forests, natural resources, and climate change were among the top topical areas that previous INE teachers identified. Teachers will develop curricular materials through multi-grade and cross-content-area collaborative groups (Teacher Fellow cohort), which will be led by university faculty, working professionals, and tribal elders. We will ensure immersive learning experiences for K-12 teachers in INE each year through at least three in-person full-day workshops, one 10-day residential program on the NAU campus during the summer, and the end of year Annual Conference. The expected outcomes among K-12 teachers are higher morale, greater collegiality and collaboration among teachers, improved content knowledge and instruction, greater use of culturally responsive curricular materials, increased teacher retention and performance - all of which will lead to higher student achievements.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
9036099302050%
1230699107050%
Goals / Objectives
The proposed program will provide immersive professional development opportunities for K-12 teachers in Native-serving schools to develop culturally responsive curriculum units in the food, agricultural, natural resources, and human (FANH) sciences. The near-term programming will focus on forests, natural resources, and environment, which can be expanded to other areas in FANH after the project's first two years. Increasing agricultural literacy among Native-serving K-12 teachers and Indigenous students supports all AFRI Farm Bill Priority areas, but the proposed program is particularly relevant to the area of "Bioenergy, natural resources, and environment." The target participants are K-12 teachers in Native-serving schools in the Southwestern United States (Figure 1). The professional development model developed here is self-sustaining as it builds upon a successful national educational model already in place in Navajo-serving schools and will be institutionally maintained beyond the life of this grant. Specific objectives are to:1) develop culturally responsive and academically rigorous FANH curricular materials through multi-grade and cross-content-area collaboration among Native-serving K-12 teachers, university faculty, and working professionals;2) build teacher-developed instructional units, including teaching strategies for combining in-person and online activities, and share innovative instructional practices among teachers in Native-serving schools;3) leverage existing knowledge among Indigenous youth, teachers, elders, and communities to empower teacher growth and foster the mutually beneficial exchange of cultural and content knowledge among partners;4) enhance and expand culturally responsive FANH curriculum offered in Native-serving schools throughout the Southwestern U.S. and beyond.
Project Methods
The teacher-driven professional development approach focuses on developing long-term, active teaching and learning strategies to deliver culturally responsive content knowledge aligned to local and state standards. Teachers will be drawn from the school districts within the existing DINÉ partnership in years 1 and 2, and we will expand the partnerships to other tribal communities in years 3 and 4 (Figure 1). Teacher Fellows participate in a seminar cohort, read and learn about the topic in partnership with the faculty member, and ultimately develop a personalized curriculum unit that they use in their own classroom. The curriculum units are aligned to local, state, and tribal standards. The curriculum units will be preserved and made accessible through INE website and NAU's institutional repository (IR), OpenKnowledge@NAU. so that other teachers can access them, thus increasing the potential impact each unit can have. Faculty seminar leaders will also work closely with Elders/Traditional Knowledge Scholars at NAU, and we will bring in additional Elders as needed to ensure that the K-12 teachers are engaging the content from both western/mainstream science perspectives and Indigenous knowledge perspectives. We have set aside funding for this important learning experience with Elders. We will also integrate guest lectures by working professionals in FANH fields, especially those who are tribal members. Participation by tribal elders and working professionals from tribal and public land management agencies will enrich the seminar discussions and also help develop future opportunities for further engagement (i.e., school visits, field trips, and shadowing/mentoring opportunities).We will offer the following topics for years 1 and 2, which will be refined for years 3 and 4 with input from participating teachers and other stakeholders. The seminar topics are:Forests and Climate Change. This seminar will be led by PD Kim and co-PD Martin in year 1 for K-12 teachers in Navajo-serving schools. The topic will be revised/refined with input from the year 1 participants and offered again in year 3 to K-12 teachers in other Native-serving schools. This topic lends itself to the DINÉ/INE's professional development model of multi-disciplinary learning and multi-age relevance. Changing the Earth's climate is already impacting everyday lives of tribal members, especially in rural Indigenous communities that rely more directly on forests and rangeland resources. This highly relevant topic also provides ample opportunities to engage active learning strategies aligned to local and state STEM standards. The year-long seminar will cover a range of topics in FANH sciences, such as 1) understanding role of forests in the Earth's climate processes, carbon cycle, and greenhouse gas effects; 2) climate change impacts on forest conditions, natural disturbance regimes and ecosystem services; 3) relevance of traditional ecological knowledge for modern forest management; 4) economics and policies of managing forests and rangeland resources under changing climate at regional, national and global scales. PD Kim has been teaching an introductory freshman-level course in environmental science online, as well as upper-level courses in forest economics and policies in-person at NAU over 20 years. She will offer up-to-date content knowledge, as well as strategies and resources for teaching online, and share her research experiences for conserving forest ecosystem services in tribal forests and tropical developing countries. Co-PD Martin will provide culturally responsive content knowledge from his personal background as a Diné tribal member and extensive professional experiences from over 30 years as a forester for the Navajo Nation and the Bureau of Indian Affairs. We will also utilize the research labs on NAU campus, as well as the Centennial Forest, which is NAU's research, teaching, and demonstration forest of nearly 50,000 acres, and the field camp.Wildlife, plants, and habitats of the Southwest. This seminar will be led by co-PD Fulé and co-PD Martin in year 2 for K-12 teachers in Navajo-serving schools and revised topics will be offered again in year 4 to teachers in other Native-serving schools. This topic addresses interesting and critically important elements of the natural environment, drawing on academic areas of biology, earth science, geography, and cultural studies. We will explore the main habitat types across the elevational gradients of southwestern landscapes, looking at key species of plants and animals. The ecological linkages of food webs, predator-prey relationships, and traditional and modern interactions of Indigenous people with plants and animals will be explored. The design of the seminar will open opportunities for teachers to develop individualized lessons for their students in FANH sciences. The role of domestic animals such as sheep and horses will also be placed in the habitat context. Social elements will include traditional cultural relationships with animals and plants, as well as policy issues such as protection for endangered species and adapting management to changing climate. The seminar will be organized by habitat type in the following categories: (1) Low elevation landscapes characterized by river valleys, grasslands, and deserts; (2) Mid elevation landscapes with pinyon and juniper woodlands, and canyon country; (3) High elevation landscapes with mountain ranges and forests, and headwaters of major rivers. Key species will be presented and participating teachers will be encouraged to add focal species from their own tribal communities. Co-PD Fulé has taught numerous courses with related content aimed at non-majors over many years at NAU and teaching abroad. He will share his research experience on several tribal lands in the Southwest. Co-PD Martin will provide culturally responsive content knowledge from his extensive professional and personal experiences as described above. We will also have short outdoor activities at the Centennial Forest at NAU as well as accessible tribal landscapes close to the sites of seminar meetings, such as the Navajo Nation Forest on the Defiance Plateau near Window Rock or the Chuska Mountains near Tsaile.

Progress 03/01/24 to 02/28/25

Outputs
Target Audience:We are engaged with a group of Native-serving educators (K-12) through the DINÉ seminar sponsored by Northern Arizona University. These educators in AZ and NM are learning from our seminar "Taking care of the land with traditional ecological knowledge". Changes/Problems:There was a delay associated with the unexpected passing of the original PD, Dr. Yeon-Su Kim. We have received a no-cost extension to carry out all four seminars originally proposed. All other elements of the project remain on track. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?PD Fulé attended PDAL PD meeting at USDA NIFA in Kansas City, April 3-5, 2024. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results in the form of completed curriculum units are posted on the INE website https://in.nau.edu/ine/. Annual showcase events every December highlight the accomplishments of teacher fellows. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We are working on the 2025 DINÉ seminar. We received a no-cost extension through 2/28/2026.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We are currently working in the fourth seminar for K-12 teachers who are building curricular units. Accomplishments to date: DINÉ Seminar 2021, led by Kim and Martin (Title: Forests and Climate Change) DINÉ Seminar 2022, led by Fulé and Martin (Title: Wildlife, plants, and habitats of the Southwest) DINÉ Seminar 2024, led by Fulé and Martin (Title: Taking Care of the Land with Traditional Ecological Knowledge) DINÉ Seminar 2025, led by Fulé, Martin, and Saxena (Title: Engaging Ways of Knowing with Forests and Global Change, in progress) Partial support for Native-serving teachers expenses

Publications


    Progress 03/01/23 to 02/29/24

    Outputs
    Target Audience:We are engaged with a group of Native-serving educators (K-12) through the DINÉ seminar sponsored by Northern Arizona University. These educators in AZ and NM are learning from our seminar "Taking care of the land with traditional ecological knowledge". Changes/Problems:There was a delay associated with the unexpected passing of the original PD, Dr. Yeon-Su Kim. We will be requesting a no-cost extension to carry out all four seminars originally proposed. All other elements of the project remain on track. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?PD Fulé attended PDAL PD meeting at USDA NIFA in Kansas City, April 3-5, 2024. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results in the form of completed curriculum units are posted on the INE website https://in.nau.edu/ine/. Annual showcase events every December highlight the accomplishments of teacher fellows. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We are completing the 2024 DINÉ seminar. We will be submitting a no-cost extension request later this year to use the remaining funds for a final seminar in 2025.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? We are currently working in the third seminar for K-12 teachers who are building curricular units. Accomplishments to date: DINÉ Seminar 2021, led by Kim and Martin (Title: Forests and Climate Change) DINÉ Seminar 2022, led by Fulé and Martin (Title: Wildlife, plants, and habitats of the Southwest) DINÉ Seminar 2024, led by Fulé and Martin (Title: Taking Care of the Land with Traditional Ecological Knowledge. In progress) Partial support for Native-serving teachers expenses

    Publications


      Progress 03/01/22 to 02/28/23

      Outputs
      Target Audience:We continued as in 2021-2022 to use the proven best practices of teacher professional development programs and structure of the Dine Institute for Navajo Nation Educators (DINE). We recruited 15 K-12 teachers teaching in schools within or adjacent to the Navajo Nation to participate in a year-long seminar (described below). Seven teachers completed their curriculum units and taught their units in their classrooms. Their final products are shared through the NAU DINE website for other teachers to access and use in their classrooms: https://in.nau.edu/ine/curricula-resources/. As previously, we were also able to work with the San Carlos Apache Tribe´s TLSI - Teacher Leadership Shilgozhoo Institute. Changes/Problems:The original PD of this project, Dr. Yeon-Su Kim, passed away tragically and unexpectedly in November, 2022. We mourn her loss. Co-PD Fule was transferred to become the PD. No seminar was offered in 2023. However, we have two years remaining in the project and two more seminars to offer, so we remain on track. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?During the intensive summer residency and meetings on the Navajo Nation, K-12 teachers developed understanding of culturally responsive schooling, as well as the content knowledge related to wildlife, plants, and habitat. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Seven teachers completed their curriculum units and taught their units in their classrooms. Their final products are shared through the NAU DINE website for other teachers to access and use in their classrooms. One middle-school teacher, K. Etsitty, brought about 30 of her students to visit the School of Forestry at NAU in May, 2023. These students may be motivated to study natural resources in the future. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We are continuing the program for next year with different group of teachers from the Navajo Nation and the San Carlos Apache Tribe.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We offered a year-long seminar called Wildlife, plants, and habitats of the Southwest. This seminar was led by PD Fule and co-PD Martin for K-12 teachers in Navajo-serving schools. The seminar started with orientation in March, continue with intensive summer engagements, including a two-week residency on the NAU campus in June 2022 and numerous meetings on the Navajo Nation. The seminar ended with the showcase and open house for the NAU DINE and all INE programs in December, 2022.

      Publications


        Progress 03/01/21 to 02/28/22

        Outputs
        Target Audience:Target audiences: Using the proven best practices of teacher professional development programs and structure of the Diné Institute for Navajo Nation Educators (DINÉ), we recruited initially 12K-12 teachers teaching in schools across the Navajo Nation to participate in a year-long seminar (described below). Nineteachers completed their curriculum units and taught their units in their classrooms. Their final products are shared through the NAU DINE website for other teachers to access and use in their classrooms. https://in.nau.edu/dine/dine-fellows-curriculum-units/ We were able to work with the San Carlos Apache tribe and will be launching a program just like DINÉ, for teachers in the San Carlos Unified School District. The program is called the SCUSD Teacher Leadership Shi?gozhóó Institute. We are currently recruiting K-12 teachers in the district to participate. Efforts We offered a year-long seminar, Forests and Climate Change. This seminar was led by PD Kim and co-PD Martin for K-12 teachers in Navajo-serving schools. The seminar started with orientation in March, continue with intensive summer engagements, including bi-weekly meetings, as well as three weekend residencies in the NAU Flagstaff Campus, and multiple drafts of curriculum units revised by the teachers based on the seminar leaders' feedbacks. The seminar ended with the showcase and open house for the NAU DINE, which the President and the First lady of the Navajo Nation, as well the NAU President attended. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?During the intensive summer engagements, including bi-weekly meetings, as well as three weekend residencies in the NAU Flagstaff Campus, K-12 teachers developed understanding of culturally responsive schooling, as well as the content knowledge related to forests and climate change. This project also offered the project team, PD and co-PDs professional development opportunities. For example, PD Kim was a visiting faculty at the Yale-New Haven Teachers Institute, which is part of the Yale National Initiative for strengthening teaching in public schools (intensive online engagement in July 6-10, 2020) and is serving on the University Advisory Council (UAC) for DINÉ/INE. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Nine teachers completed their curriculum units and taught their units in their classrooms. Their final products are shared through the NAU DINE website for other teachers to access and use in their classrooms. https://in.nau.edu/dine/dine-fellows-curriculum-units/ What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We are continuing the program for the second year with different group of teachers from the Navajo Nation and expanding the program to San Carlos Apache Reservation.

        Impacts
        What was accomplished under these goals? We have achieved parts of all four objectives above. We provided immersive professional development opportunities for nine K-12 teachers across the Navajo Nation to develop culturally responsive curriculum units and share teaching strategies for combining in-person and online activities, and share innovative instructional practices among teachers. We are continuing the program for the second year with different group of teachers from the Navajo Nation and expanding the program to San Carlos Apache Reservation.

        Publications