Source: COLORADO STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
DIVERSITY, DISTRIBUTION AND HOST RESISTANCE TO EMERGING VIRUSES AND VIROIDS OF HEMP
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025618
Grant No.
2021-68008-34136
Cumulative Award Amt.
$299,451.00
Proposal No.
2020-04954
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jan 15, 2021
Project End Date
Jan 14, 2024
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[A1701]- Critical Agricultural Research and Extension: CARE
Recipient Organization
COLORADO STATE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
FORT COLLINS,CO 80523
Performing Department
Agricultural Biology
Non Technical Summary
As the production of hemp increases across the Unites States, so have the challenges in disease management. The long-term goal of the following proposal is to develop robust and effective diagnostic tools for early pathogen detection in hemp, provide a basic understanding of epidemiology of hemp diseases and identify disease mitigation strategies. Our proposal responds directly to the research identified by hemp growers, hemp industry, diagnostic labs, researchers and other stakeholders, as well as directly addresses program priority for Plant Health and Production and Plant Products.The goals of the project will be accomplished by three objectives: 1) characterize the diversity and distribution of viruses and viroids of hemp using high-throughput sequencing technologies and identify insect vectors associated with pathogens in hemp, 2) identify host resistance to viruses and viroids in elite hemp germplasm, and 3) develop outreach and education materials that can be disseminated to hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers and other stakeholders. Findings from this research will be distributed via several mechanisms: through the Hemp Disease website hosted at the Hemp Resource Center at Colorado State University. Results will be communicated by posters, extension factsheets and scientific publications. Presentations at Advisory committee meetings, field days, pest management professionals meeting, Agricultural Extension Service (AES) meetings, and two annual webinars at the National Plant Diagnostic Network (NPDN). By responding to need of hemp growers and by directly involving them in the research plans and distribution of findings, this proposal integrates research, education and extension.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
21217301101100%
Knowledge Area
212 - Pathogens and Nematodes Affecting Plants;

Subject Of Investigation
1730 - Hemp;

Field Of Science
1101 - Virology;
Goals / Objectives
The long-term goal of the following proposal is to develop robust and effective diagnostic tools for early pathogen detection in hemp, provide a basic understanding of epidemiology of hemp diseases and identify disease mitigation strategies.The short-term goals include (1) identifying the diversity and distribution of viruses and viroids of hemp using next generation sequencing (NGS), (2) identifying potential insect vectors associated with viruses and viroids in hemp, and (3) screening a diverse hemp germplasm set for virus resistance. Our findings will then be disseminated as outreach and education materials aimed at growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnosticians, and researchers in academia.
Project Methods
Objective 1:Characterize the diversity and distribution of viruses and viroids of hemp and identify potential insect vectors.Methods/Techniques.Hemp tissue collection and processing.Plant tissue samples of early stages of propagation (3 weeks) to advanced vegetative growth (6 weeks) to plants that are in full flowering (14 weeks) will be collected from two fields each, spanning four hemp-producing regions in Colorado (Western Slope, Front Range, Southeast, and Southwest regions). Samples will consist of leaves of at least ten plants from two different hemp cultivars per location. Samples will be catalogued based on location, cultivar, and symptoms. Approximately 100 mgof leaf tissue will be used for RNA isolation. Total RNA will be isolated from 480 samples (3 trips/year x 10 plants/ trip x 2 cultivars x 2 farms x 4 locations) using commercially available kits per the standard manufacturer's protocol. Samples from each cultivars and farm will be pooled resulting in total of 48 samples (4 samples/trip x 3 trips/year x 4 locations). RNA will be quantified using a Nanodrop spectrophotometer.Bioinformatic analysis.Virus and virus-like sequences will be identified using a well-established protocol. Candidate virus sequences will be manually validated by aligning reads to draft genome assemblies. Phylogenetic trees will be constructed to reveal the relationships of identified viruses and viroids with other known isolates using the ClustalW software program. Then, analysis of SNPs for the viruses and viroids from assembled virome data will be performed using the Tablet software program to determine genetic diversity. Lastly, raw sequence data will be deposited in the Sequence Read Archive (SRA) repository and the annotated viromes obtained from the study will be deposited in GenBank at NCBI. These results will help in the identification of specific targets for development of efficient diagnostic tools.Insect collection and identification.Insect sampling will be performed in the same hemp fields as the hemp virome survey (describe above) in year 1 and 2. Insect diversity and abundance will be determined by collecting 100 180-degree sweeps with a sweep net. A sub-set of insects will be preserved in 90% ethanol and brought back to the lab where they will be identified using taxonomic keys. Specifically, we are interested in potential vector species such as aphids, leafhoppers, planthoppers, and thrips. By analyzing viruses and viroids identified in the virome analysis and the potential insect vectors collected from the same fields, we can infer virus-vector relationships.Objective 2: Identify host resistance to viruses and viroids in elite hemp germplasm.Methods/Techniques. Hemp germplasm. The NWG germplasm is built on a diverse group of over 50 founder lines include high-cannabinoid clonal and feminized seed strains widely available in the U.S. along with dioecious industrial hemp grain cultivars developed primarily in the European Union and China.Field experiments. Field experiments will be conducted at one of NWG breeding field sites located in the Front Range/Larimer county (See Letter of Support). A seed drill will be used to plant at a depth of approximately 2.5 cm, with a target plant density of 120 plants m-2 (Campbell et al., 2019). Seeding rates will be increased from that target density proportional to germination rates among cultivars. No herbicides or pesticides will be applied during either growing season. Irrigation will be delivered by overhead sprinkler irrigation in the amount of 203 mm (Campbell et al., 2019). Weather data will be obtained from the Colorado Agricultural Meteorological network and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration National Climatic Data Center. To account for climatic variability, the screening will be performed in two consecutive years (year 1 and 2).Plot experimental design. The experiment will comprise of 30 different elite lines, planted in a randomized complete block design with three replications/plots. Each plot will comprise of 30 plants planted in 6 row that are 6.1 m in length with approximately 0.25 m spacing between rows. Natural infection of pathogens will be used to inoculate plants.Data collection. At each of the growth stages (early vegetative, advanced vegetative and flowering stage), plants with visible symptoms will be photographed. To quantify virus incidence (% of plants infected plants out of total plants) and virus level (titer), leaf samples will be collected from all 30 plants representing a single cultivar per plot. All leaves per plot/replication (3 plots/replications/ x 30 cultivars) will be stacked and a small section of tissue was cut from the center of the stack. Total RNA will be performed as described above and virus titer will be quantified using reverse-transcriptase-quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR). At maturity, plant biomass will be measured as the mass of the aboveground portion of all the plants in a plot. Plants will be cut at the soil surface and air-dried for a minimum of 30 days. The plants will then be weighed before threshing. Grain yield and CBD levels from each plot will be provided by NWG, who will perform the processing and testing.Diagnostic RT-qPCR. To identify virus resistance in hemp cultivars, diagnostic Reverse-Transcriptase-quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) analysis will be performed to quantify virus titer. Based on results of the virome analysis (preliminary data in Table 1 and Objective 1), we will analyze 5-6 high priority or key pathogens (most prevalent, potential to cause losses).Objective 3: Develop outreach and education materials that can be disseminated to hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers and other stakeholders.Methods/Techniques. Hemp Disease Website and Social Media. The Hemp Disease Website will serve as a centralized repository for all extension and outreach materials (posters, factsheets publications, etc.) and to receive feedback from stakeholders. The website will be hosted at the CSU Hemp Resource Center website (http://hemp.agsci.colostate.edu/).Meetings. A second means of distributing information is through in-person meetings. The principal investigators will meet with Advisory committee comprising of grower participants and industry representative twice a year to discuss research progress and outreach needs. The CSU Extension service workshops, field days, pest management professionals meeting, CSU Agricultural Extension Service (AES) meetings (specific dates in Timeline) will also be used as means to disseminate information. Researchers will present project findings at professional meetings such as Entomological Society of America (ESA) Pacific and North Central branch meetings and annual meetings, the American Phytopathological Society (APS) branch meeting and annual meetings and the National Hemp Research & Education conferences.Publications. Lastly, information will be communicated via extension and scientific publications. Outreach materials will include state-specific extension factsheets, local newsletter articles, popular press articles, posters and presentations at regional and national meetings/field days will be deposited in the Hemp Disease website. Additionally, two annual webinars will be delivered to a diverse audience to highlight project findings. Specifically, information about diagnostics and protocols will be conveyed to other diagnostic laboratories through the National Plant Diagnostic Network newsletter, meetings and webinars. CO-PI Fulladolsa, Director of the Plant Diagnostic Clinic at CSU will lead these efforts.

Progress 01/15/21 to 01/14/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The key stakeholders were hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers. and other stakeholders. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have trained one MS student, Laine Hackenberg who is leading the research and one undergraduate student, Max Schmidtbauer, who assists the graduate student. Both students have been trained in hemp tissue RNA extraction, insect assays and virome analysis. The MS student, Laine will defend her thesis in February and the undergraduate student has joined the lab for his PhD working on NIFA-OREI funded project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?In Colorado, there has been a dedicated Research/Extension effort to identify arthropod pest and pathogen management needs associated with hemp production and to engage growers since 2015. This involvement has steadily expanded each year and in 2018 included growers in 10 Colorado counties. All information developed regarding hemp insects has been posted for use on the Hemp Insect Website at Colorado State University. This has included a series of illustrated fact sheets, frequently updated, to describe all resident arthropods that are associated with hemp. We used three main channels by which this information was disseminated: 1) Hemp Insect Website, 2) in-person meetings, and 3) publications. The Hemp Insect Website serves as a centralized repository for all extension and outreach materials (posters, factsheets publications etc.) and to receive feedback from stakeholders. The website is hosted at the CSU Hemp Resource Center website (http://hemp.agsci.colostate.edu/). We published an Extension factsheet- Beet leafhopper and beet curly top virus. 2020. Contributed data on field testing of samples, sequencing of BCTV strains and vector information. Factsheet by Whitney Cranshaw.https://webdoc.agsci.colostate.edu/hempinsects/PDFs/Curly%20Top%20Beet%20Leafhopper%202020.pdf We developed a narrated PowerPoint presentations for YouTube distribution, involving key information about this virus. A second means of distributing information was through presentations at field days, pest management professionals meeting, CSU Agricultural Extension Service (AES) meetings. Researchers will present project findings at professional meetings and the National Hemp Research & Education conference. Lastly, information was communicated via extension and scientific publications. The national research and extension community was reached through presentations at national and international conferences. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. identifying the diversity and distribution of viruses and viroids of hemp using next generation sequencing (NGS) Completed tissue collection from at 3 different timepoints- early vegetative, advanced vegetative, mature flowering from Northeastern and Western locations. Completed hemp metavirome analysis from the abovementioned locations. Asthe growing season progressed, virus incidence and diversity increased. Interestingly, it can be observed that viruses with known seed transmission such as cannabis cryptic and cannabis sativa mitovirus are present from the beginning of the growing season, while viruses that can be vectored by insects such as alfalfa mosaic virus and beet curly top virus appear later in the season. Each region has its own unique virome, but the most prevalent viruses detected across all regions were beet curly top virus, cannabis sativa mitovirus and grapevine line pattern virus, all being detected in 3 out of the 4 regions. 2. identify host resistance to viruses and viroids in elite hemp germplasm Completed screening 13 hemp genotypes for beet curly top virus (BCTV), the most predominant virus identified in hemp and identified three resistant lines.To determine if hemp lines exhibit resistance to BCTV, a screening was performed utilizing 13 genetically unique lines of hemp. There was a statistically significant difference in viral load (log copy number) between lines resulting from a one-way ANOVA (F=2.228; df=12; P=0.0207). Percent disease index (PDI) was also evaluated, PDI was calculated by the following formula PDI = (d/n)x100% where d is equal to the number of BCTV infected plants per line and n is equal to the total number of plants per line. Differences between individual lines' PDI were evaluated by comparing the proportion of infected and uninfected plants from an individual line, to the total number of infected and uninfected plants from the other lines. There were two lines that stood out by having a statistically significantly lower PDIs, line 4587 (p-value 0.04617) and line 4710 (p-value = 0.04617) utilizing Pearson's Chi-Squared test. Additionally, there was a strong correlation observed between average log copy number per line and PDI utilizing a Spearman's rank correlation rho (S=88.419, P=0.00273, rho=0.7570896). 3. develop outreach and education materials that can be disseminated to hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers, and other stakeholders. Outreach and education were fully integrated into our project at each step of development and execution of the objectives. Diverse and numerous multimedia and presentation strategies were used to reach our most diverse stakeholders. We targeted hemp producers, as well as crop advisors, crop consultants, extension personnel and hemp industry personnel (seed, genetics) with a variety of digital and traditional media. We used three main channels by which this information was disseminated: 1) Hemp Insect Website, 2) in-person meetings, and 3) publications. The Hemp Insect Website serves as a centralized repository for all extension and outreach materials (posters, factsheets publications etc.) and to receive feedback from stakeholders. The website is hosted at the CSU Hemp Resource Center website (http://hemp.agsci.colostate.edu/). We published an Extension factsheet- Beet leafhopper and beet curly top virus. 2020. Contributed data on field testing of samples, sequencing of BCTV strains and vector information. Factsheet by Whitney Cranshaw. https://webdoc.agsci.colostate.edu/hempinsects/PDFs/Curly%20Top%20Beet%20Leafhopper%202020.pdf. We developed a narrated PowerPoint presentationfor YouTube distribution, involving key information about this virus. A second means of distributing information was through presentations at field days, pest management professionals meeting, CSU Agricultural Extension Service (AES) meetings. Researchers will present project findings at professional meetings and the National Hemp Research & Education conference. Lastly, information was communicated via extension and scientific publications. The national research and extension community was reached through presentations at national and international conferences.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Under Review Year Published: 2024 Citation: A multiplex RT-PCR for the detection of three viruses and one viroid infecting hemp. Derrick J. Grunwald, Jacob MacWilliams, Laine Hackenberg, Sydney Stroschein, Renee Rioux, Punya Nachappa, and Shelby Ellison. Phytofrontiers.


Progress 01/15/22 to 01/14/23

Outputs
Target Audience:Hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers and other stakeholders. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have trained one MS student, Laine Hackenberg who is leading the research and one undergraduate student, Max Schmidtbauer, who assists the graduate student. Both students have been trained in hemp tissue RNA extraction, insect assays and virome analysis. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? The Green Screen: Using Top Viruses and Viroids Identified in the Hemp Virome to Screen Hemp Germplasm for Resistance. Laine Hackenberg, Marylee L. Kapuscinski, Mark Stenglein and Punya Nachappa.Joint ESA meeting in Vancouver (Nov 2022). Invited speaker at Hemp/cannabis pest management at the Joint ESA meeting in Vancouver (Nov 2022). Invited speaker at the Science of Hemp Conference at UKY (Nov 2022) Presented and local arrangements organizer of Western Hemp IPM working group meeting, Fort Collins (Nov 2022) Invited speaker at 2022 Gangwon Green Bio International Symposium at Seoul, South Korea (Sept 2022) Invited speaker at the Institute of Cannabis Research webinar (Apr 2022) Invited speaker at 10th International IPM Symposium (Mar 2022) 2022 Wild wild west: Emerging viruses and viroids of hemp. Department of Horticulture and Landscape Architecture, Colorado State University, Spring Seminar Series. 2022 Wild wild west: Emerging viruses and viroids of hemp. Department of Entomology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Spring Seminar Series. 2022 Emerging viruses and viroids of hemp.Pest Management in the Inter Mountain West Meeting. November 18, Fort Collins, CO What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next reporting period, we expect to: Spring 2022- Extract RNA and perform sequencing for hemp virome analysis from Northeastern and Western locations Spring 2022- Perform bioinformatic analysis of virome data Summer 2022- Sample collection from Southeast and Southwest locations Fall 2022- Extract RNA and perform sequencing for hemp virome analysis from Southeast and Southwest locations Summer/Fall 2022- Continue screening for virus resistance in F2 hemp genotypes Publish research findings on the Hemp Disease website

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. Identifying the diversity and distribution of viruses and viroids of hemp using next generation sequencing (NGS) Completed tissue collection from at 3 different timepoints- early vegetative, advanced vegetative, mature flowering from Northeastern and Western locations. Completed insect collection from hemp fields but identification is not complete. 2. Identify host resistance to viruses and viroids in elite hemp germplasm Completed screening 30 hemp genotypes for beet curly top virus, the most predominant virus identified in hemp. 3. Develop outreach and education materials that can be disseminated to hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers and other stakeholders. Research findings have been disseminated to various stakeholders at different venues including Departmental seminars at Kansas State University and University of Wyoming and at the Pest Management in the Intermountain West Meeting. Lastly, I organized a symposium on titled Key Pest and Disease Threats in Industrial Hemp in Cannabis Research Conference. Hosted by the Institute of Cannabis Research at Colorado State University Pueblo, in partnership with The Hemp Innovation Center of Oregon State University

Publications

  • Type: Book Chapters Status: Awaiting Publication Year Published: 2022 Citation: Jordan Withycombe, Max Schmidtbauer, Jacob MacWilliams and Punya Nachappa. CHAPTER 05-03.1: Beet curly top virus (BCTV). In Compendium of Cannabis Diseases. Edited by N. W. Gauthier and L. D. Thiessen Laine Hackenberg, Jacob MacWilliams, and Punya Nachappa. CHAPTER 05-06.1: Hop latent viroid (HLVd). In Compendium of Cannabis Diseases. Edited by N. W. Gauthier and L. D. Thiessen


Progress 01/15/21 to 01/14/22

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience aregrowers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnosticians and researchers in academia.growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnosticians and researchers in academia. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have trained one MS student, Laine Hackenberg who is leading the research and one undergraduate student, Max Schmidtbauer, who assists the graduate student. Both students have been trained in hemp tissue RNA extraction, insect assays and virome analysis. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?2021 Punya Nachappa, Key Pests and Diseases of Colorado. Pest Management in the Intermountain West Meeting, Virtual meeting. 2021 Punya Nachappa, Wild wild west: Emerging viruses and viroids of hemp. Department of Entomology Spring Seminar Series, Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS. 2021 Punya Nachappa, Wild wild west: Emerging viruses and viroids of hemp. Department of Microbiology, Immunology and Pathology CVID Seminar Series, Colorado State University 2020 Punya Nachappa, Wild wild west: Emerging viruses and viroids of hemp. Department of Plant Sciences Fall Seminar Series, University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY. Punya Nachappa (Chair), Adrianna Szczepaniec and Ana Cristina Fulladolsa co-organized a symposium titled Key Pest and Disease Threats in Industrial Hemp in Cannabis Research Conference. Hosted by the Institute of Cannabis Research at Colorado State University Pueblo, in partnership with The Hemp Innovation Center of Oregon State University, on August 3-5th, via the virtual conference platform, Morressier. The symposium featured 11 research presentations. Fulladolsa, A.C. 2021. Colorado hemp seed certification program. Annual WERA1007 Virtual Meeting. Fulladolsa, A.C. 2022. Nanopore sequencing for pathogen detection in specialty crops (included an example of virome work in hemp). 2022 CO Fruit and Vegetable Growers Association Annual Meeting. Denver, CO Reynoso, M., Joshi, J., and Fulladolsa, A.C. 2022. Fusarium diseases of industrial hemp. CSU Extension Factsheet. (in preparation) What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next reporting period, we except to- Spring 2022- Extract RNA and perform sequencing for hemp virome analysis from Northeastern and Western locations Spring 2022- Perform bioinformatic analysis of virome data Summer 2022- Sample collection from Southeast and Southwest locations Fall 2022- Extract RNA and perform sequencing for hemp virome analysis from Southeast and Southwest locations Summer/Fall 2022- Continue screening for virus resistance in F2 hemp genotypes Publish research findings on the Hemp Disease website

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. identifying the diversity and distribution of viruses and viroids of hemp using next generation sequencing (NGS) Completed tissue collection from at 3 different timepoints- early vegetative, advanced vegetative, mature flowering from Northeastern and Western locations. Completed insect collection from hemp fields but identification is not complete. 2. identify host resistance to viruses and viroids in elite hemp germplasm Completed screening 30 hemp genotypes for beet curly top virus, the most predominant virus identified in hemp. 3. develop outreach and education materials that can be disseminated to hemp growers, industry agronomists, crop consultants, diagnostic labs, researchers and other stakeholders. Research findings have been disseminated to various stakeholders at different venues including Departmental seminars at Kansas State University and University of Wyoming and at the Pest Management in the Intermountain West Meeting. Lastly, I organized a symposium on titled Key Pest and Disease Threats in Industrial Hemp in Cannabis Research Conference. Hosted by the Institute of Cannabis Research at Colorado State University Pueblo, in partnership with The Hemp Innovation Center of Oregon State University

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2021 Citation: Chiginsky J, Langemeier K, MacWilliams J, Albrecht T, Cranshaw W, Fulladolsa AC, Kapuscinski M, Stenglein M and Nachappa P (2021) First Insights Into the Virus and Viroid Communities in Hemp (Cannabis sativa). Front. Agron. 3:778433. doi: 10.3389/fagro.2021.778433