Source: UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
DYNAMICS OF THE GUT MICROBIOME RESPONSE TO DIETARY INTERVENTION WITH ANTHOCYANIN-RICH FOODS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025356
Grant No.
2021-67018-33938
Cumulative Award Amt.
$199,819.00
Proposal No.
2020-04437
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 1, 2021
Project End Date
Apr 30, 2024
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[A1343]- Food and Human Health
Recipient Organization
UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
LOGAN,UT 84322
Performing Department
Animal Dairy & Veterinary Scie
Non Technical Summary
Anthocyanin (ACN)-rich functional foods are thought to suppress gut inflammation and may reduce risk of colitis-associated colorectal cancer via direct action at the gut epithelium or via modulation of the gut microbiome. However, pre-clinical studies investigating these ACNs are typically idealized in their design, employing long-term, consistent dietary exposures and rarely considering dynamic shifts in the gut microbiome. Thus, there remains a critical knowledge gap regarding the dynamic response of the gut microbiome to dietary interventions with ACN-rich foods with experiment designs that more appropriately emulate common ways in which humans consume these food items. In this seed grant proposal, our primary objective is to map the dynamic response of the mouse gut microbiome to varying-length dietary supplementation with functional foods with diverse ACN profiles. Our experimental approach will address these important research questions: 1) How quickly will the gut microbiome respond to dietary intervention with ACN-rich foods as defined by a shift in relative abundance of specific taxa or changes in a- or b-diversity? 2) How long will shifts in microbiome composition persist after consumption of the ACN-rich food ceases? 3) Is the structure of the dominant ACNs in these foods deter­minative of shifts in microbiome composition? Successful completion of this seed project will generate robust data in support of our planned AFRI standard proposal to compare the efficacy of varied dietary intervention strategies (consistent, varying by source, or varying by duration) with individual or mixtures of ACN-rich foods in both mouse and human disease models.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
70238401010100%
Goals / Objectives
Anthocyanin (ACN)-rich functional foods are thought to suppress gut inflammation and may reduce risk of colitis-associated colorectal cancer via direct action at the gut epithelium or via modulation of the gut microbiome. However, our review of the most up-to-date literature revealed that no study to date has examined the dynamic response of the gut microbiome to dietary interventions with ACN-rich foods, nor has a meticulous comparison of the impact of foods with varying ACN content on microbiome composition been performed. Furthermore, the dietary intervention strategies typically employed in pre-clinical animal models are ideal­ized and do not mimic the intermittent intakes of varied ACN-rich functional foods that is much more likely and more easily achieved in humans with a general dietary shift to a polyphenol-rich diet. Pre-clinical diet intervention studies are typically limited in several key features: 1) typified by idealized designs em­ploying consistent feeding of the same functional food or bioactive; 2) the assumption that changes in the gut micro­biome induced by such dietary interventions are persistent; and 3) the assumption that changes in the rodent microbiome will mirror that for humans. Thus, there remains a critical knowledge gap regarding the dynamic response of the gut microbiome to dietary interventions with ACN-rich foods with experiment designs that more appropriately emulate common ways in which humans consume these food items. The long-term goal of the broader project this seed grant will support is to understand the dynamic response of the gut microbiome to varied duration interventions with functional foods, with the anticipated outcome being more robust recommendations for effective dietary strategies to suppress gut inflammation in patients with irritable bowel disease (IBD) or those at risk for colitis-associated colorectal cancer (CAC).To accomplish this goal, we must first determine the dynamics of the gut micro­biome response in a systematic, controlled feeding study with various ACN-rich food items. Therefore, in this seed grant proposal, our primary objectiveis to map the dynamic response of the mouse gut microbiome to varying-duration dietary supplementation with functional foods with diverse ACN profiles. Our approach will address three important research questions: 1) How quickly will the gut microbiome respond to dietary intervention with ACN-rich foods as defined by a shift in relative abundance of specific taxa or changes in a- or b-diversity? 2) How long will shifts in microbiome composition persist after con­sumption of the ACN-rich food ceases? and 3) Is the structure of the dominant ACNs in these foods deter­minative of shifts in microbiome composition? The approach will include a controlled mouse feeding study employing seven selected ACN-rich fruits, provided as freeze-dried whole fruit powders, including black currant, bilberry, elderberry, red raspberry, strawberry, chokeberry, and black raspberry. The diets will be standardized to deliver the same total ACN content as in our prior work with black raspberry (see pre­liminary data below). The study design includes varying duration of dietary intervention (1, 3, or 7 days) and assessment of the fecal microbiome composition by 16s rRNA sequencing and pro­duction of short-chain fatty acids at varying timepoints after intervention ceases (0, 1, 3, or 7 days). Our working hypotheses are as follows: 1) The gut microbiome will be rapidly responsive to interventions with ACN-rich foods; 2) Continued intake of those foods will be necessary to sustain substan­tial changes in the composition of the gut microbiome; 3) Structural differences of the major ACNs in the food powders will drive differences in gut microbiome composition as reflected in beta diversity scores and significant differences in particular taxa; and 4) Changes in the composition of the microbiome will be accompanied by variations in the production of short-chain fatty acids, suggestive of func­tional metabolic impacts of dietary interventions with ACN-rich foods. Successful completion of this seed project will generate robust data in support of our planned AFRI standard proposal to compare the efficacy of varied dietary intervention strategies (consistent, varying by source, or varying by duration) with individual or mixtures of ACN-rich foods in both mouse and human disease models.
Project Methods
Five week-old male and female mice will be fed experimental diets containingFive week-old male and female mice will be obtained from Jackson Laboratories (Bar Harbor, ME) and housed at the Laboratory Animal Resource Center (LARC) vivarium in the Bio­Innovations Center at Utah State University. Male and females will be distributed evenly across all treatment groups, and mice will be housed singly to avoid confounding by cage-effects. We do not expect a difference in microbiomes by sex in healthy mice, though our future studies should consider differences in sex as IBD is diagnosed more frequently in women than men. Following one week in quarantine, all mice will be fed the control total Western basal diet (TWD) for 14 days, then the experimental diets (listed below) for 1, 3, or 7 total days, and then switched back to the TWD for 7 additional days (see attachment "Scheme"). After each intervention period, fresh fecal samples will be obtained immediately (0d), or 1, 3, or 7 days after the experimental diet ceases.The study design includes seven ACN-rich foods, each with a distinct anthocyanin (ACN) profile, listed below.Experimental diets:a. Control total Western diet (TWD)b. Black raspberry (BRB)c. Black currant (BC)d. Chokeberry (CB)e. Bilberry (BB)f. Elderberry (EB)g. Red raspberry (RR)h. Strawberry (SB)Foods will be obtained as freeze-dried powders directly from the supplier, and a sample of each lot will be sent to the Food Composition Labor­atory at the Linus Pauling Institute, Oregon State University, for chemical analysis of phenolics and ACNs. Given our past experience employing a 10% (w/w) BRB-supplemented diet, we intend to benchmark all of the ACN-rich fruit diets to match its total ACN content. The BRB whole fruit freeze-dried powder was measured by HPLC to consist of 6.94% (w/w) total phenol­ics and 3.72% (w/w) total ACNs. A 10% (w/w) BRB diet delivers approximately 1.3 mg ACNs per mouse per day (3.5 g food/day), which scales to 444 mg for human daily intake, or about 1.1 servings (¾ power metabolic rate method for allometric scaling, assuming 25 g mouse and 60 kg human). We have sourced the other fruit powders from similar companies, including Artemis International and Northwest Wild Foods (see attachment "ACN foods"). In the event that the desired ACN content (~0.5 mg ACN/g diet) cannot be achieved with the whole food powder, we would explore the use of an ACN-rich extract preparation and similarly validate its ACN profile by testing at the Linus Pauling Institute. Alternatively, other ACN-rich foods may be considered, such as tart cherry, cranberry, or blueberry. Supplements will be shipped to Envigo for incorporation into the experimental diets, and appropriate adjustments will be made to match energy density (adjusted for sugar content) and total fiber content.Fecal samples will be collected throughout the study, and the gut microbiome composition will be determined by standard 16s rRNA sequencing.

Progress 05/01/21 to 04/30/24

Outputs
(N/A)

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? This study investigated the impact of anthocyanin (ACN)-rich functional foods on the mouse gut microbiome's response over time and examined how ACN structural diversity influenced microbiome composition. We hypothesized that the microbiome would respond rapidly to ACN-rich food intake, with ongoing consumption essential for lasting changes in composition, and that distinct ACN profiles of food powders would influence microbiome diversity and specific taxa. We conducted a multifactorial experiment with C57BL/6J male mice, testing eight diets across exposure durations of 1, 3, or 7 days and measuring responses at baseline, 0, 1, 3, or 7 days post diet exposure. Mice were housed individually and fed a Western diet supplemented with 2 g/kg of anthocyanins (ACN) from freeze-dried powders or extracts of bilberry (BB), tart cherry (TC), chokeberry (CB), elderberry (EB), black currant (BC), and black raspberry (BRB), 2 g/kg of cocoa polyphenols (CP) or no supplement (CON). Fecal microbiome samples were collected at baseline and after diet cessation at specified response intervals for 16S rRNA sequencing analysis. Alpha diversity significantly changed in mice fed the BB diet (evenness) and EB, BC, BB, or CP diets (richness), regardless of exposure duration or response time. Interestingly, for BRB, TC, and EB diets, day 0 alpha diversity spiked above baseline, but this response was not maintained through days 1-7. Similarly, unweighted unifrac beta diversity showed significant, yet transient, shifts in the fecal microbiome for BRB, BC, EB, or TC diets, with changes fading by day 1 (BC) or day 3 (EB, BRB, TC). This observation suggests a possible structure-activity relationship, where foods rich in cyanidin-3-O-glucoside or cyanidin-3-O-rutinoside altered the microbiome profile, unlike those high in cyanidin-3-galactoside (CB and BB). This study confirmed that ACN-induced microbiome changes do not persist after consumption of the ACN-rich food ceases. Furthermore, despite equal anthocyanin concentrations in the ACN-supplemented diets, the varied ACN profiles prompted distinct microbiome responses, suggesting a potential structure-activity relationship.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2021 Citation: Presentations: Benninghoff, A. (Presenter & Author), Rodriguez, D. (Author Only), Hintze, K. J. (Author Only), American Council on Medicinally Active Plants 10th Annual Conference, "Dynamics of the gut microbiome in response to dietary intervention with black raspberries in the context of a standard or Western type diet in a mouse model of inflammation-associated colorectal cancer," Virtual. (June 24, 2021 - June 25, 2021)


Progress 05/01/22 to 04/30/23

Outputs
Target Audience:global scientific community Changes/Problems:As noted above, some samples required resequencing, which was successful. One challenge is the extraordinarily expansive dataset and complicated analyses of a three-factor experiment. Data analyses is predicted to take longer than anticipated. Yet, the final dataset and analyses should be very informative. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One graduate student, Mohammed Almatani, is overseeing this work as part of his dissertation research. He has participated in several professional development workshops (research presentations, data management, etc.) and other trainings offered at USU. He has also mentored three undergraduate students who worked in the laboratory to assist in the sample processing. Additionally, in the past year, three undergraduate students worked as laboratory research assistants on this project, where they learned about experiment design, animal husbandry (working with available sentinel mice), study management, animal necropsy (working with available sentinel mice), data analysis and presentation preparation. Students also learned bench life science skills through the preparation of fecal samples for high-throughput sequencing. All students interacted closely with the PI through weekly meetings or one-on-one appointments, and these students worked very closely with other research personnel, including other graduate students. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Not yet applicable. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The remainder of the project period will include analyses of the resulting microbiome profiles and preparation of a publication detailing the findings.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? As of this report, we have completed the animal study with the diverse anthocyanin-rich foods (black raspberries, bilberries, black currant, chokeberries, tart cherry, and elderberries) with cocoa polyphenol as a non-anthocyanin comparison group. Per the experiment design, more than 700 fecal samples were collected; these were processed according to our standard operating protocol and then subject to 16s rRNA sequencing. The resulting data sets were processed using Qiime2 and mapped to the Silva database to determine the taxa present in these samples. Initial review of the sequencing results indicated that about 10% of samples required reprocessing and/or resequencing to obtain the necessary sequencing depth. This resequencing has been completed, and the final data set processed via Qiime2 with mapping to Silva. Analyses of the resulting microbiome profiles using Microbiome Analyst is ongoing.

Publications


    Progress 05/01/21 to 04/30/22

    Outputs
    Target Audience:global scientific community Changes/Problems:Based on the anthocyanin profile of the fruit powders, six anthocyanin-rich powders were selected for this animal study including bilberry, tart cherry, chokeberry, elderberry, black currant and black raspberry. Anthocyanin content of red raspberry and strawberry fruit powders was too low to use in this experiment without chemical extraction, a method not applied to any of the other fruit powders. Thus, one of these fruits was replaced by tart cherry, which did have a substantially high anthocyanin concentration by our testing. For the last experimental group, we selected a food item that would have a vastly different polyphenol profile than the others, cocoa polyphenols, with the expectation of a strong contrast in microbiome response. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One graduate student, Mohammed Almatani, is overseeing this work as part of his dissertation research. She has participated in several professional development workshops (research presentations, data management, etc.) and other trainings offered at USU. He attended the American Society of Nutrition conference in June 2022, which was held as a virtual conference. Additionally, in the past year, three undergraduate students worked as laboratory research assistants on this project, where they learned about experiment design, animal husbandry (working with available sentinel mice), study management, animal necropsy (working with available sentinel mice), data analysis and presentation preparation. Students also learned bench life science skills through the preparation of fecal samples for high-throughput sequencing. All students interacted closely with the PI through weekly meetings or one-on-one appointments, and these students worked very closely with other research personnel, including other graduate students. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Not yet applicable. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The animal study is planned for summer 2022, with microbiome analyses following during the fall 2022 term. Data analysis and reporting will conclude in spring 2023.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? As of this report, we have performed polyphenol analyses via HPLC of eight different fruit powders reportedly high anthocyanin content, including black raspberries, bilberries, black currant, red raspberries, strawberries, chokeberries, and tart cherry. The anthocyanin content varied greatly, from 0.037% (w/w) for strawberry to 18.1% for a standardized bilberry powder from Artemis-International. Profiling also identified the major anthocyanin chemical components, which were compared to the USDA polyphenol database. Subsequently, the food powders were subject to composition analyses for determination of carbohydrate, protein, fat and fiber content. With these data, the experimental diets were formulated in partnership with a nutrition scientists at Envigo. As of this report, diets were in preparation, with the animal study to be performed during the summer 2022. During this time, students have also worked on the microbiome analysis methodology to optimize for high throughput analyses. Students have also learned analytical approaches for microbiome datasets using practice datasets.

    Publications

    • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2021 Citation: Presentations Benninghoff, A. (Presenter & Author), Rodriguez, D. (Author Only), Hintze, K. J. (Author Only), American Council on Medicinally Active Plants 10th Annual Conference, "Dynamics of the gut microbiome in response to dietary intervention with black raspberries in the context of a standard or Western type diet in a mouse model of inflammation-associated colorectal cancer," Virtual. (June 24, 2021 - June 25, 2021)