Source: AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH SERVICE submitted to NRP
DECIPHERING THE GENETIC AND MOLECULAR BASIS OF GREEN CURD TRAIT IN CAULIFLOWER
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1025341
Grant No.
2021-67013-33841
Cumulative Award Amt.
$500,000.00
Proposal No.
2020-03404
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jan 15, 2021
Project End Date
Jan 14, 2026
Grant Year
2021
Program Code
[A1103]- Foundational Knowledge of Plant Products
Recipient Organization
AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH SERVICE
10300 BALTIMORE AVE
BELTSVILLE,MD 20705
Performing Department
Robert W Holley Center
Non Technical Summary
Cauliflower is a healthy cruciferous vegetable, enriched in vitamins, fiber, and phytonutrients with numerous nutritional and health benefits. While all economically important types of cauliflower produce edible white heads or curds, there are colored varieties. These colored cauliflowers not only enhance visual appeal with beautiful hues, but also add nutritional and health values. Moreover, they provide interesting and unique genetic resources to study the basis of color formation as well as nutrient and phytonutrient accumulation.Green cauliflower results from chloroplast development in the otherwise white curd. Since chloroplast is the site for many nutrient and phytonutrient biosynthesis and accumulation, green cauliflower provides additional health benefits comparing to white curd cauliflower. However, the causal gene and how it induces chloroplast development in the curd tissue are unknown. Recently, via QTL-seq analysis and fine genetic mapping, we identified a major genomic region containing a few best candidates for the Green gene (Gr). The proposed research aims to clone the Gr gene and understand how it controls chloroplast development. Three specific objectives are proposed: 1) to confirm the identity of Gr via phenotypic complementation, 2) to characterize the Gr gene, and 3) to uncover its regulatory mechanisms in mediating chloroplast development and concomitantly nutrient accumulation. The proposed research is expected to discover a new gene and new mechanisms in controlling chloroplast development in plants. The new gene and fundamental knowledge generated can be translated into new genetic tools and strategies to produce more nutritious crops, beneficial to human nutrition and health. The proposed research addresses the Program Area Priority of "Foundational Knowledge of Plant Products (A1103)".
Animal Health Component
20%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
80%
Applied
20%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
20614401040100%
Knowledge Area
206 - Basic Plant Biology;

Subject Of Investigation
1440 - Cole crops;

Field Of Science
1040 - Molecular biology;
Goals / Objectives
The major goals of this proposed research are to clone the Green (Gr) gene responsible to the green curd trait in cauliflower and to decipher its genetic and molecular basis in regulating chloroplast development for developing more nutritious crops.Objectives:Objective 1: Functional confirmation of the Gr gene via phenotypic complementation Our previous studies identified a few best candidates. In this Objective, we aim to confirm the identify of Gr via phenotypic complementation of curd color in cauliflower and in Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant that gives "curd-like" structure resembling cauliflower curd. Overexpression of the best candidates and CRISPR-Cas9 knockout of the endogenous candidate genes will be carried out to identify the gene that complements the phenotype in cauliflower curd and in Arabidopsis "curd-like" structure of ap1-1 cal-1 mutant.Objective 2. Molecular and microscopic characterization of the Gr geneIn this Objective, we will characterize the Gr gene to gain insights into better understanding of its role in conferring the green curd trait and in mediating chloroplast development. We will investigate the spatial expression pattern of Gr in various tissues of cauliflower, associate its expression with curd color in a germplasm collection of cauliflower, examine chloroplast numbers in various tissues of representative accessions, and discover the potential cause by analyzing the difference between the white and green alleles of Gr.Objective 3. Dissection of the regulatory mechanism of Gr in mediating chloroplast development Since none of the candidates is known to regulate chloroplast development, Gr represents a novel regulator in initiating chloroplast development. Gr is important as its variant promotes or abolishes chloroplast formation in cauliflower curd tissue. In this Objective, we will identify Gr-interacting proteins via several alternative and complementary strategies, which include yeast two-hybrid cDNA library screening, co-immunoprecipitation coupled with mass spectrometry analysis, and Gr protein association network analysis. We will also investigate how such interaction or the Gr-interacting protein(s) regulates chloroplast development to give the green curd phenotype in cauliflower.
Project Methods
Objective 1: Functional confirmation of the Gr gene via phenotypic complementation To functionally confirm the identity of the Gr gene, first, the candidate CDS from green cauliflower will be overexpressed in white curd cauliflower. The CDS will be cloned into the binary vector pGWB17 and transformed along with vector-only into a white cauliflower cultivar by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. We will also use CRISPR-Cas9 technique to knock out the endogenous Gr gene in a green curd cauliflower. In addition, the overexpression construct will be transformed into the Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant plants by floral dipping method. We will also knock out the Arabidopsis endogenous gene in the ap1-1 cal-1 mutant using the egg cell-specific promoter-controlled CRISPR/Cas9 system in pHEE401E-mCherry vector. The positive transgenic lines will be visually examined for color changes in curd or curd-like structure, and their chlorophyll and carotenoid pigment content will be analyzed by UPC2. If overexpression gives green curd in the white cauliflower or greener curd-like structure in Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant, and knockout gives white curd in the green cauliflower cultivar or white/lighter green curd-like structure in Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant, the results will functionally confirm the isolation of the Gr gene and provide evidence for its potential application.Objective 2. Molecular and microscopic characterization of the Gr gene The spatial expression pattern of the Gr gene in various tissues of green and white cauliflower cultivars will be examined by qRT-PCR. We will order and use more germplasm collection of cauliflower to examine their gene expression by qRT-PCR. The analysis will test out the association of Gr transcript levels with curd color to reveal its specific role in controlling the green trait. In addition, we will examine the chloroplast numbers from 10 white and 10 green curd varieties under confocal microscopy to test whether Gr also promotes chloroplast formation in other tissues in addition to curd of cauliflower. Moreover, we will clone and analyze the promoters and gene sequences from five green and white curd varieties to reveal the possible causes of difference between the green and white alleles of Gr. To test whether the promoter sequence variations alter promoter activity, the promoters of both green and white alleles will be fused to GUS gene and transformed into Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant. The GUS activity will be examined. The Gr-G:GUS and Gr-W:GUS transgenic Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 plants will also be examined to see whether the overall Gr-GUS expression pattern recapitulates the Gr gene expression pattern in cauliflower.Objective 3. Dissection of the regulatory mechanism of Gr in mediating chloroplast development To isolate the Gr-interacting proteins, a green curd cauliflower Y2H library will be constructed. The full-length ORF of Gr will be used as the bait for the library screening using the Matchmaker Gold Yeast Two-Hybrid System according to the manufacturer's instructions. The prey plasmids from positive clones will be extracted and sequenced. When multiple clones encode the same genes, they represent good candidates. As a complementary strategy, co-immunoprecipitation coupled with mass spectrometry analysis will be carried out. The transgenic lines generated in Objective 1 for phenotypic complementation in cauliflower or in Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant produce Myc-tagged proteins. Total proteins will be extracted from curd tissues and then immunoprecipitated with anti-Myc agarose beads. The co-immunoprecipitated proteins from these transgenic lines will be identified by mass spectrometry analysis. The proteins repeatedly identified from Gr transgenic lines but absence in pGWB17 vector-only control in 3-4 biological repeats represent good candidates of Gr-interacting proteins. In addition, protein-protein association network analysis will provide other level of complementary strategy for potential candidates. Proteins found in two or three alternative approaches will represent the best candidates for verification and functional study.To validate direct and specific interactions between Gr and the best interacting candidates, additional approaches commonly used to examine protein-protein interactions will be utilized. For the candidates isolated from Y2H library screening, their interactions with Gr in yeast will be further confirmed by β-galactosidase activity assay. For the candidates identified from co-immunoprecipitation/mass spectrometry analysis and protein association network analysis, Y2H analysis will first be carried out. Those confirmed interactions will be further analyzed by pull-down assay. Bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assay will also be carried out in N. benthamiana leaves to further examine their interactions in vivo and the subcellular localization of their interactions.To confirm the involvement of the interacting proteins in the Gr-mediated chloroplast development, we will overexpress and suppress the genes encoding the identified proteins either in cauliflower or in Arabidopsis ap1-1 cal-1 mutant, and examine their effects on chloroplast development in the curd or "curd-like" structure as described in Objective 1. Molecular and biochemical characterization of the interacting partners will be carried out, such as gene expression pattern by qRT-PCR, protein subcellular localization by fusing with GFP, and effect on chloroplast development when time allows.

Progress 01/15/24 to 01/14/25

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One undergraduate and two postdoctoral research associates were involved in this project. The project provided training in plant genetics, molecular biology and biochemistry analyses. It also offered the opportunity for developing skills with effective scientific communications by presenting findings in writing and verbal presentations. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Oral presentation of "Genetic factors and mechanisms underlying phytonutrient carotenoid accumulation in crops". The International Plant & Animal Genome PAG 32 Conference, San Diego, CA January 10-15, 2025 What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will proceed with our ongoing experiments to achieve the set objectives.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During the past year, we further examined various cauliflower genotypes with green and white curd colors for pigment content and for sequence difference of the candidate gene for Gr. The study confirmed that the two distinct alleles encode proteins differing by a single amino acid substitution in the chloroplast transit peptide (cTP) region and the addition of one amino acid in the mature protein between white and green cauliflower genotypes. To investigate the function of Gr, we generated transgenic lines overexpressing either the white or green allele of the cauliflower Gr gene in the backgrounds of Arabidopsis ap1/cal mutant which forms green, curd-like meristem structures and of Arabidopsis Gr homolog mutant that gives severely retarded growth and pale-yellow phenotype. We observed greener phenotype in ap1/cal mutant expressing the green allele of the cauliflower Gr gene comparing to expressing the white allele, which also functionally confirmed the identity of Gr. Furthermore, we observed that overexpression of the green allele successfully rescued the phenotype of Arabidopsis Gr homolog mutant, whereas the white allele did not. These findings support the role of Gr in chlorophyll accumulation. The Gr protein was reported to be involved in plastid pyrimidine metabolism to regulate chloroplast development. We have previously demonstrated that Gr influences protein levels rather than transcription. To further investigate the reason behind the higher protein accumulation in the green allele compared to the white allele, we are conducting an in vitro phosphorylation assay. Specifically, we aim to determine whether the green allele exhibits greater phosphorylation activity than the white allele. This experiment is currently underway. In addition, the Gr protein was reported to impact RNA metabolism which in turn influences chloroplast transcription. To investigate this, we performed RNA-Seq and Ribo-Seq (ribosome profiling) analyses on white and green cauliflower curds, as well as on Arabidopsis transgenic lines expressing the white and green Gr alleles. These experiments aim to uncover differences in translation rate between these samples. These experiments are currently in progress, and we expect to identify notable differences.

Publications

  • Type: Other Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2025 Citation: Sun T, Hazra A, Lui A, Zeng S, Wang X, Rao S, Owens L, Fei Z, Zhao Y, Mazourek M, Giovannoni JJ, Li L (2025) GLKs directly regulate carotenoid biosynthesis via interacting with GBFs in in plants. New Phytologist accepted


Progress 01/15/23 to 01/14/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The output of this research would benefit agricultural, horticultural and biological scientists following revealing novel genes and molecular mechanisms, which regulate chloroplast biogenesis in agronomically important crops. Breeders may also utilize such information to generate novel germplasms with more appealing visual as well as more nutrients associated with chloroplast development, which would consequently benefit the general public as consumers. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One undergraduate and one postdoctoral research associate were involved in this project. The project provided training in plant genetics, molecular biology and biochemistry analyses. It also offered the opportunity for developing skills with effective scientific communications by presenting findings in writing and verbal presentations. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Oral presentation entitled"Orchestration of photosynthetic pigment synthesis in plants" at The 19th International Symposium on Carotenoids. July 9-14, 2023 Toyama, Japan What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will proceed with our ongoing experiments to achieve the set objectives. We will try to demonstrate the distinguished role and mechanism of Gr protein from green allele in mediating chloroplast development.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During the past year, we were focused on characterizing the Gr protein and understanding its basis in conferring chloroplast development. We expanded Gr candidate gene expression analysis to a panel of white and green curd cauliflower varieties. In general, the Gr gene expresses higher in the green curd cultivars than the white ones, although some green cultivars show similar gene expression levels like white ones as we observed previously when comparing one green and one white cultivar. However, when we analyzed Gr protein level in curd tissues of these cultivars by western blot analysis, all green curd varieties showed high abundant Gr protein levels and all white curd varieties had very low Gr protein levels. These results indicate that the white cauliflower varieties lose the ability to accumulate the Gr protein in the curd tissue despite its normal transcription. To understand the basis underlying such Gr protein accumulation difference between white and green curd cauliflower varieties, we examined the transgenic Arabidopsis lines overexpressing either the cauliflower white or green allele of Gr gene. Although the three independent transgenic lines with white allele showed similar transgene expression levels as the three independent lines with green allele, they had much lower Gr protein abundance than those lines with green allele, consistent with what was observed between white and green curd cauliflower varieties. These results confirm the difference of the two alleles of Gr in affecting its protein accumulation. To examine whether the two Gr alleles encode proteins that alter their subcellular localization, we examined their subcellular localizations by expressing individual allele fused with YEP in tobacco leaves. Both were found to localize in chloroplasts. However, very strong signals were observed for the green allele protein and very faint signals were noted for white allele protein, further suggesting the Gr protein stability difference between the green allele vs the white allele protein. The two different alleles encode Gr protein with one amino acid change in the transit peptide (cTP) region and one amino acid addition in the mature protein of Gr green protein. To check whether the alteration of one amino acid in cTP affects Gr abundance in plants, we performed cTP import assay by fusing cTP from white and green protein to GFP and transient expression in tobacco leaves. While GFP fused to Green cTP produced predominantly mature protein, the GFP fused to white cTP generated mainly premature protein, indicating the single amino acid change greatly affects Gr protein targeting into chloroplast to influence its protein abundance in chloroplasts. At the same time, we also generated transgenic lines deleting the extra amino acid in Gr green protein. These lines showed greatly reduced Gr protein accumulation. These results indicate that both the amino acid change in cTP and the single amino acid addition contribute to Gr protein stability in the green curd cauliflower varieties, subsequently affecting chloroplast development.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Sun T, Wang P, Rao S, Zhou X, Wrightstone E, Lu S, Yuan H, Yang Y, Fish T, Thannhauser T, Liu J, Mazourek M, Grimm B, Li L (2023) Co-chaperoning of chlorophyll and carotenoid biosynthesis by ORANGE family proteins in plants. Molecular Plant 16:10481065. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.molp.2023.05.006


Progress 01/15/22 to 01/14/23

Outputs
Target Audience:The output of this research would benefit agricultural, horticultural and biological scientists following revealing novel genes and molecular mechanisms, which regulate chloroplast biogenesis in agronomically important crops. Breeders may also utilize such information to generate novel germplasms with more appealing visual as well as more nutrients associated with chloroplast development, which would consequently benefit the general public as consumers. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One undergraduate and one postdoctoral research associate was involved in this project. The project provided the training in plant genetics, molecular biology and bioinformatics analyses. It also offered the opportunity for developing skills with effective scientific communications by presenting findings in writing and verbal presentations. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Oral presentation: "Colored cauliflower, molecular basis, and genetic tools and strategies to breed nutrient dense crops". Genomic advances in fruit and vegetable breeding workshop. The International Plant & Animal Genome XXX Conference, San Diego, CA January 13-18, 2023 What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will proceed with our ongoing experiments to achieve the set objectives. We hope to functionally confirm the Gr gene leading to the green curd trait in cauliflower. We will further characterize this gene in green and white cauliflower and start to dissection of the mechanism of Gr in mediating chloroplast development.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For the Objective 1: From a list of 25 potential Gr candidates, we have narrowed down to a promising gene that likely confers the green curd trait in cauliflower. An SNP and a deletion mutation of the same gene were identified between white and green curd cauliflower. We are currently generating transgenic cauliflowers that overexpress the green allele of the candidate gene for phenotypic complementation. So far, we have established an in-house protocol to regenerate cauliflower seedlings from calli after Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. We expect to obtain positive transformants soon. In addition, we obtained a corresponding Arabidopsis knockout mutant of our candidate gene. The mutant is deficient in chloroplast biogenesis, appeared pale yellow, and showed dwarfism. We had generated transgenic Arabidopsis plants that overexpress either the white or green allele of our candidate gene in the mutant background. Transgenic lines overexpressing the green allele fully complemen the phenotypic deficiencies (displayed by the Arabidopsis mutant), while those overexpressing the white allele could only partially complement the phenotypes. These transgenic studies show the difference of the two alleles of our candidate gene in conferring chloroplast development. For the Objective 2: We first examined the candidate gene expression in the white and green curd tissue by quantitative real-time polymerase chain reactions. The gene expression analysis revealed that the candidate gene's expression level in white and green curds is similar. We then performed western blot experiments. The analysis showed that their protein levels are significantly different. We are currently examining how the differences in amino acid sequence (from the SNP and/or deletion mutations) would affect its protein stability in the curd tissue. Molecular characterization of Arabidopsis transgenic lines overexpressing the white and green allele of the candidate gene is now in progress to account for their phenotypic differences.

Publications

  • Type: Book Chapters Status: Published Year Published: 2022 Citation: 1. Sun T, Zhou X, Rao S, Liu J, Li L (2022) Protein-protein interaction techniques to investigate post-translational regulation of carotenogenesis. Methods in Enzymology Volume 671: Carotenoids: Carotenoid and apocarotenoid biosynthesis, metabolic engineering and synthetic biology. pp 301-325


Progress 01/15/21 to 01/14/22

Outputs
Target Audience:The output of this research would benefit agricultural, horticultural and biological scientists following revealing novel genes and molecular mechanisms, which regulate chloroplast biogenesis in agronomically important crops. Breeders may also utilize such information to generate novel germplasms with more appealing visual as well as more nutrients associated with chloroplast development, which would consequently benefit the general public as consumers. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One undergraduate and one postdoctoral research associate was involved in this project. The project provided the training in plant genetics, molecular biology and bioinformatics analyses. It also offered the opportunity for developing skills with effective scientific communications by presenting findings in writing and verbal presentations. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will proceed with our ongoing experiments to achieve the set objectives. We will continue functional confirmation of the Gr gene leading to the green curd trait in both Arabidopsis mutant and in white curd cauliflower. We will start to characterize this gene in green and white cauliflower and to dissection of the mechanism of Gr in mediating chloroplast development.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The COVID pandemic greatly delayed the start of the project due to the late arrival of newly hired researchers and limited number of peoplewho could work in the lab. To accomplish the above objectives, in this rating period we thoroughly examined the 35 candidate genes located within the mapped major QTL locus (named Gr5.1; on Chromosome 5) responsible to the green curd trait. By further fine mapping the Gr5.1 locus and remapping the genome region to the recently published white cauliflower genome, we narrowed down the candidates to 25 genes (excluding pseudogenes and long non-coding RNAs). We then analyzed these candidates via combination of bioinformatics, computational analyses, and literature review. We reasoned that gene products localized to either chloroplast or nucleus would most likely affect chloroplast biogenesis. Their corresponding peptide sequences were hence subjected to computational analyses and identified 14 candidates with subcellular localization signals. We then compared their gene expression level between white and green cauliflower curds and examined the INDELs and SNPs of genes expressed in curd tissues. We identified one gene to be of particular interest with the presence of INDELs within its coding sequence by comparing all white cauliflower sequences publically available with the green gene. Concurrently, we have confirmed its predicted subcellular localization and noticed a difference in the suborganelle localization within the chloroplast between the gene product from white and green cauliflowers. We are now generating the CRISPR/Cas9-mediated knockout construct and will first transform into Arabidopsis mutants in the ap1/cal background which forms green, curd-like meristem structure. We expect to observe a loss of green curd color in these mutants, which would allow us to tentatively identify the candidate Gr gene. We have also established a regeneration platform for Agrobacterium-mediated cauliflower transformation. We are in progress to transform the green allele into white curd cauliflower to confirm the identity of the Gr gene.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2022 Citation: Sun T, Rao S, Zhou X, Li L (2022) Plant carotenoids: recent advances and future perspectives. Molecular Horticulture (in press)