Source: CONNECTICUT AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION submitted to NRP
TRACKING THE SPREAD OF BEECH LEAF DISEASE IN CONNECTICUT AND NEW ENGLAND
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1023296
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 8, 2020
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2024
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
CONNECTICUT AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION
PO BOX 1106
NEW HAVEN,CT 06504
Performing Department
Plant Pathology & Ecology
Non Technical Summary
First discovered in 2012 in Lake County, Ohio, Beech Leaf Disease (BLD) has since spread to stands of American beech (Fagus grandifolia) across much of northern Ohio, western and northern Pennsylvania, New York, and Ontario, Canada, and has also been found on European beech (Fagus sylvatica) in Ohio. In 2019, BLD was identified for the first time in southern New York State and southwestern Connecticut. The disease, characterized by dark interveinal banding of leaves appearing soon after spring flush, reappears and advances in trees in subsequent years, with a reduction in buds and therefore foliage, increasing canopy thinning, and tree mortality within five to seven years. Also in 2019, researchers in Ohio, Ontario, and at the USDA confirmed that BLD is caused by a foliar nematode, Litylenchus crenatae mccannii (Lcm), closely related to Litylenchus crenatae crenatae, the nematode associated with leaf gall symptoms on Japanese beech (Fagus crenata). The American beech is an important hardwood forest species of eastern North America, occurring from Nova Scotia and southern Ontario to northern Florida and eastern Texas. With no reports to date of BLD in other New England states, Connecticut is now the gateway for the incursion of this disease into New England, where American beech is a foundational tree species, playing an important role in forest ecosystems, its cavities and canopies supporting nesting sites and shelter, and its nuts constituting a hard mast food source essential to the survival of a variety of vertebrates, from birds to black bears. Dense beech foliage also plays an important role in the forest ecosystem, both in the canopy by modulating light levels in the understory, and as leaf litter, contributing to nutrient cycling on the forest floor. Also susceptible to BLD, the European beech is an important tree of urban landscapes, often occupying iconic roles on town greens and other public spaces in New England's historic towns. The overall goal of this project, strongly grounded in both laboratory and field work, is to track the spread of BLD in Connecticut, and to develop and deploy genetic tools essential to improving our understanding of how Lcm moves within sites and from one site to another. An annual distribution survey for presence of BLD in Connecticut's forests will allow us to firmly determine the current extent of BLD in Connecticut, and track the disease as it advances in each subsequent year. In the laboratory, we will use the Lcm genome to identify molecular markers known as microsatellites - the same type of marker used in human forensics, and for many other organisms. These genetic markers will allow us to genotype individual Lcm nematodes, and thereby to track the origins of new incidences of BLD that are identified by surveys, and test hypotheses about how the nematode disperses to begin new infections. There are no reports to date of BLD in other New England states, and as of September of 2019, BLD was found only in the very southwest corner of Connecticut. Therefore, Connecticut can be considered the gateway for the incursion of this disease into New England, where American beech increases in representation and importance. Additionally, the genetic markers developed for this project will continue to serve an important role in studying the dispersal of Lcm as BLD spreads further into New England and into other eastern states. Insights into modes of transmission of Lcm gained through molecular genotyping will also be important to the development of management strategies. This project will involve collaborations with researchers in Ohio, West Virginia, Ontario, Canada, and the USDA, building upon strategic relationships based on complementary and overlapping approaches and areas of expertise.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
12331301160100%
Knowledge Area
123 - Management and Sustainability of Forest Resources;

Subject Of Investigation
3130 - Nematodes;

Field Of Science
1160 - Pathology;
Goals / Objectives
The goals of this project are to (1) undertake a distribution survey of Beech Leaf Disease in Connecticut in order to establish its current extent, with subsequent annual surveys to chart the spread of the disease; (2) using a whole-genome sequence, develop a minimum of 15 polymorphic microsatellite markers to be used for testing hypotheses on the origins and movement of the nematode in North America; (3) using these microsatellite markers, study the population genetics of Lcm; and (4) conduct public outreach through print (e.g. fact sheets), internet (CAES website), and public presentations.
Project Methods
1. BLD Distribution Survey: This will consist of field work occurring at various locations in Connecticut. To conduct this survey, we will first generate an inventory of forests, parks, and preserves in Connecticut with significant populations (≥20%) of American beech. Municipal parks with significant specimens of European beech will also be inventoried. After leaf-out (~mid-late May), we will visit target sites, systematically radiating outward north and east from 2019 sites with BLD in Fairfield County. Frequency of site visits will depend on staff availability. The data to be collected will include:Site data: slope, aspect, soil type, GPS coordinates;Percentage of beech;Co-occurring tree species;Percentage of symptomatic trees;Dbh range;Percentage of symptomatic foliage.Symptomatic foliage will be collected from trees at the edges of infected sites as well as the center. All sampled trees will be flagged and recorded. Leaves will be collected in Ziploc-type bags and stored at 4°C for downstream nematode isolations, for use in Objective 2.To identify new sites and track the spread of the disease in subsequent years, with each new season the survey will focus on the outermost sites recorded the previous year and radiate outward north and east from those sites.2. Polymorphic microsatellite markers for Litylenchus crenatae mccannii (and possibly L. crenatae crenatae): This laboratory-based work will be conducted in the Marra Lab at CAES, in New Haven, CT. Sequencing and microsatellite fragment analysis will be conducted at Yale University, New Haven, CT.This process will require the extraction of high-quality high-molecular-weight DNA from a large number (approximately 100,000) Lcm nematodes, which will be isolated from freshly collected symptomatic infested leaves.The DNA will then be processed at the Yale University Center for Genome Analysis (alternatively, Ohio State University) using current whole-genome sequencing (WGS) technology (e.g., PacBio, Illumina, or Nanopore); the resulting "reads" will then be assembled by the sequencing facility.The resulting assembled "contigs" will then be used to screen the WGS for microsatellite loci using Genome-wide Microsatellite Analyzing Tool (gMATo) (software freely available at sourceforge.net).Once the microsatellite loci are identified, PCR primers flanking each candidate locus will be designed using Primer3-Plus software (freely available at primer3plus.com). The primers will then be ordered from a primer-synthesis company (e.g., Sigma).Each microsatellite locus will then be queried for length polymorphisms among a screening population consisting of 24-32 isolates, which will be obtained from sites representing the range of current infestations in North America (and, if possible, Japan, in order to query the suitability of these primers for the Lcc subspecies.Candidate microsatellite loci will be tested in this way until a minimum of 15 informative (i.e., polymorphic) loci are obtained, generating a "suite" or microsatellite markers to be used and tested for segregation of polymorphisms from within trees, and within and among sites.3. Population genetics of Litylenchus crenatae mccannii. From each site sampled in CT, the following sampling scheme will be used to collect symptomatic leaves for nematode extraction and microsatellite genotyping.From each site, one tree will be sampled at the center of the site, along with four trees evenly distributed at the perimeter of the site, approximating four ordinal corners. Hierarchical sampling will be conducted as follows: from each tree, symptomatic leaves will be collected from each of the four ordinal corners of the tree, at ground level and at a height that is within reach with a pole pruner, yielding eight leaves per tree. From each leaf, a symptomatic portion will be sampled using a standard hole-punch to obtain 3-4 discs; these will be floated in water in a 60 mm petri dish overnight at room temperature. The following day, 8-12 individual nematodes will be transferred individually to buffer and frozen prior to a standard freeze-boil lysis. Resulting lysates will be used for microsatellite genotyping using markers developed in Procedure 2.4. Public Outreach: The goal of this procedure is to keep stakeholders informed on the occurrence of BLD in CT, and as new information is generated through research. Fact sheets and the CAES website will be updated with new information on the disease, and on locations of new infestations. Presentations suitable for the general public will be developed and used for presentations at various venues; e.g. garden clubs and tree and landscape professionals.

Progress 06/08/20 to 09/30/20

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience for this project includes, broadly, all stakeholders living in the eastern United States, as the American beech is an iconic tree of eastern forests. More specifically, tree care professionals - e.g., tree wardens, arborists, park managers, foresters, etc. - and informed members of the public will be engaged as citizen scientists in assisting with the identification of new incidences of BLD for this project. Additionally, information generated by the proposed research will be shared: with colleagues also involved in BLD research; at meetings of foresters, land managers, and tree-care professionals; at meetings of the Connecticut Tree Protective Association and Connecticut Tree Wardens; at other appropriate public forums, including The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station's Spring Open House and Plant Science Day. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?As described in Objective#4 above, presentations on beech leaf disease were given to research collaborators (4a and 4c, above); stakeholders that included master gardeners (4b, above), and tree-care professionals (4d, above). An interview with science journalist Brendan Crowley for the CT Examiner, 23 September 2020, resulted in an article on BLD for the general public (https://ctexaminer.com/2020/09/28/deadly-beech-leaf-disease-identified-across-connecticut-and-rhode-island/). An interview with science journalist Jan Ellen Spiegel for the CT Mirror, 16 July 2020, resulted in an article on research at CAES that included a discussion of BLD for the general public (https://ctmirror.org/2020/08/19/where-connecticut-covid-climate-change-and-critters-intersect/). An article on BLD was solicited by the New England chapter of the Society of American Foresters, and published in their quarterly journal (https://nesaf.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/2020_October_NQ.pdf). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? BLD Distribution Survey. This will depend on the availability of a technical support. If a seasonal assistant is provided, we will continue to survey state forests, parks, and preserves where BLD was not documented in 2020, and we will re-survey areas where BLD was observed in 2020, to determine if it is more widespread than in 2020. Development of microsatellite markers for the BLD nematode, Litylenchus crenatae mccannii (Lcm). Depending on the availability of a technical support, the whole genome sequence will be used to mine for microsatellite loci, for which PCR primers will be designed and tested against a screening population consisting of DNA from Lcm nematodes collected from areas representing the known range of BLD. Population genetics of Lcm. Depending availability of technical support, microsatellite markers identified in Goal #2 will be screened against populations of Lcm. Public Outreach: Presentations on BLD will be delivered to various stakeholder groups, as opportunities arise.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The overall goal of this project, strongly grounded in both laboratory and field work, is to track the spread of BLD in Connecticut, and to develop and deploy genetic tools essential to improving our understanding of how Lcm moves within sites and from one site to another. Progress on the project's objectives follows: BLD Distribution Survey. PI Marra, assisted by a seasonal worker, logged in 370 hours surveying 17 state forests, 11 state parks, 7 state or private preserves, and 3 city parks, in all of CT's eight counties. BLD was observed in varying densities, from extensive infestations in lower Fairfield County, to very sparse occurrences in Litchfield, Tolland, and Windham Counties. Areas of high and low densities of BLD were found in New Haven, Middlesex, and New London Counties, with the highest densities of infestations in beech stands closest to the shoreline. BLD was not found in Hartford County. For aiding confirmation of BLD in symptomatic leaf tissue before juvenile and adult nematodes can be directly observed (i.e., when only eggs are presumably present), a PCR-based detection protocol was developed that targets the Litylenchus crenatae mccanii mitochondrial COX gene. Development of microsatellite markers for the BLD nematode, Litylenchus crenatae mccannii (Lcm). With the aid of a seasonal employee, we optimized a procedure for extracting high-molecular-weight genomic DNA from nematodes isolated exclusively from a single interveinal band of symptomatic leaf tissue, collected in September 2020, when populations of nematodes inside leaves are at their highest. The extracted DNA was of high molecular weight, peaking at 55 kilobases, high quantity, ~ 5 ug, and of very high quality, with a DNA Integrity Number (DIN) of 8.9. The DNA is currently being processed for whole-genome sequencing at the Yale Center for Genomic Analysis. Population genetics of Lcm. Nothing yet to report. Public Outreach: The following presentations on BLD were given, remotely via Zoom or similar, to stakeholders: Beech Leaf Disease Working Group: meeting with multi-state collaborators. 17 June 2020; 4 August 2020. UConn Extension Master Gardener "Hot Topics" Series: 18 June 2020. CT CAPS Committee Meeting: 23 June 2020. Connecticut Tree Protective Association (professional society for certified arborists): annual meeting. 3 September 2020.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Marra, R.E., LaMondia, J., 2020. First Report of Beech Leaf Disease, caused by the foliar nematode, Litylenchus crenatae mccannii, on American Beech (Fagus grandifolia) in Connecticut. Plant Disease. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-02-20-0442-PDN
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Marra. R.E. 2020. An Overview of Beech Leaf Disease. News Quarterly of the New England Society of American Foresters 81(4): 4-7 (https://nesaf.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/2020_October_NQ.pdf).