Source: NORTH DAKOTA STATE UNIV submitted to
A NOVEL HOUSING SYSTEM TO DECREASE INJURY AND DISTRESS DURING TRANSPORT IN SWINE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1022644
Grant No.
2020-67016-31400
Cumulative Award Amt.
$195,000.00
Proposal No.
2019-06232
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2020
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2024
Grant Year
2020
Program Code
[A1251]- Animal Health and Production and Animal Products: Animal Well-Being
Project Director
Byrd, C.
Recipient Organization
NORTH DAKOTA STATE UNIV
1310 BOLLEY DR
FARGO,ND 58105-5750
Performing Department
Animal Sciences
Non Technical Summary
When pigs are approximately 6 months of age and ready to go to the processing plant, they are required to walk onto a truck trailer to be transported. The process of walking from their pens to the trailer often results in heightened stress, a reluctance to move and potential injury, particularly when they are required to ascend an unfamiliar ramp to walk into the trailer. Stress and injuries related to loading, transport, and unloading reduce animal welfare and result in significant economic losses. The purpose of this study is to evaluate a strategy for reducing pig stress associated with walking up the ramp during trailer loading. Pigs will be given access to a small ramp within their pens from approximately 3-8 weeks of age. During this time, ramp usage and the effect of the ramp on pig behavioral interaction within the pen will be evaluated. At approximately 8 weeks of age, the ramp will be removed for the remainder of their growing period (i.e. 4 months). Following the growing period, pig behavior will be evaluated during trailer loading to see if early-life ramp exposure reduces the amount of stress they experience as they ascend the ramp into the trailer. The study will also investigate whether early-life ramp exposure makes it easier for the animal caretakers to handle the pigs during loading and unloading. We hypothesize that early-life pig exposure to a ramp will result in reduced behavioral and physiological indicators of stress, fewer injuries, faster loading and unloading times and decreased required effort by animal caretakers to safely move the pigs to and from the trailer. If successful, early-life exposure to a small ramp would be an easily adoptable strategy, resulting in improved swine welfare at loading and increased economic benefit for the producer.
Animal Health Component
75%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
25%
Applied
75%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
31535101060100%
Goals / Objectives
Our overall goal is to mitigate a key problem of international importance: the loss associated with stress, injury, and death during transport of market hogs. In addition to diminishing animal well-being, transport losses at marketing occur after hogs have consumed their maximum resources, making them especially harmful to profitability and sustainability.Pig stress is reduced by easier loading, and injury and death may also be reduced. Our preliminary data indicate that a simple adaptation, providing a ramp in nursery pig housing, substantially decreases the amount of time it takes to load market hogs up a ramp, while alsodecreasing nursery pig fighting and maintaining growth.The goals of the proposed study are to validate our preliminary findings in a commercial-type production system and to expand the measured outcomes. Supporting objectives include measuring the effects of ramped nursery housing on loading and unloading speed and ease at marketing, stress to pigs in the nursery and at marketing, and pig condition at the processing facility. We will achieve the study objectives by comparing the described outcomes between pigs housed in conventional flat nursery pens and pigs housed in nursery pens containing a simple ramp and platform.The proposed project targets Program Area Code A1251, "Welfare and Well-being of Agricultural Animals". It will fulfill the Program Area Priorities by promoting the development of a new management approach that safeguards both animal welfare and sustainable production efficiency, and by creating improvement in handling and transportation to decrease injury and distress.
Project Methods
Nursery Phase:At weaning, pigs will be randomly assigned to two nursery treatments: 1) access to a ramp (RAMP), or 2) a standard flat pen (CONT). A single ramp (20° angle) will be placed in the nursery pens housing RAMP pigs. There will be resting platform at the top of the ramp, with rubberized flooring and enough area to accommodate all of the pigs in the pen early in the nursery phase. Pigs in the CONT treatment will be placed in a conventional pen of the same area, but without a ramp. The pigs will be in a wean-to-finish barn and will not be moved from their pens between weaning and marketing.Data to be collected during the nursery phase (approximately 6 weeks):A. Feed consumption amounts will be recorded for each pen.B. Tear stain scoring will be conducted after one week in the nursery as a measure of physiological stress; this measure has been shown to correlate with sympathetic nervous system activity (Marchant-Forde and Marchant-Forde, 2014), piglet aggression (DeBoer et al., 2015), and piglet exposure to novel environments (Telkänranta et al., 2015).C. Shoulder, flank, and ham lesions will be scored (4 category scoring system; Barton-Gade et al., 1995) after one week in the nursery as an indicator of pig aggression occurring in the pen.D. Pig behavioral data will be recorded via video camera during daylight hours every day for the first 7 days following weaning and once a week for the remaining 5 weeks to assess the effect of ramp presence on behavioral indicators of stress and pig welfare. Behaviors of interest include feeding, drinking, posture, and aggressive interactions between pen mates.E. Daily observations (lameness, illness, treatment, mortality) will be recorded by farm staff.F. Pen weights will be collected at the beginning and end of the nursery phase.Grow/Finish Phase:After approximately 6 weeks (the end of the nursery phase), ramps will be removed from the pens. Pigs will experience typical housing and husbandry practices in the grow/finish phase.Measures to be collected during the grow/finish phase:A. Pig body weight (averaged by pen) will be collected every 2-3 weeks this phase (on the same schedule for all pens), and pen feed intake data will be collected.B. Daily observations (lameness, illness, treatment, mortality) will be recorded by farm staff.Transport:When the pigs reach market weight, they will be loaded and transported to a commercial slaughter facility. Pigs will be moved with their pen conspecifics and encouraged to walk onto the ramp and trailer using a sorting board.Measures to be collected during loading:A. The amount of time it takes for each group to navigate the ramp leading to the transport trailer will be recorded. No aids other than the sorting board will be used for encouragement, unless a pig takes more than 3 min to load. Such pigs will be categorized as "hard to load".B. Individual refusals, slips, and falls will be counted.C. Instantaneous heart rate of the handler will be recorded to approximate changes to heart rate and heart rate variability in response to pig handling.Measures to be collected during unloading:A. The amount of time it takes the hogs to navigate the ramp when leaving the transport trailer will be measured.B. Individual refusals, slips, and falls will be counted.C. Non-ambulatory and dead pigs and pigs displaying injuries, open mouth breathing, and skin discoloration will be quantified.Statistical AnalysisData will be analyzed using the mixed procedure in SAS (v. 9.4; SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, NC). Residuals will be evaluated for normality and data will be transformed as necessary. Fixed effects will include repetition, treatment, day, and their interactions. Depending on the trait and the number of observations, repeated measures on a pen (either across time or across pigs) will be accounted for using a repeated or random statement in the mixed procedure. For repeated measures, different covariance structures will be tested and the best fit will be chosen using the Akaike Information Criterion. Treatment effects will be considered significant at the P ≤ 0.05 level.Communication of Results to Appropriate AudiencesResults will be distributed and shared via peer-reviewed journals (e.g. Journal of Animal Science, Applied Animal Behaviour Science), national and international scientific meetings (e.g. American Society of Animal Science, International Society for Applied Ethology), and additional extension bulletins and popular press opportunities (e.g. National Hog Farmer).

Progress 07/01/20 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Target audiences included swine stakeholders (producers, industry), as well as scientists and veterinarians with an interest in improving swine production. Changes/Problems:Original sample size and experimental facility described in the project approach were not met due to complications with the COVID-19 pandemic and the unavailability of a commercial partner's facilities. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Completion of 1 MS degree (M.L. Kasakamu) Completion of Graduate Student Agricultural Communication program (M.L. Kasakamu) Attendance and presentation at 2022 national ASAS meeting (M.L. Kasakamu) Attendance and presentation at 2023 Midwest ASAS meeting (M.L. Kasakamu and C.J. Byrd) Attendance and presentation at 2023 national ASAS meeting (C.J. Byrd) How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?All results have been disseminated via popular press (National Hog Farmer), scientific meetings (American Society of Animal Science), and will be published in a peer-reviewed publication (currently submitted for peer-review to Applied Animal Behaviour Science). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? CHANGE IN KNOWLEDGE: The goal of this project was to determine whether early-life exposure to a ramp and platform within the pen during the nursery phase (approx. 3-9 wks of age) improved pigs' ability to ascend and descend the loading and unloading ramps during the marketing phase of production (when pigs are approximately 5-6 months of age). Pigs are commonly requried to ascend at least one rampto access the semi-trailer that will carry them to the processing facility. Given their lack of experience with ramp structures, pigs may experience stress and may be at higher risk of injury when utilizing the ramps during loading and unloading. The objectives of this study were to measurethe effects of ramped nursery housing on 1) loading and unloading speed and ease at marketing, 2) stress to pigs in the nursery and at marketing, and 3) pig condition at the processing facility. At 21 days of age, 540 pigs were transported to the experimental facility and housed in 20 pens (each pen containing 27 pigs). The 20 pens were allocated to 1 of 2 experimental treatments: 1) A pen that contained a ramp and connected platform structure(RAMP; n = 10 pens) or 2) a pen that did not contain a ramp (CONTROL; n = 10 pens). The ramps remained in the RAMP pens for the remainder of the nursery phase and were removed at the start of the grow-finish phase (when pigs were approximately 9 weeks of age). Once the ramps were removed, the pen designfor RAMP and CONTROL pigs were the same. During the nursery phase (3- 9 weeks of age), pig behavior (standing, lying, eating, drinking, aggression)was evaluated to determine whether the presence of a ramp in the RAMP pens had an effect on behavioral performance. Additionally, pig body weight, feed intake, average daily gain, and feed to gain ratio (an indicator of feed efficiency) were evaluated as performance measures. No effect of ramp and platform provision in the RAMP pens was detected for any behavior evaluated. Similarly, no effect of ramp and platform provision in the RAMP pens was detected for any performance measure. Taken together, these results indicate that, at the very least, ramp and platform provision do not have a negative effect on swine welfare and performance during the nursery phase. At the end of the grow-finish phase (approximately 5.5 months of age), pigs were transported to the processing plant for marketing on 6 separate transport days. Groups of 4 same-treatment pigs from each of the 20 pens were loaded and unloaded on each transport day. The amount of time required for each group of 4 same-treatment pigs to ascend the loading ramp to the semi-trailer was quantified. Additionally, the incidence of trips, turnarounds on the ramp, and electric prod usage by the handler were determined. Our results indicate RAMP pigs required less time to ascend the loading ramp at marketing compared to CONTROL pigs (69.1 vs. 95.1seconds; P= 0.002). Additionally, RAMP pigs required fewer electric prod interventions during loading compared to CONTROL pigs (20 vs. 33 instances;P= 0.02). No differences in trips or turnarounds on the loading ramp were observed (P> 0.05). After ascending the loading ramp,experimental pigs were housed in 1 of 4 upper-level trailer compartment or 1 lower-level compartment in mixed-treatment groups. All pigs were required to ascend an internal trailer ramp to reach their compartment. The pigs housed in the lower-level compartment were rquired to ascend the internal trailer ramp and descend a second internal ramp to reach their compartment.After loading, all experimental pigswere transported to the processing plant approximately 325 km from the experimental facility. Upon arrival to the facility,the experimetnalpigs were unloaded in mixed treatment and variable sized groups. The amount of time required for pigs to descend the internal trailer ramp to the processing facility was quantified, along with human handler intervention (rattle paddle usage), trips, turnarounds on the ramp, and backwards movement down the ramp. Interestingly, CONT pigs descended the ramp slightly faster than RAMP pigs (12.7vs. 13.9 seconds;P= 0.03). Additionally, RAMP pigs descended the ramp backwards more often compared to CONT pigs (10 vs. 2 instances;P= 0.02). Our data do not provide a meaningful explanation for this behavior. However, descending the ramp backwards may be an attempt to avoid adverse situations (e.g. unfamiliar handlers) during unloading. The ability of an animal to successfully descend the ramp backwards may be beneficial for reducing ramp-related injuries. In conclusion, ramp and platform exposure during the nursery phase of production improves ease of loading at market weight, which is benficial for the prodcuer (i.e. faster loading) and the pig (i.e.reduced ramp novelty). Additionally, the ramp had no negative effects on behavior and growth performance during the nursery period.

Publications

  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Kasakamu, M.L., Young, J.M., Samuel, R.S., Wagner, S.A., Byrd, C.J.(2023)Ramped piglet housing in the nursery: Increasing speed of loading at transportation to marketing. National Hog Farmer Magazine (July/August 2023).
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Awaiting Publication Year Published: 2024 Citation: Kasakamu, M. L., Young, J. M., Samuel, R. S., Wagner, S. A., Byrd, C. J. (2024) The effect of ramped nursery housing on pig behavior during loading and unloading at marketing. Submitted to Applied Animal Behaviour Science in May 2024.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Kasakamu, M. L., Young, J. M., Samuel, R. S., Wagner, S. A., Byrd, C. J.(2023) PSX-19 Does housing pigs with access to a ramp alter pig behavior during the nursery period? J. Anim. Sci. 101 (Suppl 3): 514-515. doi:10.1093/jas/skad281.607
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Kasakamu, M. L., Young, J. M., Samuel, R. S., Wagner, S. A., Byrd, C. J.(2023) 183 Ramped piglet housing during the nursery phase increases speed of loading during transportation to market. J. Anim. Sci. (Suppl 2):5-6. doi:10.1093/jas/skad341.005


Progress 07/01/22 to 06/30/23

Outputs
Target Audience:Data from this project were presented at one regional scientific meeting (MW-ASAS, Madison, WI) in March 2023. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Loading and unloading data were presented to a scientific audience at the 2023 MW-ASAS meeting in Madison, WI. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next year, we wil complete all aspects of the study, including analysis, graduate student thesis writing and defense, and publication of results in peer-reviewed journals. We also anticipate a second presentation at a scientific meeting and publication of summary results via popular press opportunities.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? All on-farm behavioral recordingis finished. Currently, the loading and unloading data have been analyzed. We anticipatebehavioral data collection via recorded video to be completed by October 2023.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/21 to 06/30/22

    Outputs
    Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems:Only 20 total commerical pens (10 pens for each treatment; approximately 500 total pigs)were utilized in the data collection instead of 40 pens. We had difficulty obtaining ramp fabrication supplies in time before the project needed to be initiated due to the SDSU barn's production schedule. With the large number of pigs raised in 20 pens, we do not anticipate major effects on the results. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One-on-one mentoring of a MS student has occured throughout the entire project duration. The student has gained experience in experimental design, statistical design, behavioral data collection and analysis, heart rate variability data collection, and some public speaking (through courses on campus). How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?No, results will be disseminated once data have been analyzed. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?After the 31st, we will have all of our data collected. Behavioral observation of the video collected during thestudywill occur September - December. The MSstudent funded through the project will present her results at a professional scientific meeting during Spring 2023. The MS studenthas a tentative graduatation date of Summer 2023. At that point, we will likely submit the results of the study for peer reviewed publication.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Project data collection began in March 2022 as weaned pigs arrived at SDSU's wean-to-finish barn. Behavioral video collection occured between March and August 2022 to determine whether early-life exposure to a small ramp would reduce aggression and improve feed efficiency during the nursery and grow-finish periods. On August 3rd, we began the trailer loading aspect of the study, where we will evlaute whether presence of a ramp during the nursery period induces improved loading/unloading of the truck trailer at market weight (speed up the ramp, reduced behavioral stress associated with loading/unloading). Our 7th and final loading/unloading period will take place next week, August 31st.

    Publications


      Progress 07/01/20 to 06/30/21

      Outputs
      Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems:COVID-19 led to the loss of our experimental location. We have identified a new location (SDSU's wean-to-finish facility) for the experiment, however, it is likely that we will not have the opportunity to attain the sample size we had hoped. We are now looking at 40 pens total instead of approximately 70. Additionally, we will have to pay a fee for animal use that was not a requirement for the previous location.The reduction in pen numbers (and therefore, the reduction in ramp costs) will allow us to pay for the fees. The graduate student selected for this project is an international student. Border closures last year due to COVID-19 did not allow her to travel to the U.S. to begin her studies. She has officially arrived at NDSU and began her assistantship on August 16th, 2021. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The project will be officially initiated in early October at South Dakota State's commercial wean to finish facility. A graduate student has been identified for the project and she officially started at North Dakota State University as a graduate research assistant on August 15, 2021. Over this next reporting period, all on-farm, transport, and production plantdata will be collected, swine behavior will be collected from recorded video, and analysis of the data will begin.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? Project has not been initiated due to COVID-19 related difficulties that led to a loss of experimental locationand inability to enroll an international graduate student identified for the project.

      Publications