Source: COLLEGE OF MENOMINEE NATION submitted to NRP
MENOMINEE REMATRIATION RESEARCH PROJECT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1022615
Grant No.
2020-38424-31817
Cumulative Award Amt.
$95,000.00
Proposal No.
2019-08493
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 15, 2020
Project End Date
Sep 14, 2023
Grant Year
2020
Program Code
[ZY]- Tribal Colleges Research Grants Program
Recipient Organization
COLLEGE OF MENOMINEE NATION
PO BOX 179, N172 HWY 47/55
KESHENA,WI 54135
Performing Department
College of Menominee Nation
Non Technical Summary
This Tribal College Research proposal for the College of Menominee Nation Seed Rematriation Program is designed to foster and enhance the diversity of traditional foods systems grown on the Menominee reservation contributing to a tribally sustained community food systems through the following objectives: 1) Researching Native Menominee seeds to be rematriated from museums and seed banks in a culturally appropriate manner, 2) Rematriated seeds will be planted to determine best practices to increase knowledge of seeds for future community sharing based on the findings, 3) Key informant interviews to gather data on heirloom seeds donated by Menominee Tribal members, 4) Increased seed diversity, and lastly 5) The successful germination of seeds from both rematriated and community donated seeds. The College of Menominee Nation is a leader within the community and Northeast Wisconsin with its previous work identifying historical ancient agricultural sites on the Menominee Reservation that date back over 5000 years ago. With the recent hire of a Sustainable Agriculture faculty position, the college has the capacity to undertake meaningful research that can be shared with other Tribal Colleges and communities. In addition, students will be given the opportunity to be a part of research in higher education that will enhance their learning experience at the College of Menominee Nation. The college has worked with the Menominee Tribe of Wisconsin and the University Of Wisconsin Division Of Extension to create opportunities for the community to learn the ancient agricultural techniques as well as learn about the foods that were grown and consumed by their elders. This project will give community members the opportunity to grow traditional native plants that were once grown by their ancestors.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2010199304050%
2010199106050%
Goals / Objectives
Goal #1: Seeds will be researched, recorded digitally, and rematriated from museums and seed banks in a culturally appropriate way.Goal #2: Rematriated seeds will be planted and phenology observed to increase knowledge of seeds for future community sharingGoal #3: Key informant interviews will be conducted in 4 Menominee communities to gather data on family heirloom seedsGoal #4: Increase Menominee seed diversity by collecting and cataloguing family heirloom seeds donated by Menominee tribal membersGoal #5: Increase Menominee seed diversity by saving successfully germinated seeds from both rematriated and community donated seeds.
Project Methods
A minimum of 4 visits to museums/universities/collections will be planned each grant year to collect seeds A documentation process will be created to gather seed data. At a minimum, the following will be collected: seed type, location, & source, storage method, donation dateA local process for seed rematriation will be developed based on interactions with museums and other locationsResearch and outreach to identify seeds from other seeds sources like USDA and Seed Savers for procurementSoil samples at planting locations will be tested for nutrient qualityPlanting techniques will be informed by research findings from ancient Menominee garden projectA phenology documentation process will be adapted from Extension and other sources to include digital cameras, journaling, and Menominee moons Documentation of planted seeds for two growing seasonsGrowing guides will be drafted for future community useDevelop a culturally appropriate interview process for community engagement to include informed consent, publishing, and digital videosCommunity outreach to assess local interest and gather individuals interested in sharing storiesDigital stories and written stories will be completed for future community useA documentation process will be created to gather seed data. At a minimum, the following will be collected: seed type, location, & source, storage method, donation dateCommunity outreach will be conducted to assess local interest sharing family heirloom seedsCreate local seed bank and protocols for seed storage Develop protocols for disbursing saved seeds to program and Menominee tribal membersIncrease seeds available by germinating and growing seeds from the seed bank in each grant year

Progress 07/15/23 to 09/30/23

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience for this grant is the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin and surrounding Tribes with an interest in bringing historical seeds back to their communities. This includes youth, families, elders, and CMN students who are interested in restoring their historical knowledge and growing their own food. Changes/Problems:The first year of the project was right in the middle of COVID and this prevented us from traveling to museums and seed banks. We now have a team that has been able to work with museums and visit them within the Midwest which has brought rich opportunities for reconnecting to the seeds that were once grown in the area. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The collection of the results are still in the compilation phase. There is much to be learned from the research that is happening and we are looking forward to sharing it with the Tribal communities we serve. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?July 2023 - Work with Menominee consultant and Menominee student worker to attempt to germinate and plant seeds already in possession of the college that have historical meaning to the community and the region as well as continuing to pursue additional seeds from other sources. Two Menominee females are planning a visit to the Milwaukee Public Library to possibly rematriate the Menominee and Stockbridge seeds within the Anthropology Department. Additional community members with knowledge of traditional growing and seed germination will be brought in to assist with trying to grow these seeds out. August 2023 - Participants will continue to attempt to grow out seeds from various sources in order to build on the seed bank on campus that will have the history behind where the seeds came from and accompanying instructions. September 2023 - The group will practice learned seed saving techniques to ensure viability for future growing seasons. Stories will be documented both in writing and with video and pictures as to proper growing conditions and historical stories about the seeds.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Sustainable Agriculture faculty, Dr. Frank Kutka, was able to acquire a list of seeds from the Science Museum of Minnesota with ties to historic indigenous communities in the Midwest. Dr. Kutka was also able to locate a bean seed from Seed Savers Exchange that was grown by the Lac Courte Orielles band of Chippewa in western Wisconsin in the early 1900s. Additionally it was found that the USDA national seed bank had sunflower seeds that are of Menominee descent. Dr. Kutka is working on a paper to be submitted for publication in the Tribal College and University Research Journal about regeneration old seeds. Brian Kowalkowski, Dean of Continuing Education visited the Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian to try and get a connection to possible Menominee seeds being housed at the Smithsonian. There was no response after sharing contact information. Jennifer Gauthier, Menominee female, interviewed and shared seeds with a local couple that have been growing a garden with organic heirloom seeds for many years. She was able to document the stories they shared with regard to where the seeds came from and their true meaning. Finally, after COVID traveling restrictions have been lifted, a group was able to the Wisconsin Historical Society in Madison, Wisconsin to meet with Jacqueline Pozza Reisner, Curator of American Indian Collections. This included Jennifer Gauthier (enrolled Menominee), Lucy Grignon (Enrolled Stockbridge and Menominee descendant) and Naneque Latender (enrolled Menominee). Ms. Reisner allowed the group to review an ancient seed collection from a list of over 25 counties in the State of Wisconsin from archaeological digs that occurred over the years, The group was able to take pictures and notes to identify which seeds may have historical identity to the Menominee. The counties of interest included; Fond du lac Outagamie Door Milwaukee Waupaca Winnebago Portage Sheboygan Racine In addition to the archaeological findings they also had a curated collection from a fur trader named Mumm that included seeds from northeast Wisconsin. The College of Menominee Nation staff identified samples of interest; 4 Amaranthus (genus of annual or short-lived perennials that includes leaf vegetables, 1989.19.249) 15 Chenopodium (Goosefoot, 1989.19.233) 1 Cornus seed (genus of dogwoods, 1984.91.2448) - this is from a Euroamerican occupation, would you still be interested in it? It is possible the family was Native using Euroamerican materials or they were partially Native, we don't know for sure. 2 Gramineae seed (genus of flowering grasses that includes cereals, maize, wheat, rice, barley, 1989.19.242) 1 Nicotiana rustica (tobacco, 1984.91.2382) - 20 Rubus seeds (genus of flowering plants that includes raspberries and blackberries, 1984.91.2391, 1984.91.2371, 1984.2382) 1 Trifolium seed (genus of flowering plants in the legume or pea family, 1984.91.2436) - this is also from a Euroamerican occupation. These requests for samples has triggered the Wisconsin Historical Society to develop a policy for sampling where as long as the request doesn't completely use up an accessioned item, a pathway is in place to hand over what is requested. We have been in touch with the Curator of Anthropology Collections at the Milwaukee Public Library as they have indicated they have Menominee and Stockbridge seeds housed in their Anthropology Department. We are planning a visit yet this summer to view the specimens.

Publications


    Progress 07/15/20 to 09/30/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target audience for this grant is the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin and surrounding Tribes with an interest in bringing historical seeds back to their communities. This includes youth, families, elders, and CMN students who are interested in restoring their historical knowledge and growing their own food. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In addition to visits to museums throughout the State, the college's Nutrition Outreach Coordinator attended the Native Nutrition Conference in Minneapolis. She has also been trained in FlexFarming which is the ability to germinate seeds in doors utilizing grow lights. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We have been able to share our findings with other Tribes in the State through the Wisconsin Inter-Tribal Repatriation Committee, monthly reports to the college's board of directors, and social media outlets. At the end of the project, a seed celebration was held at the local farmers market with samples of the seeds and the plants that were discovered on display. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Sustainable Agriculture faculty, Dr. Frank Kutka, was able to acquire a list of seeds from the Science Museum of Minnesota with ties to historic indigenous communities in the Midwest. Dr. Kutka was also able to locate a bean seed from Seed Savers Exchange that was grown by the Lac Courte Orielles band of Chippewa in western Wisconsin in the early 1900s. Additionally, it was found that the USDA National Seed Bank had sunflower seeds that are of Menominee descent. Brian Kowalkowski, Dean of Continuing Education visited the Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian to try and get a connection to possible Menominee seeds being housed at the Smithsonian. There was no response after sharing contact information. Jennifer Gauthier, a female Menominee, interviewed and shared seeds with a local couple that have been growing a garden with organic heirloom seeds for many years. She was able to document the stories they shared with regard to where the seeds came from and their true meaning. Finally, after COVID traveling restrictions have been lifted, a group was able to the Wisconsin Historical Society in Madison, Wisconsin to meet with Jacqueline Pozza Reisner, Curator of American Indian Collections. This included Jennifer Gauthier (enrolled Menominee), Lucy Grignon (Enrolled Stockbridge and Menominee descendant) and Naneque Latender (enrolled Menominee). Ms. Reisner allowed the group to review an ancient seed collection from a list of over 25 counties in the State of Wisconsin from archaeological digs that occurred over the years, The group was able to take pictures and notes to identify which seeds may have historical identity to the Menominee. The counties of interest included; Fond du lac Outagamie Door Milwaukee Waupaca Winnebago Portage Sheboygan Racine In addition to the archaeological findings they also had a curated collection from a fur trader named Mumm that included seeds from northeast Wisconsin. The College of Menominee Nation staff identified samples of interest; 4 Amaranthus (genus of annual or short-lived perennials that includes leaf vegetables, 1989.19.249) 15 Chenopodium (Goosefoot, 1989.19.233) 1 Cornus seed (genus of dogwoods, 1984.91.2448) - this is from a Euroamerican occupation, would you still be interested in it? It is possible the family was Native using Euroamerican materials or they were partially Native, we don't know for sure. 2 Gramineae seed (genus of flowering grasses that includes cereals, maize, wheat, rice, barley, 1989.19.242) 1 Nicotiana rustica (tobacco, 1984.91.2382) - 20 Rubus seeds (genus of flowering plants that includes raspberries and blackberries, 1984.91.2391, 1984.91.2371, 1984.2382) 1 Trifolium seed (genus of flowering plants in the legume or pea family, 1984.91.2436) - this is also from a Euroamerican occupation. These requests for samples has triggered the Wisconsin Historical Society to develop a policy for sampling where as long as the request doesn't completely use up an accessioned item, a pathway is in place to hand over what is requested. The college's request was forwarded for approval by the Wisconsin Historical Society to the Wisconsin Inter-Tribal Repatriation Committee which is made up of all Tribal Historic Preservation Officers from the Tribes in the state. On September 14, 2023, the committee agreed to allow the seeds to be dispersed to the College of Menominee Nation for 'rematriation". The request included, 8- Rubus that include aster, daisy, and sunflowers, 3 - Rubus that include Chenopodium, 15 Rubus - that includes tobacco, 1 - Trifolium, 1 - American Hornbeam Tree, 20 Mumm seeds, 15 - Chenopodium, 2- Gramineae, 4 - Amaranthus. On December 14th, Jennifer Gauthier, Lizette Bailey, Lucy Grignon, Kes?pitay??men, Naneque LaTender, Wik?hsemen, and Kael Weshonquit traveled down to Madison to the Wisconsin Historical Society to rematriate 10 different varieties of ancient seeds that were in their archives. This was a long process to first go down and identify seeds from the area that were from archaeological projects years ago to then obtain permission to bring them back. The plan is to attempt to germinate these seeds and possibly grow them out for additional seeds. They are currently being housed in the college's temperature-controlled cooler. We werein touch with the Curator of Anthropology Collections at the Milwaukee Public Library as they have indicated they have Menominee and Stockbridge seeds housed in their Anthropology Department. We are planning a visit yet this summer to view the specimens. One of our female seed keepers was also able to visit Albany, New York and Albuquerque, New Mexicoto identify possible ancestral seeds of the Stockbridge-Munsee Tribe which is adjacent to the Menominee Reservation. Focus Areas: Archives Special Collections Botany Collections Stockbridge Beans Lenape Blue Corn Lenape White Corn Focus Areas: Lenape Blue Corn Lenape White Corn Hopi Blue Corn Since the summer of 2022, she collaborated with farms in New York that reside on the ancestral homelands of the Stockbridge tribe.Knowledge sharing, caring of the land, and important seed conversations happened. In 2023, she visited these samefarms, checking in on traditional seed relatives that were planted in the ancestral homelands soil. The seeds were thriving and doing such wonderful work on their homelands. Lenape is one of the 7 tribes that traveled with the Stockbridge Munsee Band of Mohican Nation when they were relocated from out East (MA and New York) to current-day Wisconsin. Researched growing traditional corn in different growing environments. Researched the traditional seed relatives and map out their trade routes.She connected with local seed keepers, knowledge bearers, and gardeners who have experience working with traditional seeds.

    Publications


      Progress 07/15/22 to 07/14/23

      Outputs
      Target Audience:The target audience for this grant is the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin and surrounding Tribes with an interest in bringing historical seeds back to their communities. This includes youth families, elders, and CMN students who are interested in restoring their historical knowledge and growing their own food. Changes/Problems:The first year of the project was right in the middle of COVID and this prevented us from traveling to museums and seed banks. We now have a team that has been able to work with museums and visit them within the Midwest which has brought rich opportunities for reconnecting to the seeds that were once grown in the area. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The collection of the results are still in the compilation phase. There is much to be learned from the research that is happening and we are looking forward to sharing it with the Tribal communities we serve. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?July 2023 - Work with Menominee consultant and Menominee student worker to attempt to germinate and plant seeds already in possession of the college that have historical meaning to the community and the region as well as continuing to pursue additional seeds from other sources. Two Menominee females are planning a visit to the Milwaukee Public Library to possibly rematriate the Menominee and Stockbridge seeds within the Anthropology Department. Additional community members with knowledge of traditional growing and seed germination will be brought in to assist with trying to grow these seeds out. August 2023 - Participants will continue to attempt to grow out seeds from various sources in order to build on the seed bank on campus that will have the history behind where the seeds came from and accompanying instructions. September 2023 - The group will practice learned seed saving techniques to ensure viability for future growing seasons. Stories will be documented both in writing and with video and pictures as to proper growing conditions and historical stories about the seeds.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? Sustainable Agriculture faculty, Dr. Frank Kutka, was able to acquire a list of seeds from the Science Museum of Minnesota with ties to historic indigenous communities in the Midwest. Dr. Kutka was also able to locate a bean seed from Seed Savers Exchange that was grown by the Lac Courte Orielles band of Chippewa in western Wisconsin in the early 1900s. Additionally, it was found that the USDA national seed bank had sunflower seeds that are of Menominee descent. Dr. Kutka is working on a paper to be submitted for publication in the Tribal College and University Research Journal about the regeneration of old seeds. Brian Kowalkowski, Dean of Continuing Education visited the Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian to try and get a connection to possible Menominee seeds being housed at the Smithsonian. There was no response after sharing contact information. Jennifer Gauthier, a Menominee female, interviewed and shared seeds with a local couple that has been growing a garden with organic heirloom seeds for many years. She was able to document the stories they shared with regard to where the seeds came from and their true meaning. Finally, after COVID traveling restrictions have been lifted, a group was able to the Wisconsin Historical Society in Madison, Wisconsin to meet with Jacqueline Pozza Reisner, Curator of American Indian Collections. This included Jennifer Gauthier (enrolled Menominee), Lucy Grignon (Enrolled Stockbridge and Menominee descendant), and Naneque Latender (enrolled Menominee). Ms. Reisner allowed the group to review an ancient seed collection from a list of over 25 counties in the State of Wisconsin from archaeological digs that occurred over the years, The group was able to take pictures and notes to identify which seeds may have historical identity to the Menominee. The counties of interest included; Fond du lac Outagamie Door Milwaukee Waupaca Winnebago Portage Sheboygan Racine In addition to the archaeological findings they also had a curated collection from a fur trader named Mumm that included seeds from northeast Wisconsin. The College of Menominee Nation staff identified samples of interest; 4 Amaranthus (genus of annual or short-lived perennials that includes leaf vegetables, 1989.19.249) 15 Chenopodium (Goosefoot, 1989.19.233) 1 Cornus seed (genus of dogwoods, 1984.91.2448) - this is from a Euroamerican occupation, would you still be interested in it? It is possible the family was Native using Euroamerican materials or they were partially Native, we don't know for sure. 2 Gramineae seed (genus of flowering grasses that includes cereals, maize, wheat, rice, barley, 1989.19.242) 1 Nicotiana rustica (tobacco, 1984.91.2382) - 20 Rubus seeds (genus of flowering plants that includes raspberries and blackberries, 1984.91.2391, 1984.91.2371, 1984.2382) 1 Trifolium seed (genus of flowering plants in the legume or pea family, 1984.91.2436) - this is also from a Euroamerican occupation. These requests for samples has triggered the Wisconsin Historical Society to develop a policy for sampling where as long as the request doesn't completely use up an accessioned item, a pathway is in place to hand over what is requested. We have been in touch with the Curator of Anthropology Collections at the Milwaukee Public Library as they have indicated they have Menominee and Stockbridge seeds housed in their Anthropology Department. We are planning a visit yet this summer to view the specimens.

      Publications


        Progress 07/15/21 to 07/14/22

        Outputs
        Target Audience:We continue to identify opportunities for heirloom seeds that are native to the Menominee community and try to preserve them and make them available to the Menominee community. Our audience continues to be local growers and elders who are in need of these culturally significant seeds and those that have the knowledge of where to find them. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have been able to participate in online webinars and training on seed saving as well as having partners attend the Conference on Native American Nutrition. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the fall and winter, we will be coordinating visits to a number of museums and sites we have researched where we are hoping to discover additional seeds to be brought back to the Menominee Reservation. We are also in the process of setting up interviews with local elders now that the majority of the community has been fully vaccinated. This will be conducted in a culturally appropriate manner so as to show respect to the individuals and their knowledge and family history. This will allow for the upcoming growing season to be one that will allow for Tribal Ecological Knowledge driven data that can be shared in an appropriate manner. Seed sharing among families will be encouraged as well as an opportunity for the college to hopefully also be able to obtain a sample amount for its seed library.

        Impacts
        What was accomplished under these goals? We requested and received a no-cost extension for this project from NIFA. As a result of COVID, we were not able to make visits to the museums and seeds banks we had hoped to. We also were very cautious about getting in contact with local elders so as not to put them at risk. A seed back has however been established and is currently being utilized by the community. The hope is to expand this opportunity with the extra time and the no-cost extension.

        Publications


          Progress 07/15/20 to 07/14/21

          Outputs
          Target Audience:We continue to identify opportunities for heirloom seeds that are native to the Menominee community and try to preserve them and make them available to the Menominee community. Our audience continues to be local growers and elders who are in need of these culturally significant seeds and those that have the knowledge of where to find them. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have been able to participate in online webinars and training on seed saving as well as having partners attend the Conference on Native American Nutrition. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the fall and winter, we will be coordinating visits to a number of museums and sites we have researched wherewe are hoping to discover additional seeds to be brought back to the Menominee Reservation. We are also in the process of setting up interviews with local elders now that the majority of the community has been fully vaccinated. This will be conducted in a culturally appropriate manner so as to show respect to the individuals and their knowledge and family history. This will allow for the upcoming growing season to be one that will allow for Tribal Ecological Knowledge driven data that can be shared in an appropriate manner. Seed sharing among families will be encouraged as well as an opportunity for the college to hopefully also be able to obtain a sample amount for its seed library.

          Impacts
          What was accomplished under these goals? We requested and received a no-costextension for this project from NIFA. As a result of COVID, we were not able to make visits to the museums and seeds banks we had hoped to. We also were very cautious about getting in contact with local elders so as not to put them at risk. A seed back has however been established and is currently being utilized by the community. The hope is to expand this opportunity with the extra time and the no-cost extension.

          Publications