Source: UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN submitted to NRP
EXPANDING GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE AS A RESPONSE TO ENVIRONMENTAL INJUSTICE AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1018287
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Nov 28, 2018
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2020
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
(N/A)
ANN ARBOR,MI 48109
Performing Department
Resource Ecology & Management
Non Technical Summary
A fundamental challenge to urban sustainability is how best to incorporate and balance multiple environmental, social, and economic considerations into planning processes. Land use decisions are often narrowly driven by one particular interest or benefit. This project will help develop the science necessary for effective spatial planning in a climate-constrained era by developing an approach to GI maintenance and expansion that is truly inclusive, interdisciplinary and transferable. In terms of broader impact, hundreds of millions of dollars is being poured into redevelopment of the Detroit region, with GI expansion as a major centerpiece and decisions about where and how to expand GI will have ramifications for decades to come. This project has the potential to significantly shape this expansion in a manner sensitive to environmental and social justice, in addition to traditional environmental benefits. Moreover, it will enable us to evaluate the multi-functionality of current and proposed GI, and compare them with historical land use patterns. This will help organizations and initiatives understand the effects of GI interventions by benefit (e.g. stormwater, heat island, etc.), future climate-informed pathways, and the options for siting to maximize multifunctionality (i.e. a suite of benefits rather than one or two). The GIS data layers and approach developed by this project will serve as a foundation for larger urban sustainability research projects in the Detroit region and beyond.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
50%
Developmental
30%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
12405302060100%
Knowledge Area
124 - Urban Forestry;

Subject Of Investigation
0530 - Parks and urban green space;

Field Of Science
2060 - Geography;
Goals / Objectives
Detroit is a city-region in renewal, after decades of socio-economic recession, urban decline, high land vacancy, and depopulation. The Detroit Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) consists of six counties (4000 sq. mi) and has abundant vacant and abandoned residential, commercial, and industrial property. There are ambitious plans to demolish properties and 'shrink' the city by concentrating stabilization efforts in target neighborhoods. In October 2018, recognizing the urgent and potentially irreversible threat of climate change, the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released a special report calling for ambitious adaptive mitigation efforts to limit global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. These ambitious "pathways", framed within the United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, center on transformational strategies to reduce emissions, enhance the natural CO2 sinks and stimulate adaptation options that lead to more climate-resilient systems.One emerging strategy for urban regeneration and as a means to enhance resilience and adaptive capacity is to expand green infrastructure (GI) -- the network of urban forests, greenways, parks and protected river basins that weave through a city's environs. GI can be conceptualized as a network of hubs or nodes composed of larger green patches and links (such as tree-lined streets). Not necessarily a green matrix connected throughout an urban area; GI is often fragmented with isolated pockets of green space. The ecosystem benefits of healthy and extensive GI are many (e.g. reduced stormwater flows, improved water quality, carbon sequestration) and studies indicate urban GI can improve property values and have multiple social, economic, health, and psychological benefits.The maintenance of existing urban forests and planting of new ones has emerged as a primary GI expansion strategy in city-regions worldwide. In the Detroit MSA, this is taking place through projects and initiatives. Since the early 1990s, the city-region has expanded greenways to transform abandoned industrial infrastructure and with funds from the US Forest Service, the NGO Greening of Detroit is planting trees primarily to improve stormwater retention and to reduce water pollution in Detroit's regional watersheds.The goal of this project is to take advantage of the momentum and support decisions toward social and environmental sustainability, equity, resilience and justice.
Project Methods
The research is divided into three phases, one for each project objective:1. Quantify changes in Detroit MSA's GI over a 25-year period (1992-2018): Given climate benefits from urban GI are going to accrue more significantly using the scale of the city-region, we will map GI changes for the entire Detroit MSA (1992 - 2018). We will develop a methodological guide and research manual for GI classification, a rigorous validation methodology of this process and step-by-step instructions for calculating landscape metrics. Changes will be distinguished by devising a multi-seasonal, multi-temporal approach, employing Landsat data, auxiliary variables, spectral controlling and automated sampling extraction based on no-change areas. These automatically generated samples will serve as training (70%) and validation (30%) for the Random Forests modeling framework. A suite of meaningful landscape metrics will be calculated to provide information about the size, density, isolation, proximity, connectivity and aggregation of GI patches. Change detection in the form of cross classification will then be applied at the GI patch level. The rigorous documentation of trends in GI along with the explicit "from-to" land use/cover change information, over the years, will act as a baseline to answer research questions and test hypotheses related to the drivers of these changes (e.g. population flows, sprawl, land abandonment). This spatial analysis will draw on spatial data sets already been collected (see below).2. Develop and deploy robust sustainability criteria to identify optimal sites for expanding GI in the Detroit MSA: The results generated in Phase 1 provide the baseline data for this effort. Indicators will be classified in broader categories reflecting the multifunctionality of GI and the ecosystem services they entail. In collaboration with an interdisciplinary group of SEAS and UM faculty and Detroit community collaborators, we will identify and weight the ecological and socio-economic criteria used to identify future optimal parcels for conserving and planting urban forests. Potential SEAS faculty include: Ibanez (forests and climate change), Nassauer (urban landscapes), Moore (ecosystem services), Grese (ecological restoration), Taylor (environmental justice and food access), Mohai (urban exposure to toxic pollutants), and Burton (urban stormwater and water quality). Community partners the PI has engaged with include: SEMCOG, City of Detroit Sustainability and Planning Offices, Data Driven Detroit, Detroit Future City, Greening of Detroit and Detroiters Working for Environmental Justice. We will deploy these indicators at multiple spatial scales (e.g. census block, NSP target areas, and zip code level) to see how the results and priority areas shift accordingly. As a test case, PI Newell has used this multi-criteria analysis approach to identify prospective new urban agricultural sites in Detroit's lower east side.3. Delineate future climate-resilient pathways reflecting different climatic realities and multi-dimensionality of GI: Scenarios will reflect prospective climate-resilient pathways. These scenarios will consider different climate trajectories based on IPCC GHG futures (low, medium, high), the range of benefits provided by GI (e.g. CO2 sequestration, stormwater abatement, improved air quality, urban heat island amelioration, increased green space, and landscape connectivity) and the feasibility of implementation. Co-PI Rood and Great Lakes Integrated Sciences and Assessments (GLISA) students/researchers will apply climate modeling techniques for the Detroit MSA to provide realistic spatial variability of certain variables (such as precipitation and surface air temperature) for the different future scenarios.

Progress 10/01/19 to 09/30/20

Outputs
Target Audience:Results stemming from this project mainly target stakeholders and city planners to assist in their decision making process. Moreover, region-specific results target other research teams working on the same area and related fields (USFS). In a more general context, the project also targets academics throughout the world by producing novel, transferable and replicable research published in international scientific journals. We have already published one article and a second manuscript will be submitted soon. This work would not have been possible without support from the McIntyre-Stennis Program. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has provided support and acted as a platform for a post-doctoral fellow to explore new methods and techniques in remote sensing, geospatial analysis and machine learning. In addition, the project supports three research assistants from two disciplines (sustainability-SEAS and urban planning-Taubman) who are exposed to research design and implementation, project management and scientific writing throughout the project's lifetime. The research assistants are actively involved in all analyses, writing, editing, and project meetings. Moreover, during the first year of the project, all participants had unique networking opportunities with stakeholders (Southeast Michigan Council of Governments -SEMCOG, American Forests, City of Detroit, Detroit Future City) and research specialists from the US Forest Service. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The project members have cultivated active collaboration with SEMCOG, American Forests, City of Detroit, Detroit Future City, and other collaborators. SEMCOG has released a plan to maintain and expand Green Infrastructure in the region and they anticipate our contribution to compare and inform their ongoing efforts. Moreover, the City of Detroit and the Washtenaw county are working on investing in open spaces to expand their green infrastructure and our project team works closely to assist with their goal. Specifically city and county level officials are actively collaborating with the team and regularly participate in our project meetings to develop GIS-based MCDA models tailored to their area of interest. Finally yet importantly, our project is closely followed by the U.S Forest Service which undertakes research to develop an urban forest climate change vulnerability assessment for the City of Detroit. The goals, orientation and preliminary results of the project have been communicated through two workshops held in Detroit (Sept 25, 2019) and online (Jan 26, 2021). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?After the project's lifetime we are committed to continuing work with stakeholders to operationalize our methodology on the ground. Aside from that, we are keen to continue working on the topic and pursue additional funding in collaboration with stakeholders and junior faculty. Specifically our work will be extended to state-wide application and we are exploring avenues to include future land cover projections in our analyses.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? This project has led to significant outcomes and outputs. We have published research in the journal Landscape Ecology that details our mapping of urban sprawl in southeast Michigan over 30 years and the impact of this low density single-family housing development on forests in the region. We mapped urban and road expansion at the individual building level in very high thematic resolution (10 building types). Vegetation was mapped at the tree canopy level capturing changes in larger forest patches and street trees. As phase two of this project, we are working with the City of Detroit and regional partners to develop a green infrastructure spatial planning model for siting future green space in a way that maximizes social and environmental benefits, and ecosystem services. The results of the multifunctional planning effort are detailed in a second journal article to be submitted to the Journal of the American Planning Association. Results from this project are already informing efforts and initiatives to expand Green Infrastructure in the region.

Publications


    Progress 11/28/18 to 09/30/20

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Results stemming from this project mainly targeted stakeholders and city planners (SEMCOG) to assist in their decision making process. Moreover, region-specific results target other research teams working on the same area and related fields (USFF). In a more general context, the project also targeted academics throughout the world by producing novel, transferable and replicable research published in international scientific journals. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has provided support and acted as a platform for a post-doctoral fellow to explore new methods and techniques in remote sensing, geospatial analysis and machine learning. In addition, the project supported three research assistants from two disciplines (sustainability-SEAS and urban planning-Taubman) who were exposed to research design and implementation, project management and scientific writing throughout the project's lifetime. The research assistants were actively involved in all analyses and project meetings. Moreover, during the project, all participants had unique networking opportunities with stakeholders (Southeast Michigan Council of Governments -SEMCOG) and research specialists from the US Forest Service - USFF. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The project members cultivated active collaboration with SEMCOG and the USFF from the beginning of the project. SEMCOG has released a plan to maintain and expand Green Infrastructure in the region and they anticipate our contribution to compare and inform their ongoing efforts. USFF undertakes research to develop an urban forest climate change vulnerability assessment for the City of Detroit. The goals, orientation and preliminary results of the project were communicated through a series of stakeholder workshops. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We devised a novel multiple criteria approach to explore future scenarios for the region through the prism of climate change. This approach built upon our previous findings and is expected to highlight areas that should be prioritized by SEMCOG for Green Infrastructure expansion and maintenance in order to maximize provisioning of multiple ecosystem serviced and to increase the adaptive capacity to climate change. For future projects, we expect to incorporate multiples climate scenarios in our future green infrastructure modeling.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? We mapped 30-years of land cover changes over southeast Michigan in unprecedented detail. Urban and road expansion was mapped at the individual building level with very high thematic resolution (10 building types). Based on this unique dataset we also calculated building density and characterized diachronic urban sprawl in the region. Vegetation was mapped at the tree canopy level capturing changes in larger forest patches and street trees. The interaction of these most pronounced categories was examined with the use of patch-level metrics. We calculated landscape structure and composition indices over the 30 years to examine fragmentation and changes in connectivity of forests as a response to urbanization patterns. Our results have informed current and ongoing efforts to expand Green Infrastructure in the region.

    Publications


      Progress 11/28/18 to 09/30/19

      Outputs
      Target Audience:Results stemming from this project mainly target stakeholders and city planners (SEMCOG) to assist in their decision making process. Moreover, region-specific results target other research teams working on the same area and related fields (USFF). In a more general context, the project also targets academics throughout the world by producing novel, transferable and replicable research published in international scientific journals Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has provided support and acted as a platform for a post-doctoral fellow to explore new methods and techniques in remote sensing, geospatial analysis and machine learning. In addition, the project supports three research assistants from two disciplines (sustainability-SEAS and urban planning-Taubman) who are exposed to research design and implementation, project management and scientific writing throughout the project's lifetime. The research assistants are actively involved in all analyses and project meetings. Moreover, during the first year of the project, all participants had unique networking opportunities with stakeholders (Southeast Michigan Council of Governments -SEMCOG) and research specialists from the US Forest Service - USFF. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The project members have cultivated active collaboration with SEMCOG and the USFF from the beginning of the project. SEMCOG has released a plan to maintain and expand Green Infrastructure in the region and they anticipate our contribution to compare and inform their ongoing efforts. USFF undertakes research to develop an urban forest climate change vulnerability assessment for the City of Detroit. The goals, orientation and preliminary results of the project has been communicated through four 1hour meetings and one workshop held in Detroit (Sept 25, 2019). The next workshop in Detroit is already scheduled for Aug 3-4, 2020 to communicate findings and future directions. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We are in the process of devising a novel multiple criteria approach to explore future scenarios for the region through the prism of climate change. This approach will build upon our previous findings and is expected to highlight areas that should be prioritized by SEMCOG for Green Infrastructure expansion and maintenance in order to maximize provisioning of multiple ecosystem serviced and to increase the adaptive capacity to climate change. Multiples climate scenarios delineated by the Great Lakes Integrated Sciences and Assessments will be integrated into the future land cover framework.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We mapped 30-years of land cover changes over southeast Michigan in unprecedented detail. Urban and roads expansion was mapped at the individual building level with very high thematic resolution (10 building types). Based on this unique dataset we also calculated building density and characterized diachronic urban sprawl in the region. Vegetation was mapped at the tree canopy level capturing changes in larger forest patches and street trees. The interaction of these most pronounced categories was examined with the use of patch-level metrics. We calculated landscape structure and composition indices over the 30 years to examine fragmentation and changes in connectivity of forests as a response to urbanization patterns. Our results are expected to inform current and ongoing efforts to expand Green Infrastructure in the region.

      Publications