Source: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS submitted to NRP
DESIGNING FUTURE FOODS FOR HEALTH - A NEW COURSE FOR FOOD SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING CURRICULA
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1018256
Grant No.
2019-70003-29094
Cumulative Award Amt.
$149,819.00
Proposal No.
2018-05552
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Dec 15, 2018
Project End Date
Dec 14, 2022
Grant Year
2019
Program Code
[ER]- Higher Ed Challenge
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
410 MRAK HALL
DAVIS,CA 95616-8671
Performing Department
Ag:Biological & Ag Engineering
Non Technical Summary
The quest to manufacture foods with targeted health benefits is an underpinning goal of the modern food industry. Unfortunately, most undergraduate curricula in food science and engineering are seriously lacking exposure of students to topics related to design of foods for health. The functional role of the human gastrointestinal tract in breaking down food matrices to extract nutritional compounds from the food macro- and microstructure is seldom taught in detail. There are no textbooks or other teaching resources available in this area. To remedy this critical deficiency, this proposal addresses the development of a course for undergraduate students focused at the interface between food science and nutrition, for designing the future generation of foods for health. Curricular materials will be developed using the "flipped classroom" method. These resources will include Internet-mediated course contents, such as video tutorials, virtual experiments, group quizzes, group discussion questions, and problem sets. The new course will be taught at UC Davis, and student learning will be assessed. To enhance project impact, all Internet-mediated contents developed in this project will be made available as open source for any instructor to use in their own teaching, and as a resource for food industry professionals. The information in the proposed course will increase the technical skills of graduates in food and agricultural sciences in a critical, emerging area, to ensure that the US food manufacturing industry remains globally competitive with its future hires who are able to provide increased insight in design of foods for health.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
100%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5025010101025%
5025010202025%
5025010200025%
5025010102025%
Goals / Objectives
The overall goal of this project is to develop a new course for students in the food and agricultural sciences in the emerging area of designing future foods for health, a key need for the US food manufacturing industry. In addition to the course contents, teaching/learning resources will be developed using Internet-mediated technologies and methods that have been widely proven as effective in instruction.The specific objectives of this project are:Develop video tutorials for a course "Designing Future Food for Health" for use in a "flipped classroom" approach of teaching.Create critical thinking activities involving simulations, virtual experiments, and open-ended discussion questions for use during in-class instruction.Evaluate student learning in selected knowledge areas as a result of taking the new course at UC Davis.
Project Methods
Methods Utilized for Development of Course MaterialsTo adequately understand the prior knowledge of the student audience who will be taking this new course prior to the course material development, we will conduct an initial knowledge survey of the target student audience at the beginning of the project. Undergraduate students (n = 50-60) will be selected to take the knowledge survey. At least 30 students will be selected from food science, and 10-15 students each will be selected from animal science and nutrition. The students will be in the 4th or 5th year of their undergraduate program, as this is the target audience for the course. The food science students will be recruited through a required, senior-level course currently taught by PD Bornhorst (FST110, Food Processing). Nutrition and animal science students will be recruited through similar courses, such as Experimental Nutrition (NUT117) and Lab Animal Management (ANS140). These students will be a representative sample of potential students for the new course. The knowledge survey questions will be a combination of multiple choice and open-ended questions. The information gained from the knowledge surveys will be utilized to tailor the level of the course contents to enhance student learning.Following the prior knowledge assessment of the target student audience, learning objectives will be established for all weekly topics. A learning objective will be articulated based on a student's previous knowledge of the topic (from the surveys described above) and the terminal behavior expected upon completion of a given educational unit. Care will be taken that each terminal behavior is described in actionable terms to communicate clearly what the students will be able to do. Bloom's taxonomy of educational objectives will be used to progress through a hierarchy of the six cognitive skills, from knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, and synthesis, to evaluation.The PDs will develop learning objectives for each general topic area, as well as for each lecture topic. This information will be provided to any other instructors who plan to use the course material. Based on the learning objectives, assessment questions will be developed to determine if the learning objectives have been successfully met, in collaboration with the Center for Education Effectiveness at UC Davis. Results from the assessments will be used in any follow up improvements of the course content and delivery methods. After formulating specific learning objectives for each lecture, the contents of the pre- and in-class materials for each lecture will be developed.Structure of Pre-Class and In-Class Activities The lecture material will be designed for 50-minute class periods. For each lecture involving tutorials (Lecture 1, 2, and some of Lecture 4 for each topic), students will be expected to spend 20-30 minutes outside of class viewing the tutorials, which will be posted on YouTube, and they will take a short (~5 question) online quiz to ensure that they have viewed and understood the contents of the tutorials. At the beginning of each in-class lecture period, the students will spend the first 10-15 minutes taking a group quiz, where they will be required to discuss their answers in groups of 3-4 students. If teams cannot come to a consensus about their answer, discussion may ensue between groups (facilitated with the instructor) to assist in active engagement with the course material. The quiz grade will consist of the individual online quiz as well as the group quiz.Following the group quiz, students will remain in their groups to complete a set of discussion questions that are based on the information they have viewed in the lecture tutorials prior to class for another 25-30 minutes; during the first 15 mins the students will work on the problems in groups, and the final 10-15 min of the class period will be a facilitated discussion with the instructor. Every week, each group will be assigned a group leader by the instructor; this role will rotate among the members weekly, such that students will have 2-3 opportunities during a quarter course or 4-5 opportunities during a semester course to assume a leadership role. The group leader will be responsible for facilitating the group discussion and preparing the group's solution to the assigned problems. The last 5-10 mins of the class period will be used for groups to present their answers to the class. The group leader will be responsible to present the team's solutions, which will have the added benefit of developing communication skills.During the discussion and presentations, the instructor will offer additional topical insights. If necessary, "micro-lectures", or short explanations of key concepts (~1-3 min) will be given if students are having trouble with certain material.For the lectures involving virtual labs, there will be no preparation required prior to class. During the class period, the time will be devoted mainly to problem solving experiences. Virtual experiments will be used for students to sharpen their skills in conducting "what-if" analyses as well as view results from simulations of experiments about a given topic. After testing different conditions in virtual experiments, students will be required to critically analyze their data and provide recommendations on optimal conditions to produce certain outcomes. They will begin discussion of these questions in class and will be required to complete a homework assignment that will include comparison of several different conditions that can be tested in the virtual experiment. In addition, they will be asked to write a short answer (< 1 page) to a critical thinking and analysis question based on the results of the virtual experiment that will apply the knowledge from the week's general topic to a relevant scenario in the food manufacturing industry. Promoting critical thinking and problem solving skills through virtual experiments and short answer analyses will additionally help to increase student leadership development, preparing students to be competitive in the global workforce.Evaluation of Education MaterialsFor evaluation of the student learning as a result of the proposed course, a pre-course knowledge survey will be given to all students in the class when it is taught. The survey questions will be designed in consultation with the Center for Education Effectiveness at UC Davis. The questions will be a combination of multiple choice and open-ended questions. Students will be given a similar assessment at the end of the course to evaluate their learning in the specific technical areas identified prior to the course.

Progress 12/15/18 to 12/14/22

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience consists of undergraduate students, instructors, and other researchers working on the design of functional foods for health. As the video content developed as part of this project is available online (via YouTube and PD Bornhorst's faculty website), the general public will also benefit from these materials. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project provided professional development for the two PDs in the project. There were educational opportunities provided for the nine students that participated in the course that was taught as part of this project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The target audience consists of undergraduate students, instructors, and other researchers working on the design of functional foods for health. The course was taught for the first time in Fall 2022 (September - December, 2022) at the University of California, Davis and had nine students enrolled from both food science and food engineering backgrounds. As proposed in the project, the course was a hybrid course, following the "flipped classroom" design, where students would watch 4-5 videos prior to coming to class, they would complete a quiz either online or in-class, and the class period focused on discussion and interactive activities. The video content developed as part of this project is available either on YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@RPaulSingh/videos) as well as on Prof. Bornhorst's faculty page (https://faculty.engineering.ucdavis.edu/bornhorst/teaching/teaching-resources-videos/). For four course modules (Oral Digestion Overview & Saliva Basics; Food Breakdown during Oral Digestion; Swallowing, the Esophagus, and Gastric Secretions; and Gastric Motility, Emptying, and Food Breakdown) note templates are also provided to supplement the videos developed for the course. Other course materials are available to instructors upon request. Both instructors as well as general public members can view all of the videos developed as part of this project, which will allow them to gain new knowledge and directly benefit from the activities in this project. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Over the course of the project, 48 videos were developed as part of 9 modules. Videos for each module include: Module 1: Oral Digestion Overview & Saliva Basics - ~28 min of video content in 4 videos: Oral Digestion Definitions, Oral Anatomy, Salivary Secretions, Saliva Function Module 2: Food Breakdown during Oral Digestion - ~56 min of video content in 5 videos: Salivary Enzymes, Mechanical Breakdown & Food Properties, Particle Size Determination, Determination of Rosin-Rammler Model Parameters using Excel Solver, Pathway to Swallow Module 3: Swallowing, the Esophagus, and Gastric Secretions - ~46 min of video content in 5 videos: Swallowing & the Esophagus, Gastric Anatomy and Basic Function, Gastric Secretions, Regulation of Gastric Secretions, Postprandial Gastric pH Distribution Module 4: Gastric Motility, Emptying, and Food Breakdown - ~ 36 min of video content in 5 videos: Postprandial Gastric Motility, Fasting Gastric Motility, Gastric Emptying, Models to Describe Gastric Emptying, Food Breakdown during Gastric Digestion Module 5: Physical Properties of Foods Important in Studying Digestion - ~ 37 min of video content in 8 videos: Introduction to Food Rheology, Force and Deformation, Stress and Strain, Young's Modulus, Shear Modulus, Bulk Modulus, Fundamental and Empirical Tests, Texture Profile Analysis Module 6. Physical Properties of Liquid Foods Important in the Food Digestion Processes- ~33 min of video content with animations in 7 videos: Viscosity, Newtonian fluids, Pseudoplastic liquids, Bingham liquids, Dilatant liquids, Herschel Bulkley liquids, Apparent viscosity, Elastic and viscous Module 7: Small Intestinal Anatomy, Motor Activity, Secretions, and the Pancreas - ~32 min of video content in 4 videos: Small Intestine - Anatomy, Pancreas - Anatomy, Small Intestinal Motility, Small Intestinal Secretions Module 8: Small Intestinal Secretions and Absorption Mechanisms, Carbohydrate Digestion and Absorption - ~32 min of video content in 6 videos: Small Intestinal Secretions, Small Intestine Absorption, Role of Microvilli in Absorption, Carbohydrate Introduction, Carbohydrate Digestion - Enzymes, Carbohydrate Absorption Module 9: Protein Absorption, Lipid Absorption, and the Large Intestine - ~20 min of video content in 4 videos: Protein Digestion - Introduction, Protein Digestion, Fat Digestion and Absorption, Large Intestine - Anatomy, Digestion, and Absorption In addition to the video material for each module, note outlines have been developed for learners to fill in while they are watching videos and aid in note-taking. The videos and note outlines for Modules 1-4 are posted on Prof. Bornhorst's website (https://faculty.engineering.ucdavis.edu/bornhorst/teaching/teaching-resources-videos/). The videos from Modules 5 - 9 are posted on YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@RPaulSingh/videos). To assess student learning after viewing the videos from each module, 10-20 quiz questions were developed (per module). These quiz questions were either utilized: only online; only in class; a combination of online with a group quiz in class. Use of the group quiz in class allowed for students to discuss course material and facilitated peer-peer learning. For each module, in-class quantitative example problems, case studies for discussion, and practical examples were developed. For example, in class example problems included calculation of bolus cohesive forces during mastication, calculation of the Demeester Score (for diagnosis of gastroesophageal reflux disease), and calculation of gastric emptying half time for different types of foods. Examples of practical examples and activities that were completed in class included an activity to estimate saliva secretion with foods of varying moisture content, and determination of chewing time for foods with varying moisture content and texture, including understanding inter-individual variations in mastication parameters. Examples of case studies developed include xerostomia and impacts on food digestion, and design of foods for consumers with gastroesophageal reflux disease. To reinforce the course material, five homework assignments were developed. These homework assignments included problems on: development of an infographic on oral digestion to compare and contrast between healthy adults and those with xerostomia; calculation of bolus cohesive forces for adults with normal saliva and with increased saliva viscosity due to xerostomia or medication; estimation of non-linear model parameters to quantify particle size distribution during simulated mastication and gastric digestion of almonds; understanding the "3D oral processing model" for varying food types for the amount of chewing time needed prior to a swallow; estimation of gastric emptying half time and interpretation of in vivo gastric emptying data of different meal macronutrients; development of an infographic to compare and contrast the breakdown processes in the proximal and distal stomach; and determination of kinetic parameters of a model to describe starch hydrolysis. As part of a homework assignment, students conducted a virtual experiment to determine rheological properties of a non-Newtonian liquid. The virtual experiment mimicked a laboratory experiment using a rheometer. Students collected data from the virtual experiment to calculate consistency coefficient and flow behavior index of the given liquid using Excel. In another homework assignment students were given data sets to plot blood glucose values and calculate glycemic index upon consumption of different foods. To enhance understanding of pancreatic secretions, students developed infographic of pancreatic enzyme secretions into small intestine and their activities. These course materials were utilized in teaching a new course, taught as EBS189F - Food Digestion & Functional Food Design. The course was taught for the first time in Fall 2022 (September - December, 2022) at the University of California, Davis and had nine students enrolled from both food science and food engineering backgrounds. As proposed in the project, the course was a hybrid course, following the "flipped classroom" design, where students would watch 4-5 videos prior to coming to class, they would complete a quiz either online or in-class, and the class period focused on discussion and interactive activities. After viewing all of the course videos in Modules 1-9 (described above), and completing the quizzes and homework assignments, at the end of the course, students were challenged with a food product design project where they had to design two food products for diverse consumers. The first product was for a consumer who is seeking satiety and weight loss. The second product was for a consumer who wants rapid energy prior to a workout. As part of this capstone project, students were asked to describe the target food behavior in the oral, gastric, and small intestinal environment for each of the 2 types of consumers, based on what they had learned in the course. Then, they were asked to design two food products, one product that could fulfill the requirements for each of the two different consumers. Finally, they were asked to synthesize the class information in connection with their prior knowledge about food and hypothesize about the behavior of their two food products in the upper gastrointestinal tract (mouth, stomach, small intestine). The students completed this design project in interdisciplinary teams (all teams had a mix of engineering and food science students).

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2022 Citation: R. Paul Singh and Gail M. Bornhorst. An online course to teach food digestion for the design of future foods for health. Abstract #233. Conference of Food Engineering. Raleigh, North Carolina. September 19 - 21, 2022.


Progress 12/15/20 to 12/14/21

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience consists of undergraduate students, instructors, and other researchers working on the design of functional foods for health. This progress report is based on the content developed so far for the digestion course. Once all of the content is prepared, we plan to disseminate it via YouTube to a wide audience of instructors, students, and researchers. In addition to the target audience, the general public will also be able to view the course videos, so they will ultimately be able to gain new knowledge and directly benefit from the activities in this project. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next project period, we plan to finalize the videos and course materials for the new course. We plan to teach a pilot version of the course at UC Davis that will utilize the course materials developed in this project. This pilot course offering will help the PIs get additional feedback on the course videos and activities to modify these items for future use. Once the videos are finalized, we plan to disseminate them on YouTube for free and widespread access by the target audience.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Additional video tutorials have been developed to be utilized as part of the "flipped classroom" lecture material that students would watch prior to coming to an in-person class session. During the reporting period, videos on oral anatomy, saliva secretion at the macro- and microscale, saliva function, salivary enzymes, variations in salivary amylase secretion due to individual and physiological and physical factors, saliva properties, protein hydrolysis, carbohydrate hydrolysis, and lipid hydrolysis have been developed. As part of the video development, detailed illustrations and animations have been designed to clearly convey course concepts, for example, on the anatomy of a secretory gland in the oral cavity for secretion of saliva. In addition to video development, other course material has been developed, including lecture and video note outlines (e.g. fillable notes for students to use while watching videos or while in class), detailed learning objectives for lectures, in-class examples and case studies to utilize as part of the in-person course component, and calculations to be performed in-class or as homework problems. For each lecture, quiz questions have also been developed based on the video material that students would either complete online or during the in-person lecture. For an example of the material that has been developed, for the lectures on oral digestion and saliva secretion, learning outcomes were drafted to guide the video and in-class material development. Then, material for each lecture was developed to build concepts that would allow students to achieve the desired learning outcomes. For example, for the first lecture on oral digestion, videos were developed to give definitions of general terms that would be utilized in the subsequent lectures, then the oral anatomy was explained and detailed illustrations were utilized to show a lateral and anterior view of the oral cavity. Then, additional videos were developed to explain saliva secretion, using detailed illustrations to show both the location of salivary glands in the oral cavity, and also to show the specific secretory cells within a salivary gland. Finally, videos were developed to explain general saliva function, and to give information on salivary amylase purpose, activity, and action. Fillable notes were developed for students to utilize while watching the videos that would help them fill in important concepts while providing them with key illustrations and information so they would not need to copy all information from the videos while they were watching. Quiz questions were developed based on the information conveyed in the videos, for example, to ask students about the location and function of different salivary glands, to identify salivary glands on a diagram, and to identify different key components of salivary secretions. Then, for the in-class material, course notes were developed to be utilized in the accompanying in-person lecture to the online videos. For the first lecture on oral digestion, an interactive example was developed for students to examine variations in saliva secretion while chewing foods with different properties during the class. To complement this interactive example, a case study was developed for students to critically examine xerostomia (commonly known as dry mouth), and how this may impact oral digestion and overall food and health in certain populations. In addition to the video tutorials and lecture material, topics for virtual labs have been developed and online formatting for videos has been investigated to adapt content to appropriate virtual environments suitable for widespread dissemination.

Publications


    Progress 12/15/19 to 12/14/20

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target audience is undergraduate and graduate students, as well as industry professionals who are looking to learn more about food digestion. Changes/Problems:Due to laboratory occupancy restrictions as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, the development of virtual laboratory assignments that require filming laboratory experiments and collection of data in the laboratory (with multiple people present) have been delayed. It is anticipated that later in 2021, the university will allow additional personnel into laboratories simultaneously to allow for filming of video and collection of data needed for these experiments. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?As the video tutorials and other educational materials are still in progress, they have not yet been disseminated to the communities of interest. As the videos become finalized, they will be available on YouTube for free viewing, and will be publicized through professional groups by the PDs. To test the dissemination of online content to practicing professionals and students, we uploaded an introductory video on food properties (force and deformation related to food digestion) on YouTube (https://youtu.be/Ejf0ehkDi8o). Since its upload, it has garnered 802 views with positive comments. We will be organizing other lecture videos using playlists for general dissemination of content related to food digestion. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next reporting period, we will continue preparing additional video tutorials, problem sets, guest lecture videos, and virtual laboratory experiments. We will use the experience gained from preparation of the first set of tutorials to refine the later videos and ensure that all educational materials work together to achieve the stated course learning outcomes.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? In the past year, significant progress has been made on developing the video tutorials proposed in this project. Videos and animations have been developed on specific topics related to physical properties needed to understand food breakdown during digestion, oral digestion, and intestinal digestion. Additional work has been done in preparing animations and graphics to be utilized in tutorials of the gastrointestinal tract. We have developed learning outcomes for each topical area to guide instructors who may use these content for their classes. We have created several numerical examples for different topics within this course. These numerical examples will be provided to the instructors for use as in-class or homework problems. In addition, a graduate course on food digestion was taught online in Spring 2020 (EBS289F - Engineering Food Digestion), where a series of videos were developed on advanced topics related to food digestion. As some of the basic anatomical and functional information conveyed in these videos is the same as what is being developed in this project, the student feedback and experience from this course is being incorporated into development of the video tutorials for the undergraduate-level class in this project.

    Publications


      Progress 12/15/18 to 12/14/19

      Outputs
      Target Audience:The target audience of this project is to students, researchers, and faculty both inside and outside UC Davis. The proposed course materials are in preparation, but to test its access by users on the Internet, a sample video tutorial was uploaded on YouTube. Since upload, (August 2019) the tutorial has been viewed by 395 viewers from around the world (as of February 24, 2020). Data provided by Google Analytics will be analyzed for all future uploaded tutorials to gain a better understanding of the user demographics to ensure the target audience is being reached. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?As the educational materials are still under development there have been limited professional development opportunities. However, one PhD student was involved in gathering course materials and will be involved in the future in creating specific materials for the course contents. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?As the educational materials are still largely under development they have not yet been disseminated to all stakeholders of interest. However, the videos that have been posted online have received considerable interest. A sample tutorial on "force and deformation" to characterize physical properties of digesta has been viewed by 395 viewers (as of February 24, 2020). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next reporting period, a knowledge survey will be administered to current students in FST110L (senior-level food science course) and EBS170 (senior-level biological systems engineering course). In addition, the tutorial preparation will continue. Animations and graphics will be developed to include in the tutorials and the virtual labs. The virtual lab experiments will be developed and tested by current undergraduate and graduate students. Course assignments will be developed, with plans to teach the new course at UC Davis during the coming academic year.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? Preparation of tutorials on various topics related to the course is proceeding as planned. The tutorials will be uploaded on YouTube for each lecture topic. Similarly, outlines for laboratory experiments are in preparation, and audio/video footage will be recorded during the Spring/Summer of 2020. They will be converted into virtual experiments for online access in coming months. Resources for graphics and videos have been procured from the university library using medical (and other) reference books, and will be used to develop graphics and animations for video tutorials and virtual labs. Work is also progressing on planning student assignments.

      Publications

      • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: R. Paul Singh, Gail M. Bornhorst. Strengthening food engineering education with courses on novel and emerging topics. International Congress of Engineering in Food (ICEF13). September 23-26, 2019. Melbourne, Australia.