Source: NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV submitted to NRP
PLANNING TO OPTIMIZE THE QUALITY OF STRAWBERRY NURSERY PRODUCTION IN FULL CONTROLLED ENVIRONMENT SYSTEMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1016461
Grant No.
2018-51181-28382
Cumulative Award Amt.
$47,168.00
Proposal No.
2018-03315
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2018
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2020
Grant Year
2018
Program Code
[SCRI]- Specialty Crop Research Initiative
Recipient Organization
NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV
(N/A)
RALEIGH,NC 27695
Performing Department
Horticulture Science
Non Technical Summary
The U.S. strawberry industry farm gate value is approximately $2.3 billion. CurrentlyCalifornia contributes 78% ($1.8b), Florida 19% ($449m) and North Carolina 1% ($27m) to theeconomy. The bulk of the strawberry planting material for production fields comes from nurseryoperations in the U.S. and Canada. Those strawberry nursery production systems are costlymulti-year and multi-location operations and are limited to select environmental favorableregions. This process of mostly field based plant propagation presents multiple risks forpropagators and strawberry growers, and therefore for the industry as a whole. Field basedoperations increase the risk of spreading plant borne pathogens. While these can be symptomlessand thus not recognized in propagation fields, disease symptoms under fruiting field conditionscan lead to significant losses. These threats are predicted to increase if the Methyl Bromideexempt use runs out and it is not available any longer as soil fumigant to the strawberry nurseryindustry. Moreover, changes in weather patterns, increasing costs for transportation and laborand consumer shifts to organic production make current strawberry nursery systems in the U.S.economically less efficient and potentially unsustainable.The overall aim of the proposed project is to support the development of indoorpropagation strategies to provide a low-risk, cost-effective and dependable supply of high qualityand disease free strawberry plants for producers. The project aims to support the futurecompetitiveness and sustainability of the US strawberry industry by designing precision indoorpropagation (PIP) tools to optimize strawberry nursery production and to develop disease-free propagation material. PIP is defined as the production of propagation material under fullycontrolled environments and under the exemption of natural sunlight. The PIP systems allow theprecise optimization of environmental components (e.g. light, CO2, temperature, humidity, airvelocity, nutrients) to maximize propagation efficiency, reduce pathogenic risks, and increaseeconomic returns. The benefits will be shared by nurseries and by growers of every sizeoperation and can be applied beyond PIP systems (e.g. pathogen detection, nutrition, breeding).The objectives of the proposed planning phase are:(1) the development of a strategic plan to address the cost-effective optimization of PIPfor future strawberry nursery production. This will be realized by holding a 2-day meeting withcollaboration partners in Kannapolis, NC end of June/begin of July. The work will yield a SCRISREP or CAP full proposal, formulated and shaped by face-to-face collaboration and industryengagement(2) The assessment and evaluation of specific needs for research, effective outreach andeducation, specifically about PIP systems. This will be realized by an industry needs surveybefore the meeting. This will be indicative for the a successful SCRI SREP or CAP full proposaland will be conducted as a broader survey of nursery operations, extension services and industrypartners.The proposed project addresses three legislatively mandated focus areas (1) Research inplant breeding, genomics and other methods to improve crop characteristics. As indicatedabove, using genetic tools to improve crop characteristics such as runner production or pathogenresistance will be an integrated part of this project. (2) Identify and address threats from pestsand diseases. The production of disease-free plant material is a central aim of this project andrequires the implementation of detection methods and the development of protocols for indoorpropagation systems. (3) Improve production efficacy and profitability long-term. Another majoraim of this project is the development of low-cost, high efficacy and flexible PIP tools forstrawberry nursery operations. This aim will be steered by economic evaluations and cost-benefitanalyses.The expected outcome is: (1) Intensifying transdisciplinary teams between industry andscientists to address strawberry PIP systems. (2) Identifying industry needs (3) One or moreSCRI full project teams and proposals.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2051122108115%
2051122101015%
2051122110110%
2051122110210%
2051122301020%
2051122113010%
2051122202020%
Goals / Objectives
The overall aim of the proposed project is to support the development of indoorpropagation strategies to provide a low-risk, cost-effective and dependable supply of high qualityand disease free strawberry plants for producers. The project aims to support the futurecompetitiveness and sustainability of the US strawberry industry by designing precision indoorpropagation (PIP) tools to optimize strawberry nursery production and to develop disease-free propagation material. PIP is defined as the production of propagation material under fullycontrolled environments and under the exemption of natural sunlight. The PIP systems allow theprecise optimization of environmental components (e.g. light, CO2, temperature, humidity, airvelocity, nutrients) to maximize propagation efficiency, reduce pathogenic risks, and increaseeconomic returns. The benefits will be shared by nurseries and by growers of every sizeoperation and can be applied beyond PIP systems (e.g. pathogen detection, nutrition, breeding).The objectives of the proposed planning phase are:(1) the development of a strategic plan to address the cost-effective optimization of PIPfor future strawberry nursery production. This will be realized by holding a 2-day meeting withcollaboration partners in Kannapolis, NC end of June/begin of July. The work will yield a SCRISREP or CAP full proposal, formulated and shaped by face-to-face collaboration and industryengagement(2) The assessment and evaluation of specific needs for research, effective outreach andeducation, specifically about PIP systems. This will be realized by an industry needs surveybefore the meeting. This will be indicative for the a successful SCRI SREP or CAP full proposaland will be conducted as a broader survey of nursery operations, extension services and industrypartners.
Project Methods
A industry need survey will be held before and during the meeting. A 2-day meeting for all stakeholders is planned insummer in North Carolina. A steering committee and an advisory panel has been built beforehand to realize the agenda and invitations.The meeting will have following objectives:(1) Share and discuss the results of a industry need survey; (2) Develop a vision for one or more follow up SCRISREP/CAP proposals; (3) Identify and discuss project priorities in theme based outbreak groups(4) Identify key objectives and key team members in theme based outbreak groups; (5) Discussresults and develop a common strategy for a full research and outreach SCRI SREP/CAP project;The aim of this meeting is to have a supported and feasible structure of a SCRISREP/CAP full project and committed and responsible team members in all areas of interest.On day 1, the meeting will start with a general introduction and educational session aboutcontrolled environment techniques and associated costs, led by Dr. Ricardo Hernandez (NCSU).After that, Co-PIs and selected collaborators will give a short overview of recent research andtheir vision of PIP development in strawberry. In the following, a general program vision will bediscussed under lead of chair and co-chair. Later, breakout session will be conducted to discussspecific program goals, objectives and team leaders.On day 2, results of those breakout sessionswill be shared by designated team leaders. Discussion about team specific and holistic budgetdecisions (such as e.g. a program managment assistant) will be held, led by chair and co-chair (tobe determined) with the aim to develop an overall rough budget, define team leaders, timelineand a personnel plan for a full SCRI proposal.1. Finalize roles in advisory panel and steering committee. Industry representatives,growers, association stakeholders and scientists will form steering committee and advisory panel.The roles of committee and panel members will be defined. The advisory panel will play animportant advisory and evaluation role for the project, while the steering committee mainly hasorganizational duties. Communication and organization within the panel and the committee willbe organized via conference calls, phone calls and emails. Panel and committee will decide andsend out invitations.2. Assess nursery industry needs. The second activity of the proposed project is to assessthe industry needs through a nation-wide survey and a follow up group discussion before themeeting. The survey will be developed with input from project leaders, but vetted and approvedby the advisory committee. This survey will assess needs and problems related to the strawberrynursery and propagation industry. Notification of the on-line survey will be distributed throughgrower associations, researcher/outreach networks and publications.3. Develop a SCRI SREP/CAP proposal..

Progress 09/01/19 to 08/31/20

Outputs
Target Audience: Strawberry nurseries in the U.S. and Canada Strawberry breeding programs in the U.S. and Europe. Strawberry grower Associations in the U.S. Strawberry distribution industry in the U.S. Strawberry licensing industry in the U.S. Greenhouse and Vertical Farming Industry in the U.S. Strawberry Growers nationwide. Strawerrry and Controlled Environment Reserach Community Changes/Problems:To the knowledge of the PD, this is the first project that targets all strawberry nursery partners in the US and Canada. Until now, the industry has been subject of rather discontinued research efforts. As a result, the industryis not very well known to the research community, and trusted relationships have to be developed over time. This circumstance has affected the integrity of objectives in the first SCRI full application. However, indsutry partners as well as research partners have agreed to work much closer togehter for the second SCRI application (currently to be prepared), and we made large progress on the integration and coherence of the project already. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Graduate Students were engaged in some of the industry meetings. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Research results are published in journal, dissertation. Results were shared through meetings and presentations with indsutry partners. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Submit SCRI SRS Sumit full SCRI Proposal

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal (1). A full SCRI SREP proposal ($4.5 M) was developed and submitted (Hoffmann PD). Although not successful, the reviews are being used to engage industry and collaboration partners for a new submssion for the 2020/21 cycle. Goal (2). 5 Vitrual indsutry-univeristy needs assessment and collaboration meetings were hold as response to the 2020 proposal reviews. Insights gathered at those meetings are currently used to inform and shape the 2020/21 proposal application.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Submitted Year Published: 2020 Citation: Shi, X., Hern�ndez, R. and Hoffmann, M. 2020. Timing of stolon removal alters daughter plant production and quality in the long-day strawberry (Fragaria x ananassa) cultivar Albion. HortScience (submitted).
  • Type: Theses/Dissertations Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Shi, Xiaonan. 2020. Impact of Stolon Removal Intervals and Nitrogen Source Ratios on Propagation of Long-day Strawberries (Fragaria �ananassa 'Albion') in Soil-less Greenhouse and Controlled Environment Systems. Master Thesis, North Carolina State Univeristy.
  • Type: Websites Status: Awaiting Publication Year Published: 2020 Citation: Project Homepage: http://strawberries-pip.cals.ncsu.edu


Progress 09/01/18 to 08/31/20

Outputs
Target Audience:• Strawberry nurseries in the U.S. and Canada • Strawberry breeding programs in the U.S. and Europe. • Strawberry grower Associations in the U.S. • Strawberry distribution industry in the U.S. • Strawberry licensing industry in the U.S. • Greenhouse and Vertical Farming Industry in the U.S. • Strawberry Growers nationwide. Changes/Problems:To the knowledge of the PD, this is the first project that targets all strawberry nursery partners in the US and Canada. Until now, the industry has been subject of rather discontinued research efforts. As a result, the industry is not very well known to the research community, and trusted relationships have to be developed over time. This circumstance has affected the integrity of objectives in the first SCRI full application. However, indsutry partners as well as research partners have agreed to work much closer togehter for the second SCRI application (currently to be prepared), and we made large progress on the integration and coherence of the project already, in response to the reveiwer comments. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Garduate students were part of virtual industry partner meetings How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Research results are published in journal, dissertation, presented at confernce. Results were shared through meetings and presentations with indsutry partners. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Submit SCRI SRS Sumit full SCRI Proposal Publish remaining research results

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal (1). A initiall planning meeting was held in person in 2018 at NC State University. SRS proposals were submitted in 2018 and 2019. In 2019/20, afull SCRI SREP proposal ($4.5 M) was developed and submitted (Hoffmann PD). Although not successful, the reviews are being used to engage industry and collaboration partners for a new submssion for the 2020/21 cycle. Goal (2). One online industry needs assessment was conducted in 2018. 5 in-person visits with strawberry nurseries were conudcted in 2019 by PD Hoffmann. 5 Vitrual indsutry-univeristy needs assessment and collaboration meetings were hold as response to the 2020 proposal reviews. Insights gathered at those meetings are currently used to inform and shape the 2020/21 proposal application.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Submitted Year Published: 2020 Citation: Shi, X., Hern�ndez, R. and Hoffmann, M. 2020. Timing of stolon removal alters daughter plant production and quality in the long-day strawberry (Fragaria x ananassa) cultivar Albion. HortScience (submitted).
  • Type: Theses/Dissertations Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Shi, Xiaonan. 2020. Impact of Stolon Removal Intervals and Nitrogen Source Ratios on Propagation of Long-day Strawberries (Fragaria �ananassa 'Albion') in Soil-less Greenhouse and Controlled Environment Systems. Master Thesis, North Carolina State Univeristy.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Hoffmann, Mark. 2020. An Overview of the Strawberry Nursery Industry in North America. ASHS Virtual Conference, Aug 10-13.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Xiaonan Shi, Ricardo Hernandez and Mark Hoffmann. 2020. Asexual Reproduction Regulation By Stolon Removal Intervals in Long-Day Strawberry (Fragaria x ananassa cv. Albion) ASHS Virtual Conference, Aug 10-13.
  • Type: Websites Status: Awaiting Publication Year Published: 2020 Citation: Project Homepage: http://strawberries-pip.cals.ncsu.edu/


Progress 09/01/18 to 08/31/19

Outputs
Target Audience:Following target audiences were reached by our efforst between 2018 and 2019; We have reached out rhough an online survey to strawberry nurseries in the US and Canada. We fruther more conducted face-to-face meetings with national nursery and strawberry grower stakeholders. We connected with Diagnostic Service companies as well as with breeding programs in the US and Europe. Our constant efforts of reaching out ot stakeholders resulted in several close working relationships between the SCRI group and the industry. Changes/Problems:Due to the 1:1 matching requirement, we made changes in the scope and team of the initial 2019 project. The project submitted for the FY 2020 SCRI program is entitledDevelopment of next-generation propagation strategies to increase the resilience of the US strawberry production chain.Indsutry partners are much closer involved in research and extension activities in this project, as well as inproposed socio-economic impact studies. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Preliminary reserarch resulst were shared and explained at stakeholder meetings. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The project team as successfully asked for a one year non-cost extension of the current SCRI Planning Grant. Our groals for the next reporting period are: (1) We plan to develop online resources and information about the project, (2) Disseminate preliminiary research results and develop strawberry propagation training opportunities

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal (1). A strategic meeting was held in September 2018 in Raleigh, NC, and follow up video conferences were held in preparation of a SCRI CAP pre-proposal. In 2018, an SCRI CAP Pre-Proposal was submitted to the USDA-NIFA SCRI grant program, entitled: Development and optimization of next-generation propagation and diagnostic tools to improve strawberry production. More than 20 PIs and several industry partners were part of this proposal. Theteamwas invited to submit a full SCRI CAP proposal for the FY 2019. However, due to the required 1:1 match, the PD decided to hold off with the submission for another year. In the yaer 2019, the tream was redefined and closer relationships with several industry partners were developed, leading to a pre-proposal submission in 2020. Goal (2). Several indsustry needs assessments were conducted. Besides a national online needs survey (https://ncsu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_6r3sfyooApTnbAV), several face-to-face meetings with nursery operators in the US were conducted, to assess the needs of the industry. Several key stakeholders were visited and engaged in face-to-face meetings over the course of 2019. During this process, researchers, industry partners and extension specialists identified key research and extension objectives as well as critical partners. One key result was that protocols to produce clean plant material was identified as the top priority for the nursery industry across the nation. Moreover, rising fuel and labor costs were cited as a secondary concern, along with stricter regulations on the use of pesticide, and especially the threat of losing MB. The SCRI Project teams' objectives are based on those key outcomes.

Publications