Source: UNIV OF MASSACHUSETTS submitted to NRP
UNDERSTANDING POLLEN - PISTIL INTERACTION AS A BASIS TOWARDS IMPROVING REPRODUCTIVE YIELDS IN PLANTS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1016179
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 25, 2018
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2022
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF MASSACHUSETTS
(N/A)
AMHERST,MA 01003
Performing Department
Biochemistry & Molecular Biology
Non Technical Summary
Pollen grains germinate on the stigma, the receptive surface of the female organ pistil. Each pollen grain hydrates and extrudes a pollen tube whose function is to transport two sperm cells carried in its cytoplasm to the female gametophyte inside an ovule, usually located at some distance from the stigma. Recent research in plant reproduction has produced critical insights into how a pollen tube targets the female gametophyte (where the egg apparatus is located) through a female-guided processand how the pollen tube, once inside the female gametophyte, achieves sperm release to enable fertilization. Yet mechanisms that underlie the critical first pollen-pistil interactive steps on the stigma, i.e. adhesion of pollen grains on the stigma, pollen hydration, activation and extrusion of the pollen tube to penetrate the stigmatic tissue, remain unclear. The project utilizes the model plant Arabidopsis to elucidate how these early events are orchestrated. In particular, we examine the contribution by three related receptor kinases (RKs) expressed in the stigma, FERONIA (FER), HERCULES1 (HERK1) and RK7.RKs are transmembrane proteins with an extracellular domain for interactions with other molecules, and a cytoplasmic kinase domain, which modifies molecules to alter their activities, thus mediating signals into cellular actions in response. RKs are important molecules for mediating cell-cell and cell-environment communication, including playing major roles in male-female interactions. FER, HERK1 and RK7 are members of a small RK family (with seventeen members) in Arabidopsis whose importance to plant growth and survival has been established rapidly since reports on its founding members about ten years ago. This is largely due to the potential of these RKs to be functioning at the frontline of interactions with the environment, such as changes in growth conditions or during intrusive growth such as when plants were invaded by pathogens or when pollen tubes penetrate female tissues. Work from our lab and around the world has demonstrated the importance of several members of this group of RKs. In particular FER is crucial throughout the plant's life cycle, including being critically required for female fertility. FER, HERK1 and RK7 are the three most prominently expressed in the stigma among the seventeen membered-protein family. Mutant plants lacking FER produce few seeds, yet the stigmatic function in supporting germination of pollen grains is not impaired at all. On the other hand, loss of HERK1 or RK7 does not induce any notable defects in reproduction. Preliminary results based on higher order mutants, such as loss of FER and RK7 together, indicate that initial pollen grain/tube-stigmatic tissue interaction are compromised. The project will produce information towards understanding how these three related RKs work together to support the initial male-female interactive events of pollination which, only if successful, will lead to fertilization producing grains for food and seeds for future generations.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
20624201060100%
Knowledge Area
206 - Basic Plant Biology;

Subject Of Investigation
2420 - Noncrop plant research;

Field Of Science
1060 - Biology (whole systems);
Goals / Objectives
The project addresses how flowering plants achieve fertilization, which if unsuccessful will result in reproductive failure, devastating agricultural productivity. Pollen grains germinate on the stigma, the receptive surface of the female organ pistil. Each pollen grain hydrates and extrudes a pollen tube whose function is to transport two sperm cells carried in its cytoplasm to the female gametophyte inside an ovule, usually located at some distance from the stigma. Recent research in plant reproduction has produced critical insights into how a pollen tube targets the female gametophyte (where the egg apparatus is located) through a female-guided processand how the pollen tube, once inside the female gametophyte, achieves sperm release to enable fertilization. Yet mechanisms that underlie the critical first pollen-pistil interactive steps on the stigma, i.e. adhesion of pollen grains on the stigma, pollen hydration, activation and extrusion of the pollen tube to penetrate the stigmatic tissue, remain unclear. Thestudy utilizes the model plant Arabidopsis to elucidate how these early events are orchestrated. In particular, we examine the contribution by three related receptor kinases (RKs) expressed in the stigma, FERONIA (FER), HERCULES1 (HERK1) and RK7.RKs are transmembrane proteins with an extracellular domain for interactions with other molecules, and a cytoplasmic kinase domain, which modifies molecules to alter their activities, thus mediating signals into cellular actions in response. RKs are important molecules for mediating cell-cell and cell-environment communication, including playing major roles in male-female interactions. FER, HERK1 and RK7 are members of a small RK family (with seventeen members) in Arabidopsis whose importance to plant growth and survival has been established rapidly since reports on its founding members about ten years ago. This is largely due to the potential of these RKs to be functioning at the frontline of interactions with the environment, such as changes in growth conditions or during intrusive growth such as when plants were invaded by pathogens or when pollen tubes penetrate female tissues. Work from our lab and around the world has demonstrated the importance of several members of this group of RKs. In particular FER is crucial throughout the plant's life cycle, including being critically required for female fertility. FER, HERK1 and RK7 are the three most prominently expressed in the stigma among the seventeen membered-protein family. Mutant plants lacking FER produce few seeds, yet the stigmatic function in supporting germination of pollen grains is not impaired at all. On the other hand, loss of HERK1 or RK7 does not induce any notable defects in reproduction. Preliminary results based on higher order mutants, such as loss of FER and RK7 together, indicate that initial pollen grain/tube-stigmatic tissue interaction are compromised. The project's major goal is to understand how these three related RKs work together to support the initial male-female interactive events of pollination which, only if successful, will lead to fertilization producing grains for food and seeds for future generations. Specifically, we shall (1) establish precisely when the function(s) of FER, HERK1 and RK7 are required during the initial events of pollination;(2) Identify functional partners from both the stigma and pollen that work in concert with FER, HERK1 and RK7 to establish the signal transduction pathway in the stigmatic surface and underlying tissues that orchestrate these early pollination events.
Project Methods
Molecular genetics and biochemical approaches will be used to address the research questions.Aim 1: Establish precisely when the function(s) of FER, HERK1 and RK7 are required during the initial events of pollination.(section 1,2)Aim 2.Identify interacting partners from both the stigma and pollen that potentially work in concert with FER, HERK1 and RK7.(section 3,4)For aim 1, we will usepromoter GUS analysis to determine the temporal and spatial expression pattern from FER, HERK1 and RK7 and their responses to pollination. We already have FER promoter:GUS and RK7 promoter:GUS line and their expression patterns are partially characterized. HERK1 promoter GUS line and its seedling expression has been described (20). We will obtain this line, or construct our own if necessary. These will provide very convenient materials to assess the overall developmental regulation of these genes in flowers.Arabidopsis floral developmental stages are well defined. Our focus will be on pistils from stage 13 flowers (mature but not yet pollinated) and initially self-pollinated stage 15 flowers (mature and pollinated) because of the relative ease to obtain experimental materials. Then we would compare developmentally comparable stage 15 pistils, either emasculated and left unpollinated, or emasculated and pollinated to demonstrate if developmental regulation is in place for these RKs. To assess if pollination regulates the expression of these genes, we will sample pistils at close intervals upon germination, e.g. 5, 15, 30 minutes, periods that we believe to be the most critical for this study as events are getting started on the stigma and pollen tubes are just penetrating the stigmatic tissues. Then progressively sampling will be at longer intervals in the later stages since most pollen tubes will have grown past the style/ovary junction by 2-3 hours after pollination.These studies will be accompanied by direct measurement of transcript levels by RT-PCR.Analysis of pollination and seed yield phenotypes in higher order mutants in FER, HERK1 and RK7. Since loss-of-function T-DNA induced mutants of these genes do not display pollination defects on the stigma, higher order mutants of double or triple knockouts are proposed here. Currently we have a double fer-4 rk7 mutant that show loss in seed yields even more severely than in fer-4 alone. This is probably due to few pollen tubes (pollination using wild type pollen grains) grow into the ovarian chamber, and those arriving at the female gametophyte are aborted in their ability to fertilize. We have ascertained that complementation by RK7-GFP restored fer-4 level of female defects. We will generate also fer-4 herk1 double, herk1 rk7 double, and also a triple mutant using the weaker fer-5 allele (which produces a truncated transcript), and mutant plants are generally normal developmentally except for defective root hairs.We will subject these mutants to pollination analysis by observing the behavior of wild type pollen grains on their stigmas. Natural pollination and seed production will provide some baseline suggestions, and reciprocal pollinations using these mutants and female and male parents will establish male- or female- deficiency. But hand-pollination with countable numbers of pollen grains from otherwise normal quartet (qrt) plants (26) will provide quantitative analysis of the efficiency of the stigmas from these mutants to support various stages of the early pollination process, from adhesion, to pollen tube extrusion, penetration of the stigma and growth into the stylar tissue. Results will inform when the most prominent impact occur during the germination and early tube growth processes. Seed yield analysis after corresponding pollination assays will inform whether events later in the pollen tube growth and fertilization process have compounded the severity of the phenotype. We anticipate that in the fer-4 background, we will see a more severe seed yield phenotype relative to defects in the stigmatic/stylar region. We recently showed that autophagy-mediated cytoplasmic deletion is essential for tobacco pollen germination and tube extrusion in vitro. As a first analysis to explore the in vivo process on the stigma, we will pollinate wild type and mutant pistils with Arabidopsis pollen grains expression an autophagy reporter (ATG8-GFP) to determine if the RKs studied here participate in this critical first step.For Aim 2: We will examine interactions between these stigma RKs and the following molecules. We note that the purposes here are not just to establish similar interactive relationships as those already known for the best characterizedFER, but each interaction could inform specific aspects of the pollination process. The first question is whetherthe ECDs of FER, HERK1 and RK7 bind pectic fragments generated by pollen tube penetration of pistil? We have already established that the ECDs of FER, ANXURs and BUPs bind PGA; we will determine if HERK1 and RK7 ECD have similar properties. In our studies with FER, we observed that pollinated pistils produce a pectin-rich exudate, presumably as a result of hydrolases secreted by pollen tubes during the growth process (unpublished). Such exudates will be collected and used in binding assays as carried out inwith FER, HERK1 and RK7. The second question is whetherFER, HERK1 and RK7 targets of pollen-produced RALFs? From our studies of pollen FER-related RKs, we already have several pollen-expressed RALFs, 4 and 19 in particular, in our hands, and procedures are established for their production. We will subject these RALFs and the RKs to protein-protein interactions assays already established in our laboratory.

Progress 10/01/19 to 09/30/20

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience is facuty and gradute students in the related disciplines. (1) For this period, we have published one paper, submitted one to a preprint site (BioRivx). Support from this award was acknowledged. (2) We also submitted three additional manuscripts with some of the reportedworks having been partially supported by this award.One of the two submitted manuscripts has been accepted [after Sept, 30, 2020]; the other two are still in revision. Publications in (1) are listed in the next page. Those in (2) are not listed; will do so in the next progress report cycle when the status of these manuscripts have been finalized. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In AY2019-2020, we did not have an undergraduate directly supported from this award; because of Covid-19 shutdown, we had to decline the support of a summer research student. Between Oct 1, 2019 to middle of March, 2020 (spring break), a project carried out by undergraduates (who took independent studies, so non-paid) with material cultured in facilities supported by this award was completed and submitted to BioRivx. A postdoc, Ming-Che Liu (supported on other grants but contributed to this effort), was the mentor of this undergraduate team, is 2nd author on this publication. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Two papers are now in the public domain. The unpublished results will be disseminated in similar ways. Because of Covid-19, the PIs have curtailed travel to meetings or other seminar venues, so have not been reportingthese not yet published results broadly, but will do so once traveling restrictions are removed. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?While FER/ANJEA function as a complex on the stigma, ANJ/HERK1 function as complex in the ovules, and act similar as FER alone on inducing pollenn tube disintegration and sperm release, because loss of ANJ and HERK1 together resulted in the same pollen tube overgrowth phenotype in the female gametophyte. We intend to further characterized the mechanism behind how ANJ/HERK1 work.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We have completed a project directly related to the proposed, in particular related to FERONIA and ANJEA(RK7 in the original proposal, after the fertility goddess from the Aboriginal methology --we are running out of goddess' names from the Roman and Greek methologies). We showed that FER and ANJ function as a complex in the Arabidopsis stigma gating it until compatible pollen grains land on the stigmatic surface, then FER/ANJ turns on a program to render the stigmatic papillae hospital to the germinating pollen tube. This manuscript is currently in revision. Two other submitted manuscripts were also related to pollen-stigma interaction, but was carried out as collaboration with a former postdoc who studies self-incompatibility in Chinese cabbage. This was an aspect originally proposed as an intended extention to agricultrually important crops. The results also focus on pollen-stigma interaction and how self-compatible and self-incompatible pollen are discriminated against or accepted by the stigma. TheFERONIA homolog in Chinese cabbageis part of the regulatory mechanims.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Duan Q-h, Liu M-C J, Kita, D, Jordan S, Yeh F-L J, Yvon R, Carpenter H, Federico AN, Garcia Valencia L, Eyles SJ, Wang C-s, Wu H-M, Cheung AY. (2020) FERONA controls pectin- and nitric oxide-mediated male-female interaction. Nature, 579, 561-566. Noble JA, Liu M-C J, DeFalco TA, Stegmann M, McNamara K*, Sullivan B*, Dinh KK*, Khuu N*, Hancock S, Shiu S-H, Zipfel C, Beilstein MA, Cheung AY, Palanivelu R. Conserved Molecular function and regulatory subfunctionalization of the LORELEI gene family in Brassicaceae. bioRxiv doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.27.062893. *were undergraduates in the lab.


Progress 10/01/18 to 09/30/19

Outputs
Target Audience:For this period, we have published one paper (Ge et al., 2019, Current Biology) that utilized resources supported by this project. We also reported ongoing progress in meetings.The target audience for these efforts ispeer research community in plant reproduction biology. Changes/Problems:As indicated in the previous page,the mutants we generatedo not appear to have the properties we anticipated. These are hard-earned mutants, as we need to produce double and triple mutants. However, because of gene redundancy in the plant genome, similar complications are not unusual, and some time gene families require getting combinations of 4, 5, and even up to 8 genes all mutated to see a functional manifestation from their deficiency. Should such complications arise, the continued efforts will be too complex for undergraduates and the resourcesprovidedby the project, we will have to alter in ways that the young students can contribute and raise additional resources to continue the original project. At this point, we still believe it is a manageable situation. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Kara McNamara and another undergraduate, Brookes Sullivan,were trained in these projects in the first year (June 2018-May 2019)They have graduated. Kara is now a first year graduate student in Vanderbilt University. Brookes is currently employed by the Yale Genetic Screening Center. In the summer of 2019, another undergraduate, Jordan McCarthy was trained by this project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?As journal publications; and Jordan has reported his progress at a CAFE poster session. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?For the next reporting period (ongoing research), we are focussed on finishing the genetic characterization of the mutants isolated, as they do not appear to have the properties we anticipated, thus required some continued effort. We will also continue the biochemical studies of the proteins encoded by these signal-regulatory genes to help dissect their mechanisms.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The RKs, e.g. FER,studied here do not function alone but together with a co-receptor from a family of proteins called glycosylphosphatidylinosital-anchored protein. FER's partner is called LRE and LLG1. There are two additional members, called LLG2 and LLG3,are also likely partner for other FER-related RKs. The efforts of Kara McNamara, supported by this project summer UG funds, contributed to a manuscript currently at the last phase of preparation, which studied the functional and evolutionary relationship between LRE, LLG1, LLG2 and LLG3. We are continuing to identify the partners for RK7 and HERK1.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Submitted Year Published: 2020 Citation: Conserved Molecular Functions and Regulatory Divergence Underlies Expansionand Maintenance of the LORELEI gene family in Brassicaceae (Submitted to Nature Plants).
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Ge Z, Zhao Y, Liu M-C*, Wang L, Zhong S, Hou S, Jian J, Liu T, Huang Q, Xiao J, Gu H, Wu H-M*, Dong J, Dresselhaus T, Cheung AY, Qu L-J. (2019) LLG2/3 are co-receptors in BUPS/ANX-RALF signaling to regulate Arabidopsis pollen tube integrity. Current Biology 29, 3256-3265.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2020 Citation: Qiaohong Duan1,2,#, Ming-Che James Liu1,3,#, Daniel Kita1,4,a, Samuel S. Jordan1, Fang-Ling Jessica Yeh1, Robert Yvon1,4, Hunter Carpenter1,4,, Anthony N. Federico1,b, Liliana Garcia Valencia1, Stephen J. Eyles1,5, Co-Shine Wang3, Hen-Ming Wu1,4,*, Alice Y. Cheung1,4,5,6* FERONIA Controls Pectin-and Nitric Oxide-Mediated Male-Female Interaction [Accepted (in principle) pending compliance checks, by Nature]. The formal acceptance is likely by Next Monday. We finished the compliance checks just this week.


Progress 05/25/18 to 09/30/18

Outputs
Target Audience:The reporting period for us isbetween June 1, 2018 to Sept. 30 2018 and the first three months of the project. The effort was mostly on training students the basic tools to carry out the proposed research, thus the report is not aimed at any target group but for progress update. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Two undergraduates, both rising seniors, were trained in this project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The next reporting period will focus on obtaining the mutant plants required for the proposed research and beginning the characterization of their reproductive phenotypes.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The summer efforts of two undergraduates centered on determining the genotype, i.e. mutations existing, of Arabidopsis plants needed for the proposed research. Some of the achieved projects were also relevant to other reproduction-related research in the lab, thus generally impacting our research activities.

Publications