Source: Recombinetics, Inc. submitted to NRP
TRI-PARTITE COLLABORATIVE: TARGETED GENOME EDITING TO UNDERSTAND AND ENHANCE GENETIC RESISTANCE TO BOVINE TUBERCULOSIS IN DOMESTIC CATTLE POPULATIONS (TARGET-TB)
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1015508
Grant No.
2018-67015-28700
Cumulative Award Amt.
$499,700.00
Proposal No.
2017-05688
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2018
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2021
Grant Year
2018
Program Code
[A1221]- Animal Health and Production and Animal Products: Animal Health and Disease
Recipient Organization
Recombinetics, Inc.
2575 University Avenue West, Suite 100
Saint Paul,MN 55114
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The pathogen that causes Bovine Tuberculosis (BTB) in cattle costs an estimated $3 billion to global agriculture annually and the primary financial burden of BTB in developed countries is the control of infection. The pathogen causing BTB (M. bovis) poses a significant zoonotic risk and is therefore a threat to public health, in particular to farmers and communities in the developing world that have close interactions with infected livestock. The main goal of our project, which draws on scientific expertise from the US, Ireland, and Northern Ireland; will be to identify critical genes that directly affect a bovine animal's ability to respond to infection. Our approach is novel, because we will use new resources and molecular genetic tools like bovine stem cells, genome editing, and next generation sequencing of expressed genes to quickly find critical host genes. Once found, we expect this information will be deployed to industry as management tools such as DNA marker diagnostics and genome-enabled breeding to improve existing TBT control, while avoiding additional use of antibiotics and ineffective vaccines. Ultimately, our findings offer potential solutions to reduce zoonotic risk associated with TBT.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
25%
Developmental
25%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3113499109013%
3113399109012%
3043499108013%
3043399108012%
3113499108025%
3113399108025%
Goals / Objectives
1. Identify, rank and prioritize candidate genes and genomic regulatory elements (GREs) with functionally-relevant natural sequence variants (NSVs - both SNPs and small indels) for genome editing of bovine induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC)-derived macrophages(iPSCDM) to understand and enhance macrophage resistance to M. bovis infection.2. Generate iPSCDM with loss-of-function (LOF) edits in two genes that are key to the mammalian macrophage response to mycobacterial infections.3. Generate 20 different lines of iPSCDM with NSV edits in genes and GREs identified from the scientific literature, a defined macrophage defense process, and computational analysis of extensive macrophagemycobacteria transcriptomics data.4. Implement a scientific pipeline for robust functional testing of gene edits in bovine iPSCDM using an in vitro infection model system that will be developed during the course of the project.5. Generate new information on the genetics of host-pathogen interaction for BTB that will inform and improve existing control and management tools such as diagnostics and genome-enabled breeding for enhanced resistance to M. bovis infection.6. Produce baseline information for future work to generate genome-edited cattle with enhanced resistance to M. bovis infection and reduced population incidence of BTB disease.7. Define a novel research paradigm and strategy that can be used for comparable studies of other important mycobacterial diseases. In particular, Johne's disease caused by infection with M. avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP), which also involves intracellular infection ofmacrophages in the bovine host.
Project Methods
The efforts of this project will take advantage of a multi-pronged, multi-step computational workflow that will be used to prioritise genes for subsequent genome-editing experiments (Systems Biology analyses of all previous MacHugh/Gordon laboratory data and literature). A scientific pipeline will be implemented for robust functional testing of these gene edits in bovine induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC)-derived macrophages (iPSCDM) using an in vitro infection model system (Stem cell biology approach combined with genome editing pipeline). These cells will then be used to test the efficacy of specific NSVs in enhancing the bovine macrophage response to M. bovis infection and provide baseline information for future production of gene-edited cattle with increased resistance to BTB disease (Molecular genetics and biocomputing of disease challenge experiments). These efforts will be developed through interactions between PIs on this project and the primary post-docs responsible for each work plan.Data Types Generated and ExamplesLaboratory protocols and standard operating procedures [SOPs] (docx, pdf) - Extraction of total RNA from animal tissueBiomolecular sequence information (txt, fasta) - DNA/RNA sequence information associated with specific CRISPR-Cas9 gene editsExperimentally generated scientific images (gif, jpeg, png, psd, ai) - High-resolution gel images from DNA electrophoresis experimentsHigh-throughput DNA sequencing data [high data storage overhead] (fastq, sam, bam) - RNA-seq and miRNA-seq data from transcriptional profiling of bovine iPSDMBioinformatics computer program code and scripts (sh, py, pl, r) - Linux bash script to link procedures in an RNA-seq analytical pipelineProject scientific documentation (docx, pdf, xlsx) - Scientific manuscripts in preparation for peer reviewed publication.Key Milestones from each Work Plan - WP1) Complete Systems Biology analyses of critical genes and sequence variants involved in BTB, WP2) Complete development of protocol that successfully produces iPSCs from bovine monocytes, WP3) Complete development of gene editing protocol for bovine iPSCs and production of 20 edited bovine iPSCs cell lines, and WP4) Molecular genetic and sequence based analyses of disease challenged, edited iPSCMs completed. Sub-milestones are denoted in Figure 1 under each workplan. Progress will be evaluated by meetings of collaborative team and feedback/input from our four member scientific advisory panel of experts. These details are described in the management plan of the proposal.

Progress 09/01/20 to 08/31/21

Outputs
Target Audience:There were no presentations for this reporting period due to Covid restrictions. We have shared the project overview andresults with program leaders from other funding bodies. Changes/Problems:With Covid and the previous switch made in cell types for editing,culturing and differentiation; our collaborative team became limited on the number of cell lines that could be processed through the differentiation process (takes several months/cell line). As such, Recombinetics made seven knock-out cell lines and one cell line with a precise change in MARCO1. Although reduced from the original major goal of 20 cell lines, the eight current lines represent a significant resourcefor the study of immune response to M. bovis infection in vitro, if these cells lines can be successfully differentiated and grown out into enough macrophage-like cells for further study. The process of differentiation and infection challenge are still ongoing at Queens University and University College Dublin, respectively. Their funding was extended for another year due to closures that delayed work during the Covid pandemic. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Technical training was extended to two other Recombientics employeesfor gene editing, characterization, and growth of bovine embryonic stem cells. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Most of our efforts at Recombinetics were focused on Major Goals #2 and #3. Due to the difficulties in generating iPSCDM in previous years at Queens University (Northern Ireland partner), we moved to using bovine embryonic stem cells (ESCs) available to Recombinetics as the target material for gene editing. Witin a progenitor embryonic cell line derived from a Holstein male, seven different "progeny" cell lines were manufactured. The single gene "knock-out" edits for each line were as follows: 1) ARG2, 2) GBP5, 3) IFI16, 4) IFNGR, 5) MYD88, 6) SLC11A1, and 7) TMEM173. An eighth progeny cell line was also made with an exact edit in MARCO1, which converts the typical taurine "fixed" allele to the "fixed" alternative allele found in indicine cattle. Each cell line was then grown up to threshold numbers for export to Northern Ireland, where the Simpson lab at Queens University will take each cell line through a macrophage differentiation process inculture. The SImpson lab has successfully used the founder ESC line to produce macrophage-like cells. These cells were transferred to UC-Dublin for "cell-type" immune response characterization.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/18 to 08/31/21

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The only formal presentations for this project were at CRWAD 2018 & 2019 conference attended by scientists in the field. We have shared the project overview and preliminary results with program leaders from other funding bodies. Changes/Problems:Before editing, the stem cell team at Queens needed to identify a bovine cell type that could be changed from progenitor cell to macrophage-like cell, in culture. This step was not completed until late 2020, because the initial iPSC cells did not work properly, and the project switched to bovine embryonic stem cells through resources Recombinetics had available through an agreement with UC-Davis. These cells, once identified for potential to produce challenge quality cell types, were then targeted for editing. Due to the limited time left in this project, we changed the targets from 2 to 7 knock out lines and only one line with a specific NSV, since genotyping did not support changing the other 20 candidate NSV. Such a change would offer a more informative outcome on immune response of hub genes and then later we could characterize the lone sub-species difference found in MARCO1. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Technical training was extended to a total of threeRecombinetics employees for gene editing design and transfection, screening and colony characterization for stem cell biomarkers, and growht maintenance ofbovine embryonic stem cells. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Aside from the mandatory CRWAD conference attendance no other formal reports have been generated. Publishable results depend on the differentiation of the edited ESCs to macrophage like cells and use of these cells in infection challenge experiments with M. bovis. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Recombinetics participated or led research only for activities that contributed to major goals #1-3. Major goals #4-7 are in still progress through extensions given to our Tri-Partite collaborative partners' funding agencies in Ireland and Northern Ireland based on Covid-related delays. In summary, we identified, ranked and prioritized 21 candidate genes and genomic regulatory elements (GREs) with functionally-relevant natural sequence variants (NSVs - both SNPs and small indels) as potential genome editing targets. Ten of these genes were knocked out or altered in bovine fibroblasts, through optimization processes that tested more than 20 different CRISPR/Cas9 targeting complexes. Seven of the knock-out edits were duplicated in a bovine stem cell line that has the potential to diffentiate into macrophage-like cells needed for infection challenge experments. Relatively large quantities of these cells lines were grown out and transferred to our Tri-Partite partners. Additional genotyping for 21 of the NSVs from 8 genes in a panel of 1000 animals (multi-breed and sub-species), identified one gene (MARCO1) as the best candidate for specific gene alterations to change introduce a sub-species change (from tuarine to zebu gene versions). The specific gene edit for MARCO1 was also introduced into the progenitor line of ECSs. In total, we generated 7 fibroblast lines and seven ESCslines with loss-of-function (LOF) edits in seven genes that are key to the mammalian macrophage response to mycobacterial infections. We also generated a fibroblast line and multiple ESC lineswith a specific sub-species alternative allele/NSV editin MARCO1 identified from the scientific literature, a defined macrophage defense process, and computational analysis of extensive macrophagemycobacteria transcriptomics data. The seven knock-out lines are a germplasm resource available for in vitro challenge studies of immune response and pathogen infection.

    Publications


      Progress 09/01/19 to 08/31/20

      Outputs
      Target Audience:The only presentation for this reporting period was at CRWAD 2019 conference attended by scientists in the field. We have shared the project overview and preliminary results with program leaders from other funding bodies. Changes/Problems:All current delays in this project are related to difficulties related to culturing and differentiating bovine stem cells. The switch in late 2019 to embryonic stemcells seems to have solved this technical challenge. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Technical training was completed for gene editing of bovine embryonic stem cells. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We now have gene editing methods in pluripotent embryonic stem cells working. The reagent design and editing of 20 different gene targets will be completed in 2021 based upon the prioritized list of 9 target genes involved in immune response to M. bovis.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We completed Major Goal #1 in conjunction with UC-Dublin researchers. Our list has 9 core genes which are slated for knock-out mutations and have selected a series of allelic variants for these genes where sequence variations between Indicine and Taurine cattle are differentially fixed. Gene editing Goals 2 and 3 are still in progress as we have successfully switched to using embryonic stem cells for our resource population of cells. However, the editing for 9 gene knock-outs has been optimized in bovine fibroblasts proving our CRISPR/Cas9 tools are functional in vitro. Previous efforts to make bovine iPSCDM had failed due to the difficult challenge of making these cells. Out project partners in Norther Ireland are now focusing on differentiation of enbryonic stem cells into macrophages for testing the pipeline in Goal #4.

      Publications

      • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Bostrom J, MacHugh D, Simpson D, Carlson D, Vernimmen D, ODoherty A, Hall T, Gordon S, Correia C, Margariti A, Kelaini S, Sonstegard T. Targeted genome editing to understand and enhance genetic resistance to M. bovis infection in domestic cattle. Proceedings of CRWAD 2018 (Chicago). Poster Abstract.


      Progress 09/01/18 to 08/31/19

      Outputs
      Target Audience:Currently, we have only shown the project overview and early results at the CRWAD meeting in Chicago at the end of 2018, which was only 3 months into the project. The primary audience has been other scientists attending this conference and other potential scientific collaborators. Changes/Problems:At UCD,There was a significant problem with the Rodeo computer server (rodeo.ucd.ie) used for Task 1. On the17th of October 2018, there was a power outage that damaged equipment in the UCD server centre. Rodeowas repaired by the end of January 2019. See Task 1 description for details of this problem and supportingdocumentation. The postdoctoral researcher (ROI-PDOC) Dr Carol Correia was able to accelerate this workthrough a two-week research visit to the group of Professor Hubert Pausch in ETH-Zurich during earlyJanuary 2019. We also have initiated a collaboration with Dr. Pablo Ross to use his stem cells as an alterntive source of iPSCMD; if technical challenges for stem cell derivation at QUB persist. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Only had a poster presentation at the 2018 CRWAD meeting to date. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Collaboration with Professor Hubert Pausch ondevelopment of pan-genome resources for Bos taurus andBos indicus cattle. These resources are being used toidentify functionally relevant natural sequence variants(NSVs) for the TARGET-TB project. Also, collaboration with Professor Pablo Ross to provide accessto pluripotent embryonic stem cells for genome editingand transformation to a macrophage phenotype. Thiscollaboration will provide cellular materials for theTARGET-TB project.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? During Year 1, the UCD group has identified more than 20 gene targets for genome editing to study the response to Mycobacterium bovis infection in the bovine cells that first encounter the disease-causing agent in the lungs. During Year 1, the QUB group have developed methods for generating cells suitable for genome editing from bovine embryonic tissues. During Year 1, the REC group have developed the genome editing tools to study nine of the 20 gene targets and have generated bovine cells with these nine genome edits. Through a new collaboration initiated in Year 1 with scientists at the University of California, Davis (UC Davis), the TARGET-TB project will have access to developmentally plastic bovine cells that can also be used to generate cells suitable for genome editing and for testing with laboratory infection studies.

      Publications

      • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Sonstegard, T. S., Correia, C. N., Margariti, A., Bostrom, J., Carlson, D. F., Simpson, D. A., Gordon, S. V., MacHugh, D. E. Poster: Targeted genome editing to understand and enhance genetic resistance to M. bovis infection in domestic cattle. 99th Conference of Research Workers in Animal Diseases (CRWAD), Chicago, Illinois, USA. 2nd-4th, December, 2018. https://crwad.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/CRWAD-2018.FINAL-Author- Index-and-Abstracts.pdf