Progress 02/27/18 to 01/31/21
Outputs Target Audience:Managers, regulators, researchers, and concerned cititizens of water resources, aquatic wildlife, and fisheries. Changes/Problems:The impacts of stormwater on coho salmon are very acute; progressing from mild changes in behavior to death within hours. This does not leave much time for the fish to mount a response that will be moderated bychanges in gene transcription. As such, the proposal to search for molecular pathways in coho affected by stormwater that can be used to develop tools for evaluating stormwater treatment effectiveness is premature. Our focus for the project therefore shifted to elucidating the underlying physiological changes that occur in coho leading from health to death within hours of exposure to stormwater as a first step towards identifying the target tissue(s), which is necessary for ultimately establishing the molecular initiating events. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project offered training opportunities for 2 postdocs, 1 PhD student, and 2 MS students. Two MS thesis were completed, three first-author papers for the graduate students, and co-authorship on an additional 4 papers. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results have been shared with communities of interest through regional and national presentations and meetings where the PIs, postdocs, and graduate students give invited or submitted talks, as well as through published peer-reviewed research papers, and interviews. 13 presentations at scientific conferences given by the PI 19 interviews published on radio, TV, or news paper/online 28 invited presentations given by the PI 34 poster or oral presentations at scientific conferences given by graduate students/postdocs What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?
Nothing Reported
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
Key outcomes for the project were changes in knowledge generated by 7 experiments/datasets: 1) Characterized the acute mortality syndrome in coho spawners Adult coho returning to freshwater to spawn were exposed to stormwater collected from a busy roadway in Seattle. After 4-6 h behavior was scored and blood physiology assessed compared with time-matched controls exposed to well water. Coho in stormwater displayed a spectrum of altered behaviors ranging from lethargy to immobility, with the most common being extreme lethargy. Controls were overwhelmingly asymptomatic. Blood of exposed fish had reduced pH and plasma ions, with significantly elevated hematocrit (thicker blood), compared with controls. Co-exposed adult chum showed no changes in behavior or blood parameters relative to controls. (McIntyre et al. 2018) 2) Confirmed the vulnerability of juvenile coho salmon, more fully characterized syndrome Juvenile coho salmon showed acute mortality during exposure to stormwater. Surface- and bottom-oriented behavior tracked during exposure showed a progression from discrete surfacing to continuous surface swimming, to loss of equilibrium, and immobility on the bottom of the tank prior to mortality. With mortality occurring on average 6 h into the exposure, the first change in behavior was evident at 45 min. Fish transitioned to clean water at the appearance of continuous surface swimming were not able to recover. They died in the same amount of time as fish that remained in runoff. In agreement with observed behaviors, blood parameters of sick fish were consistent with those observed in adult coho, confirming that juveniles can be used as a model for studying impacts on adults. (Chow et al. 2019) 3) Blood cells are not the target of contaminants in coho salmon affected by stormwater Blood from coho salmon was used to develop a robust new method for determining methemoglobin concentrations in fish. Methemoglobin (metHb) is formed when the hemoglobin in red blood cells is oxidized. This can occur when an organism is exposed to strongly oxidizing substances. MetHb cannot transport oxygen and can lead to tissue hypoxia if insufficient reducing power in the blood results in elevated concentrations of metHb. Fish hemoglobins are different than those in humans, requiring direct determination of their molar adsorptivities prior to using standard spectroscopic techniques to measure specific hemoglobin species like metHb. In determining these molar adsorptivities, we discovered that coho tend to have unstable metHb that spontaneously converts to hemichrome and precipitates from solution, resulting in overestimation of metHb. We developed a multivariate modeling technique to complement multi-component analysis in determining the molar adsorptivities of coho hemoglobin species. This model was then used to determine that coho affected by stormwater did not have significantly elevated metHb. Changes in behavioral and blood chemistry in sick coho that are consistent with cardio-respiratory distress therefore are not a result of insufficient oxygen transport capability by red blood cells. (Blair et al. 2020; Blair et al. 2021) 4) Hemoconcentration in coho affected by stormwater is related to changes in the vascular system Coho affected by stormwater show extremely elevated hematocrit (HCT) in addition to behaviors consistent with cardiorespiratory distress. The goal of this study was to explore reasons for the elevated HCT. We exposed juvenile coho salmon to collected roadway runoff previously shown to produce acute symptoms and mortality in this species. We sampled their blood and also conducted tests of vascular integrity via injection of a high molecular weight tracer followed by saline perfusion. We did not observe a significant production of metHb, confirming that oxygen transport by red blood cells was not involved in the cardiorespiratory distress. Antioxidant power of the blood plasma was also not different in stormwater-exposed coho compared with controls. Evans Blue dye was injected into fish hearts and allowed to circulate through the vasculature before being rinsed out by clean saline perfusion. Significant dye retention was observed in the brains of coho exposed to stormwater, suggesting that plasma - including high molecular weight molecules - was leaking from the cerebrovasculature. Anecdotally, dye was also observed leaking from the gills in runoff-exposed coho but not in control coho. A loss of vascular integrity appears to explain the elevated HCT in sick coho and led us to postulate that blood-brain barrier disruption underlies the symptoms of cardiorespiratory distress in sick coho exposed to stormwater. (Blair et al. 2021) 5) Coho exposed to stormwater have lost integrity of their blood brain barrier In the study by Blair et al. (2021), we wanted to confirm that the accumulation of the dye in the brain was due to extravasation rather than possibly retained blood (and dye) within the vasculature. We perfused coho with horseradish peroxidase (HRP) - an enzyme that has commonly been used to study blood brain barrier disruption. Followed by a clean saline perfusion, brain tissues were prepared for histology. Prepared tissue slices were treated with hydrogen peroxide to react with retained HRP and allow its localization as either intravascular or extravascular. Although we expected to see discrete locations with diffuse staining in the brains of coho exposed to stormwater, we instead saw massive diffuse HRP staining. This was compared with essentially no staining in controls. These results confimed plasma leakage and suggest that sick coho are suffering from a very pronounced failure of the blood brain barrier. Ongoing studies are exploring the timing and severity of the development of these symptoms. 6) Tire chemicals are sufficient to recreate the acute mortality syndrome in coho Land use analysis and water chemistry studies by our group and others suggested that tires might be the source of chemicals causing toxicity to coho salmon. We tested the response of coho to a 'tire particle leachate', made by recirculating water over particles abraded from the tread of tires. Adult coho salmon died when exposed to the leachate at concentrations that were environmentally realistic levels. Behavioral changes and blood physiology were identical to those caused by collected stormwater. Adult chum did not show any of these impacts, similar to their response to stormwater. (McIntyre et al. 2021) 7) The primary toxicant responsible for acute mortality of coho is 6PPD-quinone Tire particle leachate containing >2000 chemicals was fractionated to reduce chemical complexity and enable toxicant identification. Fractions were tested for toxicity to coho and also examined by high resolution mass spectrometry. Utilizing techniques including cation exchange, polarity-based separation, reverse phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), and multi-dimensional HPLC, chemical complexity of the toxic fraction was reduced to just four chemicals. The most abundant chemical in the final fraction was a previously unknown chemical; C18H22N2O2. The parent chemical was determined to be 6PPD (N-(1,3- dimethylbutyl)-N′-phenyl-p- phenylenediamine) - the most widely used anti-ozonant in tire rubber. By subjecting commercial 6PPD (C18H24N2) to ozone, we produced C18H22N2O2, confirming by nuclear magnetic resonance that the unknown chemical was 6PPD-quinone. Purified 6PPD-quinone, isolated from tire leachate or from 6PPD subjected to ozone, was highly acutely lethal to coho salmon. The median lethal concentration (LC50) was estimated as 0.79 μg/L (0.63-0.96 μg/L 95% confidence interval). This was not different from the LC50 for tire particle leachate and roadway runoff on a 6PPD-quinone basis of 0.82 μg/L (0.56-1.10 μg/L), supporting that this was the primary causal toxicant for coho salmon exposed to roadway runoff. (Tian et al. 2021)
Publications
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2021
Citation:
Blair, S., C. Barlow & J. K. McIntyre (2021). Acute cerebrovascular effects in juvenile coho salmon exposed to roadway runoff. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 78: 103.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2021
Citation:
McIntyre, J. K., J. Prat, J. Cameron, J. Wetzel, E. Mudrock, K. T. Peter, Z. Y. Tian, C. Mackenzie, J. Lundin, J. D. Stark, K. King, J. W. Davis, E. P. Kolodziej & N. L. Scholz (2021). Treading water: Tire wear particle leachate recreates an urban runoff mortality syndrome in coho but not chum salmon. Environmental Science & Technology, 55((17)): 11767.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2020
Citation:
Tian, Z. Y., H. Zhao, K. T. Peter, M. Gonzalez, J. Wetzel, C. Wu, X. Hu, J. Prat, E. Mudrock, R. Hettinger, A. E. Cortina, R. G. Biswas, F. V. C. Kock, R. Soong, A. Jenee, B. Du, F. Hou, H. He, R. Lundeen, A. Gilbreath, R. Sutton, N. L. Scholz, J. W. David, M. C. Dodd, A. Simpson, J. K. McIntyre & E. P. Kolodziej (2021). Ubiquitous tire rubber-derived chemical induces acute mortality in coho salmon. Science, 371(6525): 185.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2019
Citation:
Chow, M. I., J. I. Lundin, C. J. Mitchell, J. W. Davis, G. Young, N. L. Scholz & J. K. McIntyre (2019). An urban stormwater runoff mortality syndrome in juvenile coho salmon. Aquatic Toxicology, 214.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2018
Citation:
McIntyre, J. K., J. I. Lundin, J. R. Cameron, M. I. Chow, J. W. Davis, J. P. Incardona & N. L. Scholz (2018). Interspecies variation in the susceptibility of adult Pacific salmon to toxic urban stormwater runoff. Environmental Pollution, 238: 196.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2020
Citation:
Blair, S., C. Barlow, E. Martin, R. Schumaker & J. McIntyre (2020). Methemoglobin determination by multi-component analysis in coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) possessing unstable hemoglobin. MethodsX, 7: 100836.
|
Progress 10/01/19 to 09/30/20
Outputs Target Audience:Through presentations at national and regional conferences by the PIs, graduate students and postdocs: Stormwater managers regionally and nationally, regulators, researchers, interested citizens Changes/Problems:The impacts of storwmater on coho salmon are very acute; progressing from mild changes in behavior to death within hours. This does not leave much time for the body to mount a response that will be moderated by transcriptional responses. As such, the search for molecular pathways in coho affected by stormwater that can be used to develop tools for evaluating stormwater treatment effectiveness is premature. For the remainder of the project, our focus will be on elucidating the underlying physiological changes that occur in coho leading from health to death within hours of exposure to stormwater. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Training for 5 graduate students and one postdoc at WSU How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results have been shared primarily through presentations at local and national meetings of professionals, and also through outreach to citizens active in conservation in their watersheds around Puget Sound. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We have additional studies planned to elucidate the target tissues of the novel contaminant identified as the primary toxicant in stormwater.
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
We learned more about the underlying mode of action of stormwater on juvenile coho salmon, including their sensitivity in terms of amounts and durations of exposure that cause acute mortality, as well as what systems in the fish are the target of stormwater contaminants, and the identity of the primary toxicant causing acute mortality. By diluting roadway runoff with clean water, we found that coho exposed for as little as one hour could suffer delayed mortality within 24 h from concentrations as low as 12% stormwater. During 24-h exposures, coho died in concentrations of stormwater as low as 5%. We found that blood is not the direct target of contaminants in stormwater. We developed a method to quantitate methemoglobin in coho that can account for the instability of their hemoglobin and found that stormwater does not cause methemoglobin to be formed. This means evidence of cardio-respiratory distress in exposed coho is not due to an inability of hemoglobin to transport oxygen. We learned that a leachate made from running clean water over tire particles was sufficient to recreate the acute mortality of coho salmon, including their unique sensitivity relative to co-occurring chum salmon. Finally, using effects-directed-analysis, we were able to isolate and identify the contaminant in tire leachate primarily responsible for the acute mortality as a transformation product of an anti-oxidant added to tires to protect them from ozone.
Publications
- Type:
Theses/Dissertations
Status:
Other
Year Published:
2019
Citation:
Prat, J. 2020. ASSESSING JUVENILE COHO SALMON SENSITIVITY TO URBAN STORMWATER RUNOFF. M.S. Thesis for Washington State University, School of the Environment.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2019
Citation:
Blair, S., C. Barlow, E. Martin, R. Schumaker & J. McIntyre (2020). Methemoglobin determination by multi-component analysis in coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) possessing unstable hemoglobin. MethodsX, 7: 100836.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Awaiting Publication
Year Published:
2020
Citation:
Tian, Z. Y., H. Zhao, K. T. Peter, M. Gonzalez, J. Wetzel, C. Wu, X. Hu, J. Prat, E. Mudrock, R. Hettinger, A. E. Cortina, R. G. Biswas, F. V. C. Kock, R. Soong, A. Jenee, B. Du, F. Hou, H. He, R. Lundeen, A. Gilbreath, R. Sutton, N. L. Scholz, J. W. David, M. C. Dodd, A. Simpson, J. K. McIntyre & E. P. Kolodziej (2020). Ubiquitous tire rubber-derived chemical induces acute mortality in coho salmon. Science, Accepted Nov 5, 2020.
|