Source: DELAWARE STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
DEVELOPMENT OF GENOME-WIDE ASSOCIATION MARKERS FOR HEAT STRESS TOLERANCE IN BLUEBERRIES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1015264
Grant No.
2018-38821-27744
Cumulative Award Amt.
$500,000.00
Proposal No.
2017-07511
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Mar 15, 2018
Project End Date
Mar 14, 2022
Grant Year
2018
Program Code
[EQ]- Research Project
Recipient Organization
DELAWARE STATE UNIVERSITY
1200 NORTH DUPONT HIGHWAY
DOVER,DE 19901
Performing Department
Agriculture and Natural Resour
Non Technical Summary
Blueberry (V. corymbosum) is an economically important small fruit crop. Consumption of blueberries has been increasing in recent years due to the recognized health benefits such as prevention of heart diseases, anti-cancer activity and improved night vision. Previously, blueberry production was limited to temperate regions of Canada and northern parts of U.S., however in recent years blueberry has been grown as a commercial crop in many sub-tropical regions of the country. Occurrences of seasonal heat waves or extreme temperature events have been noticed recently and are projected to become more intense. A decrease in plant survival and fruit quality are observed in some cultivars where the daytime temperature reached above 30°C. As of now there are no heat tolerant blueberry varieties available or characterization of heat tolerant traits has not been achieved successfully in northern high blueberries. A related subtropical species V. darrowii, which grow on high temperature regions may have possibilities of possessing heat-stress tolerance traits but are not explored yet. We have successfully intercrossed these two-species producing F1 interspecific hybrids and generated several F2 families which will be used as mapping population and we also have nearly 50 divergent genotypes for the study. We will phenotype these populations for tolerance to heat stress and adaptation to temperate climate by observing several traits associated with enhancement of heat tolerance. We will genotype, identify novel Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs), Quantitative Trait Loci (QTLs) associated with heat stress and other adaptation traits by utilizing cutting edge Genotyping-by-Sequencing (GBS) technology. The associated SNPs will be developed as novel usable markers for the marker-assisted breeding (MAB) programs. Most importantly, this project will train postdoctoral research associates, graduate and undergraduate students with modern plant breeding techniques as well as helping build small fruits breeding program and research capacity at Delaware State University.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
40%
Applied
30%
Developmental
30%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
20111201080100%
Knowledge Area
201 - Plant Genome, Genetics, and Genetic Mechanisms;

Subject Of Investigation
1120 - Blueberry;

Field Of Science
1080 - Genetics;
Goals / Objectives
The goal of this research effort is to identify heat-stress tolerant plants from segregating population and develop markers, which can aid in marker-assisted breeding programs. This will be accomplished by identifying SNP markers, generating a high-density map and developing genome-wide association markers for heat-stress tolerance and its adaptation traits and by making the data generated in this effort publicly available. This new knowledge will assist blueberry breeders in developing abiotic tolerant genotypes based on genomic information rather than just relying on phenotypic evaluation.To tap the inherent genetic potential of this crop we aim to propose these objectives:1. Phenotype by screening the divergent germplasm and F2 population segregating for contrasting adaptation traits between V. darrowii (from subtropical region) and V. corymbosum (northern temperate) including vegetative and floral morphology, flowering phenology, asexual reproductive habit (rhizomatous vs. crown forming), evergreen vs. deciduous, winter hardiness, etc., 2. Identification of genetic variation in F1 and F2 segregating population for heat stress tolerance by phenotyping 3. High-throughput genotyping of germplasm, parents, F1 and F2 population by Genotyping-by-Sequencing (GBS) and identification of SNP markers 4. Integration of the knowledge and resources from this project into teaching/training of students (future talent development) and researchers (capacity building) at DSU and local blueberry farmers (outreach to stakeholders).
Project Methods
The broader methods include, phenotype by screening and evaluating blueberry germplasm, parents, F1 and a large F2 population for heat-stress tolerance, use novel genomic and postgenomic approaches for the development of high-density SNP markers and generate genome wide association marker for heat tolerance (none exists). Concurrently, this effort will help in the development of genomic and molecular marker resources for plant breeders. The resulting data will be made publicly available by depositing in NCBI GenBank, and subjected to bioinformatics and statistical analyses using appropriate software specific to the objective. Dr. Melmaiee will be teaching the "Advanced Molecular Breeding" course for graduate students and participating students will have material from this project for hands-on experience and have the opportunity to hone in on these cutting-edge technologies.Objective 1. Phenotype F2 population segregating for adaptation trait contrasts between V. darrowii (subtropical) and V. corymbosum (northern temperate) Which includes vegetative and floral morphology, flowering phenology, asexual reproductive habit (rhizomatous vs. crown forming), evergreen vs. deciduous, winter hardiness, etc.The parents, F1 and F2 progeny will be cloned through stem cuttings into smaller containers in 2018 to produce replicate (three to four replicates) plants of each genotype. The replicates will be transplanted in three-quart pots containing sand/peat media during late winter/ early spring 2019. Plant measurements, like leaf size, leaf habit, will be initiated in summer/fall on replicated design in 2019. In 2020 measurements on replicated design will include plant and leaf habit, leaf size, flowering phenology and organic acids. Heat stress experiments will be conducted concurrently and a few random plants will be sacrificed to allow for measuring root length and root morphology.Objective 2. Identification of genetic variation in germplasm, F1 and F2 segregating population for heat stress tolerance by phenotypingHeat-stress measurements on parents (replicated), F1 (replicated), F2 (single replicates) and germplasm (replicated) will be initiated in late summer 2018. This vast segregating population is a treasure to assess genetic variability. We will conduct heat-stress experiments to observe heat-stress tolerance levels for individual plants. Physiological parameters will be observed by using Li-COR portable photosynthesis system (Li- 6800) and spectrophotometer. Plants will be grown in the greenhouse with 25/20 °C day and night temperatures. Heat stress will be imposed in the growth room for different temperature conditions and newly matured leaves will be used for measuring photosynthetic and other physiological parameters like relative electrolyte leakage, reactive oxygen species, chlorophyll fluorescence, gas exchange and stem water potential.3. High-throughput genotyping of parents, F1 and F2 population by Genotyping -by- Sequencing (GBS) and identification of SNP markersLeaf samples will be collected from the above experimental material for genetic analysis. GBS will be performed to identify Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs), genome discovery and high-density molecular map and identification of quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for heat stress tolerance in blueberries.Objective 4. Integration of the knowledge and resources from this project into teaching/training of students (future talent development) and researchers (capacity building) at DSU and local blueberry farmers (outreach to stakeholders)The graduate and undergraduate students and the research associate involved in this project will be trained with traditional plant breeding and modern plant breeding techniques. Additionally, this project provides an opportunity to train future diverse plant breeders from an HBCU with a focus on small fruits and specialty crops. The output generated from this project provides material for a graduate student to use in development of a thesis.The PI will teach a graduate-level course "Advanced Plant Breeding" during the fall semesters. Genome sequences and markers generated from this project will be utilized for hands on training. Students will become familiarized with the genetic software tools and this will help them develop skills to compete in the national and international job markets. The Co-PI, Dr. Paudel, is actively involved in educating small and minority farmers in Delaware. He will organize blueberry workshops on varietal selection and cultural practices.

Progress 03/15/18 to 03/14/22

Outputs
Target Audience:Undergraduate and graduate students in my lab as they are engaged in research and lab meetings. STEM majors from Delaware State University as my students and post-doctoral scientist presented the project results at the annual research day and summer research symposiums from 2019 to 2022. Interested participants at annual National Association of Plant Breeders (NAPB) meetings, 2020 American Society for Horticultural Sciences meeting. Readers of the published research articles from this project. Additionally, Blueberry growers and enthusiasts from Mid-Atlantic region who participated in our blueberry workshops. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?A post-doctoral research associate Dr. Krishnanad P. Kulkarni was hired for accomplishing the project goals. The research project provided him the learning experience to handle large number of samples and data handling. This project also provided peer mentoring opportunities for post doc, graduate students, technician and undergraduate students in the lab and also facilitated them to participate in extension activities by way of help organize workshops and interact with clientele. This project also provided opportunities to the involved students and staff in crafting scientific communications as they were presented research findings at the annual University symposiums, professional meetings, gave elevator speeches, developed thesis and manuscripts. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The graduate Student Byron Manzanero presented research findings at the annual DSU research day, defended thesis to the public in Spring 2021. Some students from Delaware State University and The University of Rutgers were the audience. We were able to generate four peer reviewed research articles from this grant along with other grant funds. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? High chill blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) is a temperate fruit crop noted for desirable fruit quality. However, highbush cultivars are being subjected to higher summer temperatures, as well as the increased consumer demand, has blueberry production expanding to almost all continents with varying climates. With the warming climate in temperate zones northern highbush blueberry will likely require higher heat tolerance. V. darrowii, a diploid evergreen subtropical blueberry species native to the southern gulf coast may offer heat tolerance. The diploid parents NJ88-14-03, NJOPB-15, NJOPB-8 and NJ88- 12-41, F1; BNJ05-218-9 and BNJ05-237-8 and around 350 F2 plants from BNJ16-4 population were grown, genomic DNA was extracted and made ready for illumina sequencing. Plants were subjected to heat stress conditions and scoring was performed. These reciprocal crosses comprising 320 plants were subjected to high-temperature stress at 40°C for four days in the growth chamber and evaluated for chlorophyll fluorescence parameters (quantum yield [QY] and rapid fluorescence transient assay [OJIP]) and vegetation indices (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index [NDVI], Simple Ratio Index [SR] and Greenness Index [GI]). In blueberry, chlorophyll fluorescence parameters were used as an indicator of thermal tolerance and helped identify thermal-tolerant and -sensitive cultivars. GBS libraries were prepared by digesting DNA with a single restriction enzyme ApeK1 to genotype the 260 plants from the BNJ16-4 population and 60 plants from the BNJ16-5 population. We generated a large number of high-quality SNPs and successfully mapped 2.8 million GBS-obtained sequence reads per sample (Kulkarni et al. 2021) to the genome sequence of the tetraploid variety Draper. A total of 1,323 significant SNPs (p<0.01) associated with the chlorophyll fluorescence parameters and associated traits were identified by GWAS. The number of SNPs ranged from a minimum of 76 for Greenness Index to a maximum of 196 for Quantum Yield. To identify the candidate genes and their functions, 245 SNPs that were significantly associated with more than one high-temperature stress-tolerance traits were selected for further analysis.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Under Review Year Published: 2022 Citation: Byron R. Manzanero, Krishnanand P. Kulkarni, Nicholi Vorsa, Umesh K Reddy, Purushothaman Natarajan, Sathya Elavarthi1, Massimo Iorizzo, and Kalpalatha Melmaiee. Genomic relationships among wild and cultivated blueberry species. Journal of Advanced Research.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Other Year Published: 2022 Citation: Krishnanand P. Kulkarni, Nicholi Vorsa, Umesh K Reddy, Purushothaman Natarajan, Sathya Elavarthi1, Massimo Iorizzo, and Kalpalatha Melmaiee. Identification of candidate genes for high temperature stress tolerance in blueberries.


Progress 03/15/20 to 03/14/21

Outputs
Target Audience:Undergraduate and graduate students in my lab as they are engaged in research and lab meetings. STEM majors from Delaware State University as my students presented the project results at the research day and summer research symposium. Interested participants at National Association of Plant Breeders (NAPB) meeting. Additionally, Blueberry growers and enthusiasts from Mid-Atlantic region who participated in our blueberry workshops. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have hired a post-doctoral research associate Dr. Krishnanad Kulkarni for this project. The research project provided him the learning experience to handle large number of samples and data handling. This project also provides peer mentoring opportunities for post doc, graduate students, technician and undergraduate students in the lab and also facilitated them to participate in extension activities by way of help organize workshops and interact with clientele. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The results are presented at various meetings by the participation members. Graduate student Ms. Jodi Callwood has presented her research at the 1890 Association of Research Directors (ARD) meeting in April 2019 and also will be presented as posters at National Association of Plant Breeders's meeting at Pine Mountain, GA in August 2019 by PI Dr. Melmaiee and graduate student. The graduate Student Byron Manzanero presented his thesis research at the annual DSU research day. Many graduate students and undergrads from the college are the audience. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Rework on some of the bioinformatics analysis to increase the confidentiality of the candidate genes and prepare manuscripts for publication.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? High chill blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) is a temperate fruit crop noted for desirable fruit quality. However, highbush cultivars are being subjected to higher summer temperatures, as well as the increased consumer demand, has blueberry production expanding to almost all continents with varying climates. With the warming climate in temperate zones northern highbush blueberry will likely require higher heat tolerance. V. darrowii, a diploid evergreen subtropical blueberry species native to the southern gulf coast may offer heat tolerance. The diploid parents NJ88-14-03, NJOPB-15, NJOPB-8 and NJ88- 12-41, F1; BNJ05-218-9 and BNJ05-237-8 and around 350 F2 plants from BNJ16-4 population were grown, genomic DNA was extracted and made ready for illumina sequencing. Plants were subjected to heat stress conditions and scoring was performed. These reciprocal crosses comprising 320 plants were subjected to high-temperature stress at 40°C for four days in the growth chamber and evaluated for chlorophyll fluorescence parameters (quantum yield [QY] and rapid fluorescence transient assay [OJIP]) and vegetation indices (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index [NDVI], Simple Ratio Index [SR] and Greenness Index [GI]). In blueberry, chlorophyll fluorescence parameters were used as an indicator of thermal tolerance and helped identify thermal-tolerant and -sensitive cultivars. GBS libraries were prepared by digesting DNA with a single restriction enzyme ApeK1 to genotype the 260 plants from the BNJ16-4 population and 60 plants from the BNJ16-5 population. We generated a large number of high-quality SNPs and successfully mapped 2.8 million GBS-obtained sequence reads per sample (Kulkarni et al. 2021) to the genome sequence of the tetraploid variety Draper. A total of 1,323 significant SNPs (p<0.01) associated with the chlorophyll fluorescence parameters and associated traits were identified by GWAS. The number of SNPs ranged from a minimum of 76 for Greenness Index to a maximum of 196 for Quantum Yield. To identify the candidate genes and their functions, 245 SNPs that were significantly associated with more than one high-temperature stress-tolerance traits were selected for further analysis.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2021 Citation: Callwood, Jodi, Kalpalatha Melmaiee, Krishnanand P. Kulkarni, Amaranatha R. Vennapusa, Diarra Aicha, Michael Moore, Nicholi Vorsa, Purushothaman Natarajan, Umesh K. Reddy, and Sathya Elavarthi. "Differential Morpho-Physiological and Transcriptomic Responses to Heat Stress in Two Blueberry Species." International Journal of Molecular Sciences 22, no. 5 (2021): 2481.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2021 Citation: Kulkarni, Krishnanand P., Nicholi Vorsa, Purushothaman Natarajan, Sathya Elavarthi, Massimo Iorizzo, Umesh K. Reddy, and Kalpalatha Melmaiee. "Admixture Analysis Using Genotyping-by-Sequencing Reveals Genetic Relatedness and Parental Lineage Distribution in Highbush Blueberry Genotypes and Cross Derivatives." International Journal of Molecular Sciences 22, no. 1 (2021): 163.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Submitted Year Published: 2020 Citation: Kalpalatha Melmaiee*, Krishnanand P. Kulkarni, Jodi Callwood, Nicholi Vorsa and Sathya Elavarthi. Blueberries: What we know about their heat stress tolerance. American association of Horticultural Society (ASHS) annual conference August 10-14, 2020, Virtual.


Progress 03/15/19 to 03/14/20

Outputs
Target Audience:Scientific community attendies of National association of Plant Breeders 2019 annual meeting at Pine Mountain, GA and 2020 Plant and Animal Genomics ( PAG), San Diego, CA. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have hired a post-doctoral research associate Dr. Krishnanad Kulkarni for this project. The research project provided him the learning experience to handle large number of samples and data handling. This project also provides peer mentoring opportunities for post doc, graduate students, technician and undergraduate students in the lab and also facilitated them to participate in extension activities by way of help organize workshop and interact with clientele. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results were presented at the Natitional Association of Plant Breeders 2019 annual meeting at Pine Mountain, GA in August by PI and Post Doctoral Scientist presented at the Plant and Animal Genomics ( PAG) 2020 conference at San Diego, CA. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Genomic data analysis and scoring for heat stress tolerance traits will be continued. Manuscripts will be prepared from this project.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? High chill blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) is a temperate fruit crop noted for desirable fruit quality. However, highbush cultivars are being subjected to higher summer temperatures, as well as the increased consumer demand, has blueberry production expanding to almost all continents with varying climates. With the warming climate in temperate zones northern highbush blueberry will likely require higher heat tolerance. V. darrowii, a diploid evergreen subtropical blueberry species native to the southern gulf coast may offer heat tolerance. The diploid parents NJ88-14-03, NJOPB-15,NJOPB-8 and NJ88- 12-41, F1; BNJ05-218-9 and BNJ05-237-8 and around 350 F2 plants from BNJ16-4 population were grown, genomic DNA was extracted and made ready for illumina sequencing. Plants were subjected to heat stress conditions and scoring was performed. We have also collected fruits from the grand parents, F1 fruiting F2, and placed them in -80 for analysis of fruit volatiles, flavonols, organic acids and have taken data on F2 for fall senescence. Genotyping- by- Sequencing (GBS) protocol was optimized and libraries were prepared for sequencing and sequenced. Sequence quality control followed by alignment to existing blueberry, grape and Arabidopsis were performed. Identification of SNPs, LD blocks and QTL maps with one-year data were performed. Blueberry workshop was organized to interested farmers from Delaware and neighboring counties. The focus was on factors to be considered before establishing blueberry plantations including soil and water pH level testing.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: https://napb2019.uga.edu/files/2019/08/napb-program-with-abstracts.pdf pag.confex.com


Progress 03/15/18 to 03/14/19

Outputs
Target Audience:Our taget audience are blueberry growers from Delaware and surrounding regions, undergraduate and graduate students from the College of Agriculture, Science andTechnology at Delaware State University and Rutgers University. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We have hired a post-doctoral research associate Dr. Krishnanad Kulkarni for this project. The research project provided him the learning experience to handle large number of samples and data handling. This project also provides peer mentoring opportunities for post doc, graduate students, technician and undergraduate students in the lab and also facilitated them to participate in extension activities by way of help organize workshop and interact with clientel. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The results are presented at various meetings by the participation members. Graduate student Ms. Jodi Callwood has presented her research at the 1890 Association of Research Directors ( ARD) meeting in April 2019 and also will be presented as posters at National Association of Plant Breeders's meeting at Pine Mountain, GA in August 2019 by PI Dr. Melmaiee and graduate student. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the coming year we are planning on performing Genotyping-by-Sequencing (GBS), analyze the results, identify polymorhisms. Repeat the heat stress experiments for identification of reliable QTLs.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? High chill blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) is a temperate fruit crop noted for desirable fruit quality. However, highbush cultivars are being subjected to higher summer temperatures, as well as the increased consumer demand, has blueberry production expanding to almost all continents with varying climates. With the warming climate in temperate zones northern highbush blueberry will likely require higher heat tolerance. V. darrowii, a diploid evergreen subtropical blueberry species native to the southern gulf coast may offer heat tolerance. The diploid parents NJ88-14-03, NJOPB-15,NJOPB-8 and NJ88-12-41, F1; BNJ05-218-9 and BNJ05-237-8 and around 350 F2 plants from BNJ16-4 population were grown, genomic DNA was extracted and made ready for illumina sequencing. Plants were subjected to heat stress conditions and scoring was performed. We have also collected fruit from the grand parents, F1 fruiting F2, and placed them in -80 for analysis of fruit volatiles, flavonols, organic acids and have taken data on F2 for fall senescence. Blueberry workshop was organized to interested farmers from Delaware and neighboring counties. The focus was on factors to be considered before establishing blueberry plantations including soil and water pH level testing.

Publications