Source: JUN INNOVATIONS, INC. submitted to NRP
COMMERCIALIZED SUPERCOOLING TECHNOLOGY FOR SUBZERO NONFREEZING PRESERVATION OF FRESH FOODS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1013272
Grant No.
2017-33610-27013
Cumulative Award Amt.
$596,592.00
Proposal No.
2017-03586
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2017
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2020
Grant Year
2017
Program Code
[8.5]- Food Science & Nutrition
Recipient Organization
JUN INNOVATIONS, INC.
2800 WOODLAWN DR #101
HONOLULU,HI 96822
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Jun Innovations has developed a proprietary supercooling technology that preserves perishable materials at below-freezing temperatures without the formation of ice crystals. Foods are maintained in their natural state for weeks with the same taste, texture, nutrition, and moisture content they had before being supercooled. This technology offers a radically new food preservation method for consumers and the commercial food industry. The goal of the proposed Phase II project is to develop commercially viable supercooling units for technology demonstration and licensing negotiation with interested partners, including major home appliance manufacturers. In conventional refrigerators food items are frozen among ice crystals and their quality is compromised once they are thawed. Supercooling involves cooling of biological samples below a phase transition temperature in a balanced state leading to prevention of their cellular activity. In this supercooled state, damage by freezing such as protein denaturation and cellular structure injuries can be avoided. The proposed research work plan includes improvement of the supercooling stability regardless of any interfering environmental variants and the consistency with diverse perishable materials when the invention is scaled up for commercialization. Our primary strategy is to continue development and optimization of our currently working prototype, with the initial goal of producing prosumer-oriented appliances such as a stand-alone supercooling unit similar to a freezer while seeking licensing agreements to generate cash flow. Once this product line and revenue stream has been established, we can develop further applications for the commercial food industry, leading to the evolution of the food cold chain system.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
30%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
50172992020100%
Goals / Objectives
The ultimate goal of the proposed Phase II project is to develop 10 commercially viable units for technology demonstration and licensing negotiation with interested partners, including major home appliance manufacturers, transportation, food distributors, farmers and processors, and food retailers and restaurants. The developed drop-in styled supercooling unit can be placed in the existing freezer and self-programmed for food supercooling. The proposed research aim also includes (1) maintenance of the supercooling stability regardless of any interfering environmental variants and (2) improvement of the supercooling consistency with diverse perishable materials.In order to establish the commercialization of our supercooling technology, the following technical objectives are proposed:Objective 1: Develop and optimize a scaled up supercooling deviceObjective 2: Test and validate shelf life of perishable food materialsObjective 3: Study quality factor analysisObjective 4: Manufacture 10 commercially viable units (CVUs)
Project Methods
Task 1: Develop and optimize a commercially viable unit for food supercoolingController: Now that more concrete operational ranges have been established for target food samples, components and board layout can be optimized to reduce costs and increase functionality. The first component targeted for change is the MCU, past iterations used the ATMEL 32bit SAM3X8E, a costly component which proved to be much too powerful for the intended application. The 8bit ATMEGA328P is chosen as its replacement, a widely used, cheap, and easily programmable chip. Built-in pulse width modulation (PWM) allows for on the fly control of PEF and OMF wave generation in the ranges of 1Hz - 2MHz OMF and 31Hz - 2MHz PEF. The chosen ADC for this application is the ADS1220, this device is specifically designed to work with small voltage signals characteristic of thermocouples. Further improvements include over-voltage and reverse polarity protection at all power inputs, and additions of on-board data logging capabilities via SD card port and RTC (real time clock) chip. With further development of the backend software, the newly developed board is capable of stand-alone operation with real-time overcurrent protection.Box design: A uniform magnetic field across the entire sample chamber is critical to ensure proper supercooling, thus care must be taken in the scale up process. Current system designs employ the use of Hiperco-50 as a ferric core material, a costly alloy specifically engineered to amplify the magnetic field strength within electromagnets. For scale up purposes a proper substitute will be needed in order to keep costs reasonable while still maintaining high magnetic amplification. In addition proper material selection will also help in keeping overall operational cost down due to lower energy requirements in achieving a desired field strength. Other concerns include the weight of the OMF electromagnet system which currently tops off at roughly 6 lbs. If scaled up to a typical home refrigerator produce drawer the weight is projected to reach 32lbs, new approaches must be investigated in an effort to curtail this limiting factor. One such approach is the use of a laminated core, these types of cores are often used within transformers in an effort to reduce eddies currents and power loss. However a notable side benefit of such a core is the reduced weight associated with its design due to the lamination between each thin sheet of ferric material. The most current iteration of the OMF system uses a solid Hiperco-50 core material with a secondary thin sheet of ferric material to redirect the magnetic field over the sample chamber. A proposed alteration to the working design includes a laminated core and a reconfiguration of the electromagnets placement which results in a doubling of sample chamber volume with reduction in overall weight. The dimension of Box A is 260 mm x 250 mm x 230 mm (LxWxH) and Box B has 210 mm x 272 mm x 221 mm (LxWxH).Task 2: Test and validation of the shelf lifeTest and validation of the newly designed and scaled up unit will take into account the suitable environmental and system equipment operating parameters in maintaining large scale food samples. Chosen samples are meat (beef and chicken, 500 and 1000 grams) and fruits products (pineapple and strawberry, 300 and 500 gram). The samples will be loaded within the chamber of the developed device and monitoring of freezer, chamber, and sample temperatures conducted using T-type thermocouples (Omega Engineering) with data acquisition system (34970A, Agilent Technologies). The experiments will be carried under a variety of cooling conditions, taking into account ambient temperature, cooling rate, and airflow characteristics to determine operational characteristics and ranges. Operational parameters (field intensity, working frequency, the shape of electrical signal waveforms, and treatment time) of the magnetic and electric fields will be tested and optimized to determine their effects on sample temperature as well as system temperature and freezer temperature. This will be done via the monitoring of OMF and PEF subsystems with continuous instantaneous voltage and current measurements, thus power characteristics of each subsystem can be analyzed.All samples and controls will be shielded with polyethylene (PE) film to avoid dehydration during experiments. Quality factors of samples and controls will be analyzed at day 0, 7, 14, 21, and 28 days. All treatments will be done in duplicates.The degree of supercooling at which the sample was held during treatment will be controlled using a repeating sequence of three different duty cycles (0.8, 0.5, and 0.2) for the PEF. The time durations of duty cycles are 300 sec, 120 sec, and 120 sec. The duty cycle sequence will be repeated during the entire time the beef spent in the supercooled state. The input voltage will be set, through trial and error, to 5 Vrms with a frequency of 20 kHz in order to keep the internal temperature of the sample at approximately -4 ~ -6°C throughout the entire storage period. The applied voltage and frequency of the OMF are 95 Vrms and 1 Hz, respectively. The OMF is solely applied until the internal temperature of the sample reaches just below its freezing point (-2°C). The OMF treatment is referred to as phase 1, and the PEF and OMF combination treatment is referred to as phase 2 of the overall supercooling procedure. The same practice will be repeated for meat and fruit samples.Task 3: Quality factor analysisThe analyses will be carried out on the microstructure of fresh, refrigerated, and supercooled sample in comparison with the conventional freezing. Especially, the microstructure of the supercooled samples for a certain period, i.e. 4 weeks that exposed to external electric and magnetic fields will be definitively tested. At the same time, physiochemical properties of foods in color, texture, taste, other quality attributes, and microbiological examination will be tested.3.1 Light microscopic analysis3.2 Measurement of thaw drip loss3.3 Texture profile analysis (TPA)3.4 Color analysis3.5 Microbiological analysis3.6 TABRS (Lipid Oxidation)3.7 Sensory evaluationTask 4: Manufacture of CVUsOnce Jun Innovations has commercially viable products, we can use them for licensing negotiation and technology demonstration to interested parties. Currently, Dr. Jun's technology has received interest from appliance manufacturers such as Samsung, Haier, and LG Electronics. The supercooling technology and be easily incorporated into these manufacturer's existing product line, adding the supercooling feature to freezer units. These manufacturers also have the capital, infrastructure and the distribution network to bring supercooling technology to the consumer market worldwide. Upon completion of system optimization and quality factor tests (through Tasks 1 - 3), the PI group will fabricate 10 CVUs integrated with the controller, power supply, and supercooling chamber within a timeframe of 6 months. A majority of fabrication work will be performed in the lab except precision CNC work on solenoids. Fabrication of custom designed solenoids can be contracted with the SOEST Engineering Support Facility. Dr. Jun's research group at University of Hawaii will plan to contribute to mass production of CVUs and post-manufacture functional tests.

Progress 09/01/17 to 08/31/20

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One MS candidate in Bioengineering program at University of Hawaii was trained through this project. His research was directed by his mentor, Dr. Soojin Jun, Professor of Food Engineering. He was trained for simulation study of magnetic field effects on nucleation in supercooled bulk water. His research was presented in 2019 IFT meeting (New Orleans, LA). Supercooling research of one PhD candidate in MBBE program at University of Hawaii was directed by Dr. Soojin Jun, a subcontractor of this project. He was trained to explore and simulate fundamental mechanisms of electric and magnetic fields on water molecules. His research was presented in 2018 CoFE (Minneapolis, MN) and 2019 IFT meeting (New Orleans, LA). He published one manuscript in Journal of Food Process Engineering, entitled as "Effects of an oscillating magnetic field on ice nucleation in aqueous iron?oxide nanoparticle dispersions during supercooling and preservation of beef as a food application". He earned his PhD degree in 2019. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?1. Business pitch and presentation to conference meetings (i.e. 2020 TechConnect Virtual Innovation Summits & Expo) 2. Patents and publications U.S. Patent No. 10,111,452, Method of Supercooling Perishable Materials. Awarded on October 30, 2018 Japan Patent No. JP6545171B2 Supercooling method of perishable material, Awarded on July 17, 2019 Korea Patent No. KR102025978B1 Method of supercooling perishable materials, Awarded on September 26, 2019 U.S. Patent No.10,588,336, Method of Supercooling Perishable Materials, Continuation-In-Part application (CIP), Awarded on March 17, 2020. UK patent No. GB2535420, Method of supercooling perishable materials, Awarded on August 4, 2020. 3. The business executive approached potential seed investors and grant decision-makers with the supercooling CVU and the business plan to pitch them for additional financing (i.e. Xerox Parc). 4. The company met and spoke to people in refrigerator manufacturers' product development departments (i.e. LG Electronics, Samsung Electronics, and Haier Electronics). The purpose of these meetings was to make connections with potential licensees, learn about their licensing processes, and spread awareness of the supercoiling technology. 5. In 2019, Jun Innovations was one of the finalists at Pacific Business News' inaugural Titans of Technology Awards. https://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/event/163325/2019/titans-of-technology What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Objective 1: Develop and optimize a scaled up supercooling device Electrical Control Unit (ECU) system's weight and physical dimensions have been reduced from Year 1's ECU system design. A new enclosure was fabricated with an overall 60% volume reduction to achieve portability and address system weight concerns. The ECU's power-board was re-worked to a switching regulator design for better performance efficiency. Working closely with a technical partner, a new power-board based upon switching regulation was created and successfully integrated within our ECU system. The new power-board contains all the functionality of the previous power-board with the added benefit of under/over-voltage protection and fully adjustable voltage and current setting through an SPI digital interface. Thermal performance has greatly been improved with an estimated 100-Watt dissipation at maximum output for OMF and PEF combined. Being tasked with compiling and organizing all test codes into a coherent working control program, the team created a front-end interface for user interaction with ECU. Electrical measurements of the OMF and PEF system through all three phase legs of their respective H-bridge systems is now fully operational with the ability to individually monitor each phase leg's current and voltages with phase information preserved. This provides a significant advantage over previously used third party monitoring solutions thanks to the ability to monitor and calculate electrical power delivered to test samples in real time. It is now possible to monitor for common faults associated with H-bridge operations such as shorts/over-current conditions, over-heating, or under/over voltage conditions. The Large Capacity Chamber (LCC) system, which is comprised of the EM, EM support structure, Chest Freezer, Chamber temperature control system (CTCS) and ECU was developed in tandem with the ECU power-board and software development cycles. The component which dictated much of the ECU's operational parameters and the LCC's physical dimensions was the EM. During Years 1and 2's R&D phase, significant time and resources were spent investigating the best approach to scaling the EM. Heating, EM field strength, EM field uniformity, weight, and viable operational parameters were the primary guides behind its design and outcome. Balancing out each of these required substantial knowledges in the EM design and fabrication process, an EM manufacturer specializing in research applications was determined most appropriate. The EM was able to be spec'd out for continuous operation within a typical commercial chest freezer with no additional insulation to maintain internal chamber temperatures at a user-specified set point. The ECU and the LCC system have been successfully scaled up to accommodate larger food samples and test material. Former test chambers were only able to house a single test sample in volumes ranging between 1 L-3 L. The new LCC has 17 L of total volume with 15 L of the effective treatment area with an improved temperature control system. In addition, the system is now fully incorporated into an existing commercial chest freezer. Objective 2: Test and validate shelf life of perishable food materials Beef: Top round beef steaks were purchased from local meat producers (Honolulu, Hawaii). The samples were cut into 190 × 140 × 35 mm3 and covered with polyethylene film for the prevention of dehydration. A slab of meat was placed in each tray, and a total of four beef steaks within the range of 600 to 750 grams was tested at the same time. OMF and PEF were simultaneously applied to maintain a supercooled state of beef steaks at the ambient temperature of -3.5°C. Specifically, OMF (10 mT at 30 Hz) was applied from the beginning and (1.0×102 V/m at 20 kHz) was triggered when the temperature of a test sample was reached at -0°C, which is above the freezing point of beef. The time/temperature of the test samples was monitored using a data acquisition unit (Agilent 39704A, Agilent Technologies, Inc., Santa Clara, CA). K-type thermocouple wires (TT-K-40-SLE, Omega Engineering, Inc., Stamford, CT) were located underneath the meat samples. Fish: Fresh yellowfin tuna fillets (Thunnus albacares) were purchased at a retail store (Honolulu, Hawaii). The tuna samples were cut to be within 220 g ± 20 g (11×7×3 cm3) and placed in our supercooling chamber developed during the project period. The cut samples were wrapped with polyethylene film to avoid dehydration during experimentation. Samples were stored at the ambient temperature of 4°C (refrigeration), -3.5°C (supercooling), and -18°C (freezing) for up to 10 days, respectively, and the frozen samples were thawed with running water until the core temperature reached 20°C. Quality factor assessments were conducted on Day 0 and Day 10 in triplicate for each treatment. Objective 3: Study quality factor analysis Beef: For quality assessment, beef steaks were stored for 7 days at different cooling conditions such as refrigeration (4°C), freezing (-18°C), and supercooling (-3.5°C). After the preservation period, pictures were taken using a digital SLR camera (Canon, EOS Rebel T3i). The representative temperature profiles of beef steaks preserved in the LCC system indicated that the combination treatment of OMF and PEF enabled to achieve an extension of the supercooled state in larger sized beef steaks at the ambient of -3.5°C for 7 days. Noticeable color degradations were found in the refrigerated samples after 7 days, whereas the supercooling preservation maintained the redness with no external or internal sign of freezing damage. The achieved subzero temperature in the supercooled beef steaks significantly decreased the rate of color degradation without the formation of ice crystals, which damages cellular structures of food materials and cause adverse effects on their overall quality. Our tech demonstration can be found at the following link: https://youtu.be/yjmSR8AjLeU. Fish: The team measured the changes of total volatile basic nitrogen (TVB-N) to determine quality as it negatively correlated with the freshness of fish. The refrigerated tuna samples showed the largest increase in TVB-N values which were considered as spoiled, whereas the supercooled tuna had only a slightly higher TVB-N, which was statistically the same as the frozen/thawed samples. The team observed changes in total viable counts of aerobic bacteria on tuna preserved in refrigeration, freezing, and supercooling. While there was an increase in microbial counts in tuna meat by 4.1 log CFU/g when stored at 4°C for 10 days, only 1.8 log CFU/g increase was observed in the supercooled samples. The frozen/thawed samples also showed an increase in microbial counts; this might be due to the thawing process at 4°C, prior to the microbial examination. The supercooling preservation noticeably extended the shelf life of beef and tuna meats while minimizing the degradation of quality and bacterial growth. Objective 4: Manufacture 10 commercially viable units (CVUs) Jun Innovations and LG Electronics signed the collaborative research and development agreement with one year term exploratory research project funded by LG Electronics. Both companies have entered into the agreement to set out the terms and conditions with respect to the scope of this collaborative research and development project, the deliverables, the time schedules and the companies' undertakings. The proposed deliverables included designing of the scaled-up supercooling chamber in consideration of future home appliance applications. Jun Innovations designed and manufactured three CVUs consisting of ECUs and LCCs with external PID controllers. One of them was already shipped out to LG Electronics for the collaborative project and further potential licensing agreement.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Kang, T. Hoptowit, R., and. Jun, S. 2020. Effects of an oscillating magnetic field on ice nucleation in aqueous iron?oxide nanoparticle dispersions during supercooling and preservation of beef as a food application. Journal of Food Process Engineering https://doi.org/10.1111/jfpe.13525
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Kang, T., Hoptowit, R., You, Y., Chen, J., Francis, S., and Jun, S. 2019. Effect of an external magnetic field on supercooling of water and its application for food preservation. Institute of Food Technologists, June 2-5, New Orleans, LA
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Francis, S. and Jun, S. 2019. Optimization of Magnetic Field in a Solenoid Using â¿¿Electromagnetic Works⿝ (EMW) Finite Element Analysis (FEA). Institute of Food Technologists, June 2-5, New Orleans, LA
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Kang, T and Jun, S. 2018. Effect of electric and magnetic field on supercooling of beef steaks with different fat levels. Conference of Food Engineering (CoFE), September 9-12, Minneapolis, MN
  • Type: Theses/Dissertations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Kang, T. 2019. Electric and magnetic fields engineered for supercooling preservation of fresh foods: from fundamentals to applications. PhD dissertation, Molecular Biosciences and Bioengineering, University of Hawaii


Progress 09/01/18 to 08/31/19

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?PI and team will accomplish validation of LCC operation to designed specifications and diverse food preservation experiments within the LCC multi-tray chamber. Further data collection from a high strength magnetic field assembly will continue to explore the range of OMF optimized for a variety of liquid and solid materials.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The proposed objectives for Year 2 were: (1) to execute fabrication of Large Capacity Chamber (LCC) Supercooling unit (17 liter volume capacity), (2) to validate LCC operation to designed specifications, and (3) to conduct food preservation experiments within LCC. The team has fabricated LCC as specified during year 1's developmental phase. This involved bringing together each sub-system into a single operational package. The Electrical Control Unit (ECU) and the LCC system have been successfully scaled up to accommodate larger food samples and test material. Former test chambers were only able to house a single test sample in volumes ranging between 1L - 3L. The new LCC has 17L of total volume with 15L of effective treatment area with an improved temperature control system, in addition the system is now fully incorporated into an existing commercial chest freezer. The ECU now operates more reliably with increased flexibility in a smaller package, further size reduction is possible as targeted operational parameters are further refined. The team also created a self-contained device capable of independent operation from 3rd party hardware. Further investigations are still ongoing into the interactions of magnetic and electric fields upon food materials.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Soojin Jun, 2019. Supercooling technology for extended shelf life of perishable foods. the 13th International Congress on Engineering and Food (ICEF13),September 23-26, 2019, Melbourne, Australia
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Soojin Jun, 2019. Supercooling technology for extended shelf life of perishable foods. June 13, 2019. Haier Electronics, Qingdao, China


Progress 09/01/17 to 08/31/18

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Continued investigations into Helm-Holtz style electromagnet assemblies and their feasibility for use in large volumes at targeted magnetic field strength will continue. Initial studies and prototypes will focus upon the ranges of magnetic fields stated within current protocols for lean beef. Additional studies and prototypes may be conducted if investigations into high magnetic field strength applications demonstrate a better supercooling outcome. Development of software for the new electrical control unit will continue, testing and revisions to electrical designs and schematics will also continue in tandem. Continuation of shelf life studies are planned, contingencies for steady power during the 30-day testing period are being investigated. In addition, additional equipment for the extended shelf life studies are being acquired.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During this reporting period, the proposed objectives for Year 1 were: Objective 1. Develop and optimize a commercially viable unit for food supercooling and Objective 2. Test and validation of the shelf life. The completion of an initial scaled up supercooling chamber was achieved and the total chamber volume was expanded from 0.5 L to 1 L. While validation experiments were conducted with the new chamber to gauge the current design's scalability, prior protocols developed had to be translated with adjustments to operate the new device for supercooling. Supercooling of lean beef samples (200 g) was achieved on 5+ validation occasions. A newly developed electrical control unit better suited to drive larger electromagnet assemblies for scale up purposes was completed and is under testing and development. Simultaneously an exploration into Helm-Holtz based electromagnet assemblies have begun. Initial experiments have successfully supercooled 500 g ranged lean beef samples for up to 7 days. Several key aspects of the electromagnetic spectrum and their interactions with food have been largely uninvestigated. With subcontracted help through the University of Hawaii several investigations into the nature of magnetic and electric fields and their effects upon food over varying ranges of application are under way. In particular, investigations into high strength magnetic field applications and their uniformity are of key interest, plans to address these questions have been developed.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Taiyoung Kang and Soojin Jun, 2018. Effect of electric and magnetic fields on supercooling of beef steaks with different fat levels, Conference of Food Engineering, Minneapolis, MN, September 11.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Soojin Jun, 2018. Supercooling technology for extended shelf life of perishable foods. UKC 2018, Queens, NY, August 1-4.