Source: UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE submitted to
MANAGING PLANT MICROBE INTERACTIONS IN SOIL TO PROMOTE SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1012772
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
NH00677-R
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
W-3147
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 15, 2017
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2018
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Poleatewich, AN.
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE
(N/A)
DURHAM,NH 03824
Performing Department
Agriculture, Nutrition and Food Systems
Non Technical Summary
The challenge for sustainable agriculture is to develop economically viable alternatives to traditional pesticides without compromising yields. One strategy is to harness the power of naturally occurring antagonistic microbes as biopesticides, to reduce crop loss from disease. Inconsistent field performance of biopesticides however, has been a barrier to grower uptake. Because each farm and field is unique, a one-size fits all approach is not ideal for bio-based strategies. Understanding how environmental variables within different types of production systems influence biopesticide efficacy is needed to improve consistency and performance. This project aims to develop best practices tailored to specific production systems through a pre-commercial test system. Research has shown that different soil types, plant species and even cultivars harbor unique microbial communities but little is known about how this effects persistence of biocontrol agents. In this project, commercially relevant crop species/cultivars and commonly used growing substrates will be evaluated to identify combinations leading to the greatest performance and consistency. Furthermore, the integration of biopesticides, fungicides and nutrient management strategies will be evaluated in two crop systems. Knowledge gained in this project, shared with growers and biocontrol producers, will lead to improved technical support and on-farm performance. The long-term goal is to increase adoption of biopesticides giving growers a wider array of plant disease management tools for more effective sustainable production systems.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
40%
Applied
60%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2151122110225%
2161122110025%
2151460110225%
2161460110025%
Goals / Objectives
To understand how microbial populations and microbial gene expression are regulated by the biological (plants and microbes) and physical environment and how they influence disease. Implement sustainable management strategies for soilborne pathogens that are biologically based and are compatible with soil health management practices.
Project Methods
Objective 2: To understand how microbial populations and their gene expression are regulated by the biological (plants and microbes) and physical environment and how microbes influence disease.2.1 Plant species and even genotypes/cultivars within a species have unique rhizosphere microbiomes. Few studies have evaluated the effect of cultivar on colonization and disease suppression efficacy by commercial biological control agents (BCA) in horticultural crops. In this project, a model system will be established to study the effects of cultivar on biocontrol efficacy. Pythium-tomato and Pythium-strawberry pathosystems will be used as a model system. To establish the system, cultivars with similar levels of susceptibility to soilborne disease that exhibit differential biocontrol efficacy will be identified in a series of experiments. First, cultivars ranging from those currently used in commercial production to wild relatives will be screened for disease susceptibility using inoculation and plant production protocols established in previous research. The selected cultivars will then be evaluated for differential biocontrol efficacy. Four cultivars will be established in a rockwool media in the greenhouse. Cultivars will receive one of three treatments; water, fungal-BCA or bacterial-BCA. Each treatment will be applied to 10 replicate plants. Cultivars will be grown in plug trays and the biocontrol products will be applied as a drench at emergence and at transplant. Each cultivar-BCA combination will be challenged with Pythium 5-7 days post-transplant. Control treatments will not be infested and receive equal volume of water. At the end of the experiment, plant roots will be assessed for root rot severity. Roots will be sampled and plated to confirm the presence of Pythium. Plant roots in non-infested treatments will be sampled to assess colonization of the biocontrol agents. The experiment will be conducted twice.2.2 In addition to plant genotype influence on rhizosphere microbiomes, soil type has been shown to play a role in shaping the soil microbiome. The effect of growing substrates on biocontrol efficacy will be investigated using the system developed in objective 2.2. Commonly used substrates such as peat-perlite, coco-coir, wood-fiber and rockwool will be used in this study. Two classes of BCAs (fungal and bacterial) will be tested on a single cultivar in each substrate type. Each substrate-BCA combination will be applied to 10 replicate plants and the experiment will be conducted twice. Disease severity, Pythium colonization and biocontrol agent colonization will be evaluate as described in objective 2.1.The experiments conducted in this project set the stage for future research characterizing metabolite profiles and rhizosphere microbiome profiles in cultivars and soils with differential reactions to biocontrol agents.Objective 3: Implement sustainable management strategies for soilborne pathogens that are compatible and integrated with good soil health practices.Cultivar-BCA-substrate combinations yielding the greatest and most consistent efficacy in objective 2 will be further evaluated in pre-commercial production systems. The combination of propagation phase application of BCAs with production phase application of fungicides will be evaluated for synergies in replicated trials. In these experiments, plants will be grown for a full production cycle and fruit yield data collected. Production costs for top performing treatments will be calculated and compared to the conventional approach.Results from experiments conducted in objective 2 and 3 will be synthesized to develop a series of best practices and recommendations. These results and recommendations will be communicated to growers at regional meetings. Meeting participants will be surveyed to collect information on impact. Biocontrol company partners will be involved in project planning and results will be communicated in quarterly update reports.

Progress 05/15/17 to 09/30/18

Outputs
Target Audience:Undergraduates reached in the following courses through demonstration, lecture or independent study INCO 790 independent study - 1 student INCO 590 research experience - 3 students BIOL 510 Mushrooms, Molds, and Mildews: Introduction to the Fungal Kingdom- 45 students BIOL 704/804 - Plant-Microbe Interactions 20 students SAFS 405 Sustainable Agriculture and Food Production guest lecture (80 students) Commercial growers, extension specialists and industry representatives reached Floriculture Research Alliance meeting in October 2017. Approximately 80 participants. 2017 UCONN Greenhouse vegetable hydroponic workshop - approximately 30 participants 2018 Tri-State IPM workshop (Maine, Vermont and New Hampshire) - approximately 100 participants reached 2018 New Hampshire Fruit Growers Association annual meeting - approximately 30 participants 2018 New England Vegetable and Berry Growers meeting - approximately 40 participants 2018 New England Giant Pumpkin Growers meeting - approximately 15 participants Graduate students, undergraduate students, and scientists reached Invited seminar at the UMASS Stockbridge School of Agriculture Invited seminar, UNH Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition UNH graduate research conference Changes/Problems:As a new faculty member, starting in January of 2017, a significant portion of time was devoted to setting up lab and greenhouse workspaces. One challenge encountered was that I did not have full access to lab and greenhouse space until July 2017. These delays resulted in overall project delay impacting our ability to complete objective 2 (pre-commercial research trials). To compensate for the facility delays, we decided to shift our focus to objectives less dependent on facilities. For example, as the project progressed, we decided to devote more time to evaluating the effect of substrate and cultivar. We decided to include additional crop species to determine is differences observed were across crop species. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project provided opportunities for professional development in the areas of undergraduate and graduate one-on-one mentorship, conferences, workshops, and courses. One-on-one mentorship: Four undergraduate students were trained in a one-on-one setting as an independent study project thought the UNH Hamel Center for Undergraduate Research (INCO 790 and INCO 590). The students learned basic principles of plant pathology and experimental design. The students also gained laboratory and greenhouse skills related to culturing fungi in the lab, preparation of growth media, growing and maintaining plants in the greenhouse, collecting and analyzing data. Results of one student's project were presented to an audience of 80 growers, extension specialists and substrate producers at the floriculture Research Alliance greenhouse tour at UNH on October 18, 2017. One Masters level graduate student was trained whose thesis topic was directly related to the project. The student conducted experiments to evaluate the effect of cultivar and substrate on biocontrol efficacy. Through this research, the student gained skills related to experimental design, data analysis, fungal and bacterial culture, microscopy, and plant production. The student also presented their work at an international scientific conference. The provided the student to interact with scientists from across the globe and establish new networks for research. Conferences: Poster presentation at the 2018 International Congress of Plant Pathology held in Boston, MA in August 2018. Courses: Research incorporated into twocourses; Biol 510 Mushrooms, molds and mildews (taught twice in the reporting period) and Biol 704/804 Plant-microbe interactions (taught once in the reporting period). How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Outreach presentations were delivered at state and regional grower meetings to disseminate research-based information to growers and industry representatives. Presentations were given to greenhouse grower, fruit and vegetable, and tree fruit grower groups. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The challenge for sustainable agriculture is to develop economically viable alternatives to traditional pesticides. One strategy is to harness the power of naturally occurring antagonistic microbes as biopesticides, to reduce crop loss from disease. Inconsistent field performance of biopesticides however, has been a barrier to uptake. A greater understanding of how different agricultural practices influence biopesticide efficacy will allow for site-specific best-practices for extension specialists and growers to improve performance. This expanded tool-kit of management practices will increase productivity and sustainability of our agricultural production systems. Objective 1: To understand how microbial populations and microbial gene expression are regulated by the biological (plants and microbes) and physical environment and how they influence disease: 1.1 Develop a model system to study the effects of cultivar on biocontrol efficacy: During the first 6 months of the project, activities focused on developing a model system to study the effect of cultivar and substrate on biopesticide efficacy. Four isolates of Pythium species were obtained from collaborators and recovered from diseased plant material submitted to the UNH diagnostic clinic. These pathogen isolates were screened in greenhouse experiments for pathogenicity on tomato, cucumber, strawberry, petunia and calibrachoa. Protocols for plant production, pathogen dose, pathogen inoculation method, disease evaluation, and plant growth assessments were also developed. Modifications to the greenhouse are currently underway to construct a system that will mimic commercial substrate-based hydroponic production. A gutter system will be installed in greenhouse 5A at the MacFarlane Greenhouse facility on the UNH campus. Fertilization tanks and water-powered dosing systems will be installed to allow for atwo-component hydroponic fertilizer (A/B )fertilizer program in our experimental system. 1.2 Evaluate selected cultivars for differential biocontrol efficacy: Tomato and cucumber cultivars selected for susceptibility and ease of production in objective 1.1 were evaluated for differential biocontrol activity. Cultivars received one of three treatments; water, fungal-BCA (BioControl Agent) or bacterial-BCA. Each cultivar-BCA combination was infested with a zoospore suspension of Pythium aphanidermatum. At the end of the experiment, plant roots were assessed for root rot severity and root growth. Roots were sampled and plated on selective media to confirm the presence of Pythium. Plant roots in non-infested treatments were sampled to assess colonization of the biocontrol agents using culture-based methods and selective media. Above-ground biomass was assessed as fresh weight and dry weight. The experiments were conducted twice. These data are currently being analyzed for publication in a MS thesis and a peer-reviewed journal. Preliminary analyses suggest a significant effect of cultivar on plant growth promotion by the fungal biocontrol agent (Trichoderma harzianum) and then bacterial biocontrol agent (Bacillus subtilis). 1.3 Evaluate the effect of growing substrates on biocontrol efficacy: The effect of the substrate was tested on three crops; cucumber, calibrachoa, and petunia using the methods developed in objective 1.1. Experiments conducted on each crop were repeated twice. Each experiment consisted of a 4 x 3 factorial with 3 substrates and 4 biological control agents. The 3 substrates included oasis foam, peat moss, and coconut coir. The 4 biocontrol agents included Rootshield WP (Trichoderma harzianum T-22), Cease (Bacillus subtilis QST-713), Regalia (extract from Reynoutria sachalinensis), and a water control. Five replicate plants were infested with P. aphanidermatum zoospores and five replicate plants received water (to serve as healthy controls). Data analyses indicate that substrate had an effect (P<0.005) on Pythium root disease severity and biopesticide efficacy on cucumber and calibrachoa. Differenceswere not observed on petunia. Overall, there was less disease observed on plants propagated in Oasis and peat, but greater disease suppression was observed in coco coir. Plant health/growth was not significantly different between plants treated with products compared to water indicating that these products can be applied in propagation. This was an important finding as many growers report hesitation to use products in propagation due to concerns over phytotoxicity. These data were presented at the International Congress of Plant Pathology in August 2018 and are currently being written for publication in a peer-reviewed journal and a master's thesis. Objective 2: Implement sustainable management strategies for soilborne pathogens that are biologically based and are compatible with soil health management practices: Research conducted in objective 1 was reported to the biocontrol company partners and results communicated to growers. Additional grower communications are scheduled for the 2018-2019 winter meetings (i.e. the 2019 Tri-State Workshop). Biocontrol-substrate combinations yielding the greatest efficacy in objective 1 will be tested in experiments scheduled to begin in January of 2019.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: DeGenring, L., Poleatewich, A. 2018. Effect of cultivar on biocontrol efficacy of Pythium in hydroponic tomato system. Phytopathology. 108 (10S)


Progress 05/15/17 to 09/30/17

Outputs
Target Audience:Undergraduates reached in the following courses through demonstration, lecture or independent study 1. Summer volunteer student Changes/Problems:As a new faculty member, starting in January of 2017, a significant portion of time was devoted to setting up lab and greenhouse workspaces. One challenge encountered was that I did not have full access tolab and greenhouse space until July 2017. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?An undergraduate student was trained over the summer in a one-on-one setting as an independent study project. The student learned basic principles of plant pathology and experimental design. The student also gained laboratory and greenhouse skills related to culturing fungi in the lab, preparation of growth media, growing and maintaining plants in the greenhouse, collecting and analyzing data. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Plans for the next reporting period are described by objective below. Objective 1.1: Develop a model system to study the effects of cultivar on biocontrol efficacy. This objective was 80% completed during the current reporting period. Experiments to screen tomato cultivars for disease susceptibility will be completed January 2018. The strawberry and tomato experiments conducted in 2017 will be repeated in the next reporting period. Additional Pythium isolates will be collected so that cultivars can be screened against a diversity of isolates which vary in virulence. Modifications will also be made to the greenhouse. A second pre-commercial facility will be constructed to mimic commercial substrate-based hydroponic production. A gutter system will be installed in greenhouse 5A at the MacFarlane Greenhouse facility on the UNH campus. Fertilization tanks and dosatrons, water-powereddosing systems, will be installed to allow for an A/B fertilizer program in our experimental system. Objective 1.2 Evaluate selected cultivars for differential biocontrol efficacy Cultivars selected for susceptibility and ease of production in objective 1.1 will be evaluated for differential biocontrol activity. Cultivars will receive one of three treatments; water, fungal-BCA (BioControl Agent) or bacterial-BCA. Each cultivar-BCA combination will be challenged with Pythium and at the end of the experiment, plant roots will be assessed for root rot severity. Roots will be sampled and plated on selective media to confirm the presence of Pythium. Plant roots in non-infested treatments will be sampled to assess colonization of the biocontrol agents on the roots using culture-based methods and selective media. Above-ground biomass will be assessed as fresh weight and dry weight. Objective 1.3 Evaluate the effect of growing substrates on biocontrol efficacy The effect of substrate will be investigated using the system developed in objective 1.1. Commonly used substrates such as peat-perlite, coco-coir, oasis [a synthetic potting medium], wood-fiber and rockwool will be used in this study. Two classes of BCAs (fungal and bacterial) will be tested on a single cultivar in each substrate type. Disease severity, Pythium colonization and biocontrol agent colonization will be evaluated as described in objective 1.2. Objective 2: Implement sustainable management strategies for soilborne pathogens that are compatible and integrated with good soil health practices Cultivar-BCA-substrate combinations yielding the greatest and most consistent efficacy in objective 2 will be further evaluated in pre-commercial production systems. The combination of propagation phase application of BCAs with production phase application of fungicides will be evaluated for synergies in replicated trials. In these experiments, plants will be grown for a full production cycle and fruit yield data collected.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The challenge for sustainable agriculture is to develop economically viable alternatives to traditional pesticides. One strategy is to harness the power of naturally occurring antagonistic microbes as biopesticides, to reduce crop loss from disease. Inconsistent field performance of biopesticides, howeverhas been a barrier to uptake. A greater understanding of how different agricultural practices influence biopesticide efficacy will allow for site-specific best-practices for extension specialists and growers to improve performance. This expanded tool-kit of management practices will increase grower productivity and sustainability Objective 1: To understand how microbial populations and microbial gene expression are regulated by the biological (plants and microbes) and physical environment and how they influence disease: During the first 5 months of the project, activities focused on developing the model system to study the effect of cultivar and substrate on biopesticide efficacy. Several isolates of the root pathogen Pythium were obtained from collaborators. Pythium isolates were also recovered from diseased material submitted to the UNH diagnostic clinic and added to the plant pathology culture collection. These locally sourced pathogen isolates were screened in greenhouse experiments for pathogenicity and consistency on tomato andcucumber. Protocols for plant production, pathogen dose and inoculation, disease evaluation and plant growth assessments were also developed. Experiments are currently underway to determine a baseline disease susceptibility of 7 tomato cultivars. Objective 2: Implement sustainable management strategies for soilborne pathogens that are biologically based and are compatible with soil health management practices: This objective will be initiated in year 2 of the project (2018).

Publications