Source: UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE submitted to
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT IN COMMERCIAL GREENHOUSE PRODUCTION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1012018
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
NH00652-R
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
NE-1335
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jan 3, 2017
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2018
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Dickson, RY, WI.
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE
(N/A)
DURHAM,NH 03824
Performing Department
Agriculture Nutrition and Food Systems
Non Technical Summary
Primary functions of soilless substrates used in horticulture are (1) to provide physical support for plant roots, (2) hold water and nutrients for plant uptake, and (3) allow for the exchange of gases (oxygen, carbon dioxide, ethylene) between the root zone and atmosphere. Traditional substrates used in container floriculture and hydroponic food production are composed primarily of peat moss and synthetic rockwool, respectively, which in recent years have been labelled non-renewable and non-sustainable materials. Effects from climate change and heavy harvesting over the recent decades have depleted peat moss bogs in North America and Europe. Rockwool is non-biodegradable, posing environmental issues for disposal, and is currently being banned in some countries. Examples of alternative substrate components that come from renewable sources and are more sustainable include coconut husk (coir), a by-product of the palm industry, and wood fiber materials which are by-products of the paper industry in the United States. Improved processing technology of coconut coir and wood fiber have made these materials more available and at lower cost for use in horticultural substrates.The physical and chemical properties of substrate formulated with coconut coir or wood fiber differ from those of traditional peat:perlite or rockwool substrates. For example, coconut coir and wood fiber differ in physical properties such as available pore space for air and water, ability to retain water, and dry bulk density. These substrates may also differ in chemical properties such as nitrogen immobilization, micronutrient availability, potential for leaching of fertilizer nutrients, acidity or basicity, and pH buffering capacity. These factors have the potential to affect plant growth as well as fertilizer and irrigation practices during production. There is a need for more testing of new wood fiber and coir substrates so that fertilizer strategies can be developed to help growers manage pH and nutrition when using these substrates. Anecdotal evidence also suggests that coconut coir or wood fiber materials promote better root development and earlier flowering compared to conventional mixes, although this has not been thoroughly tested.Objectives of this study are (1) to evaluate new wood fiber and coconut coir substrate types by comparing their effects on plant performance and nutrient management to those of conventional substrates and (2) to develop fertilizer strategies to help growers manage pH and plant nutrition when growing in these substrates. Substrates varying in proportions of peat, wood fiber, or coconut coir will be tested in both hydroponic nutrient film technique (NFT) systems with leafy greens and herb species and in containers with floriculture species. Substrate types will be evaluated with different fertilizer programs where total applied nutrient concentration, nitrogen form, and pH will be varied. Substrate types will be analyzed for physical and chemical properties including bulk density, total porosity (air and water), pH buffering capacity, and effects on nutrient availability. Substrate and fertilizer effects on root and shoot growth, flower development, leaf chlorophyll content, and plant tissue nutrient levels and sensitivity to developing micronutrient disorders will also be tested. Project results will be presented to local growers and horticultural companies at annual meetings, regional Cooperative Extension meetings, and conferences. Results will also be published online, in Cooperative Extension reports and popular trade magazine articles, and submitted as manuscripts to peer-reviewed scientific journals.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
0%
Applied
100%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1021430102030%
2052122101035%
2052123101035%
Goals / Objectives
To develop up-to-date water and nutrient as well as energy management guidelines for greenhouse crop production and provide stakeholders with educational opportunities that teach proper implementation at their own facilities.
Project Methods
Horticultural substrates formulated with varying amounts of wood fiber or coconut coir along with fertilizer practices will be evaluated for their effects on plant growth, pH buffering, and nutrient use efficiency in commercial greenhouse production compared with conventional substrates. Experimental results will then be used to develop fertilizer and substrate management strategies for growers using substrates formulated with wood fiber and coir materials. Substrate types and fertilizer practices will be tested with hydroponically-grown leafy greens and herb species using nutrient film technique (NFT) systems and with container-grown floriculture species.Experiments will be conducted at the University of New Hampshire MacFarlane greenhouses in Durham, NH. The greenhouse environment will be controlled using an Argus environmental control computer, and portable data loggers will record air and water temperature, light levels, and relative humidity. Supplemental lighting will be provided from HID lamps during periods when the daily light integral drops below 5 moles per square meter per day.Substrate types for the hydroponic experiments will consist of rockwool (control) or oasis and substrates varying in proportions of peat, coconut coir, and wood fiber. Substrate types for container-grown experiments with floriculture species will consist of a standard peat-based substrate (control) and substrates varying in proportions of peat, coconut coir and wood fiber.Hydroponic NFT systems will consist of four to eight-foot gutters positioned at a slight gradient on top of a greenhouse bench. Each gutter will hold approximately six to twelve plants, and each hydroponic system will contain two to four gutters. Nutrient solution will be constantly pumped from reservoirs (approximately 40 gallons) below the bench to the top of each gutter, allowing the solution to flow down each gutter and over plant roots before returning to the reservoir. Nutrient levels in the reservoir will be monitored using an electrical conductivity (EC) meter, maintained with manual additions of fresh nutrient solution or clear water accordingly, and fully replenished every seven days. Solution-pH will be monitored using a portable pH meter and maintained between 5.5 and 6.5 by adding small amounts of hydrochloric acid (HCl) or sodium hydroxide (NaOH). Hydroponic nutrient solutions will vary in the concentration of total fertilizer nutrients and nitrogen forms (ammonium-N and nitrate-N).Seeds of leafy green and herb species will be germinated in trays containing cells of each substrate type. Early plant growth will be measured by the time it takes seeds to reach the cotyledon stage and a transplantable size. During this period, plant development will be evaluated using root and shoot visual indices. Final plant growth will be quantified as shoot and root dry mass accumulated after approximately four weeks in hydroponic Nutrient Film Technique (NFT) culture. Leaf chlorophyll concentration (green leaf color, quality indicator) will be indexed using a portable SPAD chlorophyll meter. Effects of the nutrient solution on substrate pH and Electrical Conductivity (EC; measured non-destructively) will be quantified over time and used to evaluate differences in substrate buffering, nutrient availability, and salt build-up. Substrate types will be evaluated for physical and chemical properties in the laboratory. Physical properties may include but are not limited to bulk density, total air and water porosities, and particle size distribution. Chemical properties may include but are not limited to pH, soluble salts (EC), nitrogen immobilization, and titratable acidity measured using an acid-titration procedure. Experiments will also be conducted with container-grown plants to test the effects of substrate type and method of fertilizer application on plant growth and quality, nutrient use efficiency, and pH buffering capacity with floriculture species. Plants grown with acidic or basic reaction fertilizers will be evaluated for effects on substrate pH change over time. Substrate pH buffering will also be quantified in the laboratory using an acid-base titration used to correlate change in pH units with milli-equivalents of acidity or basicity. Root and shoot growth, nutrient uptake, leaf chlorophyll content, physical and chemical substrate properties will be measured using the same methods used in hydroponic experiments. Time to first open flower bud and number of flowers per plant will also be recorded.Partial economic and cost-benefit analyses will be summarized for substrate types used in hydroponic leafy greens production and in container-grown floriculture production.

Progress 01/03/17 to 09/30/18

Outputs
Target Audience: Controlled-environment growing operations. Operations include greenhouse, nursery, and otherwise protected agriculture where growers produce ornamental, herbs and vegetables, and other specialty crops. Allied horticulture industries. Allied industries are commercial horticulture companies that do not directly produce crops. These include substrate manufacturers, fertilizer companies, water treatment companies, pest control companies, brokers and distributors, greenhouse supply companies, and plant breeders. New Hampshire horticulture organizations. These include both New Hampshire Plant Growers and New Hampshire Landscape Associations. University students. Includes both undergraduate and graduate students enrolled in agriculture-related and engineering curriculum. No courses were taught during this past reporting cycle. Members of the horticultural science community. Members include scientists, students, and research and development staff from other universities, private research institutions, and private industry companies. Public. This includes general homeowner, hobbyist, and prospective commercial greenhouse audiences in New Hampshire. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One graduate student has worked on this project and received one-on-one mentorship from the project director (Ryan Dickson). The student received mentoring on conducting applied research, designing experiments, collecting and analyzing data, and writing up research results. Students were also required to interact with industry stakeholders when helping with projects as part of their professional development. One undergraduate student helped write a research report and present to industry stakeholders that helped support the project. This project enabled the director (Ryan Dickson) to complete several professional development workshops and courses on grant writing and greenhouse economics. University of New Hampshire workshops included the USDA "Push" workshop, the USDA Small Business Innovation and Research workshop, and an Introduction to NSF proposals workshop to enhance grant-writing skills and knowledge. The director completed Greenhouse Cost Accounting and Profitability, an online course offered by the University of Florida designed to train growers and educators on financial benchmarking and decision-making. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Target audiences for our research results and updated strategies on managing resources (nutrients, water, energy, and growing media) for greenhouse crop production included commercial greenhouse growers, allied industries in horticulture, university academics and students, and the public. We reached these audiences using different communication platforms, including online newsletters and reports, publications in popular trade magazines, publication in peer-reviewed scientific journals, presentations at scientific meetings, grower workshops and training, and university open house events. Online newsletters and reports were written for e-GRO (electronic grower resources online), which is an online source for applied research and extension that reaches growers and academics nation-wide. In addition, articles were published in the national trade magazines GrowerTalks, Greenhouse Management, and Produce Grower, as well as for New Hampshire Cooperative Extension and the New Hampshire Communicator. Grower workshops and training targeted commercial greenhouse and nursery growers in New England as well as nation-wide. New England events included the New Hampshire Joint Winter Meeting, New England Nursery Conference, New Hampshire Plant Growers Annual Meeting, the Tri-State Integrated Pest Management (IPM) workshops (Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine), the Northeast Greenhouse Conference, and separate greenhouse best management workshops hosted by the Universities of Maine, Massachusetts, and Connecticut. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? There are often economic and environmental benefits to using new alternative materials in the growing media to produce high-value greenhouse crops. Understanding the potential of these materials to influence the rooting media properties and plant growth is critical to developing improved media formulations as well as updated fertilization, irrigation, and pH management strategies. Objective 1. EFFECTS OF WOOD CHIPS AND FIBER ON THE MEDIA PH BUFFERING CAPACITY: Last year, a range of horticultural growing media formulated using different proportions of sphagnum peat, coconut coir, bark, perlite, and wood fiber were evaluated for their pH buffering in a laboratory titration procedure. pH buffering was measured by dosing samples of each media with hydrochloric acid and recording the amount of decrease in pH. Media with greater proportions of alternative material, such as wood fiber, and less sphagnum peat had lower less pH buffering. This was verified in agreenhouse experiment where impatiens were grown in each media and irrigated with acidic and basic reaction fertilizers that lowered and raised pH, respectively. These results indicate that commercial growers using media with high proportions of alternative wood fiber materials (>30% by volume) may need to adjust the acidity or basicity of their fertilizer program to stabilize pH and prevent nutritional disorders. Objective 2. POTENTIAL OF WOOD CHIPS AND FIBER MEDIA TO IMMOBILIZE NITROGEN AND EFFECTS ON PLANT PERFORMANCE: In a project last year, flowering petunia were grown in containers in the greenhouse in media containing up to 30% (by volume) wood fiber, wood chips, and coconut coir from multiple suppliers (the remainder of the media was sphagnum peat). We evaluated the effects of alternative media materials on plant performance and the potential to immobilize fertilizer nitrogen, making nitrogen unavailable for root uptake. Across media suppliers, media containing 30% wood fiber resulted in plants with the least amount of growth and flowering and the lowest nitrogen concentrations in the dry tissue. Nitrogen concentrations measured in the media solution were also lowest in wood fiber media. However, wood fiber media did not affect leaf chlorophyll content, and all plants had green foliage and considered marketable. Despite a decrease in growth and nitrogen uptake by plants in the greenhouse, we were unable to measure nitrogen immobilization in wood fiber media using a laboratory procedure. In another project that ended this year, petuniaswere grown in media with up to 50% wood chips and fiber and were supplied fertilizer with low, moderate, high, and very high levels of nitrogen. Again, a reduction in growth and flowering were measured.Across media suppliers, media containing 30% wood fiber resulted in plants with the least amount of growth and flowering and the lowest nitrogen

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Awaiting Publication Year Published: 2019 Citation: Dickson, R.W. and Fisher, P.R. In press. Quantifying pH effect of fifteen floriculture species in peat substrate. Proc. IS on Growing Media and Soilless Cultivation. Acta Hort.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Dickson, R.W., Fisher, P.R., and Argo, W.R. 2017. Quantifying acidity and basicity of fifteen floriculture species in peat substrate. HortScience 52 (8): 1065-1072.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Dickson, R.W, and Fisher, P.R. 2017. Ammonium-nitrate ration and cation/anion uptake affect the acidity or basicity of floriculture species. Proc. IS on Growing Media and Soilless Cultivation. Acta Hort. 1168, ISHS


Progress 01/03/17 to 09/30/17

Outputs
Target Audience:Target audiences are below. Efforts aimed to target New England and nation-wide audiences, and in some cases international audiences. Controlled-environment growing operations. Operations include greenhouse, nursery, and otherwise protected agriculture where growers produce ornamental, herbs and vegetables, and other specialty crops. Allied horticulture industries. Allied industries are commercial horticulture companies that do not directly produce crops. These include substrate manufacturers, fertilizer companies, water treatment companies, pest control companies, brokers and distributors, greenhouse supply companies, and plant breeders. New Hampshire horticulture organizations. These include both New Hampshire Plant Growers and New Hampshire Landscape Associations. University students. Includes both undergraduate and graduate students enrolled in agriculture-related and engineering curriculum. No courses were taught during this past reporting cycle. An undergraduate greenhouse management course is scheduled and will be reported on next year. Members of the horticultural science community. Members include scientists, students, and research and development staff from other universities, private research institutions, and private industry companies. Public. This includes general homeowner, hobbyist, and prospective commercial greenhouse audiences in New Hampshire. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Training and professional development opportunities included courses, workshops, and one-on-one mentorships for students and the PI. Five undergraduate and one graduate student have worked on this project and received one-on-one mentorship from the project director (Ryan Dickson). Each student received mentoring in conducting applied research, designing experiments, collecting and analyzing data, and writing up research results. Students were also required to interact with industry stakeholders when helping with projects as part of their professional development. This project enabled the director (Ryan Dickson) to enroll in several professional development workshops and courses on grant writing and greenhouse economics. University of New Hampshire workshops included the USDA "Push" workshop, the USDA Small Business Innovation and Research workshop, and an Introduction to NSF proposals workshop to enhance grant-writing skills and knowledge. The director enrolled in Greenhouse Cost Accounting and Profitability, an online course offered by the University of Florida designed to train growers and educators on financial benchmarking and decision-making. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Target audiences for our research results and updated strategies on managing resources (nutrients, water, energy, and growing media) for greenhouse crop production included commercial greenhouse growers, allied industries in horticulture, university academics and students, and the public. We reached these audiences using different communication platforms, including online newsletters and reports, publications in popular trade magazines, publication in peer-reviewed scientific journals, presentations at scientific meetings, grower workshops and training, and university open house events. Online newsletters and reports were written for e-GRO (electronic grower resources online), which is an online source for applied research and extension that reaches growers and academics nation-wide. In addition, articles were published in the national trade magazines GrowerTalks, Greenhouse Management, and Produce Grower, as well as for New Hampshire Cooperative Extension and the New Hampshire Communicator. Grower workshops and training targeted commercial greenhouse and nursery growers in New England as well as nation-wide. New England events included the New Hampshire Joint Winter Meeting, New England Nursery Conference, New Hampshire Plant Growers annual Meeting, Carrol County Farm Bureau annual meeting, the Tri-State Integrated Pest Management (IPM) workshops (Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine), the Northeast Greenhouse Conference, and separate greenhouse best management workshops hosted by the Universities of Maine, Massachusetts, and Connecticut. Attendance for these workshops ranged from 30 to 600 individuals. We also participated in the University of New Hampshire Macfarlane Greenhouses Spring Open House event, where our program,as well as research results, were show-cased to homeowners and the public. Presentations to scientific audiences were delivered at American Society for Horticultural Science (ASHS) and International Society for Horticultural Science (ISHS) annual meetings. ASHS is a leading organization for horticulture scientists, academics, and industry in the United States, covering a range of topic areas from field and protected agriculture to plant breeding and molecular biology. ISHS is a similar group with international membership, divided into general topic areas. The attended 2017 ISHS meeting had a topic area of Soilless Growing Substrates and Composts for Protected Cultivation, which is a major focus of our New Hampshire Agriculture Experiment Station project. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We plan to pursue the following areas during the next reporting period to accomplish our goals. Evaluate the effects of wood chips and fiber media on nitrogen uptake by roots and plant performance across a wide range of greenhouse crop species. There is anecdotal evidence that wood fiber media will differ in effects on various plant species, which may be related to the plant growth rate and demand for nutrient. There is additional evidence suggesting that wood fiber media promotes more rapid flowering and fruiting. A range of plant species differing in nutrient demand and growth habit will be evaluated in wood fiber and wood chip media. Evaluate the effects of wood fiber and various peat grades on media properties. Blending wood fiber into a media containing mostly sphagnum peat has potential to increase media aeration, which benefits rooting. However, the amount of aeration and benefit likely depends on the grade of peat (fine, medium, or coarse). Mixing trials will be conducted with multiple wood fiber and peat grades to better understand how the initial physical properties of each material influence the properties of the final media.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? There are often economic and environmental benefits to using new alternative materials in the growing media to produce high-value greenhouse crops. Understanding the potential of these materials to influence the rooting media properties and plant growth is critical to developing improved media formulations as well as updated fertilization, irrigation, and pH management strategies. Objective 1. EFFECTS OF WOOD CHIPS AND FIBER ON THE MEDIA PH BUFFERING CAPACITY: Last year, a range of horticultural growing media formulated using different proportions of sphagnum peat, coconut coir, bark, perlite, and wood fiber were evaluated for their pH buffering in a laboratory titration procedure. pH buffering was measured by dosing samples of each media with hydrochloric acid and recording the amount of decrease in pH. Media with greater proportions of alternative material, such as wood fiber, and less sphagnum peat had lower less pH buffering. This was verified in a greenhouse experiment where impatiens were grown in each media and irrigated with acidic and basic reaction fertilizers that lowered and raised pH, respectively. These results indicate that commercial growers using media with high proportions of alternative wood fiber materials (>30% by volume) may need to adjust the acidity or basicity of their fertilizer program to stabilize pH and prevent nutritional disorders. Objective 2. POTENTIAL OF WOOD CHIPS AND FIBER MEDIA TO IMMOBILIZE NITROGEN AND EFFECTS ON PLANT PERFORMANCE: In a project last year, flowering petunia were grown in containers in the greenhouse in media containing up to 30% (by volume) wood fiber, wood chips, and coconut coir from multiple suppliers (the remainder of the media was sphagnum peat). We evaluated the effects of alternative media materials on plant performance and the potential to immobilize fertilizer nitrogen, making nitrogen unavailable for root uptake. Across media suppliers, media containing 30% wood fiber resulted in plants with the least amount of growth and flowering and the lowest nitrogen concentrations in the dry tissue. Nitrogen concentrations measured in the media solution were also lowest in wood fiber media. However, wood fiber media did not affect leaf chlorophyll content, and all plants had green foliage and considered marketable. Despite a decrease in growth and nitrogen uptake by plants in the greenhouse, we were unable to measure nitrogen immobilization in wood fiber media using a laboratory procedure.

Publications