Source: SUSTAINABLE BIOPRODUCTS LLC submitted to NRP
PRODUCTION OF HIGH-QUALITY PROTEIN, LIPIDS AND BETA-GLUCANS FROM ACID WHEY WASTE STREAMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1011423
Grant No.
2017-67021-26139
Cumulative Award Amt.
$482,829.00
Proposal No.
2016-08131
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Feb 1, 2017
Project End Date
Jan 31, 2021
Grant Year
2017
Program Code
[A1531]- Biorefining and Biomanufacturing
Recipient Organization
SUSTAINABLE BIOPRODUCTS LLC
3132 HILLCREST DR
BOZEMAN,MT 597150689
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Acid-whey, a pollutant generated during the production of Greek yogurt, has become a significant environmental problem due to rapid increase in demand for yogurt, with U.S. alone producing more than 100 million tons annually. Current methods of disposing growing quantities of acid-whey are either inadequate or cost prohibitive, consequently, alternative methods are actively being sought. As human population increases and demand for higher-quality foods grows, the need to supply greater amounts of nutritional foods is rising. Current food-production, cannot sustain the increasing demand, thus, alternative high-protein food-sources are being investigated. Sustainable Bioproducts has developed a highly-efficient and cost-effective method for production of high-protein-biomass with an exceptional nutritional profile directly from acid-whey with little need of pre-processing. The novel methodology is based on surface fermentation under low pH conditions in combination with an extremophilic fungus (MK7). Preliminary Studies demonstrated that MK7 thrives on untreated, undiluted acid-whey. Additionally, MK7 consistently formed robust biomats when grown under these conditions. Our initial results showed that biomat growth on acid-whey can remove nearly all carbon from the liquid and rapidly neutralize pH.The proposal's objectives fall within Program-Area-Priority e. Agriculture Systems and Technology, 2. Bioprocessing and Bioengineering.We propose to:• Optimize acid-whey conversion into high protein biomass using our production-platform and use this biomass to determine optimal conditions for high-quality-food production.• Improve our products' value by testing methods for separating biomass into various components and analyze their properties for food/industrial applications.• Genetically engineer strains of MK7 for improved nutritional value of biomass grown on acid-whey
Animal Health Component
45%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
45%
Developmental
45%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
7014020101060%
4030210110240%
Goals / Objectives
The goal of this proposed research is to develop our process for the production of high-protein biomat and products suitable for human food, food supplements, animal feed, and as ingredients for subsequent food and feed preparation.Project Supporting ObjectivesObjective 1: Optimize the conversion of acid whey into high protein biomats using SB's production platform and determine nutritional composition of the produced biomats.Objective 2: Evaluate and improve methods for separating biomass into valuable nutritional components (protein, oils, flavorings, beta-glucan, etc.).Objective 3: Improve nutritional value of the produced biomass by developing genetically engineered strains of strain MK7 targeting high-value compounds desirable for food, food ingredients and food supplements.Objective 4: Techno-economic analysis of producing high-protein biomass and food components from acid whey using the SB platform.HypothesesHypothesis 1: The SB platform can be used to convert nearly all of the carbon in acid whey into valuable food and food ingredients.Hypothesis 2: Strain MK7 biomats produced from acid whey can be fractionated into valuable components, thus, adding value to the process.Hypothesis 3: The production of valuable food ingredients can be controlled by adjusting culture conditions and acid whey media composition.Hypothesis 4: Genetic engineering of strain MK7 can improve its nutritional properties, and thus, add value to the process.
Project Methods
Task 1: Process Optimization.Experiments to optimize acid whey conversion to biomats will initially focus on testing different sources of acid whey using SB bioreactor systems. Additional experiments will optimize pretreatment method, pH, macro and micronutrient nutrient composition, temperature, air flow rates and humidity.Subtask 1.1: Analysis of acid whey feedstocks, Months 0-2. Acid whey batches will be obtained from Dannon Greek yogurt manufacturing facilities located throughout the U.S. and the composition of macro and micro nutrients as well as carbohydrate, protein and lipid profiles will be thoroughly analyzed by Eurofins and by SB.Subtask 1.2: Biomass production as a function of acid whey source, pretreatment and pH, Months 0-8. Growth experiments using the suite of acid whey feedstocks obtained in Subtask 1.1 will be conducted with SB's production platform. Standard operating procedures developed for producing biomats from crude glycerol will be applied. Briefly, inoculum will be grown under submerged fermentation conditions in 10 L aerated reactors using a salts medium designed specifically for strain MK7. Cultures in the late exponential phase will be used as inoculum for acid whey experiments in tray reactors. Optimization parameters in this experimental matrix will include: i) volumes of inoculum, ii) acid whey will be used directly, or pretreated by autoclaving and iii) pH. Cultureswill be added to trays and allowed to incubate for 4-7 days. Conversion efficiencies and rates of biomat growth will be determined by measuring dry weights over time. Detailed compositional analysis of the produced biomats as well as the liquid remaining in the trays after harvesting the biomass will be performed at the SB laboratoryand by Center for Biorenewable Chemicals, Eurofins and IMPROVe.Subtask 1.3: Nutrients, Months 6-12. Nutrient optimization experiments will be conductedinclude for N, P, K, Ca, Mg, S and Fe.Subtask 1.4: pH, temperature, air flow and humidity, Months 12-18. Other process parameters (temperature, air flow, humidity) will be evaluated under optimized nutrient concentrations. Process parameters will be tested using SB's controlled environmental chamber specifically built to evaluate the effects of temperature, air flow, evaporation rate and humidity on biomat growth.Task 2: Fractionation of Biomass.Methods will be developed to (A) enhance separation into two general fractions concentrated in (1) nucleotides and carbohydrates and (2) proteins and beta-glucan, (B) increase concentration and separation of proteins, beta-glucans and nucleotides by additional fractionation steps.Subtask 2.1: Cell disruption. Months 0-3. Several techniques for cell wall lysis will be evaluated. This will include freezing biomass at different rates and temperatures (e.g. slow freeze at -20 °C versus -80 °C) and different thaw temperatures (e.g. 30-75 °C) and incubation times.Subtask 2.2: Separation of biomass into various fractions. Months 0-30. (Fig. 6; Steps 3-7). A variety of separation/fractionation methods will also be evaluated. Filtering or blending the biomass after initial freeze/thaw cycle will be evaluated. Initially, a simple liquid extract/cell wall pellet fraction will be obtained after either pressing biomass after heat step or after blending and settling, centrifuging or filtering using a course filter (0.25-0.5 mm). Various pressing techniques will be evaluated. Liquid extract will be dried at 50 °C or lyophilized for analysis.The solid pellet fractionwill be dried at 50 °C or lyophilized and subjected to a 2:1 chloroform/hot methanol extraction following the Folch method. The polar fraction, insoluble transition phase and non-polar fraction will be analyzed for nutritionally relevant components along with mass balance determination. The transition phase and original pellet will be subject to a number of other separation methods to determine how nutritional components fractionate including:other solvents such as hexane, acetone, ethanol, enzyme treatments, supercritical CO2.Amino acids,glycerol, organic acids, alcohols and sugars,anions, cations,nutritionally important minerals: Ca, Fe, Mg, K, P, lipids, fatty acids, total protein, nucleic acids and ashTask 2.4 Extensively analyze the properties of protein and beta-glucans for food and industrial applications. IMPROVE will be utilized for understanding protein qualities desired for food products (e.g. texture, rheology, solubility). Detailed tests include: ileal digestibility of protein (Boisen method), ileal digestibility of dry mater (Boisen method), SDS Pages profile (fluorescent), emulsifying properties, foaming capacity and foam stability, solubility curves at 6 different pH units, viscosity (flowing properties), gelling properties, water holding capacity, oil holding capacity, proteins mass assessment using MALLS and particle size distribution. Furthermore, confocal and SEM microscopy will be utilized to understand the physical and spatial properties of our protein concentrates.Task 3: Genetic modification of strain MK7.Subtask 3.1: Genetic Modification Methods and Metabolic Targets, Months 0-30. CRISPR/Cas9 system will be employed using single gRNA (guide RNA) expressing cassettes and the multiplex gRNA expression method patented by Dr. Yang. CRISPR/Cas9 technology in brief, uses the Cas9 endonuclease coupled with gRNA targets the DNA sequence of 5′-N20-NGG-3′ (N indicates any base), where N20 is identical to the gRNA 5′ sequence and NGG is the protospacer-adjacent motif (PAM). This gRNA along with the high occurrence of PAM in genomes allows gRNA Cas9 to edit nearly any genetic element. Single and multiple gRNA's cassettes on a single plasmid will be introduced into cells to promote, knock-out and or introduce (move) regulatory genes into target sites of the strain MK7 genome. A draft genome on 8,000 contigs currently exists for strain MK7 and SB is preparing to send genomic DNA to the National Center for Genome Resources in Santa Fe, NM for higher quality sequencing, assembly and annotation. Genetic modification efforts will focus on improving the nutritional value of the biomass. Initial targets include enhanced production of beta-carotene (vitamin A) and ergosterol (vitamin D2 precursor) already produced by strain MK7.Subtask 3.2: Enhancement of vitamin D2 levels by photochemical conversion of ergosterol, Months 9-12. Strain MK7 contains high levels of naturally occurring ergosterol (a precursor to vitamin D2). Current levels of ergosterol are between 1.25-2.50 mg/g dry weight.SB will utilize UV techniques to convert ergosterol from MK7 into either previtamin D2 or vitamin D2. MK7 will be subjected to varying UV light wavelengths for various time intervals. Both fresh mat tissue as well as process dried powder will be used and levels of ergosterol, vitamin D2, and pre-vitamin D2 will be quantified using established methods (both SB and Eurofins).Task 4. Techno-economic analysis, Months 18-36.The analysis will include utilization of strains genetically edited to enhance production of specific products. Study level techno-economic analyses will be performed using data obtained in Tasks 1-3, and will include feedstock costs (transportation, storage), costs of additional nutrients (N, P), fixed and variable costs associated with the biomass production facility and equipment (inoculum production, trays, racks, maintenance of environmental growth conditions, utilities, labor, operation and maintenance of harvesting equipment, separation equipment, etc.), cost of packaging and storage of the product, and value of the product. This level of economic estimate is anticipated to assess profit margins for the process at the ±100% range.The analyses will be conducted by SB's resident engineer in collaboration with Dr. Raj Raman, at Iowa State University, CBiRC.

Progress 02/01/17 to 01/31/21

Outputs
Target Audience: Acid-whey, a pollutant generated during the production of Greek yogurt, has become a significant environmental problem due to rapid increase in demand for yogurt, with U.S. alone producing more than 100 million tons annually. Current methods of disposing growing quantities of acid-whey are either inadequate or cost prohibitive, consequently, alternative methods are actively being sought. As human population increases and demand for higher-quality foods grows, the need to supply greater amounts of nutritional foods is rising. Current food-production, cannot sustain the increasing demand, thus, alternative high-protein food-sources are being investigated. Sustainable Bioproducts has developed a highly-efficient and cost-effective method for production of high-protein-biomass with an exceptional nutritional profile directly from acid-whey with little need of pre-processing. The novel methodology is based on surface fermentation under low pH conditions in combination with an extremophilic fungus (MK7). Preliminary Studies demonstrated that MK7 thrives on untreated, undiluted acid-whey. Additionally, MK7 consistently formed robust biomats when grown under these conditions. Our results alsoshowed that biomat growth on acid-whey can remove nearly all carbon from the liquid and rapidly neutralize pH. Stakeholders in this work include industry, the public and academia. Industry will be very interested in our technology to use waste feedstocks for creation of valuable products. The public has interest in this technology to decrease waste streams and produce protein with much less impact on the environment. Academia will be interested in techniques developed for protein extraction and genetic editing. Changes/Problems: We decided to use Auburn University as a contract lab for genetic editing work as our in-house genetic editing program was not succesful. Genetic editing at Auburn did not produce the results we expected as outlined in Objective 3.In addition to the 4 Objectives outlined in our grant proposal, we were also able to succesfully produce a number of prototype products from biomats made from acid whey including leather, food products and high-protein powders. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The key accomplishments for work conducted with this USDA AFRI grant funds: Optimized the growth conditions and reactor conditions for acid whey as a feedstock with our surface fermentation technology. Developed biomass extraction process for separation of biomass into protein and fiber-rich components. Increased levels of high-value metabolites Vitamin D and Carotenoids Application team successfully converted biomats produced from acid whey into a variety of food products. Raised Series A Venture funding with Danone as one of the partners with significant interest in strain MK7 technology and using acid whey as a feedstock Successfully created biomats with mushroom species mycelium and acid whey as the feedstock. Created techno-economic model for pilot and commercial plant using acid whey as a feedstock. Successfully produced a high-quality leather prototype with acid whey as feedstock meeting all technical requirements for handbags and wallets. Attempted developing a genetic editing platform for the strain. Although a successful method has not been fully developed, significant learnings have been accomplished to understanding the strains amenability to genetic editing. Objective 1:SB, has done considerable work with optimizing conversion of acid whey and has done detailed nutritional analyses on the biomats. The goals of this objective were met with many types of media/fermentation processes. Objective 2:SB,has done considerable work with separate biomass into high value components including protein, fiber, and lipids. In addition, we have developed a method to also produce high amount of vitamin D and carotenoids. We have also produced successful food products from acid whey biomats including yogurt and chicken nuggets. We are evaluating our strain for producing leather and pet treats from acid whey as well. Further work needs to be completed to characterize our protein concentrate/ isolate for functional attributes for food and other industries. Additionally, we were successful in producing a high protein >60% stream and high fiber stream from the biomass. Commercial products that may come out of this work with acid whey as feedstock include leather, functional proteins for the food industry, vitamin D, carotenoids and animal feed. Objective 3: This objective has been found to be very difficult with our strain as it is not as amenable to genetic editing as many other fungi. Work will continue for alternative strategies. We were not successful in genetically modifying the strain for over production of high-value compounds. Objective 4:A detailed techno-economic model has been built for producing biomass with our process at different production scales using data from our pilot plant system. Acid whey is a zero cost feedstock that can be used to make protein and fiber at a very attractive price and will be pursued further for leather and materials. Leather from acid whey has a distinct advantage over competitors from feedstock cost and also process advantages (much shorter production time of only 2-4 days) and quality advantages (our mats can incorporate bonding chemistry much more efficiently than competitors). A highly detailed 32 page finalreport has been written and will be e-mailed to our project manager. The report is too long to fit in this space.

Publications


    Progress 02/01/19 to 01/31/20

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Acid-whey, a pollutant generated during the production of Greek yogurt, has become a significant environmental problem due to rapid increase in demand for yogurt, with U.S. alone producing more than 100 million tons annually. Current methods of disposing growing quantities of acid-whey are either inadequate or cost prohibitive, consequently, alternative methods are actively being sought. As human population increases and demand for higher-quality foods grows, the need to supply greater amounts of nutritional foods is rising. Current food-production, cannot sustain the increasing demand, thus, alternative high-protein food-sources are being investigated. Sustainable Bioproducts has developed a highly-efficient and cost-effective method for production of high-protein-biomass with an exceptional nutritional profile directly from acid-whey with little need of pre-processing. The novel methodology is based on surface fermentation under low pH conditions in combination with an extremophilic fungus (MK7). Preliminary Studies demonstrated that MK7 thrives on untreated, undiluted acid-whey. Additionally, MK7 consistently formed robust biomats when grown under these conditions. Our results also showed that biomat growth on acid-whey can remove nearly all carbon from the liquid and rapidly neutralize pH. Stakeholders in this work include industry, the public and academia. Industry will be very interested in our technology to use waste feedstocks for creation of valuable products. The public has interest in this technology to decrease waste streams and produce protein with much less impact on the environment. Academia will be interested in techniques developed for protein extraction and genetic editing. Changes/Problems:We have decided to use Auburn University as a contract lab for genetic editing work as our in-house genetic editing program was not succesful. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We are going to finish tasks pertaining to extraction of protein from our biomass using a recently developed set of protocols. In addition, we are going to contiinue to cultivate mushrooms and strain MK7 with acid whey using a new bioreactor system in order to produce biomats for protein work, techno--economic analyses, pet treat product development, and conversion into leather alternatives.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Application team successfully converted biomats produced from acid whey into a variety of food products. Yogurt Strain MK7 biomats were used directly to produce yogurt. The biomats were grown in trays on an acid whey feedstock/carbon source that was generated as a by-product of Greek yogurt manufacture, harvested after 6 days and were steamed within 20 minutes of harvesting.200 g of the cooled, moist biomass was blended together with 600 g of drinking quality tap water to produce a milk-like suspension referred to as "MK7 liquid dispersion." The MK7 liquid dispersion was used as an ingredient by itself or in combination with cow's milk to produce yogurt. Three mixtures containing different ratios of MK7 liquid dispersion to whole milk were prepared: 1) 25% MK7 liquid dispersion:75% whole milk, 2) 50% MK7 liquid dispersion:50% whole milk, and 3) 100% MK7 liquid dispersion. The mixtures were used to make three batches of yogurt by heating each mixture to 83oC and holding at that temperature for 14 minutes with constant stirring. The mixtures were allowed to cool to 43oC and then live yogurt cultures added as inoculum. The resulting mixture was incubated at 44oC in a yogurt maker (Model YM80; EuroCuisine, Los Angeles, CA) for 8 hours. All of the resultant mixtures had the appearance and texture of yogurt (Figure 10), as well as a smell and taste similar to typical yogurt. Chicken nugget Chicken flavored strain MK7 is a basic ingredient to a number of recipes including chicken nuggets, with or without breading, chicken for Asian dishes, or other chicken dishes as a chicken replacement.Strain MK7 biomats produced from different feedstocks/carbon sources result in slightly different chicken flavors.The glycerol chicken is sweeter and the acid whey chicken tends to be a little bit sourer. The amount of food processing and the blade used (i.e. sharp metal blade, dull metal blade, plastic blade) result in different chicken nugget textures.Further, acceptable chicken nuggets can be produced from a wide variety of biomass sizes.That is, biomass can be cut with a knife, lightly food processed or highly food processed and still result in acceptable chicken analogs. A 50 - 20:1:1 ratio ofstrain MK7:chicken stock:binder was used with or without approximately a 66.6% strain MK7:fat ratio. Suitable fats include duck fat, coconut butter, and cocoa butter.After mixing, the mixture is steamed for approximately 30 minutes to set the binder; however, some binders may require more or less time. Additional breading can then be added and the resulting nuggets process as typical for such foodstuffs. Figure 10. Products produced with strain MK7 biomats Successfully created biomats with mushroom species mycelium and acid whey as the feedstock. Acid whey was used as a substrate for cultivation of pearl oyster mats (Figure 11). The acid whey medium was mixed with 10 g/L malt extract and 1 g/L oats. Attempts with 100% acid whey were not successful with pearl oyster mushrooms. However, we would like to evaluate a number of additional species over the next year (2020) with the no cost extension. Figure 11. Initial trials of pearl oyster mushroom mycelial mats with acid whey/malt medium as substrate Created techno-economic model for pilot and commercial plant using acid whey as a feedstock. SB is currently building a 30 tonne biomass/year phase I pilot plant to be followed by a 700 tonne/year phase II plant and eventually production plants capable of producing 20,000 tonnes of strain MK7/year. Highly detailed economic models have been built on biomat production costs with CapEx and Opex assumptions and raw media costs. As part of the USDA AFRI grant, we have incorporated acid whey into the model (see model screenshots below). Currently evaluating acid whey biomats for production of a vegan leather product Updates to this project will be with our final report. Currently evaluating acid whey biomats for production of a pet food/treat products. Updates to this project will be with our final report.

    Publications


      Progress 02/01/18 to 01/31/19

      Outputs
      Target Audience: Acid-whey, a pollutant generated during the production of Greek yogurt, has become a significant environmental problem due to rapid increase in demand for yogurt, with U.S. alone producing more than 100 million tons annually. Current methods of disposing growing quantities of acid-whey are either inadequate or cost prohibitive, consequently, alternative methods are actively being sought. As human population increases and demand for higher-quality foods grows, the need to supply greater amounts of nutritional foods is rising. Current food-production, cannot sustain the increasing demand, thus, alternative high-protein food-sources are being investigated. Sustainable Bioproducts has developed a highly-efficient and cost-effective method for production of high-protein-biomass with an exceptional nutritional profile directly from acid-whey with little need of pre-processing. The novel methodology is based on surface fermentation under low pH conditions in combination with an extremophilic fungus (MK7). Preliminary Studies demonstrated that MK7 thrives on untreated, undiluted acid-whey. Additionally, MK7 consistently formed robust biomats when grown under these conditions. Our results also showed that biomat growth on acid-whey can remove nearly all carbon from the liquid and rapidly neutralize pH. Stakeholders in this work include industry, the public and academia. Industry will be very interested in our technology to use waste feedstocks for creation of valuable products. The public has interest in this technology to decrease waste streams and produce protein with much less impact on the environment. Academia will be interested in techniques developed for protein extraction and genetic editing. Changes/Problems: Genetic editing with this novel strain has proven to be much more difficult then anticipated and more difficult than model strains of fungi. We are engaging Auburn University to help with the process. Furthermore, analyses of our fiber content has been more difficult than anticipated and detailed analyses will take work outside of the scope of this grant. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Efforts will continue to develop a genetic editing platform and will utilize a new protocol for protein extraction currently being developed by SB with biomass produced with acid whey feedstock. Furthermore, proof of concept studies will be done to produce leather and pet products/treats with biomats made from acid whey.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? The key accomplishments by 12/31/2019for USDA AFRI Work includes: Optimized the growth conditions and reactor conditions for acid whey as a feedstock with our surface fermentation technology. Developed biomass extraction process for separation of biomass into protein and fiber-rich components. Increased levels of high-value metabolites Vitamin D and Carotenoids Application team successfully converted biomats produced from acid whey into a variety of food products. Raised Series A Venture funding with Danone as one of the partners with significant interest in strain MK7 technology and using acid whey as a feedstock Successfully created biomats with mushroom species mycelium and acid whey as the feedstock. Created techno-economic model for pilot and commercial plant using acid whey as a feedstock. Currently evaluating acid whey biomats for production of a vegan leather product. Currently evaluating acid whey biomats for production of a pet food/treat products. Attempted developing a genetic editing platform for the strain. Although a successful method has not been fully developed, significant learnings have been accomplished to understanding the strains amenability to genetic editing.

      Publications


        Progress 02/01/17 to 01/31/18

        Outputs
        Target Audience:Acid-whey, a pollutant generated during the production of Greek yogurt, has become a significant environmental problem due to rapid increase in demand for yogurt, with U.S. alone producing more than 100 million tons annually. Current methods of disposing growing quantities of acid-whey are either inadequate or cost prohibitive, consequently, alternative methods are actively being sought. As human population increases and demand for higher-quality foods grows, the need to supply greater amounts of nutritional foods is rising. Current food-production, cannot sustain the increasing demand, thus, alternative high-protein food-sources are being investigated. Sustainable Bioproducts has developed a highly-efficient and cost-effective method for production of high-protein-biomass with an exceptional nutritional profile directly from acid-whey with little need of pre-processing. The novel methodology is based on surface fermentation under low pH conditions in combination with an extremophilic fungus (MK7). Preliminary Studies demonstrated that MK7 thrives on untreated, undiluted acid-whey. Additionally, MK7 consistently formed robust biomats when grown under these conditions. Our results also showed that biomat growth on acid-whey can remove nearly all carbon from the liquid and rapidly neutralize pH. Stakeholders in this work include industry, the public and academia. Industry will be very interested in our technology to use waste feedstocks for creation of valuable products. The public has interest in this technology to decrease waste streams and produce protein with much less impact on the environment. Academia will be interested in techniques developed for protein extraction and genetic editing. Changes/Problems:Genetic editing with this novel strain has proven to be much more difficult then anticipated and more difficult than model strains of fungi. We are engaging Auburn University to help with the process. Furthermore, analyses of our fiber content has been more difficult than anticipated and detailed analyses will take work outside of the scope of this grant. This is not uncommon for fungi and detailed analyses of the fiber will be outside the scope of this grant. See: https://fungi.com/blogs/articles/beta-glucans-and-the-seven-pillars-of-immunity "Over the years, Fungi Perfecti LLC has spent thousands of dollars on product testing for beta-glucan content at various laboratories. The reported beta-glucan values from several independent laboratories vary greatly even though identical assays were performed. The most commonly employed assays for determination of beta-glucan content can only detect soluble beta-glucans; the insoluble beta-glucans remain undetected. Beta-glucans differ in their solubilities depending on their size, functionality, and interaction with other molecules. In agreement with other organic chemists specializing in beta-glucan analysis, we have concluded that the currently employed methods are unreliable! Deciding to place a percentage on our labels gives us sufficient pause, as we know each methodology and each laboratory would yield a different result. There is no standard, accepted,validated methodology in the industry. This fact makes us reluctant to make any such claims on our product labels, and makes any purported beta glucan levels listed for any mushroom product dubious." " What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Technicians and staff have been exposed to new techniques working on this project including wet chemistry protocols, data review/interpretation, bioreactor design and analytical instrumentation. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Efforts will continue to develop a genetic editing platform and will utilize a new protocol for protein extraction currently being developed by SB with biomass produced with acid whey feedstock. Furthermore, proof of concept studies will be done to produce leather and pet products/treats with biomats made from acid whey.

        Impacts
        What was accomplished under these goals? "please note: a 19 page ful report is available with details on progress and technical descriptions of work done and is available upon request." Production Of High-Quality Protein, Lipids And Beta-Glucans From Acid Whey Waste Streams Summary The key accomplishments by to date for USDA AFRI Work includes: Optimized the growth conditions and reactor conditions for acid whey as a feedstock with our surface fermentation technology. Developed biomass extraction process for separation of biomass into protein and fiber-rich components. Increased levels of high-value metabolites Vitamin D and Carotenoids Application team successfully converted biomats produced from acid whey into a variety of food products. Raised Series A Venture funding with Danone as one of the partners with significant interest in strain MK7 technology and using acid whey as a feedstock Successfully created biomats with mushroom species mycelium and acid whey as the feedstock. Created techno-economic model for pilot and commercial plant using acid whey as a feedstock. Currently evaluating acid whey biomats for production of a vegan leather product. Currently evaluating acid whey biomats for production of a pet food/treat products. Attempted developing a genetic editing platform for the strain. Although a successful method has not been fully developed, significant learnings have been accomplished to understanding the strains amenability to genetic editing. Project Goal The goal of this proposed research is to develop our process for the production of high-protein biomat and products suitable for human food, food supplements, animal feed, and as ingredients for subsequent food and feed preparation. Furthermore, SB intends to improve our products' value by testing methods for separating biomass into various components and analyze their properties for food/industrial applications Project Supporting Objectives Objective 1:Optimize the conversion of acid whey into high protein biomats using SB's production platform and determine nutritional composition of the produced biomats. SB, as outlined below has done considerable work with optimizing conversion of acid whey and has done detailed nutritional analyses on the biomats.Acid whey biomats were most efficiently produced under tried conditions with either the addition of 2.5% starch, 2.5% CSL and 3.75% glycerol or using ½ strength MK7-1 glycerol medium (5% glycerol with urea, NH4NO3, KH2PO4, trace minerals, MgSO4, CaCl) and ridged trays. Additional work with acid whey will include further optimization and product testing in new pilot and commercial bioreactors. Furthermore, alternative inoculum strategies being developed will be tested with acid whey. Objective 2: Evaluate and improve methods for separating biomass into valuable nutritional components (protein, oils, flavorings, beta-glucan, etc.). SB, as outlined below has done considerable work with separate biomass into high value components including protein, fiber, and lipids. In addition, we have developed a method to also produce high amount of vitamin D and carotenoids (section III). The extraction resulted in high protein fractions when pooled together resulted in fraction with 72 grams protein/100 grams of dried pooled fractions. A high fiber fraction was also obtained with estimated > 90% beta glucans. We are using the University of Georgia Polysacharide lab to determine fractions but this has been found to be very difficult because of the insoluble phase of the fiber. This is not uncommon for fungi and detailed analyses of the fiber will be outside the scope of this grant. We have also produced successful food products from acid whey biomats including yogurt and chicken nuggets. We are evaluating our strain for producing leather and pet treats from acid whey as well (sections VIII and IX). Further work needs to be completed to have a protein concentrate or isolate that is high molecular weight and functional. Further work with no cost extension during 2020 will be to employ new methods developed by SB for protein extraction, isolation and characterizations with acid whey biomats. The goal is to obtain a high molecular weight protein fraction from acid weight biomats at over 80% protein by dry weight. This would be a very valuable product for food, animal feed and fish feed. Current procedures with glycerol mats are showing excellent functional protein extraction and we will need time to test with acid whey mats. Objective 3:Improve nutritional value of the produced biomass by developing genetically engineered strains of strain MK7 targeting high-value compounds desirable for food, food ingredients and food supplements. This objective has been found to be very difficult with our strain as it is not as amenable to genetic editing as many other fungi. Work will continue for alternative strategies.A great deal of work has been done to develop a platform for genetic editing of strain MK7 using Crispr-Cas9 methods. Much work still needs to be completed to develop this platform. More details with the final report. Objective 4:Techno-economic analysis of producing high-protein biomass and food components from acid whey using the SB platform. A detailed techno-economic model has been built for producing biomass with our process at different production scales using data from our pilot plant system (section VII).SB is currently building a 30 tonne biomass/year phase I pilot plant to be followed by a 700 tonne/year phase II plant and eventually production plants capable of producing 20,000 tonnes of strain MK7/year. Highly detailed economic models have been built on biomat production costs with CapEx and Opex assumptions and raw media costs. As part of the USDA AFRI grant, we have incorporated acid whey into the model (see model screenshots below). Commercialization update:SBP has successfully secured $33 million in series A venture capital funding (May 2018). The lead investor is 1955 Capital with additional investors: Breakthrough Energy, Gary Lauder, Danone Inc., and Archer Daniels Midland. The funds will be used for further process R&D, food product development, pilot plant construction, general administrative, product marketing and obtaining regulatory approval to sell the product to consumers (GRAS - FDA generally regarded as safe). Furthermore, SBP will use the pilot plant to produce product, verify techno-economics, implement and test process/equipment changes, validate standard operating procedures, determine process flow and mass balance for use in production plants.

        Publications