Source: CORNELL UNIVERSITY submitted to
PLANT BASED GREEN SEED COATINGS AND ORGANIC SEED TREATMENTS FOR INSECT MANAGEMENT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1007492
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Nov 18, 2015
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2018
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
CORNELL UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
ITHACA,NY 14853
Performing Department
Fiber Science & Apparel Design
Non Technical Summary
Environmental stresses often occur after planting, and can have a major deleterious impact on stand establishment. Greater extremes in weather patterns during the planting period may be attributed to climate change. Poor germination is a major problem for organically grown crops such as sweet corn, and cucurbits that are major vegetable crops in the NY State and USA. Biostimulants is a category of compounds that can enhance germination and seedling growth and thus partially overcome the deleterious effect of stress on stand establishment. In addition, organic seed treatments can be applied with the seed coating formulation for efficient early season pest management.Laboratory, greenhouse and field studies will be conducted on the development of 'green' seed coatings and treatments. Seed coating materials composed of plant proteins act as biostimulants to enhance early seedling growth and other hydrophilic compounds added to the coating formulation will benefit germination under drought conditions that may occur after sowing. Seed treatments formulations extracted from neem seeds can provide control of early season insects. The ultimate goal is to develop organic seed coatings and treatments to enhance stand establishment and provide reliable early season pest management.
Animal Health Component
60%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
60%
Developmental
30%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5115340106045%
2051499113045%
2111820200010%
Goals / Objectives
Our overarching goals are to develop 'green' plant based materials that are compatible and beneficial to seeds. These materials will have tunable properties and will be developed as seed coatings with desired characteristics. These coatings will also act as delivery systems for organic seed treatments. Specific objectives are to: 1) Develop seed coat filler blends containing plant proteins, hydrophilic materials and high-density materials. 2) Develop seed treatment insecticide formulations of neem and other organic based seed treatment insecticides to be applied with the seed coatings materials. 3) Conduct lab and greenhouse studies of the 'green' coatings and investigate performance under environmental stress in sub-optimal conditions including drought, and cold temperatures. 4) Apply the neem seed treatments with the developed 'green' seed coating and conduct field trials against seed maggot as the target pest.
Project Methods
'Green' seed coatings with desired characteristics will be made by blending plant proteins from selected plant species as biostimulants, starch, guar gum and other compounds as hydrophilic materials to absorb and hold water sowing and high density materials including egg shells and finely ground minerals to increase the coating weight to facilitate sowing. Desired resin properties will be achieved through changing ingredients and their loadings. The resins will be characterized for their mechanical and moisture-holding properties.There is a critical need for organic growers to have a seed treatment insecticide for control of insect pests that attack germinating seeds or seedlings. Neem (Azadiracta indica), is one of the most promising known botanical insect control agents. Neem-based formulations will be applied with the seed coating materials for application to sweet corn seeds. Other new organic seed treatments will be examined during the course of the project.Laboratory and greenhouse studies will be conducted on the 'green' seed coatings to assess their effect on germination characteristics, seedling emergence, growth and development. We propose to evaluate the effects of climate change on seed germination characteristics. Sub-optimal conditions will be investigated including drought, and cold temperatures. Effect of selected hydrophilic materials will be evaluated in those conditions. Leaf chlorophyll content also will be measured to study the benefit of the protein-based coating with a non-destructive SPAD chlorophyll meter. Nitrogen content of plants from coated seeds will be determined and related to nitrogen applied as a seed treatment.Seed treatment efficacy of the neem treatments will be tested against seed corn maggot (SCM) (Delia platura) in field trials. Sweet corn seed treatments with neem formulations will be compared with nontreated seeds in early spring plantings. Immediately after seeds are planted, a combination of bone and meat meal will be placed in a narrow band over the row to further attract SCM females. Stand counts will be taken; however, seedlings not killed by SCM can look normal after emergence, and below-ground portions of the seed and stem may be infested with maggots. Seedlings will be excavated and inspected for SCM.Research efforts - deliver science-based knowledge to growers in cooperation with faculty with extension responsibilities and other extension educators that work on organic vegetable cropping systems.Evaluation: Year 1 - Develop protein based seed coatings derived from selected crop seeds. The protein serves as a biostimulant to increase plant growth. Greenhouse studies will be conducted on measuring the enhancement of plant growth and development followed by statistical analysis of data. Conduct preliminary studies on developing organic seed treatments.Year 2 - Develop organic insecticide seed treatments that are derived from the seeds of neem tree. Conduct field tests for control of seed corn maggot as an early season pest followed by statistical analysis of data. Conduct research on the addition of other additives in the seed coating to enhance germination under drought conditions and improve plant-ability of coated seed.Year 3 - Combine optimal organic seed coating compositions with organic seed treatments as developed in years 1 and 2. Data will be analyzed as previously described.

Progress 11/18/15 to 09/30/18

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audiences are companies that apply seed treatments and coatings to seeds, including biostimulants and organic seed treatments, and the larger US seed industry. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Cornell's Green Materials lab and Seed Science and Technology lab at Cornell AgriTech provides professionals and others with a unique experience that is not available in another US academic institute. The Post-Doc working on this project attended national conferences each year of the three-year project and presented posters on her work investigating biostimulant seed coating formulations. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results have been disseminated in several posters presented at US agricultural and seed conferences, refereed journal article, and presentations made to the seed treatment industry. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Biostimulants, applied as seed treatments, have the potential to increase the seedling vigor, and quality of many crops. In early stages of this three-year project, a 10% suspension of soy flour was used as the seed treatment binder in all coatings. The solid particulate filler was composed of mixtures of soy flour, cellulose, and diatomaceous earth, together termed as SCD. All SCD components were homogenized in water, then dried and ground to a fine particle size <106 mm. The SCD coatings were applied with rotary pan seed coating equipment at 25% of the seed weight. Increasing the proportion of soy flour increased the seed coating strength and also the time for the coating to disintegrate after soaking in water. As a result, the seed coatings reduced the percentage germination and the germination rate compared with the nontreated control. However, the 10-day-old seedling root and shoot growth showed significant improvement for all SCD coating treatments compared with controls. Plant growth and development was also measured after 30 days in the greenhouse. Fresh weight (FW) and dry weight (DW), leaf area, plant height, leaf development, Soil-Plant Analyses Development (SPAD) index (chlorophyll measurement), and nitrogen (N) per plant were all greater from coatings with 30%, 40%, and 50% soy flour than the noncoated control. Nitrogen, from the soy flour applied in the seed coatings, ranged from 0.024 to 0.073 mg per seed, while the enhanced N per plant ranged from1.7 to 8.5 mg. The coating treatment with 0.063 mg N per seed resulted in the greatest plant leaf area and highest N content. Nitrogen applied in the seed coating only accounted for 1% to 2% of the enhanced N in the plants, indicating the soy flour acted as a biostimulant rather than a fertilizer. Soy flour suspension in water can only be stored for several days before microbial growth and spoilage so was not suited for broad-scale use. Several sources of soy flour were tested and soy flour 7B from ADM, Decatur, IL had the best performance. A new seed coating blend was developed in which the dry soy flour was mixed with diatomaceous earth. The optimal proportion of soy flour to diatomaceous earth was 30:70 on a weight basis. The effect of seed treatments of a plant-based protein on growth promotion of five different crops were investigated. Seeds of radish, broccoli, tomato, hemp and cucumber were coated with mixtures of soy flour (SF), used as a solid binder, and diatomaceous earth (DE) was used as the filler to produce a dry coating blend. A laboratory-scale rotary pan coater was used to coat seeds. Seeds were placed in a germinator at 20/30° C with an 8-hour photoperiod, and germination was recorded daily. Seedling growth data were collected 6 days after emergence for radish, hemp and cucumber and 10 days after emergence for broccoli and two varieties of tomato. Dry weight, shoot and root length were measured and seed vigor index (SVI) was calculated to assess plant growth enhancement. Treated seeds had either no or a slight reduction in germination percentage compared with the non-treated control seeds; however, germination uniformity and germination rate were not significantly different than non-treated control seeds. Overall the SF + DE coating blend enhanced plant growth compared to controls for all crops evaluated. However, the magnitude of plant growth enhancement was crop specific. These data indicate that application of a plant based biostimulant via seed treatment was an environmentally friendly management approach to improve seedling vigor and seedling uniformity for sustainable crop production. Early stage research was conducted on selected organically approved insecticide seed treatments. Two commercial, organically approved seed treatment insecticides were applied to snap bean and sweet corn and studied in field trials to control seed maggot. Neither commercial material was efficacious against this insect pest and results were comparable to the nontreated check. In contrast, good control of seed maggot was achieved with thiamethoxam, the labeled, chemical seed treatment for snap bean and sweet corn. Neem extracts can perform the dual function of fertilizer and pesticide. Azadirachtin, the active ingredient of neem products is responsible for stopping the growth cycle of insects and pests, fungi etc. Neem extract also acts as an insect repellent and insect feeding inhibitor, thereby protecting the plants. In this study, experiments were performed in a germinator, greenhouse and field to examine the benefits of using neem products for organic farming and sustainable agriculture. The pest target in this case was seed corn maggot (Delia platura). Neemazal (>40% active ingredient Azadirachtin) was the neem technical product and applied as a film coat to snap bean seeds with four dosage rates (0.025, 0.05, 0.1 and 0.2g/100g seeds) compared to the conventional seed treatment insecticide thiamethoxam (Cruiser 5FS). Results from the field trial showed that percentage damaged seedlings using the conventional insecticide were significantly less than nontreated control and neem treatments. However, the lowest dosage of neemazal (0.025g/100g seeds) performed slightly better than nontreated control seeds. Results from the germinator, greenhouse and field showed that using neemazal with high dosage (especially 0.1 and 0.2g/100g seeds) were phytotoxic to seeds and seedlings, resulting in abnormal seedlings. Another possible limitation is the persistence of neem in the environment resulting in reduced efficacy compare to the chemical insecticides in the field trial.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Amirkhani, M., Mayton, H. S., Loos, M. T., Netravali, A. N., Taylor, A. G. 2018. Biostimulant effect of a plant-based protein applied as a seed coating on selected crops. 3rd annual Cornell AgriTech Research Symposium, June 29, 2018. Page 4. Cornell AgriTech Campus, Geneva, NY.


Progress 10/01/16 to 09/30/17

Outputs
Target Audience:Peer agricultural scientists that work on organic crop production systems, seed companies that sell organic seeds, companies that specialize and sell organically approved materials for pest control as well as farmers who buy seeds. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Cornell's Seed Science and Technology lab and Green Materials lab provides professionals and others with a unique experience that is not available in another US academic institutes. During this three-year project, a Post Doc has been working on this project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?A research paper based on the results of our study was presented at the NYSAES Research Symposium, Geneva, New York, USA. Another paper is being currently written for journal submission. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The composition of the seed coating may provide nutrients or serve as biostimulants to enhance early seedling growth and development. This research presents a novel method of using plant-derived protein hydrolysates as organic seed coating materials. To develop seed coating formulations we are using soy flour (a sustainable, inexpensive, and green source, as a biostimulant) and neem cake (the material left after oil extraction from neem seeds and it acts as a bio-fertilizer and helps in providing the required nutrients to plants). Protein hydrolysates could enhance nutrient availability in plant growth substrates, and increase nutrient uptake and nutrient-use efficiency in plants. Application of protein hydrolysates can also ameliorate the negative effects of abiotic plant stress for example salinity, which is one of our objectives for 2018. In this research the focus will be on vegetable crops such as broccoli, tomato, and radish. Develop seed treatment insecticide formulations of neem products with lower concentration of Azadirachtin active ingredient as a seed treatment to minimize phytotoxicity in plants and improve stand establishment in the field. Adding a layer of filler materials or polymers to the film coated seeds with neem application to delay degradation of Azadirachtin by high temperatures and other environmental exposure. Explore alternate organic compounds with activity against insect pests that may be applied as a seed treatment.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Plant-derived protein hydrolysates have excellent potential to be used as plant biostimulants due to their ability to increase the germination, productivity and quality of horticultural and agronomic crops. The objectives of this project were to determine the effect of plant based biostimulants in the form of proteins and fibers on total germination percentage, germination rate and uniformity, seedling growth, fresh and dry weight, leaf area, and chlorophyll content. We have developed seed coating formulations using soy flour, a sustainable, inexpensive, and green source that is available in plenty, as a biostimulant using broccoli and tomato as the model seeds. In all coatings water was used to hydrate the coating formulation. The solid particulate filler was composed of mixtures of finely ground soy flour (provided by ADM, Decatur, IL) and diatomaceous earth, together termed as SD. All SD components were mixed in a tumbler for making uniform filler. The SD coatings were applied with rotary pan seed coating equipment and applied at 30% of the seed weight. Increasing the proportion of soy flour increased the seed coating strength and also the time for the coating to disintegrate after soaking in water. As a result, the seed coatings reduced slightly the percentage germination compared with the nontreated control; however germination uniformity and rate were not different than the noncoated control. Moreover, the 10 days old seedling shoot growth showed significant improvement for all SD coating treatments compared to controls in both crops. Seedling growth uniformity and seed vigor index were greater for both coatings with 30 and 40% soy flour than the noncoated control for both crops. The coating treatment with plant-based proteins resulted in the greatest biomass compared to the control. Proteins applied in the seed coating can improve vegetable crop growth and uniformity. Neem seed and leaf extracts can perform the dual function of fertilizer and pesticide. At the same time they are also bio-degradable and degrade into an eco-friendly soil conditioner. Azadirachtin, the active ingredient of neem products is responsible for stopping the growth cycle of insects and pests, fungi etc. Neem extract also acts as an insect repellent and insect feeding inhibitor, thereby protecting the plants. In this study, experiments were performed in a germinator, greenhouse and field to examine the benefits of using neem products for organic farming and sustainable agriculture. The pest target in this case was seed corn maggot (Delia platura). Neemazal (>40% active ingredient Azadirachtin) was the neem technical product provided by Parry America Inc. to Dr. Taylor's Lab, and applied as a film coat to snapbean (Phaseolus vulgaris L, cv Huntington) seeds with four dosage rates (0.025, 0.05, 0.1 and 0.2g/100g seeds) compared to the conventional seed treatment insecticide thiamethoxam (Cruiser 5FS). Results from the field trial showed that percentage damaged seedlings using the conventional insecticide were significantly less than nontreated control and neem treatments. However, the lowest dosage of neemazal (0.025g/100g seeds) performed slightly better than nontreated control seeds. Results from the germinator, greenhouse and field showed that using neemazal with high dosage (especially 0.1 and 0.2g/100g seeds) were phytotoxic to seeds and seedlings, resulting in abnormal seedlings. Another possible limitation is the persistence of neem in the environment resulting in reduced efficacy compare to the chemical insecticides in the field trial.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Amirkhani, M., A. N. Netravali, A. G. Taylor. 2017. Improving Seedling Growth Uniformity and Seed Vigor Index by Using Plant-based Protein Seed Coating in Tomato and Broccoli. NYSAES Research Symposium, Geneva, New York, USA, p. 6.


Progress 11/18/15 to 09/30/16

Outputs
Target Audience:Peer agricultural scientists that work on organic crop production systems, seed companies that sell organic seeds, companies that specialize and sell organically approved materials for pest control as well as farmers who buy seeds. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Cornell's Seed Science and Technology lab and Green Materials lab provides professionals and others with a unique experience that is not available in another US academic institutes. During this three-year project, a Post Doc is working on this project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Refereed journal article was published and a poster paper presented at a seed industry conference. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Continue the development and evaluation of soy flour based coatings that act as biostimulants. Expand research on testing neem as an organic insecticide seed treatment and explore others organic compounds with insecticidal properties.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The specific objectives of this project were to determine the effect of plant based biostimulants in the form of proteins and fibers on total germination percentage, germination rate and uniformity, seedling growth, fresh and dry weight, leaf area, and chlorophyll content. This research presents a novel method of using plant-derived protein hydrolysates as seed coating materials. The objective of this study was to develop seed coating formulations using soy flour, a sustainable, inexpensive, and green source, as a biostimulant using broccoli as the model system. A 10% suspension of soy flour was used as the seed treatment binder in all coatings. The solid particulate filler was composed of mixtures of soy flour, cellulose, and diatomaceous earth, together termed as SCD. All SCD components were homogenized in water, then dried and ground to a fine particle size <106 mm. The SCD coatings were applied with rotary pan seed coating equipment at 25% of the seed weight. Increasing the proportion of soy flour increased the seed coating strength and also the time for the coating to disintegrate after soaking in water. As a result, the seed coatings reduced the percentage germination and the germination rate compared with the nontreated control. However, the 10-day-old seedling root and shoot growth showed significant improvement for all SCD coating treatments compared with controls. Plant growth and development was also measured after 30 days in the greenhouse. Fresh weight (FW) and dry weight (DW), leaf area, plant height, leaf development, Soil-Plant Analyses Development (SPAD) index (chlorophyll measurement), and nitrogen (N) per plant were all greater from coatings with 30%, 40%, and 50% soy flour than the noncoated control. Nitrogen, from the soy flour applied in the seed coatings, ranged from0.024 to 0.073 mg per seed, while the enhanced N per plant ranged from1.7 to 8.5 mg. The coating treatment with 0.063mg N per seed resulted in the greatest plant leaf area and highest N content. Nitrogen applied in the seed coating only accounted for 1%to 2% of the enhanced N in the plants, indicating the soy flour acted as a biostimulant rather than a fertilizer. Preliminary research was conducted on selected organically approved insecticide seed treatments. Two commercial materials were applied to snap bean and sweet corn and studied in field trials to control seed maggot. Neither commercial material was efficacious against this insect pest and results were comparable to the nontreated check. In contrast, good control of seed maggot was achieved with thiamethoxam, the labeled, chemical seed treatment for snap bean and sweet corn. Cornell's Seed Science and Technology lab provides professionals and others with a unique experience that is not available in another US academic institute. During this three-year project, a Post Doc is working on this project.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Masoume Amirkhani, Anil N. Netravali, Wencheng Huang, Alan G. Taylor (2016) Investigation of Soy Protein Based Biostimulant Seed Coating for Broccoli Seedling and Plant Growth Enhancement. HortScience 51(9):11211126. 2016. DOI: 10.21273/HORTSCI10913-16.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Masoume Amirkhani, Anil N. Netravali, Alan G. Taylor. 2016. Using Sustainable Plant Based Biostimulant Resins and Fibers for Seed Coating. Crops and Chemicals USA, Raleigh, NC.