Source: KENTUCKY STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
APPLICATION OF CROSSBREEDING AND GENETIC SEX REGULATION FOR DEVELOPMENT OF FAST-GROWING ALL-MALE TILAPIA CROSS FOR AQUACULTURE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1007438
Grant No.
2015-38821-24389
Cumulative Award Amt.
$299,712.00
Proposal No.
2015-05357
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2015
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2019
Grant Year
2015
Program Code
[EQ]- Research Project
Recipient Organization
KENTUCKY STATE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
FRANKFORT,KY 40601
Performing Department
College of Agriculture
Non Technical Summary
Over ninety percent of the seafood consumed in the United States is imported. Disproportionate dependence on imports can compromise food security. In order to increase domestic production and compete with foreign fish producers, US farmers should diversify by raising economically profitable alternative aquaculture species. One promising aquaculture species for Kentucky and US aquaculture is tilapia. Most of the tilapia sold in the United States are imported; however, domestic production of tilapia is expanding. It is an ideal species for culture in water conserving recirculating aquaculture systems. Tilapia raised domestically can be sold live or whole fresh and this can demand high prices in some local ethnic (Asian and Hispanic) markets in the U.S. In order to compete with imports, domestically raised tilapia need genetic improvement. This project suggests development of all-male, high-quality, fast-growing tilapia cross by applying several genetic methods including crossbreeding, genetic sex regulation, application of advanced DNA markers and color variability analysis. The developed tilapia cross will be raised in recirculation systems by fish growers in Kentucky and other states. This will allow US fish producers to increase their yield, profits and the marketability of their fish. High yields and profitability of tilapia raised in recirculating aquaculture systems will attract more US producers, increase volume and value of domestic production and thereby increase food security. Development of advanced DNA microarray technology for screening molecular genetic markers will significantly increase the capacity of the recently established Aquaculture Genetics Lab at Kentucky State University.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
30337141080100%
Knowledge Area
303 - Genetic Improvement of Animals;

Subject Of Investigation
3714 - Tilapia;

Field Of Science
1080 - Genetics;
Goals / Objectives
The goal of this project is to develop a fast-growing all-male high-quality tilapia cross for aquaculture by methods of crossbreeding, genetic sex regulation and investigation of body color variability.The objectives of the project are to:Objective 1: Perform comparative raising of several crosses of YY males with females of different strains of tilapia for identification of the best cross for rearing in recirculating systems.Objective 2: Investigate genetic variability of different tilapia parental strains using Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) molecular genetic markers.Objective 3: Investigate sex ratios in tilapia crosses to identify cross with the highest proportion of males.Objective 4: Investigate color variability in tilapia crosses to identify cross with largest percentage of red fish.
Project Methods
Research will be conducted at the KSU Aquaculture Program over a 3-year period. Procedures for Objective 1: To fulfill this objective the operation plan will consist of several consecutive steps:1) Acquiring tilapia of different lines for crossbreeding. As a preliminary step in the realization of this project YY males from two lines have already been acquired from Fishgen Ltd. Company by Aquaculture Program of Kentucky State University. For this project we plan to acquire two additional strains of red tilapia. YY males from each group will be crossed with females from these two additional lines.2) Raising of breeder fish of different acquired lines. The YY tilapia males from two lines (one red and another dark) have already been raised in a recirculating system at the KSU Aquaculture Program facility. Newly acquired fry of red tilapia from two other lines will also be raised in recirculating systems. Initially, fry will be stocked in recirculating systems with tank volume 35 gallons (132.5 liters) and will be raised until reaching approximately 2" length for a time period of about 45 days. For further rearing, fish will be transferred to recirculating system with 250-gallon tanks (946 liters); in this system fish will be raised for 8.5-9 month until reaching sexual maturity and a weight range 500-700 g. From these two lines only mature females will be selected for crossing with YY males.3) Fish breeding and production of interline crosses (hybrid fry). Fish breeders will be placed into 450-gallon (1,703 liters) tanks for spawning. In each tank 20 YY males and 40 females will be stocked for spawning (sex ratio 1 male per 2 females is commonly used for tilapia breeding). In total, four tanks will be stocked with YY males and females from different lines to produce four interline hybrids for further growth comparison. Stocked fish breeders will spawn naturally in tanks. Nile tilapia are a mouth-brooding species; eggs and larvae are incubated in females' oral cavities. We plan to remove embryos from females and continue to incubate them artificially in McDonald jars. This will help minimize size variability of fry produced by many females in the same tank and also between tanks. Initial size homogeneity of fry is very important for further comparative rearing.4) Comparative raising of crosses for identifying a cross with the best growth rate and survival. Initially fry from four crosses will be raised in recirculating systems with 35-gallon tanks with three replicate tanks for each cross. When fish reach approximately 2"-length (after about 45 days) data on fish growth and survival will be collected. Then from each cross a subsample will be randomly taken for further comparative rearing in a recirculating system with 250-gallon tanks. Each interline cross will be reared in three replicates for about 8.5 month until fish will reach market size (500-700 g). Fish will be fed with a 32% protein diet to satiation 2-3 times a day. The following parameters will be recorded at the end of rearing: survival, fish initial and final weights, weight gain, specific growth rate (SGR), and feed conversion ratio (FCR). Based on obtained data the most productive cross will be identified. Procedure for Objective 2: This project proposes using microarray technology to analyze SNP variability in lines of commercially available tilapia. To fulfill this objective the operation plan will consist of several consecutive steps:Purchase of necessary equipment, supplies and software; microarray preparation instruments, reagents and microarrays from Agilent to complement the existing Agilent SureScan Microarray in the Aquaculture Genetics Laboratory at KSU.Extraction, quantitation and quality analysis of genomic DNA from individual Nile tilapia from parental lines (30 fish from each line). Quantitation and quality analysis will be done by spectroscopy and gel electrophoresis.Restriction enzyme digestion, fluorescent labeling, and purification of the extracted genomic DNA to prepare the genomic DNA template for hybridization on the microarray.Hybridization of the sample with the microarray. Hybridization will be done with a Microarray Hybridization Chamber and Microarray Hybridization Oven purchased from Agilent.Washing of the microarray to remove unhybridized and partially hybridized DNA.Reading of the microarray with an Agilent SureScan Microarray Reader.Data processing and analysis with Agilent Genomic Workbench software. The data from the microarray will be processed and analyzed to calculate the genetic distance between the analyzed tilapia strains and predict heterosis effects in potential crosses. Procedure for Objective 3: Sex ratios (males /females) will be determined in all raised interline crosses. About 50-60 randomly taken fish from each cross will be dissected and fish sex will be determined based on the color and structure of the gonads. At this age (approximately 10 months) fish will be sexually mature. Based on these data the cross giving the maximum proportion of males (up to 100%) will be determined. As indicated above, all crosses will be obtained by crossing YY males with normal females (XY). Procedure for Objective 4: Color variability (ratios red /dark fish) will be determined in all raised interline crosses. We plan to record fish color twice: at the end of nursery rearing when fish will be transferred to larger tanks and at the end of comparative rearing. Based on these data the cross with the highest proportion of red fish will be determined. As mentioned above, all crosses will be obtained by crossing of red YY males with red females from different lines.

Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/19

Outputs
Target Audience:Graduate, undergraduate, and high school students, fish farmers, scientists, and the general public. Changes/Problems:A change was made in the methods for identification of single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers for investigation of genetic variability of tilapia strains (Objective 2). Instead of DNA microarray technology, which was planned initially, SNP markers were identified using the more advanced restriction site associated DNA sequencing (RAD-Seq) technology. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project provided an opportunity for high school, undergraduate, and graduate students to obtain basic knowledge on the principles of raising fish in a recirculating water system, fish spawning, and biological and mechanical water cleaning. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Descriptions of this project and information on its progress have been presented to fish farmers and scientists at numerous conferences, meetings, field days, and workshops. Demonstrations about the raising of tilapia in water recirculating systems have been presented at numerous tours by high school students, farmers, and the general public. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For Objective 1, growth rate of four tilapia crosses of YY males and XX females of different strains was compared. YY males from two strains and XX females from three strains were used for production of crosses. All four crosses were obtained at the same time and raised for 78 days in recirculation water systems under the same conditions. Then, fish were stocked in a recirculating system with 12 946-liter (250-US gallon) tanks for comparisons during the grow-out phase of raising. Each cross was raised in three replicated tanks and 50 fish were stocked per tank. Mean weight of stocked fish in crosses varied from 17.5 g to 21.4 g. During the 166-day raising period, fish were fed 2-3 times per day to apparent satiation; water temperature was maintained at 28°C. Based on results of comparisons during the grow-out phase of raising, one cross with a superior growth rate was identified. This cross was obtained using females from the Genetically Improved Farmed Tilapia (GIFT) strain. The growth rate of fish from this cross surpassed growth rates of other crosses by 58% or more; final mean weight of fish from this cross was 702.4 g while final mean weights of fish from three other crosses varied from 402.4 g to 447.0 g. Daily growth rate of fish from this cross was 4.1 g/d while this parameter in fish from the three other crosses was in the range of 2.3-2.6 g/d. Feed conversion ratio (FCR; ratio of fish weight gain to weight of consumed feed) for the cross with the superior gross rate (1.47) did not differ significantly from FCRs for two other crosses (1.46 and 1.48). This showed the advantage of this cross with regard to growth rate resulted from more aggressive feeding behavior of the fish and consumption of larger amount of feed. The tilapia cross with superior growth rate can be considered as the best for raising in recirculating systems. Raising of this cross will give farmers the opportunity to obtain fish of market size in a much shorter time compared with raising fish with lower growth rates. For Objective 2, investigation of genetic variability of eight tilapia strains using single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genetic markers was performed. For this purpose, a panel of approximately 31,800 SNPs have been developed using restriction site associated DNA sequencing (RAD-Seq) technology. Three YY-male and five mixed-sex strains available in the United States were investigated. In frame of this study, the rate of both intra- and interstrain variation were determined. Mean expected heterozygosity ranged from a low of 0.084 in the Miami YY strain to a high of 0.222 in the Miami mixed-sex strain. Two of the three YY groups (Miami YY strain and Fishgen YY Red strain) had the lowest expected heterozygosities (0.084 and 0.085, respectively) and second and third lowest observed heterozygosities (both 0.107). The number of private alleles varied from 90 to 3795 in different strains and tended to increase with increasing expected heterozygosity. Inbreeding, as measured by Fis (inter-individual fixation index or coefficient of inbreeding), was low in all populations, ranging from -0.060 in the Fishgen YY Dark strain to 0.04 in the GIFT (Genetically Improved Farmed Tilapia) strain. This indicates that the analyzed strains are currently being maintained with approximately random mating of individuals. Genetic differentiation between strains, as measured by Fst (subpopulation fixation index), ranged from little differentiation (Fst = 0.06 for the Ismailia Canal and GIFT strains) to strong differentiation (Fst = 0.32 for the Miami YY and Lake Manzala strains). The intermediate value of F (0.15) was detected between parental strains (Miami YY males and GIFT females) used for production of the cross with the superior growth rate (as demonstrated by results of comparative raising performed for Objective 1). For Objective 3, sex ratios in eight progenies obtained by seven crosses of YY males and XX females of different origin were investigated. The percentage of males in progenies varied from 79 to 100% with a mean value of 90.5%. The observed range of frequency of males in crosses of YY males with XX females was similar to reports from the literature on this parameter. As a result of this study, the crosses with highest proportion of males have been identified. The results of the study showed that YY tilapia males of the same origin could produce different percentages of males in crosses with females from different strains. The percentages of males in different progenies of the same cross could also differ. For Objective 4, color variability was investigated in eight progenies obtained by seven different crosses of YY males and XX females of different origins. Analysis of color variability and inheritance showed that body color (dark or red) in tilapia is determined by one gene with two alleles (R/r); a dominant allele (R) caused a red body color while a recessive allele (r) caused a dark (wild type) body color. These results coincided with previous data on color inheritance in Nile tilapia. Crosses red fish x red fish and red fish x dark fish performed in this study produced only red fish; the absence of dark fish in obtained progenies indicated that the parental genotypes in these crosses were RR x RR or RR x Rr. Crosses of dark fish (rr x rr) gave only dark fish (genotype rr) in progenies as expected. We also found that fish with a red background color can develop black spots and patches on the body. The rate of body coverage with black pigment was variable; apparently this trait is polygenic and has a complex mode of inheritance.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Delomas, T. A., Gomelsky, B., Vu, N., Campbell, M.R. and N.D. Novelo. 2019. SNP discovery and genetic variation in YY-male and mixed sex strains of Nile tilapia Oreochromis niloticus available in the United States. North American Journal of Aquaculture, 81:183-188.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Submitted Year Published: 2020 Citation: Novelo, N. D., Gomelsky, B., Coyle, S.D. and A. G. Kramer. Growth, sex segregation, sexual dimorphism and color variability in Nile Tilapia crosses of YY males with normal females of different strains. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society, submitted.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2019 Citation: Novelo, N.D., Gomelsky, B., Coyle, S.D. and A. G. Kramer. Evaluation of growth and sex segregation in Nile Tilapia crosses of YY males with normal XX females of different origin. Presented at World Aquaculture Society Conference Aquaculture 2019, New Orleans, LA, USA, March 7-11, 2019.


Progress 09/01/17 to 08/31/18

Outputs
Target Audience:Graduate and undergraduate students, high school students, fish farmers, scientists, and the general public. Changes/Problems:A change was made in the methods for identification of Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) markers for investigation of genetic variability of tilapia strains. Instead of DNA microarray technology, which was planned initially, SNPs markers were identified using the more advanced Restriction Site Associated DNA Sequencing (RAD-seq) technology. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In the reporting period, this project provided an opportunity for high school, undergraduate, and graduate students to obtain basic knowledge on the principles of raising fish in a recirculating water system, fish spawning, and biological and mechanical water cleaning. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Descriptions of this project and information on its progress have been presented on several occasions to fish farmers and scientists. Demonstrations about the raising of tilapia in water recirculating systems have been presented at numerous tours by high school students, farmers, and the general public. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?For Objectives 1, 3 and, 4, the obtained data will be analyzed and reported in presentations and articles. For Objective 2, analysis of genetic variability of tilapia strains will be continued and completed.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For Objective 1, four tilapia crosses of YY males and XX females of different strains were compared. YY males from two strains and XX females from three strains were used for production of crosses. All four crosses were obtained at the same time. Each cross was raised for 166 days in three replicated 250-gallon tanks in one recirculating system. One cross with superior growth rate was identified. This cross was obtained using females from Genetically Improved Farmed Tilapia (GIFT) line and the growth rate surpasses other crosses by 58% or more. This highly-productive tilapia cross can be considered the best for raising in recirculating systems. For Objective 2, the analysis of genetic variability of eight tilapia strains using Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) genetic markers is in progress. For this objective, a panel of approximately 30,000 SNPs have been developed using Restriction Site Associated DNA Sequencing (RAD-Seq) technology. For Objective 3, sex ratios in eight progenies obtained by seven crosses of YY males and XX females of different origins have been investigated. The percentage of males in progenies varied from 79 to 100% with a mean value of 90.5%. This demonstrated that YY tilapia males of the same origin could produce different percentages of males in crosses with females from different lines. The percentages of males in different progenies of the same cross could also differ. For Objective 4, color variability was investigated in eight progenies obtained by seven different crosses of YY males and XX females of different origins. Analysis of color variability and inheritance showed that background body color (dark or red) in tilapia is determined by one gene with two alleles; a dominant allele causes a red background color while recessive allele causes a dark body color. Crosses of the red background color x red background color and red background color x dark color produced only fish with a red background color while crossing dark fish resulted in appearance of dark offspring only. We also found that tilapia with a red background color can develop black spots and patches on the body. Coverage with black pigment on the red body is very variable and apparently this trait is polygenic with a complex mode of inheritance.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Novelo, N. D., Gomelsky, B., Coyle, S. D., Warner, J. L., and A. G. Kramer. 2018. Sex and color segregations in Nile tilapia crosses obtained from different strains of YY males and normal XX Females. Presented at Aquaculture America Conference, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA, February 19-22,2018.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Gomelsky, B., Novelo, N.D., Coyle, S.D., Kramer, A.G., and J.L. Warner. 2018. Growth rate and sex segregation in Nile tilapia crosses obtained using YY males and normal XX females of different origin. Presented at World Aquaculture Society Conference 'AQUA 2018', Montpellier, France, August 25-29, 2018.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2018 Citation: Novelo, N. D. 2018. Tilapia Hatchery and Production. Presented at Workshop on Sustainable Agriculture, Harold R. Benson Research and Demonstration Farm, Kentucky State University, Frankfort, KY, June 21, 2018.


Progress 09/01/16 to 08/31/17

Outputs
Target Audience:Graduate and undergraduate students, high school students, fish farmers, scientists, and the general public Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In the reporting period this project provided opportunity for high school, undergraduate, and graduate students to obtain basic knowledge on principles of raising fish in recirculating water system, fish spawning and biological and mechanical water cleaning. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Description of this project and information on its progress have been given in different presentations to fish farmers and scientists. Raising of tilapia in water recirculating systems has been demonstrated in numerous tours by high school students, farmers, and the general public. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The trial on comparisons of different tilapia inter-line crosses will continued and be completed. Based on results of this trial, the cross with the best growth rate will be identified. Analysis of raised inter-line crosses will be continued with regards to sex ratios and color inheritance. Genetic variability of tilapia lines used in crosses will be evaluated by the analysis of DNA genetic markers.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For Objective 1, a trial comparing four tilapia crosses of YY males with females of different lines has started. Fish are raised in a recirculating water system with three replicates for each cross. This trial will continue until fish reach market size. For Objective 2, fin clip samples from YY males of three different lines and from normal XX females of five different lines have been collected for further analysis of DNA genetic markers. Equipment and laboratory supplies needed for this analysis have been identified and some have been acquired to date. For Objectives 3 and 4, eight crosses of YY males and XX females of different lines have been obtained for analysis. Fish from four inter-line crosses have been analyzed and preliminary data on sex ratios (Objective 3) and color variability (Objective 4) were obtained. The percentage of males in crosses varied from 88 to 100%; it was shown YY tilapia males of the same origin could produce different percentage of males in crosses with females from different lines. Crosses of solid red fish (no black pigmentation) resulted in appearance of both solid red fish and fish with a background red color covered with varying amounts of black patches. Crossing of two lines with dark color produced progenies only with a dark color. Four additional inter-line tilapia crosses will also be analyzed.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Gomelsky B. Application of crossbreeding and genetic sex regulation for development of fast-growing all-male tilapia cross for aquaculture. Poster presentation at USDA Capacity Building Grants (CBG)Program Project Directors' Meeting, Virginia Beach, VA, September 19-20, 2016.
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2017 Citation: Novelo N and B. Gomelsky. Hatchery production and genetics of tilapia. Oral presentation at Indoor Tilapia, Shrimp and Aquaponics Program at Kentucky State Universitys Aquaculture Research Center, March 25th, 2017.


Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/16

Outputs
Target Audience:Graduate and undergraduate students, fish farmers, high school students, scientists, general public Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In the reporting period this project provided opportunity for graduate and graduate students to obtain basic knowledge on principles of raising fish in recirculating water systems, biological and mechanical water cleaning andwater chemistry. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Raising of tilapia in water recirculation system has been demonstrated to numerous tours by high school students, farmers and general public. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Several tilapia crosses will beproduced bybreeding of YY-males with females of two different lines. Obtained crosses will be raised in recirculating water systems and their comparative viability and growth rate will be evaluated. Preliminary data on color variability and sex ratio of fish in crosses will be obtained. Single nucleotide polymorphism identified byDNA microarray technologywill be used to evaluate genetic variability of different tilapia lines.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For accomplishment of Objective 1 two mix-sex tilapia lines have been acquired and raised in water recirculating systems. When females of these lines will reach sex maturity and appropriate size they will be bred with YY-males for production of different crosses. These tilapia crosses will be evaluated later in the frame of this project. Also, during reported period two groups of YY males (dark and red) have been raised in recirculating systems. For accomplishment of Objective 2 scientists and professionals have discussed the optimal ways of analysis;equipment and supplies foracquiring needed for fulfilment of this objective have been identified. Data on fish sex ratios (Objective 3) and fish color variability (Objective 4) will be obtained later when different crosses of tilapia will be obtained and raised. During reporting period Research Associate was selected and hired.

Publications