Source: UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA submitted to NRP
DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION OF QUALITATIVE DATA NETWORKS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1007437
Grant No.
2015-70006-24161
Cumulative Award Amt.
$174,306.00
Proposal No.
2015-06521
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2015
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2018
Grant Year
2015
Program Code
[ARDP]- Applied Research and Development Program
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA
200 D.W. BROOKS DR
ATHENS,GA 30602-5016
Performing Department
Entomology
Non Technical Summary
Researchers and extension specialists currently utilize quantitative longitudinal observations from sentinel plots or traps to assess pest populations. These data provide useful information for stakeholders, but maintaining appropriate infrastructure and cooperator networks is extremely difficult due to erosion of university funding, loss of formula funds, and increasing competition for federal grants. The overall goal of this proposal is to build and demonstrate a qualitative based pest monitoring network that utilizes brief weekly reports on pest presence or absence entered on a mobile device by a defined stakeholder support group. Uploaded data will be displayed in real time with timely targeted push notifications that enable science based decision support. Demonstration of the new system will be conducted using Georgia Cooperative Extension Agents entering county based observations on peanut rust (dispersed by airborne urediniospores), white mold on peanut (inoculated from soil borne sclerotia) and sugarcane aphid on grain sorghum (invasive insect pest). In the research component, graduate students will manage field plots in a north-south transect across Georgia using standard agronomic practices vs. Extension recommendations based on known pest or pathogen presence in that county. An economic comparison between these production systems completes the proposal.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2161830116066%
2161520113034%
Goals / Objectives
Objective 1 - Develop automated systems to enable and extend real-time data collection, data visualization and timely automated push alerts (Extension Objective).Objective 2 - Implement qualitative data monitoring networks by populating database with statewide reports focused on three specific model systems (Extension Objective).Objective 3. Validate regional decision support alerts in research plots planted on multiple farms (Research Objective).
Project Methods
For objective 1, Bugwood programmers will work with extension specialists to determine the content of the smartphone and web apps. The focus of the project will be on data recruitment for the three model systems, but the apps will be available for other specialists to select species for monitoring and act as Administrators in setting the parameters for their own model systems. In the application development stages, Extension specialists will come together to standardize how to report a given species in a qualitative manner to make this an easy and intuitive tool to use and provide data which can be used to determine proper management protocols for a variety of commodities and pests. In this example, agents would select all of their weekly information on one screen by touching appropriate responses; this task could be accomplished for a given crop in less than ten seconds! The system will be flexible to accommodate the data recording needs of the Administrators as well as useful in monitoring many species types and emergence/infestation patterns. As other Extension specialists express interest, they will be instructed on how to use the apps. They will be instructed to develop a list of species for their commodity and region and the metrics by which pest levels are to be classified. Using the information provided by the extension specialists, Bugwood programmers will construct Android, iOS, and web apps to enable pest occurrence reporting, data visualizations, and integration with the PushIPM system to send out alerts. The alert system will be coded so that the administrator can adjust the threshold, frequency, and geographic scope where reporters receive alerts.In objective 2, we will introduce the newly developed apps to extension specialists and county agents and provide training on use and functionality. Training events will be in multiple formats (in-person, live-feed web meetings, videos) and timings to ensure that agents can learn when and how they are most comfortable. Training will be conducted using the three model systems as the examples, but we will also support out-of-state extension specialists to set-up alternative model systems. After assigning login and password information, administrators will gain feedback on initial impressions of the apps and sign-up additional reporters. These sessions will be used to promote awareness of the apps, how to use them, and when alerts will be sent. Programmers will evaluate response by attendees at outreach events and adjust functionality as needed. We plan to use the spring (March-April) to allow the Reporters to gain familiarity with our model systems and make "mock" reports before starting real reporting each year on May 1. Expert specialists and reporters will use the apps to report occurrences of new invasive species and the qualitative population levels of pests in their region and commodity on a real-time basis throughout the year. Data provided by the reporters will be visualized by the system to provide users with graphs and maps. The maps will display qualitative data in different colors to represent the pest levels throughout the region. Maps can also be set to focus on specific areas and can be embedded in other websites including blogs. As the maps are pulling data from a common database, embedded maps will reflect real-time data entry.The occurrence data, qualitative data, and other information will be housed in the EDDMapS database. By providing a central data location, growers and specialists will be able to tailor their management plans to the real-time pest populations in their region and on their commodities. For any sensitive data that may have been submitted as point records, only researchers who have been granted permission by the administrators will be able to access the point-referenced data for use in modeling and other research applications under the condition that the data is not publicly released.The updated PushIPM system will be used to notify individuals as to the state of pests in their area. Administrators will be able to customize Alerts to specific locations, to encourage reporting of certain pests and to notify nearby areas of incoming pest issues. This will result in increased reporting of pests of concern or invasive species by reporters and will minimize delay in information transmission between experts and growers.In objective 3,usefulness of alerts from the three model systems (white mold and peanut rust on peanut and sugarcane aphid on grain sorghum) proposed in objectives one and two will be evaluated on University experiment stations. We will recruit and train a graduate student, preferably someone pursuing a career in Cooperative Extension, to test the hypothesis that growers can maximize profits by reacting to real time alerts as opposed to simply following standard "prescription" based fungicide and insecticide programs. These experiments will determine the consistency and accuracy with which the push alerts can make a difference to growers.Peanut and grain sorghum trials will be conducted in replicated plots, each plot measuring 15 m wide by 15 m long. Trials will be planted and actively managed at three locations stretching from extreme south to middle Georgia (this area encompasses the primary production parts of state). Plots will be planted at Attapulgus (3 miles from the Florida state line), Tifton (60 miles from Florida) and Plains (95 miles from Florida). At each location, 0.4 ha (1-acre) of land will be planted to grain sorghum and an addition 0.4 ha planted to peanut.

Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/18

Outputs
Target Audience:Although Georgia based peanut and grain sorghum growerswere the target audience for findings of this extension led project, we reached amuch broader audience including agricultural producers, crop consultants, county agents, government scientists, university scientists, industry representatives, legislators, and students.Growers, agents andconsultants that manage production acreagedirectly benefited from the knowledge gained and disseminated.County agents wereable tobetter advise their local producer clientele about the proper management of these pests. Fellow scientists and peers will be influenced by the project outcomes and published data and will continue to add to the literature on peanut rust, white mold and sugarcane aphid. Beyond the stated model systems, the conceptual framework and tools developed from the project were critical in mitigating astatewide whitefly infestation in 2017. Changes/Problems:We experienced two significant problems during the project. First, Statewide area planted to grain sorghum decreased by nearly 60% from 2015 to 2017, due to severe infestations of sugarcane aphid that limited producer economic returns in the previous year. This limited the number of agents that were actively looking for sugarcane aphids as many had zero growers growing the crop. Second, there were an unusually large number of county agent vacancies during the project. For example, in 2016 UGA Cooperative Extension hired 23 new agents, experienced 17 departures and 3 transfers. In 2017, UGA Cooperative Extension hired 16 new agents, experienced 10 departures and 11 transfers. Finally, in 2018, UGA Cooperative Extension hired 18 new agents, experienced 21 departures and 1 transfer. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project enabled complete training on one professional master's student that was hired as county agent in Georgia immediately upon graduation. Further, one Research Professional, two undergraduates, and a post doc obtained training during the completion of the project. Most importantly, approximately 150 county agents received thorough training on how to report pests and invasive insects into the EDDMapS IPM database. Additionally, these data were leveraged to obtain additional grant funding to support futher refinements of the concept or utilization of other model systems including: Toews, M.D. Areawide management of sugarcane aphid on sorghum in the coastal plain region. USDA ARS Areawide Projects 9/1/2018 to 8/31/2019 ($139,077). Toews, M.D. and P.M. Roberts. Bridge funding to support whitefly management in Georgia cotton. Cotton Incorporated. 1/1/2018 to 12/31/2018 ($22,362). Sparks, A. and M. Toews. Bridge funding to support whitefly management in Georgia agricultural commodities. Georgia Commodity Commission for Vegetables. 1/1/2018 to 12/31/2018 ($19,000). Sparks, A. and M. Toews. Bridge funding to support whitefly management in Georgia agricultural commodities. Georgia Commodity Commission for Blueberries. 1/1/2018 to 12/31/2018 ($1,000). How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results of the project were demonstrated and shared widely throughthe 3314users who downloaded EDDMapS IPM, at threeextension agent training sessions, at the Annual Meeting of the Entomological Society of America, at the USDA Area wide management of sugarcane aphid annual meeting, at the UGA cotton production workshop, with the College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Dean's advisory council, and with the Georgia congressional delegation in Washington DC. Citations of those meetings include: Bostick, N., J. Schmidt, C.T. Bargeron, T. Brenneman, AK Culbreath, D. Buntin, J. LaForest and M. Toews. 2017. Improving crop pest management using qualitative data networks. Annual Meeting of the Entomological Society of America. November 5-8, Denver, CO. Toews, M.D. 2017. Update on the Center for Invasive Species and Ecosystem Health. UGA Cooperative Extension Southwest District ANR Annual Update. December 12, Tifton. Toews, M.D. 2018. Efficacy and timing of sugarcane aphid treatments. USDA Areawide management of sugarcane aphid annual meeting. January 17, Dallas, TX. Toews, M.D. 2018. Whiteflies in cotton 2017: what happened? UGA Cotton Production Workshop. January 31, Tifton. Toews, M.D. 2018. Update on the Center for Invasive Species and Ecosystem Health. UGA Cooperative Extension Northwest District ANR Annual Update. Feb. 8, Griffin. Toews, M.D. 2018. Update on the Center for Invasive Species and Ecosystem Health. UGA Cooperative Extension Southeast District ANR Annual Update. Feb. 13, Vidalia. Toews, M.D. Whiteflies in Georgia: June 2018 update. Presentation to Georgia congressional delegation. Washington DC. June 13 (20 participants, 25 minutes). Toews, M.D. 2018. Update on whiteflies in Georgia. CAES Dean's Advisory Committee. July 31, Griffin, GA (25 participants, 30 minutes). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Objective 1 - Develop automated systems to enable and extend real-time data collection, data visualization and timely automated push alerts (Extension Objective). Utilizing computing resources and programming expertise at the Center for Invasive Species and Ecosystem Health, we adapted and modified an existing platform called EDDMapS (Early Detection and Distribution Mapping System, www.eddmaps.org) as the database backbone to support data storage, retrieval, and visualization for this project. A new web entry portal (https://www.eddmaps.org/ipm/report/) and customized smartphone apps (called EDDMapS IPM) for both iPhone and Android devices were updated and then we developed the ability to send out real-time alerts based on an adjustable threshold to specific users. For example, alerts can be configured to reach all users in the affected county, or all users in that county plus any contiguous counties. Real-time mapping icons were added with the ability to share, download or email directly from the app. The system was designed so that data could be uploaded from a smartphone app, or web portal, to a server and then returned to the smartphone app or website as a color-coded map representing the intensity of infestations throughout the region. The information technology components in EDDMapS include smartphone data entry, data logging, data processing on a server, and customized real-time alerts To increase the functionality of EDDMapS, we partnered with other similar data collection systems so that data flowing into our system flows to theirs and vice versa. Partners in this capacity include the integrated pest information platform for extension and educations (iPiPE) and MyFields (a software program available for use by crop consultants), See. Objective 2 - Implement qualitative data monitoring networks by populating database with statewide reports focused on three specific model systems (Extension Objective). We trained approximately 150 Agriculture and Natural Resource (ANR) county agents in the University of Georgia Extension Service (hereafter called agents) in the spring of 2016 and 2017 to report on the presence and relative abundance of sugarcane aphids in their respective counties using EDDMapS IPM. Agents were instructed to log qualitative estimates (i.e., not reported, not present, low levels, economic levels present) of sugarcane aphid activity in their respective counties on a weekly basis during the summer months. A project coordinator was made available to assist agents with technical issues related to using the app. Additionally, we prompted agents weekly using email to report on conditions in their counties during the summer months. For purposes of reporting on abundance and spatial distribution of sugarcane aphid for this project, EDDMapS IPM was downloaded 95times on an Apple device and 29 times on an Android device in 2018. Over the life of the project, EDDMapS IPM was downloaded 3018 times on an Apple device and 296 times on an Android device.In 2016 we received 11,392 reports from 72 reporters spread across 77 counties. In 2017, we received 9089 reports from 72 reporters spread across 64 counties. Finally, in 2018 we received 4749 reports from 34 reporters across 26 counties. In 2017, Georgia growers experienced an epidemic of whiteflies in cotton and late season vegetables. Extension specialists contacted us to adapt the system for reporting on whiteflies as well. In 2017, we received 480 reports from 42 reporters spread across 46 counties. Finally, in 2018, we received 4350 reports from 21 reporters across 34 counties for purposes of reporting on abundance and spatial distribution of silverleaf whitefly in cotton and fall vegetables.. Objective 3. Validate regional decision support alerts in research plots planted on multiple farms (Research Objective). The objectives of the study reported herein were to evaluate the suitability of using a consensus-based scouting network and determine the timing of insecticide applications for management of sugarcane aphid in grain sorghum. The timing of insecticide applications was (1) application at 25 aphids per leaf, (2) application at 50 aphids per leaf, (3) a delayed application 1 wk after occurrence of 50 aphids per leaf, or (4) not treated. Trials were completed at Plains and Attapulgus, GA. Results showed that a single application of flupyradifurone at 15.4 g(AI)/ha consistently reduced populations to nearly zero for the remainder of the season, while aphid populations in the non-treated plots reached a peak of 300-400 aphids per leaf. Aphid populations on the upper leaves reached 50 aphids per leaf in non-treated plots 1 wk after reaching the treatment threshold on the lower leaves. Although there were up to 2 wks difference between the early and delayed threshold treatments, all plots receiving insecticide applications had similar estimated yields, which were more than five times greater than yields in non-treated plots. Results from the consensus-based scouting network showed that first detections and reported first commercial applications generally occurred within 1 wk (range of 3 to 11 days) of the actual populations quantified in the research trials. These data suggest that initiating scouting for sugarcane aphid populations following notification of activity in the area through consensus reporting would provide adequate warning for preventing economic losses to sugarcane aphid.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2019 Citation: Bostick, N.M., J.H. LaForest, C.T. Bargeron, A.K. Culbreath, T.B. Brenneman, J.M. Schmidt, G.D. Buntin and M.D. Toews. Improving the application timing for management of sugarcane aphid in Georgia. J Entomol. Sci. (in press).


Progress 09/01/16 to 08/31/17

Outputs
Target Audience:Although Georgia based peanut and grain sorghum growers are the target audience for findings of this extension led project, we believe that a much broader audience including agricultural producers, crop consultants, county agents, university scientists, industry representatives, and students participating in the research process will benefit. Any grower or consultant that manages production acreage will directly benefit from the knowledge gained and disseminated. Industry representatives will gain insights into pest abundance and timing of products that are efficacious against the target pests. County agents will be better able to advise their local producer clientele about the proper management of those pests. Fellow scientists and peers will be influenced by the project outcomes and published data and will continue to add to the literature on peanut rust, white mold and sugarcane aphid. Beyond the stated model systems, the conceptual framework and tools developed from the project will be widely utilized in other model systems. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?One graduate student and a post doc were trained on applied insect pest managment skills. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?An update talk was presented in the early spring to Georgia County Agents. Two professional talks have been given. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?year two field data will be completed and then the data analyses will be completed before drafting a scientific manuscript.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Data analyses from year one showed that agents in a given county typically reported sugarcane aphid populations up to 4 weeks before they reached threshold in that area. Insecticide applications always reduced aphid populations to near zero and the populations did not rebound. There were no differences in responses between grain sorghum plots treated on threshold and those treated one week late, but numerical differences are evident and the data are trending with each new observation. Data on peanut showed a reduction of white mold when plots were treated in response to Agent's reporting the presence of white mold early in the year. Peanut rust showed up very late and did not appear to made any signifiant economic effects on the peanut model system. Year two data are currently being conducted and year two observations by county agents are currently underway. Replicated research plots were planted at Attapulgus, Tifton and Plains and the plots have been visited weekly and treated as scheduled. Insect pressure has been very high, while white mold pressure has been low and no peanut rust has shown up yet.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/16

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Although Georgia based peanut and grain sorghum growers are the target audience for findings of this extension led project, we believe that a much broader audience including agricultural producers, crop consultants, county agents, university scientists, industry representatives, and students participating in the research process will benefit. Any grower or consultant that manages production acreage will directly benefit from the knowledge gained and disseminated. Industry representatives will gain insights into pest abundance and timing of products that are efficacious against the target pests. County agents will be better able to advise their local producer clientele about the proper management of those pests. Fellow scientists and peers will be influenced by the project outcomes and published data and will continue to add to the literature on peanut rust, white mold and sugarcane aphid. Beyond the stated model systems, the conceptual framework and tools developed from the project will be widely utilized in other model systems. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?226 county agents and 110 growers were educated on the use and applicability of the EDDMapS IPM app. The graduate student is completing training for a graduate degree in pest managment from the University of Georgia. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The agents will continue reporting and the student will continue scouting. The results of the summer field work will be presented at a professional conference.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Web programers and smart phone programmers developed and released the smartphone component of the project in an app called EDDMapS IPM. This app is available for both Android and Apple operating systems. Dr. Toews trained all Georgia Cooperative Extension ANR (Ag and Natural Resources) Agents in the state on how to use the app for reporting pest abundance. Finally, the graduate student established replicated grain sorghum and peanut plots at Attapulgus, Tifton and Plains, GA. Weekly scouting for pests and reporting is currently underway.

    Publications