Source: UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE submitted to NRP
A PLANNING NETWORK OF ORGANIC FARMERS, RESEARCHERS, AND DAIRY PROCESSORS TO OPTIMIZE PRODUCTIVITY AND RESILIENCY OF FORAGE PRODUCTION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1007250
Grant No.
2015-51300-24137
Cumulative Award Amt.
$47,018.00
Proposal No.
2015-07416
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2015
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2017
Grant Year
2015
Program Code
[113.A]- Organic Agriculture Research & Extension Initiative
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE
51 COLLEGE RD SERVICE BLDG 107
DURHAM,NH 03824
Performing Department
Biological Sciences
Non Technical Summary
The Universities of New Hampshire and Wisconsin have a vested interest in establishing research and outreach partnerships with respective regional institutions, stakeholders, and state agencies to support the Northeastern and Midwestern organic dairy industry. Organic dairies in the Northeast and Midwest rely primarily on pasture during the grazing season, and continue to feed high-forage diets during the winter. Therefore, research to optimize productivity and resiliency of forage production appears to be a viable strategy to enhance the economic and environmental sustainability of organic dairies in these two regions. However, a needs assessment of organic dairy farmers who have adopted or are considering adopting forage-based approaches to optimize farm profitability has yet to be conducted. We will assemble a team of researchers and stakeholders to first identify these needs by conducting focus groups to obtain an in-depth understanding of the concerns facing organic dairy farmers (Objective 1). Higher priority issues emerging from these groups will be developed into surveys to further refine and prioritize these issues with a broader population of stakeholders (Objective 2). The highest priorities will be verified and validated with team members and stakeholders through follow-up workshops (Objective 3). Successful completion of this planning process will result in the formation of a Research and Extension Advisory Panel and submission of integrated multiregional proposal(s) to USDA-NIFA in response to the request for application for the OREI program beginning in 2016 (Objective 4). This project meets OREI legislatively-defined goals #1-2 and #5-7, and 2015 priorities #1-2, and #6.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
0%
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1010110200015%
1020199106015%
2051699310010%
2051630310010%
2132300114010%
3023499101020%
3071699101010%
3073499301010%
Goals / Objectives
Milk production has been one of the fastest growing segments of organic agriculture in the United States, yet rising feed costs and volatile milk prices have created new challenges for dairy farmers in the Northeast and Midwest. Specifically, organic dairy farmers are searching for alternative feeding strategies, including reducing or even eliminating grains from dairy rations to enhance farm profitability.Our goal isto bring together a multiregional team of researchers, extension personnel, and industry stakeholders to establish a consortium of expertise (Research and Extension Advisory Panel) to address current and future needs of organic dairy farmers interested in resilient forage production systems and new milk markets in the Northeast and Midwest.Our planning network will conduct focus group meetings, surveys, and follow-up workshops to identify the research and extension needs of organic dairy farmers who have adopted or are considering adopting diverse forage crop communities to improve soil and forage quality while marketing high quality, environmentally-friendly organic milk. Specific objectives are described below:Objective 1: Develop an in-depth understanding of the research and extension needs of organic dairy farmers from the NE and MW considering or currently using diverse forage crop communities to improve soil and forage quality, and farm profitability, via focus group meetings.Objective 2: Prioritize research and extension needs identified in the focus groups with a broader population of farmers via survey methods.Objective 3: Verify and validate the priorities with team members and stakeholders, and begin a planning process for conducting integrated soil-forage-dairy research and extension programs via follow-up workshops.Objective 4: Submit integrated proposal(s) to address the prioritized organic research and extension needs under the guidance of the Research and Extension Advisory Panel.
Project Methods
Focus groups: Participants for the focus groups will be drawn from multiple mailing and email lists that include organic dairy farmers. In addition, leaders from industry and nonprofit organizations and University extension staff will be asked to provide names of key individuals involved in the organic dairy industry. Focus group meetings will be hosted at six sites (three per region) targeting geographical areas of substantial organic dairy production in the Northeast and Midwest. The most likely sites will be VT, NY, and PA in the NE, and WI in the MW. However, the planning team will invite farmers from other states and locations will be chosen to maximize farmer participation. Each focus group will include eight to 10 participants with attention paid to a balance of farmers, industry representatives, gender/ethnic representation, and length of time involved in organic production. Purposeful sampling is a common method for identifying participants for qualitative inquiry such as focus groups. Focus group questions will be developed by planning personnel as a very general set of draft questions and will be modified based upon feedback from a few key stakeholders and planning grant collaborators. Facilitators for the focus groups will include planning personnel and extension staff from each site with evaluation expertise. Care will be taken not to recruit facilitators for a given region who are already deeply involved with farmers, hence encouraging honest and frank responses by participants. Each focus group will be conducted in a similar manner, with the facilitator providing a brief introduction of the goals of the study, the ground rules, and instructions to obtain consent from participants. Eight to 10 open-ended questions will be asked and the facilitators will ensure all participants respond, drawing out members when necessary, and politely closing off dominant participants if required. The sessions will be recorded to ensure comprehensive capture of input. Notes from each focus group will be reviewed for obvious location-specific differences, and these differences, if any, will be noted.Surveys: The survey instrument will be pilot tested with five to eight organic dairy farmers, asking each to complete the survey and participate in a follow up phone call to ensure content validity. Questions will be modified based upon the pilot test and a final copy of the survey instrument will be created and implemented. An introductory (pre-survey) will be introduced to organic dairy farmers via email and announcements in farmer-oriented publications to increase the response rate when the actual survey request is sent. Included in the communications will be a mailing address, phone number, and email address of the evaluator if questions arise about the survey. The actual survey instrument will contain a brief introductory message along with informed consent information and an estimate of how long it will take to complete the survey.Follow-up workshops: Research staff, faculty, extension personnel, and key stakeholders will be asked to attend the regional workshops that will follow this tentative agenda: 1) Welcome and introduction of project; 2) Discussion of findings; 3) Breakout sessions (sessions will reflect the themes identified in the study, such as forage production, pasture management, soil quality, environmental impact, economic issues and marketing, etc.); and 4) Invitation to participate in on-farm research, extension resource development, or serving on the Research and Extension Advisory Panel.Development and submission of integrated proposals: Approximately 10 stakeholders (farmers and industry personnel) from the Northeast and Midwest empowered with the assistance of the planning team will meet and begin to develop research proposals for submission to the OREI, AFRI, and other USDA programs.

Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/17

Outputs
Target Audience:We engaged organic dairy farmers, extension educators, milk processors, veterinarians, and dairy nutritionists in the Northeast and Midwest through7 focus group interviews, 2 regional surveys, and 2 workshops. Approximately 250 organic dairy farmers participated in our focus groups, surveys, and workshops. Changes/Problems:Project activities were developed as planned. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Our planning grant was developed to document farmers' perspectives regarding best strategies to maximize the use of forage resources to improve farm profitability. However, we did provide educational opportunities to farmers and extension educators during our 2 workshops. We presented research data relevant to our planning network and provided farmers, extension educators, and industry personnel the opportunity to learn about forage crop systems, soil health, pasture management, and dairy nutrition. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results from our focus groups and surveys have been disseminated in workshops, field days, scientific and farmer-oriented conferences, classrooms, and University online media and Extension websites. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Impact: Milk production has been one of the fastest growing segments of organic agriculture in the United States, yet rising feed costs and volatile milk prices have created new challenges for dairy farmers in the Northeast and Midwest. Specifically, organic dairy farmers are searching for alternative feeding strategies, including reducing or even eliminating grains from dairy rations to enhance farm profitability. Through 7 focus group interviews, 2 regional surveys, and 2 workshops our planning grant team brought together organic dairy farmers, scientists, extension educators, graduate and undergraduate students, and industry personnel (e.g., dairy nutritionists, veterinarians, milk processors employees) to voice their perspectives regarding organic milk production practices that maximize profitable forage use resources. Approximately 250 organic dairy farmers who participated in our focus groups, surveys, and workshops agree that managing positive feedbacks to optimize forage nutritive value and soil health on organic dairy farms through increased legume proportion and persistence in pasture swards, as well as improved forage energy:protein balance and nitrogen utilization are critical research and extension needs that must be addressed. These results are currently being used by our team in workshops, field days, and presentations in scientific and farmer-oriented conferences to educate farmers and allied industry about success and constraints to produce organic milk relying of high-forage or no-grain diets. We also empowered organic dairy farmers by developing and submitting grant proposals to OREI and ORG programs addressing their extension and research needs. Objective 1: Develop an in-depth understanding of the research and extension needs of organic dairy farmers from the NE and MW considering or currently using diverse forage crop communities to improve soil and forage quality, and farm profitability, via focus group meetings. A total of 7 focus group interviews were conducted in New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont, New York, and Wisconsin. Approximately 80 organic dairy farmers attended our group meetings and voiced their perspectives regarding research and extension needs to capitalize on forage-based resources to optimize the profitability of milk production in the Northeast and Midwest. Several topics emerged from this rich discussion including research to address pasture establishment and renovation, incorporation of annual and alternative forage crops, soil fertility, grazing management, increased proportion of legumes in pasture and hayfields, and increased energy:nitrogen ratio in forage crops used for pasture and stored feeds (e.g., hay, silage, baleage). Objective 2: Prioritize research and extension needs identified in the focus groups with a broader population of farmers via survey methods. We conducted 2 surveys targeting organic dairy farmers who are using only forage resources (pasture and conserved forages) to produce organic milk. "Grass milk" is an emerging niche market for organic dairy farmers and there is a growing number of dairies making the transition from grain use to forage-only diets. The Northeast survey targeted organic dairy farmers from Vermont and New York and the Midwest survey targeted Wisconsin organic dairies. In the Northeast our team collaborated with Sarah Flack (private dairy consultant), Heather Darby (University of Vermont), and Fay Benson (Cornell University) develop and release the survey instrument, while in the Midwest (i.e., Wisconsin) we collaborated with Organic Valley. Even though we are still analyzing our survey results, preliminary data from the Northeast showed an average farm size of 319 acres, 20 out of 79 farmers grow some annual crops for harvest or grazing, 41 out of 79 farmers feed an energy supplement at least occasionally, 66% farmers do intensive grazing, 15% farmers have a more simple rotational system, and 19% farmers do little or no rotation/continuous grazing. Survey results are key to prioritize research and extension needs in the Northeast and Midwest and we will soon complete our survey analyses to incorporate in educational events and grant proposals. Objective 3: Verify and validate the priorities with team members and stakeholders, and begin a planning process for conducting integrated soil-forage-dairy research and extension programs via follow-up workshops. Our team conducted 2 workshops with the first being held in Madison (WI) and the second in Durham (NH). We brought together approximately 30 attendees including organic dairy farmers, scientists, graduate and undergraduate students, extension educators, and industry personnel (dairy consultants and nutritionists, milk processors employees, veterinarians). Based on the focus group and survey results, the workshops were done to streamline research topics for in-depth assessment and discussions to be used or not in grant proposals according to team expertise and farmers' priorities. Objective 4: Submit integrated proposal(s) to address the prioritized organic research and extension needs under the guidance of the Research and Extension Advisory Panel. To date our team submitted 2 integrated grant proposals to both ORG and OREI programs. The grant proposal titled "Developing advanced perennial legume-grass mixtures harvested as stored feeds to improve herd productivity and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions in organic dairies in the Northeast" (PI Andre Brito) was funded by the ORG program and activities are developing. The grant proposal "Managing positive feedbacks to optimize forage nutritive value and soil health on organic dairy farms" (PI Richard Smith) was submitted to the OREI program last year and despite not being recommended for funding, it was well received by the review panel who considered the proposal very good. Our team are encouraged by this positive review and will resubmit the grant proposal this coming funding cycle. We will continue pursuing other funding sources as well.

Publications