Source: TDA RESEARCH, INC. submitted to NRP
A REGENERABLE SORBENT FOR DEEP DESULFURIZATION OF ALPHA PINENE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1006783
Grant No.
2015-33610-23782
Cumulative Award Amt.
$500,000.00
Proposal No.
2015-03277
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2015
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2018
Grant Year
2015
Program Code
[8.1]- Forests & Related Resources
Recipient Organization
TDA RESEARCH, INC.
12345 WEST 52ND AVENUE
WHEAT RIDGE,CO 80033
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Crude Sulfated Turpentine (CST) is a by-product of the Kraft wood pulping process, and its derivatives (e.g., terpenes such as alpha pinene) are used as fragrances in commercial products ranging from cosmetics to detergents. They can also be, and are, catalytically transformed into valuable chemicals by hydrogenation, oxidation and isomerization reactions. However, turpentine and its derivatives contain small but significant quantities of sulfur, which degrades the potency of the pinenes used as fragrances. Sulfur is also a highly potent catalyst poison that deactivates the precious metal and metal oxide catalysts used in the conversion processes. Hence there is need to remove sulfur from CST and pinene fractions in order to convert CST a waste stream from paper mills into a value added product.TDA isdeveloping a new, high capacity, regenerable sorbent to remove sulfur species from alpha pinene, and potentially from other terpene derivatives as well so that they can beconverted into value added chemicals.In this SBIR Phase II project, we will scale-up both the sorbent preparation methods develope din Phase I and demonstrate the sorbent's performance in an integrated system to assess the full capabilities of the desulfurizer and to turn the concept into a practical device. We will also carry out a detailed engineering analysis to assess the overall efficiency, size and cost of the desulfurizer to provide to our partners in the fragrance industry.
Animal Health Component
40%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
40%
Developmental
40%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5110660200040%
5110660202060%
Goals / Objectives
TDA Research Inc. proposes to develop a new, high capacity, regenerable sorbent to remove sulfur species from alpha pinene, and potentially from other terpene derivatives as well. The sorbent will be capable of reducing the sulfur concentration of the pinene to sub ppm levels to improve product quality, and clean up the alpha pinene to meet the requirements of the downstream catalytic conversion processes that convert it into value added chemicals.The specific Phase II objectives include:Scale-up both the sorbent preparation methods and the size of the testing systemTest the sorbent through many cycles and more hours of use to demonstrate its life and durabilityDemonstrate the sorbent's performance in a sub-scale prototype unitIntegrate the desulfurization system design with the balance of plant, and carry out a detailed engineering analysis to assess the overall efficiency, size and cost of the desulfurizer
Project Methods
We will optimize the sorbent and improve their activity and sulfur adsorption capacity, and scale-up the production of the sorbent (producing large batches of materials using commercial preparation methodology). We will separately demonstrate performance (e.g., sulfur capacity, activity) and operational capabilities (e.g., life and durability) of the sorbent in a fixed bed breakthrough apparatus. We will design and fabricate a stand-alone desulfurization system that will continuously treat 10 g/min pinene (or other terpenes). We will obtain samples from commercial suppliers, such as IFF or SwathiOil and complete all the proof-of-concept demonstrations in the high fidelity prototype. We will likely carry out these tests at TDA (due to budget constraints), while the unit will be capable of operating under hazardous conditions at a plant site for any potential follow-on demonstrations with the customer.

Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/18

Outputs
Target Audience:The target market is the pine chemical industry and the suppliers of fragrances and flavors. It will also allow for crude sulfated turpentine (CST), a byproduct from paper mills to be used as a low-cost raw material in fragrance and flavor industry to produce fragrances and flavors that are used in cosmetics, personnel hygiene products such as soaps, detergents and shampoos. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? In the first year of the project, we accomplished: We modified the bench-scale test unit used in the Phase I tests We have introduced the capability of testing multiple sorbents beds to carry out continuous sulfur removal (one bed adsorbing, while the other one being regenerated). We also introduced the capability of analyzing the regeneration off-gas products to better identify sulfur species in the off-gas to take proper measures to its disposal. We tested various sorbents and screened them based on their performance (e.g., sulfur capacity, activity) and operational capabilities (e.g., life and durability). We designed a stand-alone desulfurization system that will continuously treat 100 g/min pinene (or other terpenes). Please note that this is 10X larger than what we planned in the Phase II proposal (due to the strong commercial interest in the technology, TDA decided to modify an existing unit that can treat a larger flow of pinene and CST, which will elevate the technical readiness level of the technology at the end of Phase II and make it more viable for transition to a commercial technology). We completed a Safe Operating Procedure and acquired all approvals from TDA Safety Officer to run the unit with commercial pinene fractions We obtained pinene and crude sulfate turpentine samples from Swathi Menthol Pinene with 20-50 ppmw of total sulfur Crude sulfate turpentine with 1,500 ppmw sulfur We completed the design of a proof-of-concept prototype unit We modified an existing test skid at TDA to treat 4 barrels of pinene and crude sulfate turpentin. In the second year, of the project we accomplished the following: We have built a regenerable test rig to fully demonstrate the concept We have obtained high and low sulfur piene samples from commercial sources We have carried out proof-of-concept tests to confirm that the commercial samples could be effectively desulfurized with the TDA process We completed an engineering analysis and estimate that the treatment cost (for pinene polishing - i.e., to reduce the sulfur content of low sulfur pinene) will be less than $8/ton

Publications


    Progress 09/01/17 to 08/31/18

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target market is the pine chemical industry and the suppliers of fragrances and flavors. It will also allow for crude sulfated turpentine (CST), a byproduct from paper mills to be used as a low-cost raw material in fragrance & flavor industry to produce fragrances and flavors that are used in cosmetics, personnel hygiene products such as soaps, detergents, shampoos, etc. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?With the build-up of the proof-of-concept demo unit is complete and having commercial pinene and crude sulfate turpentine samples acquired, TDA Research is ready to move into the demonstration task. We will evaluate the sorbent and system performance at commercially significant scale. We will complete multiple cycles tests to demonstrate the life of the sorbent. Based on the results, we will complete a comprehensive cost analysis to assess the techno-economic benefits of the new technology.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? In the first year of the project, we have the following accomplishments: We modified the bench-scale test unit used in the Phase I tests We have introduced the capability of testing multiple sorbents beds to carry out continuous sulfur removal (one bed adsorbing, while the other one being regenerated). We also introduced the capability of analyzing the regeneration off-gas products to better identify sulfur species in the off-gas to take proper measures to its disposal. We tested various sorbents and screened them based on their performance (e.g., sulfur capacity, activity) and operational capabilities (e.g., life and durability). We designed a stand-alone desulfurization system that will continuously treat 100 g/min pinene (or other terpenes). Please note that this is 10X larger than what we planned in the Phase II proposal (due to the strong commercial interest in the technology, TDA decided to modify an existing unit that can treat a larger flow of pinene and CST, which will elevate the technical readiness level of the technology at the end of Phase II and make it more viable for transition to a commercial technology). We completed a Safe Operating Procedure and acquired all approvals from TDA Safety Officer to run the unit with commercial pinene fractions We obtained pinene and crude sulfate turpentine samples from Swathi Menthol Pinene with 20-50 ppmw of total sulfur Crude sulfate turpentine with 1,500 ppmw sulfur We completed the design of a proof-of-concept prototype unit We modified an existing test skid at TDA to treat 4 barrels of pinene and crude sulfate turpentine In the second year, of the project we have accomplished the following: We have built a regenerable test rig to fully demonstrate the concept We have obtained high and low sulfur piene samples from commercial sources We have carried out proof-of-concept tests to confirm that the commercial samples could be effectively desulfurized with the TDA process We completed an engineering analysis and estimate that the treatment cost (for pinene polishing - i.e., to reduce the sulfur content of low sulfur pinene) will be less than $8/ton

    Publications


      Progress 09/01/16 to 08/31/17

      Outputs
      Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Tasks remaining include: Complete proof-of-concept demonstrations with the prototype unit using pinene acquired from commercial producers (September 2017). Carry out long duration tests to demonstrate life and durability. (September - December 2017) Based on the prototype evaluations carry out a detailed engineering analysis to estimate the size and capital and operating costs of the desulfurization system. (December 2017-May 2018)

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? In the first year of the project, we have the following accomplishments: We modified the bench-scale test unit used in the Phase I tests We have introduced the capability of testing multiple sorbents beds to carry out continuous sulfur removal (one bed adsorbing, while the other one being regenerated). We also introduced the capability of analyzing the regeneration off-gas products to better identify sulfur species in the off-gas so that it can be disposed of properly. We tested various sorbents and screened them based on their performance (e.g., sulfur capacity, activity) and operational capabilities (e.g., life and durability). We designed a stand-alone desulfurization system that will continuously treat 100 g/min pinene (or other terpenes). Please note that this is 10X larger than what we planned in the Phase II proposal. Due to the strong commercial interest in the technology, TDA decided to modify an existing unit that can treat a larger flow of pinene and CST. This demonstration will elevate the technical readiness level of the technology at the end of Phase II and make it more viable for transition to a commercial technology. We completed a Safe Operating Procedure and acquired all approvals from TDA Safety Officer to run the unit with commercial pinene fractions We obtained pinene and crude sulfate turpentine samples from Swathi Menthol Pinene with 20-50 ppmw of total sulfur Crude sulfate turpentine with 1,500 ppmw sulfur We completed the design of a proof-of-concept prototype unit We modified an existing test skid at TDA to treat 4 barrels of pinene and crude sulfate turpentine Since funding resumed in May 2017, we have the following accomplishments: We have produced commercial-scale 80L batches of sorbents for demonstration. We resumed durability testing on the bench-scale. We began initial shakedown of the commercial demonstration desulfurization system. We completed design work for modifications required to integrate the commercial demonstration unit for a field test with a commercial partner. This field-test will demonstrate sorbent and system durability.

      Publications


        Progress 09/01/15 to 08/31/16

        Outputs
        Target Audience:The target market is the pine chemical industry and the suppliers of fragrances and flavors. It will also allow for crude sulfated turpentine (CST) a byproduct from paper mills to be used a low cost raw material in fragrance & flavor industry to produce fragrances and flavors that are used in cosmetics, personnel hygiene products such as soaps, detergents, shampoos, etc. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?With the build-up of the proof-of-concept demo unit is complete and having commercial pinene and crude sulfate turpentine samples acquired, TDA Research is ready to move into the demonstration task. We will evaluate the sorbent and system performance at commercially significant scale. We will complete multiple cycles tests to demonstrate the life of the sorbent. Based on the results, we will complete a comprehensive cost analysis to assess the techno-economic benefits of the new technology.

        Impacts
        What was accomplished under these goals? In the first year of the project, we have the following accomplishments: We modified the bench-scale test unit used in the Phase I tests We have introduced the capability of testing multiple sorbents beds to carry out continuous sulfur removal (one bed adsorbing, while the other one being regenerated). We also introduced the capability of analyzing the regeneration off-gas products to better identify sulfur species in the off-gas to take proper measures to its disposal. We tested various sorbents and screened them based on their performance (e.g., sulfur capacity, activity) and operational capabilities (e.g., life and durability). We designed a stand-alone desulfurization system that will continuously treat 100 g/min pinene (or other terpenes). Please note that this is 10X larger than what we planned in the Phase II proposal (due to the strong commercial interest in the technology, TDA decided to modify an existing unit that can treat a larger flow of pinene and CST, which will elevate the technical readiness level of the technology at the end of Phase II and make it more viable for transition to a commercial technology). We completed a Safe Operating Procedure and acquired all approvals from TDA Safety Officer to run the unit with commercial pinene fractions We obtained pinene and crude sulfate turpentine samples from Swathi Menthol Pinene with 20-50 ppmw of total sulfur Crude sulfate turpentine with 1,500 ppmw sulfur We completed the design of a proof-of-concept prototype unit We modified an existing test skid at TDA to treat 4 barrels of pinene and crude sulfate turpentine

        Publications