Source: UNIV OF CALIFORNIA-SAN DIEGO submitted to NRP
DECIPHERING CONFORMATIONAL GATING IN ELECTRON TRANSFER IN BIOLOGICAL NITROGEN FIXATION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1005288
Grant No.
2015-67012-22895
Cumulative Award Amt.
$137,815.00
Proposal No.
2014-02080
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Dec 15, 2014
Project End Date
Dec 14, 2016
Grant Year
2015
Program Code
[A7201]- AFRI Post Doctoral Fellowships
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF CALIFORNIA-SAN DIEGO
9500 GILMAN DRIVE
LA JOLLA,CA 92093
Performing Department
Office of Contracts and Grants
Non Technical Summary
Maintaining the food supply for the steadily increasing human population represents one of the most important challenges for scientists today. The green revolution in the mid 20th century succeeded in improving crop yields, in large part through use of industrially produced ammonia (NH3) to make fertilizer. However, manufacturing NH3 for fertilizer represents a severe burden to the environment because the process releases large amounts of greenhouse gas. To find alternative methods of generating fertilizer and providing NH3to plants, researchers look for inspiration in biological NH3production by the enzyme nitrogenase.The overall goal of this project is to learn more about the mechanism of how nitrogenase converts atmospheric dinitrogen (N2) to NH3 under ambient conditions. The conversion requires multiple electron and proton transfers to N2. These transfers are highly regulated and one of the goals of this project is to determine how electron transfer is coordinated in nitrogenase.The investigation will be conducted using nitrogenase that was purified from two bacterial sources, Azotobacter vinelandii (Av-nitrogenase) and Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus (Gd-nitrogenase). Av- and Gd-nitrogenase are closely related on the phylogenetic tree, but previous work, particularly spectroscopic and biochemical characterization, has shown that there may be differences regarding the details of how the respective enzymes produce NH3. A key feature that enables both Av- and Gd- nitrogenase to reduce N2 to NH3 at room temperature and atmospheric pressure is the ability to coordinate an energetically unfavorable process (conversion of N2 to NH3) with an energetically favorable process (ATP hydrolysis). However, the structural features of nitrogenase that make this possible are not well understood. To shed light on this process I will undertake a structure-function analysis of amino acid residues from both Gd and Av-nitrogenase that I hypothesize are responsible for coordinating electron transfer with ATP hydrolysis. By undertaking this investigation in nitrogenase from both A. vinelandii and G. diazotrophicus I will be able to uncover general structural principles in nitrogeanse for this regulation mechanism.Furthermore, an additional goal of this project is to adopt known G. diazotrophicus genetic manipulation methods for use with Gd-nitrogenase. Since G. diazotrophicus features simpler genetics than A. vinelandii, the most commonly used nitrogenase model system, this method development will greatly facilitate future nitrogenase mutagenesis projects.Ultimately, this project may inspire the design of more efficient and green industrial N2 reduction catalysts that incorporate chemical features of the nitrogenase electron delivery pathway. In addition, results from this project may be useful in ongoing investigations that use G. diazotrophicus as natural fertilizer.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
4014010200050%
4014010104050%
Goals / Objectives
This project has two objectives: 1. To elucidate in atomic detail the protein-protein interactions between the nitrogenase component proteins, nitrogenase iron protein (FeP) and nitrogenase molybdenum iron protein (MoFeP), that are important in regulating nitrogenase electron transfer. Results from this investigation will lead to an understanding of how the series of events consisting of FeP binding to MoFeP, conformational change associated with the formation of the FeP-MoFeP complex and ATP hydrolysis lead to electron transfer to N2 during substrate reduction. 2. To characterize nitrogenase from the agriculturally important organism Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus at the molecular level and develop methods of G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase genetic manipulation. This part of the project will reveal structural and potential mechanistic differences between nitrogenase from two species, G. diazotrophicus and Azotobacter vinelandii, the most widely used nitrogenase model system. Furthermore, this project will overcome a major roadblock in nitrogenase research, which is generating mutations in polychromosomal A. vinelandii. Unlike A. vinelandii, G. diazotrophicus is monochromosomal and amenable to many common genetic manipulation techniques, which will result in the development facile mutagenesis methods.
Project Methods
Objective 1: To determine the mechanism of how electron transfer is controlled in nitrogenase, I will conduct a structure-function analysis and will generate a series of nitrogenase mutants. Two regions of nitrogenase will be targeted. The first is a coil region near the P-cluster (a Fe8S7 metal cluster) termed region 1, and the second area, termed region 2, is a helix near the FeMoco (a Fe7S9MoC metal cluster, which is the site of catalysis). Region 1 and region 2 potentially share similar mechanistic roles as they are above their respective metal center and on the protein surface. Thus, through interaction with FeP, region 1 and region 2 may alter the redox properties of their respective metal centers via subtle conformational changes.By making single and combination mutations in region 1 and 2, I will alter the protein-protein interactions formed between MoFeP and FeP. Depending on the nature of the mutation, I expect weakening or strengthening of the respective protein-protein interactions between MoFeP and FeP. This in turn will change the redox potential of the respective metal center which will lead to altered enzymatic and spectroscopic properties. These effects can be studied using biochemical, biophysical and spectroscopic methods. Specifically, product formation will be investigated using diverse protein turnover assays and the redox and electronic properties studied by EPR spectroscopy.Objective 2: I will undertake a thorough biochemical, biophysical and structural characterization of Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus (Gd) nitrogenase. Sequence alignment, specifically around the residues equivalent to Azotobacter vinelandii (Av) MoFeP region 1, and spectroscopic evidence suggest the electron transfer mechanism in A. vinelandii and G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase may not be conserved. Therefore, I will perform research that is analogous to that described in objective 1 and make mutations in the region of Gd-MoFeP that is homologous to Av-MoFeP region 1. Emphasis will be placed on structural characterization of Gd-nitrogenase in different oxidation states via X-ray crystallography. As part of this project I will develop methods for making site-specific mutations in G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase. These methods will be based on published methods for genetic manipulation in G. diazotrophicus. Since G. diazotrophicus is genetically much simpler than A. vinelandii, mutants can be made more readily. Method development will include designing plasmids for G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase mutagenesis, determining growth conditions for G. diazotrophicus harboring nitrogenase mutants and modifying known nitrogenase purification methods.Evaluation: I expect to complete the proposed work within two years. A critical part in achieving this goal, making the nitrogenase mutants for specific aim 1, has already been started. If portions of the project fall behind schedule, alternative routes for the examination of nitrogenase will be used. For example, alternative mutations can be made for objective 1 in regions 1 and 2, and multiple plasmid design and mutagenesis strategies have been described in the literature for G. diazotrophicus.Furthermore, I will be evaluated by my PI, Dr. F. A. Tezcan, who will assist me in careful formulation of experimental plans and alternative approaches, which will ensure the obtainment of meaningful and impactful results. Dr. Tezcan and I regularly go over short and long-term goals in weekly updates and formal bi-annual presentation. This process will ensure experimental progress during the NIFA funding period will be achieved.

Progress 12/15/14 to 12/14/16

Outputs
Target Audience:I communicated my research output to the scientific community through 3 publications in peer reviewed scientific journals, through a poster presentation at the 2016 spring annual meeting of the American Chemical Society, and an oral presentation to the biology department of California State University, East Bay in January 2016. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has provided me the opportunity to study the structure of a novel nitrogenase in an agriculturally relevant organism. The results of my work led to the discovery of conserved structural properties of nitrogenases, which has advanced the understanding of the enzymes's electron transfer mechanism. This work has aided my professional development since my coworkers and I were able to publish our results in a high-impact journal. More importantly, the outcome of my research has raised numerous additional questions regarding electron transfer in nitrogenase, questions I wish to answer in future research as an independent PI. Furthermore, the fellowship has contributed to my professional development since it enabled me to build contacts with other NIFA fellows, thereby greatly expanding my professional network. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?This work has been disseminated through publications in peer-reviewed scientific journals, a talk at California State University, East Bay, and a conference presentation at the Spring 2016 American Chemical Society national meeting. Furthermore, parts of this work were presented by an undergraduate student who was working under my supervision at the UC San Diego undergraduate research conference. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? To address questions asked in specific aim 1, I determined the binding mechanism of the nitrogenase component proteins FeP and MoFeP in the organism Azotobacter vinelandii (Av). This step in enzymatic turnover is critical to understanding controlled, conformationally gated electron transfer. The FeP binding mechanism has not been firmly established, and transition between the binding conformation (DG1) and the active conformation (DG2) may activate electron transfer. I demonstrated that disrupting FeP-MoFeP interactions in DG1 weakens the FeP binding affinity and lowers nitrogenase activity. However, ATP hydrolysis rates and the ATP hydrolyzed to electron transfer ratio are unaffected, demonstrating that disrupting FeP binding in DG1 does not affect subsequent electron transfer processes. These results are the first to provide direct evidence that FeP binding in DG1 is critical for nitrogenase activity. I propose that DG1 represents an encounter complex, which enables rapid FeP association to MoFeP, and increases the likelihood that collisions between FeP and MoFeP lead to productive electron transfer to substrate. Furthermore, the discovery that DG1 is functionally relevant suggests that the proposed electron transfer activation mechanism during transition from DG1 to DG2 is plausible. To advance specific aim 2, I adapted methods to culture Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus (Gd), and to express and purify Gd-nitrogenase in high yield. Using purified Gd-MoFeP, I solved its crystal structure and measured its electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectrum in both the reduced and oxidized state, addressing a main goal of the proposal. The structures revealed that the P-cluster of Gd-MoFeP undergoes redox dependent structural changes. Upon oxidation, the P-cluster rearranges and is reversibly coordinated by a Tyr residue. This stands in contrast to the structure of Av-MoFeP and that of other nitrogenases, which feature redox dependent coordination by a Ser ligand. The results of this investigation suggest that having a hard O-based redox active ligand is critical to nitrogenase function. The protein structures also suggest that redox dependent P-cluster rearrangement is conserved between nitrogensaes from different organisms. Furthermore, I started biochemical characterization of Gd-nitrogenase. The FeP-MoFeP binding affinity is weaker than in Av-nitrogenase, and the specific activity is lower. I also started developing cloning methods for generating site-specific mutations in the G. diazotrophicus chromosome by creating a G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase knockout strain in which the gene for the nitrogenase β- subunit is replaced by a kanamycin resistance cassette. This strain demonstrates that it is feasible to generate site specific G. diazotrophicus mutants and it will serve as a platform for making further β- subunit mutants.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Katz, F. E. H., Owens, C. P., Tezcan, F. A. (2016). Electron transfer reactions in biological nitrogen fixation. Isr. J. Chem. 56, 682-692
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2016 Citation: Owens, C. P., Katz, F. E. H., Carter, C. H., Oswald, V. F., Tezcan, F. A. (2016) Tyrosine-coordinated P-cluster in G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase: Evidence for the importance of O-based ligands in conformationally gated electron transfer. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 138, 10124-10127
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2017 Citation: Katz, F.E.H., Shi, X., Owens, C.P., Joseph, S., Tezcan, F.A., Determination of NTPase activities in the presence of labile phosphate compounds, Analytical Biochemistry (accepted)
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Owens, C. P., Katz, F. E. H., Carter, C. H., Tezcan, F. A. Protein-protein interactions in biological nitrogen fixation, Poster presented at the 251st ACS National Meeting, March 13-17, San Diego, CA


Progress 12/15/14 to 12/14/15

Outputs
Target Audience:My efforts were communicted to the scientific community through a publication in the Journal of the American Chemical Society. I also reached academic audiences at local universities (CSU San Bernardino, UC Irvine and Chapman University),where I presented my work. Furthermore, I presented my work toother NIFA post- and predoctoral fellows at the NIFA fellows meeting. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project provided opportunities to pursue novel research characterizingA. vinelandiiandG. diazotrophicusnitrogenase, and disseminate results of my work through publication and presentations. Furthermore, I was given the opportunity to supervise the work of an undergraduate student whose project was based on my research. The student investigated the hypothesis thatweakeningA. vinelandiinitrogenase encounter complex formation also alters downstream steps in nitrogenase turnover. The results of his research suggest that disrupting the encounter complex does not affect later stages of nitrogenase turnover. These resultsindicate that the respectiverolesof the encounter complex and the active complex in turnover are distinct. This work was presented at two undergraduate research conferences at UC San Diego. In addition to gaining mentorship experience,this project has given me the opportunity to develop my teaching skills by attending workshops at the UC San Diego Center for Teaching Excellence. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The work has been disseminated to the scientific community through 1 scientific publication in the Journal of the American Chemical Society. Furthermore, I presented my work to the chemistry/biochemistry departments of local universities (CSU San Bernardino, UC Irvine and Chapman University). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Plans for objective 1: 1) Investigate activation of electron transfer in A. vinelandii nitrogenase. To do so, I will generate mutations in the A. vinelandii FeP-MoFeP complex interface along the transition pathway between encounter complex and active complex. These mutations may disrupt activation of electron transfer and will determine if the electron transfer activation step occurs during transition from the encounter complex to the active complex. 2) Investigate the possibility that activation of electron transfer occurs exclusively in the active complex. To probe this possibility, I will generate mutations in the interface of the activated FeP-MoFeP complex and study their effects on enzymatic activity and electron transfer. Plans for objective 2: 1) Solve the G. diazotrophicus MoFeP crystal structure. 2) Investigate redox dependent structural changes surrounding the G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase P-cluster as part of a broader effort to characterize electron transfer between metal clusters during G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase turnover. 3) Determine the association mechanism between FeP and MoFeP in G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase, specifically if G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase forms a distinct encounter complex like A. vinelandii nitrogenase.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Accomplishments towards objective 1: Objective 1 of this project is to determine how protein-protein interactions between nitrogenase FeP and nitrogenase MoFeP in A. vinelandii enable electron transfer between the respective nitrogenase metal clusters. In this reporting period, I determined how FeP and MoFeP associate in the first step of A. vinelandii nitrogenase turnover. FeP forms an encounter complex with MoFeP that is stabilized by electrostatic interactions. Formation of this encounter complex is required for efficient nitrogenase turnover since disrupting the encounter complex weakens FeP association to MoFeP and lowers nitrogenase activity. The encounter complex is structurally distinct from the catalytically active nitrogenase complex, suggesting that FeP undergoes a large conformation change between encounter complex and active complex. The results of this investigation raise the possibility that electron transfer between the nitrogenase metal clusters is activated as part of the transition between encounter complex and active complex. Accomplishments towards objective 2: Objective 2 of this project is to characterize nitrogenase from the organism G. diazotrophicus. During this reporting period, I optimized protocols to maximize nitrogenase expression in G. diazotrophicus laboratory growths, and I modified G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase purification methods. I have started G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase MoFeP crystallization trials to determine its protein structure. Furthermore, I have begun comparing the mechanism of G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase turnover with that of A. vinelandii nitrogenase using enzymatic assays with G. diazotrophicus nitrogenase.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2015 Citation: Owens, C. P., Katz, F. E. H., Carter, C. H., Luca, M. A., Tezcan, F. A. (2015). Evidence for functionally relevant encounter complexes in nitrogenase catalysis. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 137, 12704-12712