Source: Enertechnix, Inc. submitted to NRP
ADVANCED CONTROL SYSTEM FOR BIOMASS COMBUSTION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1005098
Grant No.
2014-33610-22601
Cumulative Award Amt.
$449,980.00
Proposal No.
2014-02560
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2014
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2016
Grant Year
2014
Program Code
[8.1]- Forests & Related Resources
Recipient Organization
Enertechnix, Inc.
PO Box 469
Maple Valley,WA 98038
Performing Department
Research and Development
Non Technical Summary
Combustion of biomass, especially in small-scale applications, produces high emissions of particulate matter (PM) that have been linked to adverse health effects and global climate change. Current industrial particulate control solutions are prohibitively expensive for use in small scale biomass burners. To overcome these challenges, inexpensive and effective combustion control solutions for small scale applications are needed. The proposed intelligent combustion control system for biofuel combustion in small scale applications can curb PM and gaseous emissions. If successful, the proposed pollution control system will be a disruptive technology and will be low cost enough to be implemented in thousands of small scale installations.
Animal Health Component
75%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
25%
Applied
75%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
13304102020100%
Knowledge Area
133 - Pollution Prevention and Mitigation;

Subject Of Investigation
0410 - Air;

Field Of Science
2020 - Engineering;
Goals / Objectives
The proposed project will demonstrate the feasibility of developing an intelligent combustion control module to maximize the efficiency of biomass combustion while minimizing emissions of PM, CO, UHC and NOx. Our hypothesis is that by measuring the temperature, levels of main combustion product species, and particulate matter, a predictive model can be developed to intelligently control combustion of biomass fuels of varying composition, moisture content, and formats. This is possible due to a combination of recent advances in sensor development and implementation of novel modeling techniques, e.g. (i) real-time exhaust measurements using low cost sensors, (ii) real-time prediction of combustor conditions using CRN (chemical reactor network) modeling, and (iii) an intelligent combustion control algorithm for minimizing pollutant emissions and maximizing combustor efficiency. Development of an intelligent combustion control system relies on the ability of the CRN to model combustion processes in the critical pollution formation zones in the biomass combustor. A CRN model will be constructed based on the results of CFD simulations; the CRN model will establish the degree of modeling complexity (detailed chemistry and network arrangement) needed to predict the emissions. A combustion control algorithm for reduction of PM2.5 and NOx emission will be developed; this algorithm will be applicable to a wide variety of biofuels. The algorithm will (i) record sensor measurements, (ii) interpret inputs using a predictive CRN model, and (iii) adjust the wood burner controls to minimize pollution formation. This control strategy will be implemented in a commercially available biomass combustion system.Phase II will be focused on achieving the following technical objectives:1. CRN Optimization and Validation for a Variety of Fuels and Burn Scenarios2. Experimental Model Validation3. Sensor Package Ruggedization4. Automated Control Algorithm Development and System IntegrationExtensive Laboratory Testing using the GCE Platform
Project Methods
Task1 CRN Optimization using Computational Fluid Dynamic SimulationIn Phase II we will employ a CFD-CRN methodology in which detailed CFD simulations will be used to guide the development of a much more complete CRN model. Similar to previously developed CRNs for other biomass combustion the furnace will be subdivided into zones based on the characteristic chemical process prevailing in those regions, such as: main flame, recirculation zone, over-fire air zone, and a burnout zone. The overall approach involves first developing a CFD model of the combustor. The resulting flow field, temperature field, and reaction rate field are used to develop the CRN model that includes the detailed chemistry, including the trace pollutant species that are the target of the work.The CFD model focuses on the fluid dynamics. For this portion of the work, we will not develop a coupled wood devolatilization/volatile flame model due to the complexity associated with the two-way coupling between the hot flame gases and the wood (this complexity arises principally due to the complex reaction/transport processes inside the large pieces of wood). Instead, we will use measured devolatilization rates (via weight loss) to treat the wood surface as a boundary condition for the gas-phase CFD calculation. Since the principal output of the CFD work is the CRN model, this approximation is both appropriate and also more accurate than trying to include the very problematic solids-gas coupling.The successful outcome of this task would be development of a fast predictive CRN scheme that captures air recirculation mechanism and can be applied for flaming and smoldering combustion regimes. This task may be complicated by the effects of different wood composition and moisture content, wood shape and size, and different pyrolysis and tar oxidation chemistry.Task 2: Experimental Model ValidationIn this task, we will use state-of-the-art combustion diagnostic instruments at UW combustion facility to obtain additional information about the combustion process. The stack measurements from our low-cost sensor array will be compared to the boiler gas, particle and 3-D temperature profile scans. A GCE biomass boiler will be installed at the UW Combustion lab. The boiler will be modified in order to perform probe measurement and visual inspection of the boiler cavity. Optical access to the combustion cavity will provide flow field visualization and visual identification of burn stages: ignition, smoldering or flaming combustion, char oxidation stage.A gas sample probe will be inserted into the boiler though an array of ports; the position of the probe will be varied to cover the entire 3-dimensional space of the combustion cavity and cover all of the combustion zones (pyrolysis layer, main flame, burn out zone and exhaust stack). Suction pyrometry will be used for gas measurements.Temperature measurements will be performed using several thermocouples: the wall temperature will be measured by thermocouples embedded into the refractory lining. Shielded thermocouples will be used for gas temperature measurements.The measurements obtained in the biomass combustor will be used to validate the CFD simulations and guide the CRN development. A successful outcome for this task will be to obtain measurements of particulate and CO emissions for several burn scenarios, capturing high-PM and CO-emission events in-situ.Task 3 Sensor Package Optimization and RuggedizationThe existing field prototype of the system relies on low cost measurements of CO and particulate matter concentration in the combustion exhaust stack and temperature in the relevant combustion zones. A sample-dilution system was built in order to operate gas and PM sensors in their linear regimes. The sample and dilution air flows are metered by small stainless steel tubing with suction for both lines provided by a small diaphragm pump. One of the most important tasks is to optimize this dilution system; this task will include extensive testing of small diameter flow metering tubes in high particle loading environments. Several different flow metering schemes such as venturi pumps and limiting orifices will be tested at a variety of flow rates providing dilution ratios in the 1:10 to 1:200 range. Several exhaust dilution system prototypes will be built and their fouling propensity in the particle laden exhaust gas will be evaluated. Repeatability and fouling propensity of the sensing module will also be evaluated.The performance of the ruggedized sensor arrays will be tested in a combustion environment to provide information about sensor-to-sensor measurement repeatability, sensor longevity in the particle laden environment, and the need to use filters and water traps.A successful outcome for this task will be low (preferably no)-maintenance operation of the dilution and sensing systems for periods consistent with end-user needs.Task 4 Automated Control Algorithm Development and System IntegrationIn the Phase 1 project we have manually operated the GCE biomass burner air-staging to influence the CO and PM emissions. It was found that algorithms based solely on temperature are limited in predicting and controlling combustion in a complex-burn situation; in particular, we have identified two specific scenarios that lead to very high emissions and low combustion efficiencies due to the incomplete pyrolysis and combustion in the primary flame zone.Optimization algorithm: Spatial information needed to optimize the combustion cannot be obtained from global temperature measurements; however it is available as an output of the CRN model. The complete species, temperature and combustion rate information from the wood pyrolysis, flame, and burnout zones will be analyzed by the algorithm and optimized to control air staging (controlled by three independent solenoid valves) and overall flow rate (controlled by the fan speed). The input to the model will be based on the real-time flow conditions and sensors (CO, PM and Temperature) input. The primary output of the algorithm will be correction to the fan speed and the opening or closing of the solenoid valves for introduction of primary and secondary air resulting in adjustment of the combustion air staging.The algorithm will be integrated with the existing temperature-based control algorithm used in the GCE burner. GCE will assist with integration of the newly developed software and their air-staging and fan speed controls.A successful outcome for this task will be implementation of a sensor-based control algorithm in the GCE biomass burner to control combustion air staging.Task 5 Extensive Laboratory Testing using GCE PlatformThe integrated algorithm will be extensively tested with variety of fuels, fuel form factors and fuel moisture levels. The testing will be performed at UW facility using an instrumented GCE biomass test unit (see task 2). At a minimum, the test will include the following wood species and formats: (1) Oak crib (2) Oak logs (3) Douglas fir crib 4) Douglas fir Logs. These two wood species are significantly different with respect to their composition and represent two different geographic regions of the US.A successful outcome for this task will be (i) maintenance-free operation of the unit for extended periods and (ii) the ability of the algorithm to optimize combustion of multiple wood species, form factors and moisture contents.

Progress 09/01/14 to 08/31/16

Outputs
Target Audience:In this project we have collaborated with professionals pursuing cleaner burning and more efficient biomass-fueled hydronic heaters. Specifically, we have worked with combustion scientists and engineers and equipment manufacturers at Greenwood Clean Energy, Inc. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?As part of this project and in collaboration with the University of Washington, an ExperimentalBiomass Reactor was designed and installed at UW in the Lab for Energy and Environmental Combustion. Three graduate students worked with analytical models and experimental hardware, advancing skills in mechanical design, combustion analysis, computational fluid dymanics, and instrumentation andtest. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Testing and results have been shared with our collaborators at Greenwod Clean Energy. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? IMPACT Combustion of biomass, especially in small-scale applications, produces high emissions of particulate matter (PM) that havebeen linked to adverse health effects and global climate change. Current industrial particulate control solutions areprohibitively expensive for use in small scale biomass burners. To overcome these challenges, inexpensive and effectivecombustion control solutions for small scale applications are needed. The intelligent combustion control system underdevelopment for biofuel combustion in small scale applications can curb PM and gaseous emissions. Further research is required, but oncesuccessfully developed, theproposed pollution control system will be a disruptive technology and will be low cost enough to be implemented in thousandsof small scale installations. OBJECTIVES 1. CRN Optimization and Validation for a Variety of Fuels and Burn Scenarios An ExperimentalBiomass Reactor (XBR) was designed, fabricated, and instrumented to allow for validation of combustion models and control algorithms. This combustor consists of an Inconel lower firebox and a 316 stainless steel upper column. Primary Air, Secondary Air, Fuel and dilution fuel flow rates are actuated with mass flow controllers via a LabVIEW interface. A number of ports at various locations are available for the installation thermocouples and gas analyzer probes. A CRN model for the reactor was generated and Computational Fluid Dynamics models of the system were created, processed and evaluated with ANSYS Fluent CFD Software. An algorithm incorporating feed forward and feedback control wasimplemented and subjected totesting. 2. Experimental Model Validation A number of experiments wereconducted with gaseous fuels to characterize concentrations of oxygen, CO, and CO2 at various combustion conditions. 3. Sensor Package Ruggedization In order to sense CO, a sensor system based on a pellistor was assembled and tested. This sensor package is able to track concentration levels that are generally present in residential wood boiler (based on the Greenwood boiler). It is also able to function at temperatures of at least 400 F. The sensor was installed in a Greenwood hydronic boiler along with a Bacharach combustion analyzer and it was observed that the sensor provided an output that tracked closely with the Bacharach CO measurements. Calibration tests wereconducted, as were tests to characterize sensor output with CO concentrations. Fouling tests over a number of days were alsoconducted with the sensor package. Some performancedeterioration was observed due to particulate contamination, but the sensor was able to be reconditioned by heating the sensor. The sensors own heating element was used in the reconditioning process. 4. Automated Control Algorithm Development and System Integration Control schemes were testing utilizing the Experimental Biomass Reactor at the University of Washington.Experimental sensors were partially integrated inGreenwood Clean Energyboiler. 5. Extensive Laboratory Testing using the GCE Platform A number of initial tests wereconducted in the GCE boiler to evaluate sensor performance and longevity. While initial tests showed little degradation in sensor performance with exposure to the combustor environment, subsequentlonger term testing showed more significant degradation. We were able to recondition the sensors to achieve improve performance.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/14 to 08/31/15

    Outputs
    Target Audience:In the first year of the project we have collaborated with professionals pursuing cleaner burning and more efficient biomass-fueled hydronic heaters. Specifically, we have worked with combustion scientists and engineers and equipment manufacturers at Greenwood Clean Energy, Inc. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?As part of this project and in collaboration with the University of Washington, an experimental burn reactor has been designed and installed at UW in the Lab for Energy and Environmental Combustion. Three graduate students are actively working with analytical models and experimental hardware, advancing skills in mechanical design, combustion analysis, computational fluid dynamics, and instrumentation and test. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Testing and results have been shared with our collaborators at Greenwood Clean Energy. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the upcoming months, we plan to continue to test and develop a rugged CO sensor and incorporate the output into the control system of a GCE boiler. Longer term testing in the boiler will be conducted to evaluate and optimize the life of this sensor.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? IMPACT Combustion of biomass, especially in small-scale applications, produces high emissions of particulate matter (PM) that have been linked to adverse health effects and global climate change. Current industrial particulate control solutions are prohibitively expensive for use in small scale biomass burners. To overcome these challenges, inexpensive and effective combustion control solutions for small scale applications are needed. The intelligent combustion control system under development for biofuel combustion in small scale applications can curb PM and gaseous emissions. If successful, the proposed pollution control system will be a disruptive technology and will be low cost enough to be implemented in thousands of small scale installations. OBJECTIVES 1. CRN Optimization and Validation for a Variety of Fuels and Burn Scenarios An experimental burn reactor has been designed, fabricated, and instrumented to allow for validation of combustion models and control algorithms. This combustor consists of an Inconel lower firebox and a 316 stainless steel upper column. Primary Air, Secondary Air, Fuel and dilution fuel flow rates are actuated with mass flow controllers via a LabVIEW interface. A number of ports at various locations are available for the installation thermocouples and gas analyzer probes. A CRN model for the reactor has been generated and Computational Fluid Dynamics models of the system have been created, processed and evaluated with ANSYS Fluent CFD Software. An algorithm incorporating feed forward and feedback control has been implemented and subjected to initial testing. 2. Experimental Model Validation A number of experiments have been conducted with gaseous fuels to characterize concentrations of oxygen, CO, and CO2 at various combustion conditions. 3. Sensor Package Ruggedization In order to sense CO, a sensor system based on a pellistor has been assembled and tested. This sensor package is able to track concentration levels that are generally present in residential wood boiler (based on the Greenwood boiler). It is also able to function at temperatures of at least 400F. The sensor has been installed in a Greenwood hydronic boiler along with a Bacharach combustion analyzer and it was observed that the sensor provided an output that tracked closely with the Bacharach CO measurements. Initial calibration tests have been conducted, and tests continue to characterize sensor output with CO concentrations. Fouling tests over a number of days have also been conducted with the sensor package. No deterioration has been observed due to particulate contamination, but more life testing is needed to assess long term reliability 4. Automated Control Algorithm Development and System Integration Control schemes for integration into the Greenwood boiler have been discussed, but not yet implemented or tested. 5. Extensive Laboratory Testing using the GCE Platform A number of initial tests have been conducted in the GCE boiler to evaluate performance and longevity.

    Publications