Source: USDA, ARS - SC.W(29501-1242) submitted to NRP
ENHANCING BOTH SOIL CARBON SEQUESTRATION AND FERTILITY WHILE REDUCING SOIL GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS THROUGH DESIGNER BIOCHAR APPLICATION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1003011
Grant No.
2014-35615-21971
Cumulative Award Amt.
$110,000.00
Proposal No.
2014-02114
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 15, 2014
Project End Date
Jul 14, 2018
Grant Year
2014
Program Code
[A3161]- Interagency Climate Change NASA
Recipient Organization
USDA, ARS - SC.W(29501-1242)
2611 West Lucas Street
Florence,SC 29501-1242
Performing Department
Coastal Plain Research Center
Non Technical Summary
Project summary--In the near future, agricultural production will need to be intensified to provide the world's burgeoning population with sustainable food and fiber supplies utilizing the same or smaller land base. Intensification of agricultural production is known to increase soil erosion, loss of soil organic carbon (SOC), and heightened uses of fertilizer resulting in a strong potential of soil and atmospheric degradation. As a countermeasure to these agronomic and environmental issues, the application of biochar to soils is widely discussed as a potential mitigation tool. Biochar is hypothesized to be capable of rebuilding soil quality, binding with organic amendments, and reducing greenhouse gas (e.g., CO2, CH4, N2O) emissions, however, universal guidelines for its use as a soil amendment and climate mitigation tool are lacking. Biochars' performance as a soil amendment has so far been evaluated under regional-specific land uses, crop management, and soils possessing heterogeneous characteristics. This approach has lead to the development of fragmented biochar policy and management platforms relevant to these regions, but lacking a holistic vision. Due to the immense complexity in soils and biochar types, our ability to predict these beneficial effects in different soils and land uses across the globe is currently limited. A preferred pathway is to design biochars that have properties tailored to improve specific soil conditions. The designer biochar concept has been often discussed among researchers, but guidelines for its creation and use are still in its infancy. The approach of designing biochars for specific soil purposes requires the scientific exchange of biochar performance results and information between scientists, stakeholders, and collaborators. Creating a worldwide scientific biochar exchange network through this designchar4food (D4F) proposal, will allow the development of suitable biochar management strategies at regional levels to be evaluated and integrated into a coherent global policy platform that sustains agricultural productivity and food security. The aim of this DF4 proposal is to create a biochar guidance plan for the production of well defined biochars with suitable properties. In this plan, forums will be proposed whereby scientists, stakeholders, and potential users from across the globe can share their scientific results, discuss new approaches, and develop plans to commercially produce, and evaluate designer biochars. These forums will be facilitated by annual biochar workshops, monthly teleconferences (webinars), specialized web-based databases, email list servers, brochures, and newsletters to insure that results are shared among scientists, biochar users, commercial manufacturers, and policy makers. Integral to this effort is the development of a computer based model capable of predicting environmental and agricultural responses of biochar use in soils across the globe. Synthesis of this global biochar data will provide numerous synergistic relationships to be developed, such as with the Global Research Alliance (GRA) to include designer biochar as one possible mitigation management tool as we strive for sustainable environmental stewardship.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
25%
Developmental
25%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
10201102000100%
Knowledge Area
102 - Soil, Plant, Water, Nutrient Relationships;

Subject Of Investigation
0110 - Soil;

Field Of Science
2000 - Chemistry;
Goals / Objectives
1. Coordinate, and integrate detached soil, agronomic, and biogeochemical results, data pools, and most recent insights related to biochars use as an effective soil amendment and greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction agent.2. Design and assess agronomic, commercial, and technological solutions to compose custom-design biochars that may enhance soil fertility, improve water retention, and cause a reduction in GHG emissions.3. Determine how biochar interacts with soil minerals and organic compartments in soils and how these interactions can be altered by land use changes from forest/pastures to cropland or with changes in soil conditions due to climate variability.4. Transfer project knowledge gains directly to farmers, stakeholders, andGlobal Research Alliance teams, through workshops,newsletters and development of 'iCHARnet'.5. Establish travel locations and schedule dates for a kickoff, mid-term, and final workshop scheduled to coincide with national and international biochar, agricultural, and environmental meetings.
Project Methods
A. Scientists in the USDA-ARS- The USDA-ARS has scientists skilled in biochar manufacture and assessment of its reactions in soils. Moreover, these scientists have access to many types of lignocellulosic- and manure-based feedstocks. The varieties of feedstocks are readily available from field crop research projects as well as cooperators. Feedstocks and their blends can be pre processed using chippers and pelletizer prior to 'in-house' pyrolysis. Blending the feedstocks and pre-processing them into different particle sizes are some of the key components available to manufacture designer biochars. These feedstocks can then be pyrolyzed between 300 to 700°C with a Lindburg pyrolyzer. Capabilities also exist with ARS colleagues to include biochars evaluation at both small and large scales experiments under a variety of row, grain, and biofuel crop production scenarios. In these experiments, they are measuring CO2 N2O and CH4 gas fluxes under laboratoryand field conditions. A more aggressive approach with evaluating biochars impact on soil GHG production/consumption is being conducted by Dr. Spokas and Venterea at the USDA-ARS-St. Paul location. Within the ARS-St. Paul location, there are four separate GHG monitoring GC systems available, which are capable of analyzing over 650 samples per day.G.2. Participants from Spain: The Spanish D4F participants consist of two separate research institutions. The first team is from the IRNAS center. This facility is a center of the Spanish Science Research Council (CSIC), a self governing body responsible to the Spanish Government. The service units include a research station with an area of 40 ha. The different soil types, its facilities for different irrigation and tillage practices, and the existing herbaceous and woody crops, representative of those in the area, make the farm of great utility for the development of many research projects. The technical assistance of IRNAS performs numerous analytical determinations of soils, plants, waters, fertilizers, and residues, and provides advice both for internal projects and the request of farmers and agro-alimentary firms in the region. The IRNAS team is formed by scientists from the Agrochemistry and Soil Conservation department, with expertise in different aspects of soil science and surface chemistry. The IRNAS center also has access to organic residues from agricultural origin feedstock such as rice hulls and olive mill waste, the latter generated in large amounts and in a short period of time, thus representing a major environmental issue. The effect of these residues on pesticide fate has been investigated under laboratory and field conditions. Specific surface area and porosity measurements of the generated biochars and biochar mixtures are available, as well as FT-IR, fluorescence spectroscopy and NMR techniques for biochar characterization, especially its soluble fraction. The second D4F team from Spain is located at the University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU) and is composed of three senior researchers (Dr. C González-Murua, Dr. JM Estavillo and Dr. MB González-Moro) and two postdoctoral researchers (Dr. S Menendez and Dr. T Fuertes-Mendizabal). Their main research is focused on the "Efficiency of Nitrogen in Agro-Forest systems (production, quality and minimization of the environmental impact)", studying in depth the fundamentals of metabolic and physiological aspects in plants in order to help decide agronomic measures in relation to the rational use of fertilizers and phyto-sanitary products. The UPV/EHU team has the capability of developing experiments to evaluate biochar at different scales (laboratory, greenhouse and field) given different aspects of biochar response (plant physiological, crop yield and quality response, and GHG emissions response). Regarding analytical instrumentation, the general techniques of a plant physiology laboratory are available with specific facilities for metabolites, enzyme activities and gene-expression determinations. An IRGA (Infra Red Gas Analysis) equipment is available (LICOR LI-6400XT) for the measurement of photosynthesis-related gas exchange parameters (CO2 assimilation and transpiration rates) by which the effect of biochar on plant water availability (water use efficiency) can be measured. For the determination of GHG emissions after biochar application in either laboratory, greenhouse or field experiments, CO2, N2O and CH4 emissions can be determined both by means of a Phytoaccoustic Multi-gas Monitor (INNOVA-1312)or by means of a Gas-Chromatograph (Agilent, 7890A) equipped with an electron capture detector for N2O detection and a flame ionization detector for CH4.G.3. Participants from Germany: Scientists from the Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH (FZJ) have the technical knowledge and analytical capabilities to be active partners in the D4F proposal. They have a multi-faceted approach for carbon and nitrogen dynamics in soil-plant-atmosphere interactions. Overall, their research is categorized into three areas: 1) Modelling of Terrestrial Systems, 2) Environmental Processes and Technologies, and 3) Terrestrial Biogeochemistry. Research to assess environmental processes is conducted at small and large scales that require usage of sophisticated analytical equipment including Nuclear Magnetic Resonance or Electromagnetic Induction spectroscopy. The Rhine-Waal University of Applied Sciences is a young university that has only last year moved to its modern campus with state-of-the-art labs and a high-tech greenhouse with chambers allowing controlled temperature from temperate to tropical conditions. Dr. Nicole Wrage-Moennig is a specialist on measuring N2O production and differentiating among its soil sources. Furthermore, her interest lies in understanding the relations between climatic changes and conditions of production, including microbial and plant biodiversity. The group at this university is well equipped for measuring CO2, NH3, N2O and CH4 emissions as well as soil fertility in incubation, greenhouse, and field studies. The research group at Justus-Liebig University Giessen (Dr. C. Kammann) has access to the full range of field and laboratory facilities (including growth chambers and open-top chambers for elevated CO2 experiments) to conduct biochar incubation and field studies. An active biochar program exists at the Institute with (currently) four large-scale, long-term biochar field studies in sandy SOC poor soil, loamy fertile soil, and poorly-drained clay soils using the same EBC-certified biochar; the fourth experiment takes places place in grassland, mimicking Chernozem (Mollisol) formation, and a fifth field experiment in Hessian pine-hornbeam forest periodically prone to drought stress will commence in winter 2013/2014. At their facility, analytical instruments for their research includes gas chromatography analyses for GHG, soil N dynamics, and methods to measure the full range of plant-soil variables, and interactions in the field (C/N analyser, plant physiological equipment, automated chambers for soil respiration, etc.). The group has a long-history of the development of stable isotope tracing tools, including the development and analytical capabilities via process-based numerical models that allow for quantifying gross rather than net N transformations and the origin of N2O emissions. The group is also experienced in adapting standardized biological test procedures (DIN-ISO-VDI) for biochar testing to assess risks, potential and functional mechanisms of the effects of biochars on plant performance; and the group is well connected to a number of German (speaking) biochar producers, stakeholders, and users.

Progress 07/15/14 to 07/14/18

Outputs
Target Audience:The Designchar4food (d4f) research project terminated this month. In the past 12 months, we had three exchanges for presenting our results. They include the following: 1. Final meeting of the d4f project participants at the 2017 American Society of Agronomy annual meeting in Tampa FL. We discussed the need to follow up on data interpretation for a biochar:nitrous oxide meta-analysis and for thu use of nitrification inhibitors on reducing nitrous oxide formation. One of these papers is currently under preparation while the other has been submitted for publication. 2. Participated in a USDA-ARS-Biochar roadmap held in June in Chicago. the meeting was attended by two program staff leadfers and several ARS scientists, and biochar users. The purpose of the workshop was to discuss the future of biochar funding by the agency and the potential use of 'CHARnet' as a program to increase communication and participation in biochar project by ARS scientists and colleagues. CHARnet was one of the final products from the d4f project. 3. Provided technical advice to Ms. Chaden Diyab, Secretariat of the Joint Programing Initiative on Agriculture, Food Security and Climate Change (FACCE-JPI) to valorize research results from the d4f project. Technical advice was provided to determine how our projectsbiochar results had an impact on soil carbon sequestration and nitrous oxide formation. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The d4f project offered the opportunity for members of the project to openly discuss their research results, assist in data inperpretation, shared analytical insturments, and co-author manuscripts. These excercises increased the professional development of project participants by being introduced to advanced statistics and laboratory sorption methods. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The d4f results were dessiminated to the following individuals/groups; 1. Both national and international scientists in Spain, Germany, and Switzerland. 2. The results were used by the FACCE-JPI community to determine if the designer biochar technology was useful to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It has the potential of being one of the guidelines for countries to reduce gas emissions in Europe. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal 1 was achieved by d4f team members conducting a meta analysis of existing literature to determine biochar impacts on nitrous oxide formation. It was found that biochar did reduce nitrous oxide formation in 38% of the published studies. Goal 2 was accomplished by the finding that biochar was able to sorb N and reduce nitrous oxide formation. This means that more N was available for plant uptake. Goal 3 was not achieved because there was insufficient time to conduct this research. Goal 4 was achieved because d4f scientists communicated and worked under the CHARnet program. Goal 5 was achieved because a begining, mid-point and final meeting were schedule among d4f participants.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Mehmood, K., et al. 2017. Biochar research activities and their relation to development and environmental quality. A meta-analysis. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 37:22, doi 10.1007//s13593-017-0430-1. Kammann C., et al. 2017. Biochar as a tool to reduce the agricultural greenhouse=gas burden-knowns, unknowns, and future research needs. J. Environ. Eng. Land. Manage. 25:114-139. doi10.3846/16486897.2017.1319375. 3. Two more manuscripts are under submission for publication for late 2018.


Progress 07/15/16 to 07/14/17

Outputs
Target Audience:The tarrget auidence reached by the d4f project included the following: 1. University and federal scientists at the European Geophysical Union meeting (April, 2017) in Vienna. 2. Scientists at international universities including Germany and Spain at the European Geophysical Union meeting. 3. Presented d4f project results to FACCE_JPI officials at Valorization workshop (March 2017) in Brussels. Changes/Problems:The project invistigator (myself) will have to provide a detailed project report to the FACCE_JPI echleons in Summer 2018. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The results have been disseminated to the interested communities through journal publications, scientific meetingsand FACCE-JPI sponsored workshops. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Publish three more journal articles outlining biochars ability to act as a fertilizer, interaction with N, and reduction in N2O production. All three of these topics are listed under project goals.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. Results from joint collaboration resulted in two journal publications that meets goals 1 and 2 as mentioned above. 2. Currently, finishing data interpretation for meta analysis of biochars impact on N2O production as per goal 2. 3. Completing laboratory experiments detailing N interaction with biochar per goal 2 and 3. 4. The d4f project participants meet at the EGU meeting in April 2017 to discuss meeting project goals and future paper publications. 5. Rec'd a no-cost extension for d4f grant until July 2018.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: 1. J. Environmental Engineering and Landscape Management 25:(02) 114-139. doi.org/10.3846/16486897.2017.1319375 2. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 2017 37:22 doi 10.1007/s13593-017-0430-1


Progress 07/15/15 to 07/14/16

Outputs
Target Audience:The target auidence is international university scientists and several scientists of the USDA-ARS. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has taught several members how to conduct a metaanalysis and statistical analyses of previously published results. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?No results have been distributed because they results are still being analyzed. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will continue to discuss our individual research measurements and develop procedures to statistically analyzed previously published data. Additionally, we will explain our methods for two laboratory experiments and how we will conduct the research investigation. It is important that we continue to dialogue between scientists so that we do not lose sight of our milestones and make sure that we deliver on our products.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We have accomplished the following in the 2015 to 2016 year: 1. developed a meta analysis of biochar literature on greenhouse gas emissions and nitrate movement, 2. produced biochars with special properties and characterized the biochar surface chemistry 3. coordinated two laboratory experiments between scientists from the USDa and Europe, 4. started to compose two biochar publications using the biochar meta analysis data, 5. monthly skype meetings between designchar4food are held to coordinate research work and publications, 6. began planning a special biochar session at the EGU meeting in Austria for 2017 to discuss final results from this project.

Publications


    Progress 07/15/14 to 07/14/15

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Our target auidence for this rating period spanned contacts with national and international scientists, biochar producers, USEPA scientists, members of NIFA-program staff, andbiochar users (golf courses, small farmers). Changes/Problems:1. We have found that many scientific articles on biochar impact of GHG production do not list key biochar characteristics. In fact, we have had to modify our protocols (e.g., mechanisms of biochar production, etc.) because of insufficient information.Wewill have to adjust our expectations and accept a few number of articles. In fact, wemay have to improvise our approach and accept newbiochar conditions (different pyrolysis temperatures). We may even have to focus only on 1 GHG like CO2 instead of N2O due to insufficient information. this remains to be seen. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has provided training with using software to transfer large meta analysis files across the internet. The project also has caused USDA participants to complete the AfgLearn training module for teleworking basics. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We plan of the following: Continue to dialogue with among the d4f teamates via Skype and at scientific meetings to complete the metaanalyis, Synthesize the metaanalysis results to arrive at key biochar characteristc to complete the designer biochar protocols and guidelines, Produce designer biochars and concieve a cross-ocean biochar experiment with European d4f teammates, Conduct lab and greenhouse experiments using designer biochars.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? For goal 1, scientists on the desigchar4food (d4f) project haveaccomplished a meta-analysis for biochars involvement with greenhouse gas (GHG, CO2, N2O, etc.) production using results published fromseveral hundred journal articles (spanning 2010 to 2015).Members of the d4f team from Spain and Germany set up a spread sheet listing critical biochar characteristics(pyrolysis temperature, pH, etc.) that impactGHGproduction/remission results. Over the several hundredpublications,there were many articles that did not list critical characterisitcs, so these articles were dropped from the metaanalysis.However, there were several dozen articles that didlist biochar characterisitcs that caused reductions in GHG production, so these articles are being furtherexamined to identify salinet biochar features causingreductions in GHG production. We expect that these sailent biochar features with set the framework to compose the designer biochars (Goal 2). It will take a few more months, for these biochar characterics to be indentified. We anticipate a scientific publication from the meta-analysis study. For Goal 2, we are just begining to recognize feedstocks and pyrolysis condititons needed to compose designer biochars to improve soil health and reduce GHG emissions. In the meanwhile, a list of crop and manure feedstocks along with biochar production conditions are being discussed withd4f teammates. This is in anticipation for theirselection of the most appropriatebiochar characterisitics. This is currently ongoing. For Goal 3,and4, we have not reached them in the first year. For Goal 5, we have had a project kick off meetingin November 2014 at Long Beach CA, and hadtwo d4f teammembers visit our Europe d4f collaborators. Additionally, Drs. Novak and Sigua made an oral and poster presentation at the USDA-NIFA project reporting meeting in Washington DC (April 2015).We also have had twomeetings via Skype in January andMay of 2015 to discuss the results of the meta-analysis. In september of 2015, several USDA d4f team memberswillattend a biochar conference in Germany.At this conference we will interface with our European d4f collaborators todiscuss the meta-analysis publication andmethods for a cross-oceanbiochar research project.

    Publications