Source: THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN submitted to NRP
BUMBLE BEE ECOLOGY AND IMPROVED FOOD SECURITY
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1000479
Grant No.
2013-67012-21114
Cumulative Award Amt.
$149,586.00
Proposal No.
2013-03464
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2013
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2015
Grant Year
2013
Program Code
[A7201]- AFRI Post Doctoral Fellowships
Recipient Organization
THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN
101 EAST 27TH STREET STE 4308
AUSTIN,TX 78712-1500
Performing Department
Sec of Integrative Biology
Non Technical Summary
Pollinating insects are essential for large-scale crop production, and thus are necessary for sustainable agriculture and continued food security in the US. Bumble bees are the most economically important native pollinators, and are likely also the most threatened. A major threat to bumble bee conservation is habitat loss, which reduces floral resources and leads to poor nutritional status in bees. In the proposed research, we integrate methods from field ecology, experimental biology, and molecular genetics to explore how food unavailability and nutrient limitation influence native bumble bees. The study will include explorations of the ways in which wild bumble bees are influenced by the loss of floral resources, as well as laboratory experiments to examine how nutrition influences bumble bees behavior and their ability to mate and disperse across the landscape. Results from this research will yield important insights into the biology of native bumble bees and will be used to develop and directly apply specific recommendations for improved bumble bee conservation and pollination industry practices. In order to conserve native pollinators and manage them for optimal pollination services, it is essential that we understand the reasons for their decline and develop practical solutions for management and conservation. Results from this research will lead to improved food security for all Americans by addressing this essential component of US agriculture.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
75%
Applied
25%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
21130901070100%
Goals / Objectives
The overarching goal of the project is touse a novel combination of field ecology methods, experimental approaches, and molecular genetic techniques to determine the management practices needed to promote healthy native bee populations and effective foraging patterns in agricultural landscapes. More specifically, the project aims to determine how: 1. Floral resources surrounding bumble bee nests influence colony development and foraging. 2. Nutritional status influences feeding behavior in bumble bee queens. 3. Nutritional status influences both the dispersal and mating ability of reproductive bumble bees.
Project Methods
The scientific methods used to address the five research questions are as follows: 1. To explore how floral resources surrounding bumble bee nests influence colony development, we will work with wild bumble bee coloniesin both agricultural and natural habitats. Transect sampling will be used to locate nests, and floral resource availability surrounding the nests will be estimated using an extensive quadrat-based plant inventory system and pollen analysis.Three variables of colony development will be recorded: i) number of workers in the colony; ii) brood in the colony (no. eggs, larvae, and pupae), and iii) survival or failure of the nests. To test our hypothesis that bumble bee colony development will be more advanced in colonies surrounded with greater floral resource availability, we will use generalized linear models that examine how each of the three measures of colony development vary as a function of field location and floral resources around the nest. 2. To determine howfloral resources surrounding bumble bee nests influence colony foraging, the focal nests (above) will also be used for behavioral observations of colony foraging behavior. During behavioral observations, the foraging activity of individual bees will be recorded, and will be combined with floral resource data (above). Generalized linear models will be used to ask how each foraging behavior response variable varies as a function of floral resource availability and nest location. 3. To determine hownutritional status influences feeding behavior in bumble bee queens, we will perform laboratory experiments with colonies of B. impatiens.Young nests will be kept in boxes connected to a lighted foraging chamber provisioned with sugar syrup and pollen. Each nest will be subjected to one of four experimental manipulations of macronutrient availability and nutritional status, each of which targets a single macronutrient independently. Effects of the four treatments on queen feeding activity will be measured using behavioral observations of queen foraging and brood feeding. Measures of colony development (no. eggs, larvae, pupae) will also be measured for each nest. To test our hypothesis, we will use ANOVA to determine what amounts of variation in queen brood-feeding behavior and colony development (response variables) are attributable to treatment, source colony, and the interaction between these factors. 4. To examine queen and male dispersal in the laboratory, we will subject young queen and maleB. impatiensto four experimental manipulations of diet and nutrition. Afterwards, they will be used in a laboratory dispersal assay based on previous work in fruit flies. To test our prediction thatqueens and males with better nutritional statuses will disperse greater distances, we will use an ANOVA that explores the proportion of variation in number of dispersal subchamber units traveled that is explained by the treatment, source colony, and the interaction of these factors.To examine nutrition and queen dispersal in the field, we will collect wild nest-site seeking queens and estimate dispersal distance using microsatellites and sibship reconstruction analysis. To test our prediction, we will use linear regression analysis to test for a correlation between dispersal distance and fat body lipid levels in nest site-seeking queens. 5. To explore hownutritional status influences mating behavior in queen and male bumble bees,B. impatiensmales and queens will be subjected to our experimental manipulations of diet and nutrition, and afterwards will beplaced in a mating chamber and the number ofcopulations will be recorded. To test our prediction thatqueens and males with higher nutrient levels will be more active and successful in mating activities, we will use ANOVA to explore how variation in mating activity is explained by treatment group, source colony, and the interaction between these two factors. Knowledge gained from the above experiments will be used to develop pollinator conservation workshops that include mechanistic, empirically-driven management suggestions for bumble bee conservation at the local and regional levels. Additionally, we will work with the University of Texas at Austin's Ladybird Johnson Wildflower Center to develop an educational program that teaches students from underrepresented communities about bumble bees and global food security, which will involve mentoring undergraduate researchers. Findings from the project will be communicated to the bumble bee pollination industry, beekeepers, farmers, other scientists, and the public through talks, outreach and professional publications, and a professional blog will be created that documents the project and related topics in native bee conservation, which will be linked to mentor Jha's website. The blog will showcase images and videos from the project and will allow readers to engage in Q&A about bumble bee biology.

Progress 09/01/13 to 08/31/15

Outputs
Target Audience:A total of four undergraduate students received research credits through the University of Texas (UT) for their assistance with the project, and another five UT students were mentored through the project. One of these students was Senior Honors Thesis student who did her project on queen bumble bee nutrition.Additionally, a high school student from an underrepresented community was mentored through the Crockett High School-UT Mentorship Program.The students were trained in basic research methods, experimental design, and science writing, among other skills, and in return made valuable contributions to the project. The PI has been in communication with Koppert Biological Systems and Biobest Industries, two leading producers of bumble bees for the commercial pollination industry, to establish ways to inform rearing practices based on results from the study. Results from the project have been communicated at three conferences(the two most recent annual meetings of the Entomological Society of America and the North American Pollinator Protection Campaign). Additionally, a review article was published from this project in the journal Molecular Ecology and several more publications are in preparation. Changes/Problems:In summer 2014 a large field experiment was supposed to take place to study bumble bee nutrition, reproduction, and colony development. However, after receiving colonies from a supplier and testing them for colony health, they were found to contain several pathogens that are detrimental to wild bumble bees, which led to the decision to not place them in the field. As an alternative research plan, the PI worked in collaboration with researchers from the Pollinator Partnership to collect wild bees in Arizona, which are being used for a study of the relationships between food availability and reproductive capabilities (i.e., ovary development) in wild, native bees. To promote a long-term solution to the broader issue of pathogen spread in bumble bees, the PI joined the North American Pollinator Protection Campaign's Bombus Task Force, whose main goal is to regulate inter-state shipments of bumble bee colonies in order to reduce the spread of harmful pathogens. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? A total of four undergraduate students received research credits through the University of Texas (UT) for their assistance with the project, and another five UT students were mentored through the project. The students were trained in basic research methods, experimental design, and science writing, among other skills, and in return made valuable contributions to the project. One UT student mentored on the projectwas a Senior Honors Thesis student who did her thesis project on queen bumble bee nutrition. This student has just started a position as a research technician at Baylor College and is applying to medical school, and the PI has written letters of support for both of these positions. A high school student from an underrepresented community was mentored through the Crockett High School-UT Mentorship Program on the project. This student presented her research on bumble bee nutrition to her peers and the Mentorship participants. One of the undergraduate students who was employed on the project has graduated and will begin graduate school in fall 2016. The PI wrote a letter of recommendation for his graduate school application and for his NSF Graduate Research Fellowship application. In regard to the PI's development, she accepted a position as an Assistant Professor in the Entomology Department at the University of California, Riverside in 2015, with the NIFA Postdoctoral Fellowship playing a pivotal role in the competitiveness ofher application. The NIFA Project Director's meeting provided additional training for the PI and the opportunity to visit the NIFA headquarters and meet key personnel in the Institute. The PI attended three professional meetings and gave talks at each, and organized symposia at two of these meetings. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? The PIgave three invited talks at professional meetings. The PI gave an outreach talk on bumble bees to the Hays County, Texas Master Gardeners. A review article, entitled "Molecular tools and bumble bees:revealing hidden details of ecology and evolution in a model system" was co-authored by the PI, her advisor, and other major figures in bumble bee biology. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For Goal 1 (determining how floral resources surrounding bumble bee nests influence colony development and foraging): a polyfloral diet experiment was performed to explore how the qualitative aspects of pollen diet influence colony development. At present, the feeding experiment has been performed and samples have been collected and stored at -80 for further analyses. For Goal 2 (determining how nutritional status influences feeding behavior in bumble bee queens): a queen feeding experiment was performed, which manipulated queen diet quality (pollen, nectar) and measured the effects of the treatment on queen survival and reproduction. This experiment is completed and the corresponding manuscript is in preparation. For Goal 3(determining how nutritional status influences both the dispersal and mating ability of reproductive bumble bees): a mating experiment was performed, which manipulated queen diet and examined how nutritional treatments influence mating behavior, including age at mating and mating frequency. This experiment is completed and the corresponding manuscript is in preparation.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2015 Citation: Woodard, S. H., Lozier, J. D., Goulson, D., Williams, P. H., Strange, J. P., & Jha, S. (2015). Molecular tools and bumble bees: revealing hidden details of ecology and evolution in a model system. Molecular Ecology 24: 29162936.


Progress 09/01/13 to 08/31/14

Outputs
Target Audience: Thus far, four undergraduate students have received research credits through the University of Texas for their assistance with the project. The students were trained in basic research methods, experimental design, and science writing, among other skills, and in return made valuable contributions to the project. Two of these students are co-authors on upcoming manuscripts (in preparation). The PI has been in communication with Koppert Biological Systems, a leading producer of bumble bees for the commercial pollination industry, to establish ways to inform rearing practices based on results from the study. Results from the project have been communicated at two conferences, the most recent annual meetings of the Entomological Society of America and the North American Pollinator Protection Campaign. Changes/Problems: In summer 2014 a large field experiment was supposed to take place to study bumble bee nutrition, reproduction and colony development. However, after receiving colonies from a supplier and testing them for colony health, they were found to contain several pathogens that are detrimental to wild bumble bees, which led to the decision to not place them in the field. As an alternative research plan, the PI worked in collaboration with researchers from the Pollinator Partnership to collect wild bees in Arizona, which are being used for a study of the relationships between food availability and reproductive capabilities (i.e., ovary development) in wild, native bees. To promote a long-term solution to the broader issue of pathogen spread in bumble bees, the PI joined the North American Pollinator Protection Campaign's Bombus Task Force, whose main goal is to regulate inter-state shipments of bumble bee colonies in order to reduce the spread of harmful pathogens. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Four undergraduate students have received research mentorship from the project PI and also earned undergraduate research credits for their participation in the project. The students received training in organismal and molecular research, basic laboratory safety and methods, and science writing, among other skills. One student designed an independent project from the research and used this as the basis for her Senior Honors Thesis at the University of Texas. Two students are co-authors on upcoming manuscripts from the project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? At present, results from the project have been presented at two academic conferences. Several manuscripts are in preparation. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? A large experiment is in preparation for the winter, which will study queen and male bumble bee activity under different nutritional regimes (as a proxy for dispersal behavior). Additionally, in the spring and summer, an experiment will be performed that will involve placing colonies in the field to study how food availability and resource use influence colony development through the season.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For goal 1 (determining how floral resources surrounding bumble bee nests influence colony development and foraging): a polyfloral diet was performed to explore how the qualitative aspects of pollen diet influence colony development. At present, the feeding experiment has been performed and samples have been collected and stored at -80 for further analyses. For goal 2 (determining how nutritional status influence feeding behavior in bumble bee queens): a queen feeding experiment was performed, which manipulated queen diet (pollen, nectar) and measured the effects of the treatment on queen survival and reproduction. This experiment is completed and the corresponding manuscript is in preparation. For goal 3 (determining how nutritional status influences both the dispersal and mating ability of reproductive bumble bees): a mating experiment was performed, which manipulated queen diet and examined how nutritional treatments influence mating behavior, including age at mating and mating frequency. This experiment is completed and the corresponding manuscript is in preparation.

Publications