Source: MONTGOMERY CONSULTING submitted to NRP
STRENGTHENING PUBLIC CORN BREEDING TO ENSURE THAT ORGANIC FARMERS HAVE ACCESS TO ELITE CULTIVARS: STRESS NURSERIES
Sponsoring Institution
Agricultural Research Service/USDA
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0421340
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 6, 2011
Project End Date
Jul 31, 2015
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
MONTGOMERY CONSULTING
2620 West Washington Street Road
Maroa,IL 61756
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
(N/A)
Animal Health Component
55%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
55%
Developmental
25%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
20215101080100%
Knowledge Area
202 - Plant Genetic Resources;

Subject Of Investigation
1510 - Corn;

Field Of Science
1080 - Genetics;
Goals / Objectives
1) Cooperate in the breeding effort through stress evaluations, 2) participate in outreach activities, and 3) cooperate in planning, execution, and reporting of experiments and breeding plans.
Project Methods
Stress evaluations will include the following evaluations. Cold germ selection: each year as many as 50 S0 bulk (2,500 seeds per entry) breeding crosses will be screened for their ability to germinate after prolonged exposure to 40 degrees F in saturated rag rolls for approximately three weeks. Individual survivors (target 250 per breeding cross) will be identified and then shipped to breeder's nurseries for transplanting, further selection, inbreeding and testing. Plots will be scored visually on a 0-9 scale for damage to late season plant integrity in an organic nursery near Clinton, Illinois. Central Illinois is an excellent environment for selecting against leaf disease and root lodging due to combinations of wind, rain, Western corn rootworm and Anthracnose. This will provide information on the ability of the breeding lines to tolerate multiple stressors. Furthermore, each year self-pollinations will be made within the top 5% of the rows in the stress nursery (150 most promising rows of the best early segregating S1, S2, S3 generations or narrow synthetics) in order to identify individual plants most tolerant to multiple stressors. These plants will be returned to the breeders for more work. Treatments include: accelerated aging, notes on stand establishment, vigor, uniformity and any other stand related abnormalities, and root & stalk lodging. Plots will be visually assessed for percentage of plants that are root or stalk lodged and for the severity of the leaf diseases. Artificial inoculation will occur for gray leaf spot, Anthracnose leaf blight, northern leaf blight, northern leaf spot, southern leaf blight, and common rust. Stewarts Wilt occurs naturally each year as there are enough flea beetles to spread it. Starting the last week in August, plots will be visually rated for percentage of leaf area still green (SG) every week. Sums of the percent green tissue for 2, 3, or 4 ratings will be used to characterize entries by computing areas under disease progress curves. Artificial inoculation with stalk rot: within 3 days of plots reaching 50% silk, the last ten plants in each plot will be inoculated with organisms in the soil by dipping a nail mounted on a stick into the soil and then forcibly injected into the center of the first elongated internode above the ground. Plots will be scored for premature death and late season plant integrity on a 0-9 scale.

Progress 10/01/12 to 09/30/13

Outputs
Progress Report Objectives (from AD-416): 1) Cooperate in the breeding effort through stress evaluations, 2) participate in outreach activities, and 3) cooperate in planning, execution, and reporting of experiments and breeding plans. Approach (from AD-416): Stress evaluations will include the following evaluations. Cold germ selection: each year as many as 50 S0 bulk (2,500 seeds per entry) breeding crosses will be screened for their ability to germinate after prolonged exposure to 40 degrees F in saturated rag rolls for approximately three weeks. Individual survivors (target 250 per breeding cross) will be identified and then shipped to breeder's nurseries for transplanting, further selection, inbreeding and testing. Plots will be scored visually on a 0-9 scale for damage to late season plant integrity in an organic nursery near Clinton, Illinois. Central Illinois is an excellent environment for selecting against leaf disease and root lodging due to combinations of wind, rain, Western corn rootworm and Anthracnose. This will provide information on the ability of the breeding lines to tolerate multiple stressors. Furthermore, each year self-pollinations will be made within the top 5% of the rows in the stress nursery (150 most promising rows of the best early segregating S1, S2, S3 generations or narrow synthetics) in order to identify individual plants most tolerant to multiple stressors. These plants will be returned to the breeders for more work. Treatments include: accelerated aging, notes on stand establishment, vigor, uniformity and any other stand related abnormalities, and root & stalk lodging. Plots will be visually assessed for percentage of plants that are root or stalk lodged and for the severity of the leaf diseases. Artificial inoculation will occur for gray leaf spot, Anthracnose leaf blight, northern leaf blight, northern leaf spot, southern leaf blight, and common rust. Stewarts Wilt occurs naturally each year as there are enough flea beetles to spread it. Starting the last week in August, plots will be visually rated for percentage of leaf area still green (SG) every week. Sums of the percent green tissue for 2, 3, or 4 ratings will be used to characterize entries by computing areas under disease progress curves. Artificial inoculation with stalk rot: within 3 days of plots reaching 50% silk, the last ten plants in each plot will be inoculated with organisms in the soil by dipping a nail mounted on a stick into the soil and then forcibly injected into the center of the first elongated internode above the ground. Plots will be scored for premature death and late season plant integrity on a 0-9 scale. Montgomery Consulting efforts so far have created breeding lines as follows: high yielding as inbreds per se; elevated protein, methionine, lysine, and carotenoids; potential for efficient nitrogen use, drought tolerant; resistance to multiple insect pests; designated for use as females and have above average leaf disease and stalk rot resistance. Such lines were developed from proprietary breeding populations. Eight segregating breeding populations [synthetics] were sent to Ames, Iowa, Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, Ithaca, New York, and Las Cruces, New Mexico for cooperative population trials. These populations are superior for developing inbreds and improved germplasm sources and some are a replication of entries tested the previous year. In addition, a set of populations was received from Cornell, Mandaamin Institute, New Mexico State University (NMSU) and USDA ARS for cooperative testing. Those populations are being compared with populations from Montgomery Consulting on each site, including a randomized, complete block experiment in Maroa, Illinois managed by Montgomery Consulting. Because of periods of extended rain, tests were planted late. Stands are inconsistent, but unlike last year, water is not currently limiting. 22 germplasm sources were screened for cold shock characteristics. Cornell sent five; Mandaamin Institute sent ten; USDA sent one and Montgomery Consulting contributed six. At least 250 responsive seedlings were returned from Plainview, Texas to Maroa, Illinois for 21 of the 22 entries. Mandaamin Institute�s ten entries were returned for transplanting in Wisconsin. All cold shock entries were hand planted in organically managed plots. Conditions in Illinois since planting have included extreme cool and extreme heat with abundant moisture. Pollination preparation (shoot bagging) is currently underway. The cooperator went to Puerto Rico three times to supervise and coordinate winter nursery activities: November-December 2012 to plant; January � February 2013 to pollinate; and April 2013 to harvest, shell and ship seed. Seed was selected for general utility and the best lines and germplasm sources were sent to plant 784 rows in the Puerto Rico nursery in November 2012. This was essentially the same number of rows compared to Montgomery Consulting in the previous winter nursery. Stand establishment was poor due to low soil moisture at planting, but approximately 250 pollinations were made by the cooperator and pollinating crew. One of the major efforts in the Puerto Rico winter nursery was to generate seed of hybrids representing inter institutional crosses in a Design II mating scheme. Each collaborator contributed at least one elite male and one elite female. Because of the stand problems and lack of uniform emergence, it was difficult to generate the target amount of seed for each hybrid. Supplies across nurseries were low and the decision was made to hold hybrid seed in reserve until the seed target could be met. A breeding nursery was planted on the Montgomery Farm near Maroa, Illinois in the spring of 2013. Stands are mostly adequate. Most of these rows were a repeat of the Design II from Puerto Rico. Also included are: a selected sample (54 rows) of elevated oleic acid inbreds and hybrids; 14 germplasm accessions from Mandaamin Institute for evaluation in a more southern environment; 50 additional germplasm sources, including native herbicide tolerance. Of primary concern is information on the combining ability of those new lines for making competitive commercial hybrids. This information will enable us to determine which lines and populations deserve more breeding work. Therefore, it seems important to focus our efforts on making test hybrids, evaluating them, and then proceeding further with those that have been proven to have both quality and yield. In practice this means more summer isolations for making test hybrids with already existing breeding lines, more focused summer nursery work, and greater reliance on winter nurseries for advancing and increasing the best lines. Toward that goal, an isolation was planted to generate approximately 300 hybrids in the summer of 2013. The isolation male is a food grade, yellow grain, white cob inbred with very good general combining ability, in the non-SS heterotic pattern. Females include proprietary lines with native resistance to multiple insect pests; drought tolerance; improved nutritional profiles, and improved yield of the inbred in seed production systems. To assist in the calibration of the Near Infrared (NIR) for elevated protein and other essential amino acids, 425 seed samples of various pedigrees and suspected chemical composition profiles were submitted to the Grain Quality Lab at Iowa State University. NIR data were returned for 406 entries.

Impacts
(N/A)

Publications


    Progress 10/01/11 to 09/30/12

    Outputs
    Progress Report Objectives (from AD-416): 1) Cooperate in the breeding effort through stress evaluations, 2) participate in outreach activities, and 3) cooperate in planning, execution, and reporting of experiments and breeding plans. Approach (from AD-416): Stress evaluations will include the following evaluations. Cold germ selection: each year as many as 50 S0 bulk (2500 seeds per entry) breeding crosses will be screened for their ability to germinate after prolonged exposure to 40 degrees F in saturated rag rolls for approximately 3 weeks. Individual survivors (target 250 per breeding cross) will be identified and then shipped to breeder's nurseries for transplanting, further selection, inbreeding and testing. Plots will be scored visually on a 0-9 scale for damage to late season plant integrity in an organic nursery near Clinton, Illinois. Central Illinois is an excellent environment for selecting against leaf disease and root lodging due to combinations of wind, rain, Western corn rootworm and Anthracnose. This will provide information on the ability of the breeding lines to tolerate multiple stressors. Furthermore, each year self-pollinations will be made within the top 5 percent of the rows in the stress nursery (150 most promising rows of the best early segregating S1, S2, S3 generations or narrow synthetics) in order to identify individual plants most tolerant to multiple stressors. These plants will be returned to the breeders for more work. Treatments include: accelerated aging, notes on stand establishment, vigor, uniformity and any other stand related abnormalities, and root & stalk lodging. Plots will be visually assessed for percentage of plants that are root or stalk lodged and for the severity of the leaf diseases. Artificial inoculation will occur for gray leaf spot, Anthracnose leaf blight, northern leaf blight, northern leaf spot, southern leaf blight, and common rust. Stewarts Wilt occurs naturally each year as there are enough flea beetles to spread it. Starting the last week in August, plots will be visually rated for percentage of leaf area still green (SG) every week. Sums of the percent green tissue for 2, 3 or 4 ratings will be used to characterize entries by computing areas under disease progress curves. Artificial inoculation with stalk rot: within 3 days of plots reaching 50% silk, the last 10 plants in each plot will be inoculated with organisms in the soil by dipping a nail mounted on a stick into the soil and then forcibly injected into the center of the first elongated internode above the ground. Plots will be scored for premature death and late season plant integrity on a 0-9 scale. The overall emphasis of Montgomery Consulting work is to provide germplasm for evaluation, screen germplasm sources for various pest reactions and stresses including reaction to cold shock, characterize the ability of germplasm sources to withstand prolonged exposure to saturated conditions at 38 degrees Fahrenheit and still germinate and achieve viable plants, produce new hybrids that have competitive ability and nutritional quality (methionine and lysine), high carotenoid content, and are adapted for high productivity under organic or low input farming systems, including under low nitrogen conditions. Additionally, advice is provided to other team members on stress testing, quantitative genetics and conventional corn breeding issues like heterotic patterns and tester choices. Finally, nurseries are worked to meet specific collaborator needs including inter-institutional crosses and observations that fall outside the specific scope of the stated details of the project. The cooperator spent extensive consulting time regarding the transfer of the breeding program from Michael Fields Agricultural Institute (MFAI). These discussions centered around maintaining progress and continuity. The effort so far has created breeding lines. Most are high yielding as inbreds per se, some have elevated protein, methionine, lysine, and carotenoids, some have potential for efficient nitrogen use, while most are designated for use as females and have above average leaf disease and stalk rot resistance. Of primary concern is information on the combining ability of new lines for making competitive commercial hybrids. This information will enable us to determine which lines and populations deserve more breeding work. Therefore, it seems important to focus our efforts on making test hybrids, evaluating them, and then proceeding further with those that have been proven to have both quality and yield. In practice this means more summer isolations for making test hybrids with already existing breeding lines, more focused summer nursery work, and greater reliance on winter nurseries for advancing and increasing the best lines. Eight segregating breeding populations, synthetics, were sent to Ames, IA, Lake Geneva, WI, Ithaca, NY, and Las Cruces, NM for cooperative population trials. These populations represent some of the better breeding populations used at Montgomery Consulting for developing inbreds and improved germplasm sources while some are a replication of entries tested the previous year. In addition, a set of populations was received from Cornell, Mandaamin Institute, New Mexico State University (NMSU) and USDA for cooperative testing. Those populations are being compared with populations from Montgomery Consulting on each site, including a randomized complete block experiment in Maroa, IL managed by Montgomery Consulting. Additionally, five more synthetics were used to replace local checks when it became apparent that those local checks would not be forwarded for the tests in Illinois. Because of the late arrival of seed, the tests were planted extremely late. The area is too large and too remote to provide supplemental water in a meaningful way. It will be a challenge to get data from these disease and insect pest trials. Twenty three germplasm sources were screened for cold shock characteristics. Of these Cornell sent five; Mandaamin Institute sent seven, USDA sent five and Montgomery Consulting contributed six. At least 250 responsive seedlings were returned from Plainview, TX to Maroa for 22 of the 23 entries. The one entry with a poor response was a very old seed source contributed by Montgomery Consulting. All entries were hand planted in organically managed plots. Conditions since planting have included extreme heat and drought. Supplemental water has been applied and pollinations are being made as this time. Seed was selected for general utility and the best lines and germplasm sources were sent to plant 720 rows in the Puerto Rico nursery in November. This was a substantially greater number of rows than for Montgomery Consulting in the previous winter nursery. The plants grew somewhat unevenly due to moisture stress but approximately 4,000 pollinations were made. One of the major efforts in this winter nursery was to generate hybrid seeds representing inter institutional crosses in a Design II mating scheme. Each collaborator contributed at least one elite male and one elite female. Because of the stand problems and lack of uniform emergence, it was difficult to generate the target amount of seed for each hybrid. Supplies across nurseries were low and the decision was made to hold hybrid seed in reserve until the target could be met. A breeding nursery was planted on the Montgomery Farm in Maroa, IL containing 80 rows in the spring of 2012. Most of these rows were a repeat of the Design II from Puerto Rico. Because of late arriving seed, the nursery was planted very late and into soil which was not uniform in moisture. Stand establishment was erratic and the area is too large and too remote to provide supplemental water in a meaningful way. It will be a challenge to get seed from this nursery. In the spring of 2012, twenty hybrids were sent by Mandaamin Institute to Maroa, IL for observation of disease and insects and agronomics.

    Impacts
    (N/A)

    Publications