Source: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS submitted to
GENETIC ASSOCIATION BETWEEN COPY NUMBER VARIATION (CNV) AND RESISTANCE TO CAMPYLOBACTER JEJUNI COLONIZATION IN THE CHICKEN
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0229596
Grant No.
2011-67012-19678
Project No.
CA-D-ASC-2170-CG
Proposal No.
2012-03297
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
A7201
Project Start Date
Jan 1, 2012
Project End Date
Aug 14, 2013
Grant Year
2012
Project Director
Abernathy, J.
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
410 MRAK HALL
DAVIS,CA 95616-8671
Performing Department
Animal Science
Non Technical Summary
The bacterium Campylobacter jejuni is one of the most commonly reported cause of foodborne infection in the United States. The major source of C. jejuni contamination in the U.S. is chickens. Therefore, control of C. jejuni in poultry farms would significantly reduce human exposure. One major strategy in protecting the food supply from C. jejuni is to decrease the bacteria that colonize the host through genetic selection. Currently, two chicken broiler lines have been identified with genetic differences in their susceptibility to C. jejuni colonization; however, the genes, genomic variations, and mechanisms that underlie these differences are unknown. The major goal of this project is aimed at elucidating the genetic variation that exists among broilers associated with resistance to C. jejuni colonization. Preliminary data available from these lines suggests copy number variation (CNV) could play a role in the differences. The objectives are to generate a high-resolution CNV chicken array and use these genetic lines to pinpoint the genomic regions that differ between birds susceptible and resistant to C. jejuni colonization. The identified CNVs will be validated in a commercial broiler population challenged with C. jejuni. By integrating this CNV experimental data with other chicken genetic information available for these lines, such as gene expression and Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) data, a high-resolution genomic road map will be constructed. The expected outcomes are to complete this combined genomic marker map and to identify regions along the chicken chromosomes associated with C. jejuni resistance. The results generated will impact the safety of the U.S. food supply by leading to the development of markers that can be used in the genetic selection of breeding stocks with resistance to the bacteria.
Animal Health Component
20%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3033220108010%
3043220108070%
3113220108010%
7123220108010%
Goals / Objectives
GOALS: Control of Campylobacter jejuni in poultry farms will significantly reduce the risk of human exposure to the bacteria and have a significant impact on food safety and public health. Genetic selection of breeding stocks for genetic resistance to bacterial colonization is an effective means of control in many agricultural environments, yet the specific genes, genomic variations, and mechanisms that underlie differences in resistance or susceptibility to C. jejuni colonization in various chicken lines have yet to be elucidated. The long term goal of this project is to assist in the development of genetic markers that can be used in the selection of chicken breeding stocks with natural resistance to C. jejuni. Understanding the genetic basis of differences in C. jejuni colonization in the chicken gut between genetic lines and individuals with different susceptibilities is the major goal of this project. OBJECTIVES: The focus of study will be to analyze genetic variation between chicken lines, specifically copy number variation. Copy number variants (CNVs) can be responsible for altered gene dosage, disrupting of genes, or varying gene regulation. CNVs are detected through the use of array comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). A fine-mapping high-resolution CGH array will be developed based on genomic regions previously identified as significant between lines. Through the use of the CGH data, along with microarray gene expression data and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) data currently available, the combined data will be used to identify putative regions along the chicken chromosome with association to resistance or susceptibility to C. jejuni. An association test will then be performed to validate the CNVs. A commercial broiler population will be challenged with C. jejuni. The two extremes broilers (most resistant and most susceptible to C. jejuni colonization) will be collected and CGH performed. EXPECTED OUTPUTS: We expect to confirm a majority of copy number variants associated with susceptibilities to C. jejuni colonization identified in the previous studies, but with significantly narrow regions of CNVs. These results will be used in creation of integrated genomic maps using all available gene expression microarray and SNP data. We expect to identify regions of the chromosomes based on the array CGH that overlap with gene expression microarray and SNP data. This information will allow the identification of several unique chromosome regions with at least one genetic marker. Through association analysis, we expect to identify significant CNVs that are associated with C. jejuni colonization in broilers. With the high-density of CGH array, along with correlation to the microarray and SNP data, we further expect to be able to identify genomic regions close to the quantitative trait loci region underlying C. jejuni resistance or susceptibility for future functional studies.
Project Methods
The broiler chickens used will be two distinct genetic broiler lines (one line is resistant to C. jejuni colonization, while the other one is susceptible to C. jejuni colonization). A number of CNVs that have significant aberrations between these two lines have previously been identified. Based on these regions identified, a high-density array CGH will be produced for fine-mapping of the genomic aberrations. The fine-mapping CGH array will be designed using the Agilent eArray software by uploading the genomic intervals found to be significantly different between C. jejuni resistant and susceptible broiler lines in the 244K array. Genomic DNA will be used to hybridize to the high-density fine-mapping array CGH. Sample processing from DNA labeling to scanning will be performed according to Agilent CGH protocols. Significant CNVs will be called using Agilent's Genomic Workbench software. A subset of significant data will be randomly validated by quantitative PCR. The data extracted from the fine-mapping CGH array will be integrated with the data from previous microarray and SNP data based on challenges of chicken broilers with C. jejuni. This data will produce an integrated genomic map of genomic regions between populations of C jejuni susceptibility or resistance. Data will be aligned manually using the JMP genomic software and Microsoft applications including Excel spreadsheets and Access. The array CGH data will be correlated with gene expression microarray and SNPs at various stringency conditions. For association study, chicken broilers will be purchased from commercial breeding sources. A total of 200 birds will be used for the challenge experiment. A total of 20 birds will be used as a preliminary screen for C.jejuni contamination. One hundred eighty 1-day old chickens will be orally inoculated with C. jejuni. At 7 d post-inoculation, whole blood will be collected; then, the birds will be sacrificed by carbon dioxide asphyxiation and the cecum removed from each bird. The cecal contents will be filtered plated on selective agar. After incubation, the number of colonies will be counted. After the plate counts, samples will be divided into two groups based on the number of colonies: the highest and lowest number of bacterial colonies observed. Of the 180 samples, the 18 most resistant and the 18 most susceptible individual samples, based on the number of bacterial colonies, will be selected for genomic DNA isolation. Array CGH will be performed on these individuals as previously completed. The results will be used to validate those genomic regions with significant association in the population to C. jejuni colonization. The project will be successful as measured by the following. First, the research should meet the two-year timeline as proposed. Second, at least two publications are expected from the results of these data. Third, the data from this project will ultimately be available to the public so that future functional studies may be initiated.

Progress 01/01/12 to 08/14/13

Outputs
Target Audience: The target audience for this project is the poultry genetic scientific community and those with an interest in chicken immunology and/or food safety research. Changes/Problems: There were no major problems to report. We did, however, make a change in one approach for our last goal. This goal was to use an array CGH platform to validate some of our findings in a commercial population of broiler chicken. We changed technologies from an array approach to a high-throughput sequencing approach. This approach is more powerful than using an array, as we were able to sequence to a high coverage, while the array was only able to cover a portion of the genome and is based on hybridization dynamics. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? TRAINING: This project involved several laboratory techniques in which students and visiting scientist were trained. As this project also involved animal trials, training was provided to students and scientists on proper handling and surgical procedures. The PD was further trained by the mentor on array and sequencing technical methods as well as bioinformatics methods. PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Professional development was provided for as the PD was afforded the opportunity to present data at major conferences. This also presented networking opportunities for the PD as well as further learning about the USDA grant process at the PD meeting in Washington D.C. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? This information has been disseminated as both oral and poster presentations at several major conferences. Information is further disseminated by publication in peer-reviewed journals. Genetic maps, custom array platforms, array data and sequencing data will be released to the public upon publication and/or submitted to public repositories. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? MAJOR ACTIVITIES COMPLETED: A candidate pool of Copy Number Variants (CNVs) in four genetic chicken lines (two inbred and two broiler lines) has been identified through the use of the Agilent chicken 244K array Comparative Genomic Hybridization (aCGH). We took those candidate CNVs and built a custom Agilent aCGH platform to saturate the identified CNVs with probes in order to reduce the spacing, referred to here as fine-mapping, of the chromosomal aberrant regions closer to the Quantitative Trait Loci (QTL) affecting genetic resistance to Campylobacter colonization. The original line A and line B broiler samples were then analyzed by the custom Agilent aCGH. We now have a list of candidate CNVs that have been fine-mapped from the original 244K platform. We have since aligned this data with existing data (including but not limited to gene expression information, gene ontologies, QTL databases) and created a genetic map in which these regions might be associated with Campylobacter colonization resistance. We have further validated a selected number of these identified CNV regions using alternative experimental approaches including quantitative and digital PCR. Lastly, we challenged a random population of broiler chicken from a commercial source with Campylobacter jejuni and determined which chickens have differences in colonization load, in order to validate our finding in a closed genetic line with those chickens used in industry. We then sequenced high-colonizing and low colonizing broilers from this population and determined significant CNVs and single nucleotide variants. We aligned this data to our previous genetic line array data to discover overlaps and validate variants associated with Campylobacter colonization. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES MET: These experiments conclude 3 of 3 goals of the project. SIGNIFICANT RESULTS ACHIEVED: We now have genomic data including CNVs and single nucleotide variants associated with Campylobacter jejuni colonization from specific genetic lines and commercial broilers. OUTCOMES: The PD has been able to map regions along chicken chromosomes in genetic lines with differences in their response to Campylobacter jejuni colonization in the chicken. Based on this information, the PD created a custom array platform. Based on this custom array, we were able to produce a fine-map of these chromosomal regions. We then created a genetic map with candidate regions that might affect Campylobacter resistance in chickens. We further defined a bioinformatic pipeline for analysis of the chromosomal regions identified to generate high-confidence copy number variants. Lastly, we created a high-throughput sequencing library and sequenced commercial broilers with varying campylobacter colonization. The information we have found benefits the scientific community by providing coordinates along regions of chicken chromosomes that may impact genes affecting bacterial colonization and infection. The information and custom platform can be used for related experiments in an attempt to identify causal chromosomal aberrations. We will directly use the information learned to further create additional experimentation.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Other Year Published: 2013 Citation: J. Abernathy, X. Li, X. Jia, S.J. Lamont, R. Crooijmans and H. Zhou. Fine-mapping of chicken genomic aberrations by identifying copy number variants associated with Campylobacter jejuni colonization
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Under Review Year Published: 2013 Citation: Copy number variation in Fayoumi and Leghorn chickens analyzed by array comparative genomic hybridization
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: H. Zhou. Fine-mapping of chicken CNVs associated with Campylobacter jejuni in the chicken. 21st Annual International Plant and Animal Genome Conference (abstract). San Diego, CA. Invited Oral Presentation.
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2012 Citation: J. Abernathy. Genetic association between Copy Number Variation (CNV) and resistance to Campylobacter jejuni colonization in the chicken. AFRI NIFA Fellowships Project Directors Meeting (abstract). Washington, D.C. Poster Presentation.
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2012 Citation: J. Abernathy, X. Li, X. Jia, and H. Zhou. Fine-mapping of chicken genomic aberrations by identifying copy number variants associated with Campylobacter jejuni colonization. 33rd Conference of the International Society of Animal Genetics (abstract). Cairns, Australia. Invited Oral and Poster Presentation.


Progress 01/01/12 to 12/31/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The following outcomes have been reached since the beginning of this project. ACTIVITIES: A candidate pool of Copy Number Variants (CNVs) in four genetic lines (two inbred and two broiler lines) has been identified through the use of the Agilent chicken 244K array Comparative Genomic Hybridization (aCGH). We took those candidate CNVs and built a custom Agilent aCGH platform to saturate the identified CNVs with probes in order to reduce the spacing, referred to here as fine-mapping, of the chromosomal aberrant regions closer to the Quantitative Trait Loci (QTL) affecting genetic resistance to Campylobacter colonization. The original line A and line B broiler samples were then analyzed by the custom Agilent aCGH. We now have a list of candidate CNVs that have been fine-mapped from the original 244K platform. We have since aligned this data with existing data (including but not limited to gene expression information, gene ontologies, QTL databases) and created a genetic map in which these regions might be associated with Campylobacter colonization resistance. We have further validated a selected number of these identified CNV regions using alternative experimental approaches including quantitative and digital PCR. These experiments conclude 2 of 3 goals of the project. EVENTS: We have presented this data at the 21st Annual International Plant and Animal Genome Conference in San Diego, California and the 33rd International Society of Animal Genetics Conference in Cairns, Australia. PRODUCTS: We created a custom Agilent 4x44K chicken aCGH array for fine-mapping chromosomal aberrations. We have also created a genetic map with candidate regions that might affect Campylobacter jejuni colonization resistance in the chicken. This information has been disseminated as both oral and poster presentations at several major conferences. Information will further be disseminated by publication in peer-reviewed journals; the preparation of manuscripts for publication is underway. Genetic maps and custom array platforms will be released to the public upon publication. PARTICIPANTS: INDIVIDUALS: The PD, Jason Abernathy, was the main participant of this project as this was his postdoctoral fellowship. Jason performed the necessary laboratory experiments and data analyses to meet the goals specified in the grant proposal. Throughout the duration of the project, the mentor, Huaijun Zhou, provided guidance where needed and allowed the PD the use of all general laboratory supplies and equipment. PARTNER ORGANIZATIONS: The USDA-ARS in College Station, Texas allowed the use of facilities and equipment as specified in the proposal. COLLABORATORS: Our collaborator at the USDA-ARS in College Station, Michael Kogut, provided use of the facilities, equipment, and chicken samples to our laboratory. He also provided skilled scientific expertise. TRAINING AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: The PD has been afforded many opportunities for training and professional development after being awarded this postdoctoral fellowship. The PD has presented this work at major scientific conferences and is preparing for publications. As the PD, and with the support of the mentor, Jason has been allowed to lead a team of undergraduate students, graduate students, and a postdoc in the execution of major parts of the project, such as field work with chickens and large-scale genomic data analyses. Jason attended his first PD meeting in Washington D.C., and as such was able to learn more about the USDA grant process and provide feedback on the fellowships program. Additionally through the use of travel funds from this grant, the PD was able to network with fellow scientists, sharpen presentation skills, and establish potential collaborations. The PD also had informal bioinformatic training from the mentor and other institute members in order to meet the established goals. TARGET AUDIENCES: TARGET AUDIENCE: The target audience is the poultry / genetic scientific community as well as the general public with an interest. EFFORTS: Partial information has been provided at scientific conferences; complete information will be provided at completion of all goals and publication of the work. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
CHANGE IN KNOWLEDGE AND ACTIONS: To date, the PD has been able to map regions along the chicken chromosome in genetic lines with differences in their response to Campylobacter jejuni colonization in the chicken. Based on this information, the PD was able to create a custom array platform. Based on this custom array, we were able to produce a fine-map of these chromosomal regions. We then created a genetic map with candidate regions that might affect Campylobacter resistance in chickens. We further defined a bioinformatic pipeline for analysis of the chromosomal regions identified to generate high-confidence copy number variants. The information we have found so far will benefit the scientific community by providing coordinates along regions of chicken chromosomes that may impact genes affecting bacterial colonization and infection. The information and custom platform can be used for related experiments in an attempt to identify causal chromosomal aberrations. We will directly use the information learned to further the goals of this project and create additional experimentation.

Publications

  • J. Abernathy. (2012) Genetic association between Copy Number Variation (CNV) and resistance to Campylobacter jejuni colonization in the chicken. AFRI NIFA Fellowships Project Directors Meeting (abstract). Washington, D.C. Poster Presentation.
  • J. Abernathy, X. Li, X. Jia, H. Zhou. (2012) Fine-mapping of chicken genomic aberrations by identifying copy number variants associated with Campylobacter jejuni colonization. 33rd Conference of the International Society of Animal Genetics (abstract). Cairns, Australia. Invited Oral and Poster Presentation.
  • H. Zhou. (2013) Fine-mapping of chicken CNVs associated with Campylobacter jejuni in the chicken. 21st Annual International Plant and Animal Genome Conference (abstract). San Diego, CA. Invited Oral Presentation.