Source: New York Harbor Foundation submitted to NRP
NEW YORK HARBOR OYSTER NURSERY AQUACULTURE EDUCATION PROJECT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0228933
Grant No.
2012-38414-19564
Cumulative Award Amt.
$44,399.00
Proposal No.
2012-01110
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2012
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2015
Grant Year
2012
Program Code
[OW]- Secondary Challenge
Recipient Organization
New York Harbor Foundation
10 South Street, Slip 7
New York,NY 10004
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Urban Assembly New York Harbor School is a New York City Career and Technical Education (CTE)-designated public high school that has developed an innovative four-year marine aquaculture curriculum, one of the first in New York City. This curriculum uses school facilities and New York Harbor itself as its learning laboratories, and is focused largely on oyster production as a means of advancing aquaculture education as well as habitat restoration goals for New York Harbor. Whereas students and teachers make ample use of an aquaculture laboratory in the school building and a floating upweller system located at the school's dock, the school has no regular access to a commercial aquaculture site or approximation thereof. This hampers the aquaculture program as students have no opportunities to gain many of the knowledge and skills required to operate a commercial aquaculture business. To fulfill this need, New York Harbor Foundation has initiated the New York Harbor Oyster Nursery Aquaculture Education Project. This project addresses the Aquaculture curriculum's need for a field site that embodies commercial practices and allows students to gain knowledge and skills needed to fulfill the increasing demand for a skilled aquaculture workforce. The following are the target objectives of this project for the target audience of Harbor School students: (1) Aquaculture upperclassmen will increase their knowledge and skills of commercial shellfish aquaculture by managing a small-scale oyster nursery as part of their Intermediate and Advanced Aquaculture coursework; (2) 40 Aquaculture seniors will increase their preparedness for the workforce by developing and presenting oyster nursery business plans to industry professionals; (3) 40 Aquaculture upperclassmen will increase their awareness of the aquaculture industry by visiting a commercial oyster nursery and meeting with industry professionals; (4) 4 upperclassmen will increase their preparedness for the workforce by completing paid summer internships to help manage the oyster nursery; and (5) 250 9th-grade students will be introduced to the field of aquaculture through a visit to the school's oyster nursery. Over the course of this project, 294 students will participate in a new, authentic component to their Aquaculture coursework. This experience will enable students to meet Aquaculture learning targets that they currently cannot meet due to the lack of an appropriate facility. The impacts of the Oyster Nursery Project will be an increased attendance rate for Aquaculture students; measurable increases in student attainment of Aquaculture learning targets; and measurable increases in student awareness of the many opportunities available in the field of aquaculture.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
30708111060100%
Knowledge Area
307 - Animal Management Systems;

Subject Of Investigation
0811 - Shellfish;

Field Of Science
1060 - Biology (whole systems);
Goals / Objectives
The goal of the Oyster Nursery Project is to add an authentic experiential project to the Harbor School's Aquaculture program through the construction and operation of an oyster nursery, and the integration of those activities into the Aquaculture curriculum. This new project will accomplish two important educational goals: (a) it will enable students to achieve learning targets that are current identified in the Aquaculture CTE curriculum but which cannot be attained without this oyster nursery; and (b) it will enhance students' overall Aquaculture learning experience, thereby improving attendance and academic performance. The overall result of the oyster nursery will be the enhanced academic achievement of Aquaculture students, who will be able to develop oyster nursery business plans and meet a series of other nursery-related knowledge and skills learning targets. The oyster nursery may also help improve Aquaculture students' attendance records and overall academic achievement, and may also result in increased awareness of commercial aquaculture and related higher education opportunities. Five target objectives have been articulated for the Oyster Nursery Project. Each of these objectives, listed below, is aligned with specific Aquaculture curriculum learning targets. Progress toward these objectives will be measured by evaluating student attendance and achievement data, the results of qualitative assessments, and participation and performance on specific projects. 1. Aquaculture upperclassmen increase their knowledge and skills of commercial shellfish aquaculture by managing a small-scale oyster nursery as part of their Intermediate and Advanced Aquaculture Coursework. Progress toward this goal will be measured by evaluating student attendance and achievement with regard to Aquaculture knowledge and skills learning targets. 2. Aquaculture seniors increase their preparedness for the workforce by developing and presenting oyster nursery business plans to industry professionals. Progress toward this goal will be measured by evaluating the oyster nursery business plans that are presented to industry professionals twice during the course of this project. 3. Aquaculture upperclassmen increase their awareness of the aquaculture industry by visiting a commercial oyster nursery and meeting with industry professionals. Progress toward this goal will be measured by evaluating the field trips that students participate in twice during the course of this project. 4. Select upperclassmen increase their preparedness for the workforce by completing paid summer internships to help manage oyster nursery. Progress toward this goal will be measured by evaluating the student internships which are funded as part of this project. 5. 9th-grade students are introduced to commercial aquaculture through a visit to the school's oyster nursery. Progress toward this goal will be measured by evaluating student participation in these visits as well as their increased awareness of the field of aquaculture through these experiences.
Project Methods
The first part of the Oyster Nursery Project involves nursery construction and operation. Nursery construction will take place during the summer of 2012 and will be led by the Aquaculture Program Director/Teacher, two technicians, and select upper-level students. The nursery will be constructed in a site in Wallabout Basin in the Brooklyn Navy Yard, a 10-minute boat ride from the School's location on Governors Island. The nursery will comprise a floating longline anchored at either end and marked with floats, and a series of oyster cages hanging from the longline in the water column. Construction of the nursery will require using small boats to deploy the anchors, line, floats, and cages. Once the nursery is constructed, it will remain in place for the duration of the project. Nursery operation will begin immediately following construction and will be led by the Aquaculture Program Director/Teacher, two technicians, and students. Operation of the nursery will require daily boat trips to and from the site during each growing season (April to October). Under the supervision of the Director/Teacher and technicians, students will travel by boat to the nursery, set up and manage the cages, and monitor the oysters, nursery environment, and equipment over the course of the growing season. Off-season operation of the nursery will require weekly boat trips to and from the site to maintain the equipment. The integration of the oyster nursery into the Aquaculture curriculum will take place through both construction and operation. Each project target is associated with specific learning targets that are written into the Aquaculture curriculum. As such, lesson planning and implementation to accomplish those project goals - i.e. seniors managing the nursery - will be embedded in the Aquaculture Program Director/Teacher's school year planning and teaching schedule. Selection of student summer interns will also be managed by the Aquaculture Program Director/Teacher. As these will be paid internship positions, a job description will be disseminated in advance of each summer vacation, and students will be required to apply and interview for the position. Student intern evaluations will be completed at the conclusion of the summer months.

Progress 07/01/12 to 06/30/15

Outputs
Target Audience:The primary audience of the Billion Oyster Project are the citizens of New York City, in particular, public school students. Students at the New York Harbor School were the primary workforce responsible for the maintenance of the oyster nursery. Through their work, these students learned valuable industry skills including, but not limited to specific bivalve aquaculture techniques, project planning,budgeting and presentation skills that will be a value to them as they pursue college and careers after high school. The secondary audience for the work under this grant are the people who attended presentations and workshops, conducted by Harbor School students throughout the project period at Aquaculture and Oyster Restoration conferences up and down the east coast. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This program is educational in nature. As such their are many opportunities for training that are addressed above. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Yes. Through the participartion in Aquaculture and Oyster Restoration Conferences as mentioned above What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. Since 2013, 54Harbor School upper classmen in the Aquaculture program worked to build, maintain, and operate the oyster nursery. This work required their mastery of Aquaculture specific skills that were also necessary learning targets for their progression through the Aquaculture Program of study at Harbor School. These skills includedspecific, hands-on tasks such as knot tying, grading oysters by size, constructing nursery trays, splicing lines and evaluating the health and growth of oysters over time. In addition to these specific career skills, students also conducted experiments to evaluate factors that affect the growth of oysters in the nursery developed an understanding of the biological systems at play. In this way the nursery served as a lens for teaching and learning that focused the knowledge and skills of both career and core academic classes through the narrative of oyster cultivation and restoration. 2. Students in the Aquaculture program of study developed professional skills in preparing for and presenting their work at a number of important industry and scientific conferences throughout the duration of the project. These conferences include the National Aquaculture Conference and Exposition in Milford, CT (2013) and in Portland ME (2015), the International Conference on Shellfish Restoration in SC (2015). Students also present annually to the Professional Advisory committee or PAC. The PAC is a group of professionals and post-secondary educators in the field of Aquaculture that advise on the program, curriculum and facilities. Through these presentations students learn to design PowerPoint presentations and use them to communicate their work. These presentations include the project design and budgeting aspects of the project in the form of business plans. These business plans served both to fulfill that Career and Financial Management requirements of the Aquaculture Program and as a capstone project for seniors. 3. Each spring students in the Aquaculture Program travel to the Fishers Island Oyster Farm on Fishers Island, NY. The purpose of the trip is to spend several days working on the farm and working together. This trip is integral to the development of these students as aquaculturists. Generally, students spend three days working on the farm and spend two nights on the Island. It is a huge challenge to give students experience with working farms due to our location in New York City. Through this grant students have the opportunity to work on our commercial scale farm and also work alongside actual professional oyster farmers. 4. It would not be possible to grow oysters on Governors Island if the work on the farm was limited to the school year calendar. Oysters are growing fastest during the summer and as a result need the most care during the warm months. In addition to their growth rate, other organisms attach to the oyster cages at a much higher rate during the late spring and early summer. These two factors combine to make the summer months the busiest on the oyster farm. In order to meet the handling requirements of the oysters on the farm, it is necessary to employ a workforce over the summer. It is of great value to the educational goals of the program to have students in the Aquaculture Program as the interns that fill this need during the summer months. Over the last three years 15 students have worked over the summer. Funding for this grant was used to leverage funding from the NYC Department of Education's Work Based Learning Program to increase the funding available for this program. As a result it was possible to hire both currently-enrolled students and alumni of the program to work the nursery over the summer. 5. Students in the 9th grade field class were able to visit the nursery on Governors Island in for the last three years of the grant period. These visits provided an introduction to the work of Aquaculture and helped the students to make a more informed choice in programs. During the spring of 2005, the entire 89th grade field class participated in two Billion Oyster Project filed cycles that required them to build cages, stock them with oysters and participate in the new field science protocols. During the selection process for CTE program following these cycles, almost half of the students in the freshman class chose Aquaculture first out of six programs. These results point to increased awareness and interest in Aquaculture provided by these experiences.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/13 to 06/30/14

    Outputs
    Target Audience: The target audience for this project includes 430 students, 25 faculty and 18 staff of the Urban Assembly New York Harbor School. In particular 45 Aquaculture program upperclassmen were the direct beneficiaries of this project. Secondary beneficiaries included all other Harbor School students and numerous middle school students at oyster project partner schools. At these partner schools, 13 teachers were provided oysters grown by Harbor School students in the Wallabout Basin Nursery. Changes/Problems: Staffing Changes During the 2013-14 school year, Pete Malinowski continued to lead the Aquaculture department at Harbor School with assistance in the hatchery from Jeremy Esposito. Sam Janis and Luis Melendez continued as Restoration Program Manager and Restoration Program Coordinator, respectively. At the beginning of this 2014-15 school year, we had a number of important staffing changes: Pete left Harbor School to join the Foundation full time as Director of the Billion Oyster Project. This move will give Pete more time to develop and implement the Project. Jeremy left the Foundation to join Harbor School full time as an Aquaculture instructor. Jeremy will continue to manage the hatchery and to work on the Project with Pete. Susannah Ceraldi, a veteran high school science teacher, joined Harbor School to teach Aquaculture alongside Jeremy. She brings a traditional science background to the department. Luis will remain at Harbor, assisting Harbor School’s waterfront director on a part time basis, driving and maintaining boats that comprise Harbor School’s fleet of educational vessels What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? This project is an education project. Opportunities for training and are central to the project. Students are trained in the construction, operation and maintenance of a working, commercial-scale oyster nursery during their daily schedule of advanced aquaculture classes and workshops. This knowledge was evident during the spring trip to Fishers Island. Staff members working on the project were also trained in the maintenance of the nursery. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? The results of the Wallabout Basin Oyster Nursery and related activities have been disseminated widely through scientific presentations at aquaculture related conferences and events, as well as through Harbor School's local restoration project and its own public communications channels. The Billion Oyster Project Website (www.billionoysterproject.org), as well as the Twitter and Instagram feeds (both @billionoyster) have allowed for new audiences to develop over the last year. Along with Hudson River Foundation and NY/NJ Baykeeper, Harbor School is prime partner in the Oyster Restoration Research Project (ORRP). ORRP operates two permitted experimental reef plots throughout New York Harbor. All of the oysters for these projects Harbor School aquaculture students. Results of their oyster production systems – including total quantities, growth rate, fouling patterns, and other data – have been disseminated through ORRP partners and published in the ORRP Phase I technical report (Grizzle et al, 2013). Additionally more than 30 supporting partners and secondary organizations from across the NY Harbor region have participated and helped to disseminate the results of ORRP stocked with oysters grown in Harbor School nurseries. The results of the project have also been transmitted by Harbor School students' and faculty members' presentations three scientific and industry related conferences and several local workshops over the past year. These include NOAA's 6th Annual Restore Americas Estuaries Conference, Blue Vision Summit 2013, the Northeast Aquaculture Association Annual Conference, and local events taking place at the New York Academy of Sciences, the American Museum of Natural History, and the Brooklyn Bridge Park Conservancy. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? The 2014-2015 reporting period is expected to show the most dramatic growth in the oyster production through the Wallabout Oyster nursery. With the nursery construction complete, Harbor School has begun the outfitting of the new oyster hatchery located in building 134 on Governors Island and is eagerly awaiting the arrival of the Virginia Maitland Sachs, a 29-foot custom designed oyster cultivation and restoration vessel. With these pieces in place Harbor School Aquaculture students will work at the Wallabout nursery twice a week, every week through the month of November and starting again in April. The full 2.5 million animal production capacity of the system is expected to be reached during the late spring of 2014. As the program expands so will progress towards the goals outlined in the project narrative. It is expected that by the end of the 2014 grant year, all Harbor School freshmen will have toured the Wallabout nursery, 25 more students will travel and work at the Fishers Island Oyster farm and sixteen more students will present their work to industry professionals.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Significant progress was made towards the goals set forth in the project narrative. Nursery equipment was purchased, environmental and government permits were secured and the nursery was constructed and stocked with oysters. Currently the nursery is home to over 750,000 live animals. These oysters live in 600 supertrays, suspended from floats on a longline modeled after a commercial aquaculture facility. The construction work was conducted over Summer and Fall of 2012 in large part by New York Harbor School students and interns. Throughout the 2013-14 school year work focused on growing and stocking the oysters in the nursery. 1. After three years of development, the Aquaculture Program of Study at Harbor School was approved by the state as an accredited Career and Technical Education program. This accomplishment is partially due to the hands-on industry specific experience gained by students through their involvement in the Wallabout Oyster Nursery. 2. 20 Aquaculture upperclassman increased their knowledge and aquaculture skills by stocking the Wallabout Oyster nursery with oysters throughout the 2013-14 school year. The majority of the work on the nursery in 2012 was conducted in the upland hatchery facility at Harbor School. Broodstock was selected, conditioned and spawned in this facility to produce the animals that would be used to stock the nursery in the Brooklyn Navy Yard. For the first time in May, 2014, oysters were transferred directly from the remote setting tanks in the upland hatchery to the Wallabout nursery. In years past oysters have spent some months at the nursery on Governors Island before being transferred to the Wallabout nursery. The assumption was made that due to water quality constraints, the small oysters were safer on Governors Island. Results showed good survival of small (<2mm) oysters in the Wallabout nursery,. This is encouraging and will allow for increased oyster production during the spring of 2015. 3. Aquaculture seniors has a number of opportunities to present their work to professionals during the 2013-14 school year.. The first was during the annual New York Harbor School Professional Advisory Committee meeting on December 11th, 2013. Five Aquaculture seniors presented their work to members of the New York City Department of Environmental Protection, Aquaculture Extension Agents, a scientist from the Nature Conservancy, industry professionals and Natural Resource Instructors from Roger Williams University. The presentation consisted of an overview of our restoration project, details on bivalve production from floating nursery systems and a business plan for the preceding production season. A similar presentation was given by six seniors to attendees of a teacher training presentation given to high School teachers on Staten Island. Here the students’ role was to inform high school teachers about the project and how oysters are grown in New York Harbor. 4. 25 Aquaculture students increased their knowledge of the industry through a weekend-long overnight trip to the Fishers Island Oyster Farm on Fishers Island, New York. These students traveled to the oysters farm and spent the weekend as if they were employees of the operation. Students worked full, nine hour days and performed a number of typical oyster farming tasks including grading oyster larvae, transferring oysters from upwelling systems to growout cages, driving boats and harvesting adult oysters. The 2014 trip was the sixth trip made by Harbor School students to the Fishers Island Oyster Farm. These students’ experience working in the Wallabout nursery was evident during their time on the commercial oyster farm. Compared to years past, the students had a more complete understanding of nursery systems and techniques. All of the nine students that successfully completed the three-year program of study received their Aquaculture CTE certificate which required passing the industry approved technical assessment. 5. During the spring and summer of 2014 a number of Harbor School students and one graduate received stipends for their work on the Wallabout nursery and growing oysters on Governors Island. Two riding juniors and two rising seniors received stipends directly funded by this grant. In addition one Alumna, Derek Thompson was able to return to Harbor School to work alongside current students. Another 8 students received stipends from other organizations to work alongside those supported by this grant. These organizations included the New York Harbor Foundation and Columbia University. 5. All (110) ninth grade students were introduced to the project through tours of the aquaculture lab, lessons from aquaculture instructors and individual presentations from current aquaculture students. Freshman gained experience using microscopes, operating hatchery equipment, counting and measuring oysters from the nursery and maintaining nursery equipment. In the future ninth graders will travel to the Wallabout nursery.

    Publications


      Progress 07/01/12 to 06/30/13

      Outputs
      Target Audience: The target audience for this project includes 430 students, 25 faculty and 18 staff of the Urban Assembly New York Harbor School. In particular 45 Aquaculture program upperclassmen were the direct beneficiaries of this project. Secondary beneficiaries included all other Harbor School students and numerous middle school students at oyster project partner schools. At these partner schools, 13 teachers were provided oysters grown by Harbor School students in the Wallabout Basin Nursery. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? This project is an education project. Opportunities for training and are central to the project. Students are trained in the construction, operation and maintenance of a working, commercial-scale oyster nursery during their daily schedule of advanced aquaculture classes and workshops. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? The results of the Wallabout Basin Oyster Nursery and related activities have been disseminated widely through scientific presentations at aquaculture related conferences and events, as well as through Harbor School’s local restoration project and its own public communications channels. Along with Hudson River Foundation and NY/NJ Baykeeper, Harbor School is prime partner in the US EPA-funded Oyster Restoration Research Project (ORRP). ORRP operates five permitted experimental reef plots throughout New York Harbor. A majority of the oysters used to seed and re-stock these five experimental reef plots were grown by Harbor School aquaculture students. Results of their oyster production systems – including total quantities, growth rate, fouling patterns, and other data – have been disseminated through ORRP partners and published in the ORRP Phase I technical report (Grizzle et al, 2013). Additionally more than 30 supporting partners and secondary organizations from across the NY Harbor region have participated and helped to disseminate the results of ORRP stocked with oysters grown in Harbor School nurseries. The results of the project have also been transmitted by Harbor School students’ and faculty members’ presentations three scientific and industry related conferences and several local workshops over the past year. These include NOAA’s 6th Annual Restore Americas Estuaries Conference, Blue Vision Summit 2013, the Northeast Aquaculture Association Annual Conference, and local events taking place at the New York Academy of Sciences, the American Museum of Natural History, and the Brooklyn Bridge Park Conservancy. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? The 2013-2014 reporting period is expected to show the most dramatic growth in the oyster production through the Wallabout Oyster nursery. With the nursery construction complete, Harbor School has begun the outfitting of the new oyster hatchery located in building 134 on Governors Island and is eagerly awaiting the arrival of the Virginia Maitland Sachs, a 25-foot custom designed oyster cultivation and restoration vessel. With these pieces in place Harbor School Aquaculture students will work at the Wallabout nursery twice a week, every week through the month of November and starting again in April. The full 2.5 million animal production capacity of the system is expected to be reached during the late spring of 2014. As the program expands so will progress towards the goals outlined in the project narrative. It is expected that by the end of the 2014 grant year, all Harbor School freshmen will have toured the Wallabout nursery, 25 more students will travel and work at the Fishers Island Oyster farm and sixteen more students will present their work to industry professionals.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? Significant progress was made towards the goals set forth in the project narrative. Nursery equipment was purchased, environmental and government permits were secured and the nursery was constructed and stocked with oysters. Currently the nursery is home to over 750,000 live animals. These oysters live in 600 supertrays, suspended from floats on a longline modeled after a commercial aquaculture facility. This work was conducted over Summer and Fall of 2012 in large part by New York Harbor School students and interns. 1. 45 Aquaculture upperclassman increased their knowledge and aquaculture skills by stocking the Wallabout Oyster nursery with oysters throughout the 2012 school year. The majority of the work on the nursery in 2012 was conducted in the upland hatchery facility at Harbor School. Broodstock was selected, conditioned and spawned in this facility to produce the animals that would be used to stock the nursery in the Brooklyn Navy Yard. After spawning larvae was reared using industry standard techniques, remotely set on shells and then cultured at the floating nursery on Governors Island in preparation for transferring into the Wallabout nursery later into the year. In upcoming years, now that the nursery system in the Navy Yard is built out and the oysters are sufficiently large to be cultured in that location, more of the work will be at the nursery site in the Brooklyn Navy Yard. 2. Aquaculture seniors had two opportunities to present project overviews including business plans to industry professionals. The first was during the annual New York Harbor School Professional Advisory Committee meeting on December 5th, 2012. Five Aquaculture seniors presented their work to members of the New York City Department of Environmental Protection, Aquaculture Extension Agents and Aquaculture and Natural Resource Instructors from Roger Williams University. The presentation consisted of an overview of our restoration project, details on bivalve production from floating nursery systems and a budget for the preceding production season. A similar presentation was given by six seniors to attendees of the National Aquaculture Conference and Exposition. This national aquaculture conference had a special focus on shellfish aquaculture and environmental restoration in 2012. This provided an ideal forum for Harbor School Aquaculture students. In total ten of 16 students presented to industry and higher education professionals. 3. 25 aquaculture students increased their knowledge of the industry through a weekend-long overnight trip to the Fishers Island Oyster Farm on Fishers Island, New York. These students traveled to the oysters farm and spent the weekend as if they were employees of the operation. Students worked full, nine hour days and performed a number of typical oyster farming tasks including grading oyster larvae, transferring oysters from upwelling systems to growout cages, driving boats and harvesting adult oysters. 4. No Aquaculture students received stipends through this grant during the summer of 2012. However three rising seniors and four rising juniors participated in an aquaculture internship through Harbor School’s Oyster Restoration Program during the summer of 2012. These students received stipends through other sources and spent their summers gaining valuable aquaculture experience through maintaining the floating nursery on Governors Island. Another eight Aquaculture students are spending the summer of 2013 working in the same internship. 5. All (110) ninth grade students were introduced to the project through tours of the aquaculture lab, lessons from aquaculture instructors and individual presentations from current aquaculture students. In the future ninth graders will travel to the Wallabout nursery.

      Publications