Source: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS submitted to NRP
LIMITATIONS TO COTTONWOOD ESTABLISHMENT AND GROWTH IN RIPARIAN HABITATS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0228243
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2011
Project End Date
May 19, 2015
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
410 MRAK HALL
DAVIS,CA 95616-8671
Performing Department
Land, Air and Water Resources
Non Technical Summary
This project will provide key information on growth characteristics and limitations for seedlings of Fremont cottonwood (Populus fremontii) the primary colonizer and foundation species of riparian forests in California. Detailed parameterization of models that describe establishment of cottonwood seedlings is needed so that the models can be reliably used by Bureau of Reclamation and other management agencies to plan flows and other actions needed to protect and regenerate sustainable riparian forests along the Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers. The experiments in this project will determine relationships between root growth rates of cottonwood seedlings and the seasonal decline in the water table in point bars during recession phases of the river hydrograph, which coincide with the natural establishment period of Fremont cottonwood. Interactions with variable hydrographs can lead to seedling inundation as well as drought. These two factors, drought and inundation, are major documented causes of cottonwood seedling mortality. Since flow control by dams and diversions, establishment of viable new cohorts of cottonwoods has been minimal along rivers in California and other western states. Multiple experiments that simulate both drought and inundation causes of mortality will be conducted to provide values for parameters needed to model the survival and growth responses of 10-90 day old cottonwood seedlings. Much previous research has used older cottonwood seedlings or even cuttings; both of these types of plant materials have much greater resistance to stresses than the young seedlings we will use. Plant growth responses will be quantified in great detail, including measurement of: maximum root depth growth rate, partitioning of biomass to roots, stems and leaves, limits of water stress tolerance, heat damage thresholds with and without drought stress, excess light damage thresholds with and without drought stress, mortality rates per day with partial and complete inundation, and effects of water temperature on inundation-induced mortality. This approach will not only provide detailed inputs for the established models being used by the Bureau and others, but will generate new knowledge of responses not currently included in the models. For successful simulation of cottonwood seedling establishment interactions of drought, heat, and light stresses as well as water characteristic effects on inundation may need to be added to the models. These interactions become even more relevant as attempts are made to model riparian forest establishment and growth under variable conditions expected with climate changes and future water developments.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2030699102012%
2030699106025%
2030699107012%
1230699102013%
1230699106025%
1230699107013%
Goals / Objectives
The overriding goal of the proposed research is to provide realistic parameters for models of riparian cottonwood seedling establishment along the Sacramento River. The multiple research objectives will allow meeting the needs for the current model formulation as well as providing new information that will facilitate model modification to better simulate responses to under variable conditions expected with climate changes and future water developments. These results will be fully documented in peer-reviewed publications and results will be used in modeling efforts by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation related to river flow planning in California. Objectives: 1. Determine maximal root and shoot growth rates for Sacramento River populations of Fremont cottonwood seedlings in typical point bar sediments and parameterize the components of growth rate responses to water table declines that vary from 0-4 cm / day. 2. Quantify the interactions of heat stress, excess light stress, and drought stress on cottonwood seedlings to determine which factors are most responsible for seedling damage and mortality. 3. Investigate effects of inundation depth, duration, and seedling age on survival and growth of Fremont cottonwood seedlings. 4. Make measurements of cottonwood seedlings along the Sacramento River to define the range of realistic field values for plant water stress, transpiration and photosynthesis rates, root/shoot allocation, and other parameters that affect seedling growth. These measurements will provide confirmation of realistic ranges and reactions that will be compared with parameter values determined in the mesocosm experiments needed for Objectives 1-3.
Project Methods
Fremont cottonwood seeds from several dozen mother trees will be collected along the Sacramento River, near Grimes, California. All experiments will include a random sampling of seedlings derived from this population of trees. All seedlings will be irrigated with a nutrient solution to assure that nutrient limitations do not occur. Objectives 1 & 2-Experiments will be conducted in mesocosms (rhizopods; modified after Mahoney and Rood 1991) that simulate the point bar environment where Fremont cottonwood seedlings naturally germinate in spring. Replicated experiments will be conducted in two growing seasons with harvests 1, 7, 14, 28, 56 and 90 days after germination. In addition to an optimal (control) treatment that will be well drained but irrigated twice daily, there will be four treatments with different rates of water table decline (1, 2, 3, 4 cm/d). Parameters affecting seedling growth rate will be measured before harvest or on harvested seedlings. Measurements through a diurnal cycle include: transpiration, photosynthesis; leaf, stem and soil water potentials; leaf conductance; leaf and air temperatures; chlorophyll fluorescence of leaves. Harvests will quantify seedling biomass and leaf area, leaf area index, root/stem/leaf biomass allocation, specific leaf area, penetration velocity of the rooting front, root branching patterns, specific root length and root depth distribution, and organ C and N content. Seedling in each rhizopod will be recorded twice weekly. These parameters provide all the inputs needed for the current version of the riparian habitat establishment model and provide data for calibration and validation of the model. To study heat, light, and water stress interactions (Objective 2), multiple dry-down experiments will be conducted. Measurements include: predawn and midday leaf petiole water potentials; leaf photosynthesis, transpiration, and conductance; and chlorophyll fluorescence. Objective 3-Seedlings will be grown in pots to different sizes. Galvanized steel stock tanks will be used to allow inundation of the potted plants to different depths. Cool inundation water will approximate Sacramento River water temperature (11 and 18 C night & day) and warm water will be 18 to 24 C (night & day). Treatments will be: A) age of plant: six or ten weeks old; B) temperature: cool or warm; C) duration: one, two, or four weeks; D) depth of inundation: soil surface, complete submergence of shoot, or no inundation. At the end of each inundation period, subsample plants will be harvested and other subsamples will be allowed to recover (like controls) for four weeks prior to final harvest. Measurements at harvest will include: leaf area and stem length, root length and average diameter, and root, stem and leaf biomass. Mortality will be recorded twice weekly. Objective 4-Cottonwood seedlings along the Sacramento River near Grimes will be marked and measured several times during two-three growing season to provide comparative field data for validation of the mesocosm measurements of plant water stress, transpiration and photosynthesis rates, root/stem/leaf biomass allocation, and root depth.

Progress 10/01/11 to 05/19/15

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems: PI retired and unavailable to complete project. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? PI retired and unavailable to complete project.

Publications


    Progress 01/01/13 to 09/30/13

    Outputs
    Target Audience: 1) Direct communication of results to agency personnel (Bureau of Reclamation, USGS, private sector) has allowed research results to be incorporated into management and planning models to improve establishment of riparian forests, improve river flow management to enhance natural cottonwood establishment, and plan for riparian restoration and 2) open publication of results in peer-reviewed literature (Tozzi & Richards 2012) make these widely available to researchers, riparian restorationists, and broader agency personnel. Changes/Problems: The only changes are continued research to better understand variation in photosynthetic capacity and water use efficiency among different genotypes of cottonwood. Previous studies used one population of cottonwood and now we are using clonal replicates from multiple populations. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Two graduate student projects were completed as part of this project. In 2013 Lisa Auchincloss completed her PhD in Plant Biology and presented her research at two national meetings. She used her training to teach restoration ecology at a local community college and now is working as a postdoc at Univ. of Georgia in a science education position that includes teaching undergraduate introductory biology as well as researching improved teaching methods. Three undergraduates worked on the project in 2013 and learned field sampling, laboratory techniques for stable isotope analyses and leaf area measurement, as well as data management and analysis. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Dissemination has been by direct reporting to agency colleagues and by publication in the peer-reviewed literature. Results were also presented at two national meetings. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Manuscripts in preparation will be completed for the experiments that addressed Objectives 1 and 3. Objective 2 was completed in 2013. Additional research addressing Objective 1 will be analysed and more measurements made to understand the genetic variation in water use efficiency and growth rate. Further we will conduct measurements to identify the physiological basis for genetic variation in water use efficiency in cottonwood.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Data analysis and writing are underway for several portions of this project. Two chapters from Auchincloss (2013) dissertation are in preparation for publication (objective 3) and one other manuscript on root growth rates (objective 1) is in preparation. A large population of clonally replicated cottonwood were sampled and leaf nitrogen content and stable isotope composition determined. These data will contribute to increased understanding of genetic variation in water use efficiency in cottonwood.

    Publications

    • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: Tozzi ES, Easlon HM, Richards JH. 2013. Interactive effects or water, light and heat stress on photosynthesis in Fremont cottonwood. Plant, Cell and Environment 36: 1423 -1434. [doi: 10.1111/pce.1207]
    • Type: Theses/Dissertations Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: Auchincloss LC. 2013. Eccophysiology or Populus fremontii: Effects of inundation, and interactions among nitrogen form, nutrient level and water availability. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California, Davis, California.


    Progress 01/01/12 to 12/31/12

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: All experiments for this project have been completed and data analysis and synthesis are underway. Preliminary results for maximum rate of Freemont cottonwood root depth extension (~1.6 cm/day) under realistic field conditions in typical point bar sandy soil, part of Objective 1, is less than previous reported values, but represents a more realistic estimate of the maximum rate of water table decline that can be tolerated by seedlings in the first 30 days following germination. These results have been reported to collaborators involved in modeling seedling establishment and in oral presentations at several scientific and agency meetings. For objectives 2 and 3 the results have been presented at several scientific meetings and submitted for publication. Key outputs are relationships of days of inundation to seedling mortality (Objective 3) and the overriding importance of heat damage as a cause of seedling death during establishment (Objective 2). Both of these findings are critical for accurate modeling of seedling mortality in riparian vegetation establishment models. In addition to reporting at scientific meetings these results have been reported to collaborators at USGS, Bureau of Reclamation and private sector. Two thesis/dissertations and two peer-reviewed publications have been completed. PARTICIPANTS: Two graduate student projects were completed as part of this project. Emily Tozzi completed her M.S. in Soils and Biogeochemistry (2011) and Lisa Auchincloss completed her Ph.D. in Plant Biology (2013). In addition to the PI, other participants were Mike Tansey, Bureau of Reclamation, Chuck Young, Stockholm Environment Institute, and Hsien Easlon, postdoc at UCDavis. TARGET AUDIENCES: Data have been reported to target audiences in the Bureau of Reclamation, USGS, and private sector. These collaborators are incorporating our parameter estimates into riparian habitat establishment models which are being used for improved river flow management and environmental planning. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

    Impacts
    Along many western North American rivers, human-altered flow patterns have led to reduced cottonwood seeding recruitment, and seedling death is often attributed to water stress. However, high flow regimes due to dam releases, rapid snowmelt, or heavy precipitation is also a significant source of seedling mortality as seedlings establishing near the low flow line become inundated by high flows. We documented that Fremont cottonwood seedlings tolerate inundation to the soil surface for at least four weeks with no changes in growth compared to controls. However, complete inundation, especially with warmer water, caused increased mortality linearly related to the duration of inundation. Mortality percentage was found to equal 4.6 + [2.5 x days of inundation]. Results indicate that establishment of new Fremont cottonwood populations in the riparian corridor will be more successful when flows do not completely cover the shoots of seedlings for more than two weeks and if water temperatures during inundation are cool. From the perspective of the management of river flows for cottonwood recruitment, deep, prolonged, late-season (warm water) inundations are the most detrimental. We also examined photosynthetic responses of Fremont cottonwood to the interactive effects of water, light, and heat stresses, which were hypothesized to be critical stresses on the exposed point bar environments where seedlings establish. Our results show that interactions of heat stress, surprisingly mediated by reduced photosynthetic capacity and not damage to photosystems, water limitation, and leaf orientation are important in determining stress to cottonwood leaves that leads to leaf death and eventual seedling mortality. Stomatal closure during water stress effectively prevented leaf dehydration and water stress damage as well as maintaining water potentials above cavitation thresholds. However, water stress predisposed leaves to photosynthetic damage as leaf temperatures rose above 31 *C. The results of this study contrast with the previous conclusions that water stress alone is the cause of cottonwood seedling mortality. Damaging temperatures are common in the exposed point bar environment where these seedlings establish. Application of these results to modeling efforts is needed because current models of riparian seedling establishment use water stress alone as a limiting factor. The impact of our results is to show that interactions with heat and light stress are more important in these effects than water stress alone.

    Publications

    • Tozzi ES. 2011. Water, light and heat stress effects on Fremont cottonwood photosynthesis. MS Thesis, University of California, Davis, California.
    • Auchincloss LC, Richards JH, Young CA, Tansey MK. 2012. Inundation depth, duration, and temperature influence Fremont cottonwood (Populus fremontii) seedling growth and survival. Western North American Naturalist 72:323-333. [doi: 10.3398/064.072.0306]
    • Auchincloss LC. 2013. Ecophysiology of Populus fremontii: Effects of inundation, and interactions among nitrogen form, nutrient level and water availability. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California, Davis, California.
    • Tozzi ES, Easlon HM, Richards JH. 2013. Interactive effects of water, light and heat stress on photosynthesis in Fremont cottonwood. Plant, Cell and Environment in press