Source: IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
RNA STRUCTURE-MEDIATED REGULATION OF CAP-INDEPENDENT TRANSLATION BY PLANT VIRUSES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0226043
Grant No.
2011-67012-30715
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2010-05198
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2011
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2013
Grant Year
2011
Program Code
[A7201]- AFRI Post Doctoral Fellowships
Recipient Organization
IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY
2229 Lincoln Way
AMES,IA 50011
Performing Department
Plant Pathology and Microbiology
Non Technical Summary
Plant viruses in the Carmovirus, Panicovirus and Umbravirus genera are economically important viruses of soybean, legumes and lentils in US and other parts of the world causing up to 100% crop loss. These viruses occur and cause economic impact wherever these and similar crops are grown. In addition to its economical importance, viruses described here use an array of unconventional tools to express encoded genes. Little is known how carmo-, panico-, and umbraviruses are able to recruit translation machinery in the absence of canonical modifications in their genome. Even less is known of how they are able to break resistance encoded by natural recessive resistance genes. The success of plant breeding for improved avirulence determinants depends on how much we know about virus gene replication and expression. The purpose of this study is to determine the roles of RNA sequences from these three different viral genera in cap-independent translation initiation, their interaction with the protein synthesis machinery and how these interactions modify RNA structure using combination of structural and functional methods such as X-ray crystallography and site-directed mutagenesis. A detailed understanding of mechanism of cap-independent translation employed by these plant viruses will make it possible to 1. identify key regulatory steps and find common themes for viral translation shared with other economically important plant viruses that will ultimately suggest new ways to control viral disease and reduce crop losses in US and world; and 2. use the RNA translation signals to control expression of nonviral genes in transgenic plants expressing any gene of agricultural interest.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2062499100020%
2062499104010%
2124030100050%
2124030104020%
Goals / Objectives
Unlike host mRNAs, many viruses lack a cap or poly(A) tail and yet they are efficiently translated. Many plant viruses harbor sequences in their genome that allow them to escape the cellular control of translation initiation and express encoded genes. My goal is to understand how viruses in the Carmovirus, Panicovirus and Umbravirus genera accomplish this to effectively parasitize the plant host. Objectives are: 1. Determine the structure and sequences required by a novel RNA called the Panicum mosaic virus-like cap-independent Translation Element (PTE) by conducting mutagenesis, translation assays, structure probing and X-ray crystallography. 2. Understanding the molecular mechanism of PTE RNA-mediated translation by conducting structural analysis of the high affinity interaction of the PTE with translation initiation factor eIF4E. The following outcomes are expected: in year 1 mapping the core PTE secondary structure, purification of large quantities of PTE and PTE/eIF4E crystal targets and obtain single PTE and PTE-eIF4E crystals is planned. Plans for year 2 include improvement of resolution limit of obtained crystals to less than 3 angstroms by optimizing crystal growing conditions, and then solving the PTE and PTE-eIF4E crystal structure. Structure interpretation in conjunction with mutagenesis and structure probing data will relate the PTE structure to its function to 1. model how PTE recruits eIF4E in the absence of 5' cap to initiate translation; 2. provide insight into translation mechanisms used by related plant viruses. (this in turn could help in design of antiviral agents targeting viral translation mechanisms); and 3. explain how these and related viruses are able to break plant-mediated resistance for more successful breeding with improved avirulence determinants. Acquired results will be published in peer reviewed scientific journals and presented at scientific conferences.
Project Methods
Structural methods such as X-ray crystallography, small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and solution structure probing with chemicals will be combined with functional in vitro and in vivo translation assays and site-directed mutagenesis to answer how RNA structures and sequences in three different virus genera facilitate efficient translation in the absence of the 5' cap structure that is required on host mRNAs. Specifically, Aim 1 focuses on determining the high-resolution tertiary structure of a novel RNA called the Panicum mosaic virus-like cap-independent Translation Element (PTE). I will start RNA structural analysis by conducting solution structure chemical probing of PTEs in the three viral genera to discern the PTE folding in solution and how this folding is regulated by charged ions. The results will aid in PTE construct design for X-ray crystallography by indicating which regions are invariable and essential for folding and therefore PTE function. Additionally, the role of cations in the PTE RNA folding using native polyacrylamide gels will highlight metal ions important for maintaining RNA architecture that need to included in crystal screens. Once optimally folded PTE structures are identified that are able to confer cap independent translation I will attempt to crystallize them alone or in the presence of translation initiation factor as outlined in aim II. Inclusion of eIF4E protein in crystallization trials is expected to act as a structural anchor and it will most likely form most of the contacts in the PTE RNA crystal lattice. Also, PTE-eIF4E crystal structure will provide more biologically relevant structural information. To aid in the interpretation of PTE-eIF4E crystal structure and further investigate the mechanism of eIF4E-PTE interaction, I will introduce mutations in eIF4E that are known to be important in cap-binding, eIF4G binding and interactions with other viruses. These mutations will highlight which residues are involved in the PTE recognition, how and if the binding partner of eIF4E, called eIF4G, modulates the affinity of eIF4E for PTE and explore the relationship between natural recessive resistance genes encoding eIF4E in other viruses and PTE-mediated translation. Upon completion of the research proposed here, detailed mechanism of the PTE mediated cap-independent translation at atomic resolution will be attainable. The crystallography results will give direct insight in how uncapped viral RNA is able to bind inside of eIF4E cap-binding pocket. The other experiments including PTE/eIF4E mutagenesis, translation studies, and structure probing do not depend on the crystallization outcome and will provide valuable information of the dynamics of this interaction and nature of the PTE fold.

Progress 09/01/11 to 08/31/13

Outputs
Target Audience: The target audiences of this project are basic researchers interested in understanding plant and viral translation mechanisms, the structure and function of viral RNAs and their interaction with host proteins. Additionally, this project also seeks to delineate the basic rules of RNA and RNA-protein structure that could be of interest to biochemistry students. Changes/Problems: As indicated in the annual progress report the project was modified to take into account a recent study by Wang et al., 2011. Structure 19, 868-880 in which a modeled tertiary structure of Panicum mosaic virus-like cap-independent Translation Element (PMV PTE) alone and bound to translation initiation factor eIF4E was featured. The PD’s grant also proposed to determine tertiary structure of the PMV PTE by X-ray crystallography. Given the fact that PTE elements from the other viral genera in this study were all predicted to adopt a similar tertiary structure and that structure is more conserved than sequence, it seems that X-ray crystallographic PTE structure determination would not yield new insights into plant virus translation mechanisms. Thus, this new information resulted in a shift in project focus to conducting mutagenesis, translation assays and structure probing to validate this structure and further understand the molecular mechanism of the PTE mediated cap-independent translation initiation. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Training activities This project allowed for the training of visiting and junior scientists in RNA structure analysis, improving PD’s teaching skills, and increasing the impact of the project. Specifically, PD trained Iowa State University MS students Mariko S. Peterson and Sannie J. Olson in basic biochemical techniques such as RNA and protein synthesis and purification, cloning, gel electrophoresis and polymerase chain reaction. Also, PD provided technical advice on solution structure probing to Dr. Natalia N. Singh, Adjunct Assistant Professor of Biomedical Sciences at Iowa State University. Training opportunities provided by PD Fellowship Grant extent beyond Iowa State University to include Ph.D students training in viral RNA structure analysis Sohoni Das Sharma, Chemistry Department at Hunter Collage, City University of New York, and Manuel Miras Marin, Centro de Edafología y Biología Aplicada del Segura (CEBAS), Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (CSIC), Spain, which resulted in a submitted manuscript to PLoS Pathogens. Professional development PD’s Fellowship Grant allowed opportunities to share project accomplishments and increase knowledge of new experimental approaches to study RNA structural properties at local, national and international scientific meetings. Also, Dr. Kraft participated in a Center for Integrating Research, Teaching and Learning (CIRTL) course: Teaching-as-Research in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) Courses and is accepted into a highly competitive professional development program entitled Preparing Future Faculty at Iowa State University this fall to further improve PD’s instructing abilities by enhancing teaching and online course delivery methods. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? The project results were presented at the 2011 EMBO Conference Series (EMBL Heidelberg, Germany), RNA 2012: The 17th Annual Meeting of the RNA Society (Ann Arbor, Michigan), 2012 AFRI NIFA Fellows Project Directors Meeting and in a talk at Iowa State University Department of Biochemistry. Further more, Dr. Kraft shared the obtained results and expertise in RNA structural analysis by providing mentoring and consulting services to scientific community on and off Iowa State University campus, resulting in one published and one submitted journal article. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1) Major activities completed: Toward these goals, untranslated regions of nine different viruses, including additional coding sequences of certain viruses in the Carmovirus, Panicovirus and Umbravirus genera were cloned into a luciferase plasmid downstream of a T7 phage promoter. mRNAs transcribed from these plasmids were added to a wheat germ translation extract, a cell-free translation system derived from tobacco Bright Yellow-2 (BY-2) cells and oat protoplast followed by luciferase measurements. The two in vitro translation systems were also used to test PTEs from viruses belonging to three viral genera for their ability to inhibit translation of reporter mRNAs in trans-inhibition assays. Mixing a reporter mRNA along with 100-fold excess of the PTE from each virus to serve as an inhibitor of the translation of the mRNA shows how well the PTE can compete for, bind, and sequester the factors of interest. The PTE dynamic structural properties belonging to three different viral genera were investigated under various ionic conditions and the key panicovirus nucleotides hypothesize to bind into cap-binding pocket of eIF4E were mutated and their functional and structural properties investigated. The investigator provided both consulting and tutoring services to graduate students from Hunter College, New York, Iowa State University and Spain. 2) Specific objectives met: High-resolution mapping and structural analysis of sequences required for PTE mediated cap-independent translation was conducted to reveal the presence of stable fold at physiological magnesium ion concentrations in both Umbravirus and Panicovirus genera. In contrast, Carmovirus PTEs adopt a stable fold that is independent of magnesium. This fold is further stabilized via a pseudoknot interaction within the Panico and Umbravirus PTEs, which interacts with the key cap-binding translation initiation factor, eIF4E. The secondary structures of diverse PTEs consist of three helices radiating from a central hub and they all harbor a conserved G residue hypothesized to insert into cap-binging pocket of eIF4E. Mutagenesis of this conserved residue in Panicoviruses revealed that replacing G with a T residue is tolerated both in vitro and in vivo suggesting that this compact base is not disturbing the cap binding interactions in eIF4E. Experiments comparing efficiencies of PTEs in three different genera and with other translation enhancers revealed that the panicovirus PTE is one of the most efficient cap-independent translation element in plant systems that also works in animal systems. The fact that PTEs fold into defined structures even in the absence of cation bodes well for obtaining meaningful crystal structure goal which has not been met yet. 3) Significant results achieved, including major findings, developments, or conclusions: As a result of provided mentoring and consulting a novel cap-independent translation element (CITE) essential for translation control in Melon necrotic spot virus resistant plants belonging to a new class called the CXTE (CABYV-Xinjiang-like translation element) was structurally characterized. The CXTE folded into two helices protruding from a central hub in magnesium independent manner and is able to control translation in the absence of eIF4E protein. Another result of student mentoring is identification of 80S ribosome pausing at the start codon on barley yellow dwarf virus reporter mRNA suggesting mechanism entrance via the 5’ end and not the through mediation of CITE from the 3’ end. Also, structural studies on the Barley yellow dwarf virus-like translation elements (BTE) revealed that Mg2+ stabilizes BTEs of all three types by charge neutralization and not by coordination to a specific site(s), and that the BTEs fold into defined, functional structures in the absence of protein that is unchanged by eIF4G binding. This supports the model in which the BTE base pairs simultaneously to the 5’ UTR and the eIF4F complex to allow the 40S ribosomal subunit recruitment to the 5’ end. All of these finding are now published with acknowledgement of NIFA funding. 4) Key outcomes or other accomplishments realized: All plant viruses are parasites of the cell’s protein synthesis machinery (ribosomes). Viruses use non-canonical translation (protein synthesis) mechanisms to induce the ribosomes to synthesize viral proteins encoded in the viral mRNA. Notably, nine viruses in the Carmovirus, Panicovirus and Umbravirus genera were all found to translate highly efficiently in plant cell extracts and in plant protoplast. In particular, Panicovirus reporter mRNAs translated 2-8 fold (depending on a virus used) higher than either Umbra or Carmovirus reporter mRNAs in vivo (cells). Further investigation revealed that these viruses utilize a powerful and highly structured 100-nucleotide Panicum mosaic virus-like translation element (PTE). Analysis of the PTE dynamic structural properties suggests the presence of stable fold at physiological magnesium ion concentrations. This RNA fold is further stabilized via a structure called a pseudoknot within the PTE, which in turn, enables the key interaction with the cap-binding translation initiation factor, eIF4E. However, magnesium dependent pseudoknot was observed only in Panicovirus and Umbravirus and not in the Carmovirus PTEs suggesting that Carmovirus RNAs utilize an alternative folding and mechanism of initiation machinery recruitment. These data enhance understanding of the mechanism of cap-independent, and possibly, by comparison, cap-dependent translation initiation. Further more, the data warrant further characterization of this remarkable ability of the PTE to bind eIF4E in the absence of a 5’ cap that could lead to new ways to limit plant virus infection. Also the information from this research will further understanding of translation in general and may lead to better means of controlling gene expression in crop plants and other higher organism.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: Kraft, J. J., Treder, K., Peterson, M., and W. A. Milller. 2013. Cation-dependent folding of 3' cap-independent translation elements facilitates interaction of a 17 nucleotide conserved sequence with eIF4G. Nucleic Acids Research 41, 3398-3413.
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Submitted Year Published: 2013 Citation: Miras, M., Sempere, R. N., Kraft, J. J., Miller, W. A., Aranda, M. A., and V. Truniger. 2013. Interfamilial recombination between viruses led to acquisition of a novel translation enhancing RNA element that extends viral host range. Manuscript submitted to PLoS Pathogens.


Progress 09/01/11 to 08/31/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Activities: The goal of this project is to understand the mechanism of messenger RNAs of certain plant viruses, which contain protein synthesis (translation) enhancer sequences called Panicum mosaic virus-like elements (PTEs). Toward this goal, untranslated regions of nine different viruses were cloned into a luciferase plasmid downstream of a T7 phage promoter. mRNAs transcribed from these plasmids were added to a wheat germ translation extract or a cell-free translation system derived from tobacco Bright Yellow-2 (BY-2) cells followed by luciferase measurements. The two translation systems were also used to test PTEs from viruses belonging to three viral genera for their ability to inhibit translation of reporter mRNAs in trans-inhibition assays. Mixing a reporter mRNA along with 100-fold excess of the PTE from each virus to serve as an inhibitor of the translation of the mRNA shows how well the PTE can compete for, bind, and sequester the factors of interest. The PTE dynamic structural properties are now being investigated under various ionic conditions. Events and Services: The project accomplishments were shared with local, national and international scientific community at several meetings. Specifically, project results were presented at 2011 EMBO Conference Series (EMBL Heidelberg, Germany), RNA 2012: The 17th Annual Meeting of the RNA Society (Ann Arbor, Michigan), 2012 AFRI NIFA Fellows Project Directors Meeting and in a talk at Iowa State University Department of Biochemistry. Both consulting and tutoring services were provided by the investigator. A graduate student from Hunter College, New York, and a graduate student from Spain were trained by Dr. Kraft. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Jelena J. Kraft, Postdoctoral Research Associate at Iowa State University is the Fellowship Grant PD. Dr. Kraft designed and performed proposed experiments. Also, the PD collected and analyzed data and shared it with national and international scientific community at annual meetings. Dr. W. Allen Miller, Professor of Plant Pathology and Microbiology and Director of Center for Plant Responses to Environmental Stresses at Iowa State University served as the Fellowship Grant PD, Jelena Kraft's mentor. As a well-established investigator in the area of plant virus translation mechanisms, Dr. Miller consulted PD on the project objectives on which to focus and on data interpretation. Further more, Dr. Miller provided PD with the materials and most of the equipment necessary to perform the research. Dr. Miller was instrumental in improving PD's writing skills by encouraging participation in proposal writing and grant writing workshops. Collaborators and contacts: PD continued collaborations with experts in structural biology, Dr. Jeffrey S. Kieft at University of Colorado, School of Medicine, HHMI, and Dr. Julie A. Hoy, Macromolecular Crystallography Facility manager at the California Institute of Technology who provided advice on structural aspects of PD grant. Training and professional development: PD's Fellowship Grant served as a platform to train visiting and junior scientists in RNA structure analysis, improving PD's teaching skills, and increasing the impact of the project. Specifically, PD trained Iowa State University MS student Mariko S. Peterson in basic biochemical techniques such as RNA and protein synthesis and purification, cloning, gel electrophoresis and polymerase chain reaction. Also, PD provided technical advice on solution structure probing to Dr. Natalia N. Singh, Adjunct Assistant Professor of Biomedical Sciences at Iowa State University. Training opportunities provided by PD Fellowship Grant extent beyond Iowa State University to include Ph.D students training in viral RNA structure analysis Sohoni Das Sharma, Chemistry Department at Hunter Collage, City University of New York and Manuel Miras Marin, Centro de Edafologia y Biologia Aplicada del Segura (CEBAS), Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientificas (CSIC), Spain. TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audiences of this project are basic researchers interested in understanding plant and viral translation mechanisms, structure and function of viral RNAs and their interaction with host proteins. Additionally, this project also seeks to delineate the basic rules of RNA and RNA-protein structure that could be of interest to biochemistry students. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: In a recent study by Wang et al., 2011. Structure 19, 868-880, a modeled tertiary structure of Panicum mosaic virus-like cap-independent Translation Element (PMV PTE) alone and bound to translation initiation factor eIF4E was featured. The PD's grant also proposed to determine tertiary structure of the PMV PTE by X-ray crystallography. Given the fact that PTE elements from the other viral genera in this study were all predicted to adopt a similar tertiary structure and that structure is more conserved than sequence, it seems that X-ray crystallographic PTE structure determination would not yield new insights into plant virus translation mechanisms. Thus, this new information resulted in a shift in project focus to conducting mutagenesis, translation assays and structure probing to validate this structure and further understand the molecular mechanism of the PTE mediated cap-independent translation initiation.

Impacts
All plant viruses are parasites of the cell's protein synthesis machinery (ribosomes). Viruses use non-canonical translation (protein synthesis) mechanisms to induce the ribosomes to synthesize viral proteins encoded in the viral mRNA. Notably, nine viruses in the Carmovirus, Panicovirus and Umbravirus genera were all found to translate highly efficiently in plant cell extracts. Further investigation revealed that these viruses utilize a powerful and highly structured 100-nucleotide Panicum mosaic virus-like translation element (PTE). Analysis of the PTE dynamic structural properties suggests the presence of stable fold at physiological magnesium ion concentrations. This RNA fold is further stabilized via a structure called a pseudoknot within the PTE, which in turn, enables the key interaction with the cap-binding translation initiation factor, eIF4E. These data enhance understanding of the mechanism of cap-independent, and possibly, by comparison, cap-dependent translation initiation. Further more, the data warrant further characterization of this remarkable ability of the PTE to bind eIF4E in the absence of a 5' cap that could lead to new ways to limit plant virus infection. Also the information from this research will further understanding of translation in general and may lead to better means of controlling gene expression in crop plants and other higher organisms.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period