Source: N Y AGRICULTURAL EXPT STATION submitted to
PROVIDING NEW YORK VEGETABLE, FRUIT AND DAIRY FARMERS WITH GREENHOUSE GAS AND CARBON MANAGEMENT TOOLS - FRUIT CROPS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0224459
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
NYG-632475
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2010
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2013
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Lakso, AL, N.
Recipient Organization
N Y AGRICULTURAL EXPT STATION
(N/A)
GENEVA,NY 14456
Performing Department
Geneva - Horticulture
Non Technical Summary
State and national energy and greenhouse gas (GHG) policies to help mitigate GHG emissions and reduce U.S. dependence on foreign oil will impact agriculture in many ways, including creating a need for farm-level quantitative information regarding current emissions, soil carbon stocks, and the potential for mitigation. Farm best management practices (BMPs) for GHG mitigation and soil carbon sequestration include: improving farm energy efficiency, producing and/or using renewable energy sources, reducing tillage, improving nitrogen fertilizer and manure management, winter cover cropping, and modifying rotation crops and land use. Many of these options could increase farmer profits if properly implemented, could lead to a new source of revenues if carbon markets develop, and have environmental, food safety, and sustainability co-benefits. Growers in other states and countries are beginning to conduct environmental footprint studies to both understand and improve their environmental effects as well as to inform and assure their customers. Unfortunately, growers are currently limited in being able to document their environmental footprint for their operation due to the lack of data and knowledge specific to crops in NY climate and soils. We propose a comprehensive research and education outreach effort on important vegetable, field, and fruit crop and dairy industries of NY and the Northeast to provide: (1) BMP fact sheets for GHG mitigation and soil carbon sequestration; (2) reliable low-cost guidelines for monitoring and verification of soil carbon stocks; (3) interactive web-based GHG auditing tools ("carbon calculators") for use by farmers and Extension educators; and (4) a state-wide analysis to identify key opportunities for GHG and carbon sequestration within the New York agriculture sector. The methods will include extensive soil sampling and analyses and production system modeling to estimate the current status; compilation of data and comparison of methods to develop estimates of GHG emissions and C sequestration; development of a web site for farm C footprint calculations; and identification of opportunities to improve the C footprint of NY agriculture. New York vegetable, fruit and field crop and dairy farmers will be better educated and better informed regarding BMPs for GHG mitigation and soil carbon sequestration. Farmers will be better prepared for new energy and climate change policies that may affect them, including the possibility of carbon offset payments through emerging carbon markets. This project will provide fruit growers with needed information to document the C balance of their operations. This information may be critical to apply for C credits as currently as perennial fruit crop systems do not fit the thinking on C credits. New York State will be better poised to develop a state-wide plan for GHG mitigation within the agriculture sector and have better information on existing inventories and databases for state planning. We will have an educational website and web-based tool to help individual farmers assess GHG emissions, energy efficiency, and BMPs for their operations.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1011110106015%
1011110206110%
1011139106015%
1011139206110%
2051110106015%
2051110206110%
2051139106015%
2051139206110%
Goals / Objectives
The goals of the project are to provide NY apple and grape growers with sound estimates of their greenhouse gas and carbon management status in an easy to use form, either in print or in a web based system. This Geneva project deals with fruit crops in collaboration with an Ithaca project that deals with vegetables and field crops and dairy. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES 1. Develop fact sheets on "Best Management Practices" for reducing greenhouse gas emissions and sequestering carbon for vegetable, field and fruit crop, and dairy operations in New York State and the region. 2. Develop low-cost approaches for strategic soil sampling and soil carbon assessment on vegetable, field and fruit crops 3. Develop an interactive, educational web-based GHG and soil carbon auditing tool, fine-tuned for use by vegetable, field, and fruit crop, and dairy operations in New York State and the region. 4. Identify key opportunities within the New York agriculture sector for GHG mitigation and carbon sequestration. RELEVANCE AND EXPECTED OUTCOMES OR IMPACTS New York vegetable, fruit and field crop and dairy farmers will be better educated and better informed regarding BMPs for GHG mitigation and soil carbon sequestration. Farmers will be better prepared for new energy and climate change policies that may affect them, including the possibility of carbon offset payments through emerging carbon markets. This project will provide fruit growers with needed information to document the C balance of their operations. This information may be critical to apply for C credits as currently as perennial fruit crop systems do not fit the thinking on C credits. New York State will be better poised to develop a state-wide plan for GHG mitigation within the agriculture sector and have better information on existing inventories and databases for state planning. We will have an educational website and web-based tool to help individual farmers assess GHG emissions, energy efficiency, and BMPs for their operations. The entire Northeast region will benefit from our educational outreach on this topic. We will make an important contribution to advancing the science and methodology for low-cost soil carbon assessments, which could influence national and international standards for agriculture, forestry and other land uses in the carbon economy. This projects addresses Agriculture and Food Systems Priority (1): minimize environmental impact and maintain profitability, and Natural Resources and Environment Priority (2): improve management for sustainable and compatible agricultural, natural resource, and energy systems.
Project Methods
OBJECTIVE 1: BMP's - For each commodity area we will first conduct a thorough search of the peer-reviewed literature, technical reports, websites with documented sources, existing databases, and other sources. We will compile, evaluate, and prioritize the information based on credibility, relevance to New York conditions, and other criteria. Our BMP fact sheets will focus on reducing GHG emissions and enhancing carbon sequestration. Faculty, Extension staff and growers in each commodity area will provide input and feedback. The Geneva component will focus on apple and grape BMP fact sheets. OBJECTIVE 2: SOIL CARBON ASSESSMENT - Primarily led by Ithaca collaborators, we will identify key sites for soil monitoring withgeospatial databases for NY, USDA soil survey databases, STATSGO2 and SSURGO (USDA 1994; 1995), and land use and crop management data. Soil samples will in general be collected to a 60 cm depth in 20-cm increments and samples measured for: total carbon and nitrogen, active carbon, and soil organic carbon. The basic field sampling design will involve core sampling at the 3 corners of triangular "microsites". Other configurations will be evaluated for fruit crops due to the row/alley configuration. The sampling will include both in the weed-free zone under the vines or trees as well as in the alleyway between rows, with appropriate weighting for the relative area of each. OBJECTIVE 3: WEB-BASED GHG ACCOUNTING TOOLS - We will evaluate existing generic GHG accounting tools for their reliability and ease of use, and modify or redesign them for application to NY systems. Results from on-going research by other groups at Cornell and elsewhere in the state will utilized. We will also use our focus groups in each commodity area described in Objective 1 for feedback on the web-based tools. In year 3 partial support for a web developer in Ithaca will facilitate this aspect of the project. OBJECTIVE 4: GHG MITIGATION AND SOIL CARBON SEQUESTRATION - We will use geospatial data on soil characteristics, land use, cropping history, and management, as well as remote sensing data to begin identifying opportunities by commodity, region, soil type, management practice for mitigation and sequestration. Results from Objectives 1 - 3 will be integrated into this effort. The fruit component of this objective will be led by Geneva. Since perennial fruit crops sequester C in their structure and are highly manipulated, a particular focus will be to examine the relative role of the apple trees and grapevines in the whole system C sequestration and GHG emissions. Current models of carbon relations of apples and grapes responding to climate and specific cultural practices will examine NY weather and practices from the primary production areas for apples of the Lake Ontario Plain, the Hudson Valley and the Champlain Valley, and for grapes the Lake Erie Shore, the Finger Lakes, the Hudson Valley and eastern Long Island. In each case, several representative orchard/vineyard planting designs and cultural practices will be examined.

Progress 10/01/10 to 09/30/13

Outputs
Target Audience: The target audiences are related environmental scientists, fruit researchers and extension specialists, growers, and ultimately consumers and policy makers who need sound estimates of carbon footprints. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? There have been relatively few detailed reports yet as this work is being integrated across several different cropping systems to develop online tools. Estimates for apples have been provided to several apple growers who use the information to snwer consumer questions. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? This is a final report but we plan to continue the modeling but introduce a wider range of climatic conditions and to continue to collaborate with co-PI's to develop carbon footprint estimates for growers in this region.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We wanted to estimate the potential role in carbon footrpints of apple trees and grape vines in New York by taking up CO2 from the air and making more stable carbon forms that may be sequestered. This was accomplished by a combination of computer simulation modeling with validation by experimental measurements. The models were called MaluSim for apple and VitiSim for grapes and were closely-related dynamic simulation models of carbon uptake and utilization. They were valdiated against growth analyses over full seasons that determined total dry matter gains in the crop and the plant. Several main points were: (1) over several seasons the total dry matter gains tended to be similar for NY conditions and were about 7 tons per hectare for grape vineyards and 12-13 tons per hectare for apple orchards; (2) since the totals were relatively constant, for healthy plants, the amount that was in fruit was about 60% for heavy crops leaving about 3-6 tons dry matter per hectare in vegetative material that could be potentially sequestered; (3) the higher the yields the lower the potential sequestration. Estimates are still being developed for the grass in the alleyways between the tree or vine rows.

Publications


    Progress 10/01/11 to 09/30/12

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: The apple and grape component of this larger Cornell project has focused on: (a) compiling a database of relevant soils data from orchards and vineyards in the primary fruit-producing regions; (b) identifying sites for further soil sampling in relation to under-represented soil types, under-row vs row middle sampling, and long-term trials with variable floor management; (c) running simulations of the previously developed apple (MaluSim) and grape (VitiSim) carbon balance models with climate data from the main fruit-producing regions of NY; (d) evaluating models to estimate the contributions of the alleyways and their cover crops to the overall orchard and vineyard carbon footprint; and (e) integrating with the larger Cornell effort to provide needed information and tools for growers to document the C balance of their operations, and to develop plans for Greenhouse Gas mitigation. Simulations of apple tree dry matter production and allocation indicate that the total potential carbon that could be fixed is somewhat controlled by year-year variation in weather. But more importantly the key is the amount of crop produced. For example, the crop can remove anywhere from zero to almost 80% of total seasonal net carbon fixation. We have also been sampling soils in transects from under the row to the center of the alleyways of vineyards and orchards to estimate soil carbon. The biomass of cover crops is not equal across the alley way due to variation in solar radiation. Soil analyses are in progress. PARTICIPANTS: Primary collaborators are at Cornell University: Dr. David Wolfe, Dept of Horticulture (lead and vegetable/field crops) Dr. Harold Van Es, Dept of Crops and Soils (soils). Some of the soil analyses re being conducted by Graduate Student Amanda Sims. TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audiences are the growers, extension specialists and researchers of apples and grapes in NY and ultimately the people of NY. Due to the similarity of the climates and production of other states in the Northeast/North Central/Great Lakes regions this research will likely have useful applications for growers in those regions as well. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

    Impacts
    Preliminary estimate based on the models have been generated but need to be integrated with cover crop carbon balance models and general calculations of carbon costs of fuel, pesticides, etc. Until then, there are no practical outcomes or impacts to report.

    Publications

    • No publications reported this period


    Progress 10/01/10 to 09/30/11

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: The apple and grape component of this larger Cornell project has focused initially on: (a) compiling a database of relevant soils data from orchards and vineyards in the primary fruit-producing regions; (b) identifying sites for further soil sampling in relation to under-represented soil types, under-row vs row middle sampling, and long-term trials with variable floor management; (c) running simulations of the previously developed apple (MaluSim) and grape (VitiSim) carbon balance models with climate data from the main fruit-producing regions of NY; (d) evaluating models to estimate the contributions of the alleyways and their cover crops to the overall orchard and vineyard carbon footprint; and (e) integrating with the larger Cornell effort to provide needed information and tools for growers to document the C balance of their operations, and to develop plans for Greenhouse Gas mitigation. Initial simulations of apple tree and grapevine carbon balance indicate that the differences across fruit-producing regions of NY are not very great due to compensating effects (e.g. warmer longer seasons in some regions have higher seasonal photosynthesis but also higher respiration). PARTICIPANTS: Primary collaborators are at Cornell University: Dr. David Wolfe, Dept of Horticulture (lead and vegetable/field crops), and Dr. Harold Van Es, Dept of Crops and Soils (soils). Due to the very small amount of this grant (NYSAES Geneva component), there are no specific training or professional development opportunities to report. TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audiences are the growers, extension specialists and researchers of apples and grapes in NY and ultimately the people of NY. Due to the similarity of the climates and production of other states in the Northeast/North Central/Great Lakes regions this research will likely have useful applications for growers in those regions as well. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

    Impacts
    Due to the early stage of this complex project, and the preliminary nature of the results so far, there are no practical outcomes or impacts to report.

    Publications

    • Lakso, A.N. 2010. Estimating the environmental footprint of New York apple orchards. New York Fruit Quarterly 18(1):26-28.