Source: UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN submitted to NRP
URBAN FORESTS, AIR TOXIC RISKS AND HEALTH OF CHILDREN: DO URBAN FORESTS IMPROVE THE HEALTH OF RACIALLY AND SOCIALLY VULNERABLE CHILDREN
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0224008
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2010
Project End Date
Oct 1, 2012
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
(N/A)
ANN ARBOR,MI 48109
Performing Department
Landscape Architecture
Non Technical Summary
Children's health and well-being are a top priority in America. Our current research funded by the Kresge Foundation suggests that air toxic risks are negatively linked to children's well-being, particularly minority children living in poor neighborhoods. Other research shows that trees can remove air toxics. What we don't know is whether trees influence the relationship between air toxic risks and children's health. This proposal describes a carefully controlled scientific study designed to show that urban forests help address one of the most important public health concerns of our time: air toxic risks and children's health.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1240530311125%
1240410115015%
1246010307025%
1246099308020%
1240410117015%
Goals / Objectives
Children are vulnerable to air pollution: Their lung function has not been fully developed and their airways are narrower than those of adults. Children who are racially and socioeconomically disadvantaged may face even greater risks of air toxics. America spends an estimated 3.2 billion dollars annually on childhood asthma alone. Even a one (1) percent reduction due to influences of urban forests would lead to significant health cost savings and healthier children. The objectives of this project are: 1. To document the relationship among children's health, air toxic risks and urban forests 2. To determine if urban forests mediate (or moderate) the relationship between air toxic risks and children's health 3. To determine whether the burdens are greatest for poor minority children This project addresses the intent of the 2009 Challenge Cost-Share Grant Program. It seeks to document and widely communicate the links that community forests have with children's environmental health. Ultimately, we would like to report to the general public, Congress, and national organizations (such State Foresters, Local Government Commission, Environmental Action Council, etc.) that children who live near healthy urban forests are significantly less likely to suffer from poor environmental health. 1. National Impacts- Children's health and well-being are of national concern. The US Department of Health and Human Services (Healthy People 2010) is focused on eliminating environmental health disparities among children. In 2006, 6.8 million children were diagnosed with asthma and 2.5 million missed eleven or more days of school due to illness or injury (CDC, 2007). Minority children and those in the lowest income families were more likely to be diagnosed with asthma and twice as likely to have absences from school. It is important document all evidence showing links between urban forests and childhood environmental health problems. 2. Nontraditional Groups: Children's environmental health (e.g., effects of air toxics on children's health) is an under-studied area in urban forest research. Children are also an underrepresented group in air toxics research but they are perhaps the most vulnerable to these risks. Increasing urban forest research in this environmentally vulnerable population is both timely and critical for protecting children's health and well-being. 3. Enormous economic significance: Total healthcare costs for children between the ages of 0-18 exceeded $200 billion (US Health and Human Services, 2004). The average spending for healthcare in children was $2,650. Healthcare costs associated with children's environmental health may be reduced significantly by providing healthy and well managed urban forests in their neighborhoods. These costs can include diagnostic, and treatment services by physicians as well as hospital stays and prescription medicine.
Project Methods
We will conduct this study with nationally available data such as Nation Survey of Children's Health (CDC-NCHS, 2003-2007), Risk Screening Environmental Indicators Geographic Microdata (EPA, 1988-2005), US Census Data (2000), and 2005 National Agriculture Imagery Program (NAIP) Digital Ortho Photo Images. We will merge these data at the zip code level (spatial unit of analysis available in the National Survey of Children's Health). Data We currently possess three datasets needed to conduct this study as described in detail below. Only the National Survey of Children's Health data needs to be acquired. Urban Forest To measure the urban forest, we will classify land cover from the 2005 National Agriculture Imagery Program (NAIP) Digital Ortho Photo Images that cover the study area. Forest canopy derived from these photos will be used to determine the total amount (percent) of forest canopy within each zip code (spatial unit of analysis available in the National Survey of Children's Health). Existing 2005 aerial photos are three-band, natural color digital orthoimages at 1-meter resolution acquired during the growing season of 2005 (June - August). Air Pollution: EPA's Risk Screening Environmental Indicators Geographic Microdata The air toxics risk data were generated by the EPA from toxic air emissions generated by polluting industrial facilities tracked in EPA's Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) database. In any given year there are close to 25,000 industrial facilities reporting emissions information to the EPA. For each year from 1988 to 2005, the EPA has used these data to model dispersion and fall out patterns of some 650 toxic chemicals from these facilities, taking into account the types, relative toxicities, timing and volume of releases, wind directions at time of release, stack heights and other factors. For each one-kilometer square in the U.S., a toxicity risk score has been estimated based on the modeling. These risk scores can be separated by type of chemical and source of the release and recombined in order to determine the degree of risk generated by individual chemicals, facilities and/or industries. For our research we intend to examine the geographic distribution of these risks for urban areas in the State of Michigan. Census Data We will use US Census 2000 data to examine the racial and socioeconomic composition of the study areas. Children's Health We will use National Survey of Children's Health to access children's well-being. The survey was conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS). The data was collected in 2003 and 2007 with a sample size of more than 100,000 each year. The survey examines the physical and emotional health of children 1-17 years of age. The survey includes questions related to child and family demographics, children's physical and mental health status, medical homes, access and use of health care services, family interactions, parental health, school and after school performances, and neighborhood and community characteristics.

Progress 10/01/10 to 10/01/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Our results have been disseminated in various national and international conferences. We presented our findings in the Council of Educators in Landscape Architecture Conference in Los Angeles and the Environmental Design Research Association conference in Chicago, 2011. We were also invited to speak our research at the University of Maryland and Kansas State University. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Christopher D. Ellis Department of Plant Science and landscape Architecture University of Maryland 2133 Plant Sciences Building College Park, MD 20742 Email: cdellis@umd.edu Tel: 301-405-7782 Dr. Byoung-Suk Kweon Department of Plant Science and landscape Architecture University of Maryland 2140 Plant Sciences Building College Park, MD 20742 Email: kweonb@umd.edu Tel: 301-405-4341 Trevor Thomas, Associate Planner Southwest Michigan Planning Commission 185 East Main Street, Suite 701 Benton Harbor, MI 49022 Email: thomast@swmpc.org Tel: 269-925-1133 Chen-Yue Zhang, Undergraduate Student Department of Electrical Engineering University of Michigan TARGET AUDIENCES: Our target audiences are children. Children's health and well-being are of national concern. The US Department of Health and Human Services (Healthy People 2010) is focused on eliminating environmental health disparities among children. In 2006, 6.8 million children were diagnosed with asthma and 2.5 million missed eleven or more days of school due to illness or injury (CDC, 2007). Minority children and those in the lowest income families were more likely to be diagnosed with asthma and twice as likely to have absences from school. It is important to document all evidence showing links between urban forests and childhood environmental health problems. Children's environmental health (e.g., effects of air toxics on children's health) is an under-studied area in urban forest research. Children are also an underrepresented group in air toxics research but they are perhaps the most vulnerable to these risks. Increasing urban forest research in this environmentally vulnerable population is both timely and critical for protecting children's health and well-being. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: we had some difficulties getting children's health data. Peter Meyer from the National Center for Health Statistics was contacted to acquire Michigan data from the National Survey of Children's Health. Our request was denied siting the following concerns: "See the attached file for an analysis of the number of Michigan ZIP codes represented in the 2007 NSCH, and the number of cases per ZIP code. Since I don't know offhand how many ZIP codes actually exist in Michigan, I can't say whether 542 is some or most of the ZIP codes, but the table makes it very clear that ZIP code-specific analysis is not feasible (more than 95% of represented ZIP codes have 10 or fewer cases), and multilevel modeling using ZIP code as a level-2 clustering variable is not feasible (more than a third of represented ZIP codes are represented by a single case)." (Peter Meyer, January 20, 2011) During this time, we completed a preliminary analysis using school performance data available through the Michigan Department of Education. In addition, we found the Panel Study of Income Dynamics data produced by the Institute of Social Research at the University of Michigan which provides some data on children's health. This data is classified as "sensitive data" and requires special handling for protection of confidentiality. The procedures required to prepare computer equipment and lab security takes significant time. After leaving the University of Michigan in July, 2011 and taking new faculty positions at the University of Maryland we were only recently able to prepare such a secure environment. Thus, our health analysis is still ongoing.

Impacts
With this grant we hope to strengthen research collaboration between the environmental justice and landscape architecture fields within SNRE at the University of Michigan. Dr.s Mohai and Kweon got a grant ($865,000) from the Kresge Foundation to further investigate schools and air toxics risk. One of their goals is to develop an effective, evidence-based national-level policy for new and existing schools for improving children's health, safety and well-being. Dr.s Ellis and Kweon were awarded a small grant from the Landscape Architecture Foundation to study the benefits of landscape projects. Their goal is to document measurable environmental, social, economic and psychological benefits of urban forest.

Publications

  • Kweon, B., Ellis, C. D., & *Thomas, T. (2011). Urban nature and student performance [Abstract]. CELA 2011: Urban Nature, 178.